This document discusses the application of Lev Vygotsky's sociocultural theory to second language acquisition (SLA). It outlines two key concepts from Vygotsky's theory - that social and cognitive processes are interrelated, and the zone of proximal development (ZPD). Regarding the first concept, social interaction plays a fundamental role in cognitive development. Learning occurs through transforming external social processes into internal cognitive processes. Regarding the ZPD, it represents the gap between independent problem-solving and problem-solving assisted by a more capable peer, and provides the conditions necessary for learning. The document analyzes how these concepts can be applied to interpreting SLA research and minimizing the gap between learners' first and second language proficiencies
Socio-cultural perspectives on second language learning faisal khallab
Language Learning In Social TermsTarget language interactions can not be viewed as a source of input for autonomous and internal learning mechanisms.
James Lantolf is the foremost figure advocating the relevance of socio -cultural theory to SLL
Lev Semeonovich Vygotksy & Jean Piaget (Language & Child Development)Mediation and mediated learningLanguage as a tool of taught
Learning is a mediated process
Learning is socially mediated
Face –to- face interaction &shared processes
This document provides an overview of sociocultural theory (SCT) perspectives on second language acquisition (SLA). Key points of SCT include: language learning occurs through social interactions; the zone of proximal development explains how learners internalize new structures with assistance; and internalization is how learners move from other-regulation to self-regulation. SCT views language as a cultural tool that mediates thinking. Methodologies like the genetic and microgenetic methods examine language development over time in social contexts. SCT challenges notions of universal acquisition orders and sequences.
1. Socio-cultural theory views learning as a social process where knowledge is constructed through interaction. The teacher assists students to reach beyond their capabilities through scaffolding and joint problem-solving within the zone of proximal development.
2. Language is seen as a cultural tool for thinking and social interaction. Learning occurs first through social interaction then becomes internalized.
3. Effective pedagogy based on this theory includes collaborative learning, scaffolding to provide optimal challenge and support, and discovery learning through problem-solving and meaningful tasks.
This document defines key concepts in sociocultural theory and its application to second language acquisition (SLA). It discusses culture, community, identity, and how learning occurs through participation in communities of practice. Sociocultural theory views SLA as a social process influenced by cultural and historical contexts. Implications include better understanding power dynamics and reconceptualizing good language learners as agents who invest in language. Limitations include little research in foreign language contexts versus immigrant contexts.
The document discusses the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, which claims that the grammatical structures of a language influence how its speakers think and perceive the world. It makes a strong claim that speakers of a language with certain distinctions will perceive relevant differences more readily. A weak claim is that speakers with words to describe certain things will find it easier to talk about them. The document also states that a language both helps its speakers perceive the world in certain ways, but also limits such perception, and that different languages lead to different world views.
Reference, Sense, and Referring Expression in SemanticsErsa Dewana
This document discusses reference, sense, and referring expressions in semantics. It defines semantics as the study of meaning in language. Reference deals with the relationship between language and the world, while sense deals with relationships inside language. There are two types of reference: variable reference, where a word can refer to different things, and constant reference, where a word always refers to the same thing. Sense is the place of an expression in a system of semantic relationships with other expressions. A referring expression is any expression used to refer to something, and can be indefinite or definite depending on the context. Opaque contexts and equative sentences are also discussed in relation to referring expressions.
Socio-cultural perspectives on second language learning faisal khallab
Language Learning In Social TermsTarget language interactions can not be viewed as a source of input for autonomous and internal learning mechanisms.
James Lantolf is the foremost figure advocating the relevance of socio -cultural theory to SLL
Lev Semeonovich Vygotksy & Jean Piaget (Language & Child Development)Mediation and mediated learningLanguage as a tool of taught
Learning is a mediated process
Learning is socially mediated
Face –to- face interaction &shared processes
This document provides an overview of sociocultural theory (SCT) perspectives on second language acquisition (SLA). Key points of SCT include: language learning occurs through social interactions; the zone of proximal development explains how learners internalize new structures with assistance; and internalization is how learners move from other-regulation to self-regulation. SCT views language as a cultural tool that mediates thinking. Methodologies like the genetic and microgenetic methods examine language development over time in social contexts. SCT challenges notions of universal acquisition orders and sequences.
