Atlantic Council
“Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies”
Washington, D.C. - September 9, 2013
Southern Company Perspectives on Energy R&D
Randall Rush
GM, Gasification Technology
Southern Company R&D Attributes
“Learn by Doing”
• Centrally located research engineers
and scientists
• Laboratories dispersed across
operating assets
• Active collaboration with utilities,
universities, vendors
• Heavily leveraged by external funding
partners
• Intellectual property positions that
do not impede technology
deployment
• Research portfolio provides hardened
technology options delivered in close
cooperation with in-house
Operations and EPC capability
DOE/Southern Company R&D Project Timeline
1970 2013
Solvent Refined Coal
Advanced Coal Cleaning
100 MW Chiyoda Demo
SCR Pilot Plant
Switchgrass Co-Firing
Advanced T-Fired Burner
DOE/EPRI Coal Quality Expert
Activated
Carbon Injection
SECARB CO2 Injection
Citronelle CO2 Injection
SECARB Phase IIIIDMS
GenVARR
Stack Water
Recovery
PSDF
NCCC
Activated Carbon Injection
MerCAP
Scrubber Additives
Low Temperature
Oxidation Catalysts
CCPI 3 CCS Demo
Kemper
IGCC- CCPI
Advanced Wall-Fired Burner
2010-2018
2007-Present
Development
1-10 MWe
Demonstration
10-100+ MWe
Commercial
250 MWe +
Research
< 0.1 MWe
Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting
from DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership
Development
1-10 MWe
Demonstration
10-100+ MWe
Commercial
250 MWe +
SCR systems
FGD systems
Baghouse w/ activated
carbon
Research
< 0.1 MWe
Carbon Dioxide
(Capture & Storage)
Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting
from DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership
Low NOx burners
Confidential and Proprietary
Development
1-10 MWe
Demonstration
10-100+ MWe
Commercial
250 MWe +
SCR systems
Crist Clean Coal Project
1992-1995
9 MW
SEI Birchwood 1996
250 MW
18,000 MW
8,000 MW
FGD systems Scholz 1978
23 MW
Yates Clean Coal
1992
100 MW
Baghouse w/ activated
carbon
Miller 1995
1 MW
Gaston 2&3 1996 &
2001 2*250 MW
Research
< 0.1 MWe
Carbon Dioxide
(Capture & Storage)
Daniel 2009
SECARB II
3000 tons
Barry 500 tpd
2011 - 2014
25MW
Citronelle
2009 - 2020
SECARB III
100k tpy
National
Carbon
Capture Center
Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting
from DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership
Industry
Southern
100,000 MW
11,000 MW
8,000 MW*
1,600 MW
• Denotes estimate
• provided by EPRI
500 MW
325,000 MW
22,000 MW
Low NOx burners
Hammond Clean Coal
1991
500 MWSmith Clean Coal
1992
180 MW
Kemper
3 MM tpd
2014 - 2054
584 MW
Confidential and Proprietary
Development
1-10 MWe
Demonstration
10-100+ MWe
Commercial
250 MWe +
SCR systems
Crist Clean Coal Project
1992-1995
9 MW
SEI Birchwood 1996
250 MW
18,000 MW
8,000 MW
FGD systems Scholz 1978
23 MW
Yates Clean Coal
1992
100 MW
Baghouse w/ activated
carbon
Miller 1995
1 MW
Gaston 2&3 1996 &
2001 2*250 MW
Research
< 0.1 MWe
Carbon Dioxide
(Capture & Storage)
Daniel 2009
SECARB II
3000 tons
Barry 500 tpd
2011 - 2014
25MW
Citronelle
2009 - 2020
SECARB III
100k tpy
National
Carbon
Capture Center
Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting
from DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership
Industry
Southern
100,000 MW
11,000 MW
8,000 MW*
1,600 MW
• Denotes estimate
• provided by EPRI
500 MW
325,000 MW
22,000 MW
Low NOx burners
Hammond Clean Coal
1991
500 MWSmith Clean Coal
1992
180 MW
Kemper
3 MM tpd
2014 - 2054
584 MW
Confidential and Proprietary
Development
1-10 MWe
Demonstration
10-100+ MWe
Commercial
250 MWe +
SCR systems
Crist Clean Coal Project
1992-1995
9 MW
SEI Birchwood 1996
250 MW
18,000 MW
8,000 MW
FGD systems Scholz 1978
23 MW
Yates Clean Coal
1992
100 MW
Baghouse w/ activated
carbon
Miller 1995
1 MW
Gaston 2&3 1996 &
2001 2*250 MW
Research
< 0.1 MWe
Carbon Dioxide
(Capture & Storage)
