SlideShare a Scribd company logo
ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin
Technical Report: Performing Arts Center for Hawaii Pacific University, Hawaii Loa Campus
May 2015
Summary
The aim of this project is to create a performing arts center for Hawaii Pacific University
that would keep with Hawaiian values and achieve a LEED Silver certification using local and/or
renewable resources. To explore possibilities, eQuest was used to determine the schematics and
any potential problems. A two-floor, rectangle minus a corner layout was chosen. The theatre,
corresponding rooms, a café and a set of bathrooms would make up the first floor. Classrooms,
practice rooms, general offices, and a library complete the second floor. The Centre would be
located between the Nursing Annex and the Academic Center and would utilize a green roof on a
white roof, local resources, and low-flow fixtures. The café would potentially be located partially
outside to take advantage of natural cooling. The green roof would have a water catchment
system with pipes leading to rain gardens used for the café. Overall energy use was reduced by
55.8%, from 49,189.58 kWh to 27,465.27 kWh. Water usage changes were calculated to save
667,577.50 liters per year.
Introduction
Beginning in the early 1990s, Hawaii Pacific College (HPC) began to look into a more
environmentally sustainable approach in anticipation to a merger with Hawaii Loa College (HL)
to create Hawaii Pacific University (HPU). Historical footprint data indicated that becoming
environmentally sustainable would be the best solution in the long run for the school, while
holding to the local idea of protecting the `aina from overuse.
The planning process has continued well into the 2000s. A draft concept plan was
generated in 2007 and a master plan was created in 2008. Several principles were developed
during this time (Hawaii Loa Plan for Student Projects):
1. Enhance the quality of education at HPU.
2. Create a campus with residential housing that supports strong teaching and strong
learning.
3. Use Hawaiian ideals to build a sustainable campus.
Purpose
The aim of the project is to develop a performing arts center for the Hawaii Loa campus
at Hawaii Pacific University. The goal is to have a performing arts center that conforms to the
university’s overall goals of becoming LEED certified at the Silver level while still incorporating
a Hawaiian sense of space.
ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin
Methods
To complete the preliminary analysis of possible performing arts center concepts, the
computer modeling program eQuest was used. The program allows users to view multiple
options before construction begins. The requirements for the performing arts center are as
follows:
1. The center will be approximately a total of 25,000 ft2.
2. A 600-seat theatre, with storage rooms, a box office, and dressing rooms
3. General office space
4. A café
5. Classrooms and practice rooms
6. Restrooms
7. An electrical room
8. A library
9. A parking lot
10. Must incorporate using renewable resources.
Using the eQuest Schematic Design Wizard, two locations were originally looked at: the
lawn between the Academic Center and the Nursing Annex, and the area above the Soccer Field.
Two different layouts were also analyzed, a rectangle minus a corner and a trapezoid. The lawn
and the rectangle minus a corner shape were chosen for the final design with two floors. A
baseline energy calculation was then done to determine how and where adjustments would be
done to make the building as sustainable as possible while keeping the design feasible for the
school.
Once the baseline was completed, room placement was decided. Building materials and
products were then chosen. This included the types of windows, doors, lighting. It also included
the type of roof needed. The roof was chosen using a green roof calculator from Portland State
University, with a growing media depth of 6 inches, leaf area index of 2 and an 80% roof cover.
The results were later added to the initial baseline energy usage to calculate sustainable energy
usage. Water usage and the products needed were calculated using an indoor water use reduction
calculator provided by LEED.
Results and Discussion
Initial analyses determined that the rectangle minus a corner with two floors is more
efficient than a trapezoid with two floors. The shape leaves less awkward space. The building
faces north. Ceiling heights were kept at 12 feet for each floor. The breakdown of the Center
layout is shown in Table 1. The theatre and its corresponding rooms (except for the general
offices) would take up 38% of the Center’s space and is planned to be on the lower floor, along
with the café. The general offices, classrooms, and library are planned to be on the second floor.
Figure 1 shows an example of the proposed layout. The café may be placed outside on a lanai to
increase office space and take advantage of the wind for natural cooling.
ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin
Baseline Calculations
