1) The document discusses the evolution of the humanitarian enterprise over the past 10 years, lessons learned from civil-military interaction during crises in Haiti, Pakistan, and Afghanistan, and what to expect for humanitarian action between now and 2020.
2) It notes major quantitative and qualitative changes to the humanitarian field, including more funding, workers, and media attention, but also greater politicization and the blending of humanitarian and political/military agendas.
3) The response to the 2010 Haiti earthquake showed the importance of military logistics support but also coordination challenges when the military takes a leading role, while the response to Pakistan floods demonstrated more positive civil-military cooperation.
This document discusses how science and technology education can strengthen peace building. It begins by outlining some of the main causes of conflicts in Africa, including inequitable distribution of resources, poverty, breakdown of communication, and lack of a culture of peace. The document then examines the role that scientific knowledge, its application, and the scientific process can play in influencing socioeconomic development, poverty reduction, communication, and mindsets that promote peace - all of which are important aspects of peace building.
The document discusses grassroots approaches to conflict transformation. It defines conflict and discusses how grassroots approaches aim to increase local ownership, empower communities, and foster lasting peace through participation and addressing community needs. Key characteristics of grassroots approaches include recognizing how conflicts affect local populations, emphasizing commonalities between groups, and addressing the root causes and perceptions that drive conflicts.
This presentation discusses the implications of transitional justice processes that ignore the grievances of rebel groups, particularly child soldiers, in sub-Saharan Africa. It argues that addressing the grievances of former child combatants is important for successful reconciliation. It also discusses several theories on the importance of understanding grievances and reducing the divide between perpetrator groups ("them") and others ("us") to end cycles of conflict. Finally, it proposes an approach to transitional justice that discusses child combatants as complex political actors with specific tactical agency and grievances.
Voluntary and Humanitarian Responses
Volunteers play an important role in humanitarian crises by meeting urgent needs that states and international organizations cannot provide. However, measuring their individual and collective impact is difficult. While volunteers aim to uphold humanitarian principles of humanity, neutrality, impartiality and independence, the reality of humanitarian crises and the large, poorly coordinated humanitarian system presents many challenges. Upholding ethics and avoiding harm is crucial for volunteers to safely and effectively assist those affected by crises.
Humanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed FoundationMMFNG
Humanitarian Imperative! By Gbenro Olajuyigbe Head, Human Security, ActionAid Nigeria
(A paper presented at MusaYar’adua Centre, Abuja at a Programme on Sustainable Humanitarian Response Mechanism for Nigeria, organized by MurtalaMuhammed Foundation on December 2, 2014).
The current challenges of humanitarian crises in Nigeria have thrown up new images of leadership, technical, capacity, policy deficiencies. The need to reconstruct effective and appropriate proactive response mechanism is imperative
Not Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict CountriesCAPRi
The document discusses the challenges of natural resource management (NRM) in post-conflict contexts. It notes that post-conflict countries face a heightened risk of conflict recurrence in the first 10 years. NRM is critical for peacebuilding but peacebuilding is also critical for NRM. The document recommends that NRM projects in post-conflict areas focus on situational awareness, conflict management, and mainstreaming peacebuilding approaches like human security, livelihoods support, and governance.
The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...CAPRi
This document discusses the role of mountain gorilla tourism in the post-conflict recovery of Rwanda. It finds that mountain gorilla tourism has significantly contributed to Rwanda's economic growth since the 1994 genocide, becoming the largest foreign exchange earner. It also discusses how revenue from gorilla tourism is shared with local communities and has helped fund projects providing education, water, and livelihoods. Transboundary collaboration between Rwanda, Uganda, and DRC on gorilla conservation has also helped promote regional peacebuilding and security.
This document provides a preliminary inventory of tactics civilians use to survive violence during armed conflicts. It is divided into three sections: physical safety, sustenance, and services. The physical safety section details various formal and informal engagement strategies civilians use to accommodate or avoid threatening powers, including persuasion, deals, disengagement, and avoidance. It also covers information gathering, assessment, and protection tactics used by communities to avoid violence. The overall aim is to document self-protection methods civilians have developed and rely on when formal protections break down during mass violence.
This document discusses how science and technology education can strengthen peace building. It begins by outlining some of the main causes of conflicts in Africa, including inequitable distribution of resources, poverty, breakdown of communication, and lack of a culture of peace. The document then examines the role that scientific knowledge, its application, and the scientific process can play in influencing socioeconomic development, poverty reduction, communication, and mindsets that promote peace - all of which are important aspects of peace building.
The document discusses grassroots approaches to conflict transformation. It defines conflict and discusses how grassroots approaches aim to increase local ownership, empower communities, and foster lasting peace through participation and addressing community needs. Key characteristics of grassroots approaches include recognizing how conflicts affect local populations, emphasizing commonalities between groups, and addressing the root causes and perceptions that drive conflicts.
This presentation discusses the implications of transitional justice processes that ignore the grievances of rebel groups, particularly child soldiers, in sub-Saharan Africa. It argues that addressing the grievances of former child combatants is important for successful reconciliation. It also discusses several theories on the importance of understanding grievances and reducing the divide between perpetrator groups ("them") and others ("us") to end cycles of conflict. Finally, it proposes an approach to transitional justice that discusses child combatants as complex political actors with specific tactical agency and grievances.
Voluntary and Humanitarian Responses
Volunteers play an important role in humanitarian crises by meeting urgent needs that states and international organizations cannot provide. However, measuring their individual and collective impact is difficult. While volunteers aim to uphold humanitarian principles of humanity, neutrality, impartiality and independence, the reality of humanitarian crises and the large, poorly coordinated humanitarian system presents many challenges. Upholding ethics and avoiding harm is crucial for volunteers to safely and effectively assist those affected by crises.
Humanitarian imperative - Murtala Muhammed FoundationMMFNG
Humanitarian Imperative! By Gbenro Olajuyigbe Head, Human Security, ActionAid Nigeria
(A paper presented at MusaYar’adua Centre, Abuja at a Programme on Sustainable Humanitarian Response Mechanism for Nigeria, organized by MurtalaMuhammed Foundation on December 2, 2014).
The current challenges of humanitarian crises in Nigeria have thrown up new images of leadership, technical, capacity, policy deficiencies. The need to reconstruct effective and appropriate proactive response mechanism is imperative
Not Your Father’s NRM: Understanding NRM in Post-Conflict CountriesCAPRi
The document discusses the challenges of natural resource management (NRM) in post-conflict contexts. It notes that post-conflict countries face a heightened risk of conflict recurrence in the first 10 years. NRM is critical for peacebuilding but peacebuilding is also critical for NRM. The document recommends that NRM projects in post-conflict areas focus on situational awareness, conflict management, and mainstreaming peacebuilding approaches like human security, livelihoods support, and governance.
The Ultimate Question of How to Cut the Pie? Revenue Sharing of Gorilla Touri...CAPRi
This document discusses the role of mountain gorilla tourism in the post-conflict recovery of Rwanda. It finds that mountain gorilla tourism has significantly contributed to Rwanda's economic growth since the 1994 genocide, becoming the largest foreign exchange earner. It also discusses how revenue from gorilla tourism is shared with local communities and has helped fund projects providing education, water, and livelihoods. Transboundary collaboration between Rwanda, Uganda, and DRC on gorilla conservation has also helped promote regional peacebuilding and security.
This document provides a preliminary inventory of tactics civilians use to survive violence during armed conflicts. It is divided into three sections: physical safety, sustenance, and services. The physical safety section details various formal and informal engagement strategies civilians use to accommodate or avoid threatening powers, including persuasion, deals, disengagement, and avoidance. It also covers information gathering, assessment, and protection tactics used by communities to avoid violence. The overall aim is to document self-protection methods civilians have developed and rely on when formal protections break down during mass violence.
This document provides background information on the civil war in Sierra Leone and discusses its roots and legacy of colonialism. It outlines that the war was driven by struggles over natural resources like diamonds, which fueled rebel groups and human rights violations. While initially over resources, the war became centered on gender-based violence as women were targeted and forced into combat roles. Despite peace agreements, post-conflict reconstruction faces challenges in recognizing the experiences of female ex-combatants. The document analyzes how gender inequality remains at the heart of ongoing peacebuilding efforts.
Mismanagement of Natural Resources: States, businesses and communitiesEric Kumeh Mensah
This presentation highlights the concepts of mismanagement, public trust and tragedy of the commons. It uses three clear examples to describe natural resources mismanagement at state, business and community levels. Root causes of NR mismanagement are then explored as well as solutions to the key issues raised. I completes by highlighting the role Natural Resource and Environmental Governance student can play in sustainable NRM.
Final fostering resilience expert roundtable new york 4 copyNE Kim
This document summarizes an expert roundtable discussion on fostering resilience in situations of conflict and fragility. The roundtable discussed: 1) Why resilience is an important concept for addressing today's interconnected crises; 2) Perspectives on resilience in conflict-affected contexts, focusing on capacity, agency, and transformation; 3) Strategies for promoting resilience, including basic service delivery, social cohesion, and addressing political dimensions; 4) Challenges in assessing and measuring resilience; and 5) The need for better coordination among humanitarian, development, and peacebuilding actors, as well as innovative financing approaches, to foster resilience in fragile settings.
Comments on the human security aspect of the poverty reduction guidelinesKayode Fayemi
The document discusses the human security dimension of poverty reduction guidelines. It analyzes four typical policy levers proposed in the guidelines: 1) Support for peace building and reconstruction, 2) Support for state monopoly of means of coercion, 3) Promoting social coherence through civil society and tolerance, and 4) Building assets against disasters and economic shocks. However, the document argues that the assumptions and focus on the state in the guidelines provide an incomplete picture in Africa given increasing state illegitimacy. A human security approach requires considering non-state actors and the complex local and international dimensions driving conflicts on the continent.
Issue paper - secure tenure in urban slums low-res FINALAngeli Alba
This document discusses secure tenure for urban slums in Asia-Pacific. It defines secure tenure and explains its importance for development. There is a continuum of land rights, from informal to formal, with eight types ranging from perceived tenure to registered freehold. Successful projects prioritize upgrading slums in situ through community-led development and partnerships between communities, municipalities, professionals, and the private sector. Forced relocation fails while incremental improvements to security of tenure through this continuum approach leads to sustainable communities and urban resiliency.
