“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
Health implications of gm food
1. M.Venkatasami,
Ph.D. (Processing and Food Engineering)
Department of Food Process Engineering
AEC&RI, TNAU.
7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 1
HEALTH IMPLICATION
OF GM FOODS
FSN 605 Advances in Food Science and Technology (2+1)
2. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 2
INTRODUCTION
Transfer of DNA between organisms
DNA transfer-Major mechanism for antibiotic resistance in pathogenic bacteria.
First genetically modified (GM) plant
An antibiotic-resistant tobacco plant.
China commercialize a transgenic crop
Virus resistant tobacco.
FDA Approval -USA
Flavour Saver tomato
1946
1983
1990
1994
3. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 3
CONT…
Canola with modified oil composition (Calgene)
Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) corn/maize (Ciba-Geigy)
Cotton resistant to the herbicide bromoxynil (Calgene)
Bt cotton (Monsanto)
Bt potatoes (Monsanto)
Soybeans resistant to the herbicide glyphosate (Monsanto)
Virus-resistant squash (Asgrow)
Additional delayed ripening tomatoes (DNAP, Zeneca/Peto, and Monsanto)
1995
A total of 35 approvals had been granted to commercially grow,
8 transgenic crops
One flower crop of carnations with 8 different traits in 6 countries plus the EU
1996
4. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 4
GM FOODS-MERITS
Diseases control
Faster growth
Resistance to frequent drought
Resistance to pests and insects
Reduces pesticides and
insecticides
Environment friendly
CROP
Higher food production
Elimination of allergens
Free from chemicals
High in minerals and vitamins
Tastes better
Increased shelf life
PRODUCT
5. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 5
GM FOODS-DEMERITS
Development of diseases which are immune to antibiotics
Long term effects on human beings are unknown
Improper labelling
Religious and cultural communities - unnatural
Total protein
Vitamins
Mineral
Toxic glycoalkaloids
GM Tomatoes
Inserting kanʳ
genes
‘Antisense’ GM
method
No
significant
alterations
Gm Parent
Substantially
equivalent
6. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 6
CONT…
Acute toxicity studies
Male/female rats
Tube-fed with homogenized
GM tomatoes
Toxic effects were
absent
GM maize
Two lines of Chardon LL
herbicide-resistant
‘phosphinothricin
acetyltransferase’
Significant
alterations
Fat
Carbohydrate
Gm Parent
Different
Toxicity tests Flawed
7. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 7
GM soybeans Agrobacterium
5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-
phosphate synthase
CONT…
Gm Parent
Substantially
equivalent
Significant
alterations
Genistein (isoflavone)
Trypsin inhibitor
GM potatoes Soybean glycinin gene
Male/female
rats
Force-fed with 2 g of GM
No difference b/w control
and GM fed rats
8. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 8
CONT…
GM cotton
Bacillus thuringiensis
subsp. kurstaki
Lepidopteran
pests
No significant
alterations
Gm Parent
Substantially
equivalent
Macronutrients
Gossypol
Cyclopropenoid fatty acids and aflatoxin levels < Conventional seeds
GM rice
soybean
glycinin gene
40– 50 mg
glycinin/g protein
Claims
20 % more protein
Decrease in moisture rather than true increase in protein
9. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 9
GM peas
Alpha-amylase
inhibitor
5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-
phosphate synthase
CONT…
GM peas fed to rats for 10 days
Two different doses viz. 30 % and 65 %
Similar to parent-line peas
Acute
toxicity
studies
Gm Parent
Substantially
equivalent
Nutritional/toxicological testing on laboratory animals should follow the clinical,
double-blind, placebo-type tests with human volunteers
MicroRNA
molecules
Present in a
diet (in rice)
May penetrate
into human
cells
Regulate the
expression of
human genes
10. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 10
ALLERGENICITY STUDIES
Alpha-amylase
Trypsin inhibitors
Allergens in rice
Crop with allergen
Non-allergenic
Target crop
Creation of a neo-allergen
Allergenicity
Antisense RNA
strategy
Bt toxin Cry1Ac
Potent oral/nasal
antigen and
adjuvant
11. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 11
RISKS
Tampering with mother nature
Increased weeds of relative species
Decrease pest competition
Beneficial insects affected by harmful quantities of Bt.
Viruses can recombine with viral fragments forming new viruses
.
Evolution
Pest-resistant and herbicide-
resistant plants
Superbugs and super weeds
12. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 12
HEALTH RISKS
The mechanisms of food hazards fall into three main categories
Inserted genes and their expression products
Secondary and pleiotropic effects of gene
expression
The insertional mutagenesis resulting from
gene integration
Transferred gene
The expression of the gene
The affects of the gene product
Health risk
Unpredictable allergenic effects New proteins can be synthesized
Bean plants
Cysteine and
methionine
Transgene -
expressed protein
Highly allergenic
13. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 13
CONT…
Secondary and pleiotropic effects of gene expression
Transgenes encode an enzyme Alters biochemical pathways
Increase or decrease in certain biochemical
New enzyme could cause depletion in the enzymatic substrate
Subsequent build up of the enzymatic product
Metabolites to diverge from one secondary metabolic pathway to another
Changes in metabolism can lead to an increase in toxin concentrations
Assessing toxins is a more difficult task due to limitations of animal models
NEW
ENZYME
14. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 14
CONT…
The insertional mutagenesis resulting from gene integration
Disrupt or change the expression
Of existing genes
Host plant
Random insertion
of gene
Inactivation of
endogenous genes
Production
mutant plants
Fusion proteins can be made from plant
DNA and inserted DNA
Concerns - the activation or up regulation
of silent or low expressed genes
It is possible to activate “genes that encode enzymes in biochemical
pathways toward the production of toxic secondary compounds”
15. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 15
GM FOODS: INDIA
Stopped all field trials
Bar on GM food crops such as Bt. brinjal
Raised the “ethical dimensions”
Long-term environmental and chronic toxicology impact,
No significant socio-economic benefits to farmers
Parliamentary
Committee
on Agriculture,
2012
GM mustard
Barnase-
barstar-bar
gene complex
Male sterile
lines
Hybrid
mustard
varieties
Bt cotton is the only genetically modified (GM) crop that has been approved for
commercial cultivation in 2002 by the Government of India.
16. 7/28/2021
ADVANCES IN FOOD SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 16
REFERENCES
Bawa, A. S., and K. R. Anilakumar. "Genetically modified foods: safety, risks and public
concerns—a review." Journal of food science and technology 50, no. 6 (2013): 1035-
1046.
Lisowska, K. "Genetically modified crops and food: pros and cons." Chemik 11 (2011):
1193-1203.