Advanced Project Data Analytics for
Improved Project Delivery
Webinar
4 July 2019
Martin Paver
CEO / Founder
www.projectingsuccess.co.uk
martinpaver@projectingsuccess.co.uk
+44 777 570 4044
SUPPORTED BY
Before we get started….
This session is being recorded.
The recording and slides will
be shared after the webinar.
All participants are muted.
Please type any questions into
the “Questions” window.
Your feedback will help us to
improve future webinars.
Please send any comments
and suggestions to:
martinpaver@projectingsuccess.co.uk
Experience
Chartered Engineer
Fellow
Chartered Project Professional
Professional Accreditation
Sectors
Project Manager $1bn
Programme Director $0.6bn
Portfolio lead $10bn
Roles
Icon credit: Icons8
Crossrail
Exhaust plume
from project
delivery
An Example: Crossrail
What Happens to the Data?
NASA Lessons Learned System
2012
• Not routinely used.
• Ill defined strategies
• Inconsistent funding
• Lack of monitoring
2001
• Limited sharing of lessons
• Dissatisfaction with processes
• Barriers
• Culture
• Lack of time
Existing Lessons Learned Analysis
http://www.treasury.govt.nz
Our Own Research: Research Paper
https://bit.ly/2T7yKnL
The Technology
Narrow (ANI) General (AGI) Super (ASI)
Performs one task Performs many tasks.
Equivalent to a human
Surpass most abilities
of a human
Chess Machines that
perform reasoning
Hal (2001)
Widely adopted Predicted 20-100 years
away
Imminently after AGI
Overview: What is AI?
The parent term
encompassing any technique
that allows a machine to act
like a human
AI, ML and Deep Learning
Artificial
Intelligence
(AI)
An AI technique that
focusses on learning from
experience
Machine
Learning
(ML)
A subset of ML that uses
neural networks based on
the brain
Deep
Learning
Why the Hype?
Data Cloud Algorithms
Icon made by Freepik from www.flaticon.com
In 2016, 90% of the world's data (that's 90% of all the data ever created)
had been created in the previous two years (IBM).
Algorithms
Credit: Google
Some Foundations: Graph Databases
Projects LessonsRisks$
Graph
Data Stored in Silos
Lesson X
Draw
down
Cost
impact
Time
impact
Mitigate
Cost
Mitigate
effective
-ness
Project 1
Project 2
Taxon-
omy
TechnicalSafetySecurity
Technical
issue
Security
Issue
Safety
Issue
Some Foundations: Tool/Platform/Data
Tool Driven
Implementation strategy driven by tool selection.
Primavera/ASTA, Risk Tool, BIM etc.
Considerable tool integration challenge.
Platform Driven
A platform that integrates multiple tools. A one stop
shop that integrates database and tools for a project
management or BIM centred use case. Vendor lock in.
Data Driven
Connected data is at the core of the solution.
Tools and platforms are used to capture, ingest,
process, visualise and provide insights.
Tool
Driven
Data
Driven
Platform
Driven
Plus integration with other corporate tools and data
Some Foundations:
Python, Flow, PowerApps and Power BI
Available as part of your current services. Leverage
your current investments.
Opportunity to tailor to your business, use cases
and integration of different systems
Some Foundations: Extracting Value from Data
Fundamentally:
• What is the predisposition of the work to variance?
• Can we predict it?
• How do we test for it?
• How do we treat it and change the future?
Evidence based, tempering against bias.
