Agile Enterprise Architecture @ Nordea
Mikkel H Brahm, PhD, Head of Customer Experience EA
Slides available at slideshare.net/mikkelbrahm
Architecture is an aspect of a building – all buildings have one
Enterprise is intentional process of doing and organizing business
MechanismsPeople
Action
Structure
A multi-perspectival approach is much more likely to succeed
Leavitt’s diamond (1965) – slightly modified
$
Agenda
Nordea’s Vision for the Future
Agile @ Nordea
Nordea Architecture Framework
Some Practical Experience
CHALLENGERS
NICHE PLAYERS
LEADERS
VISIONARIES
Completeness of Vision
AbilitytoExecute
Nordea is the leading Brick & Mortar bank
in the Nordic region
Is that good, given that what we want to be is
the leading Digital Relationship Bank?
Gartner, Magic Quadrant
6
Completeness
of Vision
Our customer vision is our North star
and our purpose and values our inner compass
Safe and trusted
Anywhere and
anytime
Relevant and
competent
Easy to deal with
Personal and digital
relationship
Customers are welcome to visit us in the branch, but not required to
9
Partner
Ecosystem
3rd-party-
branded Banking
Digital Banking
Anywhere & Anytime
Nordea Banking
@ Your place
Nordea
Open Banking
Physical
@ Nordea Banking
Classical Banking Business Model:
Financial Services
in exchange for
Money (margins & fees)
Ecosystem Business Model:
Financial Services and Access to Customers
in exchange for
Money (margins & fees), Information,
Augmenting Services, Branding/exposure, …
10
Ability
to Execute
Brick
&
Mortar
From mid-2014 to April 2018
Digital
From April 2018…
We chose a group-wide culture, business, and technology transformation
We attempt to erase the IT – Business divide, and operate Nordicly
People who understand IT
People who understand Banking
People who Change the Bank People who Run the Bank
13
Staff
Time
Projects is a temporary organisation to solve a temporary issue
Assigned to Line Assigned to Project(s)
Project Project
Time
When issues become permanent, it’s time to change the model
Assigned to Line Assigned to Products / Solutions
Portfolio of
Investments
in Change
Staff
Agile @ Nordea = based on SAFe, but also sized by investment level
15
Nordea has introduced the term Hub, which is a semi-stable development organization
• responsible for some Solution (products, services, systems)
• organized according to the variant of SAFe which matches the investment level
= burn rate ≈ number of teams.
16
17
Nordea
Architecture Framework
Gartner
Enable
Business
Outcomes
>
Fill in the
Framework
From
Enterprise Architects are the people
who put ‘no’ in innovation
Perception
To
Enterprise Architects are the people
who enable Technology Driven Business Development
Simplified organisational chart
Group
Functions
Personal Wholesale
BUSINESS CAPABILITIESCHANGETHEBANK
Group Func.
Portfolio
Banking Technology Trading TechnologyPersonal
Portfolio
Commercial
Portfolio
CEO & COO
Commercial &
Business
Wealth
Group
Architecture
Wealth
Portfolio
Wholesale
Portfolio
Change Execution Initiatives funded by Portfolios
Product (not Project) funding i.e. ≈ Stable Burn Rate
Architectural Governance is a mix of Investment Gates
and Solution Architects assigned into Hubs
Group Data
Portfolio
Group Tech
Portfolio
ARCHITECT AND
PORTFOLIO /
PRODUCT
MGMT. JOINT
PRIORITIZATION
Nordea Architecture Framework = Federated
Nordea Architecture Framework was created in 2017 to define a
common architecture practice for the Nordea group and is
encapsulated within the Group CEO Instructions on IT Governance
Group level processes and
bodies facilitate enterprise
level alignment and manage
escalations.
Capability level processes
develop architecture content
in Capability Architecture
Teams (CATs) from a group-
wide perspective.
