Tackling Corruption in India


Ritesh Kumar Singh
Mumbai, India

(rk1234.singh@gmail.com)
To ponder

• Do you know what is the size of black economy in India?

• Do you know what was the loss to the exchequer because of 2G
  scam?

• Do you what % of social sector spending actually reaches the
  intended beneficiaries?

• Do you know what’s the latest ranking of India in Corruption
  Perception Index of Transparency International?




                                                            2
The Economics of Corruption

• Corruption adds 10% to the cost of doing business globally and as
  much as 25% to the cost of public procurement (UN Estimation)

• Corruption is like an additional tax which cuts into the profits of
  businesses.

• Corruption restricts the flow of investment, and in extreme
  situations, it drives out businesses from a country and stifles
  economic growth

• Corruption creates black economy and reduces the effectiveness of
  public policies with regards to inflation management and distributive
  justice



                                                                     3
Components of a Typical Anti-corruption
    Strategy
•   A typical two-pronged approach combines preventive and deterrence
    measures to check the incidence of corruption

•   Preventive measures, while promoting transparency are devoid of
    excessive discretionary provisions and leave minimum scope for
    underhand dealing and kickbacks

•   Deterrence, on the other hand focuses on penalizing those found
    guilty of corruption so that taking lessons others do not engage in it

•   An example to distinguish the two approaches is the Right to
    Information (RTI) and Lokpal, the citizen’s ombudsman

•   While measures like RTI prevents corruption by increasing
    transparency, Lokpal deters corruption by penalizing the corrupt



                                                                        4
Genesis of Corruption in India: Market
 Distorting Policies
• In India, the root of corruption lies in market distorting policies which
  induce diversion of public money and creation of vested interests e.g.
  India’s price control and subsidy regime
• Subsidies on food, fuel and fertilizer are often given in the name of the
  poor yet a substantial portion of these are siphoned off by un-intended
  beneficiaries through corrupt means
• Such policies cause increasing subsidy burden and fiscal deficit. It also
  leads to creation of black economy which reduces the effectiveness of
  public policies with regards to inflation management and distributive
  justice
• Discretionary powers in the hands of bureaucrats and politicians being
  misused or favorable policies auctioned for personal gain, has become
  quite common in India as has been seen in the allocation of 2G
  spectrum.



                                                                       5
Thank you

Tackling Corruption In India Ritesh

  • 1.
    Tackling Corruption inIndia Ritesh Kumar Singh Mumbai, India (rk1234.singh@gmail.com)
  • 2.
    To ponder • Doyou know what is the size of black economy in India? • Do you know what was the loss to the exchequer because of 2G scam? • Do you what % of social sector spending actually reaches the intended beneficiaries? • Do you know what’s the latest ranking of India in Corruption Perception Index of Transparency International? 2
  • 3.
    The Economics ofCorruption • Corruption adds 10% to the cost of doing business globally and as much as 25% to the cost of public procurement (UN Estimation) • Corruption is like an additional tax which cuts into the profits of businesses. • Corruption restricts the flow of investment, and in extreme situations, it drives out businesses from a country and stifles economic growth • Corruption creates black economy and reduces the effectiveness of public policies with regards to inflation management and distributive justice 3
  • 4.
    Components of aTypical Anti-corruption Strategy • A typical two-pronged approach combines preventive and deterrence measures to check the incidence of corruption • Preventive measures, while promoting transparency are devoid of excessive discretionary provisions and leave minimum scope for underhand dealing and kickbacks • Deterrence, on the other hand focuses on penalizing those found guilty of corruption so that taking lessons others do not engage in it • An example to distinguish the two approaches is the Right to Information (RTI) and Lokpal, the citizen’s ombudsman • While measures like RTI prevents corruption by increasing transparency, Lokpal deters corruption by penalizing the corrupt 4
  • 5.
    Genesis of Corruptionin India: Market Distorting Policies • In India, the root of corruption lies in market distorting policies which induce diversion of public money and creation of vested interests e.g. India’s price control and subsidy regime • Subsidies on food, fuel and fertilizer are often given in the name of the poor yet a substantial portion of these are siphoned off by un-intended beneficiaries through corrupt means • Such policies cause increasing subsidy burden and fiscal deficit. It also leads to creation of black economy which reduces the effectiveness of public policies with regards to inflation management and distributive justice • Discretionary powers in the hands of bureaucrats and politicians being misused or favorable policies auctioned for personal gain, has become quite common in India as has been seen in the allocation of 2G spectrum. 5
  • 6.