Hierarchy of Skills

Hierarchy of Skills
I. Kokcharov
Invent
Solve
Work
Play
Know
Self-actualization
Esteem
Love / Belonging
Safety
Physiological
morality,
creativity,
spontaneity,
problem solving,
lack of prejudice,
acceptance of failure
self-esteem,
confidence, achievement,
respect of others, respect by others
friendship, family, sexual intimacy
security of body, of employment, of resources,
of morality, of the family, of health, of property
breathing, food, water, sex, sleep, hemostasis, excretion
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs [1]
Abraham Maslow
Picture: source Wikipedia
Mission
Mastery
Member
Myself
Money
Creating value
for others
self-improvement,
achievement
Member of a team
Originality + performance
Earning for personal needs
Work Motivation: M5-model I. Kokcharov © 2015
Skills
Skill is an ability, coming from one’s knowledge,
practice, aptitude to do something well.
Invent
Solve
Work
Play
Know
creating
new knowledge,
skills, products,
service; leadership
creative use of skills
to resolve problems
purposeful use of knowledge
motivational use of knowledge
acquiring basic knowledge
Hierarchy of Skills I. Kokcharov © 2015
Craftsman
Expert
Specialist
Apprentice
Student
Multi-level mix
Example :
business simulations [3]
 “The craftsman represents the special human condition of being engaged.” [4]
 “By one commonly used measure, about ten thousand hours of experience are
required to produce a master carpenter or musician.” [4]
Craftsman
2%
 Maslow said only 2% of people reached the stage of self-actualization.
 The same percentage can be attributed to the highest level of the Skill Hierarchy.
Craftsman is rare species
Competence
Competence is the condition of being capable;
possession of required skill, knowledge,
qualification, or capacity.
Hierarchy of Competence Adapted from Noel Burch [5]
Unconscious
Competence Right Intuition
Right Analysis
Wrong Analysis
Wrong Intuition
Conscious
Competence
Conscious
Incompetence
Unconscious
Incompetence
Learning by Doing
Participating
Receiving
To work
with a coach,
Immediate
practicing
Play
Exercises,
Discussion,
Demonstration
Audiovisual
Reading
Lecture
Retention of Learning I. Kokcharov © 2015
> 75%
20% - 75%
<20%
Needs
Safety
Physiological
Self-
actualization
Esteem
Love / Belonging
Work Motivation
Myself
Money
Mission
Mastery
Member
Invent
Solve
Work
Play
Know
Skills
Receiving
Participating
Learning
by Doing
Learning Retention Wrong Intuition
Wrong Analysis
Right Analysis
Right
Intuition
Competence
1. Maslow A.H. A Theory of Human Motivation http://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Maslow/motivation.htm
2. Kokcharov I. What motivates us to work hard?
https://aplusclick.wordpress.com/2013/01/06/what-motivates-us-to-work-hard/
3. Kokcharov I. Using Business Simulation to Analyze Project Management Decision Making. Proceeding of
45th International Simulation and Game Association Conference, Dornbirn, Austria, 2014, p.313-318.
ISBN: 978-3-7639-5420-9
4. Sennett R. The Craftsman. 2008. Penguin Books ISBN 978-0-141-02209-3
5. Noel Burch cited at Wikipedia «Four Stages of Competence»
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_stages_of_competence
6. Dreyfus S.E., Dreyfus H.L. "A Five-Stage Model of the Mental Activities Involved in Directed Skill
Acquisition" 1980
Bibliography
1 of 13

