SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Design for Continuous
                    Experimentation
                                Dan McKinley
                            Principal Engineer, Etsy
                             November 30th, 2012




Sunday, December 2, 12

Hi my name’s Dan McKinley
www.   .com




Sunday, December 2, 12

and I’m here from etsy.com
The world’s handmade
        and vintage marketplace.


Sunday, December 2, 12

Etsy is the world’s handmade and vintage marketplace.
Sunday, December 2, 12

Etsy’s a place where you can buy all kinds of things, including handmade crafts like this
sampler
Sunday, December 2, 12

... or this vintage credenza ...
Sunday, December 2, 12

... and rhinestone-studded underwear made of beef jerky ...
Sunday, December 2, 12

Beef jerky underwear is reasonably popular apparently. we’re on track to sell between $800MM and
900MM in goods this year. This makes us about as big as Hot Topic.
OCTOBER 2012
                                         1.5 billion page views
                                         55 million unique visitors
                                         USD $83 million in transactions
                                         4.2 million items sold



                                                        http://www.etsy.com/blog/news/?s=weather+report

Sunday, December 2, 12

We had about 1.5B page views in October which makes us a reasonably large website.
We love experiments.



Sunday, December 2, 12

At Etsy, we love experiments and A/B testing. And that’s the main thing I want to talk about today.
Tons of active A/B tests and rampups.




Sunday, December 2, 12

Here’s a screenshot of an internal view of the various tests and config rampups running on
just one of our pages. As you can see, there are a whole lot of them.
Sunday, December 2, 12

We’ve invested plenty of time and effort into tooling to support this work. This is a
screenshot of our A/B analyzer, which automatically generates a dashboard with important
business metrics for every configured test.
Sunday, December 2, 12

We’ve built tools that protect us from some gnarly statistics. This wizard does the math for
you and lets you know how long an experiment will need to run in order to have a significant
result.
Continuous Experimentation
                             Small, measurable changes.
                                  Keeps us honest.
                          Prevents us from breaking things.




Sunday, December 2, 12

I’m going to call what we do “continuous experimentation,” for the lack of a better term. We try to make
small changes as much as possible, and we measure those changes so that we stay honest and don’t
break the site.
Seung yun Yoo
                                                                Seoul, South Korea

                                                                knifeinthewater.etsy.com




                                          http://www.etsy.com/blog/en/2012/featured-shop-knife-in-the-water/
Sunday, December 2, 12

So what do I mean by “breaking the site?” Well, behind every Etsy shop is a person that
depends on it, and counts on us not to push changes that hurt their business. So we would
be remiss not to measure our changes.
Etsy Sales: Two Scenarios
                                                 Good product release

                                  Awful product release




Sunday, December 2, 12

The second reason we measure product releases is so that we stay honest. Much of Etsy’s
sales are seller-driven, so our graphs currently tend to go up no matter what. Obviously that
can’t continue forever. But we have to use A/B testing to tell if we’ve made things worse or
better.
Another reason we measure:




Sunday, December 2, 12
Another reason we measure:
                         Experimental results are surprising!




Sunday, December 2, 12
“When I am comparison shopping, I open items in new
             tabs. We should do that on Etsy.”

                                                                         - Typical know-it-all
                                                                              Etsy employee




Sunday, December 2, 12

Let me give you an example. A few years ago there was controversy internally at Etsy over whether or
not items should open up in new tabs. Some Etsy employees do this themselves when they’re digging
through search results, and they wish that it happened by default. They thought that the average user
would be happier if this were the case.
Sunday, December 2, 12

So we eventually stopped arguing about this and just tried it. We ran an A/B test that opened up items
in new tabs.
The Horrible Sound of Epic Failure




 credit: EmbroideryEverywhere.etsy.com
Sunday, December 2, 12

When we tried that, 70% more people gave up and left the site after getting a new tab. Maybe some
Etsy employees know how to use tabs in a browser, but my grandmother doesn’t. We’ve replicated this
result more than once.
Surprise!




Sunday, December 2, 12

Surprise! We don’t argue about that anymore.
One big thing we’ve learned
                               from experiments:




Sunday, December 2, 12

We’ve been at this for a while and one of the main things we’ve learned from this, which is the main
thing I want to talk about today,
Design and product process
                         must change to accommodate
                               experimentation.




Sunday, December 2, 12

is that process has to change to accommodate data and experimentation. If you follow a waterfall
process and try to bolt A/B testing onto it, you will fail
Removing the Search
                         Infinite Scroll
                                                                Dropdown




Sunday, December 2, 12

to illustrate this I want to go through two projects that we’ve done
Removing the Search
                         Infinite Scroll
                                                           Dropdown
                    Monolithic release.                       Multi-stage release.
                      Effort up front.                               Iterative.
                Changes many things at once.                  One thing at a time.
                    A/B test as a hurdle.                A/B testing integral to process.
                      Assumptions.                                Hypotheses.




Sunday, December 2, 12

These were two projects done largely by the same team. Infinite scroll was poorly managed, and a
release removing a dropdown in our site header was well managed.
Infinite Scroll
                                      So hot right now.




Sunday, December 2, 12

First I’ll go through our deployment of infinite scroll in search results.
Woah




Sunday, December 2, 12

If anyone doesn’t know what I mean by infinite scroll: I mean that we changed search results so that as
you scroll down, more items load in, indefinitely.
Seeing more items faster is
                         presumed to be a better experience.




Sunday, December 2, 12

The reason we did this was because we thought that it obvious that more items, faster was a better
experience. There’s a lot of web lore out there to that effect, based mostly on some findings Google’s
made in their own search.
Infinite Scroll: Release Plan
                                            (Implied)

              1. Build infinite scroll.
              2. Fix some bugs.
              3. A/B to measure obvious big improvement.
              4. Rent warehouse.
              5. Hold release party in warehouse.




Sunday, December 2, 12

So when we decided to do this we just went for it. We designed and built the feature, and then we
figured we’d release it and it’d be great.
Infinite Scroll: Results




Sunday, December 2, 12

so the results,
Infinite Scroll: Results



                          Spoiler: they were not expected.




Sunday, December 2, 12

not to spoil the surprise, were not what we were expecting.
Infinite Scroll: Results

                             Median item impressions:


                                      Infinite scroll: 40

                                      Control group: 80




Sunday, December 2, 12

People who had infinite scroll saw fewer items in search results than people in the control group, not
more.
Infinite Scroll: Results




                         Visitors seeing infinite scroll clicked
                            fewer results than the control.
Sunday, December 2, 12

they clicked on fewer items.
Infinite Scroll: Results




                         Visitors seeing infinite scroll saved
                              fewer items as favorites.
Sunday, December 2, 12

they saved fewer items as favorites.
Infinite Scroll: Results




                         Visitors seeing infinite scroll purchased
                                 fewer items from search*
Sunday, December 2, 12

They bought fewer items from search.
Now they didn’t buy fewer items overall, they just stopped using search to find those items. Which is
kind of interesting.
It was clear we’d made search worse.
Initial reaction:
                         “something’s broken.”




Sunday, December 2, 12

The first thing that occurred to us is that there must have been bugs in the product that we missed. So
we spent a month trying to figure out if that was the case. We sliced results by browser and geographic
location. We sent a guy to a public library to try using an ancient computer. We did find some bugs, but
none of them changed the overall results.
Gradual, horrible realization:
             “we changed many things at once.”




Sunday, December 2, 12

Eventually we came to terms with the fact that infinite scroll had made the product worse, and we had
changed too many things in the process to have any clue which was the culprit.
Premise-validating Experiments
                          Or: “things we should have
                           done in the first place.”




Sunday, December 2, 12

So, we were in a situation where we weren’t sure if we should continue working on this or not. Even if
we had issues in IE or something, the behavior of people using Chrome wasn’t way better, it was also
worse. How do we know if it’s a good idea to finish this or not?
So we went back and tried to verify that the premises that made us do this were right.
Are more items in search results better?




