Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
SPARKING NEW IDEAS
Parking Strategies for Stronger Communities
Ted Brovitz
Manager of Community
Planning and Design
Howard/Stein-Hudson
Associates, Inc.
April 8, 2014
Minimums, Maximums and
Everything In Between
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Minimums, Maximums and Everything In Between
 Public Vision and Planning Objectives
 Parking Audits
 Parking Regulations – Best Practices
 Parking Placement Standards
 Context-Based and Context-Building
Examples
Existing Condition
Potential Redevelopment
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Public Vision and Planning Goals
Land Use Transects – Variation in
Patterns and Context
Rural-Residential/Suburban Village Neighborhood Downtown
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Public Visioning and Planning Goals
Downtown Context and Goals
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Existing Conditions
Scenario-Building
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Future Vision
Scenario-Building
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Future Vision
Scenario-Building
Side Street
Access
Parking Behind
Building
Shared Parking
On-Street Parking
Shared Driveway
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Audit
Prior to Revising Off-Street Parking
Regulations
 Goals and Objectives by
District
• Maximize utilization and efficiency with the least
number of spaces necessary
 Inventory and Analysis
 Future Development
 Public-Private
 Shared Parking
 Wayfinding and Parking
 Pedestrian, Bicycle and
 Short-Term, Long-Term
 Enforcement and
 Off-Street Parking
• Coordinate with Parking Audit Results
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Audit
Prior to Revising Off-Street Parking
Regulations
 Goals and Objectives by
District
• Maximize utilization and efficiency with the least
number of spaces necessary
 Inventory and Analysis
by District
 Future Development
Potential (Use /S.F.)
 Public-Private
Partnerships
Opportunities
 Shared Parking
Opportunities
 Pedestrian, Bicycle and
Transit Access
 Wayfinding and Parking
Signage System
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Audit
Prior to Revising Off-Street Parking
Regulations
 Goals and Objectives by
District
• Maximize utilization and efficiency with the least
number of spaces necessary
 Inventory and Analysis
by District
 Future Development
Potential (Use and S.F.)
 Public-Private
Partnerships
Opportunities
 Shared Parking
Opportunities
 Pedestrian, Bicycle and
Transit Access
 Wayfinding and Parking
Signage System
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Audit
Prior to Revising Off-Street Parking
Regulations
 Goals and Objectives by
District
• Maximize utilization and efficiency with the least
number of spaces necessary
 Inventory and Analysis
by District
 Future Development
Potential (Use and S.F.)
 Public-Private
Partnerships
Opportunities
 Shared Parking
Opportunities
 Pedestrian, Bicycle and
Transit Access
 Wayfinding and Parking
Signage System
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Audit
Existing Buildings, Lot and Parking
Requirements
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Audit
Existing Buildings, Lot and
Parking Requirements
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Development Scenarios Under Current Standards
Parking Audit
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
 Purpose and Intent
• Maximize use with least
number of
spaces necessary
 Definitions and
Applicability
• Buildings and use
• Districts (downtowns to
neighborhoods)
• Institutions (i.e. colleges,
hospitals, civic, etc.)
