SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
1
INTRODUCTION
• Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) are one of
the largest and the most important sector of
Pakistan's economy.
• Approximately 3.2 million business enterprises in
Pakistan.
• Enterprises employing up to 99 persons constitute
over 90% of all private enterprises in the industrial
sector and employ nearly 78% of the non-
agriculture labor force.
• Contribute over 30% to the GDP
• 25% of exports of manufactured goods besides
sharing 35% in manufacturing value added.
2
RECOMMENDATIONS
The FPCCI Regional Standing
Committee on SME Sector for the
year 2009-2010 has made efforts
through identifying the problems
Suggesting Workable solutions
recommendations ; Some of them
are listed the next.
3
Areas like business development services
• Qualified human resources,
• Marketing and technology require
special attention to improve SMEs
competitiveness,
• Productivity and capacity for
Employment generation.
4
RECOMMENDATIONS
Separate Definition For Cottage/Micro
Industries
There is a need to separate the cottage industry From SME’s.
The Government of Pakistan should Clearly define the
minimum number of employees, which small and medium size
businesses should have. In this respect, the house
recommended the minimum limit from 51 up to 250 employees.
5
Financing policy of Banks for SME
• The banks should facilitate businesses through lending
money on easy terms & conditions. This aspect required
much more attention because businessmen having small
setup deserve facilitation in this respect to run their business
operations. The State Bank of Pakistan should formulate a
prudential regulation to facilitate the SME sector rather then
issuing an advice to banks for providing loans to SME sector
without clear instructions.
• There is a need to make suitable monitory & regulatory
policy for SME sector. It is suggested that Banks should
provide good financial assistance according to the business
requirements besides providing following facilitation to the
SME sector.
6
Some Suggestions
• Loan application processing time should be 15 days.
• SME sector should be offered 5% interest rate with one-
year grace period.
• Loan limit up to Rs. 5 million without any
collateral/guarantee should be provided to SME sector for
the period of one year. The loans may be granted up to Rs.
3 million to those, running a business for at least three
years.
• Govt. of Pakistan and Bank of Punjab should establish a
equity fund, for which at least Rs.50 million should be
allocated.
• There is a need to create a guarantee fund for SME Sector.
• In loan sanctioning process, banks should put private
sector preventatives/stakeholders on board before making
any decision.
7
Infrastructure for Industrial Estate
The Government should establish SME
industrial estate having an area not less
than 200 Kanals. It is suggested that
land for SME industrial area should be
allocated near the city area, enabling
SME sector to run their businesses
effectively and contribute their due role
in employment generation.
8
Skill Development Center/Cluster
Technology parks may be
established near the SME
industrial estates so that the
small industry may be benefited
with the facility.
9
SME FINANCE FOCUS POINTS
1. Commercial banks have to make concerted efforts to
explore new avenues of business, especially financing to
small & medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which play a
critical role in employment generation and poverty
alleviation.
2. SMEs finance play an important role in the creation of
employment opportunities with relatively lower investment
levels, it would help in reduce poverty and boost economic
growth which remains one of the prime objectives of
Government of Pakistan. 3.2 million Economic
establishments in the country around 99 percent of them
employ 1-10 persons, clearly indicating that they fall under
the definition of SMEs, more specifically lower-end SMEs.
10
SME FINANCE FOCUS POINTS:
3. Separate prudential regulations should be developed for
small enterprises as these small businesses have a huge
potential for growth compared with medium-sized
enterprises.
4. The focus of financial institutions should be on medium
entities. The reason for this skewed distribution is the
unorganized way of doing business of small entities. Major
issues faced by SMEs are lack of skilled labor, outdated
technology, weak governance, lack of management
hierarchy, absence of book keeping, taxation issues
coupled with limited access to formal sources of finance.
11
SME FINANCE FOCUS POINTS:
5. Capacity-building of banks through launch of SME Finance
Grass Root Cluster Training Program for credit officers
based in SME Clusters in Lahore, Sialkot, Gujranwala,
Rawalpindi, Peshawar, Quetta and Karachi.
6. SMEs could help to achieve diversified economic growth,
employment generation, reduction in income inequalities
and poverty alleviation in developed and the emerging
economies like USA, Japan, Malaysia, Thailand and South
Korea.
12
Challenges Faced by SME in Pakistan
1. Lack of proper infra-structure.
2. Regulatory complexities – relaxation in prudential rules and
easy access to loan.
3. Shortage of skilled manpower.
4. Quality control problems.
5. Lack of entrepreneurial expertise.
6. Shortage / irregular availability of financing facilities.
7. Shortage of equity sources.
8. Inability to meet credit criteria / credit conditions.
9. Inadequate bargaining skills / options.
10.Lengthy documentation procedure.
13
Proportion
Issues Identified Percentage
Lack of finance 55%
Shortage of skilled labour 39%
Getting business site 38%
Bribes 21%
Orders/Marketing of Product 28/%
Lack of Knowledge 12%
Government interference 12%
Raw Material 10%
License for work 08%