The document discusses opportunities and challenges related to civil-military cooperation in Sri Lanka. It provides background on the conflict in Sri Lanka and overview of the LTTE. It emphasizes the importance of a holistic and long-term approach to building peace that addresses root causes, rather than just symptoms. It also discusses perceptions each side has of the other and guidelines for civil-military relations according to the IASC, including maintaining separation of roles and seeking military assistance only as a last resort.
2nd ARC Report :CAPACITY BUILDING FOR CONFLICT RESOLUTIONGS SCORE
Polity and Governance topic is mentioned in the GS MAINS PAPER 2, however its indepth knowledge is equally important for writing an Essay, Public Administration (Paper-2) and even in GS Mains Paper 4. The government reports and documents become the best source for its understanding but usually the government reports are too bulky to read and grasping the main points from that become a tough task. Thus we have come up with the series of GIST of SECOND ARC Reports. It covers the main points of the complete report in about 30-35 pages (maximum). These points can be quoted directly in the Mains answer.
Tracking U.S. Humanitarian Aid Responding to Disaster in HaitiGenevieve Dejean
This document provides background information on humanitarian aid from the U.S. to Haiti over three presidential administrations in response to specific crises. It summarizes the humanitarian situation and U.S. response during the Clinton administration following the 1993 paramilitary coup and human rights violations in Haiti. The Clinton administration initially faced challenges regarding Haiti policy inherited from the previous administration. It discusses the violent context in Haiti at the time and the various factions, as well as the Clinton administration's shifting policy approach, including sanctions and peacekeeping troop deployment.
The document discusses the political economy of land and conflicts. It notes that securing land rights for all can help prevent and manage conflicts, as land is a source of livelihoods, wealth and a driver of power struggles. Understanding the various interests in land use and how competing claims are resolved is important. It emphasizes understanding shifting centers of power and interest groups, as well as considering women's land rights equally. A political economy lens is crucial, especially in contexts of poverty, weak governance and injustice, which can fuel conflicts over inequitable access to land resources. Legitimate dispute resolution mechanisms tailored to local contexts can help bridge divides and reconcile competing land claims.
American Research Journal of Humanities & Social Science (ARJHSS) is a double blind peer reviewed, open access journal published by (ARJHSS).
The main objective of ARJHSS is to provide an intellectual platform for the international scholars. ARJHSS aims to promote interdisciplinary studies in Humanities & Social Science and become the leading journal in Humanities & Social Science in the world.
Natural disasters are increasing in intensity and frequency. Preparing for disasters requires understanding how risks differently impact men and women. Disaster preparedness is most effective when communities have inclusive plans and communication with government. However, women's roles in mitigation and preparation are often overlooked. To ensure gender-inclusive preparedness, experts recommend conducting gender analysis, including women in assessments and response coordination, and developing common assessment tools.
[Ambassador Hassan] Speech: Presentation by Ambassador S. Azmat Hassan (Ret.)...GlobalPeaceFoundation
Date: Dec. 6th 2013
Session: Interfaith Partnerships: Faith and Diversity: Toward a Global Ethic for Inclusive and Moderate Societies
Speaker: Ambassador S. Azmat Hassan; Former Pakistani Ambassador to Malaysia, Syria and Morrocco, Islamic Republic of Pakistan
This document summarizes a conference held by the Jesuit Universities Humanitarian Action Network (JUHAN) on refugees and internally displaced persons. Over three days, the conference featured presentations from UN and NGO representatives on challenges facing humanitarian aid efforts, including preserving asylum spaces, developing domestic response capacities, and improving security and sustainable solutions for displaced populations. Students then participated in breakout sessions on issues like the Latin American refugee crisis, camp management, and working with the media. The goal was for students to develop action plans to address refugee needs that could be implemented at their home universities.
Zeitoun - What Matters for Effective Transboundary Water Diplomacyzeitounm
Power and norms matter greatly for effective transboundary water diplomacy and policy responses. Interventions should confront power asymmetries by (1) influencing basin leaders to move from bullies to cooperative partners through benefit-sharing and standards, and (2) challenging power imbalances by leveling players and the playing field through capacity building and establishing clear international water law standards. The Tigris and Euphrates basin exemplifies these issues, with Turkey wielding significant upstream power and the need to establish cooperative norms and standards in its interactions with Syria and Iraq.
This document discusses how transnational aid and faith-based organizations (FBOs) have undermined African governance. It argues that foreign aid has weakened accountability, democracy, and rule of law in African countries by making them dependent and responsive to external pressures. FBOs are analyzed as part of the transnational aid industry. While FBOs provide important services, the document contends they have failed to strengthen governance by enforcing rules and effectively delivering services. Their nature of operation, roles, and autonomy have misled them and weakened African governance in unintended ways. The motives of imperialist countries to exploit weaker nations for profit and domination have changed little over time, and the transnational aid industry serves these same motives by fostering dependency
Corruption Political Party System and Nigerian Democracy An Historical Analys...ijtsrd
Liberal democracy all over the world is a welcome phenomenon. In every modern society the game of politics is influenced tremendously by the elite class that projects the political culture which could make or mar democracy, as a result of the activities of the political parties. The adoption of western democracy is a mixed bag of blessing and catastrophes in the body politics of the country. Today, it is difficult to reconcile Nigerian democracy with that of the advanced democratic Countries. In Nigeria, politics is regarded as a “dirty game” which scares away the down trodden people. It has been noted that the level of socio economic development in the country is significantly related to the nature of politics in vogues. Political parties are primarily aimed at primitive accumulation of wealth. Where, “the end justifies the means” . The prevailing election rigging, thuggery, corruption, fear and intimidation by security agencies as well as hate speech in the campaigns of the politicians reflect value degeneration with the attendant instability in the country’s democracy. To this send, the paper examined political parties in Nigeria An historical Perspective from 1960 – 2019 looking at the roles of political parties as they affect the consolidation of democracy in Nigeria. Three 3 theoretical frameworks were used in the study namely Social learning theory SLT , Social Disorganization theory SDT and Corruption Permissiveness theory CPT .The study noted that Nigeria’s political parties from 1960 2019 has witnessed some challenging situation like ethnicity, corruption, violence, military intervention, civil and electoral deficiencies. Based on the findings, the study recommended among others that registered political parties should not be vehicles for the articulation and implementation of ethnic, religious or regional projects and programmes and that they should remain national in scope, courage and orientation. Aristotle Isaac Jacobs | Tarabina Veronica Pamo | Abidde Kilegha Victoria "Corruption, Political Party System and Nigerian Democracy: An Historical Analysis from 1960 – 2019" Published in International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (ijtsrd), ISSN: 2456-6470, Volume-5 | Issue-1 , December 2020, URL: https://www.ijtsrd.com/papers/ijtsrd38079.pdf Paper URL : https://www.ijtsrd.com/humanities-and-the-arts/social-science/38079/corruption-political-party-system-and-nigerian-democracy-an-historical-analysis-from-1960-– -2019/aristotle-isaac-jacobs
Deadly but Preventable Attacks: Killings and Enforced Disappearances of Those...Amnesty India
3,500 human rights defenders have been killed worldwide since 1998
281 HRDs killed globally in 2016—a significant increase from 156 defenders killed in 2015 and 136 in 2014
48 journalists killed worldwide in 2016 according to the Committee to Protect Journalists
India among deadliest countries for defenders of rights related to land, environment
Addressing the regional character of conflicts in west africaKayode Fayemi
This document discusses the regional dimensions of conflicts in West Africa and proposes a framework for human security in the region. It begins by outlining the nature and characteristics of conflicts in West Africa, noting that while some countries have made democratic progress, the region remains vulnerable to crisis and violence. It then analyzes the different thematic and geographic categories in the region in terms of their human security situations. The document argues that understanding the root causes of conflicts requires examining both historical and contemporary factors in a nuanced way. It also discusses regionalism in Africa, noting both the progress that has been made through organizations like ECOWAS but also the ongoing challenges to security arrangements and prospects for cooperative security in West Africa.
Helping prevent terrorism and violent conflict the development dimensionKayode Fayemi
The document discusses the development dimension of preventing terrorism and violent conflict in Africa. It argues that narrowly defining security as a military issue fails to address the root causes of conflicts, which are often related to lack of economic opportunity and political legitimacy. A human security approach is needed that considers individual livelihoods and promotes democracy, justice and inclusive development. International organizations must support long-term peacebuilding in a holistic manner rather than just focusing on short-term goals like elections.
Here are the prompts for today's 60 second lecture:
- Summarize your team's discussion about how to deepen learning through collaborative teams.
- Share one insight or "aha" your team discussed regarding next steps.
You have 60 seconds to stand on one leg and share! Go!
The document summarizes a professional learning community (PLC) meeting for reading interventionists. The objectives of the meeting were to standardize processes for identifying students needing interventions, identify consistent data sources to guide support, learn how to use an assessment tool called iCue, and discuss expectations for upcoming professional development on Pyramid Response to Intervention (PRTI). Participants scheduled appointments, read poems, learned how to access iCue from the director of assessment, updated process flowcharts, and discussed learning expectations for the upcoming PRTI training.
The document summarizes the district's work over the past year to improve teaching, learning, and student achievement. Key points include developing curriculum and intervention systems, implementing new programs like ADSIS, analyzing assessment data showing progress in reading and math, and recommending the board approve the annual report.
This document provides background information on the civil war in Sierra Leone and discusses its roots and legacy of colonialism. It outlines that the war was driven by struggles over natural resources like diamonds, which fueled rebel groups and human rights violations. While initially over resources, the war became centered on gender-based violence as women were targeted and forced into combat roles. Despite peace agreements, post-conflict reconstruction faces challenges in recognizing the experiences of female ex-combatants. The document analyzes how gender inequality remains at the heart of ongoing peacebuilding efforts.
