The Literature Review Finding & Evaluating Information Resources for Industrial and Systems Engineering P.L. Alford, D.V.M., M.S., M.S. Jane Stephens, M.L.I.S.
Electronic Resources – One-stop shopping? – Not Yet   Catalogs vs. Indexes/Databases vs. Web Directories vs. Web Search Engines **DIFFERENT RESOURCES NEEDED FOR DIFFERENT TYPES OF CONTENT**
Catalogs Physical location and status of the holdings of a specific library or libraries, e.g.,  LibCat Formal subject headings (usually 2-5) applied to content of entire work (Library of Congress or National Library of Medicine) Smaller entities within the work, like book chapters or conference papers, not indexed  Search by title, author, subject, format, publisher; more recently, keyword search may include abstracts or Tables of Contents
Indexes/Databases Not tied to holdings of a specific institution Indexing and abstracting of information in a particular  discipline ,  e.g ., education, medicine, or engineering; or in a particular  content  or  format ,  e.g ., newspapers, data, films; or from a particular  publisher ,  e.g ., Elsevier or U.S. government Hundreds of databases, some free, most are subscription, restricted to TAMU users
Indexes/Databases, ctnd. Indexing may cover full-text of articles; at a minimum most DBs search and/or index title, abstract, assigned keywords, source title, publisher, and date of publication  Subject-specific DBs usually assign subject descriptors using formal vocabulary; browsable indices or searchable thesaurus available to map common search terms to the formal language of the discipline
Indexes/Databases, ctnd. Some DBs contain full-text articles (may or may not contain graphics) within the database or have links to the full-text articles Some DBs have SFX ( Find Text@TAMU ) link to retrieval options Some DBs no links to full-text or local holdings; must check  LibCat ,  E-Journal Search,  or use  Get It for Me .
Choosing a Database/Index Consult subject or class guide  http://guides.library.tamu.edu Browse electronic resources by subject Ask a librarian (subject librarian contact info on guides or Evans 845-3826; WCL 845-2111; live chat link library home page)
Additional finding aids Bibliographies Specially-prepared subject bibliographies (search catalog for these) Bibliographies in reference books, textbooks, and journal articles Consult major professor, other mentors Having identified an important article, follow cites to it in Citation Index (ISI)
Choosing Indexing Resources: Four “C’s” to Consider Content – What types of publications indexed? Numbers/Source list of titles? Credibility – How authoritative is the content?  Currency – How current is the content, how frequently updated? Coverage – Years of content indexed? Changes in indexing through the years?
Content: the Three “R’s” Research reports (current studies)  Review articles and monographs (books) Reference material Data Statistics Methodology Tools Different indexing/finding aids for different content
Hierarchy of Credibility Peer-reviewed Additional rankings of journals within profession, and by citation analysis (ISI impact factor, citation half-life, etc.) Academic publishers Government agencies Reputable trade & consumer publications
Information Currency Preprints, Periodicals most current Be aware of lag time in scholarly publishing cycle; takes time for research in “hot topics” to appear in scholarly literature Lag time of year or more for information in books Often difficult to evaluate currency of Web sites
Choosing Indexing Resources:  Other Considerations Advanced search capabilities? Specialized, controlled vocabulary for indexing – also accessible by end-user? Integration with citation manager programs? Good online help, intuitive interface? Ability to set up custom search alerts?
