2010 Intelligence Community Library Consortium Meeting
Using Social Technologies for Public Health
1. Using Social Technologies for Public HealthPresented at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Alicia Livinski, MPH, MA Doug Joubert, MS, MLS
3. Disclaimer The views expressed in this talk do not represent the views of or endorsement by the United States Government, US Department of Health and Human Services, or the National Institutes of Health.
4. What is social media? “Group of internet-based applications that build on … Web 2.0 and allow for the creation and exchange of user-generated content” Kaplan Andreas M., Haenlein Michael, (2010)., Users of the world, unite! The challenges and opportunities of social media, Business Horizons, Vol. 53, Issue 1, p. 59-68. Social media are a new set of tools for the public health toolbox.
5. Why? Reach out to people Let people reach out to you Do these things efficiently and effectively
6. Social media usage in US 75% adults use Internet 62% broadband @ home 80% own cell 53% wireless internet 55% 18-29yo wireless internet via phone African American adults mobile web users 57% online adults use social networking sites 73% teens use them 19% adults use Twitter 8% of teens use Twitter ~40% online adults get email/text alerts Source: Pew Internet & American Life Project
7. Consumers want their information when they want it, how they want it, and in whatever quantitiesthey want it. Traditional Media New Media Price Waterhouse
11. How the Landscape Has Changed “Two important concepts are online interaction and user engagement*.” Will you Friend Me? Follow Me! “You need to become a Node in their network**.” Like! Social Media is not a Spectator Sport *FedEx and Ketchum, 2010 **Kristin Purcell, 2010
12. A rapid review of social media tools with public health examples
18. Facebook - Pages More than 500 millionactive users!* 28% of 2 billion** = 560,000,000 people!! 28% of all internet users get news via social networks such as Facebook!*** *Facebook Press Room (02/2011) http://www.facebook.com/press/info.php?statistics Pew Internet (03/2010) http://www.pewinternet.org/Reports/2010/Online-News/Part-5/2-News-as-a-social-activity.aspx ***http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=36492&Cr=internet&Cr1
19. Facebook – Optimizing Pages Findabilityis everything, focus on SEO Make your contentworth sharing Make your content easyto share Make your content sharablefor Facebook
20. Facebook – SEO Stats http://www.bruceclay.com/blog/2011/06/yes-virginia-facebook-is-seo-smx-advanced/
23. Twitter Twitter has 105,779,710 registered users 300,000 new users sign up per day Twitter receives 180 million unique visitors per month There are 600 million search queries on Twitter per day Twitter gets 3 billion requests a day through its API http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/just_the_facts_statistics_from_twitter_chirp.php
26. Press Release / Blog RSS Push communication Platform for communication Social communication Ways to use twitter (CC) davemott on Flickr Direct engagement (@mentions) #twitterchats Adapted from Holman, 2010
31. There are over 100,000 Twitter applications** http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/just_the_facts_statistics_from_twitter_chirp.php
32. Twitter Examples Red River Floods Boulder, CO fires Type A H1N1 influenza outbreak Food outbreak/safety Australian bushfires Mumbai attacks Hurricane season Traffic accidents/road closures – fire departments Haiti earthquake BP oil spill
37. YouTube: Audience More that 45% of users are over the age of 35* YouTube is the #2 search engine (after Google) in the United States. The site has over 140 million unique monthly users in the U.S.* The average U.S. visitor spends more the 270 minutes per month on YouTube.* 94 of Advertising Age’s Top 100 Marketers have run campaigns on the YouTube/Google Content Network.** *ComScore, Nov 2010 **Fast Company, Jan 2011 Adapted from Houghteling, 2011
38. YouTube: Content Be relevant Be informative Be genuine and engaging Build a community Adapted from Houghteling, 2011
43. YouTube: Tech Tips Use Search Engine Optimization (SEO) and Promotion Use Google Moderator Use Annotation Use Insight Awesome Resources Tips for optimizing videos on your YouTube Channel Adapted from Houghteling, 2011
47. Use Google Moderator to… …engage the community …let your audience frame the conversation …make sure everyone's voice is heard How it Works Create a series Open the series for submissions (questions, ideas, or suggestions Use Voting and Featured Questions to guide the conversation
50. Mashups Combine separate data/content from multiple sources into a new product/tool Typically mashups function using an Application Programming Interface (API) Mashups also allow you to search for and locate information and services. They also can help you track information such as disease outbreaks. Maps are frequently used for mashups, connecting to online mapping resources from Google, Yahoo, or Bing http://aids.gov/using-new-media/tools/mashups/