Mismanagement of Natural Resources: States, businesses and communitiesEric Kumeh Mensah
This presentation highlights the concepts of mismanagement, public trust and tragedy of the commons. It uses three clear examples to describe natural resources mismanagement at state, business and community levels. Root causes of NR mismanagement are then explored as well as solutions to the key issues raised. I completes by highlighting the role Natural Resource and Environmental Governance student can play in sustainable NRM.
Final fostering resilience expert roundtable new york 4 copyNE Kim
This document summarizes an expert roundtable discussion on fostering resilience in situations of conflict and fragility. The roundtable discussed: 1) Why resilience is an important concept for addressing today's interconnected crises; 2) Perspectives on resilience in conflict-affected contexts, focusing on capacity, agency, and transformation; 3) Strategies for promoting resilience, including basic service delivery, social cohesion, and addressing political dimensions; 4) Challenges in assessing and measuring resilience; and 5) The need for better coordination among humanitarian, development, and peacebuilding actors, as well as innovative financing approaches, to foster resilience in fragile settings.
Comments on the human security aspect of the poverty reduction guidelinesKayode Fayemi
The document discusses the human security dimension of poverty reduction guidelines. It analyzes four typical policy levers proposed in the guidelines: 1) Support for peace building and reconstruction, 2) Support for state monopoly of means of coercion, 3) Promoting social coherence through civil society and tolerance, and 4) Building assets against disasters and economic shocks. However, the document argues that the assumptions and focus on the state in the guidelines provide an incomplete picture in Africa given increasing state illegitimacy. A human security approach requires considering non-state actors and the complex local and international dimensions driving conflicts on the continent.
Issue paper - secure tenure in urban slums low-res FINALAngeli Alba
This document discusses secure tenure for urban slums in Asia-Pacific. It defines secure tenure and explains its importance for development. There is a continuum of land rights, from informal to formal, with eight types ranging from perceived tenure to registered freehold. Successful projects prioritize upgrading slums in situ through community-led development and partnerships between communities, municipalities, professionals, and the private sector. Forced relocation fails while incremental improvements to security of tenure through this continuum approach leads to sustainable communities and urban resiliency.
The document discusses opportunities and challenges related to civil-military cooperation in Sri Lanka. It provides background on the conflict in Sri Lanka and overview of the LTTE. It emphasizes the importance of a holistic and long-term approach to building peace that addresses root causes, rather than just symptoms. It also discusses perceptions each side has of the other and guidelines for civil-military relations according to the IASC, including maintaining separation of roles and seeking military assistance only as a last resort.
2nd ARC Report :CAPACITY BUILDING FOR CONFLICT RESOLUTIONGS SCORE
Polity and Governance topic is mentioned in the GS MAINS PAPER 2, however its indepth knowledge is equally important for writing an Essay, Public Administration (Paper-2) and even in GS Mains Paper 4. The government reports and documents become the best source for its understanding but usually the government reports are too bulky to read and grasping the main points from that become a tough task. Thus we have come up with the series of GIST of SECOND ARC Reports. It covers the main points of the complete report in about 30-35 pages (maximum). These points can be quoted directly in the Mains answer.
Tracking U.S. Humanitarian Aid Responding to Disaster in HaitiGenevieve Dejean
This document provides background information on humanitarian aid from the U.S. to Haiti over three presidential administrations in response to specific crises. It summarizes the humanitarian situation and U.S. response during the Clinton administration following the 1993 paramilitary coup and human rights violations in Haiti. The Clinton administration initially faced challenges regarding Haiti policy inherited from the previous administration. It discusses the violent context in Haiti at the time and the various factions, as well as the Clinton administration's shifting policy approach, including sanctions and peacekeeping troop deployment.
The document discusses the political economy of land and conflicts. It notes that securing land rights for all can help prevent and manage conflicts, as land is a source of livelihoods, wealth and a driver of power struggles. Understanding the various interests in land use and how competing claims are resolved is important. It emphasizes understanding shifting centers of power and interest groups, as well as considering women's land rights equally. A political economy lens is crucial, especially in contexts of poverty, weak governance and injustice, which can fuel conflicts over inequitable access to land resources. Legitimate dispute resolution mechanisms tailored to local contexts can help bridge divides and reconcile competing land claims.
American Research Journal of Humanities & Social Science (ARJHSS) is a double blind peer reviewed, open access journal published by (ARJHSS).
The main objective of ARJHSS is to provide an intellectual platform for the international scholars. ARJHSS aims to promote interdisciplinary studies in Humanities & Social Science and become the leading journal in Humanities & Social Science in the world.
Natural disasters are increasing in intensity and frequency. Preparing for disasters requires understanding how risks differently impact men and women. Disaster preparedness is most effective when communities have inclusive plans and communication with government. However, women's roles in mitigation and preparation are often overlooked. To ensure gender-inclusive preparedness, experts recommend conducting gender analysis, including women in assessments and response coordination, and developing common assessment tools.
[Ambassador Hassan] Speech: Presentation by Ambassador S. Azmat Hassan (Ret.)...GlobalPeaceFoundation
Date: Dec. 6th 2013
Session: Interfaith Partnerships: Faith and Diversity: Toward a Global Ethic for Inclusive and Moderate Societies
Speaker: Ambassador S. Azmat Hassan; Former Pakistani Ambassador to Malaysia, Syria and Morrocco, Islamic Republic of Pakistan
This document summarizes a conference held by the Jesuit Universities Humanitarian Action Network (JUHAN) on refugees and internally displaced persons. Over three days, the conference featured presentations from UN and NGO representatives on challenges facing humanitarian aid efforts, including preserving asylum spaces, developing domestic response capacities, and improving security and sustainable solutions for displaced populations. Students then participated in breakout sessions on issues like the Latin American refugee crisis, camp management, and working with the media. The goal was for students to develop action plans to address refugee needs that could be implemented at their home universities.
Zeitoun - What Matters for Effective Transboundary Water Diplomacyzeitounm
Power and norms matter greatly for effective transboundary water diplomacy and policy responses. Interventions should confront power asymmetries by (1) influencing basin leaders to move from bullies to cooperative partners through benefit-sharing and standards, and (2) challenging power imbalances by leveling players and the playing field through capacity building and establishing clear international water law standards. The Tigris and Euphrates basin exemplifies these issues, with Turkey wielding significant upstream power and the need to establish cooperative norms and standards in its interactions with Syria and Iraq.
This document discusses how transnational aid and faith-based organizations (FBOs) have undermined African governance. It argues that foreign aid has weakened accountability, democracy, and rule of law in African countries by making them dependent and responsive to external pressures. FBOs are analyzed as part of the transnational aid industry. While FBOs provide important services, the document contends they have failed to strengthen governance by enforcing rules and effectively delivering services. Their nature of operation, roles, and autonomy have misled them and weakened African governance in unintended ways. The motives of imperialist countries to exploit weaker nations for profit and domination have changed little over time, and the transnational aid industry serves these same motives by fostering dependency
Corruption Political Party System and Nigerian Democracy An Historical Analys...ijtsrd
Liberal democracy all over the world is a welcome phenomenon. In every modern society the game of politics is influenced tremendously by the elite class that projects the political culture which could make or mar democracy, as a result of the activities of the political parties. The adoption of western democracy is a mixed bag of blessing and catastrophes in the body politics of the country. Today, it is difficult to reconcile Nigerian democracy with that of the advanced democratic Countries. In Nigeria, politics is regarded as a “dirty game” which scares away the down trodden people. It has been noted that the level of socio economic development in the country is significantly related to the nature of politics in vogues. Political parties are primarily aimed at primitive accumulation of wealth. Where, “the end justifies the means” . The prevailing election rigging, thuggery, corruption, fear and intimidation by security agencies as well as hate speech in the campaigns of the politicians reflect value degeneration with the attendant instability in the country’s democracy. To this send, the paper examined political parties in Nigeria An historical Perspective from 1960 – 2019 looking at the roles of political parties as they affect the consolidation of democracy in Nigeria. Three 3 theoretical frameworks were used in the study namely Social learning theory SLT , Social Disorganization theory SDT and Corruption Permissiveness theory CPT .The study noted that Nigeria’s political parties from 1960 2019 has witnessed some challenging situation like ethnicity, corruption, violence, military intervention, civil and electoral deficiencies. Based on the findings, the study recommended among others that registered political parties should not be vehicles for the articulation and implementation of ethnic, religious or regional projects and programmes and that they should remain national in scope, courage and orientation. Aristotle Isaac Jacobs | Tarabina Veronica Pamo | Abidde Kilegha Victoria "Corruption, Political Party System and Nigerian Democracy: An Historical Analysis from 1960 – 2019" Published in International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development (ijtsrd), ISSN: 2456-6470, Volume-5 | Issue-1 , December 2020, URL: https://www.ijtsrd.com/papers/ijtsrd38079.pdf Paper URL : https://www.ijtsrd.com/humanities-and-the-arts/social-science/38079/corruption-political-party-system-and-nigerian-democracy-an-historical-analysis-from-1960-– -2019/aristotle-isaac-jacobs
Deadly but Preventable Attacks: Killings and Enforced Disappearances of Those...Amnesty India
3,500 human rights defenders have been killed worldwide since 1998
281 HRDs killed globally in 2016—a significant increase from 156 defenders killed in 2015 and 136 in 2014
48 journalists killed worldwide in 2016 according to the Committee to Protect Journalists
India among deadliest countries for defenders of rights related to land, environment
Addressing the regional character of conflicts in west africaKayode Fayemi
This document discusses the regional dimensions of conflicts in West Africa and proposes a framework for human security in the region. It begins by outlining the nature and characteristics of conflicts in West Africa, noting that while some countries have made democratic progress, the region remains vulnerable to crisis and violence. It then analyzes the different thematic and geographic categories in the region in terms of their human security situations. The document argues that understanding the root causes of conflicts requires examining both historical and contemporary factors in a nuanced way. It also discusses regionalism in Africa, noting both the progress that has been made through organizations like ECOWAS but also the ongoing challenges to security arrangements and prospects for cooperative security in West Africa.