Accessing Current Research Pre-print Sources, e.g. arXiv.org e-prints in physics, mathematics, computer science, etc.  http://arxiv.org/   Indexes to current periodicals, conference proceedings, theses, and dissertations (next slide) and indexes to industry and trade publications for industry news reports
Accessing Current Research Databases for searching the latest research ArticleFirst  (journal TOCs) PapersFirst  (conferences) Essential Science Indicators  (citation metrics & rankings, hot papers) Lexis-Nexis  (conference news coverage)  Proquest Dissertations and Theses
Theses and Dissertations ProQuest Dissertations and Theses Doctoral-level theses, many full-text online Order through  Get It for Me  (subsidized acquisition) Use LibCat to search for TAMU theses (masters and doctoral); e.g., keyword search “engineering education” AND thesis TxSpace digital repository for recent TAMU theses ( http://txspace.tamu.edu/ )
Scholarly I&S Engineering Resources (alphabetic order) ACM Digital  (computer science) Applied Science & Technology Business Source Complete  (Ebsco) Compendex  (Engineering, all types) IEEE  (Electrical eng and computer sci) INSPEC  (applied & theoretical)  ProQuest  (EconLit, Engineering, High Tech., Materials Science) Web of Science  (All academic disciplines)
Indexes/Databases for Business Content ProQuest ABI/Inform  (trade/industry publications) Ebsco Business Source Complete  (trade & scholarly publications) See General Business LibGuide  http://guides.library.tamu.edu/Business
Indexes/Databases for Mathematics / Applied Math MathSciNet SIAM  (Soc. Industrial & Applied Math) MathNetBase  (~ 400 mathematics handbooks, not articles) Springer  (books and articles from major publisher in science, technical, engineering, math)
Indexes/Databases for Social Sciences Periodicals Content Ebsco  multiple sub-databases ProQuest  multiple sub-databases  Web of Science
Indexes/Databases for Technical Reports  See Technical Reports Guide  http://guides.library.tamu.edu/reports   NTRL  (National Technical Reports Lib) GPOAccess Science.gov DTIC  (Defense Technical Information Center, formerly known as STINET)
Indexes/Databases for Patents and Intellectual Property Info Patents subject guide  http://guides.library.tamu.edu/patent   USPTO  www.uspto.gov  (Patent searching) www.pat2pdf.org    (Obtain a pdf copy of patent when you know patent #)
E-Resources for Reference Encyclopedias & other E-Books Type “encyclopedia” in Search for … Database search term box to see listing of electronic encyclopedias E-book packages (databases) include eBrary, netLibrary, EngNetBase, Knovel, MathNetBase, Safari, Science Direct, Springer, Wiley Interscience  http://guides.library.tamu.edu/e-books
Statistical Data Resources Lexis-Nexis Statistical Universe FedStats   www.fedstats.gov   United Nations  http://unstats.un.org   Search library guides with kw “data” U. No. Tx. Gov. Info. Connection www.library.unt.edu/govinfo/browse-topics/statistics
Government Publications GPOAccess   www.gpoaccess.gov   Lexis-Nexis   Federal Gateway  www.firstgov.gov   Google Unclesam   www.google.com/unclesam   KW search in  LibCat  with “Set Limits” Location to Government Documents Government, law, legal library guides
Legal Resources  http://guides.library.tamu.edu/FederalLaw   Ebsco Legal Collection Campus Research  (WestLaw) Lexis-Nexis  Cornell Legal Information Institute   http://www.law.cornell.edu/
Finding the important journals in my field Set limits in  LibCat  to type= “serial” and search by keyword Evaluate journals for their rankings in  Journal Citation Reports  (ISI) Do searches of interest in major databases and see which journals have the most articles of interest to you  Search  Ulrich’s Periodical Database
Overview of mechanics of finding and retrieving journal articles Identify articles of interest by searching an indexing database  Options for retrieval: Full text or Find Text@TAMU link when available  OR Search Now  for electronic subscription (e-journal search) Search  LibCat  or  Chiron  for print subscription (journal title search,  not  article title) Order from  Get It for Me  service
