SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Sec 3 -4 Critical Assessment of the
         Economic Model
  The Private Property Defense
• Second defense of the economic model:
  appeals to the rights of private owners than to
  the alleged beneficial consequences of
  markets.
  – Manager: obligation to maximize profits because
    their employers, owners of corporation want. Any
    alternative is an illegitimate restriction on the
    property rights of the owner.
     • Ex. If Walmart manager decided to pay higher health
       care benefits to employees than was necessary to
       attract workers, they would be misallocating corporate
       fund.
• Two significant challenges to this defense of
  economic model
  – 1st Challenge: Property rights are not absolute
     • Ones right to use property is constrained by the right of
       others
        – I can´t use my gun to shoot you
        – Zoning laws: property right are restricted for the common
          good.
            » I can´t use my home as business because of the
              residential zoning in my neighborhood prohibits such
              commercial uses.
     • Defender would argue: the use of private property in
       pursuit of profits will always override other competing
       goods and other rights if they are to successfully defend
       the principle that business managers ought always
       pursue profits for stockholders.
– Second challenge: questions understanding of stockholders
   • Stockholders are granted limited legal liability for the acts of their
     corporate property.
       – This protects stockholders from losing their personal property in judgments
         against their corporation.
       – Corporate ownership may not include all of the right and privileges that are
         included with ownership of personal property. The connection between
         ownership and control that exists for personal property does not legally exist
         for corporate property.
            » Malden Mill: owned by Aaron Feuerstein and his family.
            » Stock ownership in publicly traded corporations, Enron and
               Walmart, might be divided among millions of shares of stock
                  • Stockholders are investors
                        • Invest with hope of maximizing the return on their
                          investment.
       – Corporations need capital by investors and labor supplied by
         employees, material provided by suppliers, etc,
            » Market pressures managers
                  • provide high return to investors
                  • High salary and benefit package to keep qualified employees.
            » If investors disagree with managerial decisions, move their capital
               elsewhere.
            » If employees disagree with managerial decision, they move their labor
               force.
• Friedman: obeying the law is the only
  legitimate constraint on the pursuit of profit.
  – Corporations have ethics programs and ethics
    officers.
  – Corporate ethics is identified with obedience to
    the law
  – The perspective that compliance to the law is
    sufficient for ethical responsibility relies on a
    misleading understanding of the law
     • Law is ambiguous: in many cases it simply is not clear
       what the law requires, business mangers will often face
       decisions that will rely on their ethical judgments

More Related Content

What's hot

Corporate social responsibility: The policy debate
Corporate social responsibility: The policy debateCorporate social responsibility: The policy debate
Corporate social responsibility: The policy debate
Stephen Bainbridge
 
chapter03
 chapter03 chapter03
chapter03
Denish Vaniyawala
 
Shareholder Activism in the United States: Managing Shareholder Interventions
Shareholder Activism in the United States: Managing Shareholder InterventionsShareholder Activism in the United States: Managing Shareholder Interventions
Shareholder Activism in the United States: Managing Shareholder Interventions
Stephen Bainbridge
 
Friedman vs Carroll, Social responsibility and Ethics in Strategic Management
Friedman vs Carroll, Social responsibility and Ethics in Strategic ManagementFriedman vs Carroll, Social responsibility and Ethics in Strategic Management
Friedman vs Carroll, Social responsibility and Ethics in Strategic Management
Adepitan Fasoro
 
Ethical investment
Ethical investmentEthical investment
Ethical investment
Mohamed_Hamdy_Hafez
 
Good morning
Good morningGood morning
Good morning
Deepak Sharma
 
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & OutsourcingFriedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
Andrew Olsen
 
Chap7 business org & mgt
Chap7 business org & mgtChap7 business org & mgt
Chap7 business org & mgt
mmvidanes29
 
Protecting Yourself Against Product Liability
Protecting Yourself Against Product LiabilityProtecting Yourself Against Product Liability
Protecting Yourself Against Product Liability
Mark Klingman
 