 Required Off-Street
Parking Spaces
• Parking Table by individual
and mixed uses
 Parking Limitations and
Exemptions
• Minimum/maximum: surface
and structured
Parking – Best Practices
Standard Parking Provisions
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
 On-Street Public Parking
Credits
 Off-Street Public Parking
Lot Credits
 Public Parking Fund
• Payment In Lieu of On-site
Parking
 Joint Parking Agreements
On Adjoining Lots
 Remote or Satellite
Parking Agreements
 Valet Parking Program and
Tandem Parking
 Proximity/Availability of
Bus and Rail Service
 Proximity to Car Sharing
Program
Parking – Best Practices
On-Site Parking Reduction
Toolbox
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
3. Experience in Other
Towns/Case Studies
Example - West Concord Village Center
Private
Shared
Parking
Agreement
On-Site
Parking Off-
Set with
Public On and
Off Street
Parking
Town-MBTA
Shared
Parking and
Resident
Permit
Agreement
Parking Reduction Methods
Shared Parking – Public and Private
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
3. Experience in Other
Towns/Case Studies
Example – Hyannis Village, Barnstable MA
Public/Privat
e Owned
Shared
Parking Lot
Parking Reduction Methods
Shared Parking – Public and Private
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
3. Experience in Other
Towns/Case Studies
Example – Wellesley Center
Proximity
to Public
Parking
Lot
Parking Reduction Methods
Shared Parking – Public and Private
Shared
Parking
Agreement
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Structured Parking
Parking Reduction Methods
Public Parking Facilities in Lieu of On-Site Parking Private
Northampton, MA Brattleboro,
VT
W. Hartford, CT
Freeport, ME
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Reduction Methods
Tandem, Stacked and Valet Parking
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
 Access Management and Curb-Cut Reduction
 Internal Circulation and External Connectivity
 Placement of Parking
• Relationship to buildings and street
 Intermodal Design
• Bus facilities, internal pedestrian connections, bicycle
parking
 Landscaping and Streetscaping
• Shade, control circulation, provide access,
screening where needed
 Sustainability - ADA spaces, Compact Autos,
Alternative Fuel Vehicles, LID, Energy
 Loading, Storage and Screening
 Parking Lot Utilization – Gatherings, PARKlets,
mobile venders
Parking – Best Practices
Parking Design and Functional
Standards
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Landscaping and Streetscape Design Standards
Parking – Best Practices
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Landscaping
Parking Standards – Best Practices
Internal and External Pedestrian Access Standards
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Standards – Best Practices
Bicycle Parking and Design Standards
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Stormwater Planters
Emporia, VA
Parking Standards – Best Practices
Low Impact Design and Energy Efficiency
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Standards – Best Practices
Other Design Standards
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Utilization - Civic Gather Space &
Event Programming
Parking – Best Practices
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
 Open streets and play streets
 PARK(ing) day
 Food carts and trucks
 Pavement to plazas
 Street fairs
 Etc.
PARKing Day
Pop Up CafeMobile Vendors
Parking Utilization - Tactical
Urbanism
Parking – Best Practices
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
8. New Off-Street Parking
Zoning Bylaw
On-Site Parking
Placement,
Access,
Landscaping, and
On-Street
Parking Off-Set,
and Relationship
to Sidewalk and
Parking Placement Standards
Context-Building Standards
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Shared Access and Internal Connectivity
Parking Placement Standards
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Placement Standards
Site Layout
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Parking Placement Standards
Site Layout
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Existing
Condition
Potential Expansion and Infill
Parking Placement Standards
Strip Development Repair and Infill
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Context-Based and Context-Building
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Mediu
m
Setba
ck
All
Parki
ng to
Side
and
Rear
All
Parki
ng in
Front
Separ
ate
Curb
Cuts
Mixed
Use/
Shared
Parking
Singl
e Use
Rear
Acces
s
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
2004 Concept Plan and TND Bylaw
Propose
d
Parking
Infill
Area
Context-Based and Context-Building
Highway Commercial Context –
Linden Street, Wellesley
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Medium sized mixed use infill development with no front setback, streetscape
treatments along the frontage, shared access and parking , internal connection to
public sidewalk, outdoor dining terrace and open space, and all parking placed
behind frontage buildings.
Context-Based and Context-Building
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Wellesley/Linden Street TND – Sprawl Retrofit
and Infill Development
Infill Development Oriented to
Street and Pedestrians
New On-Street Public Parking Added
Context-Based and Context-Building
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Downtown and Village Center
Form-Based Code
Context-Based and Context-Building
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Amherst Village Centers
Context-Based and Context-Building
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
Traffic Taming and Complete Street Design Needed!
Context-Based and Context-Building
Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14
SPARKING NEW IDEAS
Parking Strategies for Stronger Communities
Ted Brovitz
Manager of Community
Planning and Design
Howard/Stein-Hudson
Associates, Inc.
