SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Dold 1
Michelle B. Dold
	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  
I n t e r n a t i o n a l D e v e l o p m e n t S t u d i e s 1 9 1
D e c e m b e r 2 0 1 4
	
  
Urbanization Without Economic
Development: Causes and Crises
Dold 2
Urbanization Without Economic Development: Causes and Crises
I. Introduction
Since the dawn of civilization, large settlements have been synonymous with
advancement- beacons of a society’s prosperity and symbols of its power and influence.
The greatest cities in history have inspired legends, etched into the collective memory of
the human population: Jericho, Babylon, Carthage, Rome, Baghdad, Beijing, London-
each the center of a booming empire characterized by technological innovation and living
standards extraordinary for their time and cradles of some of the greatest achievements in
human history. Beginning in 2008, for the first time in demographic history more than
50% of the world population lived in urban areas, a trend that demographers predict will
continue for decades to come. Not only is our world becoming increasingly urban, but the
process of urbanization itself has transformed in recent history as the benefits and
repercussions of globalization diffuse across the globe. Though whereas historically the
world’s wealthiest nations have played host to its largest cities, many megacities of today
have sprung up in some of the world’s least developed countries, oftentimes absent
significant economic growth. In recognizing such profound shifts occurring in
urbanization patterns globally, I seek to examine, first, possible mechanisms behind these
changes and, second, how such changes impact or should impact policy making in these
places. Three central questions provide a framework for the research that follows: Why
have some countries undergone rapid urbanization without increases to GDP per capita?
What are the dangers associated with this brand of urbanization? Should these
governments implement policies to slow down the pace of urbanization? Governments in
poor, rapidly urbanizing countries face unique challenges in administering enormous
Dold 3
cities without sufficient financing to do so effectively often resulting in disastrous
consequences for the urban poor. Some developing countries have undergone rapid
urbanization absent significant increases in national wealth as the global agricultural
system creates widespread impoverishment of their rural populations. When these
countries lack strong political and economic institutions, they fail to take advantage of the
benefits of urban agglomeration, falling prey to the negative externalities of extreme
population density.
II. Characterizing Modern Urbanization
The world population has undergone profound demographic shifts in the past half
century due, in large part, to changing trends in urbanization across the globe. While
recent increases in the scale of urbanization are impressive- megacities like Mexico City,
Shanghai, and Delhi have populations of 20 million, 23 million, and 25 million
respectively- the most striking shift, perhaps, has been the changing geography of
globalization. The map below (Figure 1) of growth rates of urban agglomerations from
1970-1990 demonstrates that already at this point in demographic history most of the
highest urban growth rates of 3% or more annually, illustrated by orange and red dots,
were concentrated in the global south- especially in regions such as Central America,
Western Africa, the Middle East, and Southeast Asia. Moderate growth, however, was
still occurring throughout much of North America, Europe, and Australia. Boxes on the
map represent megacities, somewhat arbitrarily defined by the United Nations as urban
agglomerations of ten million or more residents, which are scattered across the globe.
Figure 2 depicts urban growth rates from 1990 to 2014, showing that urban growth has
slowed to under 1% in most North American agglomerations and across most of the
Dold 4
European continent. During this period, high growth rates of 3% or more were
concentrated almost exclusively in Asia and Africa, a trend that demographers predict
will continue in coming decades.
	
  
Figure	
  1:	
  Growth	
  Rates	
  of	
  Urban	
  Agglomerations,	
  1970-­‐1990	
  [United	
  Nations	
  World	
  Urbanization	
  
Prospects:	
  2014	
  Revision]
	
  
Figure	
  2:	
  Growth	
  Rates	
  of	
  Urban	
  Agglomerations,	
  1990-­‐2000	
  [United	
  Nations	
  World	
  Urbanization	
  
Prospects:	
  2014	
  Revision]
City Population
500 - 750 thousand
750 - 1000 thousand
1-5 million
5-10 million
10 million or more
Growth Rate
× <1%
× 1-3%
× 3-5%
× 5% +
Note: Designations employed and the presentation of material on this map do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on
the part of the Secretariat of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory or area, or of its authorities,
or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
City Population
500 - 750 thousand
750 - 1000 thousand
1-5 million
5-10 million
10 million or more
Growth Rate
× <1%
× 1-3%
× 3-5%
× 5% +
Note: Designations employed and the presentation of material on this map do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on
the part of the Secretariat of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory or area, or of its authorities,
or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
Dold 5
The following graph (Figure 3) from the United Nations’ World Urbanization
Prospects 2014 Revision illuminates in more detail what can be gleaned from the maps
above: that the greatest contributors to growth in the urban population in the coming
decades will be from Asia and Africa, especially from exceptionally rapidly urbanizing
countries such as China, India, Nigeria, and Indonesia. Excluding the United States,
North American and European countries are notably missing from the list. Perhaps the
most striking takeaway from
the graphic is that the greatest
contributors to urban growth
will be from a massive range
of income brackets- from the
US with a 2013 per capita
income of $53,143 to Nigeria
with a GDP per capita of
$3,006 to the Democratic
Republic of the Congo, whose
average income was just $454
in 2013 (World Bank). The
graphs below (Figures 4 and 5) further substantiate this notion of a loosening correlation
between a nation’s wealth and its level of urbanization. One can observe the relationship
between percentage urban on the y-axis and purchasing power parity-adjusted income per
capita on the x-axis transform from a somewhat tight positive linear pattern, suggesting
that richer countries tended to be more urban in 1960, to a more cloud-like shape,
World Urbanization Prospects: The 2014 Revision12
Just a few countries are home to half of the world’s urban population. China has
the largest urban population (758 million), followed by India (410 million). These two
countries account for 30 per cent of the world’s urban population and, with another five
countries, the United States of America (263 million), Brazil (173 million), Indonesia (134
million), Japan (118 million) and the Russian Federation (105 million), account for more
than half of the world’s urban population.
Future increases in the world’s urban population are also expected to be highly con-
centrated in just a few countries (figure 7). Taken together, China, India and Nigeria are
projected to account for 37 per cent of the increase of nearly 2.5 billion people in the urban
population by 2050. Between 2014 and 2050, the urban areas are expected to grow by 404
million people in India, 292 million in China and 212 million in Nigeria. Seven other
countries, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Ethiopia, the United Republic of Tanzania,
Bangladesh, Indonesia and Pakistan, and the United States of America, are projected to
contribute more than 50 million each to the urban increment and will constitute together
another 20 per cent of the total increase in urban population. In a few countries, the urban
population will decrease, despite projected increases in the level of urbanization. The larg-
est declines between 2014 and 2050 are projected for Japan, with a decline of 12 million
urban dwellers and for the Russian Federation, expected to decline by 7 million.
Figure 7.
Contribution to the increase in urban population by country, 2014 to 2050
China and India will
contribute more than
one third of the global
urban population
increase between 2014
and 2050
Note: The countries shown are projected to contribute 25 million or more to the global urban increment
between 2014 and 2050. The category “Other countries” includes countries with urban increments
of less than 25 million each.
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Other countries
Democratic Republic of the Congo
China
India
nearly 2.5 billion
urban population increase
by 2050
50%
Nigeria
Indonesia
United States of America
Pakistan
Urbanpopulationincrease(millions)
Iraq
Angola
Viet Nam
Sudan
Iran (Islamic Republic of)
Uganda
Kenya
Egypt
Mexico
Brazil
Philippines
Ethiopia
United Republic of Tanzania
Bangladesh
Figure	
  3:	
  Contribution	
  to	
  the	
  Increase	
  in	
  Urban	
  Population	
  by	
  
Country,	
  2014-­‐2050	
  [United	
  Nations	
  World	
  Urbanization	
  
Prospects:	
  2014	
  Revision]
Dold 6
suggesting that by 2011 wealth was no longer a requisite nor a guaranteed outcome of
urbanization. Osaka, Japan, for example, one of the wealthiest megacities, is projected to
fall from its former place as second largest city in 1990 to the thirteenth largest city in
2030, whereas demographers predict that Lagos, Nigeria will grow to become the ninth
largest city in 2030 from its position as thirty-third in 1990 (United Nations). As the
association between urbanization and average income slackens, lower living standards in
emerging poor megacities are inciting debate within academia and popular discourse over
whether governments should adopt policies that encourage or abate urbanization in their
countries.
	