Baseline energy analyses gave us the next steps needed. The initial annual electrical use
was 850.44 kWh and the initial gas usage was 164.94 btu, for a total annual energy use of
49,189.58 kWh. Using the LEED-provided water reduction calculator, it was found that normal
water use would amount to about 2,190.00 gallons per year for 750 users.
Building Envelope Constructions
It was decided the roof would be built up and based on a metal frame (>24 in.) with
exterior 3 inch polyurethane (R-18) insulation and R-15 batting. The walls would utilize a metal
2x6 24 inch frame with a stucco exterior finish and reclaimed wood or bamboo interior walls.
The walls would also have R-2 exterior insulation, R-19 batting, and R-6 1 inch polyurethane
interior insulation. The floors would be either ceramic or stone to reduce cooling needs. The
ceilings would be lay-in acoustic tiles. Windows would account for 40% of each wall and be 6ft
x 8ft. The glass used would be double reflective clear ¼ inch air windows. The doors would be
made of opaque, solid core flush wood and be 6ft x 7ft. There would be one set of doors on each
side of the building.
Lighting
Daylight harvesting would be utilized to reduce energy costs. The analysis allowed us to
decide to use Dimming: 30% lights with a 50 fc light level. The lights would be turned on 13
hours a day 355 days a year to account for 10 holidays where the building would not be used.
Skylights were originally proposed for the top floor. However, building code dictates that only
3% of a roof can have skylights.
HVAC Use
It was decided that DX coils would be used for heating and cooling. The heat pump
would utilize air. The system would be a packaged single zone heat pump with ducted air return.
The minimum design flow would be kept at 0.75 cfm/ft2. The cooling unit would be 63 tons with
an EER efficiency of 8.20, allowing crankhouse heating. The heating unit with a COP efficiency
of 2.90.
Roof
After using the green rood calculator, we decided on an irrigated green roof on a white
roof would produce the best annual savings, of 1860.8 kWh and $228.90. It was also decided that
the green roof would also have a water catchment system with pipes leading to rain gardens that
provide local produce for the Center’s café.
Water Usage
The LEED water use reduction calculator was used to determine what kind of faucets and
toilets need to be used to save the most energy. Calculations were made using 750 individuals.
The baseline flush rate for urinals was 3.80 lpf and the baseline flush rate for toilets was 6.00 lpf.
Based off of these numbers the baseline case annual flush volume was 1,750,860.00 liters per
ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin
year. Low-flow versions reduced the flush rates to 0.5 lpf each for a total of 166,406.25 liters per
year.
Faucets were also used to calculate needed energy savings. Baseline bathroom faucets
had a flow rate of 1.90 lpm/lpc and kitchen faucets had a baseline flow rate of 8.30 lpm/lpc. This
amounts to 639,713.55 liters per year of water used. Design restroom faucets had a flow rate 1.5
lpm/lpc, while design kitchen faucets had a flow rate of 2.2 lpm/lpc. The design fixtures reduced
the annual flow volume to 501,171.25 liters per year.
Final Energy Savings
Once all changes were made using the eQuest software, it was found that the changes
reduced the total annual energy use from 49,189.58 kWh to 29,326.07 kWh. Electrical energy
use was reduced from 850.44 kWh to 622.69 kWh. Annual gas usage was reduced from 164.94
btu to 97.94 btu. This brought the total annual energy use down to 29,326.07 kWh. The green
roof savings of 1,860.80 kWh further reduced the total energy use to 27,465.27 kWh. Overall
energy use was reduced by 55.8%.
Conclusions and Recommendations
1. Solar panels along the back of the Center to reduce energy costs further may be
considered. Solar panels were not chosen as part of the final design because of the
amount of rain Kaneohe typically gets throughout the day.
2. Possibly use Save Water Bricks as a building material. The bricks filter water through
holes that provide water ways from the roof to the ground to eliminate the need for pipes
to transfer water to rain gardens. The bricks are made from fallen leaves and plastic.
3. Overall energy use was reduced by 55.8%, from 49,189.58 kWh to 27,465.27 kWh using
eQuest modifications and a green roof.
4. Water usage changes were calculated to save 667,577.50 liters per year.
ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin
Appendix
Table 1: Breakdown of Performing Arts Center Layout (25,000 ft2).
Item
Percentage
of 25,000
ft2
Theatre - includes general offices (7%), box office,
storage, dressing rooms, stage, and a 600-seat house
floor 42%
Classrooms - including practice rooms and studios 15%
Café 10%
Library - includes stacks, reading rooms, storage,
circulation area 18%
Restrooms 5%
Electrical/Mechanical Room 5%
Corridors 5%
Figure 1: A general layout of the proposed Performing Arts Center. The center would be two
floors with a total of 25,000 ft2.