Daniel 2009
SECARB II
3000 tons
Barry 500 tpd
2011 - 2014
25MW
Citronelle
2009 - 2020
SECARB III
100k tpy
National
Carbon
Capture Center
Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting from
DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership
Industry
Southern
100,000 MW
11,000 MW
8,000 MW*
1,600 MW
• Denotes estimate
• provided by EPRI
Kemper
3 MM tpd
2014 - 2054
584 MW
500 MW
325,000 MW
22,000 MW
Low NOx burners
Hammond Clean Coal
1991
500 MWSmith Clean Coal
1992
180 MW
R&D Portfolio: Carbon Capture and Storage
Coal Seam Injection Study
Pilot Capture Demo
Groundwater Impacts Study
Underground Carbon Injection
1 MW Solid Sorbent Pilot
Kemper County IGCC
Geologic Suitability Study
National Carbon Capture Center
University Training Program
Biomineralization Study
UAB Cap Rock Lab
25 MW CCS
R&D Portfolio: Carbon Capture and Storage
Coal Seam Injection Study
Pilot Capture Demo
Groundwater Impacts Study
Underground Carbon Injection
1 MW Solid Sorbent Pilot
Kemper County IGCC
Geologic Suitability Study
National Carbon Capture Center
University Training Program
Biomineralization Study
UAB Cap Rock Lab
25 MW CCS
25 MW CCS Demo
Integrated CO2 capture, compression, pipeline transportation, and geologic sequestration
• 90% CO2 capture
• Integrated Operations August 2012
• 171,400 tons of CO2 captured , 78,100
tons injected
•
Plant Barry
National Carbon Capture Center
Project Partners
National Carbon Capture Center
Partial List of Technology Suppliers
Development of the Transport Coal Gasifier for
Power and Chemical Production
TRIGTM Leverages Long History of Fluid Catalytic Cracking (FCC) Expertise
Late
30's
1942
1951
Early
1960's
1976
1980's 1990 1996 1996 China 2011 USA 2014
First
Commercial
FCC Unit
for Exxon
Orthoflow™
A Design
Orthoflow™
C Design
Resid
FCCs
Orthoflow™ F
Design
Design Based on
FCC Technology
Pilot Plant
Tech Center
Grand Forks, ND
2,600 Hours Test Run
PSDF at Wilsonville, AL.
>19,000 hrs in
gasification including
>3,000 hrs on Miss.
Lignite thru Aug‘13
TRIGTM In Kemper
County, MS, USA
Kemper County IGCC
Plant SitePlant Site
Test results from the NCCC allow
~40MW more output than would
have been possible from higher
Steam/CO ratios required in
refinery applications
• 15+ years of development at the NCCC
• 524MW on syngas w/ 65+% CO2 capture
• CO2 & other emissions ~equal to NG
• 3 MM TPY CO2 for EOR
• Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD) plus treated effluent
from City of Meridian, MS and moisture from coal
drying as makeup water
Kemper County IGCC
DOE/Southern Company R&D Project Timeline
1970 2013
Solvent Refined Coal
Advanced Coal Cleaning
100 MW Chiyoda Demo
SCR Pilot Plant
Switchgrass Co-Firing
Advanced T-Fired Burner
DOE/EPRI Coal Quality Expert
Activated
Carbon Injection
SECARB CO2 Injection
Citronelle CO2 Injection
SECARB Phase IIIIDMS
GenVARR
Stack Water
Recovery
PSDF
NCCC
Activated Carbon Injection
MerCAP
Scrubber Additives
Low Temperature
Oxidation Catalysts
CCPI 3 CCS Demo
Kemper
IGCC- CCPI
Advanced Wall-Fired Burner
2010-2018
2007-Present
Southern Company’s
Diverse Generation Portfolio
Potential 2020 Range
Average Actual Low Gas Price High Gas Price
‘07-’08 2012 High Coal Price Low Coal Price
Natural Gas 16% 45% 57% 34%
Coal 69% 36% 22% 45%
Nuclear & Other 15% 19% 21% 21%
Generation Mix by Fuel Source
The reliability of our generation fleet and the flexibility to utilize the least
expensive fuel source keeps retail prices low and less volatile
National Carbon Capture Center
Wilsonville, Alabama
Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle
Mississippi Power Plant Ratcliffe
Second Largest U.S. Solar
Cimarron Solar Facility
Largest U.S. Biomass
Nacogdoches Generating Facility
Mercury Research Center
Gulf Power Plant Crist
25-MW CCS
Alabama Power Plant Barry
Water Research Center
Georgia Power Plant Bowen
Power Delivery and End-Use