An Introduction to Benefit Corporations
An Introduction to Benefit CorporationsAn Introduction to Benefit Corporations
An Introduction to Benefit Corporations
Stephen Bainbridge
 
Issues in international business
Issues in international businessIssues in international business
Issues in international business
Biswa Mall
 
Corporate Sustainability - Theoretical Framework
Corporate Sustainability - Theoretical FrameworkCorporate Sustainability - Theoretical Framework
Corporate Sustainability - Theoretical Framework
Dayana Mastura FCCA CA
 
Forms of Business Organizations
Forms of Business Organizations Forms of Business Organizations
Forms of Business Organizations
Venkat. P
 
Business studies for grade 10
Business studies for grade 10Business studies for grade 10
Business studies for grade 10
babyakhona
 
Director versus Shareholder Primacy in New Zealand Company Law as Compared to...
Director versus Shareholder Primacy in New Zealand Company Law as Compared to...Director versus Shareholder Primacy in New Zealand Company Law as Compared to...
Director versus Shareholder Primacy in New Zealand Company Law as Compared to...
Stephen Bainbridge
 
Stakeholders
StakeholdersStakeholders
Stakeholders
Parth Kakadia
 
Chapter 4 review
Chapter 4 reviewChapter 4 review
Chapter 4 review
pejansen
 
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposalsRevitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
Stephen Bainbridge
 
Chapter # 10
Chapter # 10Chapter # 10
Unit 1.2 types of organizations
Unit 1.2 types of organizationsUnit 1.2 types of organizations
Unit 1.2 types of organizations
MrRicketts
 

What's hot (20)

Corporate social responsibility: The policy debate
Corporate social responsibility: The policy debateCorporate social responsibility: The policy debate
Corporate social responsibility: The policy debate
 
chapter03
 chapter03 chapter03
chapter03
 
Shareholder Activism in the United States: Managing Shareholder Interventions
Shareholder Activism in the United States: Managing Shareholder InterventionsShareholder Activism in the United States: Managing Shareholder Interventions
Shareholder Activism in the United States: Managing Shareholder Interventions
 
Friedman vs Carroll, Social responsibility and Ethics in Strategic Management
Friedman vs Carroll, Social responsibility and Ethics in Strategic ManagementFriedman vs Carroll, Social responsibility and Ethics in Strategic Management
Friedman vs Carroll, Social responsibility and Ethics in Strategic Management
 
Ethical investment
Ethical investmentEthical investment
Ethical investment
 
Good morning
Good morningGood morning
Good morning
 
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & OutsourcingFriedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
Friedman vs Carroll Corporate Social Responsibility & Outsourcing
 
Chap7 business org & mgt
Chap7 business org & mgtChap7 business org & mgt
Chap7 business org & mgt
 
Protecting Yourself Against Product Liability
Protecting Yourself Against Product LiabilityProtecting Yourself Against Product Liability
Protecting Yourself Against Product Liability
 
An Introduction to Benefit Corporations
An Introduction to Benefit CorporationsAn Introduction to Benefit Corporations
An Introduction to Benefit Corporations
 
Issues in international business
Issues in international businessIssues in international business
Issues in international business
 
Corporate Sustainability - Theoretical Framework
Corporate Sustainability - Theoretical FrameworkCorporate Sustainability - Theoretical Framework
Corporate Sustainability - Theoretical Framework
 
Forms of Business Organizations
Forms of Business Organizations Forms of Business Organizations
Forms of Business Organizations
 
Business studies for grade 10
Business studies for grade 10Business studies for grade 10
Business studies for grade 10
 
Director versus Shareholder Primacy in New Zealand Company Law as Compared to...
Director versus Shareholder Primacy in New Zealand Company Law as Compared to...Director versus Shareholder Primacy in New Zealand Company Law as Compared to...
Director versus Shareholder Primacy in New Zealand Company Law as Compared to...
 