More Related Content

What's hot

NAGEEB (National Action for Green Energy Efficient Buildings) meeting UK 2016...
NAGEEB (National Action for Green Energy Efficient Buildings) meeting UK 2016...NAGEEB (National Action for Green Energy Efficient Buildings) meeting UK 2016...
NAGEEB (National Action for Green Energy Efficient Buildings) meeting UK 2016...
Bernard Ammoun
 
New Central Library- LEED Profile
New Central Library- LEED Profile New Central Library- LEED Profile
New Central Library- LEED Profile
Austin Office of the City Architect
 
Turner Roberts Recreation Center
Turner Roberts Recreation Center Turner Roberts Recreation Center
Turner Roberts Recreation Center
Austin Office of the City Architect
 
Gtower report
Gtower reportGtower report
Gtower report
Elaine Bong
 
Sustainable Design Principles
Sustainable Design PrinciplesSustainable Design Principles
Sustainable Design Principles
ZMM, Inc.
 
Derek Hendry WEC Biography
Derek Hendry WEC BiographyDerek Hendry WEC Biography
Derek Hendry WEC Biography
Derek Hendry
 
IGBC
IGBCIGBC
Klingerman jadot mercado_shook_project1
Klingerman jadot mercado_shook_project1Klingerman jadot mercado_shook_project1
Klingerman jadot mercado_shook_project1
Chuck Lohre
 
Manitoba Hydro Place
Manitoba Hydro PlaceManitoba Hydro Place
Manitoba Hydro Place
Deb Bee
 
Green Building Index
Green Building IndexGreen Building Index
Green Building Index
Eraz
 
Green and Competitive - Strategy Approach for GBI
Green and Competitive - Strategy Approach for GBIGreen and Competitive - Strategy Approach for GBI
Green and Competitive - Strategy Approach for GBI
Ir. Kok Jing Shun
 
Michigan Energy Forum - May 2, 2013
Michigan Energy Forum - May 2, 2013Michigan Energy Forum - May 2, 2013
Michigan Energy Forum - May 2, 2013
AnnArborSPARK
 
Itc hotel
Itc  hotelItc  hotel
Itc hotel
Shubhangi Goel
 
Campus square building
Campus square buildingCampus square building
Campus square building
William J. Sutton II, LEED AP
 
Vinay M
Vinay MVinay M
buildings rated by GRIHA and LEED, sustainable buildings around the wold, gre...
buildings rated by GRIHA and LEED, sustainable buildings around the wold, gre...buildings rated by GRIHA and LEED, sustainable buildings around the wold, gre...
buildings rated by GRIHA and LEED, sustainable buildings around the wold, gre...
DhvaniR2
 
Leed Info
Leed InfoLeed Info
Leed Info
MrFuggles
 
Sustainable school design Case study- Discovery elementary school
Sustainable school design Case study- Discovery elementary schoolSustainable school design Case study- Discovery elementary school
Sustainable school design Case study- Discovery elementary school
Rohan Narvekar
 
