The Perfect Online Donation Process:
A journey into the unknown...

July 2011
Agenda:

          Introductions and Overview – Jason Potts



          A practical perspective on the challenge – Mike Walton


          The process of creating the best donation experience
          possible and the findings to date – Simon Norris


          Q&A - All
If there’s one reason we
  have done better than of
our peers, it is because we
  have focused like a laser
  on customer experience,
and that really does matter,
    I think, in any business.

It certainly matters online,
where word of mouth is so
        very, very powerful.



      Jeff Bezos – founder,
              Amazon.com
The perfect user experience   Not so much ...


  Arrive at airport            Arrive at airport

  Welcomed by staff            Ignored by staff

  Check in 5 mins              Check in takes 3 hours


  Priority boarding            Boarded last


  Land at destination          Land at destination
Did you know?
Q.
How did Amazon.com, using usability
testing add $2.5B to their revenue stream?
A.
By adjusting the sort order of
user comments!
Did you know?
Q.
How did Microsoft’s Bing.com search
engine increased their revenue by $80M
after a usability review?
A.
By adjusting colour of their hyperlinks!
Did you know?
   Q.
   What percentage of website visitors who
   intend to make a donation, don’t get to the
   end of the process?
   A.
   47 per cent!!!

Source: M.A.D.
Did you know?
     Q.
     What is the average conversion ratio for a
     donation form that hasn’t been usability
     tested?
     A.
     15 per cent!!!

Source: Convio/Donor Digital research 2011
http://donordigital.com/publications/Donordigital-Convio%20Donation_Form_Optimization_Whitepaper.pdf
Convio/Donor Digital results suggest the following
elements meaningfully affect user behaviour on most
donation forms:
 – Form length: A one-page form does significantly better
  for most organisations
– Column layout: One or two columns best
– Trust seals: Prominent placement above the fold matters,
  and more than one may help too
– changing gift string layouts produced improvements in
  most tests
Reasons Given for Not Donating

        • 47% decided not to donate because of confusing
          navigation, cluttered design, and/or confusing flow
          from page to page

        • 17% of people couldn't locate the donate button due to 'banner
          blindness' and 'over-formatting'

        • 53% related to content. Unclear titles and terms along with
          missing information


Source: Donation Usability: Increasing Online Giving to Non-Profits and Charities, Jacob Nielsen
http://www.johnchow.com/case-study-how-a-bum-increased-his-donations-by-over-100/
Homepage
187.0% Increase in Donations
per Unique Visitor (vs. Control
Creative)

Donation page
9.6% uplift against the Control
Creative
+ 22.76%
vs.
      Join
      Click Rate
Vs.




Baseline (creative 3)           Winner (creative 27)
   Conversion Rate = x%          Conversion Rate = x% +74.92%
• The Gorilla ad group increased conversion
  rate from 3.07% to 8.77%
  – Cost per conversion fell from £6.25 to £3.07.
• The overall conversion rate increased from
  0.26% to 2.46%
  – Cost per conversion fell from £69.71 to £8.65.
What should you test?
   • Page Heading
   • Introductory Copy
   • Donation Amounts
   • Form Layout and process
   • Field Labels & Field Prompts
   • Number of Fields
   • Buttons Size & Colour
   • Button Text
   • Security Assurances
   • Privacy Assurances
Not for Profit Mobile queries via mobile on Google
http://www.google.com/sites/help/intl/en/mobile-landing-pages/mlpb.html
Agenda:

          Introductions and Overview – Jason Potts



          A practical perspective on the challenge – Mike Walton


          The process of creating the best donation experience
          possible and the findings to date – Simon Norris


          Q&A - All
Agenda:

          Introductions and Overview – Jason Potts



          A practical perspective on the challenge – Mike Walton


          The process of creating the best donation experience
          possible and the findings to date – Simon Norris


          Q&A - All
Agenda:

