12. occintranet/task/web-accessibility
Image Description: Oxford City Council’s zero emission zone phasing map which highlights areas in
red, green, and blue. The map shows Oxford city, with a red zone in the centre and a larger green
zone surrounding the red zone, and a blue hatched zone covering most of the city depicted in the
image. Information about the zones is listed on the right hand side. ‘Red Zone, 2020’: ‘Road user
charges for non zero emissions vehicles from late 2020’. ‘Green Zone, 2021/2022’: ‘Possible road
user charges to enforce low emission and zero emission requirements from 2021/2022’. ‘Blue Zone,
2020-2025’: Most busses to by Euro 6 by December 2020; Remaining busses to be Euro 6 by
December 2022; Busses to be zero emission by 2035/2037, by will work with operations to achieve
this by 2030 if possible; Possible future ultra-low emissions zone for all vehicles. ‘Citywide Zone,
2020-2035’: All Oxford-licensed Hackney Carriages (black cabs) to be zero emission by 2020-2025;
Possible future ultra-low emission zone for all vehicles; Citywide zero emissions zone by 2035. Image
was taken from the Oxford City Council’s January 2020 Briefing note, available on the Oxford City
Council’s website here: https://www.oxford.gov.uk/downloads/file/6964/zez_briefing_note_-
_january_2020.
Crown Copyright 2019. OS Licence 0100023343.
19. occintranet/task/web-accessibility
How we use tables
Department
Class
Number
Room
Number Days
Start
Time End Time Teacher
Biology
100 5 Mon 10:00 11:00
100 5 Tue 11:00 12:30 John
205 6 Tue 09:00 10:30 Paul
315 6 Mon 13:00 14:00 George
Business
150 15 Mon 09:00 10:00 Ringo
20. occintranet/task/web-accessibility
How we use tables
Department, Class Number, Room Number, Days,
Start Time, End Time, Teacher, 100, 5, Mon, 10:00,
11:00, 100, 5, Tue, 11:00, 12:30, John, 205, 6, Tue,
09:00, 10:30, Paul, 315, 6, Mon, 13:00, 14:00, George,
Business, 150, 15, Mon, 09:00, 10:00, Ringo
Lot of ground to cover so questions at the end if time
Web accessibility covers
Council websites and their content
Council intranets and their content
Online applications (with a web front end) and their content
Mobile apps and their content
If you take one thing away from today, make it this.
We want all our customers to be able to use our websites and access our services equally easily. For all the examples that follow, think about if you created information in an obscure language that lots of people don’t understand, and then wondered why people didn’t follow your guidance
The figures on disabilities in the UK show the scale of the issue
7 million people who identify as disabled
2 million blind or partially sighted people
700,000 adults and children on the autistic spectrum, of these 40% suffer from anxiety
11 million people are deaf or hard of hearing
over 40% of people of 50, and over 70% of people over 70
6.3 million people (around 10% of the UK population) have dyslexia
Life is hard enough for people with disabilities. We shouldn’t be making it harder to get services from the council on top of that
The same applies to our own staff with disabilities – we can’t make life at work harder for them by making them use systems that are difficult to use
Even if we didn’t think helping everyone get equal access was important, there is legislation to say we have to.
Equalities Act 2010 – protected characteristics for 9 groups, including those with disabilities.
New legislation came into effect in September 2018 to ensure that websites and web applications in the public sector can be used by everybody, regardless of ability, by meeting accessibility standards.
The regulations have a specific provision for acting on a request for a ‘reasonable adjustment’
Failure to make a reasonable adjustment
11.—(1) A failure by a public sector body to comply with the accessibility requirement is to be treated as a failure to make a reasonable adjustment.
(2) A failure by a public sector body to provide a satisfactory response to a request to provide information in an accessible format, pursuant to regulation 12(2), is to be treated as a failure to make a reasonable adjustment.
(3) A “failure to make a reasonable adjustment” in this regulation means a failure to make a reasonable adjustment for the purposes of—
(a)sections 20, 21 and 29 of the Equality Act 2010; or
(b)sections 19 to 21 and 21B to 21E of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995(1).
Look = the content on the page that people add, or the designs we choose
Function = how the website behaves
Hosted on them = non-web based things like PDFs and Word documents
Quick quiz: Which of these do you think is the biggest problem for us to solve?
This is the main area where you…..
Colour blindness
Colour contrast
Colour blindness
Colour contrast
This is a real example from our Zero Emission Zone proposals
How would someone with a screen reader interpret this image?
How would it read the text – this is all on an image
Leaving disabilities aside, how is anyone using a mobile phone going to see and understand this on a small screen?
This is what would be needed to interpret it
Even then it doesn’t manage to explain what the zone covers properly
What do you think would work better?
