SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
Technology for Additive and
Subtractive Manufactured Parts
Dave Davidson
Deburring/Finishing Technologist
ddavidson@deburring-tech-group.com
https://dryfinish.wixsite.com/iso-finish
Past-Chair, Deburring/Finishing Technical Committee
Society of Manufacturing Engineers
Table of
Contents
Part 1 – Mass Finishing Process
Primer
Part 2 – Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
Process Principles
Part 3 - Additive Manufactured
Part Applications
Part 4 - What about other parts?
Part 1
What is Mass
Finishing?
• Mass finishing is a term used to
describe a group of abrasive industrial
processes by which large lots of parts
or components made from metal or
other materials can be economically
processed (edge or surface finished) in
bulk.
• All mass finishing processes utilize a
loose or free abrasive material referred
to as media within a container or
chamber of some sort. Energy is
imparted to the abrasive media mass
by a variety of means to impart motion
to it and to cause it to rub or wear
away at part surfaces.
What edge and
surface effects
can be
created?
• This processing is performed to achieve one or several
of a variety of edge and surface effects:
(1) Edge effects: Deburring, edge-break, radius
formation
(2) Surface effects: removal of surface contaminants
from heat treat and other processes, pre-plate, pre-
paint or coating surface preparation, blending in
surface irregularities from machining or fabricating
operations, producing reflective surfaces with
nonabrasive burnishing media, refining surfaces,
developing super-finish or micro-finish equivalent
surface profiles, developing compressive stress with
burnishing media to improve fatigue or wear
resistance, smoothing rough-cast or 3D Printed
Parts, improve isotropicity, promote negatively
skewed surface profiles for cooperating parts,
minimizing hand-deburring operations
Why Mass
Finishing?
• Nearly all manufactured parts or
components require some measure of
surface refinement prior to final assembly,
or the final finish or coating required to
make the parts acceptable to the
consumer or end-user.
• Most manufacturing companies who
employ mass finishing techniques do so
because of the economic advantages to be
obtained, especially when compared with
manual deburring and surface finishing
techniques.
• Mass finishing processes often reduce or
eliminate many procedures that are labor-
intensive and require extensive part
handling.
Mass
Finishing
Versatility
Although each of the mass finishing process types
carries with it a unique set of process strengths and
weaknesses, all of them are sufficiently versatile to be
able to process a wide variety of part types
successfully.
A plethora of abrasive media types, sizes, and shapes
makes it possible, in many cases, to achieve very
different results within the same equipment, ranging
from heavy grinding and radiusing to final finishing.
Components from almost every conceivable type of
material have been surface conditioned using mass
finishing techniques including ferrous and nonferrous
metals, plastics, composition materials, ceramics, and
even wood.
Mass
Finishing
Cautions
Despite the immense versatility of these types of processes, some
potential process limitations should be noted. It can be difficult to
selectively treat certain part areas to the exclusion of other areas,
which might have critical dimensional tolerance requirements. Unless
masked or fixtured, all exterior areas of the part will be affected by
the process to a greater or lesser degree, with effects on corners and
edges being more pronounced than those on flat areas, and with
interior holes, channels, and recesses being relatively unaffected in
the more common processes.
Care must be exercised in media size, shape selection, and
maintenance to prevent media lodging in holes and recesses, which
might require labor-intensive manual removal. Some parts have
shapes, sizes, or weights that may preclude them from being finished
in some mass finishing processes because of the risk of impingement
from part-on-part contact or of nesting due to certain features of the
parts interlocking together when in proximity. Additionally, most
processes that use water in conjunction with the abrasive media
create an effluent stream, which must be treated prior to discharge
into a municipal sewage or another disposal.
Mass
Finishing
Equipment
One of the more obvious factors influencing mass finishing processes
is equipment selection. There are five major equipment groups as
follows, two of these are low energy methods, two are high-energy
and one is dependent on part fixturing and is considered a high
energy method variant.
Barrel, vibratory, centrifugal barrel, centrifugal disk, and spin/spindle
finishing.
The first four groups are primarily used with parts immersed within a
body of abrasive media and are capable of some independent
movement within that mass. On occasion, fixturing or some
processing segmentation may be used to isolate delicate or critical
parts from each other. Part-on-part contact may also be minimized by
using higher media-to-part ratio combinations. Common media-to-
part ratios for noncritical parts run anywhere from 1:1 to 1:4 by
volume. Parts with a higher need for cushioning and protection may
utilize media/part ratios as high as 10:1 to 15:1.
Mass Finishing
– Part of the
Manufacturing
Process
Much time and money can be saved both in mass finishing
process operations and in process development if finishing
considerations are given sufficient weight at the design,
production, and quality control stages. Although it is a rule
more breached than observed, it should be noted that
mass finishing processes are not, and were never intended
to be, methods for rectifying errors made in earlier stages
of the manufacturing process.
It should be equally obvious that processes developed for
parts made with tools and dies that are sharp will
no longer produce the same results when that tooling
becomes dull. Mass finishing processes can produce
remarkably uniform results if process parameters are
followed carefully, but this assumes some measure of
uniformity of surface condition for a given part within a lot,
and from lot-to-lot, as received in the finishing area.
Part 2 - Centrifugal Iso-
Finishing Principles:
Equipment and
Operations
How does it work?
Machinery
Abrasive and Polishing Media
Processes
CC
• Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Technology operation is
similar to the operation of a "Ferris Wheel" but
this Ferris wheel operates at high rotational
speed with the turret swinging the barrels
around its periphery while the barrels counter-
rotate at high speed.
• This motion imparts high centrifugal force to
the parts and media in the processing
chambers. Finishing and polishing work is
performed 10 times faster than conventional
low-energy finishing equipment. On many parts,
single-digit micro-inch Ra surface finishes can
be achieved.
Why Both Wet
and Dry
Processing?
• This composite shot shows the interior of a centrifugal barrel finishing machine,
showing a barrel with parts, plastic media and liquid compound to the left, and dry
polishing granules to the right. Once the parts have been smoothed sufficiently
they will be removed from the wet processing compartment and moved to another
compartment with dry polishing.
• Burnishing processes use small heavy non-abrasive media to produce burnished
surfaces. Burnished surfaces have a less polished appearance but develop useful
beneficial compressive stress on the order of shot peening, but without the
undesirable positively skewed surface that shot-peening leaves behind.
Video of Wet and Dry Processing with
