Compiling 
Literature Reviews 
in the Life Sciences 
Amanda Werhane 
Steenbock Library 
steenbock.library.wisc.edu
Agenda 
1. Introductions 
2. About Literature Reviews 
3. Literature Sources 
4. Tools & Strategies 
5. For More Information
Introductions 
• Name? 
• Department? 
• Why are you here today? 
• Previous library workshops?
Companion Workshops 
• Writing Literature Reviews (Writing Center) 
• “Everything You Need to Know” (Libraries) 
• “Keeping Up With the Literature” (Libraries) 
• “Publishing Your Research” (Libraries) 
• Workshops on specific databases (Libraries) 
• Workshops on citation managers (Libraries)
Definitions 
• “A literature review is a written document that 
presents a logically argued case founded on a 
comprehensive understanding of the current state of 
knowledge about a topic of study. This case 
establishes a convincing thesis to answer the study’s 
question.” 
- Literature review: Six steps to success (Machi,McEvoy) 
• Introduces theories 
• Shares results of related studies & identifies gaps 
• Locates your research & results within dialogue 
- Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed method 
approaches (Creswell)
Know your Goal 
• What is expected of me? 
• Does my research make a unique contribution? 
• Is it feasible? 
• Do I understand the context? 
• What are the key methodologies, issues, or 
controversies? 
• Do I need to modify my topic? 
• Time management: 
– Dissertation & assignment calculators
Seek out Examples 
• Primary research articles 
• Review articles, meta-analyses 
• Theses & dissertations 
– Databases 
• Ask yourself: 
– How long? 
– How many sources? 
– Placement?
Identify Sources 
• Books 
– Start with: Encyclopedias, dictionaries, handbooks 
• Journal articles 
– Start with: Review articles, meta-analyses 
• Conference proceedings 
– Start with: Big international conferences 
• Other 
– Gov’t documents, technical reports, white papers… 
• How to find = Databases (see handout)
Searching Databases 
• AND, OR, NOT 
• “Phrases in quotes” 
• Truncation, wildcard symbols * ? 
• Limits: 
– Article Title 
– Journal / Source / Publication Title 
– Subject / Descriptor / Classification 
– Many more... 
• Obtaining full text of articles: “Find It”
Follow Citations 
• Backwards + forwards 
• Web of Knowledge / Web of Science 
– “References” 
– “Times Cited” 
– “Cited Reference Search” 
• Journal Citation Reports (JCR) 
– “Impact Factor”
Document your Research 
• Read, take notes, & map sources 
– Concept map tools (see Wikipedia) 
• Compile & map search terms: 
– Synonyms, broader, narrower, and related terms 
– Thesauri, taxonomies, ontologies (ex: MeSH, LCSH) 
– Scientific terms (ex: Latin names, chemical names) 
– Historical terms 
– International terms / alternate spellings 
• Manage citations, documents & notes 
– http://library.wisc.edu/citation-managers
Stay Current 
• Email alerts & RSS feeds: 
– Journal issue tables of contents 
– Keywords 
– Citations
Ask a Librarian 
• Your Liaison Librarian 
- http://library.wisc.edu/directory/liaisons 
• Drop in (desk or office) 
• Chat 
• Phone 
• E-mail 
• Appointments
Good Luck! 
• Thank you for coming  
• Evaluation (Grad Student Collaborative) 
– http://grad.wisc.edu/gsc/evals