April 8, 2014
Minimums, Maximums and
Everything In Between

MAPC sPARKing New Ideas Parking Symposium: Presentation by Ted Brovitz

  • 1.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 SPARKING NEW IDEAS Parking Strategies for Stronger Communities Ted Brovitz Manager of Community Planning and Design Howard/Stein-Hudson Associates, Inc. April 8, 2014 Minimums, Maximums and Everything In Between
  • 2.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Minimums, Maximums and Everything In Between  Public Vision and Planning Objectives  Parking Audits  Parking Regulations – Best Practices  Parking Placement Standards  Context-Based and Context-Building Examples Existing Condition Potential Redevelopment
  • 3.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Public Vision and Planning Goals Land Use Transects – Variation in Patterns and Context Rural-Residential/Suburban Village Neighborhood Downtown
  • 4.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Public Visioning and Planning Goals Downtown Context and Goals
  • 5.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Existing Conditions Scenario-Building
  • 6.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Future Vision Scenario-Building
  • 7.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Future Vision Scenario-Building Side Street Access Parking Behind Building Shared Parking On-Street Parking Shared Driveway
  • 8.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Parking Audit Prior to Revising Off-Street Parking Regulations  Goals and Objectives by District • Maximize utilization and efficiency with the least number of spaces necessary  Inventory and Analysis  Future Development  Public-Private  Shared Parking  Wayfinding and Parking  Pedestrian, Bicycle and  Short-Term, Long-Term  Enforcement and  Off-Street Parking • Coordinate with Parking Audit Results
  • 9.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Parking Audit Prior to Revising Off-Street Parking Regulations  Goals and Objectives by District • Maximize utilization and efficiency with the least number of spaces necessary  Inventory and Analysis by District  Future Development Potential (Use /S.F.)  Public-Private Partnerships Opportunities  Shared Parking Opportunities  Pedestrian, Bicycle and Transit Access  Wayfinding and Parking Signage System
  • 10.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Parking Audit Prior to Revising Off-Street Parking Regulations  Goals and Objectives by District • Maximize utilization and efficiency with the least number of spaces necessary  Inventory and Analysis by District  Future Development Potential (Use and S.F.)  Public-Private Partnerships Opportunities  Shared Parking Opportunities  Pedestrian, Bicycle and Transit Access  Wayfinding and Parking Signage System
  • 11.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Parking Audit Prior to Revising Off-Street Parking Regulations  Goals and Objectives by District • Maximize utilization and efficiency with the least number of spaces necessary  Inventory and Analysis by District  Future Development Potential (Use and S.F.)  Public-Private Partnerships Opportunities  Shared Parking Opportunities  Pedestrian, Bicycle and Transit Access  Wayfinding and Parking Signage System
  • 12.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Parking Audit Existing Buildings, Lot and Parking Requirements
  • 13.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Parking Audit Existing Buildings, Lot and Parking Requirements
  • 14.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Development Scenarios Under Current Standards Parking Audit
  • 15.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14  Purpose and Intent • Maximize use with least number of spaces necessary  Definitions and Applicability • Buildings and use • Districts (downtowns to neighborhoods) • Institutions (i.e. colleges, hospitals, civic, etc.)  Required Off-Street Parking Spaces • Parking Table by individual and mixed uses  Parking Limitations and Exemptions • Minimum/maximum: surface and structured Parking – Best Practices Standard Parking Provisions
  • 16.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14  On-Street Public Parking Credits  Off-Street Public Parking Lot Credits  Public Parking Fund • Payment In Lieu of On-site Parking  Joint Parking Agreements On Adjoining Lots  Remote or Satellite Parking Agreements  Valet Parking Program and Tandem Parking  Proximity/Availability of Bus and Rail Service  Proximity to Car Sharing Program Parking – Best Practices On-Site Parking Reduction Toolbox
  • 17.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 3. Experience in Other Towns/Case Studies Example - West Concord Village Center Private Shared Parking Agreement On-Site Parking Off- Set with Public On and Off Street Parking Town-MBTA Shared Parking and Resident Permit Agreement Parking Reduction Methods Shared Parking – Public and Private
  • 18.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 3. Experience in Other Towns/Case Studies Example – Hyannis Village, Barnstable MA Public/Privat e Owned Shared Parking Lot Parking Reduction Methods Shared Parking – Public and Private