Recommended

Developing mentoring program by
Developing mentoring programDeveloping mentoring program
Developing mentoring programSeta Wicaksana
34.3K views65 slides
Mentoring Presentation by
Mentoring PresentationMentoring Presentation
Mentoring Presentationkp361
5.3K views7 slides
MENTORING POWERPOINT by
MENTORING POWERPOINTMENTORING POWERPOINT
MENTORING POWERPOINTAndrew Schwartz
80.2K views14 slides
How to Create a Competency-Based Training Program by
How to Create a Competency-Based Training ProgramHow to Create a Competency-Based Training Program
How to Create a Competency-Based Training ProgramBizLibrary
54.6K views33 slides
Mentoring main by
Mentoring mainMentoring main
Mentoring mainPrashant Mehta
6.6K views22 slides
Mentoring Presentation 1 by
Mentoring Presentation 1Mentoring Presentation 1
Mentoring Presentation 1education department Balochistan
3K views9 slides

More Related Content

What's hot

Performance coaching n mentoring by
Performance coaching n mentoringPerformance coaching n mentoring
Performance coaching n mentoringSanjay Bhattacharya
1.9K views30 slides
Working with Emotional Intelligence by
Working with Emotional IntelligenceWorking with Emotional Intelligence
Working with Emotional IntelligenceGMR Group
53.9K views138 slides
Self-Awareness: the key to leadership effectiveness by
Self-Awareness: the key to leadership effectiveness Self-Awareness: the key to leadership effectiveness
Self-Awareness: the key to leadership effectiveness Sandra Sieb
1.4K views15 slides
Launching an Effective Mentoring Program by
Launching an Effective Mentoring ProgramLaunching an Effective Mentoring Program
Launching an Effective Mentoring ProgramDebby McNichols
28.5K views35 slides
Career Advice Presentation by
Career Advice PresentationCareer Advice Presentation
Career Advice PresentationRaheem Cardwell
2.8K views10 slides
Train the trainer by
Train the trainerTrain the trainer
Train the trainerRooprajinder Singh
33.9K views64 slides

What's hot(20)

Working with Emotional Intelligence by GMR Group
Working with Emotional IntelligenceWorking with Emotional Intelligence
Working with Emotional Intelligence
GMR Group53.9K views
Self-Awareness: the key to leadership effectiveness by Sandra Sieb
Self-Awareness: the key to leadership effectiveness Self-Awareness: the key to leadership effectiveness
Self-Awareness: the key to leadership effectiveness
Sandra Sieb1.4K views
Launching an Effective Mentoring Program by Debby McNichols
Launching an Effective Mentoring ProgramLaunching an Effective Mentoring Program
Launching an Effective Mentoring Program
Debby McNichols28.5K views
10 Steps to Building Better Relationships in Your Network by Change Grow Achieve
10 Steps to Building Better Relationships in Your Network10 Steps to Building Better Relationships in Your Network
10 Steps to Building Better Relationships in Your Network
Change Grow Achieve3.2K views
Teamwork For Good Work by Like A Team
Teamwork For Good WorkTeamwork For Good Work
Teamwork For Good Work
Like A Team2.6K views
5 Tips for Effective Leadership by Maria Pantalone
5 Tips for Effective Leadership5 Tips for Effective Leadership
5 Tips for Effective Leadership
Maria Pantalone1.4K views
Career guidance by jogajosh
Career guidanceCareer guidance
Career guidance
jogajosh37.3K views
Career counselling in pakistan by zuhra jalal
Career counselling in pakistanCareer counselling in pakistan
Career counselling in pakistan
zuhra jalal4.3K views
Learning & Development by m.dubucq
Learning & DevelopmentLearning & Development
Learning & Development
m.dubucq28.3K views
Coaching skills by Gia Tri Tien
Coaching skillsCoaching skills
Coaching skills
Gia Tri Tien20.9K views
Professional Development by Mariana Porta
Professional Development Professional Development
Professional Development
Mariana Porta13.1K views
Value Of Mentoring by Nancy Zentis
Value Of MentoringValue Of Mentoring
Value Of Mentoring
Nancy Zentis9.3K views

