SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Taku Manawa A Community Development Approach in Your Region The New Zealand Human Rights Commission Presents:
“Not about us, without us…”
Goals of this Workshop ,[object Object],• To introduce Taku Manawa ,[object Object]
To examine the underpinning principles of the programme
To evaluate and profile Taku Manawa as a way human rights community development is working,[object Object]
Human Rights  and Community Development Human rights community development is Grassroots Communities HRC Regional Support HRC Government Policy/Planning
A human rights community development approach links two significant practices: Community Development  -  empowering people within their communities to use their skills to address issues that they have identified and to have full participation in the process Human Rights –that which underpins our relationships with others and our functions in society. Human rights and responsibilities make up all aspects of our individual and collective existence
Human Rights Community Development Model
The Human Rights Approach A ‘human rights approach' has been adopted by the Commission as the conceptual base for all aspects of its work.  The Human Rights Approach involves 6 principles:  1.	Linking of decision-making at every level to the agreed human rights norms. 2.	Identification of all the relevant human rights of all involved and, in the case of conflict, the balancing of the various rights to maximise respect for all rights and right-holders, prioritising those of the most vulnerable. 3.	Emphasising the participation of all in decision-making
4.	Accountability for actions and decisions, which allows individuals and groups to express concerns about decisions that affect them adversely. 5.	Non-discrimination through the equal enjoyment of rights and obligations by all. 6.	Empowerment of individuals and groups by encouraging the use of rights as leverage for action and to legitimise their voice in decision-making. The 3 P’s of Human Rights: •	Partnership •	Participation •	Principles
TAKU MANAWA
Taku Manawa/My Human Rights was designed initially by the NZ Human Rights Commission in 2001 as an educational resource for “grassroots” communities In 2003, this initiative was extended to become a human rights community development programme based on adult education principles and practices. The Taku Manawa Human Rights Community Development Programme pilot began in the Bay of Plenty and East Coast of Aotearoa/ New Zealand in July 2003 and has since been implemented in Tai Tokerau Northland, Murihiku Southland and Kirikiriroa Hamilton Its development over the past seven years has been led by the individuals, organisations and communities that have engaged with it.  This constantly evolving process has included an in-depth evaluation of the training, expectations of members and the HRC, and on going work within the community
•	When communities are given knowledge, training and support, they can be empowered to identify, advocate for, and resolve their own human rights issues •Communities are encouraged to  foster human rights approaches in local planning and decision-making
Tairawhiti
Te Tai Tokerau
Murihiku
Kirikiriroa
“Where, after all, do universal human rights begin? In small places, close to home …” (Eleanor Roosevelt) KEY POINTS FROM ALL  TAKU MANAWA PROGRAMMES ,[object Object]
EMPOWERMENT
ACCOUNTABILITY

More Related Content

What's hot

Community radio in india
Community radio in indiaCommunity radio in india
Community radio in india
N.A. Shah Ansari
 
Charles Chikapa : The role of community radio in climate adaptation
Charles Chikapa : The role of community radio in climate adaptationCharles Chikapa : The role of community radio in climate adaptation
Charles Chikapa : The role of community radio in climate adaptationAfricaAdapt
 
COMMUNITY RADIO FOR SOCIAL CHANGE
COMMUNITY RADIO FOR SOCIAL CHANGECOMMUNITY RADIO FOR SOCIAL CHANGE
COMMUNITY RADIO FOR SOCIAL CHANGE
arpitasharma410
 
Community radio
Community radio Community radio
Community radio
Murali Krishnan L
 
Community Television
Community TelevisionCommunity Television
Community Television
CEMCA
 
Every Voice Counts: ASAN's Community Based Research Project
Every Voice Counts: ASAN's Community Based Research ProjectEvery Voice Counts: ASAN's Community Based Research Project
Every Voice Counts: ASAN's Community Based Research Project
podnosh
 
Social Integration Strategy
Social Integration StrategySocial Integration Strategy
Social Integration Strategy
Noel Hatch
 
Content Development Workshop for Community Radio Broadcasters
Content Development Workshop for  Community Radio BroadcastersContent Development Workshop for  Community Radio Broadcasters
Content Development Workshop for Community Radio Broadcasters
Bangladesh NGOs Network for Radio and Communication
 