Project DNA
A Possible Future…
Tracking Contract
Deliverables
Project Administration
Tracking receipt
Compliance and quality assessment
Deliverable graphs
Briefs, Reports
and Dashboards
Meeting Admin,
Minutes, Actions
Gotomeeting – Transcript
Extract actions into Flow
Use Flow to progress actions
Resource
Utilisation
Quality Audits,
Maturity Reviews
Forecasting,
Budgeting
Improved benchmarking
Variance analysis
Early warnings
Automatic review of timesheets
Workflows chasing timesheets
KPIs on resource performance
Data quality/completeness analysis
Frequency of updates
Comparison against good practice
Auto-reporting
Auto-dashboards
Predictive analysis
EVM data
Resourcing
Weather
Supplier performance
Dependencies
Risks etc
Real time
update of
assigned tasks
WBS Elements
Scheduling Corpus and
Context Extract Triples
Benchmarking
Adaptive SchedulingRecommendations
Scheduling
A once through process
Risk lifecycle
Leveraging Risk Experience
Connected risks Risks-Issues-Lessons
Informed risk
registers
Risk
trends
Risk mitigations
Risk
budget
Systemic Risk
Risks
Benefits
Stakeholder Management
Credit: Praxis Framework
Or
Adaptive, dynamic networks, reflecting
real time feedback and historical
performance of specific groups/individuals
Credit: Neo4J
Static Analysis
P3M Maturity assessments
Audit based vs real time
• Process adherence
• Frequency of update
• Materiality of update
• Quality of inputs
• Correlation with level of experience
Caution: We do not want to create process monkeys
I want people who are
right most of the time
• Risk identification
• Risk to issues
• Schedule adherence
• Cost adherence
• Etc….
Forensic analysis on individual and team
performance
Buying and Deploying Black Box AI
• What is contained within the dataset?
• How relevant is the data?
• How is bias managed and accounted for?
• How was the AI trained?
• How is it validated?
• Governance of decision making: “Computer said no”
AI will need to guide and inform, but we need humans in
the loop.
Are these humans project controllers or data scientists?
We must become conversant with these capabilities
Definitions
"Project Controls are the data gathering, data management
and analytical processes used to predict, understand and
constructively influence the time and cost outcomes of a
project or programme; through the communication of
information in formats that assist effective management
and decision making.“ Project Controls Online
"Project Controls are the data gathering, data management
and analytical processes used to predict, understand and
constructively influence the time and cost outcomes of a
project or programme; through the communication of
information in formats that assist effective management
and decision making.“ Project Controls Online
Project Controls or Data Analyst/Scientist?
Data Trust: Definition
Positioning for a New Future
Overall approachData Strategy
Connected Data
Data harvesting
Insights and Lean Predictive Insights
How to Prepare
Positioning For a Data Driven Future
Reporting Dashboards Data cleansing
Data Graphs
Text analytics
Insights
Benchmarking
Predictive analytics
Machine Learning
Collate
Data
Auto-Collate
Data
Connect,
Qualify and
Integrate Data
Extract
Predictive
Insights
The Learning Curve…..
What are your aspirations?
Analyst
Or
‘Operative’
Getting Started
• Start with the use case and user story
• Incremental delivery
• Maintain velocity – don’t get bogged down with data challenges
• Build momentum
• Reskill or gain an awareness: Gas fitter
• Pair up project professionals with data professionals
• ‘Turn right’
Data Roles
Data
Scientist
Data
Engineer
Data
Analyst
• Familiarisation with roles
• Gain an overview of each
• Gap analysis
• What skills does your organisation have?
• What does your organisation aspire to?
• What does the roadmap look like?
• What would you like to do?
Make good use of:
Demonstrate a Passion
You are in a competitive environment
MOOCsStart
Communities
Competitions
Events
Code/Blog
Increasinglevelofcommitment
Barriers to Adoption
Its not on the corporate ‘to do’ list
• Lack of a shared vision
• Lack of evidence to support the vision
• Lack of skilled horsepower
• Lack of data
• Siloed
• Poor quality
• Understanding the investment case
Submit questions via your GoToWebinar control panel.