Similar to Hierarchy of Skills

OB - Individual Differences by
OB - Individual DifferencesOB - Individual Differences
OB - Individual DifferencesJon R Wallace
6.1K views33 slides
BA 15 Chapter 4 by
BA 15 Chapter 4BA 15 Chapter 4
BA 15 Chapter 4dpd
2.2K views39 slides
Motivation (2) by
Motivation (2)Motivation (2)
Motivation (2)Nanda Palit
4.2K views62 slides
Self concept, personality, abilities, and emotions by
Self concept, personality, abilities, and emotionsSelf concept, personality, abilities, and emotions
Self concept, personality, abilities, and emotionsadi
8.2K views39 slides
The Coaching Presentation by
The Coaching PresentationThe Coaching Presentation
The Coaching PresentationAlbert Tobler
700 views54 slides
Self awareness skills by
Self awareness skillsSelf awareness skills
Self awareness skillsDrAbey Thomas
34K views124 slides

Similar to Hierarchy of Skills (20)

OB - Individual Differences by Jon R Wallace
OB - Individual DifferencesOB - Individual Differences
OB - Individual Differences
Jon R Wallace6.1K views
BA 15 Chapter 4 by dpd
BA 15 Chapter 4BA 15 Chapter 4
BA 15 Chapter 4
dpd2.2K views
Motivation (2) by Nanda Palit
Motivation (2)Motivation (2)
Motivation (2)
Nanda Palit4.2K views
Self concept, personality, abilities, and emotions by adi
Self concept, personality, abilities, and emotionsSelf concept, personality, abilities, and emotions
Self concept, personality, abilities, and emotions
adi 8.2K views
The Coaching Presentation by Albert Tobler
The Coaching PresentationThe Coaching Presentation
The Coaching Presentation
Albert Tobler700 views
Managing Oneself & Reflective Practices by Naomi Smith
Managing Oneself & Reflective PracticesManaging Oneself & Reflective Practices
Managing Oneself & Reflective Practices
Naomi Smith6.5K views
Motivation of employees by KharimBeine
Motivation of employeesMotivation of employees
Motivation of employees
KharimBeine23 views
Self-Management Practices in Companies by Coacharya
Self-Management Practices in Companies Self-Management Practices in Companies
Self-Management Practices in Companies
Coacharya404 views
Every Moment Counts by Marilyn Way
Every Moment Counts Every Moment Counts
Every Moment Counts
Marilyn Way403 views
Motivation and Organizational Behaviour by Muhammad Awais
Motivation and Organizational BehaviourMotivation and Organizational Behaviour
Motivation and Organizational Behaviour
Muhammad Awais2.7K views
Motivation by Deep Das
MotivationMotivation
Motivation
Deep Das970 views
Pro development for soft skill by Htain Lin Kyaw
Pro development for soft skillPro development for soft skill
Pro development for soft skill
Htain Lin Kyaw620 views
Olivia Liddell - Southeast PHP 2018 - Overcoming Your Fear of Failure by OliviaLiddell
Olivia Liddell - Southeast PHP 2018 - Overcoming Your Fear of FailureOlivia Liddell - Southeast PHP 2018 - Overcoming Your Fear of Failure
Olivia Liddell - Southeast PHP 2018 - Overcoming Your Fear of Failure
OliviaLiddell241 views

More from Igor Kokcharov

Job Interview Puzzles 2022 by
Job Interview Puzzles 2022Job Interview Puzzles 2022
Job Interview Puzzles 2022Igor Kokcharov
1.3K views25 slides
The Funniest Aplusclick Brainteasers by
The Funniest Aplusclick BrainteasersThe Funniest Aplusclick Brainteasers
The Funniest Aplusclick BrainteasersIgor Kokcharov
1.7K views41 slides
Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2020 by
Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2020Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2020
Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2020Igor Kokcharov
2K views24 slides
Geek Quotes by
Geek QuotesGeek Quotes
Geek QuotesIgor Kokcharov
194 views14 slides
Gerry Geek Wisdom by
Gerry Geek WisdomGerry Geek Wisdom
Gerry Geek WisdomIgor Kokcharov
224 views14 slides
Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2019 by
Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2019Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2019
Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2019Igor Kokcharov
1.6K views29 slides