If We Build It, Will It Last? Capacity Strengthening Through A CCCD Approach_...
If We Build It, Will It Last? Capacity Strengthening Through A CCCD Approach_...If We Build It, Will It Last? Capacity Strengthening Through A CCCD Approach_...
If We Build It, Will It Last? Capacity Strengthening Through A CCCD Approach_...CORE Group
 
Potentials of Community Radio for widening access to information and improvem...
Potentials of Community Radio for widening access to information and improvem...Potentials of Community Radio for widening access to information and improvem...
Potentials of Community Radio for widening access to information and improvem...
Bangladesh NGOs Network for Radio and Communication
 
Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...
Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...
Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...
IFPRI-PIM
 
Community Radio- C.Thatchinamoorthy Agricultural Extension
Community Radio- C.Thatchinamoorthy Agricultural ExtensionCommunity Radio- C.Thatchinamoorthy Agricultural Extension
Community Radio- C.Thatchinamoorthy Agricultural Extension
Private Agriculture College at Tamil Nadu
 
Welcome to Community Involvement SWK2003
Welcome to Community Involvement SWK2003Welcome to Community Involvement SWK2003
Welcome to Community Involvement SWK2003
Tim Curtis
 
Policy Design - Participation
Policy Design - ParticipationPolicy Design - Participation
Policy Design - Participation
Noel Hatch
 
24 march whole area approach for slideshare
24 march whole area approach for slideshare24 march whole area approach for slideshare
24 march whole area approach for slideshare
Lorna Prescott
 
Community Radio for Rural Development in Bangladesh
Community Radio for Rural Development in Bangladesh Community Radio for Rural Development in Bangladesh
Community Radio for Rural Development in Bangladesh
Bangladesh NGOs Network for Radio and Communication
 
Community radio in agriculture
Community radio in agriculture Community radio in agriculture
Community radio in agriculture
Jagriti Rohit
 
Empowering Communiites through Policy Development-The PMB Model
Empowering Communiites through Policy Development-The PMB ModelEmpowering Communiites through Policy Development-The PMB Model
Empowering Communiites through Policy Development-The PMB ModelSulleiman Adediran
 

What's hot (18)

Community radio in india
Community radio in indiaCommunity radio in india
Community radio in india
 
Charles Chikapa : The role of community radio in climate adaptation
Charles Chikapa : The role of community radio in climate adaptationCharles Chikapa : The role of community radio in climate adaptation
Charles Chikapa : The role of community radio in climate adaptation
 
COMMUNITY RADIO FOR SOCIAL CHANGE
COMMUNITY RADIO FOR SOCIAL CHANGECOMMUNITY RADIO FOR SOCIAL CHANGE
COMMUNITY RADIO FOR SOCIAL CHANGE
 
Community radio
Community radio Community radio
Community radio
 
Community Television
Community TelevisionCommunity Television
Community Television
 
Every Voice Counts: ASAN's Community Based Research Project
Every Voice Counts: ASAN's Community Based Research ProjectEvery Voice Counts: ASAN's Community Based Research Project
Every Voice Counts: ASAN's Community Based Research Project
 
Social Integration Strategy
Social Integration StrategySocial Integration Strategy
Social Integration Strategy
 
Content Development Workshop for Community Radio Broadcasters
Content Development Workshop for  Community Radio BroadcastersContent Development Workshop for  Community Radio Broadcasters
Content Development Workshop for Community Radio Broadcasters
 
If We Build It, Will It Last? Capacity Strengthening Through A CCCD Approach_...
If We Build It, Will It Last? Capacity Strengthening Through A CCCD Approach_...If We Build It, Will It Last? Capacity Strengthening Through A CCCD Approach_...
If We Build It, Will It Last? Capacity Strengthening Through A CCCD Approach_...
 
Potentials of Community Radio for widening access to information and improvem...
Potentials of Community Radio for widening access to information and improvem...Potentials of Community Radio for widening access to information and improvem...
Potentials of Community Radio for widening access to information and improvem...
 
Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...
Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...
Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...
 