Sunday, December 2, 12

First of all, is it true that more items is better?
Sunday, December 2, 12

We ran a test where we just varied the number of results in normal search results.
Are more items in search results better?


                         Barely, maybe: more people get to an item
                            page as the result count increases.

                            Absolutely no change in purchases.




Sunday, December 2, 12

And the answer was yes, maybe a little bit, but only barely. There was a very slight improvement in the
number of people that ever got to a item page. But the effect is very slight, and purchases aren’t
sensitive to this. There’s no increase in purchases when we increase the number of search results.
Are faster results better?




Sunday, December 2, 12

The other major premise was that faster search results would stop people from getting bored, and
they’d buy more as a result.
Sunday, December 2, 12

We ran a test where we slowed down search artificially, by adding sleeps().
Are faster results better?


                                               Meh




Sunday, December 2, 12

Absolutely nothing happened. Which isn’t to say that performance is pointless, but people buying items
don’t seem to be sensitive to performance at all.
credit: LunaLetterpress.etsy.com
Sunday, December 2, 12

In the end the expected benefits to infinite scroll just didn’t seem to be there. Our premises were
wrong. So we took infinite scroll out back and we shot it.
Infinite Scroll: Release Plan
                                             (Implied)

              1. Build infinite scroll.                            Lots of work

              2. Fix some bugs.
              3. A/B to measure obvious big improvement.
              4. Rent warehouse.
              5. Hold release party in warehouse.
                                             Didn’t happen

Sunday, December 2, 12

So if we go back to our “product plan,” we see a couple of major things wrong with it. We did a lot of
work, and it was pointless.
A Slightly Better Infinite
                            Scroll Release Plan

              1. Validate premise: more items is better (easy)
              2. Validate premise: faster is better (easy)
              3. Either:
                   A. Abort! (easy)
                   B. Build infinite scroll (hard).



Sunday, December 2, 12

A better way to have done this would have been to validate those premises ahead of time and then
make the call. But we didn’t do that.
Throwing out work sucks.




Sunday, December 2, 12

Throwing out work feels really horrible. Most of the time this is a really difficult choice to make, and
without a lot of honesty and discipline, most teams aren’t going to do it. We are not very rational
creatures in the face of sunk costs.
Infinite scroll: not stupid.




Sunday, December 2, 12

My point is not that infinite scroll is stupid. It may be great on your website. But we should have done a
better job of understanding the people using our website.
Removing the Search Dropdown
                         A much better experience
                            for me, personally.




Sunday, December 2, 12

So that was a bad release. I want to change gears now and go through a good one.
2007




Sunday, December 2, 12

Pretty early on, we added this dropdown to the header, mainly to pick between handmade items and
vintage items. It wasn’t intended to be permanent.
2012




Sunday, December 2, 12

But as these things always do, it got way out of hand. It looked like this five years later.
Kill the Dropdown: Project Plan

              1. Redesign marketplace facets.
              2. Default to “all items.”
              3. Rich autosuggest.
              4. Suggest shops in item results.
              5. Add favorites filter to search results.
              6. Search bars on item and shop pages.
              7. Kill the dropdown.


Sunday, December 2, 12

So we wanted to remove this thing. Chastened by the infinite scroll release, we did our best to plan this
out in smaller steps.
Kill the Dropdown: Project Plan

              1. Redesign marketplace facets.
              2. Default to “all items.”                     Short.
              3. Rich autosuggest.                        Measurable.
              4. Suggest shops in item results.            Isolated.

              5. Add favorites filter to search results.
              6. Search bars on item and shop pages.
              7. Kill the dropdown.


Sunday, December 2, 12

Each of these steps is small and isolated.
Kill the Dropdown: Project Plan

              1. Redesign marketplace facets.
              2. Default to “all items.”
                                                                             Opportunity
              3. Rich autosuggest.                                            to change
              4. Suggest shops in item results.                                 plans.
              5. Add favorites filter to search results.
              6. Search bars on item and shop pages.
              7. Kill the dropdown.


Sunday, December 2, 12

Each step is an opportunity to get real feedback and change directions if we have to.
Kill the Dropdown: Project Plan

              1. Redesign marketplace facets.
              2. Default to “all items.”
              3. Rich autosuggest.
              4. Suggest shops in item results.
              5. Add favorites filter to search results.
              6. Search bars on item and shop pages.
              7. Kill the dropdown.                        Ambitious design goal,
                                                           never out of sight.

Sunday, December 2, 12

And all of the individual releases were small, but the overall design goal was still ambitious.
Sunday, December 2, 12

So, the first thing we had to address was the fact that the dropdown was used to cut the marketplace
by different item types.
HYPOTHESIS:

                             Most users of the site don’t
                             know anything about this.




Sunday, December 2, 12

We were working from a hypothesis that most people using Etsy don’t even notice this. But again, we
had to verify this.
Sunday, December 2, 12

First we introduced this faceting on the left side of search results, and made it more obvious. This
relatively simple and it was an improvement over the old design that nobody used.
Sunday, December 2, 12

But still, relatively few people noticed that. So we also built faceting into our autosuggest. We made it
possible to drill down into categories as you typed.
Sales of Vintage Items:


                                               +3.7%




Sunday, December 2, 12

After we did this, sales of vintage items without the dropdown in place increased almost 4%. So we
increased the ability of buyers on Etsy to find vintage goods, we didn’t decrease it. Which is a great
thing to be able to tell our community.
VERIFIED HYPOTHESIS:

                             Casual users of the site don’t
                              know anything about this.




Sunday, December 2, 12

So we were right. Most people using the site in fact did not know how to use the dropdown for this.
Context-sensitive!




Sunday, December 2, 12

Another horrible behavior of the search dropdown was that it was context-sensitive. So if you were on a
shop page it defaulted to searching within the shop. And in some other situations it would search for
people.
HYPOTHESIS:

                            Casual users of the site don’t
                                    realize this.




Sunday, December 2, 12

So again, we figured that this was too complicated and nobody realized what was happening.
Sunday, December 2, 12

To contend with this we introduced a secondary search box on shop pages so that people could do a
search scoped to just the shop. This worked a lot better.
Sunday, December 2, 12

We also tried adding this search bar to the item page. But few people used it and those who did
performed very poorly.
Sunday, December 2, 12

So we took that part out.
If we had done the whole project all at once, we probably would not have noticed that this detail
sucked.
Sunday, December 2, 12

Another thing the search dropdown could be used for was searching for shops. Nobody used it.
Sunday, December 2, 12

So we added shops suggestions to item results and made sure more people could find shops
...plus five or ten other things
                                on the same scale.




Sunday, December 2, 12

So you more or less get the idea here. We had a big goal, which we could have been unmanageable
as a single release. We did it as ten or fifteen small releases.
Data was involved at every step.




Sunday, December 2, 12
Infinite Scroll


                         Design          Develop                      Measure              ಠ_ಠ


       Dropdown Redesign


                                  ✓           ✓                  ✗                ✓ ...


              Design Develop Measure



Sunday, December 2, 12

Contrasting the two release plans, infinite scroll was a big bet that didn’t work out.
The dropdown redesign was a series of small bets: some worked and some didn’t, but we didn’t have to throw
out everything when things didn’t work
Some Advice




Sunday, December 2, 12

I want to leave you with some parting advice.
Experiment with minimal
                              versions of your idea.




Sunday, December 2, 12

Experiment with a minimal version first. With infinite scroll, we should have verified the premises.
Plan on being wrong.




Sunday, December 2, 12

Plan on being wrong. If you measure, you’ll encounter many counterintuitive results.
Prefer incremental redesigns.




Sunday, December 2, 12
This will not always work.
                             Occasionally, you may
                            need to make big bets on
                                   redesigns.




Sunday, December 2, 12

This is not always going to work: you may still have to make big bets on big redesigns sometimes.
...but it usually does.




