LSGI4321
   Individual Assignment




Topic:
It has been argued that the
increasing urbanization is
unsustainable.Discuss how GIT
can help plan a green/low carbon
sustainable city?




                      SHEH WING YIN

                          09202869D
It is estimated that around half of the world’s population are now living in urban
settlements. (Cohen, 2005)With the increasing density of population in urban
areas,urbanizationbenefits the local communities both economically and
socially. The economy of scale,the desire to improve living condition and
thedevelopment of new information technologies are the examples of the
driving forces behind this process. Because of the advantages of the economy
of scale, the employment opportunities have attracted large amount of people
from rural area to seekbetter job opportunities in urban area for better living
standards. At the same time, the proximity of every household has encouraged
the development of social services and community infrastructures, which help
strengtheningsocial network. These twofactors have been the major driving
forces inshaping societies.However, the planning of economic and social
developments ismainly inshort term without paying attention to long term
impacts.


Urbanization may be beneficial to society, but itcan also bring adverse impacts
to the general public. Over the recent few years, the drawbacks of urbanization
have drawn public’s attentionbecause ofthe adverse impacts brought by
unsustainable urban development, such as air and noise pollution. The
amount of the emission of greenhouse gases has also caughtthe public’s
attention as it is found that the composition of the atmosphere has changed
gradually, which may lead to climate changes.Climate changes can pose
serious threats to human beings, for example, unexpected long drought, long
raining season and rise of sea level.The impacts brought by climate change
are long-term in global scale. (Ryan, Turton, 2007) The influences are more
severe in developing countries. Therefore, there is a need for governments to
take measures to tackle this issue in order to stop deteriorating the situation.
Thus, decision makers and planners have begun to concern about developing
of an urban area or a city in a sustainable manner. According to ESRI (2007),
sustainable development is “the balance of meeting humankind's present
needs while protecting the environment to ensure the fulfillment of future
generations' needs”. In other words, sustainable development aims at
achieving economic development, environmental protection, and social
welfare in a balanced way. Since the increases in human population and the
demandfor the natural resources have never slowed down, the need to make
the planning of the society development sustainably cannot be ignoredso that
there are sufficient natural resources for our next generations.


Green, low-carbon city is anew practical concept which is deemed as one of
the solutions to tackle climate changes. With this concept, the development
planning can bemade with consideringthe ecological cycle, which provides
green and low carbon solutions indifferent aspects such as energy and
transportation.There are a number of indicators describing the concept of
green, low-carbon city, including the level of pollutions, the proportion of green
space to urban areas, efficiency in using energy, the sustainability of energy
used, and recycling rates (Meadows, 1999) Building a green, low-carbon city
can further benefit the social development, especially environmental
aspects.Environmental benefits include reduced pollution, which helps
improve public health and quality of life. In addition,striking for ecological
balance can reduce the risks of natural hazards. For instance, more vegetation
covers can help reduce soil erosion, and hencethus reduces the risk of
flooding during rainy season.


As the relationship between humans and the environments involves spatial
factors, it is vital to utilize the spatial technology to conduct the development
planning.Geo-Information Technology (GIT) is useful in this extent as
technologies likeGIS is capable in analyzing the spatial data and realization of
terrain features by modeling and visualization.The ability of this technology in
integrating different types of spatial datahas also helpedthe planners in dealing
with the complexity involvedin the decision making processes related to
sustainable development.By using GIT, decision makers will be able not only to
see the current state of the resources that they managed but also see the
impacts of their decisions and the future state of those resources.
To concentrate on the green and low carbon development framework, different
policy areas should be considered. Renewable energy andland use design will
be discussed in the following paragraphs.


Renewable Energy – Wind Power
Energy is essential for human beings to generate electricity for different uses,
such as domestic use and industrial use. However, the main energy resources
used by humans, such as fossil fuels, are non-renewable and theirsupply
islimited.In other words, the demand for energy resources is increasing due to
rapid population growth and non-stop developments over the world while the
amount of energy resources available are decreasing rapidly. As a result, it is
necessary to developalternativesustainable energy sourcesto reduce the
dependency on the existing energy sources.