  
Figure	
  4:	
  GDP	
  per	
  Capita	
  vs.	
  Urban	
  Population	
  (%	
  of	
  Total),	
  1960	
  [Gapminder	
  World]
Dold 7
	
  
Figure	
  5:	
  GDP	
  per	
  Capita	
  vs.	
  Urban	
  Population	
  (%	
  of	
  Total),	
  2011	
  [Gapminder	
  World]
III. Positive and Negative Externalities of Urbanization
The process of absorbing rural migrants into cities includes both positive and
negative externalities, which in economics are defined as “situations in which the private
costs or benefits to the producers or purchasers of a good or service differs from the total
social costs or benefits entailed in its production and consumption” (Johnson). There are
well-known and well-researched benefits to urbanization, especially with regards to
industry, as a concentration of economic agents tends to increase productivity via
agglomeration economies. In the 1960s, urban planner Jane Jacobs characterized cities as
incubators of innovation and knowledge spillovers resulting from the collision of many
people with diverse educational backgrounds and skillsets (Rigby). However, a focus on
these assumed benefits of urbanization, sometimes referred to in the literature as the
Dold 8
“density cult” (Kotkin), are actually part of a problem that diverts attention away from
what is really happening in some of the world’s poorest megacities- widespread suffering
and inequality.
The negative externalities of rapid and intense urbanization abound and can result
in lower living standards in large cities when governments are ill equipped to mitigate
them. One such negative externality is the widespread unemployment of rural migrants
lacking in education or skills outside of agriculture; many of these migrants end up
working in the informal sector doing jobs like peddling small goods or driving rickshaws,
untaxed income that does not contribute to national wealth. Understandably, larger
populations means more stress on public services such as education and health care and
on infrastructure like roads and highways. One consequence of intense urbanization that
perhaps does not receive as much attention as it should is traffic congestion; one recent
survey estimated that 85% of traffic deaths worldwide take place in developing nations
(Kotkin). Additionally, pressure on a city’s housing supply can drive up prices and drive
urban poor into slums, where sanitation issues and dense inhabitance can facilitate the
spread of infectious disease. Other negative externalities such as environmental
degradation and massive income inequalities that characterize large cities in poor
countries typically take a back seat to more pressing issues of providing citizens with the
basic means of survival.
Dold 9
	
  
Figure	
  6:	
  Positive	
  and	
  Negative	
  Externalities	
  of	
  Urbanization	
  
	
  
None of these externalities are new per se and it is not so much their existence
that sets new global megacities apart from older ones- these dangers exist in all large
cities regardless of average income. The worry is, rather, that poorer governments often
lack the financial and institutional resources to mitigate their negative effects on the
urban population, leading to very low living standards.
IV. Glaeser’s Insight- “A World of Cities”
In order to understand the mechanisms behind these profound shifts in the
urbanization process, Harvard economist Edward Glaeser points to recent increases in
globalization, especially over the past half century. While no all encompassing or agreed
upon definition of globalization exists because of the phenomenon’s enormous scale, this
Dold 10
investigation uses the term to refer to globalized supply networks of agricultural goods
coupled with liberalized trade policies. To assess the impact of globalization on growth in
cities Glaeser, in his study “A World of Cities: The Causes and Consequences of
Urbanization in Poorer Countries”, considers the links between agricultural productivity,
country size, which he uses as a proxy for openness, and urbanization in 1961 and 2010.
In their essence, his findings demonstrate that agricultural productivity was more strongly
associated with urbanization in large than small countries and that the relationship
between local agricultural productivity and city growth became less prominent during
this period (Glaeser 3-4).
Glaeser postulates that, as globalized trade networks break the traditional links
between urban areas and the agricultural hinterlands that historically sustained them,
displaced and impoverished rural populations flood cities in search of other economic
opportunities. The macroeconomics of development tend to support this theory; as
countries orient their economies toward export to international markets and away from
subsistence agriculture, typically this process involves governments and/or private
enterprises investing large sums of capital to mechanize agriculture and make it more
efficient and opening borders to international trade. Unable to compete with the lower
prices of imports, especially when agricultural prices are artificially depressed by
government subsidies in developed nations (eg. of the US to its domestic sugar industry),
small farmers are often put out of business. When this occurs, such farmers often must
sell their land, the main source of wealth and form of inheritance in most rural societies,
or government simply seizes land for commercial agriculture and impoverished rural
dwellers must look to cities for economic opportunity.
Dold 11
Figure	
  8:	
  Potential	
  Paths	
  to	
  Urbanization-­‐	
  Closed	
  vs.	
  Open	
  Economies	
  
	
  
Figure 8: This very simplified schematic illustrates theoretically how huge cities can develop in
poorer nations. In relatively closed economies, like those of North American and European
countries during their period of urban development, urban populations are dependent on the
surrounding rural areas for sustenance, which leads to local agricultural prosperity assuming the
country has fertile soil and a climate conducive to cultivation. Agricultural abundance means that
a city can sustain larger populations and nearby urban areas will grow gradually in that much of
the rural population will stay put given high demand, and therefore high prices, for its products.
Conversely, in economies that are more open to trade, like those of many small developing
nations today, urban areas no longer necessarily depend on local agriculture for sustenance in that
they can purchase cheap imported food from international markets. In the context of a global
system of trade in agricultural products, small scale and subsistence farming become less
financially feasible. Displaced rural dwellers flood cities in search of work.
closed economies
(dependence on
local agriculture)
local agricultural
prosperity	
  
gradual growth in
nearby urban areas	
  
open economies
(dependence on
global agricultural
trade)	
  
