EFES PILSEN
Derya Nasirli, Mine Ülgüray, Appaz Bavbekov
Outline
• Introduction
• SWOT analysis
  – Porter’s Five Forces
• Current strategy analysis
• Sustainability of competitive advantage
• Possible future strategies
EFES PILSEN

• Efes Beverage Group formed in 1969 with 2 beer production
factories
• Now Efes has 14 beer factories (5 Turkey 9 abroad) in 5 countries,
and 6 malt factories
• Efes has 35.7 million hectoliter beer and 254.000 ton malt
production capacities
• Efes beverage group is the sixth largest European brewer on
combined production basis
• There are 220 exclusive dealers countrywide, and 31 exclusive
distributers in 6 metropolitan areas
EFES PILSEN
  EFES Beverage Group Market Share
                        Efes        Others


                      20%                18%         17%    14%
          21%
40%




                      80%                82%         83%    86%
          79%
60%




1987     2004         2005              2006        2007   2008




         EFES Market Shares Abroad
                            Efes        Others

 #4             #1                 #2              #1       #4

                28%
                                                   53%
                               72%
 91%                                                        87%

                72%
                                                   47%
                               28%
  9%                                                        13%

RUSSIA    MOLDAVIA KAZAKHSTAN                    GEORGIA   SERBIA
Strengths
• Europe’s sixth largest beer producer
• Most recognized brand in Turkey, 100% awareness among
  Turkish consumers
• Has international high quality and wide range of products
• Sector is transparent and consolidated. They don’t have to
  deal with 4-5 companies.
• In terms of illegal production, it is very hard to imitate
  beer, unlike raki and wine
• Market is closed for new entrants because beer production
  is a technology/knowledge intensive business and
  TV&Radio advertisement is fully restricted since 1984. It is a
  disable use of an important brand building tool.
Weaknesses
• Hardly to find suitable barley for beer
  production
• Beer consumption per capita is very low in
  Turkey
• It is very hard to introduce new products to
  the market because of the TV&Radio
  advertisement restrictions.
Opportunities

• Having well developed distribution system it is
  easy to introduce new products
• Turkey has a young population
• Market share increase opportunity in the
  abroad operations, especially in Russia
Porter’s Five Forces
• Bargaining Power of Suppliers
  – Agricultural market is very competitive, no
    producer can influence prices
• Bargaining Power of Customers
  – Mainly Efes educates its customers
     • Ex. Creation of Birahaneler
• Competitive Rivalry within Industry
  – Tuborg and Carlsberg are second movers after Efes
Porter’s Five Forces (cont’d)
• Threat of New Entrants
  – Turkish Beer Market is highly consolidated, top 2
    players control 99%
  – 100% awareness of Efes Brand
• Threat of Substitute Products
  – Turkish alcoholic market is not
    saturated, producers “teach” their customers
  – High excise duty
Other Forces

• Government policy
    • Current Government pro-Islamic, opposed to the
      alcoholic drinks consumption
    • High Excise Duty
    • Customs Union with EU, no import taxes imposed
Choosing a Strategy
• It’s common to see one of the two strategies:
  – product differentiation
    or
  – cost leadership

           Where does Efes Pilsen fit?
Choosing a Strategy
• It’s common to see one of the two strategies:
  – product differentiation
    or
  – cost leadership

           Where does Efes Pilsen fit?
Sources of Cost Advantage

• Economies of scale
  – High sales (86% market share)
  – Intranet Stock Control System
• Learning curve economies
  – High level of experience
Sources of Product Differentiation
• Product attributes
  – E.g. Timing of introduction
     • First mover in 1969
• Firm-Customer relationships
  – E.g. Consumer Marketing and Reputation
     • Advertisement through sponsoring sport activities
• Firm Linkages
  – E.g. Linkages with other firms
     • Anadolu Grup
Value Creation
• Sustainability of Efes Pilsen’s competitive
  advantage comes mainly from:
  – The unique brand perception or popularity by the
    customer
• Thus, Value Creation is high:      B-C
  – Customers are willing to pay more for Efes
    (B:Benefit)
  – Production cost of Efes Pilsen is low because of
    economies of scale (C:Cost)
Economic rent
• Economic rent = (P-C)*Q
  – P is high (price premium) because of high Benefits
    received by the customer and low competition
  – C is low (as explained in s.3)
  – Q is high (86% market share)

  Economic rent received by Efes Pilsen is high!
Analyzing Rents
                            2. Firm’s
                            mix of products,     3 Firm’s cost and benefit
                            and customers        position as compared to rivals?
                            vs. rivals?
                                                 Lower C with
                            Same                 same/close B as rivals
                            as significant                                   Cost advantage
                            rivals in the
                            Industry…

                                                 Higher B with
                                                 same/close C as rivals      Benefit advantage
                  No


                            Unique                  … with products and
                            from most               activities tightly
                            significant rivals      optimized to
1. Attractive 5             in the industry…        customer economics        Niche advantage
   Forces in
   Industry?

