A 19-year-old male presented with knee pain after falling during a basketball game. Radiographs revealed a bipartite patella, which is a congenital condition where the patella fails to fuse, seen in 2-3% of the population. It is typically asymptomatic but can cause anterior knee pain aggravated by activity. Non-operative management is indicated initially but surgical excision may be needed if non-operative treatment fails after 6 months or for displaced fragments. The main risk of surgery is patellofemoral maltracking.