Renewable energy has become a suitable substitute for energy generation,
which includes energy uses natural resources like solar energy and wind
energy. Unlike non-renewable energy, renewable energy will not be completely
used up.Furthermore, they do not emit exhaust gas whichaccelerate global
warming. Therefore, the trend of developing and researching on renewable
energy is expected to continue.(Hardcastle, Waterman-Hoey&Kunkle, 2009)
In this essay, wind farm projectwill be usedas an example to discuss how GIT
can provide assistance in the project to generate electricity via wind energy.


To determine the most suitable area for the project, some criticalinformation
has to be collected, such as population statistics, the distribution of land use,
wind intensitydata andthe network of transmission line. After collecting those
critical data, different GIS tools can be used for further analysis and evaluation.


To start with, the critical data may include both spatial and non-spatial data.
Therefore, spatial analysis, instead of traditional analysis, should be done to
analyze the relationships between them. By knowing the relationships between
differentvariables, future trend may also be predicted statistically. For instance,
population statistics and land use distribution are calculated and collected to
predict the demand for regional energy use. If some regions do not have high
demand on energy, it may not be economically efficient to carry out the project
for those regions.Another example is to use spatial analysis to describe and
show the trend of the wind intensity for ensuringthe stable supply of wind for
the power generation system. (Martin, Purellku & Gehlhaar, 2010)In this way,
spatial analysis is a useful tool in identifying the regions with high demand for
energy.


Furthermore,buffering can be used to estimate whether some protected areas
will be affected.Theoretically, buffering can also be used to highlightarea with
certainproximity of the selected feature.For example, there are evidences
showing that the construction of wind turbines will impose influence on the air
pressure around a certain distance. (Mountain Communities for Responsible
Energy, 2010) Since birds can be easily affected by the air pressure, it is
thusimportant to locate the construction areas having the least impacts on the
birds. With the data of bird populationof different districts, buffers can be
created and the areas inside the buffer will not be selected after considering
environmental aspect.


Overlay function is another powerful tool, which can integrate different data
layersto create a new layer by combining the attributes of the datalayers. For
instance, Harron(2008) has created a map which can overlay the wind
intensity layer withlayers of landscape sensitivity, archaeological and amenity
designations. With this map, project planners can spot out thearea around
constraints like steep slope and historical sites.Thus,project development will
not be carried out around those constraints.


Since the energy generated by a wind turbine can vary with environment
factors, it is essential to testvoltage fluctuation and other aspects by creating
simulation. Voltage fluctuation can then be predicted with different different
scenarios in the simulation model. In this way, solutions can be obtained for
dealing with the situations.


Building Design
Urban heat island is one of the threats faced by humans nowadays. It is
resulted from slower cooling rate in urban areas than rural areas. High
temperature in urban areas can lead to an increase in the demand of energy
for cooling purpose.As a result, vicious circleoccurs.Since the urban heat
island is partly contributed by dense buildings in urban areas, especially
commercial districts, buildingsshould be designed carefully considering
environmental aspects.


To begin with, the high density buildings in these districts usually have narrow
building gaps, blocking the natural air flow and wind. Therefore, air ventilation
is an important factor for making urban districts “cooler”. Without air flow
bringing away the heat, the heat will be concentrated in the urban areas, which
will directly increase the temperature of the whole district.


Apart from ventilation,building height is another problem - high rise buildings
usually block the air flowof the low rise buildings in their
neighborhoods.Waterfront high rise building is a good example, which has
blocked the sea breeze from flowing inland.To tackle this problem, the area
plan should be designed with wider building gaps between the buildings and
their neighborhoods with to allow the passage of breeze. In this way,
simulation model can be used to test and predictthe air pathby
inputtingpotential locationsand heights of the buildings.Hence, better
locationswithsuggested heights for the new buildings can be determined with
the minimal impacts on the natural air flow.Better air ventilation can thenbring
away the heat in the crowded areamore effectivelyto lower the overall
temperature of the entire district. Thus,less energy will be required for cooling
purpose.


