Project Identification and Selection Process Project Criteria 1
Upon completing this module, students should be able to: Identify and select projects Evaluate a potential Black Belt Project Explain the project selection process Objectives – Project ID and Selection
Project Identification Pain point or strategic concern is identified Black Belt investigates to see what BB Team could do to help resolve the issue Establish a Green Belt DMAGIC project Establish a Black Belt DMAGIC project Conduct a Lean Event Kaizen VSM 5S Establish a Black Belt DMADV project Establish a Black Belt Consulting project Do nothing
Project Selection Criteria Projects will likely have greater success if… The problem is related to a key business issue The problem is linked to a clearly defined process (you can identify the starting and ending points) You can identify the internal or external customers who use or receive the output from this process You know or can find out how the customers use the output You know or can find out what is important to the customer about the output  4 .
Project Selection Criteria You can clearly identify what a defect is and count its occurrence  You can demonstrate how improvements could enhance financial performance There is appropriate organizational support The Champion cares about this work and wants to make it happen The Champion has the authority to commit time and resources A process owner has been identified
Documenting a possible project Contact the potential project idea author to understand the full nature of the project idea.  Discuss the project idea with the proposed process owner, champion, etc. as necessary to gather information required to complete the project charter
Documenting a possible project Fill in a project charter with the information available. Customer CTQ's  Champion Name  Problem Statement  Process Owner Name  Project Scope Goal Statement Baseline Metric Performance Expected Benefits Estimate  Process Map Number (if available)  Proposed Team Member Function and/or name Estimated overall project cycle time (100,140.180 days?)
Recording An Idea
Recording An Idea What data is necessary to prioritize and select?
Common Problems and Recommendations Many projects encounter one or more of the following problems: Not relevant to customers or to business needs Project scope too large; won’t have authority to commit time/resources or to make changes in the process; can’t easily identify starting and ending points Relevant data hard to collect or too much data Can’t define what a defect is Process doesn’t cycle often enough Problem written as solution (defect defined as the X that needs correction)
Estimating Financial Impact Limited resources necessitate project prioritization  Estimates of potential financial impact plus identifying strategic support projects facilitate this prioritization At this point, exact financial estimates are not necessary, but the values do need to be quantified well enough to correctly place the project in the priority list In 3D, we will review financial categories in more detail
BB Project Evaluation Exercise Instructions:  Using the criteria for shaping a project, make rough estimates of the impact your project is likely to have.  Be prepared to discuss your ideas with the class.  10 Min
Project Charter {Project Name & No. Here} Assigned Define Measure Analyze Green Improve Control Sched Date Date Date Date Date Date Date Actual Date Date Date Date Date Date Date Process Map Number:   Number here Black Belt:  Name here Process Owner:  Name here Champion:  Name here Implementation Coordinator : Name here Data Coordinator : Name here Team Members: Name & function here Name & function here Name & function here Name & function here Name & function here Expected Benefits:   Hard Savings –$ xxx K Soft Savings –$ xxx K Other Benefits: List benefit here List benefit here Project Timeline: Customer CTQ(s):  Describe customer CTQ (customer need/defect and spec limit.) Problem Statement : List the 4 elements of a problem statement:  * Defect identification  * Magnitude of the defect (events/unit time, etc)  * Where is the defect (location/group/segment)  * Why this project is important to work now ($, strategy support, etc) Project Scope: List project/process boundaries here Goal Statement:  Increase(/decrease) the {primary metric} from {baseline state} to {improved state} by {date} without negatively impacting {secondary metric}. Baseline Metric Performance ( Time frame here ):   Short Term Long Term Zbench x.x x.x DPMO xxxxxx xxxxxx 15 Deliv template.ppt
Upon completing this module, students should be able to: Identify and select projects Evaluate a potential Black Belt Project Explain the project selection process Learning Check – Project ID and Selection

D06 Project Selection

  • 1.
    Project Identification andSelection Process Project Criteria 1
  • 2.
