The Banking Industry Chessboard
May 30, 2013
Market Capitalization: $5.949 trillion
The global banking industry weakened somewhat from a Mergers and Acquisitions
perspective, while net market capitalization increased by $51B during May, although we
saw conflicting regional trends. US banks generally improved, and Japanese banks took a
nosedive. In Europe we saw improvement, while emerging markets were mixed.
A major acquisition failure occurred in the UK, where the Co-operative Bank was set to
take over the Lloyds retail branch network. Loan losses from Britannia, a 2009 acquisition
engaged in mortgage lending surfaced out of the blue, leading to a debt downgrade. It
seems that the acquisition may have slowed the reporting of loan losses, but this will not
be clear until we gain further insight. We downgraded Co-operative Bank from Acquirer to
Performer rating during May, but we are urging caution, as reporting issues must be
investigated. Even if losses were to be confirmed at GBP 0.8bn, we believe the bank would
remain a Performer. It is hard to tell in the early stages of scandal what the undisclosed
elements may represent. At this time, we maintain our Performer rating. The case
illustrates the execution risk in the Mergers and Acquisition game.
PHIMARK Global Index: 137(-2.1%)
Acquirers: 85 (+25)
Performers: 207 (-15)
Management Change: 75 (- 3)
Acquisition Target: 120 (-12)
Distressed: 9 (- 1)
Total coverage: 496 (- 6)
Top 10 Banks in Each M&A Classification Category
Management Acquisition
Acquirer Performer Change Target Distressed
Commonwealth Bank ofAustralia Wells Fargo & Co Citigroup Inc. Bank ofAmericaCorp FNMA
Royal Bank ofCanada Industrial and Commercial BankofChina Bank ofChina Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group BancaPiccolo Credito Valtellinese
Itau Unibanco Holding SA HSBC Holdingsplc Goldman SachsGroup, Inc. Banco Santander, S.A. CyprusPopular Bank Public Co Ltd
Westpac Banking Corporation ChinaConstruction Bank Corporation LloydsBanking Group PLC BarclaysPLC Sparebanken Vest
Banco Bradesco SA JPMorgan Chase & Co. Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group BNP Paribas BancaPopolare dell'Etruriae del Lazio
Australia& New Zealand Banking Group Toronto-Dominion Bank Bank ofCommunications Co Ltd Deutsche BankAG SpareBank 1 Buskerud Vestfold
Allied Irish Banks Bank ofNovaScotia Banco Bilbao VizcayaArgentaria Banco Santander Brasil Dexia
BankCentral Asia National AustraliaBankLimited Morgan Stanley ING Groep N.V. SpareBank 1 Notteroy Tonsberg
HDFC Bank Limited U.S. Bancorp Mizuho Financial Group Inc. Royal Bank ofScotland Group Sparebanken Pluss
Pacific & Western Credit Corp UBS AG PNC Financial ServicesGroup Societe Generale Proton Bank
Top 10 Acquirer Banks
The following banks were upgraded from Performer to
Acquirer rating
The Co-operative Bank was the only downgrade among
the Top 10 from April.
Hang Seng Bank, Bank Mandiri and Bank Rakyat
Indonesia are still rated Acquirer, but were overtaken in
the rankings.
Acquirer
Commonwealth Bank ofAustralia
Royal Bank ofCanada
Itau Unibanco Holding SA
Westpac Banking Corporation
Banco Bradesco SA
Australia& New Zealand Banking Group
Allied Irish Banks
Bank Central Asia
HDFC Bank Limited
Pacific & Western Credit Corp
Australiaand New Zealand Banking Group
Itau Unibanco Holding
Banco Bradesco
Top 10 Performer Banks
Performer
WellsFargo & Co
Industrial and Commercial Bank ofChina
HSBC Holdingsplc
ChinaConstruction Bank Corporation
JPMorgan Chase & Co.
Toronto-Dominion Bank
BankofNovaScotia
National AustraliaBank Limited
U.S. Bancorp
UBS AG
Top 10 Management Change Rated Banks
JP Morgan Chase was upgraded to Performer rating,
after Jamie Dimon survived challenges from investors
wishing to strip him of the Chairman title. The bank
delivered on promises and the market voted massively
for Dimon, bidding up the value of the bank.
Blankfein of Goldman Sachs is the highest paid bank CEO
in America. Blankfein replaced the CFO at the end of
January this year, following two executive appointments
last year. Likely upgrade shortly.
Credit Suisse Group was also upgraded to Performer
rating.
The changes in Japanese monetary policy was sold as a
positive for the economy, but banks generally declined in
value and look weak from a Mergers and Acquisitions
perspective. We downgraded Mitsubishi UFJ Financial
Group to Acquisition Target rating.
Citigroup, Lloyds Banking Group and Morgan Stanley
were all upgraded from Acquisition Target to
Management Change rating during the month.
Management
Change
Citigroup Inc.
Bank ofChina
Goldman SachsGroup, Inc.
LloydsBanking Group PLC
Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group
Bank ofCommunicationsCo Ltd
Banco Bilbao VizcayaArgentaria
Morgan Stanley
Mizuho Financial Group Inc.