Helping prevent terrorism and violent conflict the development dimensionKayode Fayemi
The document discusses the development dimension of preventing terrorism and violent conflict in Africa. It argues that narrowly defining security as a military issue fails to address the root causes of conflicts, which are often related to lack of economic opportunity and political legitimacy. A human security approach is needed that considers individual livelihoods and promotes democracy, justice and inclusive development. International organizations must support long-term peacebuilding in a holistic manner rather than just focusing on short-term goals like elections.
Here are the prompts for today's 60 second lecture:
- Summarize your team's discussion about how to deepen learning through collaborative teams.
- Share one insight or "aha" your team discussed regarding next steps.
You have 60 seconds to stand on one leg and share! Go!
The document summarizes a professional learning community (PLC) meeting for reading interventionists. The objectives of the meeting were to standardize processes for identifying students needing interventions, identify consistent data sources to guide support, learn how to use an assessment tool called iCue, and discuss expectations for upcoming professional development on Pyramid Response to Intervention (PRTI). Participants scheduled appointments, read poems, learned how to access iCue from the director of assessment, updated process flowcharts, and discussed learning expectations for the upcoming PRTI training.
The document summarizes the district's work over the past year to improve teaching, learning, and student achievement. Key points include developing curriculum and intervention systems, implementing new programs like ADSIS, analyzing assessment data showing progress in reading and math, and recommending the board approve the annual report.
The document provides details of an administrative retreat for school district administrators held from August 8-10, 2012. It includes an overview of the 3-day agenda with topics to be covered each morning and afternoon. It also lists the members of 6 mixed mini-teams that will participate in activities during the retreat. The retreat focuses on developing plans and strategies for continuous improvement, data analysis, professional development, and preparing for board work sessions. Quotes and information shared focus on the challenges of creating professional learning communities and developing a consistent method for assessing performance and progress toward goals.
The Teaching and Learning Team reported to the School Board on guiding questions around student learning outcomes, assessment, and response to learning. They provided perspectives on developing rigorous curriculum, supporting job-embedded professional development, and using balanced assessments to improve instruction. The report outlined facilitating curriculum development, managing curricula, evaluating programs, developing intervention systems, and using data to drive instruction. It also discussed the role of technology in achieving educational goals and establishing a professional learning community focused on student results.
The document is a summary of an admin retreat held in August 2012. It provides details on poster paper pics that were taken on Wednesday, August 8th during the retreat. In 3 sentences or less, the document summarizes photos taken of poster papers during an administrator retreat in August 2012.
The document discusses several topics related to US foreign policy including:
- Eras of US foreign policy from isolationism pre-WWII to the post-9/11 era.
- Principles of American foreign policy in the 21st century focus on ensuring freedom and security for all.
- An examination of the Iraq war including justification for invasion, strategy, critique of staying the course policy, and slow institutional change.
- Issues related to the war on terrorism including defining the enemy and determining an end.
The document discusses the blinders of development aid from a Western perspective and the lack of legitimacy and accountability in international aid organizations. It analyzes case studies of international aid responses, including the 2010 Haiti earthquake response and the inadequate national responses to Hurricane Katrina in 2005 and the Flint water contamination crisis in 2016 in the US. The document argues that Western aid approaches are underpinned by colonial ideologies that prioritize organizational goals over local needs and sustainability.
Running Head Literature Review 1Literatu.docxcowinhelen
Running Head: Literature Review
1
Literature Review
2
Humanitarian Intervention in Libya
Name
Institution
Humanitarian Intervention in Libya
Over the most recent two decades, humanitarianism has encountered gigantic development, as both a field of try and as a point of academic research. In the custom of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), humanitarianism is customarily connected with unprejudiced, nonpartisan, and autonomous activities embraced to ensure the lives and respect of casualties of the equipped clash and different circumstances of viciousness and to furnish them with help. Following the research that has been doing recently this literature review defines, humanitarianism as the need and desire to relieve human being from suffering (Barnett 2009).
Humanitarianism is of gigantic consequences in contemporary worldwide legislative issues. Around the world, humanitarians help adds up to about 15 billion USD yearly (Global Humanitarian Assistance 2009). There is around 2,600 worldwide guide and improvement offices carrying out their specialty on each landmass and on each side of the globe; nearby and national associations bring the number more like 25,000 (Barnett 2008). In the general population cognizant, humanitarian associations and topics are absolutely ubiquitous. On the TV, on the Internet, in daily papers, and on bulletins, helpful commercials and humanitarianism topics are among the standard methods of experience amongst people groups and generally socially and physically far off universes. It is little pondered, at that point, that researchers and analysts are setting expanding logical weight on humanitarianism.
Simultaneous with the development of the philanthropic segment, the field of humanitarianism investigations has encountered quick advancement, together with its related fields of evacuee studies and improvement considers. Right now, the scene of helpful research comprises of a modest bunch of conspicuous research organizations and focuses of scholastic picking up, including the Feinstein International Center (Tufts University, USA), the Humanitarian Policy Group (Overseas Development Institute, UK), and Humanitarian Outcomes (UK). Philanthropic centered diaries incorporate the Journal of Humanitarian Affairs, Refugee Studies, and Disasters; the grant is additionally distributed in standard scholarly diaries extending from International Organization to Millennium to Voluntas. Throughout the most recent two decades, countless have likewise been distributed on the point. This literature review focuses on one part of this examination, specifically on a determination of vital late strategy centered articles; scholarly work is referenced as fitting.
In spite of the fact that there are special cases to this manage, including a few articles referred to underneath, this must be perceived as a hole. In an extensive part, this finding mirrors the impressively constrained ...
This document summarizes national civilian capacity arrangements for conflict management. It discusses the increasing focus on deploying civilian expertise to support countries recovering from conflict. Peace and stabilization missions have become more civilianized in response to the predominance of complex intrastate conflicts. However, civilian vacancy rates remain high. In response, some countries have developed rapidly deployable civilian capacity arrangements over the past decade to support missions, though challenges remain regarding coordination and building local capacity. The field continues to evolve as new arrangements are developed and existing ones improved.
Panel Debate: Mediation, Conflict Prevention, Resolution and Post-conflict Re...Africa Cheetah Run
Conflict resolution is a way for two or more parties to find a peaceful solution to a disagreement among them. The disagreement may be personal, financial, political, or emotional. When a dispute arises, often the best course of action is negotiation to resolve the disagreement. The overall reduction in the number of violent conflicts can, in part, be attributed to the collective efforts of the United Nations, other international actors and regional organisations.
This document discusses the challenges and ethics faced by a Joint, Interagency Task Force operating in a "predatory state". It begins by defining a predatory state as a regime that exploits its citizens for economic and political gain. The document then examines case studies like Operation Condor to show how Task Forces have enabled human rights abuses by working with oppressive regimes. It analyzes the difficulties faced by the Joint Special Operations Task Force - Philippines, which had to balance counterterrorism missions with concerns over the regime's "war on drugs". Ultimately, the document argues that Task Forces take on increasing ethical dilemmas as they are forced to engage more with predatory states that do not respect basic freedoms.
The document discusses the challenges of writing an essay about the 2010 Haiti earthquake. It notes that the earthquake was catastrophic, killing hundreds of thousands and displacing millions, making it difficult to encapsulate the immense loss and devastation. It also notes that Haiti had long faced issues like political instability, poverty, and environmental degradation prior to the earthquake. Analyzing how these factors intersected with the disaster and response adds complexity. The international response to the earthquake also raises questions about aid effectiveness, power dynamics, and ethics that require nuanced understanding. Lastly, honoring the experiences of those affected while providing broader analysis for unfamiliar readers demands balance and consideration of perspective. In conclusion, an essay on this topic requires not just research but
1) Natural disasters have significantly increased over the last few decades, affecting over 2 billion people and causing over $910 billion in damages globally. This trend is expected to continue with climate change.
2) Future natural disasters will likely have even greater impacts due to population growth, increasing urbanization, effects of climate change like sea level rise and extreme weather events. Developing countries are most vulnerable but developed countries face major economic impacts.
3) Effective response to increase in frequency and scale of natural disasters will challenge existing humanitarian system and require improved coordination between numerous responding entities.
Conflict Between The People, Requiring Body And The...Sharon Roberts
This document discusses potential solutions to conflicts that arise during the land acquisition process. It proposes dividing the acquisition process into three stages: pre-acquisition, acquisition, and post-acquisition. The pre-acquisition stage would deal with evaluating the need for acquisition and assessing compensation. The acquisition stage would be the legal transfer of land. The post-acquisition stage would focus on addressing socio-economic and psychological issues from displacement. Dividing the process aims to allow for specialization and address issues at each step.
International and Humanitarian Disaster Management Discussions.docxwrite4
The document discusses two main topics:
1) Conflicts that can arise between humanitarian organizations and host governments during disaster relief efforts, including issues around coordination, influence, and competing priorities.
2) The ongoing political crisis and humanitarian situation in Venezuela, exacerbated by opposing positions taken by different international actors in relation to the legitimacy of Nicolas Maduro and Juan Guaido's competing claims to the presidency.
International and Humanitarian Disaster Management Discussions.docxwrite30
The document discusses two main topics:
1) Conflicts that can arise between humanitarian organizations and host governments during disaster relief efforts, including issues around coordination, influence, and competing priorities.
2) The ongoing political crisis and humanitarian situation in Venezuela, exacerbated by opposing positions taken by different international actors in relation to the legitimacy of Nicolas Maduro and Juan Guaido's competing claims to the presidency.
An Introduction To Humanitarian Assistance India S Policy And Practice For H...Angie Miller
1) The document discusses the history and principles of humanitarian assistance, from its origins in the 1860s with Henri Dunant witnessing the Battle of Solferino and establishing the International Committee of the Red Cross, to its evolution over the 20th century with new organizations like UNICEF, UNHCR, and MSF emerging.
2) It describes how humanitarian assistance changed significantly after the Cold War, taking on broader objectives around development and peacebuilding in response to rising armed conflicts. New stakeholders like OCHA and ECHO were also established.
3) The text analyzes criticisms of humanitarian responses in the 1990s to crises in Bosnia, Somalia, and Rwanda, and how this led to a "
Similar to Working Paper 03/2012 Civil-military interaction and the future of humanitarian action (11)
International responses to conflict and complex humanitarian emergencies are diverse and multifaceted. Different actors – among them non-government organisations (NGOs), the United Nations (UN) protection mandated organisations, UN peacekeeping forces, both military and police – all have a role to play to mitigate the impact of armed conflict on civilian populations.