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Msme
MsmeMsme
Msme
 
Smeda
SmedaSmeda
Smeda
 
MSME Sector in India- An overview of the policy ecosystem
MSME Sector in India- An overview of the policy ecosystemMSME Sector in India- An overview of the policy ecosystem
MSME Sector in India- An overview of the policy ecosystem
 
Msme ppt
Msme pptMsme ppt
Msme ppt
 
Sme's
Sme'sSme's
Sme's
 
Kick starting the SME Eco system in Pakistan
Kick starting the SME Eco system in PakistanKick starting the SME Eco system in Pakistan
Kick starting the SME Eco system in Pakistan
 
Introduction to small & Medium Enterprises (SMEs)
Introduction to small & Medium Enterprises (SMEs)Introduction to small & Medium Enterprises (SMEs)
Introduction to small & Medium Enterprises (SMEs)
 
Smeda
SmedaSmeda
Smeda
 
Role of SMEs in Pakistan
Role of SMEs in PakistanRole of SMEs in Pakistan
Role of SMEs in Pakistan
 
Smeda
SmedaSmeda
Smeda
 
A study on problems and prospects of smes
A study on problems and prospects of smesA study on problems and prospects of smes
A study on problems and prospects of smes
 
Problems with SME in pakistan
Problems with SME in pakistanProblems with SME in pakistan
Problems with SME in pakistan
 
MSME'S in india
MSME'S in indiaMSME'S in india
MSME'S in india
 
sme
smesme
sme
 
MSME Financing - Key Issues and Solutions
MSME Financing - Key Issues and Solutions MSME Financing - Key Issues and Solutions
MSME Financing - Key Issues and Solutions
 
Role of sme’s in economic growth of india, SME ,MSME
Role of sme’s in economic growth of india, SME ,MSMERole of sme’s in economic growth of india, SME ,MSME
Role of sme’s in economic growth of india, SME ,MSME
 
Smeda
SmedaSmeda
Smeda
 
MSME
MSMEMSME
MSME
 
Small Medium Enterprise In Pakistan
Small Medium Enterprise In PakistanSmall Medium Enterprise In Pakistan
Small Medium Enterprise In Pakistan
 
Micro, small and medium enterprises in india
Micro, small and medium enterprises in indiaMicro, small and medium enterprises in india
Micro, small and medium enterprises in india
 

Viewers also liked

Mgt 162 SME Bank
Mgt 162 SME BankMgt 162 SME Bank
Mgt 162 SME Bankwewe lele
 
Presentation on SME Banking of Mercantile Bank Limited
Presentation on SME Banking of Mercantile Bank LimitedPresentation on SME Banking of Mercantile Bank Limited
Presentation on SME Banking of Mercantile Bank LimitedTanvir Sazzad
 
Negotiable Instrument Act 1881
Negotiable Instrument Act 1881Negotiable Instrument Act 1881
Negotiable Instrument Act 1881Dr.Aravind TS
 
Indian contract act, 1872
Indian contract act, 1872Indian contract act, 1872
Indian contract act, 1872deepu2000
 
Contract act 1872
Contract act 1872Contract act 1872
Contract act 1872butlu
 
MGT162 Assignment (POS Malaysia)
MGT162 Assignment (POS Malaysia)MGT162 Assignment (POS Malaysia)
MGT162 Assignment (POS Malaysia)Adlina Zainuri
 
Indian contract act, 1872
Indian contract act, 1872Indian contract act, 1872
Indian contract act, 1872Divyesh Chauhan
 