Tips for Managing Your Literature Cites & Reprints Make your literature review strategy and search histories a part of your research notebook Use a bibliographic/citation manager such as EndNote, RefWorks, Zotero  Keep backups of the electronic files of your reprints
EndNote Information & Links http://guides.library.tamu.edu/EndNote   Endnote Basics Video Tutorial  http://endnote.com/training/tutorials/EndNoteX5/Menu_970x562/EndNoteX5.html   How to Use Endnote in Seven Minutes  http://youtu.be/L5Kn8l2rgqk
Citation Styles & Formatting Citation Guides  http://library.tamu.edu/help   Consult journals’ publisher web sites for instructions (manuscript, author’s, contributor’s instructions, etc.)  U. of Toronto Eng. Comm. Manual -- Documentation section  www.engineering.utoronto.ca/about/programs/communication/Online_Handbook.htm
RefWorks Info & Tutorials http://guides.library.tamu.edu/RefWorks   ProQuest RefWorks channel YouTube  http://www.youtube.com/proquestrefworks
Helpful Links Thesis office  http://thesis.tamu.edu/   Writing Center  http://writingcenter.tamu.edu/   Library Research Support Pages http://guides.library.tamu.edu   http://library.tamu.edu/help
For Additional Help Contact: Jane Stephens, M.L.I.S.  [email_address]   Patricia L. Alford, D.V.M., M.S.  [email_address]   Evans Reference Desk, first floor Evans, 845-3826; West Campus Lib 845-2111 Chat  virtual reference (live chat and email), link on library home page

2012 the literature review_industrial_systemsengineering

  • 1.
    The Literature ReviewFinding & Evaluating Information Resources for Industrial and Systems Engineering P.L. Alford, D.V.M., M.S., M.S. Jane Stephens, M.L.I.S.
  • 2.
    Electronic Resources –One-stop shopping? – Not Yet  Catalogs vs. Indexes/Databases vs. Web Directories vs. Web Search Engines **DIFFERENT RESOURCES NEEDED FOR DIFFERENT TYPES OF CONTENT**
  • 3.
    Catalogs Physical locationand status of the holdings of a specific library or libraries, e.g., LibCat Formal subject headings (usually 2-5) applied to content of entire work (Library of Congress or National Library of Medicine) Smaller entities within the work, like book chapters or conference papers, not indexed Search by title, author, subject, format, publisher; more recently, keyword search may include abstracts or Tables of Contents
  • 4.
    Indexes/Databases Not tiedto holdings of a specific institution Indexing and abstracting of information in a particular discipline , e.g ., education, medicine, or engineering; or in a particular content or format , e.g ., newspapers, data, films; or from a particular publisher , e.g ., Elsevier or U.S. government Hundreds of databases, some free, most are subscription, restricted to TAMU users
  • 5.
    Indexes/Databases, ctnd. Indexingmay cover full-text of articles; at a minimum most DBs search and/or index title, abstract, assigned keywords, source title, publisher, and date of publication Subject-specific DBs usually assign subject descriptors using formal vocabulary; browsable indices or searchable thesaurus available to map common search terms to the formal language of the discipline
  • 6.
    Indexes/Databases, ctnd. SomeDBs contain full-text articles (may or may not contain graphics) within the database or have links to the full-text articles Some DBs have SFX ( Find Text@TAMU ) link to retrieval options Some DBs no links to full-text or local holdings; must check LibCat , E-Journal Search, or use Get It for Me .
  • 7.
    Choosing a Database/IndexConsult subject or class guide http://guides.library.tamu.edu Browse electronic resources by subject Ask a librarian (subject librarian contact info on guides or Evans 845-3826; WCL 845-2111; live chat link library home page)
  • 8.
    Additional finding aidsBibliographies Specially-prepared subject bibliographies (search catalog for these) Bibliographies in reference books, textbooks, and journal articles Consult major professor, other mentors Having identified an important article, follow cites to it in Citation Index (ISI)
  • 9.
    Choosing Indexing Resources:Four “C’s” to Consider Content – What types of publications indexed? Numbers/Source list of titles? Credibility – How authoritative is the content? Currency – How current is the content, how frequently updated? Coverage – Years of content indexed? Changes in indexing through the years?