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing machine
*Connection to internet and YouTube required.
Part Application: Centrifugal Iso-Burnishing
Before and after examples of 3 step Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Processing
Before and after
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
with 3D printed
component with both
flat and radiused
features
Hands Free Surface Finishing
3D Jewelry Components.
Small 3D Part Finishing and
Polishing
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
3D Printed Jewelry
Wet process smoothing and dry process polishing is used for
smoothing and then polishing precious metal jewelry
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing 3D Printed Aerospace parts
Parts are finished and polish using a Model HZ-85 with barrel divider panels to isolate parts from each other and
preserve local micro-inch surfaces.. The long length of the barrels make processing large part volumes possible.
Before and after examples of 2 step Centrifugal Iso-Burnishing Processes
Metal Fatigue
Resistance Benefit –
Centrifugal Iso-
Finishing compared
with shot peening
X-Ray diffraction used graph and
compare residual stress
development between Shot peening
(Dull – Shot peened) and Centrifugal
Iso-Burnishing process (Shiny
Processed)
Take-away Point:
Beginning Surface
Roughness =
356.24 µin. Ra
Take away point
After processing
Surface Roughness =
12.06 µin Ra
Note: More neutral or negatively skewed
surface provides better bearing supporting
surface than the positively skewed surface
shown on surface prior to Centrifugal Iso-
Finish Processing.
Comparative Evaluation of 3D Part Surface Finishes.
In this example, the same part (built standard without optimization
to address porosity or features)... was sent with the same
instructions (to polish to the highest finish possible) to five surface
finishing companies. The five different results are shown in the chart
to the right. Results compiled and storyboard developed by Shannon
Van Derren, President, Layered Manufacturing Consultants
(1) Post-Process: Multi-Cycle method, may include wet blasting with follow-up with
vibratory finishing. Multi-hour processing
(2) Rem-Chem: Multi-cycle vibratory processing. Final-Finishing often performed with
acidic accelerant compounds containing oxalic acid, maleic acid or similar material
with non-abrasive media. Outer layer is oxidized with surface peaks and asperities
incrementally removed as processing progresses.
(3) Bel Air: Vendor utilizes a variety of finishing methods, including drag finishing,
centrifugal disc, vibratory and cbf.
(4) Centrifugal Iso-Finishing. Three steps, 3D parts are typically processed (1) Heavy
abrasive smoothing: 1.5-2 hours. (2) Fine smoothing: 30 minutes (3) Final dry
polishing: 30 minutes. Cycle times vary with alloy and part geometry.
(5) Micro-tek: Primarily an unconventional electro-chemical or electro-polishing
technique. Available as a contract finishing service only.
Centrifugal Iso-
Finishing
Equipment
• Standard Machine models vary in
capacity from 1.4 cubic feet (40
liters) to 12 cubic feet (330) liters.
• All machine models feature a four
barrel configuration.
• Differing processes can be run in
the machine at the same time.
Typically process A would be run
in barrel numbers 1 and 3, while
process B would be run in barrels
2 and 4 to assure that the machine
is being operated in a balanced
condition.
Newly Designed Model HZ-85 used widely in the medical and
aerospace industries for super-finishing and polishing critical parts
Equipment
Size and
Configuration
There are two major equipment
families in the machinery line.
(1) Six-inch diameter machines for
processing small to moderately
sized parts.
(2) Twelve-inch diameter machines
for processing large parts and
larger batch volumes of parts
Abrasive, Smoothing, Burnishing and Polishing Media
Process Development and Sample Part
Processing Operations
Free sample part processing program analyzes and inspects parts,
determines the correct media and machine model and sequence of
operations to produce the required surface finish needed.
To make arrangements for submitting parts into the free sample
part processing program contact Dave Davidson at
ddavidson@deburring-tech-group.com
Contract Finishing Process Development
Outsourcing the surface finishing of 3D printed parts is available. Process
engineers will develop Centrifugal Iso-Finishing processes, submit parts
for approval and provide a quotation for post-process finishing.
To submit parts into the free sample part processing program contact
Dave Davidson at ddavidson@deburring-tech-group.com
Video: Example of Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Operations
in a Precision Machining Contract Finishing Company
• See the video on YouTube at
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dUdKjaysTYM&t=377s
Part 4 -What about conventional
or subtractive manufactured part
finishing?
• Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
often performs deburring,
finishing and polishing
functions 10 times faster
than conventional low
energy methods.
• Centrifugal force presses
media against edges and
surfaces with 10 G’s where
conventional finishing
systems are 1 G systems only
• This centrifugal pressure
produces beneficial
compressive stress in some
cases on the order of that
produced by shot peening
but with much more refined
isotropic surfaces
High performance automotive engine part finishing, extends engine
service life, improves engine performance
Automotive
Cooperating Parts
• Performance Benefits
• Reduced friction
• Increased part durability
• Improved corrosion resistance
• Reduced wear
• Reduced lubrication requirements and
cost
• Improved oil retention
• Reduced contact and bending fatigue
• Improved pitting resistance
• Reduced vibration and noise
attenuation
• Reduced applied torque requirements
• Improved surface finish uniformity
(part-to-part, feature-to-feature, and lot-
to-lot)
• High-quality, micro-finished surfaces
• Reduced Friction Benefits
• Increased fuel economy
• Reduced contact fatigue
• Increased power density
• Lower operating temperature
• Extended mean time between
maintenance overhauls
• Reduced maintenance costs
• Eliminated break-in
• Extended component life
• Reduced metal debris
• Reduced part failures
• Minimized overheating
Fit and Function Improvement
Mechanical components and assemblies perform more reliably and smoothly with low micro-inch surface finishes
produced by Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
Polishing Aerospace Engine Parts
after Machining and At Overhaul
Medical and Dental Part Finishing and Polishing
Centrifugal Iso-Finished Components.
Finishing and Polishing
Castings
Finishing and Polishing
Medical Parts
Hands-free polishing of aluminum
castings prior to powder coating
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
Machined Components
CENTRIFUGAL ISO-FINISH
Advantages over and above
Superior Edge and Surface Finish
(Before) Ground Surface (After) Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
(1)
(2)
(3)
(1) Compressive stress generation for improved fatigue failure resistance
(2) Isotropic Surfaces for wear and crack resistance
(3) Planarized or plateaued surfaces for improved bearing load surfaces
(After) Centrifugal Iso-Finishing(Before) Cast Surface
High Magnification SEM (Scanning Electron Micro-scope
X-Ray Diffraction
SWLI (Scanning White Light Interferometer)
3D Texture Mapping
Follow up. Next step.
Sample Part Processing
For assistance with (free) sample part processing, contract finishing
quotations or equipment and process quotations CONTACT:
Dave Davidson at ddavidson@deburring-tech-group.com