Stakeholders
StakeholdersStakeholders
Stakeholders
 
Chapter 4 review
Chapter 4 reviewChapter 4 review
Chapter 4 review
 
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposalsRevitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
 
Chapter # 10
Chapter # 10Chapter # 10
Chapter # 10
 
Unit 1.2 types of organizations
Unit 1.2 types of organizationsUnit 1.2 types of organizations
Unit 1.2 types of organizations
 

Viewers also liked

Sec 5 6
Sec 5 6Sec 5 6
Sec 5 6
dzhasbun
 
Sec 5 1
Sec 5 1Sec 5 1
Sec 5 1
dzhasbun
 
Sec 5 2
Sec 5 2Sec 5 2
Sec 5 2
dzhasbun
 
Sec 5 3
Sec 5 3Sec 5 3
Sec 5 3
dzhasbun
 
Sec 5 5
Sec 5 5Sec 5 5
Sec 5 5
dzhasbun
 
Chapter 5 case study
Chapter 5 case studyChapter 5 case study
Chapter 5 case study
dzhasbun
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch6
Desjardins5e ppt ch6Desjardins5e ppt ch6
Desjardins5e ppt ch6
oudesign
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch3
Desjardins5e ppt ch3Desjardins5e ppt ch3
Desjardins5e ppt ch3
oudesign
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch2
Desjardins5e ppt ch2Desjardins5e ppt ch2
Desjardins5e ppt ch2
oudesign
 
Ch 2 sec 2 1 and 2-2
Ch 2 sec 2 1 and 2-2Ch 2 sec 2 1 and 2-2
Ch 2 sec 2 1 and 2-2
dzhasbun
 
Sec 2 5
Sec 2 5Sec 2 5
Sec 2 5
dzhasbun
 
Sec 2 4
Sec 2 4Sec 2 4
Sec 2 4
dzhasbun
 
Sec 2 6
Sec 2 6Sec 2 6
Sec 2 6
dzhasbun
 
Sec 2 3
Sec 2 3Sec 2 3
Sec 2 3
dzhasbun
 
Mod 1 notes
Mod 1 notesMod 1 notes
Mod 1 notes
mverm1
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch4
Desjardins5e ppt ch4Desjardins5e ppt ch4
Desjardins5e ppt ch4
oudesign
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch8
Desjardins5e ppt ch8Desjardins5e ppt ch8
Desjardins5e ppt ch8
oudesign
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch9
Desjardins5e ppt ch9Desjardins5e ppt ch9
Desjardins5e ppt ch9
oudesign
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch10
Desjardins5e ppt ch10Desjardins5e ppt ch10
Desjardins5e ppt ch10
oudesign
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch11
Desjardins5e ppt ch11Desjardins5e ppt ch11
Desjardins5e ppt ch11
oudesign
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Sec 5 6
Sec 5 6Sec 5 6
Sec 5 6
 
Sec 5 1
Sec 5 1Sec 5 1
Sec 5 1
 
Sec 5 2
Sec 5 2Sec 5 2
Sec 5 2
 
Sec 5 3
Sec 5 3Sec 5 3
Sec 5 3
 
Sec 5 5
Sec 5 5Sec 5 5
Sec 5 5
 
Chapter 5 case study
Chapter 5 case studyChapter 5 case study
Chapter 5 case study
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch6
Desjardins5e ppt ch6Desjardins5e ppt ch6
Desjardins5e ppt ch6
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch3
Desjardins5e ppt ch3Desjardins5e ppt ch3
Desjardins5e ppt ch3
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch2
Desjardins5e ppt ch2Desjardins5e ppt ch2
Desjardins5e ppt ch2
 
Ch 2 sec 2 1 and 2-2
Ch 2 sec 2 1 and 2-2Ch 2 sec 2 1 and 2-2
Ch 2 sec 2 1 and 2-2
 
