International Law 
Meaning. Sources. Weakness. 
Enduring Value.
The Meaning of International Law 
• Defining international law: 
– The customs, norms, principles, rules and 
other legal relations among states and other 
international legal personality that establish 
binding obligations. 
– A body of rules which binds states and other 
agents in world politics with one another.
Sources of International Law 
• Sources: 
1. Conventions and treaties 
2. International customs 
3. Generally recognized principles of law 
4. International judicial decisions, writing of 
recognized scholars and treatises.
Weakness of International Law 
• Vague and conflicting obligations— 
largely the result of importance of 
treaties and conventions 
• No effective legal system 
1. Lack of compulsory jurisdiction 
a. International Court of Justice 
b. Optional Clause 
2. Absence of judicial hierarchy
Weakness of International Law 
• Law and Power 
1. Powerful states able to ignore law when 
it conflicts with their interests 
2. Law itself is often a reflection of power 
and interests
The Enduring Value of International 
Law 
• False lessons of spectacular failures 
1. Example: Kellogg-Briand Pact 
2. Need realistic vision of what international 
law can and cannot accomplish 
3. Positive v. normative law traditions
The Enduring Value of 
International Law 
• States usually abide by international law 
1.Identitive compliance 
2.Utilitarian compliance 
3.Coercive compliance (possibility of 
reprisals) 
• Liberalism and international law: 
embodying shared values 
• Constructivism and international law: 
shaping norms and identities
Conclusion 
International Law, neither an irrelevancy 
nor panacea.

Understanding International Law in International Relation

  • 1.
    International Law Meaning.Sources. Weakness. Enduring Value.
  • 2.
    The Meaning ofInternational Law • Defining international law: – The customs, norms, principles, rules and other legal relations among states and other international legal personality that establish binding obligations. – A body of rules which binds states and other agents in world politics with one another.
  • 3.
    Sources of InternationalLaw • Sources: 1. Conventions and treaties 2. International customs 3. Generally recognized principles of law 4. International judicial decisions, writing of recognized scholars and treatises.
  • 4.
    Weakness of InternationalLaw • Vague and conflicting obligations— largely the result of importance of treaties and conventions • No effective legal system 1. Lack of compulsory jurisdiction a. International Court of Justice b. Optional Clause 2. Absence of judicial hierarchy
  • 5.
    Weakness of InternationalLaw • Law and Power 1. Powerful states able to ignore law when it conflicts with their interests 2. Law itself is often a reflection of power and interests
  • 6.
    The Enduring Valueof International Law • False lessons of spectacular failures 1. Example: Kellogg-Briand Pact 2. Need realistic vision of what international law can and cannot accomplish 3. Positive v. normative law traditions
  • 7.
    The Enduring Valueof International Law • States usually abide by international law 1.Identitive compliance 2.Utilitarian compliance 3.Coercive compliance (possibility of reprisals) • Liberalism and international law: embodying shared values • Constructivism and international law: shaping norms and identities
  • 8.
    Conclusion International Law,neither an irrelevancy nor panacea.