Case study
Case studyCase study
Case study
Alyssia Choo
 
Austin Energy System Control Center - LEED Profile
Austin Energy System Control Center - LEED ProfileAustin Energy System Control Center - LEED Profile
Austin Energy System Control Center - LEED Profile
Austin Office of the City Architect
 

What's hot (20)

NAGEEB (National Action for Green Energy Efficient Buildings) meeting UK 2016...
NAGEEB (National Action for Green Energy Efficient Buildings) meeting UK 2016...NAGEEB (National Action for Green Energy Efficient Buildings) meeting UK 2016...
NAGEEB (National Action for Green Energy Efficient Buildings) meeting UK 2016...
 
New Central Library- LEED Profile
New Central Library- LEED Profile New Central Library- LEED Profile
New Central Library- LEED Profile
 
Turner Roberts Recreation Center
Turner Roberts Recreation Center Turner Roberts Recreation Center
Turner Roberts Recreation Center
 
Gtower report
Gtower reportGtower report
Gtower report
 
Sustainable Design Principles
Sustainable Design PrinciplesSustainable Design Principles
Sustainable Design Principles
 
Derek Hendry WEC Biography
Derek Hendry WEC BiographyDerek Hendry WEC Biography
Derek Hendry WEC Biography
 
IGBC
IGBCIGBC
IGBC
 
Klingerman jadot mercado_shook_project1
Klingerman jadot mercado_shook_project1Klingerman jadot mercado_shook_project1
Klingerman jadot mercado_shook_project1
 
Manitoba Hydro Place
Manitoba Hydro PlaceManitoba Hydro Place
Manitoba Hydro Place
 
Green Building Index
Green Building IndexGreen Building Index
Green Building Index
 
Green and Competitive - Strategy Approach for GBI
Green and Competitive - Strategy Approach for GBIGreen and Competitive - Strategy Approach for GBI
Green and Competitive - Strategy Approach for GBI
 
Michigan Energy Forum - May 2, 2013
Michigan Energy Forum - May 2, 2013Michigan Energy Forum - May 2, 2013
Michigan Energy Forum - May 2, 2013
 
Itc hotel
Itc  hotelItc  hotel
Itc hotel
 
Campus square building
Campus square buildingCampus square building
Campus square building
 
Vinay M
Vinay MVinay M
Vinay M
 
buildings rated by GRIHA and LEED, sustainable buildings around the wold, gre...
buildings rated by GRIHA and LEED, sustainable buildings around the wold, gre...buildings rated by GRIHA and LEED, sustainable buildings around the wold, gre...
buildings rated by GRIHA and LEED, sustainable buildings around the wold, gre...
 
Leed Info
Leed InfoLeed Info
Leed Info
 
Sustainable school design Case study- Discovery elementary school
Sustainable school design Case study- Discovery elementary schoolSustainable school design Case study- Discovery elementary school
Sustainable school design Case study- Discovery elementary school
 
Case study
Case studyCase study
Case study
 
Austin Energy System Control Center - LEED Profile
Austin Energy System Control Center - LEED ProfileAustin Energy System Control Center - LEED Profile
Austin Energy System Control Center - LEED Profile
 

Similar to Technical Report

Project Information - Gharkey St House
Project Information - Gharkey St HouseProject Information - Gharkey St House
Project Information - Gharkey St House
ecoREHABstudio
 
Green Museums Ca Academy A Pope
Green Museums Ca Academy A PopeGreen Museums Ca Academy A Pope
Green Museums Ca Academy A Pope
Mandy Smith
 
Ashrae isbd poster
Ashrae isbd posterAshrae isbd poster
Ashrae isbd poster
Vignesh Mohankumar
 
2012 ISCN Symposium - Energy Optimization at Central Michigan University 2012
2012 ISCN Symposium - Energy Optimization at Central Michigan University 20122012 ISCN Symposium - Energy Optimization at Central Michigan University 2012
2012 ISCN Symposium - Energy Optimization at Central Michigan University 2012
ISCN_Secretariat
 