Sec 2 5
Sec 2 5Sec 2 5
Sec 2 5
 
Sec 2 4
Sec 2 4Sec 2 4
Sec 2 4
 
Sec 2 6
Sec 2 6Sec 2 6
Sec 2 6
 
Sec 2 3
Sec 2 3Sec 2 3
Sec 2 3
 
Mod 1 notes
Mod 1 notesMod 1 notes
Mod 1 notes
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch4
Desjardins5e ppt ch4Desjardins5e ppt ch4
Desjardins5e ppt ch4
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch8
Desjardins5e ppt ch8Desjardins5e ppt ch8
Desjardins5e ppt ch8
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch9
Desjardins5e ppt ch9Desjardins5e ppt ch9
Desjardins5e ppt ch9
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch10
Desjardins5e ppt ch10Desjardins5e ppt ch10
Desjardins5e ppt ch10
 
Desjardins5e ppt ch11
Desjardins5e ppt ch11Desjardins5e ppt ch11
Desjardins5e ppt ch11
 

Similar to Sec 3 4

U0404.pdf
U0404.pdfU0404.pdf
U0404.pdf
sandy735877
 
Prof. Eilís Ferran, FOI Roundtable presentation - 16 October 2013
Prof. Eilís Ferran, FOI Roundtable presentation - 16 October 2013Prof. Eilís Ferran, FOI Roundtable presentation - 16 October 2013
Prof. Eilís Ferran, FOI Roundtable presentation - 16 October 2013
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Ch 1.pptx
Ch 1.pptxCh 1.pptx
Ch 1.pptx
MinhHi89
 
Confidentiality, Conflicts of interest & occupational Crime
Confidentiality, Conflicts of interest & occupational CrimeConfidentiality, Conflicts of interest & occupational Crime
Confidentiality, Conflicts of interest & occupational Crime
srirenga
 
Boatright ch11
Boatright ch11Boatright ch11
Boatright ch11
LinaAlzate9
 
Mba1034 cg law ethics week 2 corporate governance intro
Mba1034 cg law ethics week 2 corporate governance  introMba1034 cg law ethics week 2 corporate governance  intro
Mba1034 cg law ethics week 2 corporate governance intro
Stephen Ong
 
Individual & firm
Individual & firmIndividual & firm
Individual & firm
Ayesha Shoukat
 
chapter08
chapter08chapter08
Foss Vs Harbottle
Foss Vs HarbottleFoss Vs Harbottle
Foss Vs Harbottle
ShakariMurug
 
Stakeholder organization stout 5 6 from carly
Stakeholder organization stout 5 6 from carlyStakeholder organization stout 5 6 from carly
Stakeholder organization stout 5 6 from carly
Jordi Comas
 
Carmen Theriault - Trustees - Directors of Private Companies: Which Hat Rules?
Carmen Theriault - Trustees - Directors of Private Companies: Which Hat Rules?Carmen Theriault - Trustees - Directors of Private Companies: Which Hat Rules?
Carmen Theriault - Trustees - Directors of Private Companies: Which Hat Rules?
Estate Planning Council of Abbotsford
 
Management Liability Coverage
Management Liability CoverageManagement Liability Coverage
Management Liability Coverage
iRisk.info
 
Bcu msc cg week 1 intro
Bcu msc cg week 1  introBcu msc cg week 1  intro
Bcu msc cg week 1 intro
Stephen Ong
 
Insurance Coverage for Management Mess-ups
Insurance Coverage for Management Mess-upsInsurance Coverage for Management Mess-ups
Insurance Coverage for Management Mess-ups
iRisk.info
 
Chapter 3 copy.ppt
Chapter 3 copy.pptChapter 3 copy.ppt
Chapter 3 copy.ppt
WilliamLopezFlores2
 