More from Igor Kokcharov(20)

Job Interview Puzzles 2022 by Igor Kokcharov
Job Interview Puzzles 2022Job Interview Puzzles 2022
Job Interview Puzzles 2022
Igor Kokcharov1.3K views
The Funniest Aplusclick Brainteasers by Igor Kokcharov
The Funniest Aplusclick BrainteasersThe Funniest Aplusclick Brainteasers
The Funniest Aplusclick Brainteasers
Igor Kokcharov1.7K views
Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2019 by Igor Kokcharov
Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2019Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2019
Aplusclick Best Puzzles 2019
Igor Kokcharov1.6K views
18 Best Aplusclick Puzzles 2018 by Igor Kokcharov
18 Best Aplusclick Puzzles 201818 Best Aplusclick Puzzles 2018
18 Best Aplusclick Puzzles 2018
Igor Kokcharov2.2K views
What Is Project Portfolio Management by Igor Kokcharov
What Is Project Portfolio ManagementWhat Is Project Portfolio Management
What Is Project Portfolio Management
Igor Kokcharov3.6K views
Guesstimate Methods and Examples by Igor Kokcharov
Guesstimate Methods and ExamplesGuesstimate Methods and Examples
Guesstimate Methods and Examples
Igor Kokcharov12.3K views
Responsibility Assignment Matrix - RACI Chart Explained by Igor Kokcharov
Responsibility Assignment Matrix - RACI Chart Explained  Responsibility Assignment Matrix - RACI Chart Explained
Responsibility Assignment Matrix - RACI Chart Explained
Igor Kokcharov15.5K views
What Is Project Risk Management? by Igor Kokcharov
What Is Project Risk Management?What Is Project Risk Management?
What Is Project Risk Management?
Igor Kokcharov10.2K views
Structural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 2 Fracture Mechanics by Igor Kokcharov
Structural Integrity Analysis: Chapter  2 Fracture MechanicsStructural Integrity Analysis: Chapter  2 Fracture Mechanics
Structural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 2 Fracture Mechanics
Igor Kokcharov2.2K views
Structural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 9 Composites by Igor Kokcharov
Structural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 9 CompositesStructural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 9 Composites
Structural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 9 Composites
Igor Kokcharov1.6K views
Structural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 3 Mechanical Properties of Materials by Igor Kokcharov
Structural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 3 Mechanical Properties of MaterialsStructural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 3 Mechanical Properties of Materials
Structural Integrity Analysis: Chapter 3 Mechanical Properties of Materials
Igor Kokcharov2K views
Structural Integrity Analysis. Chapter 1 Stress Concentration by Igor Kokcharov
Structural Integrity Analysis. Chapter 1 Stress ConcentrationStructural Integrity Analysis. Chapter 1 Stress Concentration
Structural Integrity Analysis. Chapter 1 Stress Concentration
Igor Kokcharov4.8K views
Funny Math Funny Logic by Igor Kokcharov
Funny Math Funny LogicFunny Math Funny Logic
Funny Math Funny Logic
Igor Kokcharov11.3K views
A+Click Short Math Situations SMS by Igor Kokcharov
A+Click Short Math Situations SMSA+Click Short Math Situations SMS
A+Click Short Math Situations SMS
Igor Kokcharov832 views
Math Practical Problems for Human Beings by Igor Kokcharov
Math Practical Problems for Human BeingsMath Practical Problems for Human Beings
Math Practical Problems for Human Beings
Igor Kokcharov5.5K views
Project Manager 7 Sins 7 Jokes 7 Riddles by Igor Kokcharov
Project Manager 7 Sins 7 Jokes 7 RiddlesProject Manager 7 Sins 7 Jokes 7 Riddles
Project Manager 7 Sins 7 Jokes 7 Riddles
Igor Kokcharov17.1K views

