ALTRUISM LOST
        BY TATIANA DURÁN
SONGS OF SELFISHNESS

See the world through other’s
          eyes…
                Why when we do
               anything for or with
              others lead us to the
             motive of self-interest?


What’s good for me?       Psychological egoism
“every particular affection, benevolence
among the rest, is subservient to self-
love” BISHOP BUTTLER



“The people we regard as moral are
simply selfish in a different way… JOHN
STUART MILL
BARRY SCHWARTZ
            biology, economics and
  “evolutionary
  behavior theory share a common vision
  of what it means to be a person… human
  beings are out of pursue self-interest, to
  satisfy wants, to maximize utility, or
  preference, or profit, or reinforcement, or
  reproductive fitness. They are greedy,
  insatiable on the pursuit of want satisfaction”
BIOLOGY


Edward O. Wilson


   Altruism = central
   theoretical problem of
   sociobiology

    Richard Dewkins: “Genes”,
    not on individuals nor
    groups. (1)
Robert Trivers



    One individual saves another
    because it increases the probability
    that the favor will be returned. (2)



        Two kinds of human altruism
ECONOMICS AND OTHER SOCIAL
        SCIENCES


          • Economics is not an
            assumption


          • The first principle of Economics
            is that every agent is actuated
            only by self-interest. FRANCIS
            EDGEWORTH
AMERICAN ECONOMIC REVIEW
 There are only three reasons people give
 money to charity: direct benefits to the
 donor, indirect benefits to the donor, or a
 “kantian motive” in which “a donor benefits
 neither directly nor indirectly from the
 consumption of the charitable good, but
 merely from the act of giving…

A person is reliable if and only if it is more
 advantageous to him than being unreliable.
• “Altruism” = exchange

• Friendship, social approval, social
  rewards.


• Give in order to get


• Reciprocity= a way of mobilizing egoistic
  motivations and channeling them into the
  maintenance of the social system.
PSYCHOLOGY
• Sociobiologists: psychology needs what
  they have to offer (more realistic
  understanding of human being)


• Michael and Lisa Wallach: Satisfaction of
  our own needs is what motivate the
  individual.


• Freud: child altruistic impulses.
Clinicians…




                                                    JEAN BAKER MILLER
        An apparent




                      FREUD /DAUGHTER
FREUD
                                        Altruism
        desire to                       people                          may think
        help                            should                          they see
        contributes                                                     through to
        a reaction                      surrender                       the fact that
        formation                       to real                         the woman
        against                         impulses.                       is serving
        one’s real                                                      herself
        desire, TO                                                      through
        HURT.                                                           serving
                                                                        others.
RIGHT OR           Is this going to
 WRONG              work for me?



 Psychology has distinctions only
 between good and bad forms of
  selfishness. ALLAN BLOOM.
The amount of romantic love a person
 feels for someone is supposed to be direct
function of the benefits he/she derives from
               the relationship.




                                               Learning
                        Behaviorism
                                                theory




                         EGOISM                   EGOISM
1.Seeking reward.
 2.Avoiding punishment.
3.We find someone’s else
     pain distressing.
BEHIND THE APPEAL OF EGOISM
 Altruism   is only a chimera.

 Morality   is married to the idea of doing for
 oneself.

 Ethical   egoism

 Kant= self-love and morality pull in opposite
 directions.
Guilt
                       Who are
You’ve got
                        you to
 to start     Stop
                        judge
 putting     feeling
                       another
 yourself     guilty
                       person’s
   first
                         life?
UTOPIA: ALTRUISTIC PERFECTION OR A
RACE OF SAINTS

• It does each   • To linger on     • This
  of us an         saintliness        approach
                   communicate        has the
  injustice by     s the
  seeming to                          effect of
                   reassuring         turning
  put part of      message that
  human            a few larger-      altruism into
  nature           than-life          an all-or –
  beyond our       characters         nothing
  reach            have become        proposition.
                   specialists in
                   helping
                   others.

