Transitions in Hydraulic
        Engineering
Impact of the Delta Works on the Recent
Developments in Hydraulic Engineering


       Krystian W. Pilarczyk
          (former) Rijkswaterstaat
  Hydraulic Engineering Institute, Delft
      krystian.pilarczyk@gmail.com
Transitions in
                          Hydraulic Engineering
                              Content:
                              • Introduction
                              • (brief) History of Netherlands
                                in coping floods
                              • Delta Works overview
                              • Impact of Delta Works on
                                recent developments in
                                hydraulic engineering
                              • Conclusions


- erosion – scour - closures – bottom protection – revetments – filters – geotextiles
Introduction

                The Netherlands
                Low-lying country


With dikes




                "God created the world, and the Dutch created
Without dikes   the Netherlands"
Dutch History   "God created the world, and the
                Dutch created the Netherlands"



       Flood protection
              in
       The Netherlands
         through the
          centuries
Dutch history



(MSL)
Watersystem & Rainfall problems in NL




                                                            Storage
                         Storage
        Storage




                  land




                                                                      River
  Sea




                                           Polder


                                   water




                                                    water
                                                    water
  "God created the world, and the Dutch created the Netherlands."
Zeeland about 1500
Turning point:   Disaster 1953


                   Dike breaches and
                      inundation
Why is flood defence
important ?
   Flood events:
    flood event               damage                       victims
    Sea 1953                  ƒ 1.500 106                  1835
    Meuse 1993                ƒ       250 106              ----
                                                      6
    Rhine 1995                ƒ       500 10               ----
    Meuse 1995                ƒ       165 106              ----
    Rainfall 1998             ƒ 1.100 106                  ----

          Road and Hydraulic Engineering Devision, Delft


         1 US $=2 f


We can not avoid the floods
but we can/must minimize the
consequences
(victims, economical damage)
High safety standards needed
1997
From Disaster   1953


                       (open)Eastern
                       Scheldt barrier




                         Western Scheldt




    to Delta Works                                Antwerp


  Deltaplan
Closure
   Techniques

                             Dike
                             wheel
       Scour hole

                                     Caisson-closure

Cable-line
(also during the 1st stage
Eastern Scheldt closure)
                                                           scour
                                              Bottom
                                              protection
From Closed to Open
                                  Eastern Scheldt Project
                                  Environment & Ecology




   1973 start discussion on environmental issues
   !974 stop execution full closure
   1976 decision Open Storm Surge Barrier
                                                   http://foto.telenet.be/photo-gallery/tags/label-oosterschelde.html
Storm-surge barrier Eastern Scheldt




                         Final
From the past to the present


Eastern
Scheldt

                                            Zierikzee
                                Rotterdam   City rights 1248

                                                                              Vlissingen


                    Zierikzee
  Eastern Scheldt
                                                  View from the Expo      Center
    Vlissingen                                    Eastern Scheldt Storm Surge Barrier




                                                               http://www.zierikzee-monumentenstad.nl/
Techniques
          Overview of the
          Eastern Scheldt
        Storm Surge Barrier




scour – bottom protection – foundation –
superstructure – high tolerance requirements
Techniques
Techniques
From traditional to
     modern
Modern Techniques
Techniques
Storm-surge barrier
 Rotterdam (1997)
Transition into integrated/multidisciplinary approach


       Transitions in
    hydraulic engineering
                   Impact Delta Works

                                             Soil –Water –
                                         Structure interactions
                                                but also
                                             Environment
                                           Environmental Impact Assessment
Transition from deterministic to probabilistic approach


Design Philosophy & Methodology
                                                          Failure or inundation

     Risk
                                  <Typ naam hier>
                                                            Loading
                                   <Typ titel hier>                       Resistance


        <Typ naam hier>           <Typ naam hier>           <Typ naam hier>
         <Typ titel hier>          <Typ titel hier>          <Typ titel hier>




                                        Failure modes & Failure tree
Transition from traditional to   Closure by dumped
modern techniques                      method
                                 (rock, blocks, bags)

     Closing                       using cable-line


   techniques
• Gradual closures
     – Horizontal
     – Vertical                  Principles of closure
                                      techniques
• Sand closures
     – Pipe discharged
     – Dumped
• Sudden closures
     – Caissons
Transition to innovative techniques


       Sand Closures
Techniques &
   problems
Grevelingen Dam and sluice
(Siphon)                                           High salinity



                                              Density
Low salinity                                  current
               High salinity                  and
                                              erosion
                               Low salinity
Scour and
        Bottom
       protection