INDIAN CONTRACT ACT
INDIAN CONTRACT ACT INDIAN CONTRACT ACT
INDIAN CONTRACT ACT Harsh Tiwari
 
Indian contract act 1872
Indian contract act 1872Indian contract act 1872
Indian contract act 1872Deborah Sharon
 

Viewers also liked (13)

Mgt 162 SME Bank
Mgt 162 SME BankMgt 162 SME Bank
Mgt 162 SME Bank
 
Regulations
RegulationsRegulations
Regulations
 
SME BANK
SME BANKSME BANK
SME BANK
 
Presentation on SME Banking of Mercantile Bank Limited
Presentation on SME Banking of Mercantile Bank LimitedPresentation on SME Banking of Mercantile Bank Limited
Presentation on SME Banking of Mercantile Bank Limited
 
Global SME Banking
Global SME BankingGlobal SME Banking
Global SME Banking
 
Negotiable Instrument Act 1881
Negotiable Instrument Act 1881Negotiable Instrument Act 1881
Negotiable Instrument Act 1881
 
Best of SME Banking
Best of SME BankingBest of SME Banking
Best of SME Banking
 
Indian contract act, 1872
Indian contract act, 1872Indian contract act, 1872
Indian contract act, 1872
 
Contract act 1872
Contract act 1872Contract act 1872
Contract act 1872
 
MGT162 Assignment (POS Malaysia)
MGT162 Assignment (POS Malaysia)MGT162 Assignment (POS Malaysia)
MGT162 Assignment (POS Malaysia)
 
Indian contract act, 1872
Indian contract act, 1872Indian contract act, 1872
Indian contract act, 1872
 
INDIAN CONTRACT ACT
INDIAN CONTRACT ACT INDIAN CONTRACT ACT
INDIAN CONTRACT ACT
 
Indian contract act 1872
Indian contract act 1872Indian contract act 1872
Indian contract act 1872
 

Similar to Sme umt-ver1[1].0

Empowering MSMEs - Skills Development of the MSME Sector - Part - 7
Empowering MSMEs - Skills Development of the MSME Sector - Part - 7Empowering MSMEs - Skills Development of the MSME Sector - Part - 7
Empowering MSMEs - Skills Development of the MSME Sector - Part - 7Resurgent India
 
Empowering MSMEs through financing and linkages
Empowering MSMEs through financing and linkagesEmpowering MSMEs through financing and linkages
Empowering MSMEs through financing and linkagesMisbah Hussain
 
UNIT 3.pdf..............................
UNIT 3.pdf..............................UNIT 3.pdf..............................
UNIT 3.pdf..............................MalkeetSingh85
 
Entrepreneurship Development: Unit No. 3
Entrepreneurship Development: Unit No. 3Entrepreneurship Development: Unit No. 3
Entrepreneurship Development: Unit No. 3amitsethi21985
 
Role of sme’s in the socio-economic stability of KPK & FATA
Role of sme’s in the socio-economic stability of KPK & FATARole of sme’s in the socio-economic stability of KPK & FATA
Role of sme’s in the socio-economic stability of KPK & FATAWaqar Noor
 
Eco term paper
Eco term paperEco term paper
Eco term papershimubd
 
Sme developing role
Sme developing roleSme developing role
Sme developing roleAamir Sohail
 
entrepreneurship and small business management unit iii
entrepreneurship and small business management unit iiientrepreneurship and small business management unit iii
entrepreneurship and small business management unit iiiPENDYSINGH
 
Small and Medium Enterprise In Malaysia MBA OUM
Small and Medium Enterprise In Malaysia MBA OUMSmall and Medium Enterprise In Malaysia MBA OUM
Small and Medium Enterprise In Malaysia MBA OUMShah Sheikh
 
Govt. policy programmes for entrepreneurship development
Govt. policy programmes for entrepreneurship developmentGovt. policy programmes for entrepreneurship development
Govt. policy programmes for entrepreneurship developmentMita Meher
 
All that you must know about MSME Registration.
All that you must know about MSME Registration.All that you must know about MSME Registration.
All that you must know about MSME Registration.Estartupindia.com
 
MSME - All you need to know about this sector
MSME - All you need to know about this sectorMSME - All you need to know about this sector
MSME - All you need to know about this sectorshubhadeep saha
 