To sum up, not only can decision makers be able to know more about the
current state of the resources managed by them, but they can also understand
the impacts of their decisions and future state of those resources.


Limitations of using GIT tools and techniques for the planning of a green
and low carbon city
Beyond the usefulness of GIT technology in the sustainable planning
design,there are several challengesand obstacles that may be faced by the
planners.


Firstly, the cost of data acquisition can be very high. The raster data like high
resolution satellite image and aerial images are expensive products.They can
contribute around 80% - 90% of the project budget. (Masters,Hirsch & Wong,
1994).


After finish collecting the critical data for the project, the stageof data
processing is time consuming. It is due to the fact that differentdistricts have
different economic, social and environmentalelements.Hence, huge amount of
spatial and non-spatial data have to be collected, which needs a large
proportion of time to do the data processing throughout the project.


In addition, the products of 3D animations and visualization are
hardware-demanding in nature and have very large file size.If3D products are
not createdand displayed inthe computers with goodhardwarequality,this may
impose difficulties in creating 3D products. Theproject members may need to
spend a lot of time on the stage of creating 3D models, which decrease work
efficiency as a whole.


Conclusion
Sustainable development is an urgent issue to be addressed by our society.
The effectiveness of GIT to provide tools and techniques to support the spatial
analysis, decision-making and spatial display for the development project has
been examined. To plan for a green and low carbon sustainable city, different
policy areas should be focused. Renewable energy and building design are
used as the examples of how GIT assist in the planning of the development
project and it is shown that tools and techniques of GIT are useful to a large
extent.However, this technology has a number of limitations, which may
impose challenges to the planners. To overcome the obstacles of the existing
technology, more researches should be carried outto improve the efficiency of
tools and techniques so that better urban planning can be achieved in the
future.
Reference:
Cohen, B. (2005). Urbanization in developing countries: Current trends, future
projections, and key challenges for sustainability. Technology in Society,
28 (2006), 63-80.


Ryan, L. & Turton, H. (2007). Sustainable Automobile Transport.Cheltenham:
Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
GIS for sustainable development (2007). Retrieved October 20, 2011 from
ESRI, Web site:
http://www.esri.com/library/bestpractices/sustainable-development.pdf


Meadows, D. (1999). Indicators and information systems for
sustainable development. In: Satterthwaite, D., ed. The Earthscan
reader in sustainable cities. Earthscan, London


Hardcastle, A., Waterman-Hoey, S. &Kunkle,R.(2009). Renewable Energy
Industry Trends and Workforce Development in Washington State ., .


Negative impacts on Wind Farms (2010). Retrieved November 4, 2011 from,
Mountain Communities for Responsible Energy Web site:
http://www.wvmcre.org/neg_imapcts/neg_impacts.htm

Harron, S. (2008). Planning for Wind Energy in Donegal. Retrieved November
4, 2011 from Donegal County Council, Web site:
http://www.donegalcoco.ie/NR/rdonlyres/21B39DE5-C26A-4885-B7AC-32206
A4F37D7/0/PlanningforWindEnergyinDonegal.pdf


Martin, F., Purellku, I. & Gehlhaar, T. (2010). Modelling of and Simulation with
Grid Code validated Wind Turbine Models.