PNC Financial ServicesGroup
Top 10 Acquisition Target Rated Banks
Banco Santander Brasil was downgraded from
Management Change to Acquisition Target in May.
As C, Lloyds, and MS were upgraded, Royal Bank of
Scotland and Societe Generale rose into the top 10.
Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group was downgraded from
Management Change, leading the trend in Japan.
Acquisition
Target
Bank ofAmericaCorp
Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group
Banco Santander, S.A.
BarclaysPLC
BNP Paribas
Deutsche Bank AG
Banco Santander Brasil
ING Groep N.V.
Royal Bank ofScotland Group
Societe Generale
Top 10 Distressed Rated Banks
Central Arizona Bank, Scottsdale, AZ with approximately
$31.6 million in total assets and $30.8 million in total
deposits was closed. Western State Bank has agreed to
assume all deposits.
Sunrise Bank, Valdosta, GA with approximately
$60.8 million in total assets and $57.8 million in total
deposits was closed. Synovus Bank has agreed to
assume all deposits.
Pisgah Community Bank, Asheville, NC with
approximately $21.9 million in total assets and $21.2
million in total deposits was closed. Capital Bank, N.A.
has agreed to assume all deposits.
Distressed
FNMA
BancaPiccolo Credito Valtellinese
CyprusPopular Bank Public Co Ltd
Sparebanken Vest
BancaPopolare dell'Etruriae del Lazio
SpareBank 1 Buskerud Vestfold
Dexia
SpareBank 1 Notteroy Tonsberg
Sparebanken Pluss
Proton Bank
Watch-list:
Troubled banks that
could go into distress
ECB Financial Stability Review – Further
decline in bank profitability, linked to
credit losses and a weak macroeconomic
environment is the primary risk, and
rising.
• Caisse Régionale de Crédit Agricole de Normandie-Seine
• Alpha Bank SA
• Sandnes Sparebank
• Caisse Regionale de Credit Agricole Mutuel de la Loire-Haute-Loire
• Banca Popolare di Spoleto
• Caisse Regionale de Credit Agricole Mutuel Toulouse 31
• Cecil Bancorp
• Banco Popolare
• CRCAM Nord de France
• Caisse Régionale de Crédit Agricole Mutuel de La Touraine et du
Poitou
• Credit Agricole Brie Picardie
• Crédit Agricole d'Ille-et-Vilaine
• Crédit Agricole Sud Rhône Alpes
• Caisse Regionale de Credit Agricole Mutuel Alpes Provence
• Credit Agricole du Morbihan
Trond Johannessen
Director
Phimark BV
+31 620 59 1015
trond@blackwolfbv.com

The banking chessboard 20130531

  • 1.
    The Banking IndustryChessboard May 30, 2013 Market Capitalization: $5.949 trillion The global banking industry weakened somewhat from a Mergers and Acquisitions perspective, while net market capitalization increased by $51B during May, although we saw conflicting regional trends. US banks generally improved, and Japanese banks took a nosedive. In Europe we saw improvement, while emerging markets were mixed. A major acquisition failure occurred in the UK, where the Co-operative Bank was set to take over the Lloyds retail branch network. Loan losses from Britannia, a 2009 acquisition engaged in mortgage lending surfaced out of the blue, leading to a debt downgrade. It seems that the acquisition may have slowed the reporting of loan losses, but this will not be clear until we gain further insight. We downgraded Co-operative Bank from Acquirer to Performer rating during May, but we are urging caution, as reporting issues must be investigated. Even if losses were to be confirmed at GBP 0.8bn, we believe the bank would remain a Performer. It is hard to tell in the early stages of scandal what the undisclosed elements may represent. At this time, we maintain our Performer rating. The case illustrates the execution risk in the Mergers and Acquisition game. PHIMARK Global Index: 137(-2.1%) Acquirers: 85 (+25) Performers: 207 (-15) Management Change: 75 (- 3) Acquisition Target: 120 (-12) Distressed: 9 (- 1) Total coverage: 496 (- 6)
  • 2.
    Top 10 Banksin Each M&A Classification Category Management Acquisition Acquirer Performer Change Target Distressed Commonwealth Bank ofAustralia Wells Fargo & Co Citigroup Inc. Bank ofAmericaCorp FNMA Royal Bank ofCanada Industrial and Commercial BankofChina Bank ofChina Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group BancaPiccolo Credito Valtellinese Itau Unibanco Holding SA HSBC Holdingsplc Goldman SachsGroup, Inc. Banco Santander, S.A. CyprusPopular Bank Public Co Ltd Westpac Banking Corporation ChinaConstruction Bank Corporation LloydsBanking Group PLC BarclaysPLC Sparebanken Vest Banco Bradesco SA JPMorgan Chase & Co. Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group BNP Paribas BancaPopolare dell'Etruriae del Lazio Australia& New Zealand Banking Group Toronto-Dominion Bank Bank ofCommunications Co Ltd Deutsche BankAG SpareBank 1 Buskerud Vestfold Allied Irish Banks Bank ofNovaScotia Banco Bilbao VizcayaArgentaria Banco Santander Brasil Dexia BankCentral Asia National AustraliaBankLimited Morgan Stanley ING Groep N.V. SpareBank 1 Notteroy Tonsberg HDFC Bank Limited U.S. Bancorp Mizuho Financial Group Inc. Royal Bank ofScotland Group Sparebanken Pluss Pacific & Western Credit Corp UBS AG PNC Financial ServicesGroup Societe Generale Proton Bank
  • 3.