What about using a list of streets in each zone
So we’re all used to adding a hyperlink to an email or in a PDF. But getting this wrong means hard work for someone else
Think about how you use the web as a sighted user. Do you read every word carefully, in sequence, from top to bottom? No. Humans are lazy by design and have learned to ‘scan’ pages for interesting information as fast as possible.
People that use screen readers will skip to headings and lists of links to get to what they need quickly
So how does this list of links look in a screen reader?
So not ideal
Links need to give a clear idea of where they are taking people next so they know if it is what they are looking for.
Best way to think is that every link needs to make sense in isolation
Using ‘here’ or ‘click here’ is really common and really unhelpful
The Google doc link is long and ugly!
So here’s an improved version of the same document
That link to the google doc tells the user that’s what they’ll end up seeing
And how does that look in a screen reader?
Isn’t this better?
Wouldn’t you know exactly where you’re going next?
Using headings properly is such an easy thing to do, but we often make life more difficult for ourselves as well as other people by not using them
We play around with text size, bold, underlining all to make the different parts of a document we’re writing
These built-in styles in Word do that work for us.
The same things apply for web pages. These use built in header styles that screen readers can understand really clearly
Remember we talked about how we skip around when we view web pages, and that screen reader users do the same? Headings become really important here
Heading 1 is always for the title of a web page or document – you only use this once
Heading 2 is your main topic
Heading 3 is a sub-topic
You may even go down to heading 4
But if you skip straight from 1 to 3 you start to confuse a screen reader
Tables are a convenient way for us to lay out lots of information but they may cause more problems than they solve if not created properly on a web page
This one looks perfectly harmless doesn’t it? I knocked this up on Excel and copy/pasted it. Easy for me, but how does that work on a web page?
So this is how a screen reader would read out that table. Without a proper structure that a screen reader can understand it becomes gibberish
Copying and pasting in tables just doesn’t work for websites. And for tables within PDFs it’s the same story – they need other information about them to work properly and
Here’s a well formatted table for comparison.
First rule is: don’t use a table unless you really need one, and then only for data not to layout text. Better still use bullet points with headings to make it easier to read
Think about how easy the information you’re trying to convey will be
Keep it simple – multi-column tables can be difficult even for able bodied people to read and understand. No more than 3 columns,
Always define which row is the header, and use just one row, not multiple rows
Start a new table if the subject changes. Don’t try and cram everything into one table as it won’t make sense
Don’t copy and paste a table – use the web content system to create it
Videos are a great way to get lots of information across, and be more engaging, but they are also a way to exclude people
Some people with disabilities will find a video with lots of cuts/changes, text overlays hard to follow.
Captions in videos will only work if people can see them
The minimum we have to do to be compliant is include a complete transcript, which can be read by a screen reader too. That’s something we haven’t done so far. They should contain additional descriptions, explanations, or comments that may be beneficial, such as indications of laughter or an explosion.
So here’s an example of Oxfordshire County Council doing this with their videos
This section isn’t really one most staff have to worry about. That’s where my team come in
But if you are commissioning someone to create a website for you, or you’re buying software that the public will use via a web browser, you need to at least know there are things that your designer needs to take account of
Also, if you’re buying software that will have a website front end you need to make sure it meets the standards
This is the non-web based content that we load
So let’s talk about PDFs
Our single biggest problem in making the web more accessible is our heavy use of PDFs, Word Docs, Excel spreadsheets
We have literally thousands of these, and most of them fail the accessibility tests
We have 175 ‘forms’ that are downloads for people to fill in and email to us.
As mentioned earlier, this is the biggest single problem we have to fix, but there are no easy fixes as any changes can only be done manually, one-by-one.
Got experts Shaw Trust – 11 websites and web applications
Developed a plan about next steps
Looking at all 25 of our smaller websites, including service ones
As web content comes through the team we do what we can to fix it. Biggest problem is with large PDF documents from designers that haven’t been designed with accessibility in mind. These can take days to fix, and we just don’t have the resources to do this
Also looking at
We’ve already pulled together a batch of good practice guidance on the intranet to give you practical help in improving content going on the web. Just search for ‘accessibility’ to find it. It’s pretty comprehensive!
We’ll also be introducing a deadline after which time we won’t publish any non-compliant downloads – 1 April 2019. After this time, documents will be sent back to you to fix. Again, the intranet guidance covers how you can repair non-compliant items, but the best approach is to not use them at all if you can
If you have to create a PDF-based document as it will also be in print, make sure the designers you are using are told they must comply with the regulations, and they won’t get paid it they don’t. We’re looking to work with Comms and Procurement to source some designers that can be relied on to produce compliant documents. For any work you commission, start to quote this accessibility standard – if your designers don’t understand it, it’s time to get better designers!
Finally, my team would much rather be asked for advice or suggestions than tell people they can’t do something. If we’re approached early on we can point people the right way or suggest alternatives, which we’re really happy to do. There’s a lot to get your head around with this and we understand that