Technology Lab
U.S. first New Nuclear
Georgia Power Plant Vogtle
Smart Grid: Integrated Distribution
Management System
Air Quality Science Center
SEARCH network; ARIES; mercury
Savannah Seaport Electrification
All-electric Crane Demonstration
Campo Verde Solar Facility
Imperial County, California
Apex Solar Facility
North Las Vegas, Nevada
Spectrum Solar Facility
Clark County, Nevada
Granville Solar Facility
Granville County, North Carolina
R&D Delivers Benefits to the Industry
Recent Southern Company Projects with R&D Foundations
National Carbon Capture Center
Wilsonville, Alabama
Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle
Mississippi Power Plant Ratcliffe
Second Largest U.S. Solar
Cimarron Solar Facility
Largest U.S. Biomass
Nacogdoches Generating Facility
Mercury Research Center
Gulf Power Plant Crist
25-MW CCS
Alabama Power Plant Barry
Water Research Center
Georgia Power Plant Bowen
Power Delivery and End-Use
Technology Lab
U.S. first New Nuclear
Georgia Power Plant Vogtle
Smart Grid: Integrated Distribution
Management System
Air Quality Science Center
SEARCH network; ARIES; mercury
Savannah Seaport Electrification
All-electric Crane Demonstration
Campo Verde Solar Facility
Imperial County, California
Apex Solar Facility
North Las Vegas, Nevada
Spectrum Solar Facility
Clark County, Nevada
Granville Solar Facility
Granville County, North Carolina
R&D Delivers Benefits to the Industry
Recent Southern Company Projects with R&D Foundations Non-Coal Focus
Benefits from Investments in Clean Coal Technology
+183%
-82%
-88%
Sources: EPA National Air Pollutant Emission Trends
EIA Annual Energy Review
-96%
Coal-fired Generation Emission Rates
Between 1970 and 2008 U.S. SO2, NOx, and particulate
emissions from coal-fired electric power plants were
reduced by 82 to 96%, while coal-fired generation almost
doubled.
Between 1990 and 2010 Southern Company’s SO2, NOx,
and mercury emissions from coal-fired electric power
plants were reduced by 60 to 80%, while coal-fired
generation increased by 40%.

Advanced Fossil Energy Technologies: Presentation by Southern Company

  • 1.
    Atlantic Council “Advanced FossilEnergy Technologies” Washington, D.C. - September 9, 2013 Southern Company Perspectives on Energy R&D Randall Rush GM, Gasification Technology
  • 2.
    Southern Company R&DAttributes “Learn by Doing” • Centrally located research engineers and scientists • Laboratories dispersed across operating assets • Active collaboration with utilities, universities, vendors • Heavily leveraged by external funding partners • Intellectual property positions that do not impede technology deployment • Research portfolio provides hardened technology options delivered in close cooperation with in-house Operations and EPC capability
  • 3.
    DOE/Southern Company R&DProject Timeline 1970 2013 Solvent Refined Coal Advanced Coal Cleaning 100 MW Chiyoda Demo SCR Pilot Plant Switchgrass Co-Firing Advanced T-Fired Burner DOE/EPRI Coal Quality Expert Activated Carbon Injection SECARB CO2 Injection Citronelle CO2 Injection SECARB Phase IIIIDMS GenVARR Stack Water Recovery PSDF NCCC Activated Carbon Injection MerCAP Scrubber Additives Low Temperature Oxidation Catalysts CCPI 3 CCS Demo Kemper IGCC- CCPI Advanced Wall-Fired Burner 2010-2018 2007-Present
  • 4.
    Development 1-10 MWe Demonstration 10-100+ MWe Commercial 250MWe + Research < 0.1 MWe Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting from DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership
  • 5.
    Development 1-10 MWe Demonstration 10-100+ MWe Commercial 250MWe + SCR systems FGD systems Baghouse w/ activated carbon Research < 0.1 MWe Carbon Dioxide (Capture & Storage) Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting from DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership Low NOx burners
  • 6.