          Introductions and Overview – Jason Potts



          A practical perspective on the challenge – Mike Walton


          The process of creating the best donation experience
          possible and the findings to date – Simon Norris


          Q&A - All

Iof 2011 best donation form session

  • 1.
    The Perfect OnlineDonation Process: A journey into the unknown... July 2011
  • 2.
    Agenda: Introductions and Overview – Jason Potts A practical perspective on the challenge – Mike Walton The process of creating the best donation experience possible and the findings to date – Simon Norris Q&A - All
  • 3.
    If there’s onereason we have done better than of our peers, it is because we have focused like a laser on customer experience, and that really does matter, I think, in any business. It certainly matters online, where word of mouth is so very, very powerful. Jeff Bezos – founder, Amazon.com
  • 4.
    The perfect userexperience Not so much ... Arrive at airport Arrive at airport Welcomed by staff Ignored by staff Check in 5 mins Check in takes 3 hours Priority boarding Boarded last Land at destination Land at destination
  • 5.
    Did you know? Q. Howdid Amazon.com, using usability testing add $2.5B to their revenue stream? A. By adjusting the sort order of user comments!
  • 6.
    Did you know? Q. Howdid Microsoft’s Bing.com search engine increased their revenue by $80M after a usability review? A. By adjusting colour of their hyperlinks!
  • 7.
    Did you know? Q. What percentage of website visitors who intend to make a donation, don’t get to the end of the process? A. 47 per cent!!! Source: M.A.D.
  • 8.
    Did you know? Q. What is the average conversion ratio for a donation form that hasn’t been usability tested? A. 15 per cent!!! Source: Convio/Donor Digital research 2011 http://donordigital.com/publications/Donordigital-Convio%20Donation_Form_Optimization_Whitepaper.pdf
  • 9.
    Convio/Donor Digital resultssuggest the following elements meaningfully affect user behaviour on most donation forms: – Form length: A one-page form does significantly better for most organisations – Column layout: One or two columns best – Trust seals: Prominent placement above the fold matters, and more than one may help too – changing gift string layouts produced improvements in most tests
  • 10.
    Reasons Given forNot Donating • 47% decided not to donate because of confusing navigation, cluttered design, and/or confusing flow from page to page • 17% of people couldn't locate the donate button due to 'banner blindness' and 'over-formatting' • 53% related to content. Unclear titles and terms along with missing information Source: Donation Usability: Increasing Online Giving to Non-Profits and Charities, Jacob Nielsen
  • 11.
  • 14.
    Homepage 187.0% Increase inDonations per Unique Visitor (vs. Control Creative) Donation page 9.6% uplift against the Control Creative
  • 15.
    + 22.76% vs. Join Click Rate
  • 16.
    Vs. Baseline (creative 3) Winner (creative 27) Conversion Rate = x% Conversion Rate = x% +74.92%
  • 19.
    • The Gorillaad group increased conversion rate from 3.07% to 8.77% – Cost per conversion fell from £6.25 to £3.07. • The overall conversion rate increased from 0.26% to 2.46% – Cost per conversion fell from £69.71 to £8.65.
  • 20.
    What should youtest? • Page Heading • Introductory Copy • Donation Amounts • Form Layout and process • Field Labels & Field Prompts • Number of Fields • Buttons Size & Colour • Button Text • Security Assurances • Privacy Assurances
  • 21.
    Not for ProfitMobile queries via mobile on Google
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Agenda: Introductions and Overview – Jason Potts A practical perspective on the challenge – Mike Walton The process of creating the best donation experience possible and the findings to date – Simon Norris Q&A - All
  • 24.
    Agenda: Introductions and Overview – Jason Potts A practical perspective on the challenge – Mike Walton The process of creating the best donation experience possible and the findings to date – Simon Norris Q&A - All
  • 25.
    Agenda: Introductions and Overview – Jason Potts A practical perspective on the challenge – Mike Walton The process of creating the best donation experience possible and the findings to date – Simon Norris Q&A - All