More Related Content

What's hot

Surface finishing process
Surface finishing processSurface finishing process
Surface finishing process
Siya Agarwal
 
Analysis of abrasive jet machining parameters on mrr and kerf width of hard a...
Analysis of abrasive jet machining parameters on mrr and kerf width of hard a...Analysis of abrasive jet machining parameters on mrr and kerf width of hard a...
Analysis of abrasive jet machining parameters on mrr and kerf width of hard a...
IAEME Publication
 

What's hot (20)

2005 codef proceedings - turbo-abrasive machining
2005 codef proceedings - turbo-abrasive machining2005 codef proceedings - turbo-abrasive machining
2005 codef proceedings - turbo-abrasive machining
 
particle technology (report)
particle technology (report)particle technology (report)
particle technology (report)
 
Srppt
SrpptSrppt
Srppt
 
Surface finishing process
Surface finishing processSurface finishing process
Surface finishing process
 
size reduction,laws involved in size reduction ,application & mills
 size reduction,laws involved in size reduction ,application & mills size reduction,laws involved in size reduction ,application & mills
size reduction,laws involved in size reduction ,application & mills
 
Size reduction and the importance of particle size
Size reduction and the importance of particle sizeSize reduction and the importance of particle size
Size reduction and the importance of particle size
 
micronization by pankaj
 micronization by pankaj micronization by pankaj
micronization by pankaj
 
Analysis of abrasive jet machining parameters on mrr and kerf width of hard a...
Analysis of abrasive jet machining parameters on mrr and kerf width of hard a...Analysis of abrasive jet machining parameters on mrr and kerf width of hard a...
Analysis of abrasive jet machining parameters on mrr and kerf width of hard a...
 