Sunday, December 2, 12

But if you’re throwing this card down all the time you’re probably doing it wrong
Thank you.
                           Dan McKinley
                          dan@etsy.com




Sunday, December 2, 12

thanks

More Related Content

What's hot

Déjà Vu: The Importance of Time and Causality in Recommender Systems
Déjà Vu: The Importance of Time and Causality in Recommender SystemsDéjà Vu: The Importance of Time and Causality in Recommender Systems
Déjà Vu: The Importance of Time and Causality in Recommender Systems
Justin Basilico
 
Shallow and Deep Latent Models for Recommender System
Shallow and Deep Latent Models for Recommender SystemShallow and Deep Latent Models for Recommender System
Shallow and Deep Latent Models for Recommender System
Anoop Deoras
 
Contextualization at Netflix
Contextualization at NetflixContextualization at Netflix
Contextualization at Netflix
Linas Baltrunas
 
Personalization at Netflix - Making Stories Travel
Personalization at Netflix -  Making Stories Travel Personalization at Netflix -  Making Stories Travel
Personalization at Netflix - Making Stories Travel
Sudeep Das, Ph.D.
 
Cohort Analysis at Scale
Cohort Analysis at ScaleCohort Analysis at Scale
Cohort Analysis at Scale
Blake Irvine
 
Lessons Learned from Building Machine Learning Software at Netflix
Lessons Learned from Building Machine Learning Software at NetflixLessons Learned from Building Machine Learning Software at Netflix
Lessons Learned from Building Machine Learning Software at Netflix
Justin Basilico
 
Data behind UA
Data behind UA Data behind UA
Data behind UA
GameCamp
 
Deep Learning for Recommender Systems
Deep Learning for Recommender SystemsDeep Learning for Recommender Systems
Deep Learning for Recommender Systems
Yves Raimond
 
Sequential Decision Making in Recommendations
Sequential Decision Making in RecommendationsSequential Decision Making in Recommendations
Sequential Decision Making in Recommendations
Jaya Kawale
 
A Multi-Armed Bandit Framework For Recommendations at Netflix
A Multi-Armed Bandit Framework For Recommendations at NetflixA Multi-Armed Bandit Framework For Recommendations at Netflix
A Multi-Armed Bandit Framework For Recommendations at Netflix
Jaya Kawale
 
A Deep Dive Into Value and Outcomes (Kristin Skinner and Kamdyn Moore at Desi...
A Deep Dive Into Value and Outcomes (Kristin Skinner and Kamdyn Moore at Desi...A Deep Dive Into Value and Outcomes (Kristin Skinner and Kamdyn Moore at Desi...
A Deep Dive Into Value and Outcomes (Kristin Skinner and Kamdyn Moore at Desi...
Rosenfeld Media
 
Time, Context and Causality in Recommender Systems
Time, Context and Causality in Recommender SystemsTime, Context and Causality in Recommender Systems
Time, Context and Causality in Recommender Systems
Yves Raimond
 
Space Ape's Live Ops Stack: Engineering Mobile Games for Live Ops from Day 1
Space Ape's Live Ops Stack: Engineering Mobile Games for Live Ops from Day 1Space Ape's Live Ops Stack: Engineering Mobile Games for Live Ops from Day 1
Space Ape's Live Ops Stack: Engineering Mobile Games for Live Ops from Day 1
Simon Hade
 
Artwork Personalization at Netflix
Artwork Personalization at NetflixArtwork Personalization at Netflix
Artwork Personalization at Netflix
Justin Basilico
 
Supporting decisions with ML
Supporting decisions with MLSupporting decisions with ML
Supporting decisions with ML
Megan Neider
 
Practical AI for Business: Bandit Algorithms
Practical AI for Business: Bandit AlgorithmsPractical AI for Business: Bandit Algorithms
Practical AI for Business: Bandit Algorithms
SC5.io
 
Correlation, causation and incrementally recommendation problems at netflix ...
Correlation, causation and incrementally  recommendation problems at netflix ...Correlation, causation and incrementally  recommendation problems at netflix ...
Correlation, causation and incrementally recommendation problems at netflix ...
Roelof van Zwol
 
Deeper Things: How Netflix Leverages Deep Learning in Recommendations and Se...
 Deeper Things: How Netflix Leverages Deep Learning in Recommendations and Se... Deeper Things: How Netflix Leverages Deep Learning in Recommendations and Se...
Deeper Things: How Netflix Leverages Deep Learning in Recommendations and Se...
Sudeep Das, Ph.D.
 
Tableau Conference 2018: Binging on Data - Enabling Analytics at Netflix
Tableau Conference 2018: Binging on Data - Enabling Analytics at NetflixTableau Conference 2018: Binging on Data - Enabling Analytics at Netflix
Tableau Conference 2018: Binging on Data - Enabling Analytics at Netflix
Blake Irvine
 
Developing an effective LTV model at the soft launch and keeping it valid fur...
Developing an effective LTV model at the soft launch and keeping it valid fur...Developing an effective LTV model at the soft launch and keeping it valid fur...
Developing an effective LTV model at the soft launch and keeping it valid fur...
GameCamp
 

What's hot (20)

Déjà Vu: The Importance of Time and Causality in Recommender Systems
Déjà Vu: The Importance of Time and Causality in Recommender SystemsDéjà Vu: The Importance of Time and Causality in Recommender Systems
Déjà Vu: The Importance of Time and Causality in Recommender Systems
 
Shallow and Deep Latent Models for Recommender System
Shallow and Deep Latent Models for Recommender SystemShallow and Deep Latent Models for Recommender System
Shallow and Deep Latent Models for Recommender System
 
Contextualization at Netflix
Contextualization at NetflixContextualization at Netflix
Contextualization at Netflix
 
Personalization at Netflix - Making Stories Travel
Personalization at Netflix -  Making Stories Travel Personalization at Netflix -  Making Stories Travel
Personalization at Netflix - Making Stories Travel
 
Cohort Analysis at Scale
Cohort Analysis at ScaleCohort Analysis at Scale
Cohort Analysis at Scale
 
Lessons Learned from Building Machine Learning Software at Netflix
Lessons Learned from Building Machine Learning Software at NetflixLessons Learned from Building Machine Learning Software at Netflix
Lessons Learned from Building Machine Learning Software at Netflix
 
Data behind UA
Data behind UA Data behind UA
Data behind UA
 
Deep Learning for Recommender Systems
Deep Learning for Recommender SystemsDeep Learning for Recommender Systems
Deep Learning for Recommender Systems
 
Sequential Decision Making in Recommendations
Sequential Decision Making in RecommendationsSequential Decision Making in Recommendations
Sequential Decision Making in Recommendations
 
A Multi-Armed Bandit Framework For Recommendations at Netflix
A Multi-Armed Bandit Framework For Recommendations at NetflixA Multi-Armed Bandit Framework For Recommendations at Netflix
A Multi-Armed Bandit Framework For Recommendations at Netflix
 
A Deep Dive Into Value and Outcomes (Kristin Skinner and Kamdyn Moore at Desi...
A Deep Dive Into Value and Outcomes (Kristin Skinner and Kamdyn Moore at Desi...A Deep Dive Into Value and Outcomes (Kristin Skinner and Kamdyn Moore at Desi...
A Deep Dive Into Value and Outcomes (Kristin Skinner and Kamdyn Moore at Desi...
 