Msme indian eco
Msme indian ecoMsme indian eco
Msme indian ecoKowsarAli2
 

Similar to Sme umt-ver1[1].0 (20)

Empowering MSMEs - Skills Development of the MSME Sector - Part - 7
Empowering MSMEs - Skills Development of the MSME Sector - Part - 7Empowering MSMEs - Skills Development of the MSME Sector - Part - 7
Empowering MSMEs - Skills Development of the MSME Sector - Part - 7
 
Empowering MSMEs through financing and linkages
Empowering MSMEs through financing and linkagesEmpowering MSMEs through financing and linkages
Empowering MSMEs through financing and linkages
 
UNIT 3.pdf..............................
UNIT 3.pdf..............................UNIT 3.pdf..............................
UNIT 3.pdf..............................
 
Entrepreneurship Development: Unit No. 3
Entrepreneurship Development: Unit No. 3Entrepreneurship Development: Unit No. 3
Entrepreneurship Development: Unit No. 3
 
Satyaveer
SatyaveerSatyaveer
Satyaveer
 
Role of sme’s in the socio-economic stability of KPK & FATA
Role of sme’s in the socio-economic stability of KPK & FATARole of sme’s in the socio-economic stability of KPK & FATA
Role of sme’s in the socio-economic stability of KPK & FATA
 
Esbd unit iii
Esbd unit iiiEsbd unit iii
Esbd unit iii
 
MSMEs IN INDIA
 MSMEs IN INDIA MSMEs IN INDIA
MSMEs IN INDIA
 
Medium, Small and Micro enterprises MSM
Medium, Small and Micro enterprises MSMMedium, Small and Micro enterprises MSM
Medium, Small and Micro enterprises MSM
 
Eco term paper
Eco term paperEco term paper
Eco term paper
 
Sme developing role
Sme developing roleSme developing role
Sme developing role
 
entrepreneurship and small business management unit iii
entrepreneurship and small business management unit iiientrepreneurship and small business management unit iii
entrepreneurship and small business management unit iii
 
Small and Medium Enterprise In Malaysia MBA OUM
Small and Medium Enterprise In Malaysia MBA OUMSmall and Medium Enterprise In Malaysia MBA OUM
Small and Medium Enterprise In Malaysia MBA OUM
 
Govt. policy programmes for entrepreneurship development
Govt. policy programmes for entrepreneurship developmentGovt. policy programmes for entrepreneurship development
Govt. policy programmes for entrepreneurship development
 
CII Policy Watch - MSME
CII Policy Watch - MSMECII Policy Watch - MSME
CII Policy Watch - MSME
 
CII Policy Watch: MSME
CII Policy Watch: MSMECII Policy Watch: MSME
CII Policy Watch: MSME
 
All that you must know about MSME Registration.
All that you must know about MSME Registration.All that you must know about MSME Registration.
All that you must know about MSME Registration.
 
MSME - All you need to know about this sector
MSME - All you need to know about this sectorMSME - All you need to know about this sector
MSME - All you need to know about this sector
 
Msme indian eco
Msme indian ecoMsme indian eco
Msme indian eco
 
MSME
MSMEMSME
MSME
 

More from Naeem Hassan

Introduction to computing
Introduction to computingIntroduction to computing
Introduction to computingNaeem Hassan
 
Perception and Decision Making in Organizations
Perception and Decision Making in OrganizationsPerception and Decision Making in Organizations
Perception and Decision Making in OrganizationsNaeem Hassan
 
Individual Behavior and Learning in business/ Organizations
Individual Behavior and Learning in business/ OrganizationsIndividual Behavior and Learning in business/ Organizations
Individual Behavior and Learning in business/ OrganizationsNaeem Hassan
 
Psychological development in middle childhood
Psychological development in middle childhood Psychological development in middle childhood
Psychological development in middle childhood Naeem Hassan
 
Sustainable fisheries policy and coastal resources management
Sustainable fisheries policy and coastal resources managementSustainable fisheries policy and coastal resources management
Sustainable fisheries policy and coastal resources managementNaeem Hassan
 
Suggestions to government for improving livestock sector
Suggestions to government for improving livestock sectorSuggestions to government for improving livestock sector
Suggestions to government for improving livestock sectorNaeem Hassan
 