046-057_Monterey Bay
046-057_Monterey Bay046-057_Monterey Bay
046-057_Monterey Bay
Jeff Blaevoet
 
Collateral Healing Conference Table made from 10% recycled cardboard.
Collateral Healing Conference Table made from 10% recycled cardboard. Collateral Healing Conference Table made from 10% recycled cardboard.
Collateral Healing Conference Table made from 10% recycled cardboard.
Stanley Shetka
 
Case study- Coca Cola Place
Case study- Coca Cola PlaceCase study- Coca Cola Place
Case study- Coca Cola Place
Amir Borghei
 
COTE Top Ten: Intelligent Design for a Restorative Future
COTE Top Ten: Intelligent Design for a Restorative FutureCOTE Top Ten: Intelligent Design for a Restorative Future
COTE Top Ten: Intelligent Design for a Restorative Future
juliekannai
 
IAED 342-Research Presentation
IAED 342-Research PresentationIAED 342-Research Presentation
IAED 342-Research Presentation
Serra's Art Studio
 
George Washington Carver Branch Library- LEED Profile
George Washington Carver Branch Library- LEED Profile George Washington Carver Branch Library- LEED Profile
George Washington Carver Branch Library- LEED Profile
Austin Office of the City Architect
 
Building Science 1: Project 1 G- Tower
Building Science 1: Project 1 G- TowerBuilding Science 1: Project 1 G- Tower
Building Science 1: Project 1 G- Tower
hiewyennee
 
Council house 2 sustainable building example
Council house 2 sustainable building exampleCouncil house 2 sustainable building example
Council house 2 sustainable building example
UET Lahore
 
BULLITT CENTER, SEATTLE, WASHINGTON.pptx
BULLITT CENTER, SEATTLE, WASHINGTON.pptxBULLITT CENTER, SEATTLE, WASHINGTON.pptx
BULLITT CENTER, SEATTLE, WASHINGTON.pptx
PushpaHarshitha05
 
Green building Manipal University
Green building  Manipal UniversityGreen building  Manipal University
Green building Manipal University
Siddiq Salim
 
Radnor Middle School sets example in Sustainability
Radnor Middle School sets example in SustainabilityRadnor Middle School sets example in Sustainability
Radnor Middle School sets example in Sustainability
Farrah85p
 
Boris Shapiro Sustainability Program in NJIT
Boris Shapiro Sustainability Program in NJITBoris Shapiro Sustainability Program in NJIT
Boris Shapiro Sustainability Program in NJIT
Boris Shapiro PE
 
Green Buildings
Green BuildingsGreen Buildings
Green Buildings
Yamini K
 
"Products / Technologies: Lessons Learnt form Radian Retrofit Project" - Paul...
"Products / Technologies: Lessons Learnt form Radian Retrofit Project" - Paul..."Products / Technologies: Lessons Learnt form Radian Retrofit Project" - Paul...
"Products / Technologies: Lessons Learnt form Radian Retrofit Project" - Paul...
Sustainable Business Partnership
 
IOWAN School Design 12 April 2014
IOWAN School Design 12 April 2014 IOWAN School Design 12 April 2014
IOWAN School Design 12 April 2014
Andrea Wheeler
 
Green Building Case Study on TERI,bangalore.
Green Building Case Study on TERI,bangalore.Green Building Case Study on TERI,bangalore.
Green Building Case Study on TERI,bangalore.
Vinay M
 

Similar to Technical Report (20)

Project Information - Gharkey St House
Project Information - Gharkey St HouseProject Information - Gharkey St House
Project Information - Gharkey St House
 
Green Museums Ca Academy A Pope
Green Museums Ca Academy A PopeGreen Museums Ca Academy A Pope
Green Museums Ca Academy A Pope
 
Ashrae isbd poster
Ashrae isbd posterAshrae isbd poster
Ashrae isbd poster
 
2012 ISCN Symposium - Energy Optimization at Central Michigan University 2012
2012 ISCN Symposium - Energy Optimization at Central Michigan University 20122012 ISCN Symposium - Energy Optimization at Central Michigan University 2012
2012 ISCN Symposium - Energy Optimization at Central Michigan University 2012
 
046-057_Monterey Bay
046-057_Monterey Bay046-057_Monterey Bay
046-057_Monterey Bay
 
Collateral Healing Conference Table made from 10% recycled cardboard.
Collateral Healing Conference Table made from 10% recycled cardboard. Collateral Healing Conference Table made from 10% recycled cardboard.
Collateral Healing Conference Table made from 10% recycled cardboard.
 