    Top 10 AcquirerBanks The following banks were upgraded from Performer to Acquirer rating The Co-operative Bank was the only downgrade among the Top 10 from April. Hang Seng Bank, Bank Mandiri and Bank Rakyat Indonesia are still rated Acquirer, but were overtaken in the rankings. Acquirer Commonwealth Bank ofAustralia Royal Bank ofCanada Itau Unibanco Holding SA Westpac Banking Corporation Banco Bradesco SA Australia& New Zealand Banking Group Allied Irish Banks Bank Central Asia HDFC Bank Limited Pacific & Western Credit Corp Australiaand New Zealand Banking Group Itau Unibanco Holding Banco Bradesco
  • 4.
    Top 10 PerformerBanks Performer WellsFargo & Co Industrial and Commercial Bank ofChina HSBC Holdingsplc ChinaConstruction Bank Corporation JPMorgan Chase & Co. Toronto-Dominion Bank BankofNovaScotia National AustraliaBank Limited U.S. Bancorp UBS AG
  • 5.
    Top 10 ManagementChange Rated Banks JP Morgan Chase was upgraded to Performer rating, after Jamie Dimon survived challenges from investors wishing to strip him of the Chairman title. The bank delivered on promises and the market voted massively for Dimon, bidding up the value of the bank. Blankfein of Goldman Sachs is the highest paid bank CEO in America. Blankfein replaced the CFO at the end of January this year, following two executive appointments last year. Likely upgrade shortly. Credit Suisse Group was also upgraded to Performer rating. The changes in Japanese monetary policy was sold as a positive for the economy, but banks generally declined in value and look weak from a Mergers and Acquisitions perspective. We downgraded Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group to Acquisition Target rating. Citigroup, Lloyds Banking Group and Morgan Stanley were all upgraded from Acquisition Target to Management Change rating during the month. Management Change Citigroup Inc. Bank ofChina Goldman SachsGroup, Inc. LloydsBanking Group PLC Sumitomo Mitsui Financial Group Bank ofCommunicationsCo Ltd Banco Bilbao VizcayaArgentaria Morgan Stanley Mizuho Financial Group Inc. PNC Financial ServicesGroup
  • 6.
    Top 10 AcquisitionTarget Rated Banks Banco Santander Brasil was downgraded from Management Change to Acquisition Target in May. As C, Lloyds, and MS were upgraded, Royal Bank of Scotland and Societe Generale rose into the top 10. Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group was downgraded from Management Change, leading the trend in Japan. Acquisition Target Bank ofAmericaCorp Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group Banco Santander, S.A. BarclaysPLC BNP Paribas Deutsche Bank AG Banco Santander Brasil ING Groep N.V. Royal Bank ofScotland Group Societe Generale
  • 7.
    Top 10 DistressedRated Banks Central Arizona Bank, Scottsdale, AZ with approximately $31.6 million in total assets and $30.8 million in total deposits was closed. Western State Bank has agreed to assume all deposits. Sunrise Bank, Valdosta, GA with approximately $60.8 million in total assets and $57.8 million in total deposits was closed. Synovus Bank has agreed to assume all deposits. Pisgah Community Bank, Asheville, NC with approximately $21.9 million in total assets and $21.2 million in total deposits was closed. Capital Bank, N.A. has agreed to assume all deposits. Distressed FNMA BancaPiccolo Credito Valtellinese CyprusPopular Bank Public Co Ltd Sparebanken Vest BancaPopolare dell'Etruriae del Lazio SpareBank 1 Buskerud Vestfold Dexia SpareBank 1 Notteroy Tonsberg Sparebanken Pluss Proton Bank
  • 8.
    Watch-list: Troubled banks that couldgo into distress ECB Financial Stability Review – Further decline in bank profitability, linked to credit losses and a weak macroeconomic environment is the primary risk, and rising. • Caisse Régionale de Crédit Agricole de Normandie-Seine • Alpha Bank SA • Sandnes Sparebank • Caisse Regionale de Credit Agricole Mutuel de la Loire-Haute-Loire • Banca Popolare di Spoleto • Caisse Regionale de Credit Agricole Mutuel Toulouse 31 • Cecil Bancorp • Banco Popolare • CRCAM Nord de France • Caisse Régionale de Crédit Agricole Mutuel de La Touraine et du Poitou • Credit Agricole Brie Picardie • Crédit Agricole d'Ille-et-Vilaine • Crédit Agricole Sud Rhône Alpes • Caisse Regionale de Credit Agricole Mutuel Alpes Provence • Credit Agricole du Morbihan
  • 9.
    Trond Johannessen Director Phimark BV +31620 59 1015 trond@blackwolfbv.com