1                 2                 3
CONCLUSIONS
Reducing   non-economic issues
 has relation with reduce economic
 issues.

Bonus/grades.


Ethics   pays.
50658195 altruism-lost

50658195 altruism-lost

  • 1.
    ALTRUISM LOST BY TATIANA DURÁN
  • 3.
    SONGS OF SELFISHNESS Seethe world through other’s eyes… Why when we do anything for or with others lead us to the motive of self-interest? What’s good for me? Psychological egoism
  • 4.
    “every particular affection,benevolence among the rest, is subservient to self- love” BISHOP BUTTLER “The people we regard as moral are simply selfish in a different way… JOHN STUART MILL
  • 6.
    BARRY SCHWARTZ biology, economics and  “evolutionary behavior theory share a common vision of what it means to be a person… human beings are out of pursue self-interest, to satisfy wants, to maximize utility, or preference, or profit, or reinforcement, or reproductive fitness. They are greedy, insatiable on the pursuit of want satisfaction”
  • 7.
    BIOLOGY Edward O. Wilson Altruism = central theoretical problem of sociobiology Richard Dewkins: “Genes”, not on individuals nor groups. (1)
  • 8.
    Robert Trivers One individual saves another because it increases the probability that the favor will be returned. (2) Two kinds of human altruism
  • 9.
    ECONOMICS AND OTHERSOCIAL SCIENCES • Economics is not an assumption • The first principle of Economics is that every agent is actuated only by self-interest. FRANCIS EDGEWORTH
  • 10.
    AMERICAN ECONOMIC REVIEW There are only three reasons people give money to charity: direct benefits to the donor, indirect benefits to the donor, or a “kantian motive” in which “a donor benefits neither directly nor indirectly from the consumption of the charitable good, but merely from the act of giving… A person is reliable if and only if it is more advantageous to him than being unreliable.
  • 11.
    • “Altruism” =exchange • Friendship, social approval, social rewards. • Give in order to get • Reciprocity= a way of mobilizing egoistic motivations and channeling them into the maintenance of the social system.
  • 13.
    PSYCHOLOGY • Sociobiologists: psychologyneeds what they have to offer (more realistic understanding of human being) • Michael and Lisa Wallach: Satisfaction of our own needs is what motivate the individual. • Freud: child altruistic impulses.
  • 14.
    Clinicians… JEAN BAKER MILLER An apparent FREUD /DAUGHTER FREUD Altruism desire to people may think help should they see contributes through to a reaction surrender the fact that formation to real the woman against impulses. is serving one’s real herself desire, TO through HURT. serving others.
  • 15.
    RIGHT OR Is this going to WRONG work for me? Psychology has distinctions only between good and bad forms of selfishness. ALLAN BLOOM.
  • 16.
    The amount ofromantic love a person feels for someone is supposed to be direct function of the benefits he/she derives from the relationship. Learning Behaviorism theory EGOISM EGOISM
  • 17.
    1.Seeking reward. 2.Avoidingpunishment. 3.We find someone’s else pain distressing.
  • 18.
    BEHIND THE APPEALOF EGOISM  Altruism is only a chimera.  Morality is married to the idea of doing for oneself.  Ethical egoism  Kant= self-love and morality pull in opposite directions.
  • 19.
    Guilt Who are You’ve got you to to start Stop judge putting feeling another yourself guilty person’s first life?
  • 20.
    UTOPIA: ALTRUISTIC PERFECTIONOR A RACE OF SAINTS • It does each • To linger on • This of us an saintliness approach communicate has the injustice by s the seeming to effect of reassuring turning put part of message that human a few larger- altruism into nature than-life an all-or – beyond our characters nothing reach have become proposition. specialists in helping others. 1 2 3
  • 21.
    CONCLUSIONS Reducing non-economic issues has relation with reduce economic issues. Bonus/grades. Ethics pays.