Community Radio- C.Thatchinamoorthy Agricultural Extension
Community Radio- C.Thatchinamoorthy Agricultural ExtensionCommunity Radio- C.Thatchinamoorthy Agricultural Extension
Community Radio- C.Thatchinamoorthy Agricultural Extension
 
Welcome to Community Involvement SWK2003
Welcome to Community Involvement SWK2003Welcome to Community Involvement SWK2003
Welcome to Community Involvement SWK2003
 
Policy Design - Participation
Policy Design - ParticipationPolicy Design - Participation
Policy Design - Participation
 
24 march whole area approach for slideshare
24 march whole area approach for slideshare24 march whole area approach for slideshare
24 march whole area approach for slideshare
 
Community Radio for Rural Development in Bangladesh
Community Radio for Rural Development in Bangladesh Community Radio for Rural Development in Bangladesh
Community Radio for Rural Development in Bangladesh
 
Community radio in agriculture
Community radio in agriculture Community radio in agriculture
Community radio in agriculture
 
Empowering Communiites through Policy Development-The PMB Model
Empowering Communiites through Policy Development-The PMB ModelEmpowering Communiites through Policy Development-The PMB Model
Empowering Communiites through Policy Development-The PMB Model
 

Viewers also liked

Pacific Languages Framework Factsheet
Pacific Languages Framework FactsheetPacific Languages Framework Factsheet
Pacific Languages Framework Factsheetdiversityforum2011
 
Taking the internet to isolated communities in Aotearoa New Zealand
Taking the internet to isolated communities in Aotearoa New ZealandTaking the internet to isolated communities in Aotearoa New Zealand
Taking the internet to isolated communities in Aotearoa New Zealanddiversityforum2011
 
Quantifying Ethnic Religious Diversity
Quantifying Ethnic Religious DiversityQuantifying Ethnic Religious Diversity
Quantifying Ethnic Religious Diversitydiversityforum2011
 
Settlement and integration outcomes
Settlement and integration outcomesSettlement and integration outcomes
Settlement and integration outcomesdiversityforum2011
 
Feed report powerpoint poverty
Feed report powerpoint povertyFeed report powerpoint poverty
Feed report powerpoint povertymolodetz05
 
The State, Religion and Belief
The State, Religion and BeliefThe State, Religion and Belief
The State, Religion and Beliefdiversityforum2011
 
Poverty Powerpoint for Citizenship
Poverty Powerpoint for CitizenshipPoverty Powerpoint for Citizenship
Poverty Powerpoint for CitizenshipKenneth Tan
 
Economic research on diversity
Economic research on diversityEconomic research on diversity
Economic research on diversitydiversityforum2011
 
Econometrics lecture 1st
Econometrics lecture 1stEconometrics lecture 1st
Econometrics lecture 1stIshaq Ahmad
 
PPT: Can money buy happiness for Belgians?
PPT: Can money buy happiness for Belgians?PPT: Can money buy happiness for Belgians?
PPT: Can money buy happiness for Belgians?
Emily Van de Walle
 

Viewers also liked (13)

Pacific Languages Framework
Pacific Languages FrameworkPacific Languages Framework
Pacific Languages Framework
 
Pacific Languages Framework Factsheet
Pacific Languages Framework FactsheetPacific Languages Framework Factsheet
Pacific Languages Framework Factsheet
 
Taking the internet to isolated communities in Aotearoa New Zealand
Taking the internet to isolated communities in Aotearoa New ZealandTaking the internet to isolated communities in Aotearoa New Zealand
Taking the internet to isolated communities in Aotearoa New Zealand
 
Quantifying Ethnic Religious Diversity
Quantifying Ethnic Religious DiversityQuantifying Ethnic Religious Diversity
Quantifying Ethnic Religious Diversity
 
Settlement and integration outcomes
Settlement and integration outcomesSettlement and integration outcomes
Settlement and integration outcomes
 
Feed report powerpoint poverty
Feed report powerpoint povertyFeed report powerpoint poverty
Feed report powerpoint poverty
 