Recently uploaded

Top 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore Professionals by
Top 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore ProfessionalsTop 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore Professionals
Top 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore Professionalsaltafhsayyednimetler
12 views14 slides
Bloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdf by
Bloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdfBloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdf
Bloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdfBloomerang
95 views32 slides
UCA towards I5.0 OECD.pdf by
UCA towards I5.0 OECD.pdfUCA towards I5.0 OECD.pdf
UCA towards I5.0 OECD.pdfAPPAU_Ukraine
7 views16 slides
Effective Supervisory Skill by
Effective Supervisory SkillEffective Supervisory Skill
Effective Supervisory SkillSeta Wicaksana
14 views26 slides
terms_2.pdf by
terms_2.pdfterms_2.pdf
terms_2.pdfJAWADIQBAL40
51 views8 slides
Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict by
Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict
Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict Seta Wicaksana
17 views14 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

Top 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore Professionals by altafhsayyednimetler
Top 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore ProfessionalsTop 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore Professionals
Top 10 IT Tasks Small Businesses Can Entrust to Offshore Professionals
Bloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdf by Bloomerang
Bloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdfBloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdf
Bloomerang_Forecasting Your Fundraising Revenue 2024.pptx.pdf
Bloomerang95 views
Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict by Seta Wicaksana
Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict
Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict
Seta Wicaksana17 views
Why Networking Events Don't Work_ Why You Should Give Talks Instead by HarryRamsay1
Why Networking Events Don't Work_ Why You Should Give Talks Instead Why Networking Events Don't Work_ Why You Should Give Talks Instead
Why Networking Events Don't Work_ Why You Should Give Talks Instead
HarryRamsay17 views
Episode 258 Snippets: Rob Gevertz of First Five Yards by Neil Horowitz
Episode 258 Snippets: Rob Gevertz of First Five YardsEpisode 258 Snippets: Rob Gevertz of First Five Yards
Episode 258 Snippets: Rob Gevertz of First Five Yards
Neil Horowitz47 views
INT Value Proposition Partner- Indirect Channel-E.pptx by LoadingSystems
INT Value Proposition Partner- Indirect Channel-E.pptxINT Value Proposition Partner- Indirect Channel-E.pptx
INT Value Proposition Partner- Indirect Channel-E.pptx
LoadingSystems9 views
bookmyshow-1.pptx by 125071035
bookmyshow-1.pptxbookmyshow-1.pptx
bookmyshow-1.pptx
12507103510 views
Coomes Consulting Business Profile by Chris Coomes
Coomes Consulting Business ProfileCoomes Consulting Business Profile
Coomes Consulting Business Profile
Chris Coomes44 views
Bloomerang Thank Yous Dec 2023.pdf by Bloomerang
Bloomerang Thank Yous Dec 2023.pdfBloomerang Thank Yous Dec 2023.pdf
Bloomerang Thank Yous Dec 2023.pdf
Bloomerang88 views
Assignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptx by BethanyAline
Assignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptxAssignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptx
Assignment 4: Reporting to Management.pptx
BethanyAline17 views
See the new MTN tariffs effected November 28, 2023 by Kweku Zurek
See the new MTN tariffs effected November 28, 2023See the new MTN tariffs effected November 28, 2023
See the new MTN tariffs effected November 28, 2023
Kweku Zurek29.4K views
Presentation on proposed acquisition of leading European asset manager Aermon... by KeppelCorporation
Presentation on proposed acquisition of leading European asset manager Aermon...Presentation on proposed acquisition of leading European asset manager Aermon...
Presentation on proposed acquisition of leading European asset manager Aermon...
KeppelCorporation122 views
NYKAA PPT .pptx by 125071081
NYKAA PPT .pptxNYKAA PPT .pptx
NYKAA PPT .pptx
12507108110 views
NewBase 23 November 2023 Energy News issue - 1676 by Khaled Al Awadi_compre... by Khaled Al Awadi
NewBase  23 November 2023  Energy News issue - 1676 by Khaled Al Awadi_compre...NewBase  23 November 2023  Energy News issue - 1676 by Khaled Al Awadi_compre...
NewBase 23 November 2023 Energy News issue - 1676 by Khaled Al Awadi_compre...
Khaled Al Awadi17 views
The 10 Most Iconic Leaders in Supply Chain 2023_compressed.pdf by ciolook1
The 10 Most Iconic Leaders in Supply Chain 2023_compressed.pdfThe 10 Most Iconic Leaders in Supply Chain 2023_compressed.pdf
The 10 Most Iconic Leaders in Supply Chain 2023_compressed.pdf
ciolook16 views