Time, Context and Causality in Recommender Systems
Time, Context and Causality in Recommender SystemsTime, Context and Causality in Recommender Systems
Time, Context and Causality in Recommender Systems
 
Space Ape's Live Ops Stack: Engineering Mobile Games for Live Ops from Day 1
Space Ape's Live Ops Stack: Engineering Mobile Games for Live Ops from Day 1Space Ape's Live Ops Stack: Engineering Mobile Games for Live Ops from Day 1
Space Ape's Live Ops Stack: Engineering Mobile Games for Live Ops from Day 1
 
Artwork Personalization at Netflix
Artwork Personalization at NetflixArtwork Personalization at Netflix
Artwork Personalization at Netflix
 
Supporting decisions with ML
Supporting decisions with MLSupporting decisions with ML
Supporting decisions with ML
 
Practical AI for Business: Bandit Algorithms
Practical AI for Business: Bandit AlgorithmsPractical AI for Business: Bandit Algorithms
Practical AI for Business: Bandit Algorithms
 
Correlation, causation and incrementally recommendation problems at netflix ...
Correlation, causation and incrementally  recommendation problems at netflix ...Correlation, causation and incrementally  recommendation problems at netflix ...
Correlation, causation and incrementally recommendation problems at netflix ...
 
Deeper Things: How Netflix Leverages Deep Learning in Recommendations and Se...
 Deeper Things: How Netflix Leverages Deep Learning in Recommendations and Se... Deeper Things: How Netflix Leverages Deep Learning in Recommendations and Se...
Deeper Things: How Netflix Leverages Deep Learning in Recommendations and Se...
 
Tableau Conference 2018: Binging on Data - Enabling Analytics at Netflix
Tableau Conference 2018: Binging on Data - Enabling Analytics at NetflixTableau Conference 2018: Binging on Data - Enabling Analytics at Netflix
Tableau Conference 2018: Binging on Data - Enabling Analytics at Netflix
 
Developing an effective LTV model at the soft launch and keeping it valid fur...
Developing an effective LTV model at the soft launch and keeping it valid fur...Developing an effective LTV model at the soft launch and keeping it valid fur...
Developing an effective LTV model at the soft launch and keeping it valid fur...
 

Viewers also liked

Enchanted Objects: The next wave of the web
Enchanted Objects: The next wave of the webEnchanted Objects: The next wave of the web
Enchanted Objects: The next wave of the web
David Rose
 
Building ZingMe News Feed System
Building ZingMe News Feed SystemBuilding ZingMe News Feed System
Building ZingMe News Feed System
Chau Thanh
 
Choose Boring Technology
Choose Boring TechnologyChoose Boring Technology
Choose Boring Technology
Dan McKinley
 
Sơ lược kiến trúc hệ thống Zing Me
Sơ lược kiến trúc hệ thống Zing MeSơ lược kiến trúc hệ thống Zing Me
Sơ lược kiến trúc hệ thống Zing Me
zingopen
 
Design a scalable social network: Problems and solutions
Design a scalable social network: Problems and solutionsDesign a scalable social network: Problems and solutions
Design a scalable social network: Problems and solutions
Chau Thanh
 
Inside Zalo: Developing a mobile messenger for the audience of millions - VN ...
Inside Zalo: Developing a mobile messenger for the audience of millions - VN ...Inside Zalo: Developing a mobile messenger for the audience of millions - VN ...
Inside Zalo: Developing a mobile messenger for the audience of millions - VN ...
Zalo_app
 
Etsy Activity Feeds Architecture
Etsy Activity Feeds ArchitectureEtsy Activity Feeds Architecture
Etsy Activity Feeds Architecture
Dan McKinley
 
Essentials of Product Management
Essentials of Product ManagementEssentials of Product Management
Essentials of Product Management
Janna Bastow
 
The Art of Product Management
The Art of Product ManagementThe Art of Product Management
The Art of Product Management
Sachin Rekhi
 
A Product Manager's Job
A Product Manager's JobA Product Manager's Job
A Product Manager's Job
joshelman
 

Viewers also liked (10)

Enchanted Objects: The next wave of the web
Enchanted Objects: The next wave of the webEnchanted Objects: The next wave of the web
Enchanted Objects: The next wave of the web
 
Building ZingMe News Feed System
Building ZingMe News Feed SystemBuilding ZingMe News Feed System
Building ZingMe News Feed System
 
Choose Boring Technology
Choose Boring TechnologyChoose Boring Technology
Choose Boring Technology
 
Sơ lược kiến trúc hệ thống Zing Me
Sơ lược kiến trúc hệ thống Zing MeSơ lược kiến trúc hệ thống Zing Me
Sơ lược kiến trúc hệ thống Zing Me
 
Design a scalable social network: Problems and solutions
Design a scalable social network: Problems and solutionsDesign a scalable social network: Problems and solutions
Design a scalable social network: Problems and solutions
 
Inside Zalo: Developing a mobile messenger for the audience of millions - VN ...
Inside Zalo: Developing a mobile messenger for the audience of millions - VN ...Inside Zalo: Developing a mobile messenger for the audience of millions - VN ...
Inside Zalo: Developing a mobile messenger for the audience of millions - VN ...
 
Etsy Activity Feeds Architecture
Etsy Activity Feeds ArchitectureEtsy Activity Feeds Architecture
Etsy Activity Feeds Architecture
 
Essentials of Product Management
Essentials of Product ManagementEssentials of Product Management
Essentials of Product Management
 
The Art of Product Management
The Art of Product ManagementThe Art of Product Management
The Art of Product Management
 
A Product Manager's Job
A Product Manager's JobA Product Manager's Job
A Product Manager's Job
 

Similar to Design for Continuous Experimentation

Big Data, Big Changes: Data-Driven Product Development at Etsy
Big Data, Big Changes: Data-Driven Product Development at EtsyBig Data, Big Changes: Data-Driven Product Development at Etsy
Big Data, Big Changes: Data-Driven Product Development at Etsy
Jason Davis
 
Data driven-products-now
Data driven-products-nowData driven-products-now
Data driven-products-now
Dan McKinley
 
Shift from Packaged Software to Hosted Services
Shift from Packaged Software to Hosted ServicesShift from Packaged Software to Hosted Services
Shift from Packaged Software to Hosted Services
SVPMA
 
Pet Startups or Create Your Own Pet Related Tech Startup!
Pet Startups or Create Your Own Pet Related Tech Startup!Pet Startups or Create Your Own Pet Related Tech Startup!
Pet Startups or Create Your Own Pet Related Tech Startup!
BarkWorld Expo
 
Game Product Discovery: Validation & Iteration
Game Product Discovery: Validation & IterationGame Product Discovery: Validation & Iteration
Game Product Discovery: Validation & Iteration
Martyn Jones
 
Validation and Iteration in Games - Martyn Jones
Validation and Iteration in Games - Martyn JonesValidation and Iteration in Games - Martyn Jones
Validation and Iteration in Games - Martyn Jones
Mind the Product
 
iOS Prototyping with Xcode Storyboards
iOS Prototyping with Xcode StoryboardsiOS Prototyping with Xcode Storyboards
iOS Prototyping with Xcode Storyboards
Kyle Oba
 
Turning Data Into Meaningful Insights
Turning Data Into Meaningful InsightsTurning Data Into Meaningful Insights
Turning Data Into Meaningful Insights
Mark Joseph L. Tan
 
13 0212 toccon - carpenter altmetrics 2
13 0212 toccon - carpenter altmetrics 213 0212 toccon - carpenter altmetrics 2
13 0212 toccon - carpenter altmetrics 2
National Information Standards Organization (NISO)
 
99 inception-deck
99 inception-deck99 inception-deck
99 inception-deck
drewz lin
 
Continous delivery
Continous deliveryContinous delivery
Continous delivery
Andrzej Grzesik
 
Creating Powerful Proposals - Groupmind, Inc.
Creating Powerful Proposals - Groupmind, Inc.Creating Powerful Proposals - Groupmind, Inc.
Creating Powerful Proposals - Groupmind, Inc.
John Sexton
 
The 4Cs in the 21st C
The 4Cs in the 21st CThe 4Cs in the 21st C
The 4Cs in the 21st C
Will Richardson
 
How to Get There - An Ideathon Toolkit
How to Get There - An Ideathon ToolkitHow to Get There - An Ideathon Toolkit
How to Get There - An Ideathon Toolkit
Daniel Teng
 
Class 2: Setting the foundation for a successful website design
Class 2: Setting the foundation for a successful website designClass 2: Setting the foundation for a successful website design
Class 2: Setting the foundation for a successful website design
Don Stanley
 
NCDevCon2012_designing the mobile experience
NCDevCon2012_designing the mobile experienceNCDevCon2012_designing the mobile experience
NCDevCon2012_designing the mobile experience
Dee Sadler
 
The Web Designers Toolkit
The Web Designers ToolkitThe Web Designers Toolkit
The Web Designers Toolkit
R/GA
 
Dan mc kinley_final
Dan mc kinley_finalDan mc kinley_final
Dan mc kinley_final
Lean Startup Co.
 