Size reduction
Size reductionSize reduction
Size reduction
 
A REVIEW ON ABRASIVE JET MACHINING
A REVIEW ON ABRASIVE JET MACHININGA REVIEW ON ABRASIVE JET MACHINING
A REVIEW ON ABRASIVE JET MACHINING
 
Surface finishing processes
Surface finishing processesSurface finishing processes
Surface finishing processes
 
Ajm ppt12345 copy fr ucm
Ajm ppt12345   copy fr ucmAjm ppt12345   copy fr ucm
Ajm ppt12345 copy fr ucm
 
Lapping Machine Process and Application
Lapping Machine Process and ApplicationLapping Machine Process and Application
Lapping Machine Process and Application
 
Pharmaceutical Engineering: Size reduction
Pharmaceutical Engineering: Size reductionPharmaceutical Engineering: Size reduction
Pharmaceutical Engineering: Size reduction
 
Ajm unit 2
Ajm unit 2Ajm unit 2
Ajm unit 2
 
Size reduction f copy
Size reduction f   copySize reduction f   copy
Size reduction f copy
 
Ball mill
Ball millBall mill
Ball mill
 
Types of grinders
Types of grindersTypes of grinders
Types of grinders
 
Abrasive water jet machining
Abrasive water jet machiningAbrasive water jet machining
Abrasive water jet machining
 
Abrasive jet machining
Abrasive jet machiningAbrasive jet machining
Abrasive jet machining
 

Similar to Centrifugal Iso-Finishing for Additive Manufactured Parts

Vibratory finishing versatile effective and reliable finishing
Vibratory finishing   versatile effective and reliable finishingVibratory finishing   versatile effective and reliable finishing
Vibratory finishing versatile effective and reliable finishing
Dave Davidson
 

Similar to Centrifugal Iso-Finishing for Additive Manufactured Parts (20)

Metal finishing deveopments article
Metal finishing deveopments articleMetal finishing deveopments article
Metal finishing deveopments article
 
Mr82 264
Mr82 264Mr82 264
Mr82 264
 
Turbo-Finish Technical Bulletin
Turbo-Finish Technical BulletinTurbo-Finish Technical Bulletin
Turbo-Finish Technical Bulletin
 
Turbo sme-99
Turbo sme-99Turbo sme-99
Turbo sme-99
 
Tf 3rd sme international machining conference-rev a-
Tf 3rd sme international machining conference-rev a-Tf 3rd sme international machining conference-rev a-
Tf 3rd sme international machining conference-rev a-
 
Convert machined surfaces to plateaued surf
Convert machined surfaces to plateaued surfConvert machined surfaces to plateaued surf
Convert machined surfaces to plateaued surf
 
Vibratory finishing versatile effective and reliable finishing
Vibratory finishing   versatile effective and reliable finishingVibratory finishing   versatile effective and reliable finishing
Vibratory finishing versatile effective and reliable finishing
 
Gillam cascade
Gillam cascadeGillam cascade
Gillam cascade
 
Greem finish-davidson
Greem finish-davidsonGreem finish-davidson
Greem finish-davidson
 
Developmentsindrymassfin davidson
Developmentsindrymassfin davidsonDevelopmentsindrymassfin davidson
Developmentsindrymassfin davidson
 
Finite Element Analysis of Roller Burnishing Process
Finite Element Analysis of Roller Burnishing ProcessFinite Element Analysis of Roller Burnishing Process
Finite Element Analysis of Roller Burnishing Process
 
Assignment 03
Assignment 03Assignment 03
Assignment 03
 
UNIT-4.pptx
UNIT-4.pptxUNIT-4.pptx
UNIT-4.pptx
 
Turbofinish99
Turbofinish99Turbofinish99
Turbofinish99
 
Davidson rt
Davidson rtDavidson rt
Davidson rt
 
Davidson centrifugal finishing
Davidson centrifugal finishingDavidson centrifugal finishing
Davidson centrifugal finishing
 
Mr81 231
Mr81 231Mr81 231
Mr81 231
 
K10672
K10672K10672
K10672
 
Turbo finish press release
Turbo finish press releaseTurbo finish press release
Turbo finish press release
 
October 2013 f2 deburring 1
October 2013 f2 deburring 1October 2013 f2 deburring 1
October 2013 f2 deburring 1
 

More from Dave Davidson

More from Dave Davidson (20)

MFI Mass Finishing Equipment and Media
MFI Mass Finishing Equipment and MediaMFI Mass Finishing Equipment and Media
MFI Mass Finishing Equipment and Media
 
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
Centrifugal Iso-FinishingCentrifugal Iso-Finishing
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
 
Modern machine-shop-apr-18 centrifugal isofinishing crnakshafts
Modern machine-shop-apr-18 centrifugal isofinishing crnakshaftsModern machine-shop-apr-18 centrifugal isofinishing crnakshafts
Modern machine-shop-apr-18 centrifugal isofinishing crnakshafts
 
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Technical article as seen in Products Finishing mag...
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Technical article as seen in Products Finishing mag...Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Technical article as seen in Products Finishing mag...
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Technical article as seen in Products Finishing mag...
 
Iso-Finishing sample part finishing application form
Iso-Finishing sample part finishing application formIso-Finishing sample part finishing application form
Iso-Finishing sample part finishing application form
 
MFI full finishing product catalog with technical assistance info
MFI full finishing product catalog with technical assistance infoMFI full finishing product catalog with technical assistance info
MFI full finishing product catalog with technical assistance info
 
It's the Finish that Counts. Technical Magazine article reprint.
It's the Finish that Counts. Technical Magazine article reprint.It's the Finish that Counts. Technical Magazine article reprint.
It's the Finish that Counts. Technical Magazine article reprint.
 