rural
impoverishment	
  
rapid growth in
nearby urban areas	
  
Dold 12
The danger in this, Glaeser points out, is that huge cities with massive populations
in need of service and infrastructure provision can develop in poor countries whose
political and economic institutions tend to be weaker and whose governments are less
well-equipped to handle the challenges that large-scale urbanization can bring. The core
of Glaeser’s insight centers upon poor versus rich governments’ responses to the negative
externalities of urbanization. He holds that “the ability to punish bad behavior is limited
by the institutional strength of a particular society” (Glaeser 20). When a country’s
institutions are weak, meaning they lack a well-established rule of law or property rights
and there is lots of public sector corruption, the outcome of intense urbanization is either,
as Glaeser terms it, “anarchy” or “draconian prevention” (Glaeser 4).
One example of what Glaeser would consider anarchy in the face of urbanization
comes from Dhaka, Bangladesh, which is tied with Lagos as the most rapidly
urbanization city in the world with an estimated growth rate of 3.6% from 2010-2015
(World Bank). In addition to boasting the fastest growing, but also one of the poorest
megacities, Bangladesh also has one of the most corrupt governments in the world,
ranking 145th
out of 175 countries recently surveyed by Transparency International
(Transparency International). Many urban poor in Dhaka do not have access to basic
social services that the government is constitutionally bound to offer either inexpensively
or for free. For example, a recent survey of Bangladeshi households found that 44% of
patients in public health facilities had to pay bribes for care (Manzoor 13), demonstrating
an anarchic lack of enforcement of government regulations.
At the other end of the spectrum, some poorer governments may choose to curb
negative externalities through authoritarian policies. For example, in 1958 the
Dold 13
Communist Chinese government began mandating that rural migrants carry proof of
formal residence and employment in cities like Shanghai in order to receive social
services such as education or healthcare (“Migrant Workers and Their Children”). Such a
policy suggests that some poor and rapidly urbanizing countries may face a tradeoff
between economic growth and political repression should governments choose to take
that route. Such examples support the notion that there is a link between institutional
quality and development, especially in large cities.
V. Support from Acemoglu and Robinson
Research by Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson on the effects of institutional
quality on development, as articulated in their book Why Nations Fail, has become
foundational in the field of political economics. Their findings further substantiate the
hypothesis that weak institutions make large cities in poor countries more vulnerable to
the negative externalities of intense and rapid urbanization. Their thesis holds that the
density and quality of rules put in place to structure politics (the level of democracy),
economics (the extent of free markets), and society (inclusive or extractive institutions)
either foster or inhibit economic growth (Acemoglu and Robinson). The authors write
extensively about the fact that development requires investment, not just by governments,
enterprises and capitalists, but also by everyday people. This investment, however, will
only occur when people and businesses can trust in the institutional foundations of the
country to protect their property rights so that can reliably expect a return on that
investment.
Rampant corruption and bribery in the public sector greatly increase the cost of
accomplishing almost anything in a country, discouraging capitalists from starting or
Dold 14
growing businesses that could potentially act as sources of national wealth or keeping
poor individuals from receiving the services that they need.
VI. Case Study- Dhaka, Bangladesh
To coalesce all of these abstract concepts, as they do not carry much significance
without application, I will zero in on one example of a rapidly urbanizing low-income
country- Bangladesh. Dhaka is the political, commercial, and industrial epicenter of the
country, its economic activity concentrated in the production of textiles, garments,
chemicals and pharmaceuticals (“Dhaka”). As noted above, Dhaka is the fastest growing
city in the world with a current population of roughly twelve million that has quadrupled
over the past 25 years, but is the world’s poorest megacity with an average annual income
of just $829 (Kotkin). The city adds 300,000 to 400,000 people annually, mostly migrants
from poor rural areas motivated by push factors of overpopulation, natural disaster and
loss of land. According to a 2008 survey by the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, 4.5
million rural Bangladeshis are completely landless, which has especially impoverishing
effects given that land is the main source of wealth in the countryside. Author Shahadat
Hossain notes
In this agriculture based country, land is the main means to generate
subsistence and surplus and is the most valuable asset to the rural poor.
Increased loss and fragmentation of land among the poor and increased
concentration of land among the rich, coupled with a high natural growth
rate of the population raise the number of landless and hungry. (Hossain
18)
Pull factors to Dhaka can include employment opportunities in the informal sector that do
not necessitate extended education or training and relative freedom for female workers in
the city (Hossain 18).
Dold 15
Unfortunately most rural migrants to Dhaka experience very low living standards,
especially from the lack of public services available for the 3.4 million people that live in
Dhaka’s slums. Estimates show that in these informal housing communities only 65% of
households are literate, 37% of people have access to safe drinking water, and only 10%
of shelters are built from concrete, the other 90% being built from scrap metal, bamboo,
and other temporary building materials (World Bank). The majority of Dhaka’s
population lives below the official poverty line, historically measured by caloric intake,
quantifying the absolute poor as those who intake 2122 k.cal or less daily. While
nationally the percentage of people living under this threshold decreased from 47.8% to
44.5% from 1988-2000, the percentage of urbanites meeting this criterion for poverty
increased from 47.6% to 52.5% during the same period (Hossain 14).
Infrastructural degradation occurs throughout the city both because of strain from
large populations and overuse, but also because of government neglect and corruption.
For example, in 2013 one garment factory in the industrial zone of Savar, just outside
Dhaka, collapsed killing over 1,000 people and injuring countless others. Upon
inspection, the factory was found to have been constructed with “substandard materials
and in a blatant disregard for building codes” (Yardley) and factory owners have been
accused of bribing local officials for construction permits (Yardley). One report from the
investigation of the collapse even found that “10% of lawmakers in the national
parliament are owners of garment businesses in Bangladesh” (Hussein). Such anarchic
neglect of regulation and impunity on behalf of the government shows that weak
institutions particularly harm urban poor.
Dold 16
As previously mentioned, the Bangladeshi government performs abysmally in
Transparency International’s annual survey of public sector corruption. In the most recent
rankings, the country came in 90th
out of 142 countries in judicial independence, 146th
out
of 187 in the human development index, 129th
out of 179 in the press freedom index, and
in the 27th
and 38th
percentiles in the rule of law and accountability categories,
respectively (Transparency International). Not only do such weak institutions increase
transaction costs and encourage capital flight, but they also keep poor from receiving
social services that the Bangladesh government is obligated to provide. For example, in
order to raise literacy rates, the government extends stipends to females pursuing
secondary education, though a survey found that 22% of these women paid illegal bribes
to enroll and 38% of program participants reported receiving less money than they were
promised (Manzoor 7). Weak regulatory institutions coupled with government impunity
have kept Dhaka from realizing the positive externalities of its rapid urbanization, leaving
the vast majority of its residents to suffer.
VII. An Intriguing Solution- Paul Romer’s Charter Cities
Another notable economist to weigh in on the issue of poor country urbanization
and institutional quality is Paul Romer, a former Stanford economist now researching at
the NYU’s Stern School of Business. Romer recognizes the same malady that bars poor
countries from utilizing urbanization for development in many cases and, in his
promotion of “charter cities”, he offers a work around for the poor institutions in these
countries. Romer proposes that governments construct new cities entirely from scratch
governed by charters that lay out regulations and enforcements mechanisms different
from those that govern the rest of the country, especially ones that encourage investment
Dold 17
by emphasizing property rights (but also rules about sanitation, traffic control, service
administration, etc.). Romer compares charter cities to the Special Economic Zones that
China established during the 1980s to attract foreign capital. He holds that foreign
investors could finance construction of these cities’ infrastructure in exchange for “fee
income use from the users” (Freakonomics). These countries could then enter into written
commitments with governments known for having strong, credible institutions, like the
US or Canada for example, which could act as guarantors to ensure that these countries
do not renege on promises made in the charter. Romer insists that these charters would be
further legitimized by rural dwellers choosing, without being coerced, to move to cities.
Though in theory this sounds positive, the implementation of charter cities poses
profound problems. First is the question of why corrupt officials who benefit from the
status quo would be willing to essentially renounce control over a part or parts of their
territory. This introduces the other glaring issue of enforcing rules laid out in the charter;
the reason that these types of cities would be necessarily in the first place is that
institutions that govern the rest of the country are too weak to encourage investment, so it
is unlikely that such weak or corrupt regimes would adhere to agreements, even if third
party guarantors were involved. Additionally, though the special economic zones were
largely successful in fomenting economic growth in China, such success has not come
without a price. Protests against land acquisition have sprung up in rural China,
especially in the Guangdong province, as the zone is taking over rural areas to
accommodate foreign investors (Ismaylova). Such development also comes at the
expense of Chinese laborers who endure poor working conditions in these factories.
Dold 18
While Romer’s charter city idea is riddled with logistical and perhaps ethical
complications, I included it in this discussion because it further proves that institutions
are at the heart of development. Romer recognizes what Glaeser, Acemoglu, and
Robinson do- that weak institutions can keep poor countries from benefitting from
urbanization and that development requires governments to make credible and long-term
commitments to protecting property rights and enforcing the rule of law. Though charter
cities may not be the correct avenue to development, that strong institutions are necessary
for economic growth has become widely accepted.
VIII. Conclusions
Throughout this research, it has become apparent that despite the popular notion
that large, dense cities go hand-in-hand with national wealth, urbanization in and of itself
is not necessarily beneficial for a country or a population unless paired with good
governance. Edward Glaeser notes, however, that, “The connections and social
movements that form readily in the dense confines of urban areas can ultimately be
strong enough to change and discipline government” (Glaeser 41). Just as cities can act as
incubators for innovation in industry and technology, they can also generate
agglomeration economies for political reform as people share their grievances and ideas
for change. Large populations of suffering urban poor have the potential to form
coalitions to pressure their governments into greater accountability, the only way that true
change can occur when corrupt bureaucrats benefit from the status quo of extractive
institutions. Future political, economic, and demographic research on urbanization should
keep in mind not only the objective of economic growth, but also pursuing equity
alongside development
Works	
  Cited	
  
Acemoglu, Daron, James Robinson, and Simon Johnson. "Institutions as a Fundamental
Cause of Long-Run Growth." Handbook of Economic Growth. Vol. 1A. Elsevier B.V.,
2005. 386-472. Web. 1 Oct. 2014.
"BANGLADESH: Landless Numbers on the Rise." IRIN Humanitarian News and
Analysis. IRIN, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 1 Nov. 2014.
"Can "Charter Cities" Change the World? A Q&A With Paul Romer."Freakonomics.
Freakonomics LLC, 29 Sept. 2009. Web. 1 Nov. 2014.
"Corruption by Country/Territory." Transparency International. Transparency
International, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 1 Dec. 2014.
Chakrabortty, Aditya. "Paul Romer Is a Brilliant Economist – but His Idea for Charter
Cities Is Bad." Guardian 27 July 2010. Web. 5 Dec. 2014.
"Dhaka." Encyclopaedia Brittannica. Encyclopædia Britannica, 2013. Print.
Glaeser, Edward. "A World of Cities: Causes and Consequences of Urbanization in
Poorer Countries." NBER Working Paper Series 19745 (2013): 1-58. National Bureau of
Economic Research. Web. 1 Oct. 2014.
Hasan, Manzoor. "Public Sector Corruption in Bangladesh: Political and Bureaucratic."
(2007). Institute of Governance Studies, BRAC University. Web. 1 Nov. 2014.
Hossain, Shahadat. "Rapid Urban Growth and Poverty in Dhaka City."Bangladesh E-
Journal of Sociology 5.1 (2008): 1-24. Web. 1 Nov. 2014.
Hussein, Sajjad. "Six Months after Bangladeshi Factory Collapse, Workers Remain in
Peril." CNN.com. Cable News Network, 24 Oct. 2013. Web. 1 Dec. 2014.
Ismaylova, Eugenia. "Special Economic Zones: Select Advantages and Substantial
Problems." Illinois Business Law Journal (2007). University of Illinois. Web. 1 Dec.
2014.
Johnson, Paul. "Externality." A Glossary of Political Economy Terms. Auburn: U of
Auburn, Department of Political Science, 2005. Print.
Kotkin, Joel. "Megacities And The Density Delusion: Why More People Doesn't Equal
More Wealth." Forbes 16 Apr. 2013. Print.
Kotkin, Joel. "The Problem With Megacities." Forbes 4 Apr. 2011. Print.
"Migrant Workers and Their Children." China Labour Bulletin (2013). The China Labour
Bulletin. Web. 1 Oct. 2014.
Rigby, David . "Agglomeration." Economic Geography. University of California, Los
Angeles, Department of Geography. Haines Hall, Los Angeles. 19 Feb. 2014. Lecture.
Romer, Paul. "Why the World Needs Charter Cities." TEDGlobal 2009. TED. Oxford
University, Oxford. 1 July 2009. Lecture.
"South Asia- World Population Day - July 11(South Asia Growth)." The World Bank.
The World Bank Group, 1 Jan. 2013. Web. 1 Dec. 2014.
"Transparency International Bangladesh." Transparency International. Transparency
International, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 1 Dec. 2014.
"World Development Indicators." World Bank. The World Bank Group, 1 Jan. 2014.
Web. 1 Nov. 2014.
World Urbanization Prospects: The 2014 Revision (2014): 1-32. United Nations,
Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division. Web. 1 Nov. 2014.
Yardley, Jim. "Report on Deadly Factory Collapse in Bangladesh Finds Widespread
Blame." New York Times 22 May 2013. Print.
	