(sorry, function not available on mobile devices)
Contact
Please find me on Linkedin:
Martin Paver
Martin Paver
CEO / Founder
www.projectingsuccess.co.uk
martinpaver@projectingsuccess.co.uk
+44 777 570 4044
Project Data Analytics
Also follow the Project Data Analytics group
And a big thanks to Mark Constable at
For helping to make it happen

Advanced Project Data Analytics for Improved Project Delivery

  • 1.
    Advanced Project DataAnalytics for Improved Project Delivery Webinar 4 July 2019 Martin Paver CEO / Founder www.projectingsuccess.co.uk martinpaver@projectingsuccess.co.uk +44 777 570 4044 SUPPORTED BY
  • 2.
    Before we getstarted…. This session is being recorded. The recording and slides will be shared after the webinar. All participants are muted. Please type any questions into the “Questions” window. Your feedback will help us to improve future webinars. Please send any comments and suggestions to: martinpaver@projectingsuccess.co.uk
  • 3.
    Experience Chartered Engineer Fellow Chartered ProjectProfessional Professional Accreditation Sectors Project Manager $1bn Programme Director $0.6bn Portfolio lead $10bn Roles Icon credit: Icons8
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
    What Happens tothe Data?
  • 7.
    NASA Lessons LearnedSystem 2012 • Not routinely used. • Ill defined strategies • Inconsistent funding • Lack of monitoring 2001 • Limited sharing of lessons • Dissatisfaction with processes • Barriers • Culture • Lack of time
  • 8.
    Existing Lessons LearnedAnalysis http://www.treasury.govt.nz
  • 9.
    Our Own Research:Research Paper https://bit.ly/2T7yKnL
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Narrow (ANI) General(AGI) Super (ASI) Performs one task Performs many tasks. Equivalent to a human Surpass most abilities of a human Chess Machines that perform reasoning Hal (2001) Widely adopted Predicted 20-100 years away Imminently after AGI Overview: What is AI?
  • 12.
    The parent term encompassingany technique that allows a machine to act like a human AI, ML and Deep Learning Artificial Intelligence (AI) An AI technique that focusses on learning from experience Machine Learning (ML) A subset of ML that uses neural networks based on the brain Deep Learning
  • 13.
    Why the Hype? DataCloud Algorithms Icon made by Freepik from www.flaticon.com In 2016, 90% of the world's data (that's 90% of all the data ever created) had been created in the previous two years (IBM).
  • 14.
  • 15.
    Some Foundations: GraphDatabases Projects LessonsRisks$ Graph Data Stored in Silos Lesson X Draw down Cost impact Time impact Mitigate Cost Mitigate effective -ness Project 1 Project 2 Taxon- omy TechnicalSafetySecurity Technical issue Security Issue Safety Issue
  • 16.
    Some Foundations: Tool/Platform/Data ToolDriven Implementation strategy driven by tool selection. Primavera/ASTA, Risk Tool, BIM etc. Considerable tool integration challenge. Platform Driven A platform that integrates multiple tools. A one stop shop that integrates database and tools for a project management or BIM centred use case. Vendor lock in. Data Driven Connected data is at the core of the solution. Tools and platforms are used to capture, ingest, process, visualise and provide insights. Tool Driven Data Driven Platform Driven Plus integration with other corporate tools and data
  • 17.
    Some Foundations: Python, Flow,PowerApps and Power BI Available as part of your current services. Leverage your current investments. Opportunity to tailor to your business, use cases and integration of different systems
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Fundamentally: • What isthe predisposition of the work to variance? • Can we predict it? • How do we test for it? • How do we treat it and change the future? Evidence based, tempering against bias. Project DNA
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Tracking Contract Deliverables Project Administration Trackingreceipt Compliance and quality assessment Deliverable graphs Briefs, Reports and Dashboards Meeting Admin, Minutes, Actions Gotomeeting – Transcript Extract actions into Flow Use Flow to progress actions Resource Utilisation Quality Audits, Maturity Reviews Forecasting, Budgeting Improved benchmarking Variance analysis Early warnings Automatic review of timesheets Workflows chasing timesheets KPIs on resource performance Data quality/completeness analysis Frequency of updates Comparison against good practice Auto-reporting Auto-dashboards Predictive analysis
  • 22.