Gear Finishing Technical Intewrview
Gear Finishing Technical IntewrviewGear Finishing Technical Intewrview
Gear Finishing Technical Intewrview
 
BV PRODUCTS - Bowl and Tub Vibratory Finishing Systems
BV PRODUCTS - Bowl and Tub Vibratory Finishing SystemsBV PRODUCTS - Bowl and Tub Vibratory Finishing Systems
BV PRODUCTS - Bowl and Tub Vibratory Finishing Systems
 
BV PRODUCTS VIBRATORY FINISHING SYSTEMS FOR DEBURRING AND FINISHING
BV PRODUCTS VIBRATORY FINISHING SYSTEMS FOR DEBURRING AND FINISHINGBV PRODUCTS VIBRATORY FINISHING SYSTEMS FOR DEBURRING AND FINISHING
BV PRODUCTS VIBRATORY FINISHING SYSTEMS FOR DEBURRING AND FINISHING
 
BV Products - Vibratory Finishing machinery for deburring and polishing
BV Products - Vibratory Finishing machinery for deburring and polishingBV Products - Vibratory Finishing machinery for deburring and polishing
BV Products - Vibratory Finishing machinery for deburring and polishing
 
BV Products TECHNOVIBE Series
BV Products TECHNOVIBE Series BV Products TECHNOVIBE Series
BV Products TECHNOVIBE Series
 
Centrifugal iso finishing sample processing
Centrifugal iso finishing sample processingCentrifugal iso finishing sample processing
Centrifugal iso finishing sample processing
 
Centrifugal iso finishing contract services
Centrifugal iso finishing contract services Centrifugal iso finishing contract services
Centrifugal iso finishing contract services
 
Centrifugal iso-Finishing 3D parts
Centrifugal iso-Finishing 3D partsCentrifugal iso-Finishing 3D parts
Centrifugal iso-Finishing 3D parts
 
Centrifugal iso finishing - part dividers
Centrifugal iso finishing - part dividersCentrifugal iso finishing - part dividers
Centrifugal iso finishing - part dividers
 
Final vibratory iso-finishing processes
Final   vibratory iso-finishing processesFinal   vibratory iso-finishing processes
Final vibratory iso-finishing processes
 
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Equipment
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing EquipmentCentrifugal Iso-Finishing Equipment
Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Equipment
 
Centrifugal iso finishing - Equipment description
Centrifugal iso finishing - Equipment descriptionCentrifugal iso finishing - Equipment description
Centrifugal iso finishing - Equipment description
 
Centrifugal iso finishing - how it works
Centrifugal iso finishing - how it worksCentrifugal iso finishing - how it works
Centrifugal iso finishing - how it works
 

Recently uploaded

RS Khurmi Machine Design Clutch and Brake Exercise Numerical Solutions
RS Khurmi Machine Design Clutch and Brake Exercise Numerical SolutionsRS Khurmi Machine Design Clutch and Brake Exercise Numerical Solutions
RS Khurmi Machine Design Clutch and Brake Exercise Numerical Solutions
Atif Razi
 
School management system project report.pdf
School management system project report.pdfSchool management system project report.pdf
School management system project report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 
Standard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Standard Reomte Control Interface - NeometrixStandard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Standard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Neometrix_Engineering_Pvt_Ltd
 
Laundry management system project report.pdf
Laundry management system project report.pdfLaundry management system project report.pdf
Laundry management system project report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
 

Recently uploaded (20)

NO1 Pandit Black Magic Removal in Uk kala jadu Specialist kala jadu for Love ...
NO1 Pandit Black Magic Removal in Uk kala jadu Specialist kala jadu for Love ...NO1 Pandit Black Magic Removal in Uk kala jadu Specialist kala jadu for Love ...
NO1 Pandit Black Magic Removal in Uk kala jadu Specialist kala jadu for Love ...
 
Arduino based vehicle speed tracker project
Arduino based vehicle speed tracker projectArduino based vehicle speed tracker project
Arduino based vehicle speed tracker project
 
Explosives Industry manufacturing process.pdf
Explosives Industry manufacturing process.pdfExplosives Industry manufacturing process.pdf
Explosives Industry manufacturing process.pdf
 
Courier management system project report.pdf
Courier management system project report.pdfCourier management system project report.pdf
Courier management system project report.pdf
 
ASME IX(9) 2007 Full Version .pdf
ASME IX(9)  2007 Full Version       .pdfASME IX(9)  2007 Full Version       .pdf
ASME IX(9) 2007 Full Version .pdf
 
Construction method of steel structure space frame .pptx
Construction method of steel structure space frame .pptxConstruction method of steel structure space frame .pptx
Construction method of steel structure space frame .pptx
 
RS Khurmi Machine Design Clutch and Brake Exercise Numerical Solutions
RS Khurmi Machine Design Clutch and Brake Exercise Numerical SolutionsRS Khurmi Machine Design Clutch and Brake Exercise Numerical Solutions
RS Khurmi Machine Design Clutch and Brake Exercise Numerical Solutions
 
School management system project report.pdf
School management system project report.pdfSchool management system project report.pdf
School management system project report.pdf
 
Quality defects in TMT Bars, Possible causes and Potential Solutions.
Quality defects in TMT Bars, Possible causes and Potential Solutions.Quality defects in TMT Bars, Possible causes and Potential Solutions.
Quality defects in TMT Bars, Possible causes and Potential Solutions.
 