Over the last 13 years a significant amount of work has been done to improve the international community’s response in relation to the protection of civilians (POC). This has been led by different actors – the UN Security Council, the Department of Peacekeeping Operations (DPKO) and the humanitarian community made up of UN humanitarian agencies, the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), and NGOs – all working in the same complex humanitarian contexts.
Despite the development of POC, there is a perceived ‘disconnect’ between the understanding of different forms of protection, the different disciplines practising or working on the POC, and the different guidance and legal regimes imposing obligations on both state and non-state actors in the area of protection.
This paper is the first contribution to a broader research project that aims to determine whether the perceived disconnect between actors involved in protection work is real or anecdotal. By exploring the evolution of protection language and policy through the UN Security Council, DPKO and the humanitarian community, it is possible to develop an improved understanding of some of the reasons for distinct protection policies and definitions that exist between different actors. Some initial variations in the interpretation of POC are quick to emerge, giving rise to additional questions about how the distinctions can be better understood.
Historically, international humanitarian law (IHL) through the Geneva Conventions of 1949 and their Additional Protocols of 1977 has required the protection of civilian populations in armed conflict. The Geneva Conventions provide guidance with regard to the obligations of states and parties to a conflict to apply the principle of distinction and to ensure precaution in attack as they pursue their military objectives. This was the first international legal framework to provide for the protection of civilians and forms the foundation of the ‘Protection of Civilians’ concept.
Throughout the 1990s, devastating failures to protect civilians from violence and atrocities shaped thinking at the United Nations (UN) and gave rise to a more expansive concept of Protection of Civilians, incorporating international human rights law, international refugee law, and including best practices in peacekeeping operations and humanitarian response. This is reflected in the adoption of Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict as a thematic concern of the UN Security Council, and the development of policy and guidance relating to civilian protection since 1999, at the United Nations and elsewhere. The term ‘Protection of Civilians’ has expanded from a set of legal obligations in IHL to a conceptual and operational framework used by multiple ‘protection actors’ and practitioners—military and civilian, political and humanitarian.
The concept of Protection of Civilians has developed in response to conflicts and crises as they emerged and as a result has developed unevenly. Combined with the fact that there is no operational definition of Protection of Civilians, there is a perception among protection practitioners that different actors involved in providing protection to people caught up in crisis understand and implement the concept differently. This perception raised questions among the researchers as to whether different understandings actually exist, and if so what the implications for the implementation of civilian protection might be. This gave rise to a research project titled In Search of Common Ground – Understanding Civilian Protection Language and Practice for Civil and Military Practitioners.
This paper explores the relationship between security and development, with a focus on how different types of violence inhibit development in fragile and conflict-affected states.
This paper is based upon a comprehensive literature review of separate pieces of research including academic studies, datasets and policy analysis. It explores statistics and figures that illustrate the barriers that insecurity poses to achieving development outcomes in fragile and conflict-afflicted states. It also examines these dynamics in detail in four countries: Afghanistan, Solomon Islands, South Sudan and Timor-Leste.
The assignment was not to come up with policy recommendations per se; rather it was to present a comprehensive synopsis of how different types of violence shackles and inhibits development in fragile and conflict-affected states. The research team believes that the material presented will be of use to inform policy debate and development, including in the field of security sector reform.
The analysis is contextualised by focusing on three types of violence: political, criminal and interpersonal. The barriers these different types of violence pose to development is presented throughout the report, and embedded in the country case studies.
The statistics uncovered in the course of the project are stark and unnerving. These statistics, among others, are used to highlight the barriers that different types of violence pose to development. It is not only the financial cost, but also the broader institutional and social costs that generate a series of barriers for meaningful development. Through synthesising these statistics, this paper contributes to the understandings of the links between security and development, paving way for policy recommendations and lines of action for Australia and development practitioners.
This document provides an introductory overview of conflict-related sexual and gender-based violence for non-specialists. It examines dominant patterns of such violence, including widespread violence against women and girls as well as male victims. It explores a range of causes beyond strategic warfare, like gender inequality. It also identifies gaps in preventing and responding to violence, such as lack of support services and data. The overview aims to improve understanding and support for preventing and addressing this complex issue.
This document presents a strategic framework for mass atrocity prevention. It begins by noting that while conflict prevention has received significant attention, comparatively less focus has been placed on preventing the specific crimes related to the Responsibility to Protect (R2P) principle: genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and crimes against humanity. The framework is designed to develop a more specific strategic approach for preventing mass atrocity crimes. It involves clarifying what crimes are being prevented, identifying stages of regression towards atrocities, systematizing policy tools that could mitigate risk factors or change escalatory dynamics, and assessing what is needed for tools to be effective. The framework draws on deductive and inductive reasoning, moving between conceptual assumptions and empirical observations
Armed conflicts and natural disasters are inherently gendered crises; they can affect women, men, girls and boys in profoundly different ways. It is increasingly accepted that understanding these differences—or adopting a gender perspective—improves the effectiveness of responses to these crises, as well as the efforts of policy-making, advocacy, research and training institutions that focus on them. A gender perspective is more frequently recognised as a core requirement for all personnel involved in these efforts. However, there are many who are expected to engage with gender issues, yet remain unfamiliar with them. For this audience, there is a dearth of literature that provides an introductory overview of gender issues in crisis environments.
This paper is intended to be an educational and awareness-raising resource for those who are beginning to engage with gender issues in crisis environments, whether they are civilian, military or police. It examines gender dimensions commonly observed in conflict and disaster environments, such as differences in casualty trends, risks, threats, vulnerabilities, needs, opportunities and stresses. It provides examples of the operational benefits of a gender perspective and the harmful consequences resulting from the absence of a gender perspective.
The document discusses the challenges of developing civilian policing in Afghanistan. It outlines two main models of policing - the community policing model and the gendarmerie or paramilitary model. Efforts to establish an Afghan National Police since 2001 have relied too heavily on the militarized gendarmerie model and faced challenges including high casualty rates, desertion, and lack of focus on core policing skills in training. For civilian policing to be effective in Afghanistan, it will require moving away from militarization and prioritizing policing approaches accepted by local communities.
This document discusses guidelines for interaction between civilian police and military personnel during international peace and stability operations. It recommends that before deployments, governments develop strategic frameworks and policies to facilitate cooperation. It also recommends pre-deployment training that allows police and military to learn about each other's roles and capabilities. During operations, conducting thorough risk assessments is important to determine the appropriate roles for police and military given the security environment. The roles and capabilities of each force should be considered to ensure they are suited to the tasks required.
The document provides a summary report from the 2011 Civil-Military Interaction Seminar. The following are the key points from the document:
1. The seminar brought together 125 experts from 21 countries to discuss current trends in civil-military practice and future needs. Five broad themes were examined: local-level processes, new and non-traditional players, the importance of information, prevention/preparedness, and civil-military guidelines.
2. Current global trends shaping civil-military engagement include the fragile economic realities in post-conflict states, fluidity in humanitarianism, and increasing natural disasters in complex environments. Integrated economic reconstruction is needed to support transitions from war to peace.
3. Three clear
This document summarizes analysis conducted by the Military Operations Analysis Team using extensive databases on military engagements, intelligence, villages, economic activity, and social development in Phuoc Tuy province during Australia's involvement in the Vietnam War from 1966 to 1971. The analysis applies statistical, spatial, and temporal techniques to understand factors like changes in insurgent and government control over time, who initiated military contacts, and the impact of various counterinsurgency programs.
1) RAMSI has been transitioning its civilian development, policing, and military components in Solomon Islands over the past decade as the security situation has improved.
2) The civilian development programs will transition to long-term bilateral and multilateral development partners, while the military component will withdraw in mid-2013 and policing will continue being supported for the foreseeable future.
3) While some of the factors that contributed to the past tensions have been addressed, such as rebuilding government institutions and removing weapons, unfinished issues remain like unequal economic development and potential for civil unrest, requiring an ongoing capable local police force.
The document summarizes Operation Sumatra Assist, the Australian Defense Force's (ADF) response to the 2004 Boxing Day tsunami in Indonesia. It discusses [1] the initial ADF deployment of medical personnel, engineers, and aircraft to provide relief; [2] the establishment of facilities like a field hospital and water purification plants to aid survivors; and [3] the challenges of coordinating relief efforts with other countries' militaries and aid organizations. The ADF response was praised for its speed, cultural sensitivity when working with Indonesian communities, and professionalism under difficult conditions in providing emergency relief.
The document is an aide-memoire created by the New Zealand Defence Force (NZDF) to capture best practices from their support of domestic disaster relief efforts in 2011, including Operations PIKE, CHRISTCHURCH QUAKE, and RENA. The aide-memoire aims to assist NZDF planning and operations, as well as inform other agencies involved in disaster response. It contains lessons learned from the 2011 events and is intended to complement NZDF doctrine. The document provides guidance to the military and other agencies in planning for and coordinating disaster relief operations.
The document summarizes an international conference on building security capacity held from September 6-8, 2011 in Washington DC. The conference was co-sponsored by the Australian Civil-Military Centre and the US Center for Complex Operations. Key topics discussed included lessons learned from security sector capacity building efforts, disarmament and demobilization programs, and the importance of civil-military cooperation in peace and stabilization operations. Presenters emphasized the need for context-specific approaches, long-term capacity building led by the host country, and maintaining security gains through political and economic development.
The document discusses the challenges of rebuilding war-torn states and achieving sustainable peace through economic reconstruction. It outlines the difficult transition these countries must make from an economy of war to an economy of peace and then eventual normal development. However, the record of success is poor, with about half of countries relapsing back into conflict. Key challenges include balancing security and economic priorities, integrating military and civilian strategies, and effectively using large amounts of aid to support the transition without creating dependency or distortions. An effective strategy must make peace irreversible by addressing the root causes of conflict and transforming the political and security situation.