A submission on HK’s Climate Change Strategy & Action Agenda (2010).
Retrieved October 20, 2011 from Civic Exchange, Web site:
http://www.civic-exchange.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/101217Climat
ePaper.pdf
Masters, E., Hirsch, B. & Wong, K. (1994). GPS/GIS and Space Time Data.
Retrieved November 5, 2011 from The University of New South Wales, School
of Geomatic Engineering Web site:
http://webone.novatel.ca/assets/Documents/Papers/File36.pdf

09202869d

  • 1.
    LSGI4321 Individual Assignment Topic: It has been argued that the increasing urbanization is unsustainable.Discuss how GIT can help plan a green/low carbon sustainable city? SHEH WING YIN 09202869D
  • 2.
    It is estimatedthat around half of the world’s population are now living in urban settlements. (Cohen, 2005)With the increasing density of population in urban areas,urbanizationbenefits the local communities both economically and socially. The economy of scale,the desire to improve living condition and thedevelopment of new information technologies are the examples of the driving forces behind this process. Because of the advantages of the economy of scale, the employment opportunities have attracted large amount of people from rural area to seekbetter job opportunities in urban area for better living standards. At the same time, the proximity of every household has encouraged the development of social services and community infrastructures, which help strengtheningsocial network. These twofactors have been the major driving forces inshaping societies.However, the planning of economic and social developments ismainly inshort term without paying attention to long term impacts. Urbanization may be beneficial to society, but itcan also bring adverse impacts to the general public. Over the recent few years, the drawbacks of urbanization have drawn public’s attentionbecause ofthe adverse impacts brought by unsustainable urban development, such as air and noise pollution. The amount of the emission of greenhouse gases has also caughtthe public’s attention as it is found that the composition of the atmosphere has changed gradually, which may lead to climate changes.Climate changes can pose serious threats to human beings, for example, unexpected long drought, long raining season and rise of sea level.The impacts brought by climate change are long-term in global scale. (Ryan, Turton, 2007) The influences are more severe in developing countries. Therefore, there is a need for governments to take measures to tackle this issue in order to stop deteriorating the situation. Thus, decision makers and planners have begun to concern about developing of an urban area or a city in a sustainable manner. According to ESRI (2007), sustainable development is “the balance of meeting humankind's present needs while protecting the environment to ensure the fulfillment of future generations' needs”. In other words, sustainable development aims at
  • 3.
    achieving economic development,environmental protection, and social welfare in a balanced way. Since the increases in human population and the demandfor the natural resources have never slowed down, the need to make the planning of the society development sustainably cannot be ignoredso that there are sufficient natural resources for our next generations. Green, low-carbon city is anew practical concept which is deemed as one of the solutions to tackle climate changes. With this concept, the development planning can bemade with consideringthe ecological cycle, which provides green and low carbon solutions indifferent aspects such as energy and transportation.There are a number of indicators describing the concept of green, low-carbon city, including the level of pollutions, the proportion of green space to urban areas, efficiency in using energy, the sustainability of energy used, and recycling rates (Meadows, 1999) Building a green, low-carbon city can further benefit the social development, especially environmental aspects.Environmental benefits include reduced pollution, which helps improve public health and quality of life. In addition,striking for ecological balance can reduce the risks of natural hazards. For instance, more vegetation covers can help reduce soil erosion, and hencethus reduces the risk of flooding during rainy season. As the relationship between humans and the environments involves spatial factors, it is vital to utilize the spatial technology to conduct the development planning.Geo-Information Technology (GIT) is useful in this extent as technologies likeGIS is capable in analyzing the spatial data and realization of terrain features by modeling and visualization.The ability of this technology in integrating different types of spatial datahas also helpedthe planners in dealing with the complexity involvedin the decision making processes related to sustainable development.By using GIT, decision makers will be able not only to see the current state of the resources that they managed but also see the impacts of their decisions and the future state of those resources.
