A Model for Rural Health Education for 
First Year Medical Students: 
Understanding Barriers to Care 
Ruth L. Bush, M.D., J.D., M.P.H. 
Vice Dean for Academic Affairs and Vice Dean, 
Bryan/College Station Campus 
Professor of Surgery, Texas A & M College of Medicine 
The Muster 2014
Disclosures 
• Faculty: Ruth L. Bush 
• Relationships with 
commercial interests: 
–None
What is the Problem? 
Shortage of US primary care physicians – most 
concern in rural populations 
• 9% physicians located where 
20% of population resides (rural 
areas) 
• 3% of current medical school 
graduates plan to enter rural 
practice 
• Rural upbringing 
• Expressed plan to eventually become a family/primary care 
physician 
3
Texas Rural Populations & Physicians 
• 23 Counties with 
0 primary care 
physicians 
• 16 Counties with 
1 primary care 
physician 
• 138 Counties with 
2 or more primary 
care physicians 
4
Medical Challenges in Rural Communities 
Longer travel distances 
Higher costs of medical care 
High fixed overhead per-patient revenue 
Fewer healthcare providers 
More emphasis on generalists 
Higher dependency on Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement 
Higher rates of chronic disease 
5
How do we provide solutions to this 
problem? 
Add education about these issues to 
students’ experiences! 
6
Setting & Rotation Structure 
• Multidisciplinary teams: physicians, hospital chaplains, 
social workers, nurse educators, and 1st and 2nd year 
TAM-COM students 
• Paired with underserved families in a Holland, Texas 
(pop. 1,121) rural community 
• Primary goal: To facilitate and improve family’s interface 
with health care resources and expose students to rural 
health care barriers 
7
Purpose 
1. Enhance students’ knowledge of barriers to 
health care access and chronic healthcare 
needs in a rural population 
2. Provide educational experiences within an 
interprofessional environment 
8
Benefit to Students 
9 
Early 
exposure to 
rural medicine 
Understanding 
of rural 
communities’ 
issues 
Encouraged to 
pursue rural 
primary care
Methods 
Physicians 
• Students created monthly interactive presentations and 
handouts for families to facilitate conversation around 
heath views, needs, and concerns 
• Short term goals set by families – students research and 
find resources or ask questions pertinent to their specific 
families’ health concerns 
10 
Rural 
Health 
Care 
Teams 
1st & 2nd 
year 
medical 
students 
Hospital 
Chaplains 
Social 
Workers 
Nurse 
Educators 
Families
Methods: First Year Curriculum 
• 13 students in 2010-2011 
• Families recruited by school nurse based on 
health care needs of the children 
• Students placed in small groups (2-3) and 
assigned to family 
– Presentations: disseminate information 
– Handouts: facilitate conversation 
– Discussions 
• Students also worked with mentors to set goals 
and reflect on progress 
11
First-Year Families 
12
Methods: Second Year Curriculum 
• 6 returning participants, 16 first year students, and 
nursing students 
• Families given option to participate again, new families 
recruited 
• Physician/mentor present with each group 
• Students provided: 
– Interactive presentations on health care topics 
– Guidance for meetings (2nd-year students) 
• Health fair held during the final meeting, and training 
session for students was held at the school 
13
Second-Year Families 
14
What impacts did this make on the 
students? 
How will it impact rural healthcare? 
15 
Participation Survey
Results: Changes in Students 
• 27 medical students participated in 2 years 
• 93% increased knowledge about difficulties 
associated with rural living and barriers to health 
care access 
• Increased knowledge of 
– Health concerns/struggles prevalent in a rural 
community 
– The importance of the physician-patient relationship
Results 
• Increased interest in primary care residencies 
after completing program 
• Program helped with 
development as future 
physician (25 students) 
– Listening skills 
– More understanding of 
circumstances 
surrounding rural living 
17
Discussion 
• Early exposure to medical issues in rural 
community influences students’ approach to 
medicine 
• Accomplished one of the core medical education 
competencies 
• Students’ “people skills” improved, developing 
future relationships with patients 
– Compassion 
– Patience 
– Listening to patients and circumstances 
18
Discussion: Rural Populations 
Decreased 
• Number of health care providers 
• Fewer specialists 
• Services provided by medical facilities 
19 
Increased 
• Rate of chronic diseases 
• Elderly and children 
• Unemployment and underemployment 
rates 
• Poor, uninsured, underinsured 
residents 
• Distance to healthcare 
• Cost of healthcare
Conclusions 
• Understanding: Participants were able to understand healthcare 
disparities affecting rural families and to understand alternative 
medical resources necessary for optimized healthcare. 
• Awareness: Students’ awareness of social determinants of health 
and global health issues was increased. 
• Knowledge: Communication skills and clinical knowledge was 
expanded early in students’ medical education 
• Professional development: increase overall 
20
21 
Thank you! 
Ruth Bush, MD, JD, MPH 
rbush@medicine.tamhsc.edu

