1111  Lincoln  Road                                      PAM.  Artful  Living.                                                                                                                NWS  &  Park.  Moris  Moreno  for  the  NYT     UNIVERSITY  OF  MIAMI     ARC  122:  Architecture  Theory  II   SPRING  2016   Professor  Frank  Martinez     Final  Assignment:    Experiencing,  Thinking  and  Reflecting  on  Excellence  in  Architecture     ASSIGNMENT     Select  one  (1)  building  from  the  list  below  of  three  (3)  recent,  locally  built  projects  and  write  a   short  Paper  centering  on  why  the  work  of  Architecture  supports  and  demonstrates  notions  on   the relationship between human needs, behavior, cultural diversity, social equity, and professional judgment and responsibility in design. Your criticism shall include an analysis of the building’s context and relationship with public and private spaces. You shall support your analysis by using the selected and listed Ethical  Canons  and  Standards.  Only   use  those  applicable  and  deemed  appropriate  to  your  building.  These  canons  and  standards  will   serve,  as  a  conceptual  framework,  to  construct  a  convincing  claim.     The  paper  should  be  between  650  –  750  words  (double  spaced  using  Times  New  Roman  font)   and  follow  the  MLA  format  outlined  below.  Choose  and  analyze  the  building  first  as  it  relates  to   your  observed  correspondence  with  some  of  the  ethics  criteria  described  herein,  class  lectures   topics  and  referential  readings  reserved  at  the  library.  It  is  important  to  formulate  an  objective   appraisal   and   to   demonstrate   how   the   design   resulted   in   a   critical,   responsible   and   accomplished  work,  which  contributes  to  the  building  of  place  and  for  the  good  of  the  client,   society,  and  the  public.       A   brief   description   of   each   building   is   included.   These   are   very   different   building   projects   ranging  from  private  development  to  civic  institution.  Please  familiarize  yourself  with  the  3   buildings   and   select   one   that   both   interests   and   inspires   you   to   investigate   further.   Thoughtfully  integrate  values  from  the  Ethical  Canons  and  Standards  as  applie ...

1. 1111
Lincoln
Road
PAM.
Artful
Living.

3. NWS
&
Park.
Moris
Moreno
for
the
NYT
UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI
ARC 122: Architecture Theory II
SPRING 2016
Professor Frank Martinez
Final
Assignment:
Experiencing,
Thinking

4. and
Reflecting
on
Excellence
in
Architecture
ASSIGNMENT
Select
one
(1)
building
from
the
list
below
of
three
(3)
recent,
locally
built
projects
and
write
a
short
Paper
centering
on
why
the

5. work
of
Architecture
supports
and
demonstrates
notions
on
the relationship between human needs, behavior, cultural
diversity, social equity, and
professional judgment and responsibility in design. Your
criticism shall include an
analysis of the building’s context and relationship with public
and private spaces. You
shall support your analysis by using the selected and listed
Ethical
Canons
and
Standards.
Only
use
those
applicable
and
deemed
appropriate
to
your
building.
These
canons
and
standards
will

6. serve,
as
a
conceptual
framework,
to
construct
a
convincing
claim.
The
paper
should
be
between
650
–
750
words
(double
spaced
using
Times
New
Roman
font)
and
follow
the
MLA
format

7. outlined
below.
Choose
and
analyze
the
building
first
as
it
relates
to
your
observed
correspondence
with
some
of
the
ethics
criteria
described
herein,
class
lectures
topics
and
referential
readings
reserved
at
the
library.
It

8. is
important
to
formulate
an
objective
appraisal
and
to
demonstrate
how
the
design
resulted
in
a
critical,
responsible
and
accomplished
work,
which
contributes
to
the
building
of
place
and
for
the
good
of
the

9. client,
society,
and
the
public.
A
brief
description
of
each
building
is
included.
These
are
very
different
building
projects
ranging
from
private
development
to
civic
institution.
Please
familiarize
yourself
with

10. the
3
buildings
and
select
one
that
both
interests
and
inspires
you
to
investigate
further.
Thoughtfully
integrate
values
from
the
Ethical
Canons
and
Standards
as
applied
in
the
design.
A
site
visit
is

11. required
to
experience
the
architecture
and
to
establish
the
principles
to
classify,
compare,
summarize,
explain
and/or
interpret
in
your
assessment
of
the
building.
Document
your
observations
in
the
form
of
notes,
photographs
and
sketches.