Standard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Standard Reomte Control Interface - NeometrixStandard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
Standard Reomte Control Interface - Neometrix
 
KIT-601 Lecture Notes-UNIT-4.pdf Frequent Itemsets and Clustering
KIT-601 Lecture Notes-UNIT-4.pdf Frequent Itemsets and ClusteringKIT-601 Lecture Notes-UNIT-4.pdf Frequent Itemsets and Clustering
KIT-601 Lecture Notes-UNIT-4.pdf Frequent Itemsets and Clustering
 
Scaling in conventional MOSFET for constant electric field and constant voltage
Scaling in conventional MOSFET for constant electric field and constant voltageScaling in conventional MOSFET for constant electric field and constant voltage
Scaling in conventional MOSFET for constant electric field and constant voltage
 
The Benefits and Techniques of Trenchless Pipe Repair.pdf
The Benefits and Techniques of Trenchless Pipe Repair.pdfThe Benefits and Techniques of Trenchless Pipe Repair.pdf
The Benefits and Techniques of Trenchless Pipe Repair.pdf
 
HYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generation
HYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generationHYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generation
HYDROPOWER - Hydroelectric power generation
 
Electrostatic field in a coaxial transmission line
Electrostatic field in a coaxial transmission lineElectrostatic field in a coaxial transmission line
Electrostatic field in a coaxial transmission line
 
Top 13 Famous Civil Engineering Scientist
Top 13 Famous Civil Engineering ScientistTop 13 Famous Civil Engineering Scientist
Top 13 Famous Civil Engineering Scientist
 
Pharmacy management system project report..pdf
Pharmacy management system project report..pdfPharmacy management system project report..pdf
Pharmacy management system project report..pdf
 
Halogenation process of chemical process industries
Halogenation process of chemical process industriesHalogenation process of chemical process industries
Halogenation process of chemical process industries
 
shape functions of 1D and 2 D rectangular elements.pptx
shape functions of 1D and 2 D rectangular elements.pptxshape functions of 1D and 2 D rectangular elements.pptx
shape functions of 1D and 2 D rectangular elements.pptx
 
Laundry management system project report.pdf
Laundry management system project report.pdfLaundry management system project report.pdf
Laundry management system project report.pdf
 