  

More Related Content

What's hot

Urban settlements
Urban settlementsUrban settlements
Urban settlements
RiyasPk7
 
Population and urbanization
Population and urbanizationPopulation and urbanization
Population and urbanizationSeth Allen
 
Lesson 8 Urbanization*
Lesson 8   Urbanization*Lesson 8   Urbanization*
Lesson 8 Urbanization*
rachelkcole
 
Demography
DemographyDemography
Demography
Sunshine Enaguas
 
1008_landlines final 4.05
1008_landlines final 4.051008_landlines final 4.05
1008_landlines final 4.05Heather McCall
 
201.07 population, ecology, urbanization
201.07 population, ecology, urbanization201.07 population, ecology, urbanization
201.07 population, ecology, urbanization
cjsmann
 
Psipa final paper -sustainable cities
Psipa  final paper -sustainable citiesPsipa  final paper -sustainable cities
Psipa final paper -sustainable cities
JIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
Impact of urbanization
Impact of urbanizationImpact of urbanization
Impact of urbanization
rasikapatil26
 
Measures of Urbanization
 Measures of Urbanization Measures of Urbanization
Measures of Urbanization
nowaj sharif
 
GLOBAL CITIES Tomorrow: Paris, London, New York, Hong Kong, Dubai, Moscow,… W...
GLOBAL CITIES Tomorrow: Paris, London, New York, Hong Kong, Dubai, Moscow,… W...GLOBAL CITIES Tomorrow: Paris, London, New York, Hong Kong, Dubai, Moscow,… W...
GLOBAL CITIES Tomorrow: Paris, London, New York, Hong Kong, Dubai, Moscow,… W...
Azamat Abdoullaev
 
City profile of Abuja
City profile of AbujaCity profile of Abuja
City profile of Abuja
ChiahembaNor
 
Hero Motor Corp - The Hero Challenge
Hero Motor Corp - The Hero ChallengeHero Motor Corp - The Hero Challenge
Hero Motor Corp - The Hero Challenge
Ronak Soni
 
Defining Urban, Urbanization and Urbanism
Defining Urban, Urbanization and UrbanismDefining Urban, Urbanization and Urbanism
Defining Urban, Urbanization and Urbanism
Jo Balucanag - Bitonio
 
Mprhgd lec6 migration
Mprhgd lec6 migrationMprhgd lec6 migration
Mprhgd lec6 migration
Guannu Kuluku Dezon
 
Global C4IR-1 Masterclass Cambridge - Sharratt WSP 2017
Global C4IR-1 Masterclass Cambridge - Sharratt WSP 2017Global C4IR-1 Masterclass Cambridge - Sharratt WSP 2017
Global C4IR-1 Masterclass Cambridge - Sharratt WSP 2017
Justin Hayward
 
Professor Tony Champion
Professor Tony ChampionProfessor Tony Champion
Migration and its effects on urban life
Migration and its effects on urban lifeMigration and its effects on urban life
Migration and its effects on urban life
Rithika Ravishankar
 
VN stelt vervangingsmigratie als superoplossing voor
VN stelt vervangingsmigratie als superoplossing voorVN stelt vervangingsmigratie als superoplossing voor
VN stelt vervangingsmigratie als superoplossing voor
Thierry Debels
 
Gravitational Model to Predict the Megalopolis Mobility of the Center of Mexico
Gravitational Model to Predict the Megalopolis Mobility of the Center of MexicoGravitational Model to Predict the Megalopolis Mobility of the Center of Mexico
Gravitational Model to Predict the Megalopolis Mobility of the Center of Mexico
IJAEMSJORNAL
 

What's hot (20)

Urbanisation
UrbanisationUrbanisation
Urbanisation
 
Urban settlements
Urban settlementsUrban settlements
Urban settlements
 
Population and urbanization
Population and urbanizationPopulation and urbanization
Population and urbanization
 
Lesson 8 Urbanization*
Lesson 8   Urbanization*Lesson 8   Urbanization*
Lesson 8 Urbanization*
 
Demography
DemographyDemography
Demography
 
1008_landlines final 4.05
1008_landlines final 4.051008_landlines final 4.05
1008_landlines final 4.05
 
201.07 population, ecology, urbanization
201.07 population, ecology, urbanization201.07 population, ecology, urbanization
201.07 population, ecology, urbanization
 
Psipa final paper -sustainable cities
Psipa  final paper -sustainable citiesPsipa  final paper -sustainable cities
Psipa final paper -sustainable cities
 
Impact of urbanization
Impact of urbanizationImpact of urbanization
Impact of urbanization
 
Measures of Urbanization
 Measures of Urbanization Measures of Urbanization
Measures of Urbanization
 
GLOBAL CITIES Tomorrow: Paris, London, New York, Hong Kong, Dubai, Moscow,… W...
GLOBAL CITIES Tomorrow: Paris, London, New York, Hong Kong, Dubai, Moscow,… W...GLOBAL CITIES Tomorrow: Paris, London, New York, Hong Kong, Dubai, Moscow,… W...
GLOBAL CITIES Tomorrow: Paris, London, New York, Hong Kong, Dubai, Moscow,… W...
 
City profile of Abuja
City profile of AbujaCity profile of Abuja
City profile of Abuja
 
Hero Motor Corp - The Hero Challenge
Hero Motor Corp - The Hero ChallengeHero Motor Corp - The Hero Challenge
Hero Motor Corp - The Hero Challenge
 
Defining Urban, Urbanization and Urbanism
Defining Urban, Urbanization and UrbanismDefining Urban, Urbanization and Urbanism
Defining Urban, Urbanization and Urbanism
 
Mprhgd lec6 migration
Mprhgd lec6 migrationMprhgd lec6 migration
Mprhgd lec6 migration
 
Global C4IR-1 Masterclass Cambridge - Sharratt WSP 2017
Global C4IR-1 Masterclass Cambridge - Sharratt WSP 2017Global C4IR-1 Masterclass Cambridge - Sharratt WSP 2017
Global C4IR-1 Masterclass Cambridge - Sharratt WSP 2017
 
Professor Tony Champion
Professor Tony ChampionProfessor Tony Champion
Professor Tony Champion
 
Migration and its effects on urban life
Migration and its effects on urban lifeMigration and its effects on urban life
Migration and its effects on urban life
 
VN stelt vervangingsmigratie als superoplossing voor
VN stelt vervangingsmigratie als superoplossing voorVN stelt vervangingsmigratie als superoplossing voor
VN stelt vervangingsmigratie als superoplossing voor
 
Gravitational Model to Predict the Megalopolis Mobility of the Center of Mexico
Gravitational Model to Predict the Megalopolis Mobility of the Center of MexicoGravitational Model to Predict the Megalopolis Mobility of the Center of Mexico
Gravitational Model to Predict the Megalopolis Mobility of the Center of Mexico
 

Viewers also liked

The Fuelwood Market Chain of Kinshasa: Socio-economic and sustainability outc...
The Fuelwood Market Chain of Kinshasa: Socio-economic and sustainability outc...The Fuelwood Market Chain of Kinshasa: Socio-economic and sustainability outc...
The Fuelwood Market Chain of Kinshasa: Socio-economic and sustainability outc...
Verina Ingram
 
resume_Prashant2014- Technical
resume_Prashant2014- Technicalresume_Prashant2014- Technical
resume_Prashant2014- TechnicalPrashant jadhav
 
Viking longhouse
Viking longhouseViking longhouse
Viking longhouse
Asher Ely
 
Elmes_Yarleque_Mapping_licit_illicit_gold_mining_in_madre_de_dios_Peru
Elmes_Yarleque_Mapping_licit_illicit_gold_mining_in_madre_de_dios_PeruElmes_Yarleque_Mapping_licit_illicit_gold_mining_in_madre_de_dios_Peru
Elmes_Yarleque_Mapping_licit_illicit_gold_mining_in_madre_de_dios_PeruGabriel Yarlequé Ipanaqué
 
STATEMENT BY R GUMM
STATEMENT BY R GUMMSTATEMENT BY R GUMM
STATEMENT BY R GUMMRebecca Gumm
 
Don't be boring - Push the envelope!
 Don't be boring - Push the envelope! Don't be boring - Push the envelope!
Don't be boring - Push the envelope!
quickmail
 
Element 1_Integrated Skills
Element 1_Integrated SkillsElement 1_Integrated Skills
Element 1_Integrated Skills
NatalyMesias
 
Sử dụng tôn định hình
Sử dụng tôn định hìnhSử dụng tôn định hình
Sử dụng tôn định hình
Hùng Tạ Huy
 

Viewers also liked (14)

The Fuelwood Market Chain of Kinshasa: Socio-economic and sustainability outc...
The Fuelwood Market Chain of Kinshasa: Socio-economic and sustainability outc...The Fuelwood Market Chain of Kinshasa: Socio-economic and sustainability outc...
The Fuelwood Market Chain of Kinshasa: Socio-economic and sustainability outc...
 
resume_Prashant2014- Technical
resume_Prashant2014- Technicalresume_Prashant2014- Technical
resume_Prashant2014- Technical
 
Viking longhouse
Viking longhouseViking longhouse
Viking longhouse
 
It Works Body Wraps!
It Works Body Wraps!It Works Body Wraps!
It Works Body Wraps!
 