  • 19.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 3. Experience in Other Towns/Case Studies Example – Wellesley Center Proximity to Public Parking Lot Parking Reduction Methods Shared Parking – Public and Private Shared Parking Agreement
  • 20.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Structured Parking Parking Reduction Methods Public Parking Facilities in Lieu of On-Site Parking Private Northampton, MA Brattleboro, VT W. Hartford, CT Freeport, ME
  • 21.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Parking Reduction Methods Tandem, Stacked and Valet Parking
  • 22.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14  Access Management and Curb-Cut Reduction  Internal Circulation and External Connectivity  Placement of Parking • Relationship to buildings and street  Intermodal Design • Bus facilities, internal pedestrian connections, bicycle parking  Landscaping and Streetscaping • Shade, control circulation, provide access, screening where needed  Sustainability - ADA spaces, Compact Autos, Alternative Fuel Vehicles, LID, Energy  Loading, Storage and Screening  Parking Lot Utilization – Gatherings, PARKlets, mobile venders Parking – Best Practices Parking Design and Functional Standards
  • 23.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Landscaping and Streetscape Design Standards Parking – Best Practices
  • 24.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Parking Landscaping Parking Standards – Best Practices Internal and External Pedestrian Access Standards
  • 25.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Parking Standards – Best Practices Bicycle Parking and Design Standards
  • 26.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Stormwater Planters Emporia, VA Parking Standards – Best Practices Low Impact Design and Energy Efficiency
  • 27.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Parking Standards – Best Practices Other Design Standards
  • 28.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Parking Utilization - Civic Gather Space & Event Programming Parking – Best Practices
  • 29.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14  Open streets and play streets  PARK(ing) day  Food carts and trucks  Pavement to plazas  Street fairs  Etc. PARKing Day Pop Up CafeMobile Vendors Parking Utilization - Tactical Urbanism Parking – Best Practices
  • 30.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 8. New Off-Street Parking Zoning Bylaw On-Site Parking Placement, Access, Landscaping, and On-Street Parking Off-Set, and Relationship to Sidewalk and Parking Placement Standards Context-Building Standards
  • 31.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Shared Access and Internal Connectivity Parking Placement Standards
  • 32.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Parking Placement Standards Site Layout
  • 33.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Parking Placement Standards Site Layout
  • 34.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Existing Condition Potential Expansion and Infill Parking Placement Standards Strip Development Repair and Infill
  • 35.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Context-Based and Context-Building
  • 36.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Mediu m Setba ck All Parki ng to Side and Rear All Parki ng in Front Separ ate Curb Cuts Mixed Use/ Shared Parking Singl e Use Rear Acces s
  • 37.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 2004 Concept Plan and TND Bylaw Propose d Parking Infill Area Context-Based and Context-Building Highway Commercial Context – Linden Street, Wellesley
  • 38.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Medium sized mixed use infill development with no front setback, streetscape treatments along the frontage, shared access and parking , internal connection to public sidewalk, outdoor dining terrace and open space, and all parking placed behind frontage buildings. Context-Based and Context-Building
  • 39.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 Wellesley/Linden Street TND – Sprawl Retrofit and Infill Development Infill Development Oriented to Street and Pedestrians New On-Street Public Parking Added Context-Based and Context-Building
  • 40.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Downtown and Village Center Form-Based Code Context-Based and Context-Building
  • 41.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Amherst Village Centers Context-Based and Context-Building
  • 42.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14 Traffic Taming and Complete Street Design Needed! Context-Based and Context-Building
  • 43.
    Sparking New IdeasWorkshop – 04.08.14Sparking New Ideas Workshop – 04.08.14 SPARKING NEW IDEAS Parking Strategies for Stronger Communities Ted Brovitz Manager of Community Planning and Design Howard/Stein-Hudson Associates, Inc. April 8, 2014 Minimums, Maximums and Everything In Between