  • 10.
    Content: the Three“R’s” Research reports (current studies) Review articles and monographs (books) Reference material Data Statistics Methodology Tools Different indexing/finding aids for different content
  • 11.
    Hierarchy of CredibilityPeer-reviewed Additional rankings of journals within profession, and by citation analysis (ISI impact factor, citation half-life, etc.) Academic publishers Government agencies Reputable trade & consumer publications
  • 12.
    Information Currency Preprints,Periodicals most current Be aware of lag time in scholarly publishing cycle; takes time for research in “hot topics” to appear in scholarly literature Lag time of year or more for information in books Often difficult to evaluate currency of Web sites
  • 13.
    Choosing Indexing Resources: Other Considerations Advanced search capabilities? Specialized, controlled vocabulary for indexing – also accessible by end-user? Integration with citation manager programs? Good online help, intuitive interface? Ability to set up custom search alerts?
  • 14.
    Accessing Current ResearchPre-print Sources, e.g. arXiv.org e-prints in physics, mathematics, computer science, etc. http://arxiv.org/ Indexes to current periodicals, conference proceedings, theses, and dissertations (next slide) and indexes to industry and trade publications for industry news reports
  • 15.
    Accessing Current ResearchDatabases for searching the latest research ArticleFirst (journal TOCs) PapersFirst (conferences) Essential Science Indicators (citation metrics & rankings, hot papers) Lexis-Nexis (conference news coverage) Proquest Dissertations and Theses
  • 16.
    Theses and DissertationsProQuest Dissertations and Theses Doctoral-level theses, many full-text online Order through Get It for Me (subsidized acquisition) Use LibCat to search for TAMU theses (masters and doctoral); e.g., keyword search “engineering education” AND thesis TxSpace digital repository for recent TAMU theses ( http://txspace.tamu.edu/ )
  • 17.
    Scholarly I&S EngineeringResources (alphabetic order) ACM Digital (computer science) Applied Science & Technology Business Source Complete (Ebsco) Compendex (Engineering, all types) IEEE (Electrical eng and computer sci) INSPEC (applied & theoretical) ProQuest (EconLit, Engineering, High Tech., Materials Science) Web of Science (All academic disciplines)
  • 18.
    Indexes/Databases for BusinessContent ProQuest ABI/Inform (trade/industry publications) Ebsco Business Source Complete (trade & scholarly publications) See General Business LibGuide http://guides.library.tamu.edu/Business
  • 19.
    Indexes/Databases for Mathematics/ Applied Math MathSciNet SIAM (Soc. Industrial & Applied Math) MathNetBase (~ 400 mathematics handbooks, not articles) Springer (books and articles from major publisher in science, technical, engineering, math)
  • 20.
    Indexes/Databases for SocialSciences Periodicals Content Ebsco multiple sub-databases ProQuest multiple sub-databases Web of Science
  • 21.
    Indexes/Databases for TechnicalReports See Technical Reports Guide http://guides.library.tamu.edu/reports NTRL (National Technical Reports Lib) GPOAccess Science.gov DTIC (Defense Technical Information Center, formerly known as STINET)
  • 22.
    Indexes/Databases for Patentsand Intellectual Property Info Patents subject guide http://guides.library.tamu.edu/patent USPTO www.uspto.gov (Patent searching) www.pat2pdf.org   (Obtain a pdf copy of patent when you know patent #)
  • 23.
    E-Resources for ReferenceEncyclopedias & other E-Books Type “encyclopedia” in Search for … Database search term box to see listing of electronic encyclopedias E-book packages (databases) include eBrary, netLibrary, EngNetBase, Knovel, MathNetBase, Safari, Science Direct, Springer, Wiley Interscience http://guides.library.tamu.edu/e-books
  • 24.
