Enriching Globalization Studies
With Low Cost Tech & Social Media:
Serving More Than 1 Goal at a Time

Michele DeStefano
Professor, University of Miami School of Law
Founder, LawWithoutWalls
AALS 2014
Road Map
U.S. Law Market
U.S. Legal Education
“Certain things. They should stay the way they
are. You ought to be able to stick them in one
of those big glass cases and just leave them
alone.”
- JD Salinger, Catcher in the Rye

36 Year Old Twinkie
Rising Costs
Enrollment Plummets

2010-2013: From 50,000 to
38,000
But not at Harvard Law School .
..
•
•
•
•

Seton Hall Down 43%
Hamline Down 55%
Applications down 38% 2010-2013
AND even Harvard Law School has fewer
applications
– Harvard accepted 16% of applicants for 2015
vs. 11% year prior
Predicting Law School Closings
Law School Market

+
Globalization
Everyone is Affected by
Globalization
Law School Market

+
Globalization

+
Innovation
Multi-Disciplinary
Open Collaboration is
the Key to Innovation
So Many Reasons To Use
Technology
“The sign of a good decision is the
multiplicity of reasons for it. If more than
one goal is served, then a decision is more
likely to be wise.”
- Russel, Children of God
Good & Bad Uses of Tech
Time, Space, Place
So Many Options (Not All Good)
Asynchronous
On-Line Education: MOOCs
2012 “Year of MOOC”
For Profit
• Coursera:
–
–
–
–

More than 2 Million Registrants
Some classes more than 100,000 students
Over 370 courses
Partnerships with over 30 institutions including
Brown, Princeton, and Columbia

• Udacity 25 courses
NonProfit
– Harvard and MIT EdX Non-profit $30 million and
35courses
Free of Charge but not for Long

Sell Names to Employers, Credit,
Certificates
Mostly Computer Science &
Math
But Also Legal Education
Non-Credit
• Case Western Professor Michael Scharf
MOOC international criminal law
(Coursera)
• UCL Dame Hazel MOOC English
common law, (Coursera)
• Harvard„s Professor William Fisher MOOC
copyright law EdX)
• Yale„s Professor Akhil Amar MOOC
constitutional law (Coursera 2014)
But Also Legal Education
For Credit
• University of Akron School of Law MOOC
Commercial Paper for course
• On Line LLM Degrees e.g., Washington
University
And Around the World
Some Upsides & Downsides
Potential Upsides
•
•
•
•
•
•

Cost/Efficiency
Size
Fast & peer feedback
Global
Talent
Convenience
Potential Downsides
•
•
•
•

Testing/Grading (peer assessment)
Cheating
Quality
ABA Rules
– 12 credits max for distance learning courses
– 4 credits max of distance learning in any
semester
– No distance learning course for credit during
first year of law school
Pressure on the ABA
Synchronous
Ain‟t Nothing Like the Real
Thing
Depends on the Real Thing
Synchronous May Be More
Up Close & Personal
Synchronous: Your Class

Blackboard, Google Drive, Twitter,
Facebook, Linked In, One on-line
Synchronous: Multi-University
LWOW X
Adobe Connect
The Future: Blended
INNOVATING LEGAL EDUCA TION AND PRACTICE

MICHELE DESTEFANO
FOUNDER, LAWWITHOUTWALLS
PROFESSOR OF LAW
INNOVATING LEGAL EDUCATION AND PRACTICE

Part-virtual collaboratory

Develops 21st century lawyering skills
Law + Business + Technology + Innovation
26 Law & Business Schools
45+ Students
Bifröst University (Iceland)

Stanford Law School

Fordham Law School

Tel Aviv University (Israel)

Harvard Law School

University College London (UK)

IE Business School (Spain)

University of Miami Law

IE Law School (Spain)

University of Montreal Law

Indiana University Law

University of São Paulo (Brazil)

National Law School of India

University of St. Gallen (Switzerland)

New York Law School

University of Sydney Law (Australia)

Peking University STL (China)

Wharton School of Business

Pontifical Catholic U (Chile)

York University School of Business

Sciences Po Business (France)

York University School of Law

Sciences Po Law (France)

Witwatersrand Law (South Africa)
Three Parts to LawWithoutWalls

1. KickOff in person

2. Virtual Dynamic Teaming
& weekly Virtual Sessions
3. ConPosium in person
DOCCs
DOCCs – Central Video
DOCCs - No Single Best Way
DOCCs- More than 1 Talking Head
Professor Michele DeStefano:
Innovation Tech & the Law Course
• In Person Component:
• One hour in-person class sessions that
include a mix of teaming and skills-based
exercises along with explorative sessions on
entrepreneurial ventures and innovations in
the law
• On-Line Component:
• Assigned, pre-recorded 2-hour Virtual
Thought Leader Session (VTLS) from
LawWithoutWalls.
• Assigned relevant reading materials on the
weekly topics addressed by these sessions.
Professor Michele DeStefano:
Innovation Tech & the Law Course
Semester Work: Students write weekly response
papers that package their learnings from the
readings, the research they conducted, and the
VTLS into a provoking 1-2 page thought-piece.
Final Projects: Student teams develop a 6-7 minute
ignite-style presentation on any topic, idea, or
business solution that is a technological innovation
in the law involving
Class Cloud: All course materials, WRPs, and
assignments will be ]in a folders on Google Drive
The Future . . . Can‟t Be Just on
Cost
Tech: A Tool to Add Value
A Path: Not An End in Itself