Prezentation on pak energy
Prezentation on pak energyPrezentation on pak energy
Prezentation on pak energyNaeem Hassan
 
Comparative eco system
Comparative eco systemComparative eco system
Comparative eco systemNaeem Hassan
 
Land reform in pakistan
Land reform in pakistanLand reform in pakistan
Land reform in pakistanNaeem Hassan
 
Agriculture schemes
Agriculture schemesAgriculture schemes
Agriculture schemesNaeem Hassan
 
Agriculture credit
Agriculture creditAgriculture credit
Agriculture creditNaeem Hassan
 
Sada bahar scheme (sbs)
Sada bahar scheme (sbs)Sada bahar scheme (sbs)
Sada bahar scheme (sbs)Naeem Hassan
 
Money & credit (zohaib & zulfiqar)
Money & credit (zohaib & zulfiqar)Money & credit (zohaib & zulfiqar)
Money & credit (zohaib & zulfiqar)Naeem Hassan
 
Pakistan infrastructure
Pakistan infrastructurePakistan infrastructure
Pakistan infrastructureNaeem Hassan
 
Generalization and example
Generalization and exampleGeneralization and example
Generalization and exampleNaeem Hassan
 
Generalizations concepts
Generalizations conceptsGeneralizations concepts
Generalizations conceptsNaeem Hassan
 

More from Naeem Hassan (20)

Introduction to computing
Introduction to computingIntroduction to computing
Introduction to computing
 
Perception and Decision Making in Organizations
Perception and Decision Making in OrganizationsPerception and Decision Making in Organizations
Perception and Decision Making in Organizations
 
Individual Behavior and Learning in business/ Organizations
Individual Behavior and Learning in business/ OrganizationsIndividual Behavior and Learning in business/ Organizations
Individual Behavior and Learning in business/ Organizations
 
Psychological development in middle childhood
Psychological development in middle childhood Psychological development in middle childhood
Psychological development in middle childhood
 
Family
FamilyFamily
Family
 
Sustainable fisheries policy and coastal resources management
Sustainable fisheries policy and coastal resources managementSustainable fisheries policy and coastal resources management
Sustainable fisheries policy and coastal resources management
 
Suggestions to government for improving livestock sector
Suggestions to government for improving livestock sectorSuggestions to government for improving livestock sector
Suggestions to government for improving livestock sector
 
Prezentation on pak energy
Prezentation on pak energyPrezentation on pak energy
Prezentation on pak energy
 
Comparative eco system
Comparative eco systemComparative eco system
Comparative eco system
 
Livestock
LivestockLivestock
Livestock
 
Land reform in pakistan
Land reform in pakistanLand reform in pakistan
Land reform in pakistan
 
Trade & payment
Trade & paymentTrade & payment
Trade & payment
 
Agriculture schemes
Agriculture schemesAgriculture schemes
Agriculture schemes
 
Agriculture credit
Agriculture creditAgriculture credit
Agriculture credit
 
Sada bahar scheme (sbs)
Sada bahar scheme (sbs)Sada bahar scheme (sbs)
Sada bahar scheme (sbs)
 
Money & credit (zohaib & zulfiqar)
Money & credit (zohaib & zulfiqar)Money & credit (zohaib & zulfiqar)
Money & credit (zohaib & zulfiqar)
 
Pakistan infrastructure
Pakistan infrastructurePakistan infrastructure
Pakistan infrastructure
 
Generalization and example
Generalization and exampleGeneralization and example
Generalization and example
 
Generalize
GeneralizeGeneralize
Generalize
 
Generalizations concepts
Generalizations conceptsGeneralizations concepts
Generalizations concepts
 