Velasquez_C8.pdf
Velasquez_C8.pdfVelasquez_C8.pdf
Velasquez_C8.pdf
ShaniaEricka
 
Business revision- AQA
Business revision- AQABusiness revision- AQA
Business revision- AQA
anicholls1234
 
CH6.pptx
CH6.pptxCH6.pptx
CH6.pptx
ssuser1e8a26
 
BUS 116 Chap027 corporate governance
BUS 116 Chap027 corporate governanceBUS 116 Chap027 corporate governance
BUS 116 Chap027 corporate governance
neogenesis6
 
Introduction to finance.pptx
Introduction to finance.pptxIntroduction to finance.pptx
Introduction to finance.pptx
MdMohanUddin
 

Similar to Sec 3 4 (20)

U0404.pdf
U0404.pdfU0404.pdf
U0404.pdf
 
Prof. Eilís Ferran, FOI Roundtable presentation - 16 October 2013
Prof. Eilís Ferran, FOI Roundtable presentation - 16 October 2013Prof. Eilís Ferran, FOI Roundtable presentation - 16 October 2013
Prof. Eilís Ferran, FOI Roundtable presentation - 16 October 2013
 
Ch 1.pptx
Ch 1.pptxCh 1.pptx
Ch 1.pptx
 
Confidentiality, Conflicts of interest & occupational Crime
Confidentiality, Conflicts of interest & occupational CrimeConfidentiality, Conflicts of interest & occupational Crime
Confidentiality, Conflicts of interest & occupational Crime
 
Boatright ch11
Boatright ch11Boatright ch11
Boatright ch11
 
Mba1034 cg law ethics week 2 corporate governance intro
Mba1034 cg law ethics week 2 corporate governance  introMba1034 cg law ethics week 2 corporate governance  intro
Mba1034 cg law ethics week 2 corporate governance intro
 
Individual & firm
Individual & firmIndividual & firm
Individual & firm
 
chapter08
chapter08chapter08
chapter08
 
Foss Vs Harbottle
Foss Vs HarbottleFoss Vs Harbottle
Foss Vs Harbottle
 
Stakeholder organization stout 5 6 from carly
Stakeholder organization stout 5 6 from carlyStakeholder organization stout 5 6 from carly
Stakeholder organization stout 5 6 from carly
 
Carmen Theriault - Trustees - Directors of Private Companies: Which Hat Rules?
Carmen Theriault - Trustees - Directors of Private Companies: Which Hat Rules?Carmen Theriault - Trustees - Directors of Private Companies: Which Hat Rules?
Carmen Theriault - Trustees - Directors of Private Companies: Which Hat Rules?
 
Management Liability Coverage
Management Liability CoverageManagement Liability Coverage
Management Liability Coverage
 
Bcu msc cg week 1 intro
Bcu msc cg week 1  introBcu msc cg week 1  intro
Bcu msc cg week 1 intro
 
Insurance Coverage for Management Mess-ups
Insurance Coverage for Management Mess-upsInsurance Coverage for Management Mess-ups
Insurance Coverage for Management Mess-ups
 
Chapter 3 copy.ppt
Chapter 3 copy.pptChapter 3 copy.ppt
Chapter 3 copy.ppt
 
Velasquez_C8.pdf
Velasquez_C8.pdfVelasquez_C8.pdf
Velasquez_C8.pdf
 
Business revision- AQA
Business revision- AQABusiness revision- AQA
Business revision- AQA
 
CH6.pptx
CH6.pptxCH6.pptx
CH6.pptx
 
BUS 116 Chap027 corporate governance
BUS 116 Chap027 corporate governanceBUS 116 Chap027 corporate governance
BUS 116 Chap027 corporate governance
 
Introduction to finance.pptx
Introduction to finance.pptxIntroduction to finance.pptx
Introduction to finance.pptx
 

More from dzhasbun

Ch. 1 Sec 1-7 and 1-8
Ch. 1 Sec 1-7 and 1-8Ch. 1 Sec 1-7 and 1-8
Ch. 1 Sec 1-7 and 1-8
dzhasbun
 