Enriching Globalization With Low Cost Tech & Social Media: Serving More than One Goal at a Time

  • 1.
    Enriching Globalization Studies WithLow Cost Tech & Social Media: Serving More Than 1 Goal at a Time Michele DeStefano Professor, University of Miami School of Law Founder, LawWithoutWalls AALS 2014
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
    “Certain things. Theyshould stay the way they are. You ought to be able to stick them in one of those big glass cases and just leave them alone.” - JD Salinger, Catcher in the Rye 36 Year Old Twinkie
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
    But not atHarvard Law School . .. • • • • Seton Hall Down 43% Hamline Down 55% Applications down 38% 2010-2013 AND even Harvard Law School has fewer applications – Harvard accepted 16% of applicants for 2015 vs. 11% year prior
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Everyone is Affectedby Globalization
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
    So Many ReasonsTo Use Technology “The sign of a good decision is the multiplicity of reasons for it. If more than one goal is served, then a decision is more likely to be wise.” - Russel, Children of God
  • 15.
    Good & BadUses of Tech Time, Space, Place
  • 16.
    So Many Options(Not All Good)
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
    2012 “Year ofMOOC” For Profit • Coursera: – – – – More than 2 Million Registrants Some classes more than 100,000 students Over 370 courses Partnerships with over 30 institutions including Brown, Princeton, and Columbia • Udacity 25 courses NonProfit – Harvard and MIT EdX Non-profit $30 million and 35courses
  • 20.
    Free of Chargebut not for Long Sell Names to Employers, Credit, Certificates
  • 21.
  • 22.
    But Also LegalEducation Non-Credit • Case Western Professor Michael Scharf MOOC international criminal law (Coursera) • UCL Dame Hazel MOOC English common law, (Coursera) • Harvard„s Professor William Fisher MOOC copyright law EdX) • Yale„s Professor Akhil Amar MOOC constitutional law (Coursera 2014)
  • 23.
    But Also LegalEducation For Credit • University of Akron School of Law MOOC Commercial Paper for course • On Line LLM Degrees e.g., Washington University
  • 24.
  • 25.
    Some Upsides &Downsides
  • 26.
  • 27.
    Potential Downsides • • • • Testing/Grading (peerassessment) Cheating Quality ABA Rules – 12 credits max for distance learning courses – 4 credits max of distance learning in any semester – No distance learning course for credit during first year of law school
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Ain‟t Nothing Likethe Real Thing
  • 31.
    Depends on theReal Thing
  • 32.
    Synchronous May BeMore Up Close & Personal
  • 33.
    Synchronous: Your Class Blackboard,Google Drive, Twitter, Facebook, Linked In, One on-line
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
    INNOVATING LEGAL EDUCATION AND PRACTICE MICHELE DESTEFANO FOUNDER, LAWWITHOUTWALLS PROFESSOR OF LAW
  • 39.
    INNOVATING LEGAL EDUCATIONAND PRACTICE Part-virtual collaboratory Develops 21st century lawyering skills Law + Business + Technology + Innovation
  • 40.
    26 Law &Business Schools 45+ Students Bifröst University (Iceland) Stanford Law School Fordham Law School Tel Aviv University (Israel) Harvard Law School University College London (UK) IE Business School (Spain) University of Miami Law IE Law School (Spain) University of Montreal Law Indiana University Law University of São Paulo (Brazil) National Law School of India University of St. Gallen (Switzerland) New York Law School University of Sydney Law (Australia) Peking University STL (China) Wharton School of Business Pontifical Catholic U (Chile) York University School of Business Sciences Po Business (France) York University School of Law Sciences Po Law (France) Witwatersrand Law (South Africa)
  • 41.
    Three Parts toLawWithoutWalls 1. KickOff in person 2. Virtual Dynamic Teaming & weekly Virtual Sessions 3. ConPosium in person
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.
    DOCCs - NoSingle Best Way
  • 45.
    DOCCs- More than1 Talking Head
  • 46.
    Professor Michele DeStefano: InnovationTech & the Law Course • In Person Component: • One hour in-person class sessions that include a mix of teaming and skills-based exercises along with explorative sessions on entrepreneurial ventures and innovations in the law • On-Line Component: • Assigned, pre-recorded 2-hour Virtual Thought Leader Session (VTLS) from LawWithoutWalls. • Assigned relevant reading materials on the weekly topics addressed by these sessions.
  • 47.
    Professor Michele DeStefano: InnovationTech & the Law Course Semester Work: Students write weekly response papers that package their learnings from the readings, the research they conducted, and the VTLS into a provoking 1-2 page thought-piece. Final Projects: Student teams develop a 6-7 minute ignite-style presentation on any topic, idea, or business solution that is a technological innovation in the law involving Class Cloud: All course materials, WRPs, and assignments will be ]in a folders on Google Drive
  • 48.
    The Future .. . Can‟t Be Just on Cost
  • 49.
    Tech: A Toolto Add Value
  • 50.
    A Path: NotAn End in Itself