Compiling Literature Reviews in the Life Sciences

  • 1.
    Compiling Literature Reviews in the Life Sciences Amanda Werhane Steenbock Library steenbock.library.wisc.edu
  • 2.
    Agenda 1. Introductions 2. About Literature Reviews 3. Literature Sources 4. Tools & Strategies 5. For More Information
  • 3.
    Introductions • Name? • Department? • Why are you here today? • Previous library workshops?
  • 4.
    Companion Workshops •Writing Literature Reviews (Writing Center) • “Everything You Need to Know” (Libraries) • “Keeping Up With the Literature” (Libraries) • “Publishing Your Research” (Libraries) • Workshops on specific databases (Libraries) • Workshops on citation managers (Libraries)
  • 5.
    Definitions • “Aliterature review is a written document that presents a logically argued case founded on a comprehensive understanding of the current state of knowledge about a topic of study. This case establishes a convincing thesis to answer the study’s question.” - Literature review: Six steps to success (Machi,McEvoy) • Introduces theories • Shares results of related studies & identifies gaps • Locates your research & results within dialogue - Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed method approaches (Creswell)
  • 6.
    Know your Goal • What is expected of me? • Does my research make a unique contribution? • Is it feasible? • Do I understand the context? • What are the key methodologies, issues, or controversies? • Do I need to modify my topic? • Time management: – Dissertation & assignment calculators
  • 7.
    Seek out Examples • Primary research articles • Review articles, meta-analyses • Theses & dissertations – Databases • Ask yourself: – How long? – How many sources? – Placement?
  • 8.
    Identify Sources •Books – Start with: Encyclopedias, dictionaries, handbooks • Journal articles – Start with: Review articles, meta-analyses • Conference proceedings – Start with: Big international conferences • Other – Gov’t documents, technical reports, white papers… • How to find = Databases (see handout)
  • 9.
    Searching Databases •AND, OR, NOT • “Phrases in quotes” • Truncation, wildcard symbols * ? • Limits: – Article Title – Journal / Source / Publication Title – Subject / Descriptor / Classification – Many more... • Obtaining full text of articles: “Find It”
  • 10.
    Follow Citations •Backwards + forwards • Web of Knowledge / Web of Science – “References” – “Times Cited” – “Cited Reference Search” • Journal Citation Reports (JCR) – “Impact Factor”
  • 11.
    Document your Research • Read, take notes, & map sources – Concept map tools (see Wikipedia) • Compile & map search terms: – Synonyms, broader, narrower, and related terms – Thesauri, taxonomies, ontologies (ex: MeSH, LCSH) – Scientific terms (ex: Latin names, chemical names) – Historical terms – International terms / alternate spellings • Manage citations, documents & notes – http://library.wisc.edu/citation-managers
  • 12.
    Stay Current •Email alerts & RSS feeds: – Journal issue tables of contents – Keywords – Citations
  • 13.
    Ask a Librarian • Your Liaison Librarian - http://library.wisc.edu/directory/liaisons • Drop in (desk or office) • Chat • Phone • E-mail • Appointments
  • 14.
    Good Luck! •Thank you for coming  • Evaluation (Grad Student Collaborative) – http://grad.wisc.edu/gsc/evals

Editor's Notes

  • #4 Amanda Werhane librarian at Steenbock Library Steenbock primarily serves CALS, SOHE, Vet Med, Nelson IES, UW Extension open to everyone, popular with undergrads in nearby dorms liaison librarian for the plant & insect science departments in the College of Agricultural & Life Sciences Masters degree in librarianship 5 years ago Bachelors degree in Conservation Biology 14 years ago * How many of you have met your department’s liaison librarian?
  • #5 Writing Center website Library Workshops by date and Workshops by subject website
  • #6  Logically argued case – not just an annotated list of articles Comprehensive, state of knowledge – broad and deep Establishes a convincing thesis – clearly provides a context and establishes the basis for your research
  • #8  Primary research articles Every scholarly article cites previously-published research http://library.wisc.edu – Databases – Top 10 – Web of Science – All Databases – madison in address – current week Pick an article to look at – Find It “Examination of Xenorhabdus nematophila lipases in pathogenic and mutualistic host interactions reveals a role for xlpA in nematode progeny production” Review articles: “Vertebrate maternal-effect genes: Insights into fertilization, early cleavage divisions, and germ cell determinant localization from studies in the zebrafish” Theses & dissertations: http://library.wisc.edu – Databases – dissertations – Search – Theses & Dissertations – Advanced – Goldman Irwin in Advisor “Development of Carrot…” – Chapter 1 is “Review of Relevant Literature” – browse to Ch.1 references Types of literature: books, journal articles, government documents, websites, dissertations, Publications back to 1922, and something “in press”
  • #9 * Multidisciplinary Online Sources / Subject-Specific
  • #10 All databases are different Look for “Help” files http://clue.library.wisc.edu http://library.wisc.edu/research-tips
  • #12  Dissertation calculator – search Google Assignment calculator – search UW website (College Library) MeSH – Databases – Top 10 – PubMed – “alkaline phosphatase” in MeSH - demonstrate synonyms, broader, narrower, and related terms LCSH – MadCat – cranberries – “Insects and diseases injurious to cranberries” – click subject Concept map tools – search Wikipedia
  • #15 * “Books for More Info” handout