This document summarizes a presentation about choosing project management tools. It discusses the client's initial request for help with their tools, an audit of the client's current process and structure, and a proposed solution using Jira and Confluence. While Jira could meet most of their needs, it has some limitations for scaled agile frameworks. An alternative, VersionOne, is presented that is designed specifically for scaled agile but lacks some of Jira's flexibility and plugins. The document recommends choosing a tool based on the project's specific needs and processes.

1. CIKLUM
CONSULTING
1
How Cossacks have
chosen tools
Ciklum Consulting,
March 26, 2014

2. 2
Purpose of the speech

3. AGENDA
3
• Why listen to me?
• Initial request
• Our approach
• Solution
• Challenges
• Alternative tools

4. 4
Why Listen To Me?
Yuri Kudin
• More than 8 years in IT
• Technical background
• Last few years working with
Distributed Agile teams
• Consulting experience
• Practical experience with Atlassian
products during the last 6 years

5. 5
Client
Automotive parts web shop
• US based
• 400+ people in UA entity
• 30+ people in development unit

6. 6
Initial Request

7. 7
Approach
TOOLS
TRAINING
AUDIT WORKSHOP TOOLS CONFIGURATION
WORKSHOP WITH
THE TEAM

8. 8
Audit & Solution

9. 9
Org and Product Structure
CAT
Catalogues teams Order team
3rd party
Providers
ORDER
IMPORT-EXPORT
3rd party
Providers
INTERNAL
Internal team

10. 10
Project Workflow
Formalization Preparation Development Publishing

11. 11
Backlog Items
Project
Epic
• Story
• Bug
• Technical Debt
• Investigation
• Task
• Technical Task
Product
Project
Task

12. 12
Theory VS Practice
Portfolio
Program
Team
Business
epics
Arch
Epics
Features
Arch
Features
Theory Our Case
High level
epics
Technical
Epics
Stories,
Sub-tasks
Spikes,
Refact. etc
Epics
Stories,
Sub-tasks
Tech Debt,
Tasks

13. 13
Requirements Structure
Confluence
Jira
High level
requirements
Epic
Story
Tech. Task

14. 14
Boards Structure
Epics
Portfolio
Management
Confluence
Team
Team
Team
Link
Team
Parallel Sprints
CAT board ORDERD & INTERNAL board

15. 15
Implementation

16. 16
Confluence

17. 17
Epic workflow

18. 18
Epic workflow

19. 19
Epics Board Status Mapping

20. 20
Epics Board Status Mapping

21. 21
Epics Board

22. 22
Reporting

23. 23
Story workflow

24. 24
Technical task workflow

25. 25
Task Board

26. 26
Task board: Priority issue

27. 27
Sprint Reporting

28. 28
JIRA restrictions in scaled agile
• Challenges with multi-level hierarchy
visualization
• No automated update of linked items
• Limited amount of columns
• Lack out of box reporting for scaled agile

29. 29
Alternative tools

30. 30
JIRA vs V1
JIRA VS V1

31. 31
JIRA vs V1
Advantages
• Suitable for scaled Agile (SAFe
support)
• Out of the box supports all aspects of
Agile Software development
• Great relation visualization
Disadvantages
• Less flexible
• Restriction with reporting (incl. V1
Analytics)
Advantages
• Powerful workflow engine
• Great user experience
• Flexible reporting
• Huge amount of plugins
Disadvantages
• Lack of flexibility in extending items
hierarchy
• Lack of out of box preconfigured
templates

32. 32
Official comparison
• https://www.atlassian.com/software/
jira/agile/agile-comparison#!greenhopper-versionone
• http://www.versionone.com/vs/versionone-vs-altassian-jira-agile/

33. 33
Summary
• Often, a wish to change a tool is a wish
to change a process
• Match tools to the process
• Choose the tool according to needs

34. www.ciklum.com/consulting
34
Yuri Kudin
Technical Consultant
Consulting Office (CSC)
P +38 044 545 77 45 (ext. 2348)
M +38 097 922 76 79
E yuk@ciklum.com
W www.ciklum.com/consulting
S ykudin
We would be glad to answer your questions!
Contacts