Centrifugal Iso-Finishing for Additive Manufactured Parts

  • 1. Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Technology for Additive and Subtractive Manufactured Parts Dave Davidson Deburring/Finishing Technologist ddavidson@deburring-tech-group.com https://dryfinish.wixsite.com/iso-finish Past-Chair, Deburring/Finishing Technical Committee Society of Manufacturing Engineers
  • 2. Table of Contents Part 1 – Mass Finishing Process Primer Part 2 – Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Process Principles Part 3 - Additive Manufactured Part Applications Part 4 - What about other parts?
  • 3. Part 1 What is Mass Finishing? • Mass finishing is a term used to describe a group of abrasive industrial processes by which large lots of parts or components made from metal or other materials can be economically processed (edge or surface finished) in bulk. • All mass finishing processes utilize a loose or free abrasive material referred to as media within a container or chamber of some sort. Energy is imparted to the abrasive media mass by a variety of means to impart motion to it and to cause it to rub or wear away at part surfaces.
  • 4. What edge and surface effects can be created? • This processing is performed to achieve one or several of a variety of edge and surface effects: (1) Edge effects: Deburring, edge-break, radius formation (2) Surface effects: removal of surface contaminants from heat treat and other processes, pre-plate, pre- paint or coating surface preparation, blending in surface irregularities from machining or fabricating operations, producing reflective surfaces with nonabrasive burnishing media, refining surfaces, developing super-finish or micro-finish equivalent surface profiles, developing compressive stress with burnishing media to improve fatigue or wear resistance, smoothing rough-cast or 3D Printed Parts, improve isotropicity, promote negatively skewed surface profiles for cooperating parts, minimizing hand-deburring operations
  • 5. Why Mass Finishing? • Nearly all manufactured parts or components require some measure of surface refinement prior to final assembly, or the final finish or coating required to make the parts acceptable to the consumer or end-user. • Most manufacturing companies who employ mass finishing techniques do so because of the economic advantages to be obtained, especially when compared with manual deburring and surface finishing techniques. • Mass finishing processes often reduce or eliminate many procedures that are labor- intensive and require extensive part handling.
  • 6. Mass Finishing Versatility Although each of the mass finishing process types carries with it a unique set of process strengths and weaknesses, all of them are sufficiently versatile to be able to process a wide variety of part types successfully. A plethora of abrasive media types, sizes, and shapes makes it possible, in many cases, to achieve very different results within the same equipment, ranging from heavy grinding and radiusing to final finishing. Components from almost every conceivable type of material have been surface conditioned using mass finishing techniques including ferrous and nonferrous metals, plastics, composition materials, ceramics, and even wood.
  • 7. Mass Finishing Cautions Despite the immense versatility of these types of processes, some potential process limitations should be noted. It can be difficult to selectively treat certain part areas to the exclusion of other areas, which might have critical dimensional tolerance requirements. Unless masked or fixtured, all exterior areas of the part will be affected by the process to a greater or lesser degree, with effects on corners and edges being more pronounced than those on flat areas, and with interior holes, channels, and recesses being relatively unaffected in the more common processes. Care must be exercised in media size, shape selection, and maintenance to prevent media lodging in holes and recesses, which might require labor-intensive manual removal. Some parts have shapes, sizes, or weights that may preclude them from being finished in some mass finishing processes because of the risk of impingement from part-on-part contact or of nesting due to certain features of the parts interlocking together when in proximity. Additionally, most processes that use water in conjunction with the abrasive media create an effluent stream, which must be treated prior to discharge into a municipal sewage or another disposal.
  • 8. Mass Finishing Equipment One of the more obvious factors influencing mass finishing processes is equipment selection. There are five major equipment groups as follows, two of these are low energy methods, two are high-energy and one is dependent on part fixturing and is considered a high energy method variant. Barrel, vibratory, centrifugal barrel, centrifugal disk, and spin/spindle finishing. The first four groups are primarily used with parts immersed within a body of abrasive media and are capable of some independent movement within that mass. On occasion, fixturing or some processing segmentation may be used to isolate delicate or critical parts from each other. Part-on-part contact may also be minimized by using higher media-to-part ratio combinations. Common media-to- part ratios for noncritical parts run anywhere from 1:1 to 1:4 by volume. Parts with a higher need for cushioning and protection may utilize media/part ratios as high as 10:1 to 15:1.
  • 9. Mass Finishing – Part of the Manufacturing Process Much time and money can be saved both in mass finishing process operations and in process development if finishing considerations are given sufficient weight at the design, production, and quality control stages. Although it is a rule more breached than observed, it should be noted that mass finishing processes are not, and were never intended to be, methods for rectifying errors made in earlier stages of the manufacturing process. It should be equally obvious that processes developed for parts made with tools and dies that are sharp will no longer produce the same results when that tooling becomes dull. Mass finishing processes can produce remarkably uniform results if process parameters are followed carefully, but this assumes some measure of uniformity of surface condition for a given part within a lot, and from lot-to-lot, as received in the finishing area.
  • 10. Part 2 - Centrifugal Iso- Finishing Principles: Equipment and Operations How does it work? Machinery Abrasive and Polishing Media Processes
  • 11. CC • Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Technology operation is similar to the operation of a "Ferris Wheel" but this Ferris wheel operates at high rotational speed with the turret swinging the barrels around its periphery while the barrels counter- rotate at high speed. • This motion imparts high centrifugal force to the parts and media in the processing chambers. Finishing and polishing work is performed 10 times faster than conventional low-energy finishing equipment. On many parts, single-digit micro-inch Ra surface finishes can be achieved.
  • 12. Why Both Wet and Dry Processing? • This composite shot shows the interior of a centrifugal barrel finishing machine, showing a barrel with parts, plastic media and liquid compound to the left, and dry polishing granules to the right. Once the parts have been smoothed sufficiently they will be removed from the wet processing compartment and moved to another compartment with dry polishing. • Burnishing processes use small heavy non-abrasive media to produce burnished surfaces. Burnished surfaces have a less polished appearance but develop useful beneficial compressive stress on the order of shot peening, but without the undesirable positively skewed surface that shot-peening leaves behind.