This document discusses conflict prevention in theory and practice. It begins by noting the broad agreement on the importance of preventive action but the gap between rhetoric and reality. It then discusses the development of conflict prevention frameworks and mechanisms over time at the UN and other organizations. However, capacity for preventive action remains limited. The challenges of translating early warnings into timely responses and of addressing the underlying causes of conflicts are also discussed. Effective prevention requires tailored strategies and leadership to coordinate multi-faceted prevention efforts.
The document summarizes lessons learned from Christchurch, New Zealand's response to major earthquakes in 2010 and 2011. It discusses:
1) The earthquakes caused widespread damage across Christchurch, destroying infrastructure and claiming 182 lives. A state of emergency was declared.
2) Restoring critical infrastructure like roads, water, and sewage systems was a top priority. This was achieved through a large coordinated effort involving the city, military, and contractors.
3) The military played a key role, providing logistical support, security, and humanitarian aid. However, coordinating their command-and-control style with the city's more collaborative approach required adjustment.
This document summarizes a conference and workshop on emerging law relating to the detention of non-state actors engaged in hostilities. The conference explored legal gaps and questions around detaining powers, applicable legal regimes, and standards. Speakers discussed increasing convergence between international humanitarian law and international human rights law. The workshop involved closed discussions of national detention practices and transferring detainees. Overall, the document examines complex legal issues and practical challenges surrounding the detention of non-state actors in non-international armed conflicts.
Here are the key points about the UN Cluster Approach:
- The Cluster Approach was established by the UN to improve coordination and response in sectors or areas of activity during humanitarian emergencies.
- Clusters are groups of humanitarian organizations, both UN and non-UN, in each of the main sectors of humanitarian action such as water, health and logistics.
- The clusters provide a clear point of contact and leadership in each sector. A designated agency called the 'cluster lead' facilitates cluster coordination and planning.
- The goal is to ensure a more coherent sector-wide response by filling gaps and reducing duplication of effort.
- Clusters operate at both the national and sub-national levels. At the national
Australia’s peacekeeping and peacebuilding
experiences in the Autonomous Region of
Bougainville in Papua New Guinea, and in
Solomon Islands and Timor-Leste.
Working Paper 03/2012 Civil-military interaction and the future of humanitarian action
1. Civil-military interaction and
the future of humanitarian action
Antonio Donini Senior Researcher, Feinstein International Centre, Tufts University
> Paper 03/2012
‘That’s the reason they’re called lessons,’ the Gryphon
remarked: ‘because they lessen from day to day.’
—Alice in Wonderland
The following discussion is structured into three parts:
>> a brief update on the evolution of the
humanitarian enterprise in the past 10 years
network power. The enterprise has also become much more
>> lessons from civil–military interaction
professionalised: for many humanitarian aid workers—and
in three recent crises
there are an estimated 300 000—working in emergencies
>> what we can expect in the years to 2020. has become a career rather than a voluntary mission.
‘Oligopolisation’ has also continued apace. Northern
Evolution of the humanitarian federations of major non-government organisations and UN
humanitarian agencies define how the enterprise works,
enterprise, 2000 to 2010 what constitutes a crisis and how it should be tackled.
In the years from 2000 to 2010 there were major Barriers to entry for groups from the South have become
quantitative and qualitative changes in the nature of the higher; the isomorphism has increased—‘you’ can join ‘us’
humanitarian enterprise. but only on ‘our’ terms.
Quantitative changes We are more technically proficient and do more evaluations
(and have more conferences) but are we better? Are we
Never has there been so much money, so many aid workers more effective at saving lives?
and so much media attention devoted to humanitarian
matters. The humanitarian enterprise now accounts for Qualitative changes
more than US$14 billion a year.1 Afghanistan, Iraq, Darfur, Somalia, Sri Lanka and Haiti stand
Institutionalisation of the enterprise has exploded, in terms as setbacks for humanitarianism. The ‘instrumentalisation’
of standards, norms, guidelines, clusters, accountability and of humanitarian action in support of political and military
1 ACMC Paper 3/2012 > Conflict prevention in practice: from rhetoric to reality
2. agendas has resulted in unprecedented levels of co‑option,
blurring of lines, and the subordination of humanitarianism
Lessons from civil-military
to politics. The Global War on Terror has accelerated interaction: three crises
this process, and in extreme cases the result is the
Haiti and Pakistan constitute examples from which much can
criminalisation of humanitarian action (for example, in the
be learnt about civil–military responses; Afghanistan teach
cases of Somalia and Palestine). As a consequence, aid
us lessons about ‘stabilisation’ and the future of civil–military
agencies are becoming more risk averse.
interaction.
Humanitarianism is also being affected by the current
wave of interventionism, which is fuelled in part by the Haiti
International Criminal Court and responsibility to protect An extremely strong—magnitude 7.0 on the Richter
agendas. Increasingly, the North’s human rights agenda Scale—earthquake hit Haiti on 12 January 2010. The
clashes with the humanitarian agenda. And the humanitarian resultant devastation triggered a massive humanitarian
enterprise has itself become much more interventionist. response, in which the US military, the UN peace mission
We are perhaps witnessing the merger of humanitarianism and 27 other military contingents played a crucial role.
and empire: non-government organisations are ‘the Civil‑military interaction was widely seen to be helpful in
mendicant orders of empire’, ‘the capillary vessels of terms of logistics, but the dominance of the US military
globalization’.2 Even those who do not see themselves as presence gave rise to many questions.
‘force multipliers’ of Northern world-ordering agendas or
of stabilisation operations3 are affected by association. In Important factors
Afghanistan, Iraq and Darfur we have paid a high price for This was natural disaster in an unnatural setting. It occurred
being seen to take sides. in a densely populated urban area in what is a very poor
country and a weak state that was mostly sidelined in the
The collapse of the asylum and protection regime is aftermath of the quake. A dense population in an urban
another area of concern. From refugees to IDPs (internally environment characterised by shanty housing posed new
displaced persons) to ISPs (internally stuck persons), challenges for humanitarian organisations. There was poor
dealing with protection has become more difficult. On overall interaction with Haitian civil society and groups. The
the plus side, though, those who deliberately cause harm long history of US hegemony and economic interests, which
to civilians are increasingly questioned by civil society— had resulted in decades of weakening of the state, affected
witness the Arab Spring. the quality of the response.
Finally, the humanitarian field is more crowded than Coordination
ever, with the emergence of new traditions (Islamic non- The immediate post-quake period was a time of huge
government organisations and donors), a diversification of logistical effort accompanied by a serious coordination
donors (Gulf states, Brazil, Cuba–Venezuela, and private deficit. The absence of humanitarian leadership
donors and foundations) and new types of ‘humanitarian’ compounded by slow needs assessment undermined the
action (for-profit organisations and private security humanitarians’ efforts to influence the overall direction
companies), including military–aid hybrids. and shape of the operation. The humanitarians’ directing
In summary, the politicisation and manipulation of military contingents was poor, so US Central Command
of humanitarian action have reached new heights: took the strategic lead in Florida. US control of the airport
humanitarian action is now inseparable from western foreign in Port‑au-Prince was resented, although the US did do vital
policy.4 At the same time, humanitarian action has itself work in rehabilitating the air link and the seaport area.
crossed the threshold of power—from a powerful discourse The Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
to a discourse of power. At its heart this is power that moves and the UN–NGO aid community were unclear about the
unprecedented amounts of funds and influences public civil‑military relationship in a non-war setting; and there was
opinion and governance, but it also a biopolitical power that much uncertainty about how to interact with US and other
expresses itself at its most extreme in triage—who is ‘saved’, military participants. The Joint Operations Tasking Centre
who is ‘damned’, and who remains in a transient or, more functioned well, however, as a single point of tasking and
often than not, permanent state of purgatory. What we have communication.
is a kind of primordial form of instrumentalisation that is
consubstantial with the humanitarian relationship.
2 ACMC Paper 3/2012 > Conflict prevention in practice: from rhetoric to reality
3. Mobilisation of military logistic assets was vital on occasions, so the relationship was harmonious and led to the
but there were persistent concerns about the militarisation establishment of a new disaster management infrastructure.
of relief. The history of military interventions in Haiti fuelled
The role of the military
unease about the military’s motivations, and a widespread
International military forces—there were 19 different
perception in Haiti that the US military presence was linked
contingents—played an important role in the early
to hegemonic interests and a desire to curb migration to the
post‑quake stage, and the contribution of the national
United States.
Pakistani military5 was significant from the start. Helicopters
Cuba provided a contrary example to the US behemoth— played a central role because of the mountainous terrain and
‘gauze not guns’. A total of 1500 Cuban doctors were collapsed roads. The Pakistani military has a larger stock of
deployed (some remain there); they treated 70 000 patients helicopters than anyone else.
in contrast to the US medical ship treating only 8600.
There are three general lessons to be learnt in relation to the
The lesson here concerns the need for a better appreciation military role in 2005:
that disaster relief goes way beyond logistics and that such
>> A strong, well-equipped national military force
vital assets will be of help only when they are part of a
can bring important benefits to the humanitarian
coordinated humanitarian plan that is specific to the crisis
response to a natural disaster, even one with
in question.
peripheral ‘complexity’, as is the case with
Pakistan Kashmir and the Northwest Frontier region.
In the case of Pakistan, there are three elements in play: >> The logistical and information role of the military
should ideally not be allowed to bleed over into
>> ‘exemplary’ civil–military interaction in the roles such as assessment and coordination, which
response to the 2005 earthquake are better lodged within a humanitarian-response
>> manipulation of aid during the 2008–2009 surge capacity that is sympathetic to the norms espoused
in conflict—known as the ‘displacement crisis’ by humanitarians and at odds with military culture.