600m
Scour and Bottom protection
  Eastern Scheldt Barrier
Research as design tool


    Scour research
  Scour prediction
Scour
research


                      Prototype tests Brouwersdam
   Discharge sluice
Scour
prototype
 results


            undermining


Prediction instability of upper slope
- still a problem
Flow slides
                       Flow slide (Zeeland)

schematic view
of a flow-slide




                      After flow-slide

        Before flow-slide
Liquefaction
        and flow slide in sand
maximum 200m

                                              Average slope

                                                   Shear failure
                                                                   30 m




       after flo w s lide in sand




                         maximum 50 m            average slope



clay                                                                30 m


loose sand

                     after flow slide with cla y on top
Scour &
 bottom
protection
  design
   rules
Transition in design techniques of revetments

     Revetments
                             Riprap/rubble mound structures
                 From Hudson:       Hs/∆Dn50 = (KD cotα)1/3
                                                                    0.2
                                                  Hs = 6.2 0.18 ⎛ S ⎞ -0.5
                 Into Van   der Meer:                     P ⎜       ⎟ ξm
                                                ∆ Dn 50         ⎝ N⎠
From riprap into pitched stone/blocks

   Block
Revetments




             Internal erosion
Bank                To
                       Rotterdam

Protection
Basic research
Model tests


Prototype tests

          Also
          PIANC
          guidelines



Application
                       To Antwerp
environmental

      Techniques
Salt-fresh water separation
Transition in filter design: from
                                              extension of design criteria for filters
geometrically closed into load-based design


Granular Filters
                Various test facilities
Filters
              From granular filters into geotextiles and
              composite filters ; from geometrically open to
              hydrodynamically sandtight (based on loading)
geotextiles
Filters
Possible extension of design
criteria for filters
Some other aspects

  •   Geosynthetics
  •   Geosystems
  •   Waste & Alternative materials
  •   Technology Transfer
Dissemination
of knowledge




                Validation
Knowledge development: Laboratory tests




Simulation of the flow through a
dikeTesting grass cover as revetment
     gap
                 Delta flume
Transition into


 Alternative Techniques
                                          Sand and clay bags closure




                  Granular filters from
                  brick material
Conclusions
  Large projects (like Delta Works)
 need usually some specific solutions.
    It stimulates new research and
innovation, which contribute strongly
 to new developments in hydraulic &
           coastal engineering

 A systematic & comprehensive
approach must be taken to solve
  stream & shoreline problems
Knowledge is      Knowledge cycles
always going
   ahead




               We are always in
               Transition
Thank you for
your attention


    Further information:


  www.Tawinfo.nl
www.deltawerken.com
I wish you a pleasant stay in the Netherlands
The end




www.enwinfo.nl, (english, downloads)