Scalding at Etsy
Scalding at EtsyScalding at Etsy
Scalding at Etsy
Dan McKinley
 
Beyond Milkshakes - Using JTBD for Innovation & Product Design
Beyond Milkshakes - Using JTBD for Innovation & Product DesignBeyond Milkshakes - Using JTBD for Innovation & Product Design
Beyond Milkshakes - Using JTBD for Innovation & Product Design
Redgate-Design
 

Similar to Design for Continuous Experimentation (20)

Big Data, Big Changes: Data-Driven Product Development at Etsy
Big Data, Big Changes: Data-Driven Product Development at EtsyBig Data, Big Changes: Data-Driven Product Development at Etsy
Big Data, Big Changes: Data-Driven Product Development at Etsy
 
Data driven-products-now
Data driven-products-nowData driven-products-now
Data driven-products-now
 
Shift from Packaged Software to Hosted Services
Shift from Packaged Software to Hosted ServicesShift from Packaged Software to Hosted Services
Shift from Packaged Software to Hosted Services
 
Pet Startups or Create Your Own Pet Related Tech Startup!
Pet Startups or Create Your Own Pet Related Tech Startup!Pet Startups or Create Your Own Pet Related Tech Startup!
Pet Startups or Create Your Own Pet Related Tech Startup!
 
Game Product Discovery: Validation & Iteration
Game Product Discovery: Validation & IterationGame Product Discovery: Validation & Iteration
Game Product Discovery: Validation & Iteration
 
Validation and Iteration in Games - Martyn Jones
Validation and Iteration in Games - Martyn JonesValidation and Iteration in Games - Martyn Jones
Validation and Iteration in Games - Martyn Jones
 
iOS Prototyping with Xcode Storyboards
iOS Prototyping with Xcode StoryboardsiOS Prototyping with Xcode Storyboards
iOS Prototyping with Xcode Storyboards
 
Turning Data Into Meaningful Insights
Turning Data Into Meaningful InsightsTurning Data Into Meaningful Insights
Turning Data Into Meaningful Insights
 
13 0212 toccon - carpenter altmetrics 2
13 0212 toccon - carpenter altmetrics 213 0212 toccon - carpenter altmetrics 2
13 0212 toccon - carpenter altmetrics 2
 
99 inception-deck
99 inception-deck99 inception-deck
99 inception-deck
 
Continous delivery
Continous deliveryContinous delivery
Continous delivery
 
Creating Powerful Proposals - Groupmind, Inc.
Creating Powerful Proposals - Groupmind, Inc.Creating Powerful Proposals - Groupmind, Inc.
Creating Powerful Proposals - Groupmind, Inc.
 
The 4Cs in the 21st C
The 4Cs in the 21st CThe 4Cs in the 21st C
The 4Cs in the 21st C
 
How to Get There - An Ideathon Toolkit
How to Get There - An Ideathon ToolkitHow to Get There - An Ideathon Toolkit
How to Get There - An Ideathon Toolkit
 
Class 2: Setting the foundation for a successful website design
Class 2: Setting the foundation for a successful website designClass 2: Setting the foundation for a successful website design
Class 2: Setting the foundation for a successful website design
 
NCDevCon2012_designing the mobile experience
NCDevCon2012_designing the mobile experienceNCDevCon2012_designing the mobile experience
NCDevCon2012_designing the mobile experience
 
The Web Designers Toolkit
The Web Designers ToolkitThe Web Designers Toolkit
The Web Designers Toolkit
 
Dan mc kinley_final
Dan mc kinley_finalDan mc kinley_final
Dan mc kinley_final
 
Scalding at Etsy
Scalding at EtsyScalding at Etsy
Scalding at Etsy
 
Beyond Milkshakes - Using JTBD for Innovation & Product Design
Beyond Milkshakes - Using JTBD for Innovation & Product DesignBeyond Milkshakes - Using JTBD for Innovation & Product Design
Beyond Milkshakes - Using JTBD for Innovation & Product Design
 

Recently uploaded

Poznań ACE event - 19.06.2024 Team 24 Wrapup slidedeck
Poznań ACE event - 19.06.2024 Team 24 Wrapup slidedeckPoznań ACE event - 19.06.2024 Team 24 Wrapup slidedeck
Poznań ACE event - 19.06.2024 Team 24 Wrapup slidedeck
FilipTomaszewski5
 
GNSS spoofing via SDR (Criptored Talks 2024)
GNSS spoofing via SDR (Criptored Talks 2024)GNSS spoofing via SDR (Criptored Talks 2024)
GNSS spoofing via SDR (Criptored Talks 2024)
Javier Junquera
 
JavaLand 2024: Application Development Green Masterplan
JavaLand 2024: Application Development Green MasterplanJavaLand 2024: Application Development Green Masterplan
JavaLand 2024: Application Development Green Masterplan
Miro Wengner
 
GraphRAG for LifeSciences Hands-On with the Clinical Knowledge Graph
GraphRAG for LifeSciences Hands-On with the Clinical Knowledge GraphGraphRAG for LifeSciences Hands-On with the Clinical Knowledge Graph
GraphRAG for LifeSciences Hands-On with the Clinical Knowledge Graph
Neo4j
 
GlobalLogic Java Community Webinar #18 “How to Improve Web Application Perfor...
GlobalLogic Java Community Webinar #18 “How to Improve Web Application Perfor...GlobalLogic Java Community Webinar #18 “How to Improve Web Application Perfor...
GlobalLogic Java Community Webinar #18 “How to Improve Web Application Perfor...
GlobalLogic Ukraine
 
Christine's Supplier Sourcing Presentaion.pptx
Christine's Supplier Sourcing Presentaion.pptxChristine's Supplier Sourcing Presentaion.pptx
Christine's Supplier Sourcing Presentaion.pptx
christinelarrosa
 
Mutation Testing for Task-Oriented Chatbots
Mutation Testing for Task-Oriented ChatbotsMutation Testing for Task-Oriented Chatbots
Mutation Testing for Task-Oriented Chatbots
Pablo Gómez Abajo
 
What is an RPA CoE? Session 2 – CoE Roles
What is an RPA CoE?  Session 2 – CoE RolesWhat is an RPA CoE?  Session 2 – CoE Roles
What is an RPA CoE? Session 2 – CoE Roles
DianaGray10
 
Day 2 - Intro to UiPath Studio Fundamentals
Day 2 - Intro to UiPath Studio FundamentalsDay 2 - Intro to UiPath Studio Fundamentals
Day 2 - Intro to UiPath Studio Fundamentals
UiPathCommunity
 
AI in the Workplace Reskilling, Upskilling, and Future Work.pptx
AI in the Workplace Reskilling, Upskilling, and Future Work.pptxAI in the Workplace Reskilling, Upskilling, and Future Work.pptx
AI in the Workplace Reskilling, Upskilling, and Future Work.pptx
Sunil Jagani
 
Northern Engraving | Nameplate Manufacturing Process - 2024
Northern Engraving | Nameplate Manufacturing Process - 2024Northern Engraving | Nameplate Manufacturing Process - 2024
Northern Engraving | Nameplate Manufacturing Process - 2024
Northern Engraving
 