Case study- Coca Cola Place
Case study- Coca Cola PlaceCase study- Coca Cola Place
Case study- Coca Cola Place
 
COTE Top Ten: Intelligent Design for a Restorative Future
COTE Top Ten: Intelligent Design for a Restorative FutureCOTE Top Ten: Intelligent Design for a Restorative Future
COTE Top Ten: Intelligent Design for a Restorative Future
 
IAED 342-Research Presentation
IAED 342-Research PresentationIAED 342-Research Presentation
IAED 342-Research Presentation
 
George Washington Carver Branch Library- LEED Profile
George Washington Carver Branch Library- LEED Profile George Washington Carver Branch Library- LEED Profile
George Washington Carver Branch Library- LEED Profile
 
Building Science 1: Project 1 G- Tower
Building Science 1: Project 1 G- TowerBuilding Science 1: Project 1 G- Tower
Building Science 1: Project 1 G- Tower
 
Council house 2 sustainable building example
Council house 2 sustainable building exampleCouncil house 2 sustainable building example
Council house 2 sustainable building example
 
BULLITT CENTER, SEATTLE, WASHINGTON.pptx
BULLITT CENTER, SEATTLE, WASHINGTON.pptxBULLITT CENTER, SEATTLE, WASHINGTON.pptx
BULLITT CENTER, SEATTLE, WASHINGTON.pptx
 
Green building Manipal University
Green building  Manipal UniversityGreen building  Manipal University
Green building Manipal University
 
Radnor Middle School sets example in Sustainability
Radnor Middle School sets example in SustainabilityRadnor Middle School sets example in Sustainability
Radnor Middle School sets example in Sustainability
 
Boris Shapiro Sustainability Program in NJIT
Boris Shapiro Sustainability Program in NJITBoris Shapiro Sustainability Program in NJIT
Boris Shapiro Sustainability Program in NJIT
 
Green Buildings
Green BuildingsGreen Buildings
Green Buildings
 
"Products / Technologies: Lessons Learnt form Radian Retrofit Project" - Paul...
"Products / Technologies: Lessons Learnt form Radian Retrofit Project" - Paul..."Products / Technologies: Lessons Learnt form Radian Retrofit Project" - Paul...
"Products / Technologies: Lessons Learnt form Radian Retrofit Project" - Paul...
 
IOWAN School Design 12 April 2014
IOWAN School Design 12 April 2014 IOWAN School Design 12 April 2014
IOWAN School Design 12 April 2014
 
Green Building Case Study on TERI,bangalore.
Green Building Case Study on TERI,bangalore.Green Building Case Study on TERI,bangalore.
Green Building Case Study on TERI,bangalore.
 