Elmes_Yarleque_Mapping_licit_illicit_gold_mining_in_madre_de_dios_Peru
Elmes_Yarleque_Mapping_licit_illicit_gold_mining_in_madre_de_dios_PeruElmes_Yarleque_Mapping_licit_illicit_gold_mining_in_madre_de_dios_Peru
Elmes_Yarleque_Mapping_licit_illicit_gold_mining_in_madre_de_dios_Peru
 
ali_safe
ali_safeali_safe
ali_safe
 
STATEMENT BY R GUMM
STATEMENT BY R GUMMSTATEMENT BY R GUMM
STATEMENT BY R GUMM
 
Don't be boring - Push the envelope!
 Don't be boring - Push the envelope! Don't be boring - Push the envelope!
Don't be boring - Push the envelope!
 
PARW August 2015 Article
PARW August 2015 ArticlePARW August 2015 Article
PARW August 2015 Article
 
Heal Force Thermo Cycler EN 20140905
Heal Force Thermo Cycler EN 20140905Heal Force Thermo Cycler EN 20140905
Heal Force Thermo Cycler EN 20140905
 
Element 1_Integrated Skills
Element 1_Integrated SkillsElement 1_Integrated Skills
Element 1_Integrated Skills
 
Sử dụng tôn định hình
Sử dụng tôn định hìnhSử dụng tôn định hình
Sử dụng tôn định hình
 
sherif saad cv
sherif saad cvsherif saad cv
sherif saad cv
 
Career Coach and Volunteer Presentation
Career Coach and Volunteer PresentationCareer Coach and Volunteer Presentation
Career Coach and Volunteer Presentation
 

Similar to TERM PAPER

Levels, Patterns and Trends of Urbanization (World)
Levels, Patterns and Trends of Urbanization (World)Levels, Patterns and Trends of Urbanization (World)
Levels, Patterns and Trends of Urbanization (World)
ShreemoyeeSaha1
 
Urbandevelopment projectsandrisksmanagement
Urbandevelopment projectsandrisksmanagementUrbandevelopment projectsandrisksmanagement
Urbandevelopment projectsandrisksmanagement
Dr.Madhav Prasad Koirala
 
Urban Planning and Settlements
Urban Planning and SettlementsUrban Planning and Settlements
Urban Planning and Settlementssorbi
 
Urbanization and Globalization.pptx
Urbanization and Globalization.pptxUrbanization and Globalization.pptx
Urbanization and Globalization.pptx
Jo Balucanag - Bitonio
 
URBANISATION AND ENVIRONMENT
URBANISATION AND ENVIRONMENTURBANISATION AND ENVIRONMENT
URBANISATION AND ENVIRONMENT
Priti Thakkar
 
urbanisation-181014110414.pdfshsushusbsusbeueb
urbanisation-181014110414.pdfshsushusbsusbeueburbanisation-181014110414.pdfshsushusbsusbeueb
urbanisation-181014110414.pdfshsushusbsusbeueb
AdityaSharma811028
 
Why to study Urbanisation ?
Why to study Urbanisation ?Why to study Urbanisation ?
Why to study Urbanisation ?
Ravikant Joshi
 
Due Thurs. 4-30-15 4pmPlease answer in 1 ½ two 2 paragraphs, be very.docx
Due Thurs. 4-30-15 4pmPlease answer in 1 ½ two 2 paragraphs, be very.docxDue Thurs. 4-30-15 4pmPlease answer in 1 ½ two 2 paragraphs, be very.docx
Due Thurs. 4-30-15 4pmPlease answer in 1 ½ two 2 paragraphs, be very.docx
jacksnathalie
 
Annexes
Annexes Annexes
Planning green smart cities (autosaved)
Planning  green smart cities (autosaved)Planning  green smart cities (autosaved)
Planning green smart cities (autosaved)
JIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
Chapter 1PopulationPrudent men should judge of future
Chapter 1PopulationPrudent men should judge of future Chapter 1PopulationPrudent men should judge of future
Chapter 1PopulationPrudent men should judge of future
EstelaJeffery653
 
Foreign Policy for an Urban World: Global Governance and the Rise of Cities
Foreign Policy for an Urban World: Global Governance and the Rise of CitiesForeign Policy for an Urban World: Global Governance and the Rise of Cities
Foreign Policy for an Urban World: Global Governance and the Rise of Cities
atlanticcouncil
 
Designing for smart and Inclusive Cities in india
Designing for smart  and Inclusive Cities in indiaDesigning for smart  and Inclusive Cities in india
Designing for smart and Inclusive Cities in india
JitKumarGupta1
 
Challenges faced in emergency response phase in urban areas
Challenges faced in  emergency response phase in urban areasChallenges faced in  emergency response phase in urban areas
Challenges faced in emergency response phase in urban areas
Ashique Hasan
 
Challenges faced in emergency response phase in urban areas
Challenges faced in  emergency response phase in urban areasChallenges faced in  emergency response phase in urban areas
Challenges faced in emergency response phase in urban areas
Ashique Hasan
 
Essay On Urbanisation
Essay On UrbanisationEssay On Urbanisation
Essay On Urbanisation
Cheap Paper Writing Service
 
Urbanisation and Suburbanisation
Urbanisation and SuburbanisationUrbanisation and Suburbanisation
Urbanisation and Suburbanisation
year12blanchgeography
 
World Urbanization Prospects 2014 - UN Highlights, complete report in PDF for...
World Urbanization Prospects 2014 - UN Highlights, complete report in PDF for...World Urbanization Prospects 2014 - UN Highlights, complete report in PDF for...
World Urbanization Prospects 2014 - UN Highlights, complete report in PDF for...
Graciela Mariani
 
2014 revision of the World Urbanization Prospects
2014 revision of the World Urbanization Prospects2014 revision of the World Urbanization Prospects
2014 revision of the World Urbanization Prospects
Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UN DESA)
 
Urban Settlement- derived from time savers standard
Urban Settlement- derived from time savers standardUrban Settlement- derived from time savers standard
Urban Settlement- derived from time savers standard
arananeust
 

Similar to TERM PAPER (20)

Levels, Patterns and Trends of Urbanization (World)
Levels, Patterns and Trends of Urbanization (World)Levels, Patterns and Trends of Urbanization (World)
Levels, Patterns and Trends of Urbanization (World)
 
Urbandevelopment projectsandrisksmanagement
Urbandevelopment projectsandrisksmanagementUrbandevelopment projectsandrisksmanagement
Urbandevelopment projectsandrisksmanagement
 
Urban Planning and Settlements
Urban Planning and SettlementsUrban Planning and Settlements
Urban Planning and Settlements
 
Urbanization and Globalization.pptx
Urbanization and Globalization.pptxUrbanization and Globalization.pptx
Urbanization and Globalization.pptx
 
URBANISATION AND ENVIRONMENT
URBANISATION AND ENVIRONMENTURBANISATION AND ENVIRONMENT
URBANISATION AND ENVIRONMENT
 
urbanisation-181014110414.pdfshsushusbsusbeueb
urbanisation-181014110414.pdfshsushusbsusbeueburbanisation-181014110414.pdfshsushusbsusbeueb
urbanisation-181014110414.pdfshsushusbsusbeueb
 
Why to study Urbanisation ?
Why to study Urbanisation ?Why to study Urbanisation ?
Why to study Urbanisation ?
 
Due Thurs. 4-30-15 4pmPlease answer in 1 ½ two 2 paragraphs, be very.docx
Due Thurs. 4-30-15 4pmPlease answer in 1 ½ two 2 paragraphs, be very.docxDue Thurs. 4-30-15 4pmPlease answer in 1 ½ two 2 paragraphs, be very.docx
Due Thurs. 4-30-15 4pmPlease answer in 1 ½ two 2 paragraphs, be very.docx
 
Annexes
Annexes Annexes
Annexes
 
Planning green smart cities (autosaved)
Planning  green smart cities (autosaved)Planning  green smart cities (autosaved)
Planning green smart cities (autosaved)
 
Chapter 1PopulationPrudent men should judge of future
Chapter 1PopulationPrudent men should judge of future Chapter 1PopulationPrudent men should judge of future
Chapter 1PopulationPrudent men should judge of future
 
Foreign Policy for an Urban World: Global Governance and the Rise of Cities
Foreign Policy for an Urban World: Global Governance and the Rise of CitiesForeign Policy for an Urban World: Global Governance and the Rise of Cities
Foreign Policy for an Urban World: Global Governance and the Rise of Cities
 
Designing for smart and Inclusive Cities in india
Designing for smart  and Inclusive Cities in indiaDesigning for smart  and Inclusive Cities in india
Designing for smart and Inclusive Cities in india
 
Challenges faced in emergency response phase in urban areas
Challenges faced in  emergency response phase in urban areasChallenges faced in  emergency response phase in urban areas
Challenges faced in emergency response phase in urban areas
 
Challenges faced in emergency response phase in urban areas
Challenges faced in  emergency response phase in urban areasChallenges faced in  emergency response phase in urban areas
Challenges faced in emergency response phase in urban areas
 
Essay On Urbanisation
Essay On UrbanisationEssay On Urbanisation
Essay On Urbanisation
 
Urbanisation and Suburbanisation
Urbanisation and SuburbanisationUrbanisation and Suburbanisation
Urbanisation and Suburbanisation
 
World Urbanization Prospects 2014 - UN Highlights, complete report in PDF for...
World Urbanization Prospects 2014 - UN Highlights, complete report in PDF for...World Urbanization Prospects 2014 - UN Highlights, complete report in PDF for...
World Urbanization Prospects 2014 - UN Highlights, complete report in PDF for...
 