  • 13. Video of Wet and Dry Processing with Centrifugal Iso-Finishing machine *Connection to internet and YouTube required.
  • 14. Part Application: Centrifugal Iso-Burnishing Before and after examples of 3 step Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Processing
  • 15. Before and after Centrifugal Iso-Finishing with 3D printed component with both flat and radiused features
  • 16. Hands Free Surface Finishing 3D Jewelry Components.
  • 17. Small 3D Part Finishing and Polishing
  • 18. Centrifugal Iso-Finishing 3D Printed Jewelry Wet process smoothing and dry process polishing is used for smoothing and then polishing precious metal jewelry
  • 19. Centrifugal Iso-Finishing 3D Printed Aerospace parts Parts are finished and polish using a Model HZ-85 with barrel divider panels to isolate parts from each other and preserve local micro-inch surfaces.. The long length of the barrels make processing large part volumes possible.
  • 20. Before and after examples of 2 step Centrifugal Iso-Burnishing Processes
  • 21. Metal Fatigue Resistance Benefit – Centrifugal Iso- Finishing compared with shot peening X-Ray diffraction used graph and compare residual stress development between Shot peening (Dull – Shot peened) and Centrifugal Iso-Burnishing process (Shiny Processed)
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 26.
  • 27. Take away point After processing Surface Roughness = 12.06 µin Ra
  • 28. Note: More neutral or negatively skewed surface provides better bearing supporting surface than the positively skewed surface shown on surface prior to Centrifugal Iso- Finish Processing.
  • 29.
  • 30. Comparative Evaluation of 3D Part Surface Finishes. In this example, the same part (built standard without optimization to address porosity or features)... was sent with the same instructions (to polish to the highest finish possible) to five surface finishing companies. The five different results are shown in the chart to the right. Results compiled and storyboard developed by Shannon Van Derren, President, Layered Manufacturing Consultants (1) Post-Process: Multi-Cycle method, may include wet blasting with follow-up with vibratory finishing. Multi-hour processing (2) Rem-Chem: Multi-cycle vibratory processing. Final-Finishing often performed with acidic accelerant compounds containing oxalic acid, maleic acid or similar material with non-abrasive media. Outer layer is oxidized with surface peaks and asperities incrementally removed as processing progresses. (3) Bel Air: Vendor utilizes a variety of finishing methods, including drag finishing, centrifugal disc, vibratory and cbf. (4) Centrifugal Iso-Finishing. Three steps, 3D parts are typically processed (1) Heavy abrasive smoothing: 1.5-2 hours. (2) Fine smoothing: 30 minutes (3) Final dry polishing: 30 minutes. Cycle times vary with alloy and part geometry. (5) Micro-tek: Primarily an unconventional electro-chemical or electro-polishing technique. Available as a contract finishing service only.
  • 31. Centrifugal Iso- Finishing Equipment • Standard Machine models vary in capacity from 1.4 cubic feet (40 liters) to 12 cubic feet (330) liters. • All machine models feature a four barrel configuration. • Differing processes can be run in the machine at the same time. Typically process A would be run in barrel numbers 1 and 3, while process B would be run in barrels 2 and 4 to assure that the machine is being operated in a balanced condition.
  • 32. Newly Designed Model HZ-85 used widely in the medical and aerospace industries for super-finishing and polishing critical parts
  • 33. Equipment Size and Configuration There are two major equipment families in the machinery line. (1) Six-inch diameter machines for processing small to moderately sized parts. (2) Twelve-inch diameter machines for processing large parts and larger batch volumes of parts
  • 34. Abrasive, Smoothing, Burnishing and Polishing Media
  • 35. Process Development and Sample Part Processing Operations Free sample part processing program analyzes and inspects parts, determines the correct media and machine model and sequence of operations to produce the required surface finish needed. To make arrangements for submitting parts into the free sample part processing program contact Dave Davidson at ddavidson@deburring-tech-group.com
  • 36. Contract Finishing Process Development Outsourcing the surface finishing of 3D printed parts is available. Process engineers will develop Centrifugal Iso-Finishing processes, submit parts for approval and provide a quotation for post-process finishing. To submit parts into the free sample part processing program contact Dave Davidson at ddavidson@deburring-tech-group.com
  • 37. Video: Example of Centrifugal Iso-Finishing Operations in a Precision Machining Contract Finishing Company • See the video on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dUdKjaysTYM&t=377s
  • 38. Part 4 -What about conventional or subtractive manufactured part finishing? • Centrifugal Iso-Finishing often performs deburring, finishing and polishing functions 10 times faster than conventional low energy methods. • Centrifugal force presses media against edges and surfaces with 10 G’s where conventional finishing systems are 1 G systems only • This centrifugal pressure produces beneficial compressive stress in some cases on the order of that produced by shot peening but with much more refined isotropic surfaces
  • 39. High performance automotive engine part finishing, extends engine service life, improves engine performance
  • 40. Automotive Cooperating Parts • Performance Benefits • Reduced friction • Increased part durability • Improved corrosion resistance • Reduced wear • Reduced lubrication requirements and cost • Improved oil retention • Reduced contact and bending fatigue • Improved pitting resistance • Reduced vibration and noise attenuation • Reduced applied torque requirements • Improved surface finish uniformity (part-to-part, feature-to-feature, and lot- to-lot) • High-quality, micro-finished surfaces • Reduced Friction Benefits • Increased fuel economy • Reduced contact fatigue • Increased power density • Lower operating temperature • Extended mean time between maintenance overhauls • Reduced maintenance costs • Eliminated break-in • Extended component life • Reduced metal debris • Reduced part failures • Minimized overheating
  • 41. Fit and Function Improvement Mechanical components and assemblies perform more reliably and smoothly with low micro-inch surface finishes produced by Centrifugal Iso-Finishing
  • 42. Polishing Aerospace Engine Parts after Machining and At Overhaul
  • 43. Medical and Dental Part Finishing and Polishing
  • 47. Hands-free polishing of aluminum castings prior to powder coating
  • 49. CENTRIFUGAL ISO-FINISH Advantages over and above Superior Edge and Surface Finish (Before) Ground Surface (After) Centrifugal Iso-Finishing (1) (2) (3) (1) Compressive stress generation for improved fatigue failure resistance (2) Isotropic Surfaces for wear and crack resistance (3) Planarized or plateaued surfaces for improved bearing load surfaces (After) Centrifugal Iso-Finishing(Before) Cast Surface High Magnification SEM (Scanning Electron Micro-scope X-Ray Diffraction SWLI (Scanning White Light Interferometer) 3D Texture Mapping
  • 50. Follow up. Next step. Sample Part Processing For assistance with (free) sample part processing, contract finishing quotations or equipment and process quotations CONTACT: Dave Davidson at ddavidson@deburring-tech-group.com