Social Determinants of Health – 
Upstream Medicine 
Presented at the 
Global Community Engaged Medical Education Muster 
Uluru, Northern Territory 
27-30 October, 2014 
By 
Nancy W Dickey, MD 
Professor, Department of Family Medicine 
Texas A&M University Health Science Center College of Medicine
Faculty/Presenter 
Disclosure 
Slide 1 
• Faculty: Nancy W Dickey, MD 
• Relationships with commercial interests: 
– Consulting Fees: Association of 
Academic Health Centers 
– Others: Employee of Texas A&M 
University Heatlh Science Center 
College of Medicine
Disclosure of Commercial 
Support 
Slide 2 
• This program has received in-kind 
support from Texas A&M University 
Health Science Center in the form of 
travel support 
• AAHC consulting is not related to this 
forum. 
• Potential for conflict(s) of interest: 
None 
 Nancy W Dickey, MD, has received 
funding from Texas A&M University 
Health Science Center supporting this 
program.
Mitigating Potential Bias 
Slide 3 
• The AAHC consulting is not related 
to curriculum development or this 
conference. 
• The support of the University is in 
support of an expectation of 
developing curriculum and sharing 
best practices across the globe. A 
full report will be made back to 
the university regarding my 
presentation and additional 
lessons learned for incorporation 
into university curriculum.
Achieving “Total Health” requires 
attention beyond the exam room…. 
Health is driven by multiple factors that are intricately linked—of which medical care is one 
component. Total Health is a comprehensive solution that addresses all components. 
Drivers of Health 
Source: Determinants of Health and Their Contribution to Premature Death. JAMA 1993 
| © 2011 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, 
5 November 27, 2014 
Inc.
Teaching students the 
breadth of their role… 
• Get them early so they learn this is important – 
even before they begin to learn physical diagnosis 
and differential diagnosis 
• Living laboratory 
• “Relatively blatant examples 
• Sticky” learning 
– Associated with real patients 
– Practice assessment & judgment 
• As with procedural skills, technique, sequence, 
and practice help promote “muscle memory”
The Curriculum 
• WHEN: During the pre clerkship training phase 
• WHO: M-1 Students in a longitudinal experience 
through first 10 months of pre-clerkship 
education 
• HOW: Selected reading & discussion to learn 
concepts 
Active Learning Process through patient/client 
interaction 
• Assign two students to a patient 
• Facilitate home visits 
• Attend one or more clinic visits and access clinic medical 
records 
• Each team will select ONE social issue that impacts the health 
measure/outcome of the assigned patient 
• Develop a plan to address the social “upstream” issue 
selected 
• Additional credit for any team of students that actually takes 
steps to implement the plan
Assessing Performance…
Assessing Performance… 
• Readings followed by small group 
discussion 
• Documentation of clinic and 
home visits 
– Demonstration of 
understanding link between 
upstream issues and medical 
issues 
• Description of selection of 
social/upstream issue(s) 
– Demonstration of 
understanding of concept 
• Reasonableness of recommended 
plan/intervention 
*Steps taken to actually 
implement may lead to additional 
credit
Questions

122 muster2014 Dickey

  • 1.
    Social Determinants ofHealth – Upstream Medicine Presented at the Global Community Engaged Medical Education Muster Uluru, Northern Territory 27-30 October, 2014 By Nancy W Dickey, MD Professor, Department of Family Medicine Texas A&M University Health Science Center College of Medicine
  • 2.
    Faculty/Presenter Disclosure Slide1 • Faculty: Nancy W Dickey, MD • Relationships with commercial interests: – Consulting Fees: Association of Academic Health Centers – Others: Employee of Texas A&M University Heatlh Science Center College of Medicine
  • 3.
    Disclosure of Commercial Support Slide 2 • This program has received in-kind support from Texas A&M University Health Science Center in the form of travel support • AAHC consulting is not related to this forum. • Potential for conflict(s) of interest: None  Nancy W Dickey, MD, has received funding from Texas A&M University Health Science Center supporting this program.
  • 4.
    Mitigating Potential Bias Slide 3 • The AAHC consulting is not related to curriculum development or this conference. • The support of the University is in support of an expectation of developing curriculum and sharing best practices across the globe. A full report will be made back to the university regarding my presentation and additional lessons learned for incorporation into university curriculum.
  • 5.
    Achieving “Total Health”requires attention beyond the exam room…. Health is driven by multiple factors that are intricately linked—of which medical care is one component. Total Health is a comprehensive solution that addresses all components. Drivers of Health Source: Determinants of Health and Their Contribution to Premature Death. JAMA 1993 | © 2011 Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, 5 November 27, 2014 Inc.
  • 6.
    Teaching students the breadth of their role… • Get them early so they learn this is important – even before they begin to learn physical diagnosis and differential diagnosis • Living laboratory • “Relatively blatant examples • Sticky” learning – Associated with real patients – Practice assessment & judgment • As with procedural skills, technique, sequence, and practice help promote “muscle memory”
  • 7.
    The Curriculum •WHEN: During the pre clerkship training phase • WHO: M-1 Students in a longitudinal experience through first 10 months of pre-clerkship education • HOW: Selected reading & discussion to learn concepts Active Learning Process through patient/client interaction • Assign two students to a patient • Facilitate home visits • Attend one or more clinic visits and access clinic medical records • Each team will select ONE social issue that impacts the health measure/outcome of the assigned patient • Develop a plan to address the social “upstream” issue selected • Additional credit for any team of students that actually takes steps to implement the plan
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Assessing Performance… •Readings followed by small group discussion • Documentation of clinic and home visits – Demonstration of understanding link between upstream issues and medical issues • Description of selection of social/upstream issue(s) – Demonstration of understanding of concept • Reasonableness of recommended plan/intervention *Steps taken to actually implement may lead to additional credit
  • 10.

Editor's Notes

  • #6 There are health behaviors, social, economic, and environmental factors that determine the quality and length of life. Behaviors than can negatively impact health include smoking, lack of exercise, unhealthy diets, alcohol use and unsafe sex practices.   Social and economic factors include education, employment, income, family and social support, and community safety   The physical factors include the quality of the environment But for the purposes of educating medical students, we tend to spend an inverse portion of time i.e. 90% on medical care, 7% (and that only recently) on genetics and personal behavior and less than 5% on environmental and social factors – and we usually promptly refer them to someone else to deal with those issues.
  • #8 Outlines the skills, performances, attitudes, and values pupils are expected to learn from schooling. It includes statements of desired pupil outcomes, descriptions of materials, and the planned sequence that will be used to help pupils attain the outcomes. The total learning experience provided by a school. It includes the statements of desired pupil outcomes, descriptions of materials, and the planned sequence that will be used to help pupils attain the outcomes., which relate to the way the school is organized.
  • #9 statements of desired pupil outcomes, descriptions of materials, and the planned sequence that will be used to help pupils attain the outcomes. the skills, performances, attitudes, and values statements of desired pupil outcomes, descriptions of materials, and the planned sequence that will be used to help pupils attain the outcomes.
  • #10 statements of desired pupil outcomes, descriptions of materials, and the planned sequence that will be used to help pupils attain the outcomes. the skills, performances, attitudes, and values statements of desired pupil outcomes, descriptions of materials, and the planned sequence that will be used to help pupils attain the outcomes.