>> the shadow of the Global War on Terror >> Importantly, a military deeply embedded in the
and armed conflict in the response to the political structure, as is the Pakistani military, can
unprecedented flooding of 2010. be mobilised rapidly but arrives unrestrained by
civilian or humanitarian oversight and is in danger of
The dominance of the military in Pakistan colours all aspects
being dismissive of humanitarian considerations.
of political life and shapes external policy and domestic
politics as well as the economy. There is little space for The displacement crisis of 2008–09
elected civil administrations to operate, and in any case and the flooding in 2010
such administrations are seen as invariably corrupt and If the 2005 earthquake response was an example of
self-interested. Moreover, Pakistan is a nuclear state, with successful civil–military cooperation, not so the two
the world’s fastest growing nuclear arsenal and a huge subsequent crises. The so-called displacement crisis of
army. Other important features are a population of over 2008–09 and the 2010 floods entailed a completely different
180 million that is growing rapidly, a faltering economy, rapid relationship between humanitarian agencies and the military.
urbanisation, and ever-reducing prospects of a viable future The shadow of the Global War on Terror and the military’s
for many. The regional brinkmanship of Pakistan’s politics is a role in pushing back different sets of Pakistani armed groups
further cause for concern. Additionally, Pakistan is on course changed the dynamics: militant attacks, counter-insurgency
for many disasters, including water shortages, in the future. operations and a surge in fighting beginning in 2008 resulted
in the displacement—including by force—of hundreds of
The 2005 earthquake
thousands of civilians. The result was a complex and deadly
On 8 October 2005 a devastating earthquake to hit Kashmir
situation; according to one estimate, 35 000 civilians were
and the Northwest Frontier region: there were 75 000 deaths
killed between 2008 and 2010.6
and over 100 000 injured; more than half a million homes
were destroyed over a large area. Winter was approaching. Access to vulnerable groups was denied in many locations,
Pakistan had little experience in disaster preparedness and there was heavy-handed control and manipulation of
and response, but the military swung into action and are humanitarian aid. Disrespect for principles and the blurring
widely considered to have done a good job in difficult of lines between military, political and relief objectives
circumstances. Relief and military interests converged, became major concerns. Access was constrained both
3 ACMC Paper 3/2012 > Conflict prevention in practice: from rhetoric to reality
4. on security grounds and because of the military’s desire agencies openly flouted the UN decision not to use military
to keep humanitarian agencies away from certain areas. assets because civilian alternatives were available.
Non‑objection certificates were used to curtail access or to
force agencies to do the military’s bidding. Afghanistan and the perils of stabilisation
Beneficiary lists became a point of contention: the military The challenges in the civil–military relationship evident in
wanted to control these so that the ‘bad guys’ would not the cases of Haiti and Pakistan pale in comparison with
receive assistance. As a result, many vulnerable groups those in Afghanistan. Afghanistan was, and remains, a
received little or no assistance. There were also serious totally different ball game, where the tension between the
protection problems: large numbers of people were forcibly role of the military and its interaction with non-government
displaced from Swat and other areas and then forced to organisations often reached breaking point. The question
return to their area of origin when the military decided they at hand is a very important one, at the heart of the
should, rather than when it was safe to do so. world‑ordering debate: how do we transform dangerous
situations that are perceived as threatening to ‘our’ interests
Moreover, the aid community had assumed it could apply into more benign environments that fit with ‘our’ ideas of
the ‘quake model’ of cooperation with the Pakistani military what liberal peace in the borderlands should look like?
and was unprepared for a complex response in a conflict
setting. Most agencies, including the United Nations, were The following paragraphs look at the polarising matter of
more anxious to safeguard their historical relationships with stabilisation from a humanitarian perspective, as a subset
the Government of Pakistan rather than pressing for the of the broader ‘coherence’, or ‘joined-up government’,
support of humanitarian principles. agenda in dealing with conflict and crisis. On the face
of it, coordination between all involved would seem to
The UN leadership was inexperienced in humanitarian make sense. The underlying theme of the proponents of
matters or lacked leadership, or both. It was unable to stabilisation is ‘If only we had a clear and effective division
negotiate access to the conflict areas and did not even of labour between the civil, military, development and
try to enter into a conversation with the ‘other side’ in humanitarian actors, between the outsiders and the local
relation to access to and protection of civilians. The nadir authorities in “hot” stabilization situations, then our goals
was reached when the UN political representative stated, would be within our grasp’.
‘Assistance should follow military gains’. The exceptions were
the International Committee of the Red Cross, Médecins But this point of view can be disputed. We are not all in
Sans Frontières and the Office for the Coordination of the same boat. Aid agencies that provide humanitarian
Humanitarian Affairs, which strived to work according to assistance do not have goals in common with those of the
principle in a very difficult environment. military in places such as Afghanistan and Somalia. From a
humanitarian perspective, one can argue that humanitarian
The response to the 2010 floods—a disaster on an action needs to be protected and insulated from stabilisation
enormous scale—benefited from the experience of the and politically motivated initiatives.
post-quake disaster management institution building of the
Pakistani authorities, but it suffered from the consequences There are two questions here:
of the instrumentalisation of humanitarian action in the >> Should humanitarian action be linked to,
‘displacement crisis’. Again, access was strictly controlled by or included in, comprehensive or coherent
the military. In some areas of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province, approaches to conflict resolution?
only national staff were allowed in; in others not even them.
>> Even if such action is not included, what is the impact of
Humanitarian principles were put under severe stress these approaches on principled humanitarian action?
on the ‘last resort’ decision about whether military air
The answer to the first question is straightforward:
assets—including NATO assets from the Afghan theatre—
humanitarians should not take sides. They should not make
should be used.
pronouncements on whether a war is just or unjust because
The lesson learnt there concerns the question of when a to do so is to undermine their ability to respond to need.
‘natural disaster’ is not a natural disaster. The Pakistani floods Obviously, then, they should not engage in controversies
show the importance of narratives, how those narratives of a political nature and, even less, engage in action with a
shape the response, and the consequences of labelling. Most belligerent. Neutrality is not an end in itself: it is a means
of the aid organisations accepted the ‘natural disaster’ label of fulfilling the humanitarian imperative. Furthermore, the
and saw no problem in cooperating with the military, or even perception of being associated with a belligerent carries
NATO. The UN country team was split on this, and some potentially deadly consequences for humanitarian aid workers.
4 ACMC Paper 3/2012 > Conflict prevention in practice: from rhetoric to reality
5. The answer to the second question is more complicated, if ‘aid’ … ‘During a recent mission, the Afghan National
not murky. And this murkiness spreads across political and Army and their coalition mentors provided relief to
the assistance participants alike. the Afghan people. In return for their generosity,
the ANA asked the elders to provide them with
In Afghanistan the United Nations is, and is seen as, aligned
assistance in tracking down anti-government forces’.
with the US-led intervention. The UN’s humanitarian
capacity is weak and further diminished by its association >> Recently there has been a surge in night searches
with an integrated mission that is intimately linked to the of NGO compounds—in particular, medical
International Security Assistance Force. clinics. This is not only in violation of international
humanitarian law: it also exposes NGO staff to the
The majority of non-government organisations do not fare
perception that they are associated with coalition
much better since many work as implementing partners
forces or passing intelligence information to them.
for government programs or, even if they do not, are
nonetheless seen as part of the international enterprise that These examples show that, even if humanitarian agencies
supports the government.7 The defence of humanitarian are not involved in stabilisation activities, such activities can
principles is left to the International Committee of the Red have potentially dangerous consequences for the perceived
Cross, and recently Médecins Sans Frontières, which are the neutrality and impartiality of the agencies and their staff.
only international organisations capable of working neutrally, They are likely to make the negotiation of humanitarian
impartially and independently. access—which requires a minimum degree of acceptance
and trust from all belligerents—more difficult. So far, only
To complicate matters, with the exception of Switzerland,
the International Committee of the Red Cross and Médecins
all the donors in Afghanistan are also belligerents. They are
Sans Frontières have had a steady dialogue on access and
reluctant to admit that there is a humanitarian crisis and
acceptance in areas dominated by different elements of the
would rather see ‘their’ non-government organisations as
armed opposition.
force multipliers for their political and military objectives.
Indirectly, therefore, stabilisation operations affect In summary, there are good practical reasons for
humanitarianism because that is where the money is, and separating or insulating principled humanitarian action
NGOs are obliged to balance principle with institutional from stabilisation activities. There are also strong ethical
survival. It would appear that until recently they tended and policy reasons for doing so. Humanitarian action
to choose the latter over the former. There is a ‘rice bowl’ derives its legitimacy from universal principles enshrined
problem here: if the NGOs are unwilling to do the bidding in the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration
of the stabilisation donors, the private contractors or the of Human Rights, and international humanitarian law.
military itself will do the job. Such principles often do not sit well with the Security
Council’s political compromises: politics—the ‘art of
There have been many instances of a flagrant blurring of the
the possible’—is not necessarily informed by principle.
lines. The following are examples:
Incorporating a function that draws legitimacy from the UN
>> In 2008–2009 USAID sought applications for a five‑year Charter (or the Universal Declaration) in a management
$150 million project. The request documentation structure born of political compromise in the Security
detailed several alarming objectives. Among Council is questionable and possibly self-defeating.
others, USAID asked organisations to implement
The question of better insulation of humanitarian action, if
‘post‑battlefield cleanup’ operations, essentially asking
not its complete separation from politics and stabilisation
that they work with communities in the aftermath
approaches, is likely to remain an unresolved one on the
of a battle and operate in or alongside provincial
humanitarian agenda for some time. The International
reconstruction teams, which, as military–assistance
Committee of the Red Cross and other Dunantist
hybrids, were supposed to win hearts and minds and
humanitarians remain wary of, if not hostile to, the
communicate a narrative of successful development.
militarisation of aid inherent in stabilisation agendas.
