Robin Rice & Jeff HaywoodUniversity of EdinburghIDCC, Chicago, 20101Research Data Management (RDM) Initiatives at the                                   University of Edinburgh
Pressure  for changeResearch funders seeking to add valuePublishers responding to demand Public wanting access to publicly funded dataUniversities reluctant to step up to challenge?2Wwarby on flickr
Overview & contextData Library services and projectsInformation Services initiativesResearch Data Storage working groupResearch Data Management Policy consultationNext steps3
Data Library Services and projectsData Library serviceEdinburgh DataShareJISC-funded projects DISC-UK DataShare (2007-2009)Data Audit Framework Implementation (2008)Research Data MANTRA (2010-2011)4
5What is a data library? A data library refers to both the content and the services that foster use of collections of numeric, audio-visual, textual or geospatial data sets for secondary use in research. Focus on re-use of data
Data Library Service at UoEfinding…accessing …using …teaching …6iStock Photo, ChartsBin and mkandlez on flickr
Web guidanceMore recent focus on support for managing one’s dataOnline suite of web pages for IS website developed in 2009http://www.ed.ac.uk/is/data-management7
Data repository service for staff8
DISC-UK DataShare projectPiloted institutional data repositories at Edinburgh, Oxford & Southampton Uni’sThree different models on 3 open source repository platforms9
10
11
DAF projectsRecommendation to JISC:	“JISC should develop a Data Audit Framework to enable all universities and colleges to carry out an audit of departmental data collections ...” Liz Lyon (2007). Dealing with Data: Roles, Rights, Responsibilities and Relationships
Findings from 5 DAF case studiesStorage provision often insufficientLong retention periods needed for high value dataAd-hoc practices; no formal data mgmt plans Lack of standardised procedures in creating and storing dataMinimal metadata; much effort expended in finding extant data on servers13European Parliament on flickr
Research Data MANTRA (MANagementTRAining)Open online learning materials in RDM for postgrads and early career researchersGrounded in three disciplines, working with graduate schoolsVideo stories from senior researchers to augment web-based ‘chapters’Data handling exercises in four software analysis packages. 14.ash on flickr
Information Services initiativesThe RDS group identified types of data storage requirements and features that an effective University-wide storage service should offer. The RDM group drafted a university policy for managing research data, taking account of increasing funding agency demands for compliance, the open access agenda, and the shared responsibilities of the university and principal investigators.	The Vice Principal for KM established two strategic working groups:WG on RDS (storage)WG on RDM (mgmt)15Photo courtesy Orange County Archives
Finding the storage ‘sweet spot’Globally accessible cross-platform file storeAuthentication, authorisation & accessBackup and synchingArchivingFederated data storage solutionCentralisation & trustNetwork of support16Quasimondo on flickr
Events influencing the RDM groupRecent adoption of the Code of Practice for Research (UK Research Integrity Office, 2009)  by the university’s research office, obligating the institution to provide support for retention and access to data underlying published research.‘Climategate’ email review at East Anglia University highlighting the reputational risk and legal accountability associated with staff not being forthcoming in response to Freedom of Information (FOI) requests for data from the public. 17
Draft University data policy (1 of 2)Commitment to research excellence includes RDM throughout lifecycleThe University should provide training, support and advice, as well as mechanisms and services for storage, backup, registration, deposit and retentionNew research proposals should explicitly address data capture, management, integrity, confidentiality, retention, sharing and publicationResponsibility for plan and sound data mgmt is with PIs18Litherland on flickr
Draft University data policy (2 of 2)Research data management plans must ensure that research data is available for access and re-use where appropriate and under appropriate safeguards.The legitimate interests of the subjects of research data must be protected.Research data of future historical interest, and all research data that represent records of the University, including data that substantiate research findings, should be offered and assessed for deposit and retention in an appropriate national or international data service or domain repository, or a University repository.19Steve Rhode on flickr
End of story ... To be continuedThis month, the leaders of the two working groups are meeting with the Vice Principal to review outcome of consultation and determine next steps.Thank you!Robin.Rice@ed.ac.uk & Jeff.Haywood@ed.ac.uk20