Initiative level processes
develop targeted architecture
content to support a specific
business or initiative / solution
scope.Source: Nordea Architecture Framework
23
Practical experience
…so far
Simplified 2-layer Application Model
Flexible Front-Ends
Enable differentiated
services, and coherent
superior experiences
across channels
Digitized Factory
Enable simplified
automated (“no paper, no
people”) banking exposed
through domain services
The facade of a Digital Bank is the lesser effort
• UI & UX that customers can love
• Coherent RESTful banking Service API
• Alignment of national Customer and User models
• Alignment of national & segment Agreement solutions
• Authentication & Signing integrated to
national and industry standards e.g. NemID and OAuth
• New communication infrastructure for digital signing, chat,
online meetings, notifications, call recording, …
• New ways of working for customer service staff to cope
with spontaneous chat and online meetings (e-Branches)
• Aggregate data across own back-ends and 3rd-parties
• Integrate with market infrastructure solutions
Coping with sins and omissions of the past is the greater effort
Our Core Banking Replacement Program
is not only about consolidating IT
It is perhaps not even primarily about that
It is about ensuring an operating core
that can support changes to the business
that we cannot even forsee yet
27
Who is
the business?
Requirements work time-boxed to a PI per PI, and test included in Dev
29
The Digital Foundation enables faster delivery of new services
30
Mechanisms
 Culture Transformation Programme
 Combo: Training & Staff Changes
 ”Brick & Mortar” Corporate Culture
 Too few people with Digital skills
Summary
Is Nordea in a good position to become the Leading Digital Bank?
CONs PROs
People
Action
Structure
$
 Country differences complicate
business processes and IT solutions
 Face-2-Face servicing model
outdated
 Harmonize country units’ business
models, services & processes
 Fast Build-Test-Learn loops
 Cost/Income ratio unsustainable
 Autonomous Segments threaten
Simplification Journey
 Significant cost-savings
 Centralization/Strengthening of
Business & IT Development
 Vast legacy IT portfolio with
high degree of local variation
and Technical Debt
 Significant investment
in modernizing Operational Core
(Group Simplification)
Thank you!
Mikkel H Brahm, PhD, Head of Customer Experience EA
mikkel.brahm@nordea.com

Agile Enterprise Architecture at Nordea

  • 1.
    Agile Enterprise Architecture@ Nordea Mikkel H Brahm, PhD, Head of Customer Experience EA Slides available at slideshare.net/mikkelbrahm
  • 2.
    Architecture is anaspect of a building – all buildings have one Enterprise is intentional process of doing and organizing business
  • 3.
    MechanismsPeople Action Structure A multi-perspectival approachis much more likely to succeed Leavitt’s diamond (1965) – slightly modified $
  • 4.
    Agenda Nordea’s Vision forthe Future Agile @ Nordea Nordea Architecture Framework Some Practical Experience
  • 5.
    CHALLENGERS NICHE PLAYERS LEADERS VISIONARIES Completeness ofVision AbilitytoExecute Nordea is the leading Brick & Mortar bank in the Nordic region Is that good, given that what we want to be is the leading Digital Relationship Bank? Gartner, Magic Quadrant
  • 6.
  • 8.
    Our customer visionis our North star and our purpose and values our inner compass Safe and trusted Anywhere and anytime Relevant and competent Easy to deal with Personal and digital relationship
  • 9.
    Customers are welcometo visit us in the branch, but not required to 9 Partner Ecosystem 3rd-party- branded Banking Digital Banking Anywhere & Anytime Nordea Banking @ Your place Nordea Open Banking Physical @ Nordea Banking Classical Banking Business Model: Financial Services in exchange for Money (margins & fees) Ecosystem Business Model: Financial Services and Access to Customers in exchange for Money (margins & fees), Information, Augmenting Services, Branding/exposure, …
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Brick & Mortar From mid-2014 toApril 2018 Digital From April 2018… We chose a group-wide culture, business, and technology transformation
  • 12.