Hierarchy of Skills

  • 1. Hierarchy of Skills I. Kokcharov Invent Solve Work Play Know
  • 2. Self-actualization Esteem Love / Belonging Safety Physiological morality, creativity, spontaneity, problem solving, lack of prejudice, acceptance of failure self-esteem, confidence, achievement, respect of others, respect by others friendship, family, sexual intimacy security of body, of employment, of resources, of morality, of the family, of health, of property breathing, food, water, sex, sleep, hemostasis, excretion Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs [1] Abraham Maslow Picture: source Wikipedia
  • 3. Mission Mastery Member Myself Money Creating value for others self-improvement, achievement Member of a team Originality + performance Earning for personal needs Work Motivation: M5-model I. Kokcharov © 2015
  • 4. Skills Skill is an ability, coming from one’s knowledge, practice, aptitude to do something well.
  • 5. Invent Solve Work Play Know creating new knowledge, skills, products, service; leadership creative use of skills to resolve problems purposeful use of knowledge motivational use of knowledge acquiring basic knowledge Hierarchy of Skills I. Kokcharov © 2015 Craftsman Expert Specialist Apprentice Student
  • 7.  “The craftsman represents the special human condition of being engaged.” [4]  “By one commonly used measure, about ten thousand hours of experience are required to produce a master carpenter or musician.” [4] Craftsman
  • 8. 2%  Maslow said only 2% of people reached the stage of self-actualization.  The same percentage can be attributed to the highest level of the Skill Hierarchy. Craftsman is rare species
  • 9. Competence Competence is the condition of being capable; possession of required skill, knowledge, qualification, or capacity.
  • 10. Hierarchy of Competence Adapted from Noel Burch [5] Unconscious Competence Right Intuition Right Analysis Wrong Analysis Wrong Intuition Conscious Competence Conscious Incompetence Unconscious Incompetence
  • 11. Learning by Doing Participating Receiving To work with a coach, Immediate practicing Play Exercises, Discussion, Demonstration Audiovisual Reading Lecture Retention of Learning I. Kokcharov © 2015 > 75% 20% - 75% <20%
  • 12. Needs Safety Physiological Self- actualization Esteem Love / Belonging Work Motivation Myself Money Mission Mastery Member Invent Solve Work Play Know Skills Receiving Participating Learning by Doing Learning Retention Wrong Intuition Wrong Analysis Right Analysis Right Intuition Competence
  • 13. 1. Maslow A.H. A Theory of Human Motivation http://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Maslow/motivation.htm 2. Kokcharov I. What motivates us to work hard? https://aplusclick.wordpress.com/2013/01/06/what-motivates-us-to-work-hard/ 3. Kokcharov I. Using Business Simulation to Analyze Project Management Decision Making. Proceeding of 45th International Simulation and Game Association Conference, Dornbirn, Austria, 2014, p.313-318. ISBN: 978-3-7639-5420-9 4. Sennett R. The Craftsman. 2008. Penguin Books ISBN 978-0-141-02209-3 5. Noel Burch cited at Wikipedia «Four Stages of Competence» http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_stages_of_competence 6. Dreyfus S.E., Dreyfus H.L. "A Five-Stage Model of the Mental Activities Involved in Directed Skill Acquisition" 1980 Bibliography