2014 revision of the World Urbanization Prospects
2014 revision of the World Urbanization Prospects2014 revision of the World Urbanization Prospects
2014 revision of the World Urbanization Prospects
 
Urban Settlement- derived from time savers standard
Urban Settlement- derived from time savers standardUrban Settlement- derived from time savers standard
Urban Settlement- derived from time savers standard
 

TERM PAPER

  • 1. Dold 1 Michelle B. Dold             I n t e r n a t i o n a l D e v e l o p m e n t S t u d i e s 1 9 1 D e c e m b e r 2 0 1 4   Urbanization Without Economic Development: Causes and Crises
  • 2. Dold 2 Urbanization Without Economic Development: Causes and Crises I. Introduction Since the dawn of civilization, large settlements have been synonymous with advancement- beacons of a society’s prosperity and symbols of its power and influence. The greatest cities in history have inspired legends, etched into the collective memory of the human population: Jericho, Babylon, Carthage, Rome, Baghdad, Beijing, London- each the center of a booming empire characterized by technological innovation and living standards extraordinary for their time and cradles of some of the greatest achievements in human history. Beginning in 2008, for the first time in demographic history more than 50% of the world population lived in urban areas, a trend that demographers predict will continue for decades to come. Not only is our world becoming increasingly urban, but the process of urbanization itself has transformed in recent history as the benefits and repercussions of globalization diffuse across the globe. Though whereas historically the world’s wealthiest nations have played host to its largest cities, many megacities of today have sprung up in some of the world’s least developed countries, oftentimes absent significant economic growth. In recognizing such profound shifts occurring in urbanization patterns globally, I seek to examine, first, possible mechanisms behind these changes and, second, how such changes impact or should impact policy making in these places. Three central questions provide a framework for the research that follows: Why have some countries undergone rapid urbanization without increases to GDP per capita? What are the dangers associated with this brand of urbanization? Should these governments implement policies to slow down the pace of urbanization? Governments in poor, rapidly urbanizing countries face unique challenges in administering enormous
  • 3. Dold 3 cities without sufficient financing to do so effectively often resulting in disastrous consequences for the urban poor. Some developing countries have undergone rapid urbanization absent significant increases in national wealth as the global agricultural system creates widespread impoverishment of their rural populations. When these countries lack strong political and economic institutions, they fail to take advantage of the benefits of urban agglomeration, falling prey to the negative externalities of extreme population density. II. Characterizing Modern Urbanization The world population has undergone profound demographic shifts in the past half century due, in large part, to changing trends in urbanization across the globe. While recent increases in the scale of urbanization are impressive- megacities like Mexico City, Shanghai, and Delhi have populations of 20 million, 23 million, and 25 million respectively- the most striking shift, perhaps, has been the changing geography of globalization. The map below (Figure 1) of growth rates of urban agglomerations from 1970-1990 demonstrates that already at this point in demographic history most of the highest urban growth rates of 3% or more annually, illustrated by orange and red dots, were concentrated in the global south- especially in regions such as Central America, Western Africa, the Middle East, and Southeast Asia. Moderate growth, however, was still occurring throughout much of North America, Europe, and Australia. Boxes on the map represent megacities, somewhat arbitrarily defined by the United Nations as urban agglomerations of ten million or more residents, which are scattered across the globe. Figure 2 depicts urban growth rates from 1990 to 2014, showing that urban growth has slowed to under 1% in most North American agglomerations and across most of the
  • 4. Dold 4 European continent. During this period, high growth rates of 3% or more were concentrated almost exclusively in Asia and Africa, a trend that demographers predict will continue in coming decades.   Figure  1:  Growth  Rates  of  Urban  Agglomerations,  1970-­‐1990  [United  Nations  World  Urbanization   Prospects:  2014  Revision]   Figure  2:  Growth  Rates  of  Urban  Agglomerations,  1990-­‐2000  [United  Nations  World  Urbanization   Prospects:  2014  Revision] City Population 500 - 750 thousand 750 - 1000 thousand 1-5 million 5-10 million 10 million or more Growth Rate × <1% × 1-3% × 3-5% × 5% + Note: Designations employed and the presentation of material on this map do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the Secretariat of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory or area, or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. City Population 500 - 750 thousand 750 - 1000 thousand 1-5 million 5-10 million 10 million or more Growth Rate × <1% × 1-3% × 3-5% × 5% + Note: Designations employed and the presentation of material on this map do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the Secretariat of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory or area, or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.
  • 5. Dold 5 The following graph (Figure 3) from the United Nations’ World Urbanization Prospects 2014 Revision illuminates in more detail what can be gleaned from the maps above: that the greatest contributors to growth in the urban population in the coming decades will be from Asia and Africa, especially from exceptionally rapidly urbanizing countries such as China, India, Nigeria, and Indonesia. Excluding the United States, North American and European countries are notably missing from the list. Perhaps the most striking takeaway from the graphic is that the greatest contributors to urban growth will be from a massive range of income brackets- from the US with a 2013 per capita income of $53,143 to Nigeria with a GDP per capita of $3,006 to the Democratic Republic of the Congo, whose average income was just $454 in 2013 (World Bank). The graphs below (Figures 4 and 5) further substantiate this notion of a loosening correlation between a nation’s wealth and its level of urbanization. One can observe the relationship between percentage urban on the y-axis and purchasing power parity-adjusted income per capita on the x-axis transform from a somewhat tight positive linear pattern, suggesting that richer countries tended to be more urban in 1960, to a more cloud-like shape, World Urbanization Prospects: The 2014 Revision12 Just a few countries are home to half of the world’s urban population. China has the largest urban population (758 million), followed by India (410 million). These two countries account for 30 per cent of the world’s urban population and, with another five countries, the United States of America (263 million), Brazil (173 million), Indonesia (134 million), Japan (118 million) and the Russian Federation (105 million), account for more than half of the world’s urban population. Future increases in the world’s urban population are also expected to be highly con- centrated in just a few countries (figure 7). Taken together, China, India and Nigeria are projected to account for 37 per cent of the increase of nearly 2.5 billion people in the urban population by 2050. Between 2014 and 2050, the urban areas are expected to grow by 404 million people in India, 292 million in China and 212 million in Nigeria. Seven other countries, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Ethiopia, the United Republic of Tanzania, Bangladesh, Indonesia and Pakistan, and the United States of America, are projected to contribute more than 50 million each to the urban increment and will constitute together another 20 per cent of the total increase in urban population. In a few countries, the urban population will decrease, despite projected increases in the level of urbanization. The larg- est declines between 2014 and 2050 are projected for Japan, with a decline of 12 million urban dwellers and for the Russian Federation, expected to decline by 7 million. Figure 7. Contribution to the increase in urban population by country, 2014 to 2050 China and India will contribute more than one third of the global urban population increase between 2014 and 2050 Note: The countries shown are projected to contribute 25 million or more to the global urban increment between 2014 and 2050. The category “Other countries” includes countries with urban increments of less than 25 million each. 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 Other countries Democratic Republic of the Congo China India nearly 2.5 billion urban population increase by 2050 50% Nigeria Indonesia United States of America Pakistan Urbanpopulationincrease(millions) Iraq Angola Viet Nam Sudan Iran (Islamic Republic of) Uganda Kenya Egypt Mexico Brazil Philippines Ethiopia United Republic of Tanzania Bangladesh Figure  3:  Contribution  to  the  Increase  in  Urban  Population  by   Country,  2014-­‐2050  [United  Nations  World  Urbanization   Prospects:  2014  Revision]
  • 6. Dold 6 suggesting that by 2011 wealth was no longer a requisite nor a guaranteed outcome of urbanization. Osaka, Japan, for example, one of the wealthiest megacities, is projected to fall from its former place as second largest city in 1990 to the thirteenth largest city in 2030, whereas demographers predict that Lagos, Nigeria will grow to become the ninth largest city in 2030 from its position as thirty-third in 1990 (United Nations). As the association between urbanization and average income slackens, lower living standards in emerging poor megacities are inciting debate within academia and popular discourse over whether governments should adopt policies that encourage or abate urbanization in their countries.   Figure  4:  GDP  per  Capita  vs.  Urban  Population  (%  of  Total),  1960  [Gapminder  World]
  • 7. Dold 7   Figure  5:  GDP  per  Capita  vs.  Urban  Population  (%  of  Total),  2011  [Gapminder  World] III. Positive and Negative Externalities of Urbanization The process of absorbing rural migrants into cities includes both positive and negative externalities, which in economics are defined as “situations in which the private costs or benefits to the producers or purchasers of a good or service differs from the total social costs or benefits entailed in its production and consumption” (Johnson). There are well-known and well-researched benefits to urbanization, especially with regards to industry, as a concentration of economic agents tends to increase productivity via agglomeration economies. In the 1960s, urban planner Jane Jacobs characterized cities as incubators of innovation and knowledge spillovers resulting from the collision of many people with diverse educational backgrounds and skillsets (Rigby). However, a focus on these assumed benefits of urbanization, sometimes referred to in the literature as the