104 muster2014 Bush

  • 1.
    A Model forRural Health Education for First Year Medical Students: Understanding Barriers to Care Ruth L. Bush, M.D., J.D., M.P.H. Vice Dean for Academic Affairs and Vice Dean, Bryan/College Station Campus Professor of Surgery, Texas A & M College of Medicine The Muster 2014
  • 2.
    Disclosures • Faculty:Ruth L. Bush • Relationships with commercial interests: –None
  • 3.
    What is theProblem? Shortage of US primary care physicians – most concern in rural populations • 9% physicians located where 20% of population resides (rural areas) • 3% of current medical school graduates plan to enter rural practice • Rural upbringing • Expressed plan to eventually become a family/primary care physician 3
  • 4.
    Texas Rural Populations& Physicians • 23 Counties with 0 primary care physicians • 16 Counties with 1 primary care physician • 138 Counties with 2 or more primary care physicians 4
  • 5.
    Medical Challenges inRural Communities Longer travel distances Higher costs of medical care High fixed overhead per-patient revenue Fewer healthcare providers More emphasis on generalists Higher dependency on Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement Higher rates of chronic disease 5
  • 6.
    How do weprovide solutions to this problem? Add education about these issues to students’ experiences! 6
  • 7.
    Setting & RotationStructure • Multidisciplinary teams: physicians, hospital chaplains, social workers, nurse educators, and 1st and 2nd year TAM-COM students • Paired with underserved families in a Holland, Texas (pop. 1,121) rural community • Primary goal: To facilitate and improve family’s interface with health care resources and expose students to rural health care barriers 7
  • 8.
    Purpose 1. Enhancestudents’ knowledge of barriers to health care access and chronic healthcare needs in a rural population 2. Provide educational experiences within an interprofessional environment 8
  • 9.
    Benefit to Students 9 Early exposure to rural medicine Understanding of rural communities’ issues Encouraged to pursue rural primary care
  • 10.
    Methods Physicians •Students created monthly interactive presentations and handouts for families to facilitate conversation around heath views, needs, and concerns • Short term goals set by families – students research and find resources or ask questions pertinent to their specific families’ health concerns 10 Rural Health Care Teams 1st & 2nd year medical students Hospital Chaplains Social Workers Nurse Educators Families
  • 11.
    Methods: First YearCurriculum • 13 students in 2010-2011 • Families recruited by school nurse based on health care needs of the children • Students placed in small groups (2-3) and assigned to family – Presentations: disseminate information – Handouts: facilitate conversation – Discussions • Students also worked with mentors to set goals and reflect on progress 11
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Methods: Second YearCurriculum • 6 returning participants, 16 first year students, and nursing students • Families given option to participate again, new families recruited • Physician/mentor present with each group • Students provided: – Interactive presentations on health care topics – Guidance for meetings (2nd-year students) • Health fair held during the final meeting, and training session for students was held at the school 13
  • 14.
  • 15.
    What impacts didthis make on the students? How will it impact rural healthcare? 15 Participation Survey
  • 16.
    Results: Changes inStudents • 27 medical students participated in 2 years • 93% increased knowledge about difficulties associated with rural living and barriers to health care access • Increased knowledge of – Health concerns/struggles prevalent in a rural community – The importance of the physician-patient relationship
  • 17.
    Results • Increasedinterest in primary care residencies after completing program • Program helped with development as future physician (25 students) – Listening skills – More understanding of circumstances surrounding rural living 17
  • 18.
    Discussion • Earlyexposure to medical issues in rural community influences students’ approach to medicine • Accomplished one of the core medical education competencies • Students’ “people skills” improved, developing future relationships with patients – Compassion – Patience – Listening to patients and circumstances 18
  • 19.
    Discussion: Rural Populations Decreased • Number of health care providers • Fewer specialists • Services provided by medical facilities 19 Increased • Rate of chronic diseases • Elderly and children • Unemployment and underemployment rates • Poor, uninsured, underinsured residents • Distance to healthcare • Cost of healthcare
  • 20.
    Conclusions • Understanding:Participants were able to understand healthcare disparities affecting rural families and to understand alternative medical resources necessary for optimized healthcare. • Awareness: Students’ awareness of social determinants of health and global health issues was increased. • Knowledge: Communication skills and clinical knowledge was expanded early in students’ medical education • Professional development: increase overall 20
  • 21.
    21 Thank you! Ruth Bush, MD, JD, MPH rbush@medicine.tamhsc.edu

Editor's Notes