  • 4.
    To concentrate onthe green and low carbon development framework, different policy areas should be considered. Renewable energy andland use design will be discussed in the following paragraphs. Renewable Energy – Wind Power Energy is essential for human beings to generate electricity for different uses, such as domestic use and industrial use. However, the main energy resources used by humans, such as fossil fuels, are non-renewable and theirsupply islimited.In other words, the demand for energy resources is increasing due to rapid population growth and non-stop developments over the world while the amount of energy resources available are decreasing rapidly. As a result, it is necessary to developalternativesustainable energy sourcesto reduce the dependency on the existing energy sources. Renewable energy has become a suitable substitute for energy generation, which includes energy uses natural resources like solar energy and wind energy. Unlike non-renewable energy, renewable energy will not be completely used up.Furthermore, they do not emit exhaust gas whichaccelerate global warming. Therefore, the trend of developing and researching on renewable energy is expected to continue.(Hardcastle, Waterman-Hoey&Kunkle, 2009) In this essay, wind farm projectwill be usedas an example to discuss how GIT can provide assistance in the project to generate electricity via wind energy. To determine the most suitable area for the project, some criticalinformation has to be collected, such as population statistics, the distribution of land use, wind intensitydata andthe network of transmission line. After collecting those critical data, different GIS tools can be used for further analysis and evaluation. To start with, the critical data may include both spatial and non-spatial data. Therefore, spatial analysis, instead of traditional analysis, should be done to analyze the relationships between them. By knowing the relationships between differentvariables, future trend may also be predicted statistically. For instance,
  • 5.
    population statistics andland use distribution are calculated and collected to predict the demand for regional energy use. If some regions do not have high demand on energy, it may not be economically efficient to carry out the project for those regions.Another example is to use spatial analysis to describe and show the trend of the wind intensity for ensuringthe stable supply of wind for the power generation system. (Martin, Purellku & Gehlhaar, 2010)In this way, spatial analysis is a useful tool in identifying the regions with high demand for energy. Furthermore,buffering can be used to estimate whether some protected areas will be affected.Theoretically, buffering can also be used to highlightarea with certainproximity of the selected feature.For example, there are evidences showing that the construction of wind turbines will impose influence on the air pressure around a certain distance. (Mountain Communities for Responsible Energy, 2010) Since birds can be easily affected by the air pressure, it is thusimportant to locate the construction areas having the least impacts on the birds. With the data of bird populationof different districts, buffers can be created and the areas inside the buffer will not be selected after considering environmental aspect. Overlay function is another powerful tool, which can integrate different data layersto create a new layer by combining the attributes of the datalayers. For instance, Harron(2008) has created a map which can overlay the wind intensity layer withlayers of landscape sensitivity, archaeological and amenity designations. With this map, project planners can spot out thearea around constraints like steep slope and historical sites.Thus,project development will not be carried out around those constraints. Since the energy generated by a wind turbine can vary with environment factors, it is essential to testvoltage fluctuation and other aspects by creating simulation. Voltage fluctuation can then be predicted with different different scenarios in the simulation model. In this way, solutions can be obtained for
  • 6.
    dealing with thesituations. Building Design Urban heat island is one of the threats faced by humans nowadays. It is resulted from slower cooling rate in urban areas than rural areas. High temperature in urban areas can lead to an increase in the demand of energy for cooling purpose.As a result, vicious circleoccurs.Since the urban heat island is partly contributed by dense buildings in urban areas, especially commercial districts, buildingsshould be designed carefully considering environmental aspects. To begin with, the high density buildings in these districts usually have narrow building gaps, blocking the natural air flow and wind. Therefore, air ventilation is an important factor for making urban districts “cooler”. Without air flow bringing away the heat, the heat will be concentrated in the urban areas, which will directly increase the