  • 8. Dold 8 “density cult” (Kotkin), are actually part of a problem that diverts attention away from what is really happening in some of the world’s poorest megacities- widespread suffering and inequality. The negative externalities of rapid and intense urbanization abound and can result in lower living standards in large cities when governments are ill equipped to mitigate them. One such negative externality is the widespread unemployment of rural migrants lacking in education or skills outside of agriculture; many of these migrants end up working in the informal sector doing jobs like peddling small goods or driving rickshaws, untaxed income that does not contribute to national wealth. Understandably, larger populations means more stress on public services such as education and health care and on infrastructure like roads and highways. One consequence of intense urbanization that perhaps does not receive as much attention as it should is traffic congestion; one recent survey estimated that 85% of traffic deaths worldwide take place in developing nations (Kotkin). Additionally, pressure on a city’s housing supply can drive up prices and drive urban poor into slums, where sanitation issues and dense inhabitance can facilitate the spread of infectious disease. Other negative externalities such as environmental degradation and massive income inequalities that characterize large cities in poor countries typically take a back seat to more pressing issues of providing citizens with the basic means of survival.
  • 9. Dold 9   Figure  6:  Positive  and  Negative  Externalities  of  Urbanization     None of these externalities are new per se and it is not so much their existence that sets new global megacities apart from older ones- these dangers exist in all large cities regardless of average income. The worry is, rather, that poorer governments often lack the financial and institutional resources to mitigate their negative effects on the urban population, leading to very low living standards. IV. Glaeser’s Insight- “A World of Cities” In order to understand the mechanisms behind these profound shifts in the urbanization process, Harvard economist Edward Glaeser points to recent increases in globalization, especially over the past half century. While no all encompassing or agreed upon definition of globalization exists because of the phenomenon’s enormous scale, this
  • 10. Dold 10 investigation uses the term to refer to globalized supply networks of agricultural goods coupled with liberalized trade policies. To assess the impact of globalization on growth in cities Glaeser, in his study “A World of Cities: The Causes and Consequences of Urbanization in Poorer Countries”, considers the links between agricultural productivity, country size, which he uses as a proxy for openness, and urbanization in 1961 and 2010. In their essence, his findings demonstrate that agricultural productivity was more strongly associated with urbanization in large than small countries and that the relationship between local agricultural productivity and city growth became less prominent during this period (Glaeser 3-4). Glaeser postulates that, as globalized trade networks break the traditional links between urban areas and the agricultural hinterlands that historically sustained them, displaced and impoverished rural populations flood cities in search of other economic opportunities. The macroeconomics of development tend to support this theory; as countries orient their economies toward export to international markets and away from subsistence agriculture, typically this process involves governments and/or private enterprises investing large sums of capital to mechanize agriculture and make it more efficient and opening borders to international trade. Unable to compete with the lower prices of imports, especially when agricultural prices are artificially depressed by government subsidies in developed nations (eg. of the US to its domestic sugar industry), small farmers are often put out of business. When this occurs, such farmers often must sell their land, the main source of wealth and form of inheritance in most rural societies, or government simply seizes land for commercial agriculture and impoverished rural dwellers must look to cities for economic opportunity.
  • 11. Dold 11 Figure  8:  Potential  Paths  to  Urbanization-­‐  Closed  vs.  Open  Economies     Figure 8: This very simplified schematic illustrates theoretically how huge cities can develop in poorer nations. In relatively closed economies, like those of North American and European countries during their period of urban development, urban populations are dependent on the surrounding rural areas for sustenance, which leads to local agricultural prosperity assuming the country has fertile soil and a climate conducive to cultivation. Agricultural abundance means that a city can sustain larger populations and nearby urban areas will grow gradually in that much of the rural population will stay put given high demand, and therefore high prices, for its products. Conversely, in economies that are more open to trade, like those of many small developing nations today, urban areas no longer necessarily depend on local agriculture for sustenance in that they can purchase cheap imported food from international markets. In the context of a global system of trade in agricultural products, small scale and subsistence farming become less financially feasible. Displaced rural dwellers flood cities in search of work. closed economies (dependence on local agriculture) local agricultural prosperity   gradual growth in nearby urban areas   open economies (dependence on global agricultural trade)   rural impoverishment   rapid growth in nearby urban areas  
  • 12. Dold 12 The danger in this, Glaeser points out, is that huge cities with massive populations in need of service and infrastructure provision can develop in poor countries whose political and economic institutions tend to be weaker and whose governments are less well-equipped to handle the challenges that large-scale urbanization can bring. The core of Glaeser’s insight centers upon poor versus rich governments’ responses to the negative externalities of urbanization. He holds that “the ability to punish bad behavior is limited by the institutional strength of a particular society” (Glaeser 20). When a country’s institutions are weak, meaning they lack a well-established rule of law or property rights and there is lots of public sector corruption, the outcome of intense urbanization is either, as Glaeser terms it, “anarchy” or “draconian prevention” (Glaeser 4). One example of what Glaeser would consider anarchy in the face of urbanization comes from Dhaka, Bangladesh, which is tied with Lagos as the most rapidly urbanization city in the world with an estimated growth rate of 3.6% from 2010-2015 (World Bank). In addition to boasting the fastest growing, but also one of the poorest megacities, Bangladesh also has one of the most corrupt governments in the world, ranking 145th out of 175 countries recently surveyed by Transparency International (Transparency International). Many urban poor in Dhaka do not have access to basic social services that the government is constitutionally bound to offer either inexpensively or for free. For example, a recent survey of Bangladeshi households found that 44% of patients in public health facilities had to pay bribes for care (Manzoor 13), demonstrating an anarchic lack of enforcement of government regulations. At the other end of the spectrum, some poorer governments may choose to curb negative externalities through authoritarian policies. For example, in 1958 the
  • 13. Dold 13 Communist Chinese government began mandating that rural migrants carry proof of formal residence and employment in cities like Shanghai in order to receive social services such as education or healthcare (“Migrant Workers and Their Children”). Such a policy suggests that some poor and rapidly urbanizing countries may face a tradeoff between economic growth and political repression should governments choose to take that route. Such examples support the notion that there is a link between institutional quality and development, especially in large cities. V. Support from Acemoglu and Robinson Research by Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson on the effects of institutional quality on development, as articulated in their book Why Nations Fail, has become foundational in the field of political economics. Their findings further substantiate the hypothesis that weak institutions make large cities in poor countries more vulnerable to the negative externalities of intense and rapid urbanization. Their thesis holds that the density and quality of rules put in place to structure politics (the level of democracy), economics (the extent of free markets), and society (inclusive or extractive institutions) either foster or inhibit economic growth (Acemoglu and Robinson). The authors write extensively about the fact that development requires investment, not just by governments, enterprises and capitalists, but also by everyday people. This investment, however, will only occur when people and businesses can trust in the institutional foundations of the country to protect their property rights so that can reliably expect a return on that investment. Rampant corruption and bribery in the public sector greatly increase the cost of accomplishing almost anything in a country, discouraging capitalists from starting or
  • 14. Dold 14 growing businesses that could potentially act as sources of national wealth or keeping poor individuals from receiving the services that they need. VI. Case Study- Dhaka, Bangladesh To coalesce all of these abstract concepts, as they do not carry much significance without application, I will zero in on one example of a rapidly urbanizing low-income country- Bangladesh. Dhaka is the political, commercial, and industrial epicenter of the country, its economic activity concentrated in the production of textiles, garments, chemicals and pharmaceuticals (“Dhaka”). As noted above, Dhaka is the fastest growing city in the world with a current population of roughly twelve million that has quadrupled over the past 25 years, but is the world’s poorest megacity with an average annual income of just $829 (Kotkin). The city adds 300,000 to 400,000 people annually, mostly migrants from poor rural areas motivated by push factors of overpopulation, natural disaster and loss of land. According to a 2008 survey by the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics, 4.5 million rural Bangladeshis are completely landless, which has especially impoverishing effects given that land is the main source of wealth in the countryside. Author Shahadat Hossain notes In this agriculture based country, land is the main means to generate subsistence and surplus and is the most valuable asset to the rural poor. Increased loss and fragmentation of land among the poor and increased concentration of land among the rich, coupled with a high natural growth rate of the population raise the number of landless and hungry. (Hossain 18) Pull factors to Dhaka can include employment opportunities in the informal sector that do not necessitate extended education or training and relative freedom for female workers in the city (Hossain 18).