Technical Report

  • 1. ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin Technical Report: Performing Arts Center for Hawaii Pacific University, Hawaii Loa Campus May 2015 Summary The aim of this project is to create a performing arts center for Hawaii Pacific University that would keep with Hawaiian values and achieve a LEED Silver certification using local and/or renewable resources. To explore possibilities, eQuest was used to determine the schematics and any potential problems. A two-floor, rectangle minus a corner layout was chosen. The theatre, corresponding rooms, a café and a set of bathrooms would make up the first floor. Classrooms, practice rooms, general offices, and a library complete the second floor. The Centre would be located between the Nursing Annex and the Academic Center and would utilize a green roof on a white roof, local resources, and low-flow fixtures. The café would potentially be located partially outside to take advantage of natural cooling. The green roof would have a water catchment system with pipes leading to rain gardens used for the café. Overall energy use was reduced by 55.8%, from 49,189.58 kWh to 27,465.27 kWh. Water usage changes were calculated to save 667,577.50 liters per year. Introduction Beginning in the early 1990s, Hawaii Pacific College (HPC) began to look into a more environmentally sustainable approach in anticipation to a merger with Hawaii Loa College (HL) to create Hawaii Pacific University (HPU). Historical footprint data indicated that becoming environmentally sustainable would be the best solution in the long run for the school, while holding to the local idea of protecting the `aina from overuse. The planning process has continued well into the 2000s. A draft concept plan was generated in 2007 and a master plan was created in 2008. Several principles were developed during this time (Hawaii Loa Plan for Student Projects): 1. Enhance the quality of education at HPU. 2. Create a campus with residential housing that supports strong teaching and strong learning. 3. Use Hawaiian ideals to build a sustainable campus. Purpose The aim of the project is to develop a performing arts center for the Hawaii Loa campus at Hawaii Pacific University. The goal is to have a performing arts center that conforms to the university’s overall goals of becoming LEED certified at the Silver level while still incorporating a Hawaiian sense of space.
  • 2. ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin Methods To complete the preliminary analysis of possible performing arts center concepts, the computer modeling program eQuest was used. The program allows users to view multiple options before construction begins. The requirements for the performing arts center are as follows: 1. The center will be approximately a total of 25,000 ft2. 2. A 600-seat theatre, with storage rooms, a box office, and dressing rooms 3. General office space 4. A café 5. Classrooms and practice rooms 6. Restrooms 7. An electrical room 8. A library 9. A parking lot 10. Must incorporate using renewable resources. Using the eQuest Schematic Design Wizard, two locations were originally looked at: the lawn between the Academic Center and the Nursing Annex, and the area above the Soccer Field. Two different layouts were also analyzed, a rectangle minus a corner and a trapezoid. The lawn and the rectangle minus a corner shape were chosen for the final design with two floors. A baseline energy calculation was then done to determine how and where adjustments would be done to make the building as sustainable as possible while keeping the design feasible for the school. Once the baseline was completed, room placement was decided. Building materials and products were then chosen. This included the types of windows, doors, lighting. It also included the type of roof needed. The roof was chosen using a green roof calculator from Portland State University, with a growing media depth of 6 inches, leaf area index of 2 and an 80% roof cover. The results were later added to the initial baseline energy usage to calculate sustainable energy usage. Water usage and the products needed were calculated using an indoor water use reduction calculator provided by LEED. Results and Discussion Initial analyses determined that the rectangle minus a corner with two floors is more efficient than a trapezoid with two floors. The shape leaves less awkward space. The building faces north. Ceiling heights were kept at 12 feet for each floor. The breakdown of the Center layout is shown in Table 1. The theatre and its corresponding rooms (except for the general offices) would take up 38% of the Center’s space and is planned to be on the lower floor, along with the café. The general offices, classrooms, and library are planned to be on the second floor. Figure 1 shows an example of the proposed layout. The café may be placed outside on a lanai to increase office space and take advantage of the wind for natural cooling.