Sme umt-ver1[1].0

  • 1. 1 INTRODUCTION • Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) are one of the largest and the most important sector of Pakistan's economy. • Approximately 3.2 million business enterprises in Pakistan. • Enterprises employing up to 99 persons constitute over 90% of all private enterprises in the industrial sector and employ nearly 78% of the non- agriculture labor force. • Contribute over 30% to the GDP • 25% of exports of manufactured goods besides sharing 35% in manufacturing value added.
  • 2. 2 RECOMMENDATIONS The FPCCI Regional Standing Committee on SME Sector for the year 2009-2010 has made efforts through identifying the problems Suggesting Workable solutions recommendations ; Some of them are listed the next.
  • 3. 3 Areas like business development services • Qualified human resources, • Marketing and technology require special attention to improve SMEs competitiveness, • Productivity and capacity for Employment generation.
  • 4. 4 RECOMMENDATIONS Separate Definition For Cottage/Micro Industries There is a need to separate the cottage industry From SME’s. The Government of Pakistan should Clearly define the minimum number of employees, which small and medium size businesses should have. In this respect, the house recommended the minimum limit from 51 up to 250 employees.
  • 5. 5 Financing policy of Banks for SME • The banks should facilitate businesses through lending money on easy terms & conditions. This aspect required much more attention because businessmen having small setup deserve facilitation in this respect to run their business operations. The State Bank of Pakistan should formulate a prudential regulation to facilitate the SME sector rather then issuing an advice to banks for providing loans to SME sector without clear instructions. • There is a need to make suitable monitory & regulatory policy for SME sector. It is suggested that Banks should provide good financial assistance according to the business requirements besides providing following facilitation to the SME sector.
  • 6. 6 Some Suggestions • Loan application processing time should be 15 days. • SME sector should be offered 5% interest rate with one- year grace period. • Loan limit up to Rs. 5 million without any collateral/guarantee should be provided to SME sector for the period of one year. The loans may be granted up to Rs. 3 million to those, running a business for at least three years. • Govt. of Pakistan and Bank of Punjab should establish a equity fund, for which at least Rs.50 million should be allocated. • There is a need to create a guarantee fund for SME Sector. • In loan sanctioning process, banks should put private sector preventatives/stakeholders on board before making any decision.
  • 7. 7 Infrastructure for Industrial Estate The Government should establish SME industrial estate having an area not less than 200 Kanals. It is suggested that land for SME industrial area should be allocated near the city area, enabling SME sector to run their businesses effectively and contribute their due role in employment generation.
  • 8. 8 Skill Development Center/Cluster Technology parks may be established near the SME industrial estates so that the small industry may be benefited with the facility.
  • 9. 9 SME FINANCE FOCUS POINTS 1. Commercial banks have to make concerted efforts to explore new avenues of business, especially financing to small & medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which play a critical role in employment generation and poverty alleviation. 2. SMEs finance play an important role in the creation of employment opportunities with relatively lower investment levels, it would help in reduce poverty and boost economic growth which remains one of the prime objectives of Government of Pakistan. 3.2 million Economic establishments in the country around 99 percent of them employ 1-10 persons, clearly indicating that they fall under the definition of SMEs, more specifically lower-end SMEs.
  • 10. 10 SME FINANCE FOCUS POINTS: 3. Separate prudential regulations should be developed for small enterprises as these small businesses have a huge potential for growth compared with medium-sized enterprises. 4. The focus of financial institutions should be on medium entities. The reason for this skewed distribution is the unorganized way of doing business of small entities. Major issues faced by SMEs are lack of skilled labor, outdated technology, weak governance, lack of management hierarchy, absence of book keeping, taxation issues coupled with limited access to formal sources of finance.
  • 11. 11 SME FINANCE FOCUS POINTS: 5. Capacity-building of banks through launch of SME Finance Grass Root Cluster Training Program for credit officers based in SME Clusters in Lahore, Sialkot, Gujranwala, Rawalpindi, Peshawar, Quetta and Karachi. 6. SMEs could help to achieve diversified economic growth, employment generation, reduction in income inequalities and poverty alleviation in developed and the emerging economies like USA, Japan, Malaysia, Thailand and South Korea.
  • 12. 12 Challenges Faced by SME in Pakistan 1. Lack of proper infra-structure. 2. Regulatory complexities – relaxation in prudential rules and easy access to loan. 3. Shortage of skilled manpower. 4. Quality control problems. 5. Lack of entrepreneurial expertise. 6. Shortage / irregular availability of financing facilities. 7. Shortage of equity sources. 8. Inability to meet credit criteria / credit conditions. 9. Inadequate bargaining skills / options. 10.Lengthy documentation procedure.
  • 13. 13 Proportion Issues Identified Percentage Lack of finance 55% Shortage of skilled labour 39% Getting business site 38% Bribes 21% Orders/Marketing of Product 28/% Lack of Knowledge 12% Government interference 12% Raw Material 10% License for work 08%