This document summarizes a project analyzing web traffic logs from three academic institutions - Portland State University, University of Oregon, and Oregon Health & Science University. The project aimed to see if traffic patterns differed based on institution type and identify common metrics for evaluating academic library websites. Key findings included traffic closely following academic terms at PSU and UO but not OHSU. Unique visitors and page views also differed significantly between institutions. Further analysis of top pages showed libraries' homepages accounted for 32-38% of traffic at PSU and UO but only 4% at OHSU. The document concludes by discussing challenges in comparing data and implications for website design and services.