MOJ-UPR
MOJ-UPR MOJ-UPR
MOJ-UPR
 
The State, Religion and Belief
The State, Religion and BeliefThe State, Religion and Belief
The State, Religion and Belief
 
War on Poverty
War on PovertyWar on Poverty
War on Poverty
 
Poverty Powerpoint for Citizenship
Poverty Powerpoint for CitizenshipPoverty Powerpoint for Citizenship
Poverty Powerpoint for Citizenship
 
Economic research on diversity
Economic research on diversityEconomic research on diversity
Economic research on diversity
 
Econometrics lecture 1st
Econometrics lecture 1stEconometrics lecture 1st
Econometrics lecture 1st
 
PPT: Can money buy happiness for Belgians?
PPT: Can money buy happiness for Belgians?PPT: Can money buy happiness for Belgians?
PPT: Can money buy happiness for Belgians?
 

Similar to Taku Manawa workshop

Ensuring Citizen-led Accountability of the Sustainable Development Goals.
Ensuring Citizen-led Accountability of the Sustainable Development Goals.Ensuring Citizen-led Accountability of the Sustainable Development Goals.
Ensuring Citizen-led Accountability of the Sustainable Development Goals.
Humentum
 
Foundations of cd
Foundations of cdFoundations of cd
Foundations of cd
Dr. Hina Kaynat
 
Lecture-13. Community development.pptx
Lecture-13. Community development.pptxLecture-13. Community development.pptx
Lecture-13. Community development.pptx
Rajaguru S
 
Disability Equality NW buisness plan (Dec 11)
Disability Equality NW buisness plan (Dec 11)Disability Equality NW buisness plan (Dec 11)
Disability Equality NW buisness plan (Dec 11)
Rich Watts
 
Hume Global Learning Village Annual Research Conference
Hume Global Learning Village Annual Research ConferenceHume Global Learning Village Annual Research Conference
Hume Global Learning Village Annual Research Conference
Hume City Council
 
Main aims and objectives of the organisation
Main aims and objectives of the organisationMain aims and objectives of the organisation
Main aims and objectives of the organisation
Aashishkumar Gupta
 
social welfare management presentation by aasim ur rehman
social welfare management presentation by aasim ur rehmansocial welfare management presentation by aasim ur rehman
social welfare management presentation by aasim ur rehman
salvat123
 
Everyday Democracy's Dialogue to Change Process
Everyday Democracy's Dialogue to Change ProcessEveryday Democracy's Dialogue to Change Process
Everyday Democracy's Dialogue to Change Process
Everyday Democracy
 
PPT_The Legal Bases of GAD Implementation.pptx
PPT_The Legal Bases of GAD Implementation.pptxPPT_The Legal Bases of GAD Implementation.pptx
PPT_The Legal Bases of GAD Implementation.pptx
beyaaap
 
Development communication
Development communicationDevelopment communication
Development communication
Asmita Neupane
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Community mobilization
Community mobilizationCommunity mobilization
Community mobilization
monaaboserea
 
The Little Red Car
The Little Red CarThe Little Red Car
Learning Beyond the School Day
Learning Beyond the School DayLearning Beyond the School Day
Learning Beyond the School Day
Everyday Democracy
 
Launch of Evaluation Toolkit / Lansio pecyn cymorth gwerthuso
Launch of Evaluation Toolkit / Lansio pecyn cymorth gwerthusoLaunch of Evaluation Toolkit / Lansio pecyn cymorth gwerthuso
Launch of Evaluation Toolkit / Lansio pecyn cymorth gwerthusoParticipation Cymru
 
Ms Maria Jose Novoa : Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...
Ms Maria Jose Novoa	: Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...Ms Maria Jose Novoa	: Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...
Ms Maria Jose Novoa : Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...
cooperatives
 

Similar to Taku Manawa workshop (20)

Ensuring Citizen-led Accountability of the Sustainable Development Goals.
Ensuring Citizen-led Accountability of the Sustainable Development Goals.Ensuring Citizen-led Accountability of the Sustainable Development Goals.
Ensuring Citizen-led Accountability of the Sustainable Development Goals.
 