    Statistical Data ResourcesLexis-Nexis Statistical Universe FedStats www.fedstats.gov United Nations http://unstats.un.org Search library guides with kw “data” U. No. Tx. Gov. Info. Connection www.library.unt.edu/govinfo/browse-topics/statistics
  • 25.
    Government Publications GPOAccess www.gpoaccess.gov Lexis-Nexis Federal Gateway www.firstgov.gov Google Unclesam www.google.com/unclesam KW search in LibCat with “Set Limits” Location to Government Documents Government, law, legal library guides
  • 26.
    Legal Resources http://guides.library.tamu.edu/FederalLaw Ebsco Legal Collection Campus Research (WestLaw) Lexis-Nexis Cornell Legal Information Institute http://www.law.cornell.edu/
  • 27.
    Finding the importantjournals in my field Set limits in LibCat to type= “serial” and search by keyword Evaluate journals for their rankings in Journal Citation Reports (ISI) Do searches of interest in major databases and see which journals have the most articles of interest to you Search Ulrich’s Periodical Database
  • 28.
    Overview of mechanicsof finding and retrieving journal articles Identify articles of interest by searching an indexing database Options for retrieval: Full text or Find Text@TAMU link when available OR Search Now for electronic subscription (e-journal search) Search LibCat or Chiron for print subscription (journal title search, not article title) Order from Get It for Me service
  • 29.
    Tips for ManagingYour Literature Cites & Reprints Make your literature review strategy and search histories a part of your research notebook Use a bibliographic/citation manager such as EndNote, RefWorks, Zotero Keep backups of the electronic files of your reprints
  • 30.
    EndNote Information &Links http://guides.library.tamu.edu/EndNote Endnote Basics Video Tutorial http://endnote.com/training/tutorials/EndNoteX5/Menu_970x562/EndNoteX5.html How to Use Endnote in Seven Minutes http://youtu.be/L5Kn8l2rgqk
  • 31.
    Citation Styles &Formatting Citation Guides http://library.tamu.edu/help Consult journals’ publisher web sites for instructions (manuscript, author’s, contributor’s instructions, etc.) U. of Toronto Eng. Comm. Manual -- Documentation section www.engineering.utoronto.ca/about/programs/communication/Online_Handbook.htm
  • 32.
    RefWorks Info &Tutorials http://guides.library.tamu.edu/RefWorks ProQuest RefWorks channel YouTube http://www.youtube.com/proquestrefworks
  • 33.
    Helpful Links Thesisoffice http://thesis.tamu.edu/ Writing Center http://writingcenter.tamu.edu/ Library Research Support Pages http://guides.library.tamu.edu http://library.tamu.edu/help
  • 34.
    For Additional HelpContact: Jane Stephens, M.L.I.S. [email_address] Patricia L. Alford, D.V.M., M.S. [email_address] Evans Reference Desk, first floor Evans, 845-3826; West Campus Lib 845-2111 Chat virtual reference (live chat and email), link on library home page

Editor's Notes

  • #2 The Literature Review Fall 2005 HLTH 681 Contact Patricia Alford, D.V.M., M.S., palford@tamu.edu
  • #3 The Literature Review Fall 2005 HLTH 681 Contact Patricia Alford, D.V.M., M.S., palford@tamu.edu Google, Amazon, and other information sources on the World Wide Web have raised expectations that a literature review can be accomplished with “One-stop shopping”. In library lingo, a so-called “Federated search” will retrieve the desired information, whether it’s in a book, journal article, or government web site, by using a single search interface. This hypothetical search interface is linked to the catalogs of all the participating libraries, as well as to hundreds of databases that index the articles contained in thousands of electronic journal archives, AND to search engines that index millions of web pages. However, although federated searching of multiple catalogs and databases is already available, it is not recommended as a sound strategy for doing a thorough literature review. At present, because of the marked difference between the way in which books are cataloged and the way in which journal articles are indexed, federated searching is unlikely to retrieve the desired results.