    Confidential and Proprietary Development 1-10MWe Demonstration 10-100+ MWe Commercial 250 MWe + SCR systems Crist Clean Coal Project 1992-1995 9 MW SEI Birchwood 1996 250 MW 18,000 MW 8,000 MW FGD systems Scholz 1978 23 MW Yates Clean Coal 1992 100 MW Baghouse w/ activated carbon Miller 1995 1 MW Gaston 2&3 1996 & 2001 2*250 MW Research < 0.1 MWe Carbon Dioxide (Capture & Storage) Daniel 2009 SECARB II 3000 tons Barry 500 tpd 2011 - 2014 25MW Citronelle 2009 - 2020 SECARB III 100k tpy National Carbon Capture Center Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting from DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership Industry Southern 100,000 MW 11,000 MW 8,000 MW* 1,600 MW • Denotes estimate • provided by EPRI 500 MW 325,000 MW 22,000 MW Low NOx burners Hammond Clean Coal 1991 500 MWSmith Clean Coal 1992 180 MW Kemper 3 MM tpd 2014 - 2054 584 MW
  • 7.
    Confidential and Proprietary Development 1-10MWe Demonstration 10-100+ MWe Commercial 250 MWe + SCR systems Crist Clean Coal Project 1992-1995 9 MW SEI Birchwood 1996 250 MW 18,000 MW 8,000 MW FGD systems Scholz 1978 23 MW Yates Clean Coal 1992 100 MW Baghouse w/ activated carbon Miller 1995 1 MW Gaston 2&3 1996 & 2001 2*250 MW Research < 0.1 MWe Carbon Dioxide (Capture & Storage) Daniel 2009 SECARB II 3000 tons Barry 500 tpd 2011 - 2014 25MW Citronelle 2009 - 2020 SECARB III 100k tpy National Carbon Capture Center Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting from DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership Industry Southern 100,000 MW 11,000 MW 8,000 MW* 1,600 MW • Denotes estimate • provided by EPRI 500 MW 325,000 MW 22,000 MW Low NOx burners Hammond Clean Coal 1991 500 MWSmith Clean Coal 1992 180 MW Kemper 3 MM tpd 2014 - 2054 584 MW
  • 8.
    Confidential and Proprietary Development 1-10MWe Demonstration 10-100+ MWe Commercial 250 MWe + SCR systems Crist Clean Coal Project 1992-1995 9 MW SEI Birchwood 1996 250 MW 18,000 MW 8,000 MW FGD systems Scholz 1978 23 MW Yates Clean Coal 1992 100 MW Baghouse w/ activated carbon Miller 1995 1 MW Gaston 2&3 1996 & 2001 2*250 MW Research < 0.1 MWe Carbon Dioxide (Capture & Storage) Daniel 2009 SECARB II 3000 tons Barry 500 tpd 2011 - 2014 25MW Citronelle 2009 - 2020 SECARB III 100k tpy National Carbon Capture Center Coal-based Technology Development Directly Resulting from DOE/Southern Company R&D Partnership Industry Southern 100,000 MW 11,000 MW 8,000 MW* 1,600 MW • Denotes estimate • provided by EPRI Kemper 3 MM tpd 2014 - 2054 584 MW 500 MW 325,000 MW 22,000 MW Low NOx burners Hammond Clean Coal 1991 500 MWSmith Clean Coal 1992 180 MW
  • 9.
    R&D Portfolio: CarbonCapture and Storage Coal Seam Injection Study Pilot Capture Demo Groundwater Impacts Study Underground Carbon Injection 1 MW Solid Sorbent Pilot Kemper County IGCC Geologic Suitability Study National Carbon Capture Center University Training Program Biomineralization Study UAB Cap Rock Lab 25 MW CCS
  • 10.
    R&D Portfolio: CarbonCapture and Storage Coal Seam Injection Study Pilot Capture Demo Groundwater Impacts Study Underground Carbon Injection 1 MW Solid Sorbent Pilot Kemper County IGCC Geologic Suitability Study National Carbon Capture Center University Training Program Biomineralization Study UAB Cap Rock Lab 25 MW CCS
  • 11.
    25 MW CCSDemo Integrated CO2 capture, compression, pipeline transportation, and geologic sequestration • 90% CO2 capture • Integrated Operations August 2012 • 171,400 tons of CO2 captured , 78,100 tons injected • Plant Barry
  • 12.
    National Carbon CaptureCenter Project Partners
  • 13.
    National Carbon CaptureCenter Partial List of Technology Suppliers
  • 14.