Call for evaluations of the Network Debate Program
Call for evaluations of the Network Debate Program Call for evaluations of the Network Debate Program
Call for evaluations of the Network Debate Program
 
Foundations of cd
Foundations of cdFoundations of cd
Foundations of cd
 
Lecture-13. Community development.pptx
Lecture-13. Community development.pptxLecture-13. Community development.pptx
Lecture-13. Community development.pptx
 
Disability Equality NW buisness plan (Dec 11)
Disability Equality NW buisness plan (Dec 11)Disability Equality NW buisness plan (Dec 11)
Disability Equality NW buisness plan (Dec 11)
 
Hume Global Learning Village Annual Research Conference
Hume Global Learning Village Annual Research ConferenceHume Global Learning Village Annual Research Conference
Hume Global Learning Village Annual Research Conference
 
Main aims and objectives of the organisation
Main aims and objectives of the organisationMain aims and objectives of the organisation
Main aims and objectives of the organisation
 
social welfare management presentation by aasim ur rehman
social welfare management presentation by aasim ur rehmansocial welfare management presentation by aasim ur rehman
social welfare management presentation by aasim ur rehman
 
Everyday Democracy's Dialogue to Change Process
Everyday Democracy's Dialogue to Change ProcessEveryday Democracy's Dialogue to Change Process
Everyday Democracy's Dialogue to Change Process
 
Squamish Website
Squamish WebsiteSquamish Website
Squamish Website
 
PPT_The Legal Bases of GAD Implementation.pptx
PPT_The Legal Bases of GAD Implementation.pptxPPT_The Legal Bases of GAD Implementation.pptx
PPT_The Legal Bases of GAD Implementation.pptx
 
Development communication
Development communicationDevelopment communication
Development communication
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
Community mobilization
Community mobilizationCommunity mobilization
Community mobilization
 
The Little Red Car
The Little Red CarThe Little Red Car
The Little Red Car
 
Learning Beyond the School Day
Learning Beyond the School DayLearning Beyond the School Day
Learning Beyond the School Day
 
Funders forum TM
Funders forum TMFunders forum TM
Funders forum TM
 
REMI-Project proposal.
REMI-Project proposal.REMI-Project proposal.
REMI-Project proposal.
 
Launch of Evaluation Toolkit / Lansio pecyn cymorth gwerthuso
Launch of Evaluation Toolkit / Lansio pecyn cymorth gwerthusoLaunch of Evaluation Toolkit / Lansio pecyn cymorth gwerthuso
Launch of Evaluation Toolkit / Lansio pecyn cymorth gwerthuso
 
Ms Maria Jose Novoa : Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...
Ms Maria Jose Novoa	: Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...Ms Maria Jose Novoa	: Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...
Ms Maria Jose Novoa : Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...
 

More from diversityforum2011

Living in New Zealand in your culture, poverty and cultural privilege
Living in New Zealand in your culture, poverty and cultural privilegeLiving in New Zealand in your culture, poverty and cultural privilege
Living in New Zealand in your culture, poverty and cultural privilegediversityforum2011
 
Maori representation in local govt
Maori representation in local govtMaori representation in local govt
Maori representation in local govtdiversityforum2011
 

More from diversityforum2011 (11)

Living in New Zealand in your culture, poverty and cultural privilege
Living in New Zealand in your culture, poverty and cultural privilegeLiving in New Zealand in your culture, poverty and cultural privilege
Living in New Zealand in your culture, poverty and cultural privilege
 
Tracking equality at work
Tracking equality at workTracking equality at work
Tracking equality at work
 
UNICEF
UNICEFUNICEF
UNICEF
 
Structural discrimination
Structural discriminationStructural discrimination
Structural discrimination
 
Pacific languages forum
Pacific languages forumPacific languages forum
Pacific languages forum
 
MOJ- CERD report card
MOJ- CERD report cardMOJ- CERD report card
MOJ- CERD report card
 
Maori representation in local govt
Maori representation in local govtMaori representation in local govt
Maori representation in local govt
 
IMSED research
IMSED researchIMSED research
IMSED research
 
Diversity awards 2011
Diversity awards 2011Diversity awards 2011
Diversity awards 2011
 
Diversity action 2011
Diversity action 2011Diversity action 2011
Diversity action 2011
 