  • 3. ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin Baseline Calculations Baseline energy analyses gave us the next steps needed. The initial annual electrical use was 850.44 kWh and the initial gas usage was 164.94 btu, for a total annual energy use of 49,189.58 kWh. Using the LEED-provided water reduction calculator, it was found that normal water use would amount to about 2,190.00 gallons per year for 750 users. Building Envelope Constructions It was decided the roof would be built up and based on a metal frame (>24 in.) with exterior 3 inch polyurethane (R-18) insulation and R-15 batting. The walls would utilize a metal 2x6 24 inch frame with a stucco exterior finish and reclaimed wood or bamboo interior walls. The walls would also have R-2 exterior insulation, R-19 batting, and R-6 1 inch polyurethane interior insulation. The floors would be either ceramic or stone to reduce cooling needs. The ceilings would be lay-in acoustic tiles. Windows would account for 40% of each wall and be 6ft x 8ft. The glass used would be double reflective clear ¼ inch air windows. The doors would be made of opaque, solid core flush wood and be 6ft x 7ft. There would be one set of doors on each side of the building. Lighting Daylight harvesting would be utilized to reduce energy costs. The analysis allowed us to decide to use Dimming: 30% lights with a 50 fc light level. The lights would be turned on 13 hours a day 355 days a year to account for 10 holidays where the building would not be used. Skylights were originally proposed for the top floor. However, building code dictates that only 3% of a roof can have skylights. HVAC Use It was decided that DX coils would be used for heating and cooling. The heat pump would utilize air. The system would be a packaged single zone heat pump with ducted air return. The minimum design flow would be kept at 0.75 cfm/ft2. The cooling unit would be 63 tons with an EER efficiency of 8.20, allowing crankhouse heating. The heating unit with a COP efficiency of 2.90. Roof After using the green rood calculator, we decided on an irrigated green roof on a white roof would produce the best annual savings, of 1860.8 kWh and $228.90. It was also decided that the green roof would also have a water catchment system with pipes leading to rain gardens that provide local produce for the Center’s café. Water Usage The LEED water use reduction calculator was used to determine what kind of faucets and toilets need to be used to save the most energy. Calculations were made using 750 individuals. The baseline flush rate for urinals was 3.80 lpf and the baseline flush rate for toilets was 6.00 lpf. Based off of these numbers the baseline case annual flush volume was 1,750,860.00 liters per
  • 4. ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin year. Low-flow versions reduced the flush rates to 0.5 lpf each for a total of 166,406.25 liters per year. Faucets were also used to calculate needed energy savings. Baseline bathroom faucets had a flow rate of 1.90 lpm/lpc and kitchen faucets had a baseline flow rate of 8.30 lpm/lpc. This amounts to 639,713.55 liters per year of water used. Design restroom faucets had a flow rate 1.5 lpm/lpc, while design kitchen faucets had a flow rate of 2.2 lpm/lpc. The design fixtures reduced the annual flow volume to 501,171.25 liters per year. Final Energy Savings Once all changes were made using the eQuest software, it was found that the changes reduced the total annual energy use from 49,189.58 kWh to 29,326.07 kWh. Electrical energy use was reduced from 850.44 kWh to 622.69 kWh. Annual gas usage was reduced from 164.94 btu to 97.94 btu. This brought the total annual energy use down to 29,326.07 kWh. The green roof savings of 1,860.80 kWh further reduced the total energy use to 27,465.27 kWh. Overall energy use was reduced by 55.8%. Conclusions and Recommendations 1. Solar panels along the back of the Center to reduce energy costs further may be considered. Solar panels were not chosen as part of the final design because of the amount of rain Kaneohe typically gets throughout the day. 2. Possibly use Save Water Bricks as a building material. The bricks filter water through holes that provide water ways from the roof to the ground to eliminate the need for pipes to transfer water to rain gardens. The bricks are made from fallen leaves and plastic. 3. Overall energy use was reduced by 55.8%, from 49,189.58 kWh to 27,465.27 kWh using eQuest modifications and a green roof. 4. Water usage changes were calculated to save 667,577.50 liters per year.
  • 5. ENVS 4000: Final Project Debbie Durbin Appendix Table 1: Breakdown of Performing Arts Center Layout (25,000 ft2). Item Percentage of 25,000 ft2 Theatre - includes general offices (7%), box office, storage, dressing rooms, stage, and a 600-seat house floor 42% Classrooms - including practice rooms and studios 15% Café 10% Library - includes stacks, reading rooms, storage, circulation area 18% Restrooms 5% Electrical/Mechanical Room 5% Corridors 5% Figure 1: A general layout of the proposed Performing Arts Center. The center would be two floors with a total of 25,000 ft2.