  • 15. Dold 15 Unfortunately most rural migrants to Dhaka experience very low living standards, especially from the lack of public services available for the 3.4 million people that live in Dhaka’s slums. Estimates show that in these informal housing communities only 65% of households are literate, 37% of people have access to safe drinking water, and only 10% of shelters are built from concrete, the other 90% being built from scrap metal, bamboo, and other temporary building materials (World Bank). The majority of Dhaka’s population lives below the official poverty line, historically measured by caloric intake, quantifying the absolute poor as those who intake 2122 k.cal or less daily. While nationally the percentage of people living under this threshold decreased from 47.8% to 44.5% from 1988-2000, the percentage of urbanites meeting this criterion for poverty increased from 47.6% to 52.5% during the same period (Hossain 14). Infrastructural degradation occurs throughout the city both because of strain from large populations and overuse, but also because of government neglect and corruption. For example, in 2013 one garment factory in the industrial zone of Savar, just outside Dhaka, collapsed killing over 1,000 people and injuring countless others. Upon inspection, the factory was found to have been constructed with “substandard materials and in a blatant disregard for building codes” (Yardley) and factory owners have been accused of bribing local officials for construction permits (Yardley). One report from the investigation of the collapse even found that “10% of lawmakers in the national parliament are owners of garment businesses in Bangladesh” (Hussein). Such anarchic neglect of regulation and impunity on behalf of the government shows that weak institutions particularly harm urban poor.
  • 16. Dold 16 As previously mentioned, the Bangladeshi government performs abysmally in Transparency International’s annual survey of public sector corruption. In the most recent rankings, the country came in 90th out of 142 countries in judicial independence, 146th out of 187 in the human development index, 129th out of 179 in the press freedom index, and in the 27th and 38th percentiles in the rule of law and accountability categories, respectively (Transparency International). Not only do such weak institutions increase transaction costs and encourage capital flight, but they also keep poor from receiving social services that the Bangladesh government is obligated to provide. For example, in order to raise literacy rates, the government extends stipends to females pursuing secondary education, though a survey found that 22% of these women paid illegal bribes to enroll and 38% of program participants reported receiving less money than they were promised (Manzoor 7). Weak regulatory institutions coupled with government impunity have kept Dhaka from realizing the positive externalities of its rapid urbanization, leaving the vast majority of its residents to suffer. VII. An Intriguing Solution- Paul Romer’s Charter Cities Another notable economist to weigh in on the issue of poor country urbanization and institutional quality is Paul Romer, a former Stanford economist now researching at the NYU’s Stern School of Business. Romer recognizes the same malady that bars poor countries from utilizing urbanization for development in many cases and, in his promotion of “charter cities”, he offers a work around for the poor institutions in these countries. Romer proposes that governments construct new cities entirely from scratch governed by charters that lay out regulations and enforcements mechanisms different from those that govern the rest of the country, especially ones that encourage investment
  • 17. Dold 17 by emphasizing property rights (but also rules about sanitation, traffic control, service administration, etc.). Romer compares charter cities to the Special Economic Zones that China established during the 1980s to attract foreign capital. He holds that foreign investors could finance construction of these cities’ infrastructure in exchange for “fee income use from the users” (Freakonomics). These countries could then enter into written commitments with governments known for having strong, credible institutions, like the US or Canada for example, which could act as guarantors to ensure that these countries do not renege on promises made in the charter. Romer insists that these charters would be further legitimized by rural dwellers choosing, without being coerced, to move to cities. Though in theory this sounds positive, the implementation of charter cities poses profound problems. First is the question of why corrupt officials who benefit from the status quo would be willing to essentially renounce control over a part or parts of their territory. This introduces the other glaring issue of enforcing rules laid out in the charter; the reason that these types of cities would be necessarily in the first place is that institutions that govern the rest of the country are too weak to encourage investment, so it is unlikely that such weak or corrupt regimes would adhere to agreements, even if third party guarantors were involved. Additionally, though the special economic zones were largely successful in fomenting economic growth in China, such success has not come without a price. Protests against land acquisition have sprung up in rural China, especially in the Guangdong province, as the zone is taking over rural areas to accommodate foreign investors (Ismaylova). Such development also comes at the expense of Chinese laborers who endure poor working conditions in these factories.
  • 18. Dold 18 While Romer’s charter city idea is riddled with logistical and perhaps ethical complications, I included it in this discussion because it further proves that institutions are at the heart of development. Romer recognizes what Glaeser, Acemoglu, and Robinson do- that weak institutions can keep poor countries from benefitting from urbanization and that development requires governments to make credible and long-term commitments to protecting property rights and enforcing the rule of law. Though charter cities may not be the correct avenue to development, that strong institutions are necessary for economic growth has become widely accepted. VIII. Conclusions Throughout this research, it has become apparent that despite the popular notion that large, dense cities go hand-in-hand with national wealth, urbanization in and of itself is not necessarily beneficial for a country or a population unless paired with good governance. Edward Glaeser notes, however, that, “The connections and social movements that form readily in the dense confines of urban areas can ultimately be strong enough to change and discipline government” (Glaeser 41). Just as cities can act as incubators for innovation in industry and technology, they can also generate agglomeration economies for political reform as people share their grievances and ideas for change. Large populations of suffering urban poor have the potential to form coalitions to pressure their governments into greater accountability, the only way that true change can occur when corrupt bureaucrats benefit from the status quo of extractive institutions. Future political, economic, and demographic research on urbanization should keep in mind not only the objective of economic growth, but also pursuing equity alongside development
  • 19. Works  Cited   Acemoglu, Daron, James Robinson, and Simon Johnson. "Institutions as a Fundamental Cause of Long-Run Growth." Handbook of Economic Growth. Vol. 1A. Elsevier B.V., 2005. 386-472. Web. 1 Oct. 2014. "BANGLADESH: Landless Numbers on the Rise." IRIN Humanitarian News and Analysis. IRIN, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 1 Nov. 2014. "Can "Charter Cities" Change the World? A Q&A With Paul Romer."Freakonomics. Freakonomics LLC, 29 Sept. 2009. Web. 1 Nov. 2014. "Corruption by Country/Territory." Transparency International. Transparency International, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 1 Dec. 2014. Chakrabortty, Aditya. "Paul Romer Is a Brilliant Economist – but His Idea for Charter Cities Is Bad." Guardian 27 July 2010. Web. 5 Dec. 2014. "Dhaka." Encyclopaedia Brittannica. Encyclopædia Britannica, 2013. Print. Glaeser, Edward. "A World of Cities: Causes and Consequences of Urbanization in Poorer Countries." NBER Working Paper Series 19745 (2013): 1-58. National Bureau of Economic Research. Web. 1 Oct. 2014. Hasan, Manzoor. "Public Sector Corruption in Bangladesh: Political and Bureaucratic." (2007). Institute of Governance Studies, BRAC University. Web. 1 Nov. 2014. Hossain, Shahadat. "Rapid Urban Growth and Poverty in Dhaka City."Bangladesh E- Journal of Sociology 5.1 (2008): 1-24. Web. 1 Nov. 2014. Hussein, Sajjad. "Six Months after Bangladeshi Factory Collapse, Workers Remain in Peril." CNN.com. Cable News Network, 24 Oct. 2013. Web. 1 Dec. 2014. Ismaylova, Eugenia. "Special Economic Zones: Select Advantages and Substantial Problems." Illinois Business Law Journal (2007). University of Illinois. Web. 1 Dec. 2014. Johnson, Paul. "Externality." A Glossary of Political Economy Terms. Auburn: U of Auburn, Department of Political Science, 2005. Print. Kotkin, Joel. "Megacities And The Density Delusion: Why More People Doesn't Equal More Wealth." Forbes 16 Apr. 2013. Print.
  • 20. Kotkin, Joel. "The Problem With Megacities." Forbes 4 Apr. 2011. Print. "Migrant Workers and Their Children." China Labour Bulletin (2013). The China Labour Bulletin. Web. 1 Oct. 2014. Rigby, David . "Agglomeration." Economic Geography. University of California, Los Angeles, Department of Geography. Haines Hall, Los Angeles. 19 Feb. 2014. Lecture. Romer, Paul. "Why the World Needs Charter Cities." TEDGlobal 2009. TED. Oxford University, Oxford. 1 July 2009. Lecture. "South Asia- World Population Day - July 11(South Asia Growth)." The World Bank. The World Bank Group, 1 Jan. 2013. Web. 1 Dec. 2014. "Transparency International Bangladesh." Transparency International. Transparency International, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 1 Dec. 2014. "World Development Indicators." World Bank. The World Bank Group, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 1 Nov. 2014. World Urbanization Prospects: The 2014 Revision (2014): 1-32. United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division. Web. 1 Nov. 2014. Yardley, Jim. "Report on Deadly Factory Collapse in Bangladesh Finds Widespread Blame." New York Times 22 May 2013. Print.