    We attempt toerase the IT – Business divide, and operate Nordicly People who understand IT People who understand Banking People who Change the Bank People who Run the Bank
  • 13.
    13 Staff Time Projects is atemporary organisation to solve a temporary issue Assigned to Line Assigned to Project(s) Project Project
  • 14.
    Time When issues becomepermanent, it’s time to change the model Assigned to Line Assigned to Products / Solutions Portfolio of Investments in Change Staff
  • 15.
    Agile @ Nordea= based on SAFe, but also sized by investment level 15 Nordea has introduced the term Hub, which is a semi-stable development organization • responsible for some Solution (products, services, systems) • organized according to the variant of SAFe which matches the investment level = burn rate ≈ number of teams.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
    From Enterprise Architects arethe people who put ‘no’ in innovation Perception To Enterprise Architects are the people who enable Technology Driven Business Development
  • 20.
    Simplified organisational chart Group Functions PersonalWholesale BUSINESS CAPABILITIESCHANGETHEBANK Group Func. Portfolio Banking Technology Trading TechnologyPersonal Portfolio Commercial Portfolio CEO & COO Commercial & Business Wealth Group Architecture Wealth Portfolio Wholesale Portfolio Change Execution Initiatives funded by Portfolios Product (not Project) funding i.e. ≈ Stable Burn Rate Architectural Governance is a mix of Investment Gates and Solution Architects assigned into Hubs Group Data Portfolio Group Tech Portfolio
  • 21.
  • 22.
    Nordea Architecture Framework= Federated Nordea Architecture Framework was created in 2017 to define a common architecture practice for the Nordea group and is encapsulated within the Group CEO Instructions on IT Governance Group level processes and bodies facilitate enterprise level alignment and manage escalations. Capability level processes develop architecture content in Capability Architecture Teams (CATs) from a group- wide perspective. Initiative level processes develop targeted architecture content to support a specific business or initiative / solution scope.Source: Nordea Architecture Framework
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Simplified 2-layer ApplicationModel Flexible Front-Ends Enable differentiated services, and coherent superior experiences across channels Digitized Factory Enable simplified automated (“no paper, no people”) banking exposed through domain services
  • 25.
    The facade ofa Digital Bank is the lesser effort • UI & UX that customers can love • Coherent RESTful banking Service API • Alignment of national Customer and User models • Alignment of national & segment Agreement solutions • Authentication & Signing integrated to national and industry standards e.g. NemID and OAuth • New communication infrastructure for digital signing, chat, online meetings, notifications, call recording, … • New ways of working for customer service staff to cope with spontaneous chat and online meetings (e-Branches) • Aggregate data across own back-ends and 3rd-parties • Integrate with market infrastructure solutions
  • 26.
    Coping with sinsand omissions of the past is the greater effort Our Core Banking Replacement Program is not only about consolidating IT It is perhaps not even primarily about that It is about ensuring an operating core that can support changes to the business that we cannot even forsee yet
  • 27.
  • 28.
    Requirements work time-boxedto a PI per PI, and test included in Dev
  • 29.
  • 30.
    The Digital Foundationenables faster delivery of new services 30
  • 31.
    Mechanisms  Culture TransformationProgramme  Combo: Training & Staff Changes  ”Brick & Mortar” Corporate Culture  Too few people with Digital skills Summary Is Nordea in a good position to become the Leading Digital Bank? CONs PROs People Action Structure $  Country differences complicate business processes and IT solutions  Face-2-Face servicing model outdated  Harmonize country units’ business models, services & processes  Fast Build-Test-Learn loops  Cost/Income ratio unsustainable  Autonomous Segments threaten Simplification Journey  Significant cost-savings  Centralization/Strengthening of Business & IT Development  Vast legacy IT portfolio with high degree of local variation and Technical Debt  Significant investment in modernizing Operational Core (Group Simplification)
  • 32.
    Thank you! Mikkel HBrahm, PhD, Head of Customer Experience EA mikkel.brahm@nordea.com