12. You
may
also
want
to
use
found
documentation
drawings
of
the
building
along
with
your
own
sketches
and
photographs
as
illustrations
to
support
your
analysis.
BUILDINGS: *referenced books on reserve (available
at the front desk of SoA library)
1111 LINCOLN ROAD

13. Architects Herzog & de Meuron
Location 11 11 Lincoln Road, Miami Beach, FL,
USA
Area 300 parking spaces + sq. ft.
Project Year 2010
When local developer Robert Wennett bought the adjacent
1968 Brutalist office building and
reimagined what could be done on its surface parking
lot, 11 11 Lincoln Rd became much
more than just another parking garage. After
interviewing many internationally recognized
architects, the local developer selected Herzog & de
Meuron to lead the design of the $65MM
unique shopping, dining, residential and parking
experience. As Miami’s premier urban
lifestyle destination, 11 11 features a curated collection of
international retailers and fine fare
hotspots at its base1. The 7th floor of this open air
structure is often rented for corporate and
private events; the “garage” has become a destination
for architects, photographers and
tourists to visit.
PEREZ ART MUSEUM MIAMI
Architects Herzog & de Meuron
Location Pérez Art Museum Miami, 1103 Biscayne
Blvd, Miami, FL 33130, USA
Area 119,750 sq. ft.
Project Year 2013
Link http://www.pamm.org/about/building

14. Forming part of the redeveloping downtown waterfront
on Biscayne Bay , the Pérez Art
Museum Miami (PAMM) is located in Museum Park. It
was formerly located in Downtown and
known as the Miami Art Museum until 2013 when, under
the leadership of director Terence
Riley, plans were made by Swiss architects Herzog &
de Meuron and the museum was
relocated. To achieve this, the MAM entered into a
public-­‐private partnership (PPP) with the
City of Miami and Miami-­‐Dade County. The City
provided the land, the County voters provided
$100MM through bonds, and another $120MM were
raised from private donors. The
museum was controversially renamed after a generous
gift from The Related Group’s
developer Mr. Jorge Perez. Its direct neighbors are the 20
acre Museum Park, the Patricia and
Phillip Frost Museum of Science (under construction)
and a major freeway, connecting
mainland Miami with Miami Beach. Simultaneously
oriented towards the park, the water and
the city, the new PAMM is an open and inviting structure
from all sides alike.2

16. 1 "About." 11 11. Web. 24 Mar. 2016.
2 "Perez Art Museum / Herzog & De Meuron." ArchDaily.
07 Apr. 2014. Web. 21 Mar. 2016.
NEW WORLD CENTER + PARK
Frank Gehry
500 17th Street, Miami Beach, FL, USA
756
Architect
Location
Capacity
Project Year 2011
Located a block north of Lincoln Rd., the new home of
the New World Symphony also features a
2.5 acre public park designed by West 8. On this
park, a SoundScape area allows people to
experience, live and free, many of the events happening
inside the concert hall through the use

17. of audio-­‐visual technology on a 7,000 sq. ft. projection
wall. The building itself is a unique post-­‐
graduate orchestral academy, a musical laboratory for
generating new ideas about the way
music is taught, experienced and presented.3 The 100,641
sq. ft. building cost approximately
$160MM. Of that, $25MM came from Miami Dade
County, $15MM from the City of Miami
Beach, and the rest from private donations and the sale of
the New World Symphony’s previous
home, the Lincoln Theater (which now features the H&M
store).
BIBLIOGRAPHY (IN RESERVE AT THE LIBRARY)
For the Perez Art Museum
Work
in
Progress
:
Herzog
&
De
Meuron's
Miami
Art
Museum
Miami
:
Miami
Art
Museum,
2008.