Research Data Management Initiatives at the University of Edinburgh

  • 1.
    Robin Rice &Jeff HaywoodUniversity of EdinburghIDCC, Chicago, 20101Research Data Management (RDM) Initiatives at the University of Edinburgh
  • 2.
    Pressure forchangeResearch funders seeking to add valuePublishers responding to demand Public wanting access to publicly funded dataUniversities reluctant to step up to challenge?2Wwarby on flickr
  • 3.
    Overview & contextDataLibrary services and projectsInformation Services initiativesResearch Data Storage working groupResearch Data Management Policy consultationNext steps3
  • 4.
    Data Library Servicesand projectsData Library serviceEdinburgh DataShareJISC-funded projects DISC-UK DataShare (2007-2009)Data Audit Framework Implementation (2008)Research Data MANTRA (2010-2011)4
  • 5.
    5What is adata library? A data library refers to both the content and the services that foster use of collections of numeric, audio-visual, textual or geospatial data sets for secondary use in research. Focus on re-use of data
  • 6.
    Data Library Serviceat UoEfinding…accessing …using …teaching …6iStock Photo, ChartsBin and mkandlez on flickr
  • 7.
    Web guidanceMore recentfocus on support for managing one’s dataOnline suite of web pages for IS website developed in 2009http://www.ed.ac.uk/is/data-management7
  • 8.
  • 9.
    DISC-UK DataShare projectPilotedinstitutional data repositories at Edinburgh, Oxford & Southampton Uni’sThree different models on 3 open source repository platforms9
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
    DAF projectsRecommendation toJISC: “JISC should develop a Data Audit Framework to enable all universities and colleges to carry out an audit of departmental data collections ...” Liz Lyon (2007). Dealing with Data: Roles, Rights, Responsibilities and Relationships
  • 13.
    Findings from 5DAF case studiesStorage provision often insufficientLong retention periods needed for high value dataAd-hoc practices; no formal data mgmt plans Lack of standardised procedures in creating and storing dataMinimal metadata; much effort expended in finding extant data on servers13European Parliament on flickr
  • 14.
    Research Data MANTRA(MANagementTRAining)Open online learning materials in RDM for postgrads and early career researchersGrounded in three disciplines, working with graduate schoolsVideo stories from senior researchers to augment web-based ‘chapters’Data handling exercises in four software analysis packages. 14.ash on flickr
  • 15.
    Information Services initiativesTheRDS group identified types of data storage requirements and features that an effective University-wide storage service should offer. The RDM group drafted a university policy for managing research data, taking account of increasing funding agency demands for compliance, the open access agenda, and the shared responsibilities of the university and principal investigators. The Vice Principal for KM established two strategic working groups:WG on RDS (storage)WG on RDM (mgmt)15Photo courtesy Orange County Archives
  • 16.
    Finding the storage‘sweet spot’Globally accessible cross-platform file storeAuthentication, authorisation & accessBackup and synchingArchivingFederated data storage solutionCentralisation & trustNetwork of support16Quasimondo on flickr
  • 17.
    Events influencing theRDM groupRecent adoption of the Code of Practice for Research (UK Research Integrity Office, 2009) by the university’s research office, obligating the institution to provide support for retention and access to data underlying published research.‘Climategate’ email review at East Anglia University highlighting the reputational risk and legal accountability associated with staff not being forthcoming in response to Freedom of Information (FOI) requests for data from the public. 17
  • 18.
    Draft University datapolicy (1 of 2)Commitment to research excellence includes RDM throughout lifecycleThe University should provide training, support and advice, as well as mechanisms and services for storage, backup, registration, deposit and retentionNew research proposals should explicitly address data capture, management, integrity, confidentiality, retention, sharing and publicationResponsibility for plan and sound data mgmt is with PIs18Litherland on flickr
  • 19.
    Draft University datapolicy (2 of 2)Research data management plans must ensure that research data is available for access and re-use where appropriate and under appropriate safeguards.The legitimate interests of the subjects of research data must be protected.Research data of future historical interest, and all research data that represent records of the University, including data that substantiate research findings, should be offered and assessed for deposit and retention in an appropriate national or international data service or domain repository, or a University repository.19Steve Rhode on flickr
  • 20.
    End of story... To be continuedThis month, the leaders of the two working groups are meeting with the Vice Principal to review outcome of consultation and determine next steps.Thank you!Robin.Rice@ed.ac.uk & Jeff.Haywood@ed.ac.uk20

Editor's Notes

  • #3 The pressure brought to bear on researchers to improve their data management and data sharing practice has come from research funders seeking to add value to expensive research and solve cross-disciplinary grand challenges; publishers seeking to be responsive to calls for transparency and reproducability of the scientific record; and the public seeking to gain and re-use knowledge for their own purposes using new online tools. Higher education institutions have been rather reluctant to assert their role in either incentivising or supporting their academic staff in meeting these more demanding requirements for research practice
  • #6 A data library is normally part of a larger institution (academic, corporate, scientific, medical, governmental, etc.) established to serve the data users of that organisation.
  • #16 The outcome of the RDM document is a draft university policy for managing research data, taking account of increasing funding agency demands for compliance, the open access agenda, and the shared responsibilities of the university and principal investigators. The RDS document identifies the types of data that need storage and the features that an effective University-wide storage service would need to offer. The staff effort and hardware/software implications of the documents are substantial and a joint implementation plan will be key to their effectiveness.