The document compares widgets and shortcodes in WordPress, focusing on their purposes and usability. Widgets offer a drag-and-drop interface while shortcodes can be placed in any content area, providing flexibility in content presentation. The talk is aimed at developers and non-developers alike, encouraging audiences to understand and utilize these tools effectively.

1. Shortcodes vs Widgets:
Which one and how?
Amanda Giles
@AmandaGilesNH
http://www.amandagiles.com/blog/shortcodes-vs-widgets/
WordCamp Boston – Aug 23, 2014 - #wcbos

2. Who am I?
• Independent IT Consultant
• WordPress Developer (Themes and Plugins, but mostly themes)
• Run the Seacoast NH WordPress Meetup
• Lover
• Fighter
• Apparently I like playing with PowerPoint…
• Teacher / Trainer

3. And I have cats!

4. Information Gathering…
• Who here has used a widget?
• Who here has created a widget?
• Who has lost hours trying plugin after plugin to
find the “right” widget or shortcode?
• Who here has used a shortcode?
• Who here has created a shortcode?

5. Who is this talk geared towards?
Developers

6. But what if I’m not a
developer?

8. Top 5 Reasons you should stay
(evenifyou’renotadeveloper)
5. Be more likely to use a widgets or shortcodes (if
you haven’t before)
4. Utilize a “create your own shortcode” plugin
3. Convince the plugin developer to modify their
widget or shortcode to address your needs
better
2. Find a widget or shortcode that’s close to your
needs and hire someone to modify it
1. Roll up your sleeves and try your hand at coding a
widget or shortcode

9. What is a widget?
• A way to take inputted criteria from a WordPress user
and convert that to into output for a website visitor.
• Drag and Drop widgets into widget areas under
Appearance > Widgets
• Collect input [criteria] from user via a form
• When website is viewed, content is displayed to a
website visitor

10. Widget Examples

11. What is a shortcode?
• A way to take inputted criteria from a WordPress user
and convert that to into output for a website visitor.
• Typed manually into the post’s TinyMCE editor, typed
into a widget*, or sometimes created via a button in the
TinyMCE Editor.
• Collect input from user via attributes within the
shortcode
• When website is viewed, content is displayed to a
website visitor
• A way to take inputted criteria from a WordPress user
and convert that to into output for a website visitor.
• Typed manually into the post’s TinyMCE editor, typed
into a widget*, or sometimes created via a button in the
TinyMCE Editor.
• Collect input from user via attributes within the
shortcode
• When website is viewed, content is displayed to a
website visitor

12. Shortcode Example

13. Shortcode Example

14. Shortcode Structure
Shortcode structure depends on how the shortcode is written.
Syntax: [shortcode]content[/shortcode]
Example: [email]john@doe.com[/email]
Syntax: [shortcode attribute=“value”]
Example: [email address=“john@doe.com”]
Syntax: [shortcode attribute=“value”]content[/shortcode]
Example: [email class=“contactme”]john@doe.com[/shortcode]

15. Why create your own
shortcodes and widgets?

16. But seriously…
Widgets and shortcodes are ways to
control the content and/or presentation
while giving the user choices about that
content, location, and even presentation.

17. A good widget or shortcode should…
For Users:
Anticipate what choices or variations
the user might want
For Developers:
Offer ways to adjust the
output where feasible

18. What does that mean?
• Offer choices to filter what content shows
• Offer choices about what parts of that content
are shown
• Offer style choices
• Provide basic clean styling or no styling
• Be sure to tag elements with id/class so styles
can be addressed to specific elements
• Use hooks to allow filtering/altering of output
(for developers)

19. Widgets vs Shortcodes
+ Drag and Drop
+ Easy and Intuitive UI
+ Can include descriptive text
- Not very intuitive to use
- Typos are their downfall
- No visible guidance
- Only put them in widget
areas
- Can’t copy them
- More coding
+ Put them in any content
area (including in widget
areas)
+ Easily copy them
+ Less coding

20. Anatomy of a Widget
1. Declaration/Contruct
Tell WordPress some information about your widget and how to identify it
2. User Interface / Form
Define the form that will gather user's choices about the widget instance
3. Update/Save Logic
Save the user's choices about the widget instance
4. Widget Display Logic
Display the widget instance to the website visitor
5. Register the Widget
Tell WordPress to register your widget and include it on the
Appearance > Widgets page

21. Widget Code Structure

22. On to the code!

23. Anatomy of a Shortcode
1. Shortcode function
Interprets the shortcode attributes and content and “returns” the output
2. Register the Shortcode function
Tell WordPress to register your shortcode so that it will be
interpreted when used.

25. Widgets vs Shortcodes
+ Drag and Drop
+ Easy and Intuitive UI
+ Can include descriptive text
- Not very intuitive to use
- Typos are their downfall
- No visible guidance
- Only put them in widget
areas
- Can’t copy them
- More coding
+ Put them anywhere
(including in widget areas)
+ Easily copy them
+ Less coding

26. Questions?

27. Thank You!
Find these slides and all related files at:
http://www.amandagiles.com/blog/shortcodes-vs-widgets/
www.AmandaGiles.com
@AmandaGilesNH on Twitter
amanda@amandagiles.com – Please feel free to send me
feedback or questions