18. For 1111 Lincoln Rd.
1111
Lincoln
Road
=
1111
Lincoln
Road:
2005-­‐2010
Miami
Beach
(EE
UU
/
USA)
[Herzog
&
de
Meuron]
For the New World Symphony & West 8 Park
Casabella,
2011
Jan.,
v.75,
n.797,
p.88-­‐99
Axonometric
drawings,
photographs,
sections,
plans

19. 3 "Overview | New World Symphony." Overview | New
World Symphony. Web. 27 Mar. 2016.
CODE OF ETHICS & PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT
Members
of
The
AIA
are
dedicated
to
the
highest
standards
of
professionalism,
integrity,
and
competence.
The
Code
is
arranged
in
3
tiers
of
statements:

20. Canons,
Ethical
Standards,
and
Rules
of
Conduct:
• Canons
are
broad
principles
of
conduct
• Ethical
Standards
(E.S.)
are
more
specific
goals
towards
which
members
should
aspire
• Rules
are
mandatory;
violation
of

21. a
Rule
is
grounds
for
disciplinary
action
CANON
I
-­‐
GENERAL
OBLIGATIONS
Members
should
maintain
and
advance
their
knowledge
of
the
art
and
science
of
architecture,

22. respect
the
body
of
architectural
accomplishment,
contribute
to
its
growth,
thoughtfully
consider
the
social
and
environmental
impact
of
their
professional
activities,
and
exercise
learned
and
uncompromised
professional
judgment.
E.S.
1.2:

23. Standards
of
Excellence
Members
should
continually
seek
to
raise
the
standards
of
aesthetic
excellence,
architectural
education,
research,
training,
and
practice.
E.S.
1.3:
Knowledge
and
Skill
Members
should
respect
and

24. help
conserve
their
natural
and
cultural
heritage
while
striving
to
improve
the
environment
and
the
quality
of
life
within
it.
E.S.
1.4:
Human
Rights
Members
should
uphold
human
rights
in
all

25. their
professional
endeavors.
E.S.
1.5:
Allied
Arts
&
Industries
Members
should
promote
allied
arts
and
contribute
to
the
knowledge
and
capability
of
the
building
industries
as
a
whole.

26. CANON
II
-­‐
OBLIGATIONS
TO
THE
PUBLIC
Members
should
embrace
the
spirit
and
letter
of
the
law
governing
their
professional
affairs
and
should
promote
and
serve
the
public
interest
in

27. their
personal
and
professional
activities.
E.S.
2.3:
Civic
Responsibility
Members
should
be
involved
in
civic
activities
as
citizens
and
professionals,
and
should
strive
to
improve
public
appreciation
and
understanding
of
architecture

28. and
the
functions
and
responsibilities
of
architects.
CANON
VI
-­‐
OBLIGATIONS
TO
THE
ENVIRONMENT
Members
should
promote
sustainable
design
and
development
principles
in
their
professional

29. activities.
E.S.
6.1:
Sustainable
Design
In
performing
design
work,
Members
should
be
environmentally
responsible
and
advocate
sustainable
building
and
site
design.
E.S.
6.2:
Sustainable
Development
In

30. performing
professional
services,
Members
should
advocate
the
design,
construction,
and
operation
of
sustainable
buildings
and
communities.
FORMAT
The
paper
shall
follow
the
MLA
format
and
include:

31. • Format:
1
inch
margins;
double
spaced;
12-­‐point
font.
• Page
Header
(name
and
page
number,
upper
right
of
every
page)
• Title
Page
(
with
assignment
info
and
an
informative
title)
• Citations

32. • Works
Cited
List
If
you
have
format
questions
please
consult
your
library
website:
https://library.miami.edu/citation-­‐style-­‐guides/
Additionally,
you
are
encouraged
to
use
the
following
references:

33. A
“visual”
guide
to
MLA
format:
https://owl.english.purdue.edu/media/pdf/20090701095636_747.
pdf
MLA
Format
Papers:
Step-­‐by-­‐step
Instructions
for
Writing
Research
Essays:
http://jerz.setonhill.edu/writing/academic1/mla-­‐style-­‐papers/
DETAILS
Papers

34. will
be
due
by
Monday,
April
11th
and
shall
be
uploaded
onto
your
Blackboard
site
using
the
following
title:
ARC
122_Final
Assignment_LastName_FirstName.
If
you
should
have
any
questions
about
this

35. assignment
please
feel
free
to
contact
Professor
Frank
Martinez
at
[email protected]
or
Victor
Chavez
at
[email protected]