                                                 …game theory used to
                                                 deter entry and
                  Yes….                                                            Market power
                                                 maintain win-win game                    17
Market Power



1. Attractive 5
   Forces in
   Industry?




                          …game theory used to
                          deter entry and         Market
          Yes….           maintain win-win game   Power
                                                           18
Efes is..
• competing in Turkey on the basis of a
  combination of:

  – Benefit advantage
            +
  – Market Power
EFES Possible Strategies
                       Beer per Capita Consumption
              Turkey    11
              China          25
         Kazakhistan           30
           Moldova              33
            Greece                38
            Bulgaria                   61
              Russia                     65
           Serbia M.                      68
           Romania                          71
          W. Europe                          74
            Hungary                           75
                USA                            77
             Poland                                 83
                 UK                                      96
           Germany                                            114
         Czech Rep.                                                  159


         * Source: Canadean Global Beer Trends, 2006, Company Data




TURKEY                                                                     INTERNATIONAL
Turkish Market
INCREASE THE MARKET SHARE BY ENLARGING THE TURKISH BEER MARKET
   WHILE MAINTAINING THE PROFITABILITY
• Enlargement and diversification of the beer consumption area, like sports
   games, jazz/blues organizations etc.
• Continue with the Birahane improvement project. Changing the concepts
   of traditional Turkish Birahanes into modern and civilized environments
   where people share their best times. Clean, fashionable, and entertaining.
   By this, also woman will be targeted as a new customer type. Efes has to
   increase the woman’s beer consumption amount within the total
   consumption.
• Continue with effective portfolio management of brands, SKU’s and
   Channels.
International Markets
• INCREASE THE MARKET SHARE IN THE TARGETED
  MARKETS BY M&A
• Increasing the presence in the current
  markets, such as
  Russia, Kazakhstan, Moldavia, Georgia and Serbia
  – Ex. By 2012 Efes plans to increase its market share in
    Russia from 9% to 15%
• Analyze potential markets and continue the
  international expansion
  – Advantage of CCI Distribution channels
Thanks for your attention