    Development of theTransport Coal Gasifier for Power and Chemical Production TRIGTM Leverages Long History of Fluid Catalytic Cracking (FCC) Expertise Late 30's 1942 1951 Early 1960's 1976 1980's 1990 1996 1996 China 2011 USA 2014 First Commercial FCC Unit for Exxon Orthoflow™ A Design Orthoflow™ C Design Resid FCCs Orthoflow™ F Design Design Based on FCC Technology Pilot Plant Tech Center Grand Forks, ND 2,600 Hours Test Run PSDF at Wilsonville, AL. >19,000 hrs in gasification including >3,000 hrs on Miss. Lignite thru Aug‘13 TRIGTM In Kemper County, MS, USA
  • 15.
    Kemper County IGCC PlantSitePlant Site Test results from the NCCC allow ~40MW more output than would have been possible from higher Steam/CO ratios required in refinery applications • 15+ years of development at the NCCC • 524MW on syngas w/ 65+% CO2 capture • CO2 & other emissions ~equal to NG • 3 MM TPY CO2 for EOR • Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD) plus treated effluent from City of Meridian, MS and moisture from coal drying as makeup water
  • 16.
  • 17.
    DOE/Southern Company R&DProject Timeline 1970 2013 Solvent Refined Coal Advanced Coal Cleaning 100 MW Chiyoda Demo SCR Pilot Plant Switchgrass Co-Firing Advanced T-Fired Burner DOE/EPRI Coal Quality Expert Activated Carbon Injection SECARB CO2 Injection Citronelle CO2 Injection SECARB Phase IIIIDMS GenVARR Stack Water Recovery PSDF NCCC Activated Carbon Injection MerCAP Scrubber Additives Low Temperature Oxidation Catalysts CCPI 3 CCS Demo Kemper IGCC- CCPI Advanced Wall-Fired Burner 2010-2018 2007-Present
  • 18.
    Southern Company’s Diverse GenerationPortfolio Potential 2020 Range Average Actual Low Gas Price High Gas Price ‘07-’08 2012 High Coal Price Low Coal Price Natural Gas 16% 45% 57% 34% Coal 69% 36% 22% 45% Nuclear & Other 15% 19% 21% 21% Generation Mix by Fuel Source The reliability of our generation fleet and the flexibility to utilize the least expensive fuel source keeps retail prices low and less volatile
  • 19.
    National Carbon CaptureCenter Wilsonville, Alabama Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle Mississippi Power Plant Ratcliffe Second Largest U.S. Solar Cimarron Solar Facility Largest U.S. Biomass Nacogdoches Generating Facility Mercury Research Center Gulf Power Plant Crist 25-MW CCS Alabama Power Plant Barry Water Research Center Georgia Power Plant Bowen Power Delivery and End-Use Technology Lab U.S. first New Nuclear Georgia Power Plant Vogtle Smart Grid: Integrated Distribution Management System Air Quality Science Center SEARCH network; ARIES; mercury Savannah Seaport Electrification All-electric Crane Demonstration Campo Verde Solar Facility Imperial County, California Apex Solar Facility North Las Vegas, Nevada Spectrum Solar Facility Clark County, Nevada Granville Solar Facility Granville County, North Carolina R&D Delivers Benefits to the Industry Recent Southern Company Projects with R&D Foundations
  • 20.
    National Carbon CaptureCenter Wilsonville, Alabama Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle Mississippi Power Plant Ratcliffe Second Largest U.S. Solar Cimarron Solar Facility Largest U.S. Biomass Nacogdoches Generating Facility Mercury Research Center Gulf Power Plant Crist 25-MW CCS Alabama Power Plant Barry Water Research Center Georgia Power Plant Bowen Power Delivery and End-Use Technology Lab U.S. first New Nuclear Georgia Power Plant Vogtle Smart Grid: Integrated Distribution Management System Air Quality Science Center SEARCH network; ARIES; mercury Savannah Seaport Electrification All-electric Crane Demonstration Campo Verde Solar Facility Imperial County, California Apex Solar Facility North Las Vegas, Nevada Spectrum Solar Facility Clark County, Nevada Granville Solar Facility Granville County, North Carolina R&D Delivers Benefits to the Industry Recent Southern Company Projects with R&D Foundations Non-Coal Focus
  • 21.
    Benefits from Investmentsin Clean Coal Technology +183% -82% -88% Sources: EPA National Air Pollutant Emission Trends EIA Annual Energy Review -96% Coal-fired Generation Emission Rates Between 1970 and 2008 U.S. SO2, NOx, and particulate emissions from coal-fired electric power plants were reduced by 82 to 96%, while coal-fired generation almost doubled. Between 1990 and 2010 Southern Company’s SO2, NOx, and mercury emissions from coal-fired electric power plants were reduced by 60 to 80%, while coal-fired generation increased by 40%.