Te Arikinui Tribute
Te Arikinui TributeTe Arikinui Tribute
Te Arikinui Tribute
 

Taku Manawa workshop

  • 1. Taku Manawa A Community Development Approach in Your Region The New Zealand Human Rights Commission Presents:
  • 2. “Not about us, without us…”
  • 3.
  • 4. To examine the underpinning principles of the programme
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7. Human Rights and Community Development Human rights community development is Grassroots Communities HRC Regional Support HRC Government Policy/Planning
  • 8. A human rights community development approach links two significant practices: Community Development - empowering people within their communities to use their skills to address issues that they have identified and to have full participation in the process Human Rights –that which underpins our relationships with others and our functions in society. Human rights and responsibilities make up all aspects of our individual and collective existence
  • 9.
  • 10. Human Rights Community Development Model
  • 11. The Human Rights Approach A ‘human rights approach' has been adopted by the Commission as the conceptual base for all aspects of its work. The Human Rights Approach involves 6 principles: 1. Linking of decision-making at every level to the agreed human rights norms. 2. Identification of all the relevant human rights of all involved and, in the case of conflict, the balancing of the various rights to maximise respect for all rights and right-holders, prioritising those of the most vulnerable. 3. Emphasising the participation of all in decision-making
  • 12. 4. Accountability for actions and decisions, which allows individuals and groups to express concerns about decisions that affect them adversely. 5. Non-discrimination through the equal enjoyment of rights and obligations by all. 6. Empowerment of individuals and groups by encouraging the use of rights as leverage for action and to legitimise their voice in decision-making. The 3 P’s of Human Rights: • Partnership • Participation • Principles
  • 14. Taku Manawa/My Human Rights was designed initially by the NZ Human Rights Commission in 2001 as an educational resource for “grassroots” communities In 2003, this initiative was extended to become a human rights community development programme based on adult education principles and practices. The Taku Manawa Human Rights Community Development Programme pilot began in the Bay of Plenty and East Coast of Aotearoa/ New Zealand in July 2003 and has since been implemented in Tai Tokerau Northland, Murihiku Southland and Kirikiriroa Hamilton Its development over the past seven years has been led by the individuals, organisations and communities that have engaged with it. This constantly evolving process has included an in-depth evaluation of the training, expectations of members and the HRC, and on going work within the community
  • 15. • When communities are given knowledge, training and support, they can be empowered to identify, advocate for, and resolve their own human rights issues •Communities are encouraged to foster human rights approaches in local planning and decision-making
  • 20.
  • 24.
  • 25. • ensuring flexibility to meet changes proposed by participants, • facilitating formal and informal spaces for dialogue, conversation and having fun, • mentoring and supporting facilitators and organisations throughout the project, • brokering relationships between HRC staff and Commissioners and the facilitators that don’t rely on ongoing involvement from the project manager, • sound dialogical processes, • celebrating successes!
  • 26. human rights education creates meaningful and sustainable change – building human rights capability amongst those most vulnerable to human rights violations, and building understanding amongst those most able to violate, or defend, those rights.

Editor's Notes

  1. Introduction of presenters and regions
  2. Read from notes
  3. GROUP WORK: people move around the 6 “Principles” spread around the room on large sheets paper noting how they view these in terms of creating or supporting diversity in practice within their community, workplace etc. Can be discussed 1 at a time.
  4. Read from notes, slide 13
  5. GROUP WORK – Discuss the perceived benefits and/or disadvantages of training local community members to deliver HR support, education and advocacy within their community as opposed to commission representatives. Collate feedback
  6. Representatives to speak on this
  7. Representatives to speak on this
  8. Representatives to speak on this
  9. Representatives to speak on this
  10. GROUPS: In groups, draw own organisation, group, community e.g. local health organisation, council, etc. Apply the 6 Human Rights Principles to the aforementioned “Unfair” practices. Do these principles help solve issues of “unfairness” inequality” “discrimination”?? Do they help support and encourage diversity?Collate
  11. GROUP WORK: Can this programme transfer into other communities represented at the forum? What would work and what could be changed to be more effective in the unique environment of own community? Collate answers and discussion in large group