Efes Pilsen's Strategic Analysis

  • 1.
    EFES PILSEN Derya Nasirli,Mine Ülgüray, Appaz Bavbekov
  • 2.
    Outline • Introduction • SWOTanalysis – Porter’s Five Forces • Current strategy analysis • Sustainability of competitive advantage • Possible future strategies
  • 3.
    EFES PILSEN • EfesBeverage Group formed in 1969 with 2 beer production factories • Now Efes has 14 beer factories (5 Turkey 9 abroad) in 5 countries, and 6 malt factories • Efes has 35.7 million hectoliter beer and 254.000 ton malt production capacities • Efes beverage group is the sixth largest European brewer on combined production basis • There are 220 exclusive dealers countrywide, and 31 exclusive distributers in 6 metropolitan areas
  • 4.
    EFES PILSEN EFES Beverage Group Market Share Efes Others 20% 18% 17% 14% 21% 40% 80% 82% 83% 86% 79% 60% 1987 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 EFES Market Shares Abroad Efes Others #4 #1 #2 #1 #4 28% 53% 72% 91% 87% 72% 47% 28% 9% 13% RUSSIA MOLDAVIA KAZAKHSTAN GEORGIA SERBIA
  • 5.
    Strengths • Europe’s sixthlargest beer producer • Most recognized brand in Turkey, 100% awareness among Turkish consumers • Has international high quality and wide range of products • Sector is transparent and consolidated. They don’t have to deal with 4-5 companies. • In terms of illegal production, it is very hard to imitate beer, unlike raki and wine • Market is closed for new entrants because beer production is a technology/knowledge intensive business and TV&Radio advertisement is fully restricted since 1984. It is a disable use of an important brand building tool.
  • 6.
    Weaknesses • Hardly tofind suitable barley for beer production • Beer consumption per capita is very low in Turkey • It is very hard to introduce new products to the market because of the TV&Radio advertisement restrictions.
  • 7.
    Opportunities • Having welldeveloped distribution system it is easy to introduce new products • Turkey has a young population • Market share increase opportunity in the abroad operations, especially in Russia
  • 8.
    Porter’s Five Forces •Bargaining Power of Suppliers – Agricultural market is very competitive, no producer can influence prices • Bargaining Power of Customers – Mainly Efes educates its customers • Ex. Creation of Birahaneler • Competitive Rivalry within Industry – Tuborg and Carlsberg are second movers after Efes
  • 9.
    Porter’s Five Forces(cont’d) • Threat of New Entrants – Turkish Beer Market is highly consolidated, top 2 players control 99% – 100% awareness of Efes Brand • Threat of Substitute Products – Turkish alcoholic market is not saturated, producers “teach” their customers – High excise duty
  • 10.
    Other Forces • Governmentpolicy • Current Government pro-Islamic, opposed to the alcoholic drinks consumption • High Excise Duty • Customs Union with EU, no import taxes imposed
  • 11.
    Choosing a Strategy •It’s common to see one of the two strategies: – product differentiation or – cost leadership Where does Efes Pilsen fit?
  • 12.
    Choosing a Strategy •It’s common to see one of the two strategies: – product differentiation or – cost leadership Where does Efes Pilsen fit?
  • 13.
    Sources of CostAdvantage • Economies of scale – High sales (86% market share) – Intranet Stock Control System • Learning curve economies – High level of experience
  • 14.
    Sources of ProductDifferentiation • Product attributes – E.g. Timing of introduction • First mover in 1969 • Firm-Customer relationships – E.g. Consumer Marketing and Reputation • Advertisement through sponsoring sport activities • Firm Linkages – E.g. Linkages with other firms • Anadolu Grup
  • 15.
    Value Creation • Sustainabilityof Efes Pilsen’s competitive advantage comes mainly from: – The unique brand perception or popularity by the customer • Thus, Value Creation is high: B-C – Customers are willing to pay more for Efes (B:Benefit) – Production cost of Efes Pilsen is low because of economies of scale (C:Cost)
  • 16.
    Economic rent • Economicrent = (P-C)*Q – P is high (price premium) because of high Benefits received by the customer and low competition – C is low (as explained in s.3) – Q is high (86% market share) Economic rent received by Efes Pilsen is high!
  • 17.
    Analyzing Rents 2. Firm’s mix of products, 3 Firm’s cost and benefit and customers position as compared to rivals? vs. rivals? Lower C with Same same/close B as rivals as significant Cost advantage rivals in the Industry… Higher B with same/close C as rivals Benefit advantage No Unique … with products and from most activities tightly significant rivals optimized to 1. Attractive 5 in the industry… customer economics Niche advantage Forces in Industry? …game theory used to deter entry and Yes…. Market power maintain win-win game 17
  • 18.
    Market Power 1. Attractive5 Forces in Industry? …game theory used to deter entry and Market Yes…. maintain win-win game Power 18
  • 19.
    Efes is.. • competingin Turkey on the basis of a combination of: – Benefit advantage + – Market Power
  • 20.
    EFES Possible Strategies Beer per Capita Consumption Turkey 11 China 25 Kazakhistan 30 Moldova 33 Greece 38 Bulgaria 61 Russia 65 Serbia M. 68 Romania 71 W. Europe 74 Hungary 75 USA 77 Poland 83 UK 96 Germany 114 Czech Rep. 159 * Source: Canadean Global Beer Trends, 2006, Company Data TURKEY INTERNATIONAL
  • 21.
    Turkish Market INCREASE THEMARKET SHARE BY ENLARGING THE TURKISH BEER MARKET WHILE MAINTAINING THE PROFITABILITY • Enlargement and diversification of the beer consumption area, like sports games, jazz/blues organizations etc. • Continue with the Birahane improvement project. Changing the concepts of traditional Turkish Birahanes into modern and civilized environments where people share their best times. Clean, fashionable, and entertaining. By this, also woman will be targeted as a new customer type. Efes has to increase the woman’s beer consumption amount within the total consumption. • Continue with effective portfolio management of brands, SKU’s and Channels.
  • 22.
    International Markets • INCREASETHE MARKET SHARE IN THE TARGETED MARKETS BY M&A • Increasing the presence in the current markets, such as Russia, Kazakhstan, Moldavia, Georgia and Serbia – Ex. By 2012 Efes plans to increase its market share in Russia from 9% to 15% • Analyze potential markets and continue the international expansion – Advantage of CCI Distribution channels
  • 23.
    Thanks for yourattention