>> There has been improper use of the term ‘humanitarian’
As a humanitarian, I want to keep out of partisan politics
by the military. A NATO–ISAF press release8 reads,
because that is the best guarantee I have of being able to
‘Humanitarian assistance operations are helping both
assist and protect the most vulnerable, wherever they may
the people of Afghanistan and coalition forces fight
be. As a citizen, I want peace and a more just world. I am
the global war on terror …’ Under a strategy known
therefore interested in actions that address the root causes
as ‘information operations’, remote villages receive
of conflict rather than just binding up the wounds. The
5 ACMC Paper 3/2012 > Conflict prevention in practice: from rhetoric to reality
6. questions here are: Does it work? Are my citizen taxpayer control to areas hitherto ‘pre-capitalist’ or surviving at the
dollars, euros and pounds being well spent? margins of the capitalist system. When the objective of the
external intervention is peacebuilding or nation building the
It does not seem so. The Bonn process, which was
record so far is dubious. The assumption that it is possible to
supposed to usher in a durable peace in Afghanistan, has
engineer rapid and durable change through a combination
badly backfired. In 2002–03, when there were fewer than
of military means and humanitarian assistance and to steer
4000 International Security Assistance Force troops in
this change from the outside is as yet unproven. It might
Afghanistan, aid agencies had access to all provinces. Now,
be possible to smother a crisis for a time (as in Bosnia), but
with more than 30 times as many troops being present,
ultimately peacebuilding is about social transformation: like
non-government organisations have access to maybe a
democracy, it cannot be imposed from the outside; it has to
fifth of the country. The conflict has intensified, so have
be illuminated from within.
civilian casualties, and resentment of ‘foreign occupation’ is
more widespread. Now that foreign troop withdrawals are There are three practical, or solution-focused, conclusions
accelerating, there is a risk that the country will slide back one can draw:
into the kind of civil war that eventuated after the collapse of
>> Debate is good, and it helps to contextualise
the Soviet-backed regime in 1992.
complex situations and the variations in ‘stabilisation’
The argument about the effectiveness of stabilisation approaches. In places such as Iraq and Afghanistan
operations has so far been mainly ideological. On one it should be possible to agree that narrowly defined
side are the proponents of linking assistance and security. humanitarian action—saving and protecting the
This can be done brutally in a counter-insurgency lives of civilians caught up in crisis and conflict—
context—‘If you tell us where the Taliban are, we will give can and should be kept separate from partisan
you assistance’. Or it can be done more subtly, as with the or politically motivated stabilisation operations.
‘clear‑shape‑hold‑build’, or so-called integrated, approaches A space needs to be reserved for card-carrying
when assistance was provided to win over ‘swing districts’. humanitarians working according to time-tested
Brutal or subtle, the ideological contention is that assistance principles and engaging with all sets of belligerents.
‘delivers’ security.
>> Situations evolve with time. In Afghanistan, victory,
On the other side of the argument this claim is disputed. peace and ‘post-conflictness’ were declared
Development is always a conflict-based process involving far too soon—hence the unprecedented levels
winners and losers. It is about politics. Reducing poverty of instrumentalisation and blurring of lines, the
in places such as Afghanistan is obviously a worthy and consequent attacks against aid workers, and the
necessary goal of itself, but expecting poverty reduction difficulties of reaching those in need of life-saving
efforts to bring ‘security’ is a stretch. Arguing about help. Other situations show that when a threshold
provincial reconstruction teams and ‘hearts and minds’ of stability is reached or when there is basic
operations will be productive only if verifiable facts can be agreement among all involved on what should
relied on. The evidence now shows convincingly that buying be the way forward (in Sierra Leone or Nepal, for
hearts and minds with small-scale projects does not work.9 example) comprehensive and coherent approaches
One study concludes, ‘There is little evidence this approach make more sense, and, if necessary, the military
is generating stability …’10 can have a role in implementing an agreed plan.
There is danger in seeking quick impacts. Remember the >> In relation to the role of the military in crisis response,
Taliban commander telling his captors, ‘You Americans have we have doctrine (the Oslo Guidelines, which enshrine
watches; we have time’. There is also danger in throwing the principle of ‘last resort’), we have practice, and
money at complex problems. Sloppy aid does not win hearts we have extreme variation in contexts. The Pakistan
and minds. earthquake shows that in a ‘natural disaster’ setting
much can be achieved by civil–military interaction and
even cooperation. But when the context changes (the
Humanitarian action to 2020 spread of armed conflict, floods, and huge numbers
Looking ahead, it is useful to consider stabilisation of people displaced) the risk of militarisation and
operations as an integral part of global governance and manipulation of aid becomes high. Haiti confirms this:
world ordering: they are aimed at making the ‘borderlands’ many Haitians resented the overbearing militarisation
safe for globalisation; they are part of the process of of the response. Afghanistan confirms it, too.
extension of the dominant forms of production and social
6 ACMC Paper 3/2012 > Conflict prevention in practice: from rhetoric to reality
7. It might well be that Afghanistan is an aberration: many saw >> The settling of tectonic plates leading to a more complex
it as a laboratory of new approaches, but the experiment multipolar world is, however, likely to lead to localised,
has largely failed. And it might well be, as some studies are and in some cases extremely violent, conflicts. Some
showing, that we are witnessing a global decline in conflict will argue that in today’s asymmetrical conflicts there is
as a source of human suffering.11 no space for neutrality, but recent crises such as those
in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iraq and Somalia demonstrate
But then another cause for concern rears its head. If it
the exact opposite: the shrinking of humanitarian space
is true that conflict as a vector of humanitarian need is
and the instrumentalisation of humanitarian action
declining, vulnerability linked to climate change, natural
have had deleterious effects for communities needing
hazards, poor governance, technological, and possibly
assistance, for the security of humanitarian aid workers,
civilisation‑changing, or ‘black swan’, events seem to be
and for the credibility of the aid workers’ organisations.
increasing. If this trend is confirmed in the longer term, it will
probably be the future focus of humanitarian agencies. And >> New players will become much more active in the relief
this is where the military and the civilian agencies are likely arena. China, India, Brazil and Indonesia are likely to
to interact. bring different perspectives and operational approaches
that will challenge the current Northern or western
In such disaster settings, Northern humanitarian agencies
functioning of the humanitarian enterprise. It is likely
will inevitably clash with the logic of the state. Again, the
that assistance from these countries will compete
comfortable interventionist spirit of Northern humanitarians
with that provided by the established agencies and
will be increasingly challenged by states and civil society
that it will be much more ‘state-centric’ compared
organisations in the South. It will also be necessary to deal
with the current norm. What this means in terms of
with ‘compound catastrophic events’, where disasters,
the protection of at-risk communities and their rights
poor or dysfunctional governance, criminality and service
at times of crisis is as yet unclear. On the positive
breakdown exacerbate the crisis. It is debatable whether
side, one can expect local groups to be much better
traditional humanitarian approaches are adequate to
informed through the internet and social media and in
respond to such rapidly changing forms of vulnerability and
a much better position to demand accountability and
the rising risks they entail in contexts where the state will
transparency in relation to the provision of assistance.
have primary responsibility for responding.
>> At the same time the need for a protected niche
This has implications for the scope and shape of a
for principled humanitarian agencies—such as the
humanitarian enterprise that is still based on Cold War and
International Committee of the Red Cross or Médecins
post–Cold War assumptions of what constitutes a crisis. The
Sans Frontières—will remain. This might result in
enterprise is essentially backward-looking. We are getting
a more modest humanitarian enterprise, closer in
better at dealing with last year’s crisis, and perhaps today’s.
ambition and intent to time-tested humanitarian
But is the enterprise adapted to the challenges that are likely
principles. Such an enterprise would stand a better
to come its way in the coming decades? How is it faring in
chance of saving and protecting lives in conflict
places such as Yemen and Syria? Not very well, it seems.
or complex political emergencies than today’s
Because of strong affirmations of state sovereignty (in Sudan increasingly politically driven and militarised forms
and Sri Lanka, for example) and because the nature of a of relief, on one hand, and emerging non-western
crisis can implicate the state directly in the response, it is ‘sovereignty-based’ discourses on the other.
possible to foresee a number of changes:
>> There will be more regulation and more pressure to Notes
conform to national state–driven agendas. This is 1
Development Initiatives figures for 2010: devint.org.
not necessarily a bad thing. Gone are the days of free
and easy humanitarian interventionism on the part
2
M Hardt & A Negri, Empire, Harvard University Press, Cambridge
MA, 2000.
of non-government organisations and UN agencies.
3
The US Stabilization Manual defines ‘medical stabilisation
>> Humanitarian agencies will inevitably engage with operations’ thus: ‘Stability operations are humanitarian relief missions
national militaries (and the international contingents that the military conducts outside the U.S. in pre-conflict, conflict and
coming to help them). When the state is legitimate and post-conflict countries, disaster areas or underdeveloped nations, and
the external intervention is agreed to by all involved, in coordination with other federal agencies, allied governments and
there is no reason that civilian and military agencies international organizations. The new policy elevates the importance
should not work together with a division of labour that of such military health support in stability operations, called Medical
respects their respective ethos and competence. Stability Operations (MSOs), to a DoD [Department of Defense] priority
that is comparable with combat operations’.
7 ACMC Paper 3/2012 > Conflict prevention in practice: from rhetoric to reality
8. 4
Actually, this is not so new. In 1976 Henry Kissinger stated, ‘Disaster
relief is becoming increasingly a major instrument of our foreign policy’.
5
In total, the Pakistani military deployed 60 000 troops to assist in
the earthquake response. This is about 10 per cent of its total strength.
6
The Costs of War project, Brown University, 2011.
7
Most, if not all, NGOs are multi-mandate organisations focused
principally on reconstruction, development, and advocacy or solidarity.
Some engage in humanitarian activities as part of their varied portfolio.
The absence of a critical mass of principled, or Dunantist, humanitarian
players affects the quality of the debate surrounding humanitarian
concerns and the ability to respond to these concerns on the ground.
8
23 December 2008.
9
The Feinstein International Center at Tufts University is completing
a series of case studies on the effectiveness of ‘hearts and minds’
operations in Afghanistan, with the aim of providing some evidence as
to whether these operations actually promote security. The final report
on this research will be issued in early 2012 (see fic.tufts.edu).
10
‘As political pressures to “show results” in troop contributing
countries intensify, more and more assistance is being channelled
through military actors to “win hearts and minds” while efforts to
address the underlying causes of poverty … are being sidelined.’
‘Development projects implemented with military money or through
military-dominated structures aim to achieve fast results but are often
poorly executed, inappropriate and do not have sufficient community
involvement to make them sustainable’—Actionaid–Oxfam, Quick
Impact, Quick Collapse: the dangers of militarized aid in Afghanistan,
Oxfam America, Washington DC, 2010.
11
Human Security Institute, University of British Columbia study,
available online.
8 ACMC Paper 3/2012 > Conflict prevention in practice: from rhetoric to reality