52. Mashup - Resources Mashup Tutorials 100 Things to do with Google Maps Mashups
53. Blogs Website with periodic updates (posts) Usually one author or a few authors who represent a single organization Usually has a particular theme…but within a theme may cover recent publications, conferences, websites, random thoughts, etc. Usually allows public comments
54. RSS Web feed format to publish updates to a blog, news headlines, audio/video, new journal tables of contents AKA “feed” or “web feed” RSS = “Really Simple Syndication” Subscribe to an RSS feed Timely notification of updates to a favored site RSS feeds read using “RSS reader”, “feed reader” or “aggregator” – can be web-based, desktop-based or mobile device-based
55. Why Use RSS? New issues of journals /Table of Contents alerts Breaking news stories/headlines Reduce email volume Web-based readers available from anywhere
56. Wikis A kind of web page that is easy to edit Several people can be editors Changes can be tracked and undone
58. H1N1 CDC/ C. S. Goldsmith and A. Balish (2009) CDC/ C. S. Goldsmith and A. Balish (2009)
59. Brief (A)H1N1 Timeline Early outbreaks in North America in April 2009 WHO declared a pandemic in June 2009 & 74 countries and territories had reported laboratory confirmed infections As of April 25, 2010, more than 214 countries, including over 17,919 deaths 39-80 million cases of 2009 H1N1 occurred between April-December 12, 2009 in USA (CDC) 7,880-16,460 2009 H1N1-related deaths occurred in USA between April and December 12, 2009 (CDC)
60. H1N1 + Social Media You want to disseminate your public health messaging for H1N1 to the general public and target the high-risk groups Messaging focused on: Prevention How transmitted Treatment Vaccine Find out what the public is really saying about H1N1 “ground-truthing”
62. Twitter Use to: Push out your message – must be “short & sweet” Rumor control (H1N1 vaccines) Correct misinformation (pork & swine flu) Direct people to your website or tel # to call Monitor school closures Find out what the public is doing (swine flu parties) Know who you’re trying to reach, not all of your target audiences will use Twitter
66. H1N1+Local PH Dept Examples Contra Costa, CA recent tweets and posts included announcements on the expansion of groups eligible for vaccine, a call for volunteers at flu clinics, food handling tips, flu clinic schedules, and statistics regarding fatalities and hospitalizations. Howard County, MD used Twitter and Facebook as tools to reach one of the CDC target groups for H1N1 vaccination—college students. Fairfax County, VA Health Department let their constituents know about H1N1 vaccine clinic wait times by tweeting. They used social media as an interactive tool, taking comments and questions online.
72. YouTube: Fairfax County, VA videos about flu season safety tips, flu vaccine shipments, and clinics
73. Ushahidi.com Combines SMS, Twitter and Google Maps Anyone with a mobile phone can text about voter fraud, health dangers, human rights abuses, etc. Administrators can view incoming information on a map and send back information to original sender
79. So what works? Does it make a difference? What can we learn?
80. Advantages Fast Less formal Personal face for impersonal institutions Interactive Engaging In-depth training not necessary Hip, modern, cool, etc. “engage in the conversation”
81. Disadvantages (or concerns) Potential for misinformation or bias Privacy Security Demographics of users A lot of noise Time involved Tech requirements & tech support Blocked by many agencies and hospitals Lots of mostly non-interoperable systems Additional marketing required Like every group project
82. Should I Try Social Media? Leaves a trace that can be read, shared, and analyzed Different sites have unique aspects that influence connections and usage Twitter posts are public, Facebook posts and comments are semi-private LiveJournal has “moods” Yahoo Answers requires categories while MS Live uses tags
83. Engaged & Empowered Engaging people and answering their questions is important “…. staff has taken the time to listen to feedback and addressed issues such as vaccine availability.” Open Government initiative New content can be sent to cell phones as text messages, it is an easy way to reach mobile locations And an easy way for them to reach you
84. Sick City: A Cautionary Tale March 2009: Lots of buzz about a new website that tracks people's tweets about being sick, having sore throats, and other physical maladies. March 30: Onset of first confirmed H1N1 case in US May: "The tool went from being marginally useful, though still a bit noisy, to totally drowned in noise and hence useless, in the space of a day.... At one point SickCity was processing over 1500 tweets a minute related to flu (almost none of them by people who actually had flu)." ??: Site taken down.