Demystifying Knowledge Management through Storytelling
Demystifying Knowledge Management through StorytellingDemystifying Knowledge Management through Storytelling
Demystifying Knowledge Management through Storytelling
Enterprise Knowledge
 
Connector Corner: Seamlessly power UiPath Apps, GenAI with prebuilt connectors
Connector Corner: Seamlessly power UiPath Apps, GenAI with prebuilt connectorsConnector Corner: Seamlessly power UiPath Apps, GenAI with prebuilt connectors
Connector Corner: Seamlessly power UiPath Apps, GenAI with prebuilt connectors
DianaGray10
 
Discover the Unseen: Tailored Recommendation of Unwatched Content
Discover the Unseen: Tailored Recommendation of Unwatched ContentDiscover the Unseen: Tailored Recommendation of Unwatched Content
Discover the Unseen: Tailored Recommendation of Unwatched Content
ScyllaDB
 
Apps Break Data
Apps Break DataApps Break Data
Apps Break Data
Ivo Velitchkov
 
What is an RPA CoE? Session 1 – CoE Vision
What is an RPA CoE?  Session 1 – CoE VisionWhat is an RPA CoE?  Session 1 – CoE Vision
What is an RPA CoE? Session 1 – CoE Vision
DianaGray10
 
"Frontline Battles with DDoS: Best practices and Lessons Learned", Igor Ivaniuk
"Frontline Battles with DDoS: Best practices and Lessons Learned",  Igor Ivaniuk"Frontline Battles with DDoS: Best practices and Lessons Learned",  Igor Ivaniuk
"Frontline Battles with DDoS: Best practices and Lessons Learned", Igor Ivaniuk
Fwdays
 
"NATO Hackathon Winner: AI-Powered Drug Search", Taras Kloba
"NATO Hackathon Winner: AI-Powered Drug Search",  Taras Kloba"NATO Hackathon Winner: AI-Powered Drug Search",  Taras Kloba
"NATO Hackathon Winner: AI-Powered Drug Search", Taras Kloba
Fwdays
 
[OReilly Superstream] Occupy the Space: A grassroots guide to engineering (an...
[OReilly Superstream] Occupy the Space: A grassroots guide to engineering (an...[OReilly Superstream] Occupy the Space: A grassroots guide to engineering (an...
[OReilly Superstream] Occupy the Space: A grassroots guide to engineering (an...
Jason Yip
 
Astute Business Solutions | Oracle Cloud Partner |
Astute Business Solutions | Oracle Cloud Partner |Astute Business Solutions | Oracle Cloud Partner |
Astute Business Solutions | Oracle Cloud Partner |
AstuteBusiness
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Poznań ACE event - 19.06.2024 Team 24 Wrapup slidedeck
Poznań ACE event - 19.06.2024 Team 24 Wrapup slidedeckPoznań ACE event - 19.06.2024 Team 24 Wrapup slidedeck
Poznań ACE event - 19.06.2024 Team 24 Wrapup slidedeck
 
GNSS spoofing via SDR (Criptored Talks 2024)
GNSS spoofing via SDR (Criptored Talks 2024)GNSS spoofing via SDR (Criptored Talks 2024)
GNSS spoofing via SDR (Criptored Talks 2024)
 
JavaLand 2024: Application Development Green Masterplan
JavaLand 2024: Application Development Green MasterplanJavaLand 2024: Application Development Green Masterplan
JavaLand 2024: Application Development Green Masterplan
 
GraphRAG for LifeSciences Hands-On with the Clinical Knowledge Graph
GraphRAG for LifeSciences Hands-On with the Clinical Knowledge GraphGraphRAG for LifeSciences Hands-On with the Clinical Knowledge Graph
GraphRAG for LifeSciences Hands-On with the Clinical Knowledge Graph
 
GlobalLogic Java Community Webinar #18 “How to Improve Web Application Perfor...
GlobalLogic Java Community Webinar #18 “How to Improve Web Application Perfor...GlobalLogic Java Community Webinar #18 “How to Improve Web Application Perfor...
GlobalLogic Java Community Webinar #18 “How to Improve Web Application Perfor...
 
Christine's Supplier Sourcing Presentaion.pptx
Christine's Supplier Sourcing Presentaion.pptxChristine's Supplier Sourcing Presentaion.pptx
Christine's Supplier Sourcing Presentaion.pptx
 
Mutation Testing for Task-Oriented Chatbots
Mutation Testing for Task-Oriented ChatbotsMutation Testing for Task-Oriented Chatbots
Mutation Testing for Task-Oriented Chatbots
 
What is an RPA CoE? Session 2 – CoE Roles
What is an RPA CoE?  Session 2 – CoE RolesWhat is an RPA CoE?  Session 2 – CoE Roles
What is an RPA CoE? Session 2 – CoE Roles
 
Day 2 - Intro to UiPath Studio Fundamentals
Day 2 - Intro to UiPath Studio FundamentalsDay 2 - Intro to UiPath Studio Fundamentals
Day 2 - Intro to UiPath Studio Fundamentals
 
AI in the Workplace Reskilling, Upskilling, and Future Work.pptx
AI in the Workplace Reskilling, Upskilling, and Future Work.pptxAI in the Workplace Reskilling, Upskilling, and Future Work.pptx
AI in the Workplace Reskilling, Upskilling, and Future Work.pptx
 
Northern Engraving | Nameplate Manufacturing Process - 2024
Northern Engraving | Nameplate Manufacturing Process - 2024Northern Engraving | Nameplate Manufacturing Process - 2024
Northern Engraving | Nameplate Manufacturing Process - 2024
 
Demystifying Knowledge Management through Storytelling
Demystifying Knowledge Management through StorytellingDemystifying Knowledge Management through Storytelling
Demystifying Knowledge Management through Storytelling
 
Connector Corner: Seamlessly power UiPath Apps, GenAI with prebuilt connectors
Connector Corner: Seamlessly power UiPath Apps, GenAI with prebuilt connectorsConnector Corner: Seamlessly power UiPath Apps, GenAI with prebuilt connectors
Connector Corner: Seamlessly power UiPath Apps, GenAI with prebuilt connectors
 
Discover the Unseen: Tailored Recommendation of Unwatched Content
Discover the Unseen: Tailored Recommendation of Unwatched ContentDiscover the Unseen: Tailored Recommendation of Unwatched Content
Discover the Unseen: Tailored Recommendation of Unwatched Content
 
Apps Break Data
Apps Break DataApps Break Data
Apps Break Data
 
What is an RPA CoE? Session 1 – CoE Vision
What is an RPA CoE?  Session 1 – CoE VisionWhat is an RPA CoE?  Session 1 – CoE Vision
What is an RPA CoE? Session 1 – CoE Vision
 
"Frontline Battles with DDoS: Best practices and Lessons Learned", Igor Ivaniuk
"Frontline Battles with DDoS: Best practices and Lessons Learned",  Igor Ivaniuk"Frontline Battles with DDoS: Best practices and Lessons Learned",  Igor Ivaniuk
"Frontline Battles with DDoS: Best practices and Lessons Learned", Igor Ivaniuk
 
"NATO Hackathon Winner: AI-Powered Drug Search", Taras Kloba
"NATO Hackathon Winner: AI-Powered Drug Search",  Taras Kloba"NATO Hackathon Winner: AI-Powered Drug Search",  Taras Kloba
"NATO Hackathon Winner: AI-Powered Drug Search", Taras Kloba
 
[OReilly Superstream] Occupy the Space: A grassroots guide to engineering (an...
[OReilly Superstream] Occupy the Space: A grassroots guide to engineering (an...[OReilly Superstream] Occupy the Space: A grassroots guide to engineering (an...
[OReilly Superstream] Occupy the Space: A grassroots guide to engineering (an...
 