Transitions In Hydraulic Engngineering

  • 1.
    Transitions in Hydraulic Engineering Impact of the Delta Works on the Recent Developments in Hydraulic Engineering Krystian W. Pilarczyk (former) Rijkswaterstaat Hydraulic Engineering Institute, Delft krystian.pilarczyk@gmail.com
  • 2.
    Transitions in Hydraulic Engineering Content: • Introduction • (brief) History of Netherlands in coping floods • Delta Works overview • Impact of Delta Works on recent developments in hydraulic engineering • Conclusions - erosion – scour - closures – bottom protection – revetments – filters – geotextiles
  • 3.
    Introduction The Netherlands Low-lying country With dikes "God created the world, and the Dutch created Without dikes the Netherlands"
  • 4.
    Dutch History "God created the world, and the Dutch created the Netherlands" Flood protection in The Netherlands through the centuries
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Watersystem & Rainfallproblems in NL Storage Storage Storage land River Sea Polder water water water "God created the world, and the Dutch created the Netherlands."
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Turning point: Disaster 1953 Dike breaches and inundation
  • 9.
    Why is flooddefence important ? Flood events: flood event damage victims Sea 1953 ƒ 1.500 106 1835 Meuse 1993 ƒ 250 106 ---- 6 Rhine 1995 ƒ 500 10 ---- Meuse 1995 ƒ 165 106 ---- Rainfall 1998 ƒ 1.100 106 ---- Road and Hydraulic Engineering Devision, Delft 1 US $=2 f We can not avoid the floods but we can/must minimize the consequences (victims, economical damage) High safety standards needed
  • 10.
    1997 From Disaster 1953 (open)Eastern Scheldt barrier Western Scheldt to Delta Works Antwerp Deltaplan
  • 11.
    Closure Techniques Dike wheel Scour hole Caisson-closure Cable-line (also during the 1st stage Eastern Scheldt closure) scour Bottom protection
  • 12.
    From Closed toOpen Eastern Scheldt Project Environment & Ecology 1973 start discussion on environmental issues !974 stop execution full closure 1976 decision Open Storm Surge Barrier http://foto.telenet.be/photo-gallery/tags/label-oosterschelde.html
  • 13.
  • 14.
    From the pastto the present Eastern Scheldt Zierikzee Rotterdam City rights 1248 Vlissingen Zierikzee Eastern Scheldt View from the Expo Center Vlissingen Eastern Scheldt Storm Surge Barrier http://www.zierikzee-monumentenstad.nl/
  • 15.
    Techniques Overview of the Eastern Scheldt Storm Surge Barrier scour – bottom protection – foundation – superstructure – high tolerance requirements
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Transition into integrated/multidisciplinaryapproach Transitions in hydraulic engineering Impact Delta Works Soil –Water – Structure interactions but also Environment Environmental Impact Assessment
  • 21.
    Transition from deterministicto probabilistic approach Design Philosophy & Methodology Failure or inundation Risk <Typ naam hier> Loading <Typ titel hier> Resistance <Typ naam hier> <Typ naam hier> <Typ naam hier> <Typ titel hier> <Typ titel hier> <Typ titel hier> Failure modes & Failure tree
  • 22.
    Transition from traditionalto Closure by dumped modern techniques method (rock, blocks, bags) Closing using cable-line techniques • Gradual closures – Horizontal – Vertical Principles of closure techniques • Sand closures – Pipe discharged – Dumped • Sudden closures – Caissons
  • 23.
    Transition to innovativetechniques Sand Closures
  • 24.
    Techniques & problems Grevelingen Dam and sluice (Siphon) High salinity Density Low salinity current High salinity and erosion Low salinity
  • 25.
    Scour and Bottom protection 600m
  • 26.
    Scour and Bottomprotection Eastern Scheldt Barrier
  • 27.
    Research as designtool Scour research Scour prediction
  • 28.
    Scour research Prototype tests Brouwersdam Discharge sluice
  • 29.
    Scour prototype results undermining Prediction instability of upper slope - still a problem
  • 30.
    Flow slides Flow slide (Zeeland) schematic view of a flow-slide After flow-slide Before flow-slide
  • 31.
    Liquefaction and flow slide in sand maximum 200m Average slope Shear failure 30 m after flo w s lide in sand maximum 50 m average slope clay 30 m loose sand after flow slide with cla y on top
  • 32.
  • 33.
    Transition in designtechniques of revetments Revetments Riprap/rubble mound structures From Hudson: Hs/∆Dn50 = (KD cotα)1/3 0.2 Hs = 6.2 0.18 ⎛ S ⎞ -0.5 Into Van der Meer: P ⎜ ⎟ ξm ∆ Dn 50 ⎝ N⎠
  • 34.
    From riprap intopitched stone/blocks Block Revetments Internal erosion
  • 35.
    Bank To Rotterdam Protection Basic research Model tests Prototype tests Also PIANC guidelines Application To Antwerp
  • 36.
    environmental Techniques Salt-fresh water separation
  • 37.
    Transition in filterdesign: from extension of design criteria for filters geometrically closed into load-based design Granular Filters Various test facilities
  • 38.
    Filters From granular filters into geotextiles and composite filters ; from geometrically open to hydrodynamically sandtight (based on loading) geotextiles
  • 39.
    Filters Possible extension ofdesign criteria for filters
  • 40.
    Some other aspects • Geosynthetics • Geosystems • Waste & Alternative materials • Technology Transfer
  • 41.
  • 42.
    Knowledge development: Laboratorytests Simulation of the flow through a dikeTesting grass cover as revetment gap Delta flume
  • 44.
    Transition into AlternativeTechniques Sand and clay bags closure Granular filters from brick material
  • 45.
    Conclusions Largeprojects (like Delta Works) need usually some specific solutions. It stimulates new research and innovation, which contribute strongly to new developments in hydraulic & coastal engineering A systematic & comprehensive approach must be taken to solve stream & shoreline problems
  • 46.
    Knowledge is Knowledge cycles always going ahead We are always in Transition
  • 47.
    Thank you for yourattention Further information: www.Tawinfo.nl www.deltawerken.com
  • 48.
    I wish youa pleasant stay in the Netherlands
  • 49.