85. JHUSPH has >28K followers but they don’t seem to reply, mention, or retweetJH much icerocket.com
87. So what? New technologies allow rumors and alternative views to spread quickly. You may think blogs and tweets and facebook are silly, but people are using social media to talk about public health issues and find information. The policies, analysis, justification, etc. aren’t evolving as quickly as the tools themselves.
We are not going to discuss: How to write a social media policy for your agency/group How to develop a communications strategy which specific tools to use or how to evaluate their use or develop metrics
According to Kaplan & Haenlein “social media is a group of internet-based applications that build on Web 2.0 and allow for the creation and exchange of user-generated content”Social media is a tool.Kaplan Andreas M., Haenlein Michael, (2010)., Users of the world, unite! The challenges and opportunities of social media, Business Horizons, Vol. 53, Issue 1, p. 59-68.
In the United States, according to Lee Rainie of the Pew Internet & American Life Project, 75% of American adults use the internet62% of American adults use broadband connections at home 80% of American adults own a cell phone55% of 18-29 year olds have accessed the internet wirelessly via cell phoneAfrican Americans adults are the most active users of the mobile web, and their use is growing at a faster pace than mobile internet use among white or Hispanic adults. 57% of online American adults 18 and older use a social networking site like MySpace, Facebook or LinkedIn73% of teens 12-17 use online social networksAs of August 2009, Facebook was the most popular online social network for American adults 18 and older. Teens are not using Twitter in large numbers. While teens are bigger users of almost all other online applications, Twitter is an exception.Understanding which tools are and are not being used by different age and racial groups is important in selecting the correct social media tools to use.Lee Rainie, April 2010 – CIL 2010 presentation “Information fluency and imagining the internet”http://www.pewinternet.org/Presentations/2010/Apr/Computers-in-Libraries.aspxLee Rainie, April 2010 – presentation: “Networked Individuals: How they are reshaping social life and learning environments “ - http://www.pewinternet.org/Presentations/2010/Apr/University-of-Connecticut-Library-Forum.aspxv
Nodes include Twitter, and Facebook
Nodes include Twitter, and Facebook
Twitter group chats offer a clever and effective way to meet people with like interests and to share insights into the topic of discussion. Chatters track their conversations using hashtags (#) followed by the name of the chat
Winner of the US Dept. of Health & Human Services 2009 Flu Prevention Video PSA Contest. Written, composed, produced, and performed by John D. Clarke, MD, FAAFP.
YouTube Insight is a self-service analytics and reporting tool that enables anyone with a YouTube account to view detailed statistics about the audience for the videos that they upload to the site
Google Moderator allows you to create a series about anything that you are interested in discussing and open it up for people to submit questions, ideas, or suggestions. These are called submissions. Anyone can come to the site and submit a question, idea, or vote, and anyone can vote. Google Moderator shows you a question in the box with the blue background. This is called the Featured Question.
Google Moderator allows you to create a series about anything that you are interested in discussing and open it up for people to submit questions, ideas, or suggestions. These are called submissions. Anyone can come to the site and submit a question, idea, or vote, and anyone can vote. Google Moderator shows you a question in the box with the blue background. This is called the Featured Question.
As we all may remember, 2009 included the arrival of the H1N1 type of A influenza virus. We passed the one year anniversary of its appearance in the United States in March 2009.