Ch 1 sec 1 6
Ch 1 sec 1 6Ch 1 sec 1 6
Ch 1 sec 1 6
dzhasbun
 
Ch. 1 sec 1- 5
Ch. 1 sec 1- 5Ch. 1 sec 1- 5
Ch. 1 sec 1- 5
dzhasbun
 
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
dzhasbun
 
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
dzhasbun
 
Ch.1 sec 1 2
Ch.1 sec 1 2Ch.1 sec 1 2
Ch.1 sec 1 2
dzhasbun
 
Ch. 1 sec 1 1
Ch. 1 sec 1 1Ch. 1 sec 1 1
Ch. 1 sec 1 1
dzhasbun
 

More from dzhasbun (7)

Ch. 1 Sec 1-7 and 1-8
Ch. 1 Sec 1-7 and 1-8Ch. 1 Sec 1-7 and 1-8
Ch. 1 Sec 1-7 and 1-8
 
Ch 1 sec 1 6
Ch 1 sec 1 6Ch 1 sec 1 6
Ch 1 sec 1 6
 
Ch. 1 sec 1- 5
Ch. 1 sec 1- 5Ch. 1 sec 1- 5
Ch. 1 sec 1- 5
 
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
 
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
Ch. 1 sec 1 3 and 1-4
 
Ch.1 sec 1 2
Ch.1 sec 1 2Ch.1 sec 1 2
Ch.1 sec 1 2
 
Ch. 1 sec 1 1
Ch. 1 sec 1 1Ch. 1 sec 1 1
Ch. 1 sec 1 1
 

Sec 3 4

  • 1. Sec 3 -4 Critical Assessment of the Economic Model The Private Property Defense
  • 2. • Second defense of the economic model: appeals to the rights of private owners than to the alleged beneficial consequences of markets. – Manager: obligation to maximize profits because their employers, owners of corporation want. Any alternative is an illegitimate restriction on the property rights of the owner. • Ex. If Walmart manager decided to pay higher health care benefits to employees than was necessary to attract workers, they would be misallocating corporate fund.
  • 3. • Two significant challenges to this defense of economic model – 1st Challenge: Property rights are not absolute • Ones right to use property is constrained by the right of others – I can´t use my gun to shoot you – Zoning laws: property right are restricted for the common good. » I can´t use my home as business because of the residential zoning in my neighborhood prohibits such commercial uses. • Defender would argue: the use of private property in pursuit of profits will always override other competing goods and other rights if they are to successfully defend the principle that business managers ought always pursue profits for stockholders.
  • 4. – Second challenge: questions understanding of stockholders • Stockholders are granted limited legal liability for the acts of their corporate property. – This protects stockholders from losing their personal property in judgments against their corporation. – Corporate ownership may not include all of the right and privileges that are included with ownership of personal property. The connection between ownership and control that exists for personal property does not legally exist for corporate property. » Malden Mill: owned by Aaron Feuerstein and his family. » Stock ownership in publicly traded corporations, Enron and Walmart, might be divided among millions of shares of stock • Stockholders are investors • Invest with hope of maximizing the return on their investment. – Corporations need capital by investors and labor supplied by employees, material provided by suppliers, etc, » Market pressures managers • provide high return to investors • High salary and benefit package to keep qualified employees. » If investors disagree with managerial decisions, move their capital elsewhere. » If employees disagree with managerial decision, they move their labor force.
  • 5. • Friedman: obeying the law is the only legitimate constraint on the pursuit of profit. – Corporations have ethics programs and ethics officers. – Corporate ethics is identified with obedience to the law – The perspective that compliance to the law is sufficient for ethical responsibility relies on a misleading understanding of the law • Law is ambiguous: in many cases it simply is not clear what the law requires, business mangers will often face decisions that will rely on their ethical judgments