Astute Business Solutions | Oracle Cloud Partner |
Astute Business Solutions | Oracle Cloud Partner |Astute Business Solutions | Oracle Cloud Partner |
Astute Business Solutions | Oracle Cloud Partner |
 

Design for Continuous Experimentation

  • 1. Design for Continuous Experimentation Dan McKinley Principal Engineer, Etsy November 30th, 2012 Sunday, December 2, 12 Hi my name’s Dan McKinley
  • 2. www. .com Sunday, December 2, 12 and I’m here from etsy.com
  • 3. The world’s handmade and vintage marketplace. Sunday, December 2, 12 Etsy is the world’s handmade and vintage marketplace.
  • 4. Sunday, December 2, 12 Etsy’s a place where you can buy all kinds of things, including handmade crafts like this sampler
  • 5. Sunday, December 2, 12 ... or this vintage credenza ...
  • 6. Sunday, December 2, 12 ... and rhinestone-studded underwear made of beef jerky ...
  • 7. Sunday, December 2, 12 Beef jerky underwear is reasonably popular apparently. we’re on track to sell between $800MM and 900MM in goods this year. This makes us about as big as Hot Topic.
  • 8. OCTOBER 2012 1.5 billion page views 55 million unique visitors USD $83 million in transactions 4.2 million items sold http://www.etsy.com/blog/news/?s=weather+report Sunday, December 2, 12 We had about 1.5B page views in October which makes us a reasonably large website.
  • 9. We love experiments. Sunday, December 2, 12 At Etsy, we love experiments and A/B testing. And that’s the main thing I want to talk about today.
  • 10. Tons of active A/B tests and rampups. Sunday, December 2, 12 Here’s a screenshot of an internal view of the various tests and config rampups running on just one of our pages. As you can see, there are a whole lot of them.
  • 11. Sunday, December 2, 12 We’ve invested plenty of time and effort into tooling to support this work. This is a screenshot of our A/B analyzer, which automatically generates a dashboard with important business metrics for every configured test.
  • 12. Sunday, December 2, 12 We’ve built tools that protect us from some gnarly statistics. This wizard does the math for you and lets you know how long an experiment will need to run in order to have a significant result.
  • 13. Continuous Experimentation Small, measurable changes. Keeps us honest. Prevents us from breaking things. Sunday, December 2, 12 I’m going to call what we do “continuous experimentation,” for the lack of a better term. We try to make small changes as much as possible, and we measure those changes so that we stay honest and don’t break the site.
  • 14. Seung yun Yoo Seoul, South Korea knifeinthewater.etsy.com http://www.etsy.com/blog/en/2012/featured-shop-knife-in-the-water/ Sunday, December 2, 12 So what do I mean by “breaking the site?” Well, behind every Etsy shop is a person that depends on it, and counts on us not to push changes that hurt their business. So we would be remiss not to measure our changes.
  • 15. Etsy Sales: Two Scenarios Good product release Awful product release Sunday, December 2, 12 The second reason we measure product releases is so that we stay honest. Much of Etsy’s sales are seller-driven, so our graphs currently tend to go up no matter what. Obviously that can’t continue forever. But we have to use A/B testing to tell if we’ve made things worse or better.
  • 16. Another reason we measure: Sunday, December 2, 12
  • 17. Another reason we measure: Experimental results are surprising! Sunday, December 2, 12
  • 18. “When I am comparison shopping, I open items in new tabs. We should do that on Etsy.” - Typical know-it-all Etsy employee Sunday, December 2, 12 Let me give you an example. A few years ago there was controversy internally at Etsy over whether or not items should open up in new tabs. Some Etsy employees do this themselves when they’re digging through search results, and they wish that it happened by default. They thought that the average user would be happier if this were the case.
  • 19. Sunday, December 2, 12 So we eventually stopped arguing about this and just tried it. We ran an A/B test that opened up items in new tabs.
  • 20. The Horrible Sound of Epic Failure credit: EmbroideryEverywhere.etsy.com Sunday, December 2, 12 When we tried that, 70% more people gave up and left the site after getting a new tab. Maybe some Etsy employees know how to use tabs in a browser, but my grandmother doesn’t. We’ve replicated this result more than once.
  • 21. Surprise! Sunday, December 2, 12 Surprise! We don’t argue about that anymore.
  • 22. One big thing we’ve learned from experiments: Sunday, December 2, 12 We’ve been at this for a while and one of the main things we’ve learned from this, which is the main thing I want to talk about today,
  • 23. Design and product process must change to accommodate experimentation. Sunday, December 2, 12 is that process has to change to accommodate data and experimentation. If you follow a waterfall process and try to bolt A/B testing onto it, you will fail
  • 24. Removing the Search Infinite Scroll Dropdown Sunday, December 2, 12 to illustrate this I want to go through two projects that we’ve done
  • 25. Removing the Search Infinite Scroll Dropdown Monolithic release. Multi-stage release. Effort up front. Iterative. Changes many things at once. One thing at a time. A/B test as a hurdle. A/B testing integral to process. Assumptions. Hypotheses. Sunday, December 2, 12 These were two projects done largely by the same team. Infinite scroll was poorly managed, and a release removing a dropdown in our site header was well managed.
  • 26. Infinite Scroll So hot right now. Sunday, December 2, 12 First I’ll go through our deployment of infinite scroll in search results.
  • 27. Woah Sunday, December 2, 12 If anyone doesn’t know what I mean by infinite scroll: I mean that we changed search results so that as you scroll down, more items load in, indefinitely.
  • 28. Seeing more items faster is presumed to be a better experience. Sunday, December 2, 12 The reason we did this was because we thought that it obvious that more items, faster was a better experience. There’s a lot of web lore out there to that effect, based mostly on some findings Google’s made in their own search.
  • 29. Infinite Scroll: Release Plan (Implied) 1. Build infinite scroll. 2. Fix some bugs. 3. A/B to measure obvious big improvement. 4. Rent warehouse. 5. Hold release party in warehouse. Sunday, December 2, 12 So when we decided to do this we just went for it. We designed and built the feature, and then we figured we’d release it and it’d be great.
  • 30. Infinite Scroll: Results Sunday, December 2, 12 so the results,
  • 31. Infinite Scroll: Results Spoiler: they were not expected. Sunday, December 2, 12 not to spoil the surprise, were not what we were expecting.
  • 32. Infinite Scroll: Results Median item impressions: Infinite scroll: 40 Control group: 80 Sunday, December 2, 12 People who had infinite scroll saw fewer items in search results than people in the control group, not more.
  • 33. Infinite Scroll: Results Visitors seeing infinite scroll clicked fewer results than the control. Sunday, December 2, 12 they clicked on fewer items.
  • 34. Infinite Scroll: Results Visitors seeing infinite scroll saved fewer items as favorites. Sunday, December 2, 12 they saved fewer items as favorites.
  • 35. Infinite Scroll: Results Visitors seeing infinite scroll purchased fewer items from search* Sunday, December 2, 12 They bought fewer items from search. Now they didn’t buy fewer items overall, they just stopped using search to find those items. Which is kind of interesting. It was clear we’d made search worse.
  • 36. Initial reaction: “something’s broken.” Sunday, December 2, 12 The first thing that occurred to us is that there must have been bugs in the product that we missed. So we spent a month trying to figure out if that was the case. We sliced results by browser and geographic location. We sent a guy to a public library to try using an ancient computer. We did find some bugs, but none of them changed the overall results.
  • 37. Gradual, horrible realization: “we changed many things at once.” Sunday, December 2, 12 Eventually we came to terms with the fact that infinite scroll had made the product worse, and we had changed too many things in the process to have any clue which was the culprit.
  • 38. Premise-validating Experiments Or: “things we should have done in the first place.” Sunday, December 2, 12 So, we were in a situation where we weren’t sure if we should continue working on this or not. Even if we had issues in IE or something, the behavior of people using Chrome wasn’t way better, it was also worse. How do we know if it’s a good idea to finish this or not? So we went back and tried to verify that the premises that made us do this were right.