A pandemic is the worldwide spread of a new disease. After early outbreaks in North America in April 2009 the new influenza virus spread rapidly around the world. By the time WHO declared a pandemic in June 2009, a total of 74 countries and territories had reported laboratory confirmed infections. To date, most countries in the world have confirmed infections from the new virus.The new virus has also led to patterns of death and illness not normally seen in influenza infections. Most of the deaths caused by the pandemic influenza have occurred among younger people, including those who were otherwise healthy. Pregnant women, younger children and people of any age with certain chronic lung or other medical conditions appear to be at higher risk of more complicated or severe illness. Many of the severe cases have been due to viral pneumonia, which is harder to treat than bacterial pneumonias usually associated with seasonal influenza. http://www.who.int/csr/disease/swineflu/en/As of April 25, 2010, more than 214 countries, including over 17,919 deathsCDC estimates that between 39 million and 80 million cases of 2009 H1N1 occurred between April and December 12, 2009. The mid-level in this range is about 55 million people infected with 2009 H1N1.CDC estimates that between 173,000 and 362,000 2009 H1N1-related hospitalizations occurred between April and December 12, 2009. The mid-level in this range is about 246,000 H1N1-related hospitalizations. CDC estimates that between 7,880 and 16,460 2009 H1N1-related deaths occurred between April and December 12, 2009. The mid-level in this range is about 11,160 2009 H1N1-related deaths. http://cdc.gov/h1n1flu/estimates_2009_h1n1.htm In contrast, the seasonal flu kills about 36,000 people a year, with 90 percent of these deaths occurring in people 65 years and older.influenza-like-illness (ILI),
So here is our scenario for today, High risk groups include: pregnant women; immunocompromised; college students; young children.You also want to find out what the public is really saying about the vaccine, transmission etc.
Social media was used extensively during H1N1 in 2009 to disseminate information, respond to rumors, and promote resources.
You could use Twitter to:Limited to 140 charactersRumor control about vaccine availability; autism & vaccine Not everyone is using Twitter, so it should be one tool among many used to disseminate your messages.
Here are 2 of the CDC’s Twitter feeds on H1N1.Their feeds: pointed to their H1N1 webpages new clinical care guidelines statistics on cases, hospitalizations, & deaths press briefings, testimony, webcasts vaccine information
Flu.gov’s Twitter pageFlu.gov is the US Government’s central site for information on H1N1. The HHS Interagency Public Affairs Group on Influenza Preparedness and Response, is responsible for coordinating pandemic-related information across the federal government.Flu.gov repeats or leads back to the CDC H1N1 webpages, but also included information from other USG sources, WHO, webcasts, FAQs etc.
PAHO’s Twitter feed links back to WHO, PAHO & CDC websites, press briefings, new reports, statistics etc.
Vaccine clinic hours & schedulesWait timesEligible groupsNeed for volunteersStatistics on H1N1 in local communities or stateFlu prevention tips
Like Twitter, Facebook could be used to:Promote flu vaccination (HHS created a badge for people to post on their Facebook pages that were vaccinated)Point people to your H1N1 information page
Much of the information that can be shared on Twitter can also be posted to Facebook although more detailed information can be shared here (not limited to word count)
PAHO’s YouTube channel includes videos on H1N1 and other public health concerns; however, they are available in English & Spanish
So how do you keep track of all of the sources of information on a topic, or resources you are using?You could try the following that I used for H1N1 last year.Use RSS feeds to stream new content to an iGoogle tab. iGoogle is a customizable page attached to your Google account, but that you can also share with others.Use web browser apps to update, track, search Twitter or Facebook. You can also download and use apps for your smartphones and cellphones to post new content to Twitter or Facebook.Firefox apps for Twitter :Ping.fm (updating social media tools all at once)TweetScan (search keywords in Twitter)ShareAHolic (share pages via Facebook, Twitter, email, Gmail etc.)Deepest Sender (WordPress blog)Brizzly (Twitter & Facebook streams on 1-page)Monkeyfly (retweets & searches)Flicrk appsTwitPic (send pictures to Twitter)TweetStats (statistics for your Twitter account)TwitterBar (post to your Twitter account right from the FF toolbar)
Use RSS features & automated searches from Twitter, Google, YouTube, websites, journal TOCsBlog feedsPress release feedsCDC H1N1 flu update pageCDC YouTube channelGoogle search feedetc. to keep up-to-date on new postings, news or information
Live is more social, less serious more usefulFacebook is a “semi-protected environment” or “a semi-unknown place populated by semi-unknown users”.
Facebook and Twitter can be updated, posted to or followed via smartphone or cellphone using applications;Mobile internet access is only going to become more widespread and important in the future. In 2008, there were 4 billion mobile phone subscriptions, which reached 61 of every 100 people. While most mobile phone users are in the developed world, the developing world is rapidly increasing in number of users. This is where mobile internet access is important. Most people will access the internet and your content online via a phone not a computer.