    Upon completing thismodule, students should be able to: Identify and select projects Evaluate a potential Black Belt Project Explain the project selection process Objectives – Project ID and Selection
  • 3.
    Project Identification Painpoint or strategic concern is identified Black Belt investigates to see what BB Team could do to help resolve the issue Establish a Green Belt DMAGIC project Establish a Black Belt DMAGIC project Conduct a Lean Event Kaizen VSM 5S Establish a Black Belt DMADV project Establish a Black Belt Consulting project Do nothing
  • 4.
    Project Selection CriteriaProjects will likely have greater success if… The problem is related to a key business issue The problem is linked to a clearly defined process (you can identify the starting and ending points) You can identify the internal or external customers who use or receive the output from this process You know or can find out how the customers use the output You know or can find out what is important to the customer about the output 4 .
  • 5.
    Project Selection CriteriaYou can clearly identify what a defect is and count its occurrence You can demonstrate how improvements could enhance financial performance There is appropriate organizational support The Champion cares about this work and wants to make it happen The Champion has the authority to commit time and resources A process owner has been identified
  • 6.
    Documenting a possibleproject Contact the potential project idea author to understand the full nature of the project idea. Discuss the project idea with the proposed process owner, champion, etc. as necessary to gather information required to complete the project charter
  • 7.
    Documenting a possibleproject Fill in a project charter with the information available. Customer CTQ's Champion Name Problem Statement Process Owner Name Project Scope Goal Statement Baseline Metric Performance Expected Benefits Estimate Process Map Number (if available) Proposed Team Member Function and/or name Estimated overall project cycle time (100,140.180 days?)
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Recording An IdeaWhat data is necessary to prioritize and select?
  • 10.
    Common Problems andRecommendations Many projects encounter one or more of the following problems: Not relevant to customers or to business needs Project scope too large; won’t have authority to commit time/resources or to make changes in the process; can’t easily identify starting and ending points Relevant data hard to collect or too much data Can’t define what a defect is Process doesn’t cycle often enough Problem written as solution (defect defined as the X that needs correction)
  • 11.
    Estimating Financial ImpactLimited resources necessitate project prioritization Estimates of potential financial impact plus identifying strategic support projects facilitate this prioritization At this point, exact financial estimates are not necessary, but the values do need to be quantified well enough to correctly place the project in the priority list In 3D, we will review financial categories in more detail
  • 12.
    BB Project EvaluationExercise Instructions: Using the criteria for shaping a project, make rough estimates of the impact your project is likely to have. Be prepared to discuss your ideas with the class. 10 Min
  • 13.
    Project Charter {ProjectName & No. Here} Assigned Define Measure Analyze Green Improve Control Sched Date Date Date Date Date Date Date Actual Date Date Date Date Date Date Date Process Map Number: Number here Black Belt: Name here Process Owner: Name here Champion: Name here Implementation Coordinator : Name here Data Coordinator : Name here Team Members: Name & function here Name & function here Name & function here Name & function here Name & function here Expected Benefits: Hard Savings –$ xxx K Soft Savings –$ xxx K Other Benefits: List benefit here List benefit here Project Timeline: Customer CTQ(s): Describe customer CTQ (customer need/defect and spec limit.) Problem Statement : List the 4 elements of a problem statement: * Defect identification * Magnitude of the defect (events/unit time, etc) * Where is the defect (location/group/segment) * Why this project is important to work now ($, strategy support, etc) Project Scope: List project/process boundaries here Goal Statement: Increase(/decrease) the {primary metric} from {baseline state} to {improved state} by {date} without negatively impacting {secondary metric}. Baseline Metric Performance ( Time frame here ): Short Term Long Term Zbench x.x x.x DPMO xxxxxx xxxxxx 15 Deliv template.ppt
  • 14.
    Upon completing thismodule, students should be able to: Identify and select projects Evaluate a potential Black Belt Project Explain the project selection process Learning Check – Project ID and Selection