This document summarizes the agenda and instructions for a university tutorial on resume peer review. Students were divided into groups of 5 and instructed to exchange resume drafts without technology. The TA then provided feedback and students reviewed each other's resumes based on a rubric addressing formatting, sections, and achievement-based experiences. Students were asked to identify peers with applications that stood out and areas for improvement, and to nominate who they would interview. Action items included deadlines to submit final resumes and cover letters and attend a networking event.
4. Peer Review - Instructions
1. Write your table number on ALL of your
documents
2. Put your documents in a pile in the
middle of the table
3. Take out your marking utensils
Each new slide section
PASS DOCUMENT TO THE RIGHT
5. • Name is preferred name
with (given name) in
brackets
• Phone and address are
included
• LinkedIn URL is
personalized
header
• No personal pronouns (I, we,
he, she)
• Reasonable amount of white
space – is it easy to read?
• Experiences listed in reverse
chronological order by start
date
general
• Titles formatted the same
• Spacing is consistent
• Margins are reasonable (≥1.5cm)
• Phrases either ALL end in period or not
• Dates
• Usually right-aligned
• All have month and year, or just year
• All months are abbreviated to same # of
letters
• Uses hyphens (–) OR dashes (-)
• Font:
• Size is ≥ 10
• Generally no more than two types of
font
• Numbers under 10 are spelled out (i.e.
two vs. 2)
• Bullets: same size/style, aligned
consistency
Resume – Header/Formatting
6. Resume – Profile/Key Competencies
Very clearly and
convincingly summarizes
strengths/experiences/skill
s
Provides clear and
convincing link to the rest
of the resume
Matching to job posting
(multiple references)
Third person
rubric important guidelines
o Key competencies are more of
a direct match to the job
posting (ex. 3-5 years in sales,
hard skills like software
development, etc)
o Career aspirations
o Additional languages
7. Resume – Education
Does it clearly summarize
education experiences
(i.e. including academic
projects / relevant courses
/ grades / awards)?
Is there any ambiguity
with respect to the info
provided?
Does it match the job
description?
rubric important guidelines
o BCom not BCOMM
o Start with the degree
o List expected date of completion (either
as “Completion: …” or “Expected
Completion: ...”)
o No laundry lists of courses: only
specific, relevant courses
o GPA –score/%/letter grade, indicating
the school scale
o Key/relevant projects and awards: write
in accomplishment statement form
o Transfer schools can be separate if
desired
o Exchange schools can be separate or
incorporated
8. Resume – Accomplishment Statements
Are experiences achievement
based?
Do numbers clearly quantify
achievements where appropriate?
Do statements have
Accomplishment, Proof,
Transferrable Skills, and Scope of
Action?
Are the result verbs varied and
strong?
Does language indicate familiarity
with industry / company? Does it
match the job description?
rubric important guidelines
o Reverse chronological order by
start date
o You can include explanation
sentences of
companies/experiences if
necessary (but need to do it for
ALL or NONE)
o Eliminate filler words
o Keep it to one sentence (2 lines
is best)
o The elements of the RATS
statement should be apparent (but
not necessarily in RATS order)
10. Resume - Interests
Be able to speak extensively about the
topics you put here
Specifics draw them in
Differentiate
Well rounded (physical/creative/worldly-
ness)
BE FUN!! But appropriate
11. Resume - Branding
Personal qualifications are well tailored to requirements of
job (clear 60-70% match)
Multiple words from job description are included in resume
(5+)
Interests section show personality and relevant specific
interests
There is strong evidence of CAN-WANT-FIT match made
14. Last Question…
Out of the applications you have on your table:
Who had the WOW factor?
What was good about their application?
What do they need to work on?
WHO WOULD YOU INTERVIEW?
15. Action Items
Resume & Cover Letter is due on March 8th @ 2:00PM
via Turnitin
LinkedIn Profile is due before next tutorial!
Networking Event on March 10th, 2016
Office Hours!!!!