temperature of the whole district. Apart from ventilation,building height is another problem - high rise buildings usually block the air flowof the low rise buildings in their neighborhoods.Waterfront high rise building is a good example, which has blocked the sea breeze from flowing inland.To tackle this problem, the area plan should be designed with wider building gaps between the buildings and their neighborhoods with to allow the passage of breeze. In this way, simulation model can be used to test and predictthe air pathby inputtingpotential locationsand heights of the buildings.Hence, better locationswithsuggested heights for the new buildings can be determined with the minimal impacts on the natural air flow.Better air ventilation can thenbring away the heat in the crowded areamore effectivelyto lower the overall temperature of the entire district. Thus,less energy will be required for cooling purpose. To sum up, not only can decision makers be able to know more about the
  • 7.
    current state ofthe resources managed by them, but they can also understand the impacts of their decisions and future state of those resources. Limitations of using GIT tools and techniques for the planning of a green and low carbon city Beyond the usefulness of GIT technology in the sustainable planning design,there are several challengesand obstacles that may be faced by the planners. Firstly, the cost of data acquisition can be very high. The raster data like high resolution satellite image and aerial images are expensive products.They can contribute around 80% - 90% of the project budget. (Masters,Hirsch & Wong, 1994). After finish collecting the critical data for the project, the stageof data processing is time consuming. It is due to the fact that differentdistricts have different economic, social and environmentalelements.Hence, huge amount of spatial and non-spatial data have to be collected, which needs a large proportion of time to do the data processing throughout the project. In addition, the products of 3D animations and visualization are hardware-demanding in nature and have very large file size.If3D products are not createdand displayed inthe computers with goodhardwarequality,this may impose difficulties in creating 3D products. Theproject members may need to spend a lot of time on the stage of creating 3D models, which decrease work efficiency as a whole. Conclusion Sustainable development is an urgent issue to be addressed by our society. The effectiveness of GIT to provide tools and techniques to support the spatial analysis, decision-making and spatial display for the development project has been examined. To plan for a green and low carbon sustainable city, different
  • 8.
    policy areas shouldbe focused. Renewable energy and building design are used as the examples of how GIT assist in the planning of the development project and it is shown that tools and techniques of GIT are useful to a large extent.However, this technology has a number of limitations, which may impose challenges to the planners. To overcome the obstacles of the existing technology, more researches should be carried outto improve the efficiency of tools and techniques so that better urban planning can be achieved in the future.
  • 9.
    Reference: Cohen, B. (2005).Urbanization in developing countries: Current trends, future projections, and key challenges for sustainability. Technology in Society, 28 (2006), 63-80. Ryan, L. & Turton, H. (2007). Sustainable Automobile Transport.Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited. GIS for sustainable development (2007). Retrieved October 20, 2011 from ESRI, Web site: http://www.esri.com/library/bestpractices/sustainable-development.pdf Meadows, D. (1999). Indicators and information systems for sustainable development. In: Satterthwaite, D., ed. The Earthscan reader in sustainable cities. Earthscan, London Hardcastle, A., Waterman-Hoey, S. &Kunkle,R.(2009). Renewable Energy Industry Trends and Workforce Development in Washington State ., . Negative impacts on Wind Farms (2010). Retrieved November 4, 2011 from, Mountain Communities for Responsible Energy Web site: http://www.wvmcre.org/neg_imapcts/neg_impacts.htm Harron, S. (2008). Planning for Wind Energy in Donegal. Retrieved November 4, 2011 from Donegal County Council, Web site: http://www.donegalcoco.ie/NR/rdonlyres/21B39DE5-C26A-4885-B7AC-32206 A4F37D7/0/PlanningforWindEnergyinDonegal.pdf Martin, F., Purellku, I. & Gehlhaar, T. (2010). Modelling of and Simulation with Grid Code validated Wind Turbine Models. A submission on HK’s Climate Change Strategy & Action Agenda (2010). Retrieved October 20, 2011 from Civic Exchange, Web site: http://www.civic-exchange.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/101217Climat ePaper.pdf
  • 10.
    Masters, E., Hirsch,B. & Wong, K. (1994). GPS/GIS and Space Time Data. Retrieved November 5, 2011 from The University of New South Wales, School of Geomatic Engineering Web site: http://webone.novatel.ca/assets/Documents/Papers/File36.pdf