  • 39. Are more items in search results better? Sunday, December 2, 12 First of all, is it true that more items is better?
  • 40. Sunday, December 2, 12 We ran a test where we just varied the number of results in normal search results.
  • 41. Are more items in search results better? Barely, maybe: more people get to an item page as the result count increases. Absolutely no change in purchases. Sunday, December 2, 12 And the answer was yes, maybe a little bit, but only barely. There was a very slight improvement in the number of people that ever got to a item page. But the effect is very slight, and purchases aren’t sensitive to this. There’s no increase in purchases when we increase the number of search results.
  • 42. Are faster results better? Sunday, December 2, 12 The other major premise was that faster search results would stop people from getting bored, and they’d buy more as a result.
  • 43. Sunday, December 2, 12 We ran a test where we slowed down search artificially, by adding sleeps().
  • 44. Are faster results better? Meh Sunday, December 2, 12 Absolutely nothing happened. Which isn’t to say that performance is pointless, but people buying items don’t seem to be sensitive to performance at all.
  • 45. credit: LunaLetterpress.etsy.com Sunday, December 2, 12 In the end the expected benefits to infinite scroll just didn’t seem to be there. Our premises were wrong. So we took infinite scroll out back and we shot it.
  • 46. Infinite Scroll: Release Plan (Implied) 1. Build infinite scroll. Lots of work 2. Fix some bugs. 3. A/B to measure obvious big improvement. 4. Rent warehouse. 5. Hold release party in warehouse. Didn’t happen Sunday, December 2, 12 So if we go back to our “product plan,” we see a couple of major things wrong with it. We did a lot of work, and it was pointless.
  • 47. A Slightly Better Infinite Scroll Release Plan 1. Validate premise: more items is better (easy) 2. Validate premise: faster is better (easy) 3. Either: A. Abort! (easy) B. Build infinite scroll (hard). Sunday, December 2, 12 A better way to have done this would have been to validate those premises ahead of time and then make the call. But we didn’t do that.
  • 48. Throwing out work sucks. Sunday, December 2, 12 Throwing out work feels really horrible. Most of the time this is a really difficult choice to make, and without a lot of honesty and discipline, most teams aren’t going to do it. We are not very rational creatures in the face of sunk costs.
  • 49. Infinite scroll: not stupid. Sunday, December 2, 12 My point is not that infinite scroll is stupid. It may be great on your website. But we should have done a better job of understanding the people using our website.
  • 50. Removing the Search Dropdown A much better experience for me, personally. Sunday, December 2, 12 So that was a bad release. I want to change gears now and go through a good one.
  • 51. 2007 Sunday, December 2, 12 Pretty early on, we added this dropdown to the header, mainly to pick between handmade items and vintage items. It wasn’t intended to be permanent.
  • 52. 2012 Sunday, December 2, 12 But as these things always do, it got way out of hand. It looked like this five years later.
  • 53. Kill the Dropdown: Project Plan 1. Redesign marketplace facets. 2. Default to “all items.” 3. Rich autosuggest. 4. Suggest shops in item results. 5. Add favorites filter to search results. 6. Search bars on item and shop pages. 7. Kill the dropdown. Sunday, December 2, 12 So we wanted to remove this thing. Chastened by the infinite scroll release, we did our best to plan this out in smaller steps.
  • 54. Kill the Dropdown: Project Plan 1. Redesign marketplace facets. 2. Default to “all items.” Short. 3. Rich autosuggest. Measurable. 4. Suggest shops in item results. Isolated. 5. Add favorites filter to search results. 6. Search bars on item and shop pages. 7. Kill the dropdown. Sunday, December 2, 12 Each of these steps is small and isolated.
  • 55. Kill the Dropdown: Project Plan 1. Redesign marketplace facets. 2. Default to “all items.” Opportunity 3. Rich autosuggest. to change 4. Suggest shops in item results. plans. 5. Add favorites filter to search results. 6. Search bars on item and shop pages. 7. Kill the dropdown. Sunday, December 2, 12 Each step is an opportunity to get real feedback and change directions if we have to.
  • 56. Kill the Dropdown: Project Plan 1. Redesign marketplace facets. 2. Default to “all items.” 3. Rich autosuggest. 4. Suggest shops in item results. 5. Add favorites filter to search results. 6. Search bars on item and shop pages. 7. Kill the dropdown. Ambitious design goal, never out of sight. Sunday, December 2, 12 And all of the individual releases were small, but the overall design goal was still ambitious.
  • 57. Sunday, December 2, 12 So, the first thing we had to address was the fact that the dropdown was used to cut the marketplace by different item types.
  • 58. HYPOTHESIS: Most users of the site don’t know anything about this. Sunday, December 2, 12 We were working from a hypothesis that most people using Etsy don’t even notice this. But again, we had to verify this.
  • 59. Sunday, December 2, 12 First we introduced this faceting on the left side of search results, and made it more obvious. This relatively simple and it was an improvement over the old design that nobody used.
  • 60. Sunday, December 2, 12 But still, relatively few people noticed that. So we also built faceting into our autosuggest. We made it possible to drill down into categories as you typed.
  • 61. Sales of Vintage Items: +3.7% Sunday, December 2, 12 After we did this, sales of vintage items without the dropdown in place increased almost 4%. So we increased the ability of buyers on Etsy to find vintage goods, we didn’t decrease it. Which is a great thing to be able to tell our community.
  • 62. VERIFIED HYPOTHESIS: Casual users of the site don’t know anything about this. Sunday, December 2, 12 So we were right. Most people using the site in fact did not know how to use the dropdown for this.
  • 63. Context-sensitive! Sunday, December 2, 12 Another horrible behavior of the search dropdown was that it was context-sensitive. So if you were on a shop page it defaulted to searching within the shop. And in some other situations it would search for people.
  • 64. HYPOTHESIS: Casual users of the site don’t realize this. Sunday, December 2, 12 So again, we figured that this was too complicated and nobody realized what was happening.
  • 65. Sunday, December 2, 12 To contend with this we introduced a secondary search box on shop pages so that people could do a search scoped to just the shop. This worked a lot better.
  • 66. Sunday, December 2, 12 We also tried adding this search bar to the item page. But few people used it and those who did performed very poorly.
  • 67. Sunday, December 2, 12 So we took that part out. If we had done the whole project all at once, we probably would not have noticed that this detail sucked.
  • 68. Sunday, December 2, 12 Another thing the search dropdown could be used for was searching for shops. Nobody used it.
  • 69. Sunday, December 2, 12 So we added shops suggestions to item results and made sure more people could find shops
  • 70. ...plus five or ten other things on the same scale. Sunday, December 2, 12 So you more or less get the idea here. We had a big goal, which we could have been unmanageable as a single release. We did it as ten or fifteen small releases.
  • 71. Data was involved at every step. Sunday, December 2, 12
  • 72. Infinite Scroll Design Develop Measure ಠ_ಠ Dropdown Redesign ✓ ✓ ✗ ✓ ... Design Develop Measure Sunday, December 2, 12 Contrasting the two release plans, infinite scroll was a big bet that didn’t work out. The dropdown redesign was a series of small bets: some worked and some didn’t, but we didn’t have to throw out everything when things didn’t work
  • 73. Some Advice Sunday, December 2, 12 I want to leave you with some parting advice.
  • 74. Experiment with minimal versions of your idea. Sunday, December 2, 12 Experiment with a minimal version first. With infinite scroll, we should have verified the premises.
  • 75. Plan on being wrong. Sunday, December 2, 12 Plan on being wrong. If you measure, you’ll encounter many counterintuitive results.
  • 77. This will not always work. Occasionally, you may need to make big bets on redesigns. Sunday, December 2, 12 This is not always going to work: you may still have to make big bets on big redesigns sometimes.
  • 78. ...but it usually does. Sunday, December 2, 12 But if you’re throwing this card down all the time you’re probably doing it wrong
  • 79. Thank you. Dan McKinley dan@etsy.com Sunday, December 2, 12 thanks