    EVM data Resourcing Weather Supplier performance Dependencies Risksetc Real time update of assigned tasks WBS Elements Scheduling Corpus and Context Extract Triples Benchmarking Adaptive SchedulingRecommendations Scheduling
  • 23.
    A once throughprocess Risk lifecycle Leveraging Risk Experience Connected risks Risks-Issues-Lessons Informed risk registers Risk trends Risk mitigations Risk budget Systemic Risk Risks
  • 24.
  • 25.
    Stakeholder Management Credit: PraxisFramework Or Adaptive, dynamic networks, reflecting real time feedback and historical performance of specific groups/individuals Credit: Neo4J Static Analysis
  • 26.
    P3M Maturity assessments Auditbased vs real time • Process adherence • Frequency of update • Materiality of update • Quality of inputs • Correlation with level of experience Caution: We do not want to create process monkeys I want people who are right most of the time • Risk identification • Risk to issues • Schedule adherence • Cost adherence • Etc…. Forensic analysis on individual and team performance
  • 27.
    Buying and DeployingBlack Box AI • What is contained within the dataset? • How relevant is the data? • How is bias managed and accounted for? • How was the AI trained? • How is it validated? • Governance of decision making: “Computer said no” AI will need to guide and inform, but we need humans in the loop. Are these humans project controllers or data scientists? We must become conversant with these capabilities
  • 28.
    Definitions "Project Controls arethe data gathering, data management and analytical processes used to predict, understand and constructively influence the time and cost outcomes of a project or programme; through the communication of information in formats that assist effective management and decision making.“ Project Controls Online "Project Controls are the data gathering, data management and analytical processes used to predict, understand and constructively influence the time and cost outcomes of a project or programme; through the communication of information in formats that assist effective management and decision making.“ Project Controls Online Project Controls or Data Analyst/Scientist?
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Positioning for aNew Future Overall approachData Strategy Connected Data Data harvesting Insights and Lean Predictive Insights
  • 31.
  • 32.
    Positioning For aData Driven Future Reporting Dashboards Data cleansing Data Graphs Text analytics Insights Benchmarking Predictive analytics Machine Learning Collate Data Auto-Collate Data Connect, Qualify and Integrate Data Extract Predictive Insights
  • 33.
    The Learning Curve….. Whatare your aspirations? Analyst Or ‘Operative’
  • 34.
    Getting Started • Startwith the use case and user story • Incremental delivery • Maintain velocity – don’t get bogged down with data challenges • Build momentum • Reskill or gain an awareness: Gas fitter • Pair up project professionals with data professionals • ‘Turn right’
  • 35.
    Data Roles Data Scientist Data Engineer Data Analyst • Familiarisationwith roles • Gain an overview of each • Gap analysis • What skills does your organisation have? • What does your organisation aspire to? • What does the roadmap look like? • What would you like to do? Make good use of:
  • 36.
    Demonstrate a Passion Youare in a competitive environment MOOCsStart Communities Competitions Events Code/Blog Increasinglevelofcommitment
  • 37.
    Barriers to Adoption Itsnot on the corporate ‘to do’ list • Lack of a shared vision • Lack of evidence to support the vision • Lack of skilled horsepower • Lack of data • Siloed • Poor quality • Understanding the investment case
  • 38.
    Submit questions viayour GoToWebinar control panel. (sorry, function not available on mobile devices)
  • 39.
    Contact Please find meon Linkedin: Martin Paver Martin Paver CEO / Founder www.projectingsuccess.co.uk martinpaver@projectingsuccess.co.uk +44 777 570 4044 Project Data Analytics Also follow the Project Data Analytics group
  • 40.
    And a bigthanks to Mark Constable at For helping to make it happen