1. Socio-cultural theory views learning as a social process where knowledge is constructed through interaction. The teacher assists students to reach beyond their capabilities through scaffolding and joint problem-solving within the zone of proximal development.
2. Language is seen as a cultural tool for thinking and social interaction. Learning occurs first through social interaction then becomes internalized.
3. Effective pedagogy based on this theory includes collaborative learning, scaffolding to provide optimal challenge and support, and discovery learning through problem-solving and meaningful tasks.
This document defines key concepts in sociocultural theory and its application to second language acquisition (SLA). It discusses culture, community, identity, and how learning occurs through participation in communities of practice. Sociocultural theory views SLA as a social process influenced by cultural and historical contexts. Implications include better understanding power dynamics and reconceptualizing good language learners as agents who invest in language. Limitations include little research in foreign language contexts versus immigrant contexts.
The document discusses the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, which claims that the grammatical structures of a language influence how its speakers think and perceive the world. It makes a strong claim that speakers of a language with certain distinctions will perceive relevant differences more readily. A weak claim is that speakers with words to describe certain things will find it easier to talk about them. The document also states that a language both helps its speakers perceive the world in certain ways, but also limits such perception, and that different languages lead to different world views.
Reference, Sense, and Referring Expression in SemanticsErsa Dewana
This document discusses reference, sense, and referring expressions in semantics. It defines semantics as the study of meaning in language. Reference deals with the relationship between language and the world, while sense deals with relationships inside language. There are two types of reference: variable reference, where a word can refer to different things, and constant reference, where a word always refers to the same thing. Sense is the place of an expression in a system of semantic relationships with other expressions. A referring expression is any expression used to refer to something, and can be indefinite or definite depending on the context. Opaque contexts and equative sentences are also discussed in relation to referring expressions.
An Introduction to Applied Linguistics part 2Samira Rahmdel
The document discusses the scope and definition of applied linguistics. It begins by stating that applied linguistics is not exclusively about language teaching, but also involves other fields that utilize linguistic knowledge like speech therapy, literary criticism, and communications engineering. It then distinguishes applied linguistics as an activity rather than a theoretical study, using linguistic findings to address practical problems. Finally, it maps out the scope of applied linguistics by classifying its areas of study into three categories: language and education, language, work, and law, and language, information, and effect. Several examples are provided for each category to illustrate the broad and diverse range of activities to which applied linguistics is relevant.
The psychological basis of contrastive analysissara_galastarxy
The psychological basis of contrastive analysis is transfer theory. Transfer theory hypothesizes that prior learning affects subsequent learning. There are three paradigms - A, B, and C - that describe how transfer occurs between a first and second language based on the similarity and differences of stimuli and responses. Paradigm A involves the same formal devices used for different purposes, paradigm B involves different formal devices for the same meaning, and paradigm C has no similarities and is not useful for contrastive analysis. Contrastive analysis uses a behaviorist stimulus-response model of psychology but two cognitivist alternatives are cross-association and the ignorance hypothesis. The ignorance hypothesis has weaknesses as it does not account for learners being exposed to the target language
This document discusses context and co-text in language. It defines context as the circumstances and audience that influence the meaning communicated by a speaker or writer. It also discusses reference as using linguistic forms like pronouns or definite articles to identify something, and how reference relies on shared knowledge between the speaker and listener. Finally, it explains how inference, collaboration between communicators, and pragmatic connections within a sociocultural community are necessary to understand references in context.
This document discusses equivalence and non-equivalence in translation. It begins by defining equivalence as when a linguistic unit carries the same intended meaning between languages. Non-equivalence occurs when there is no direct translation between languages and can happen at all levels from words to full texts. Common issues with non-equivalence include differences in idioms, collocations, and pragmatics between languages. When facing non-equivalence, translators must find workarounds like paraphrasing or using a combination of translation strategies. Achieving full equivalence is impossible but a high level can be attained through adaptations and avoiding overly literal translations.
This document discusses different types of sense relations between linguistic expressions, including synonymy, hyponymy, paraphrase, and entailment.
1) Synonymy is defined as the relationship between two predicates that have the same sense. Hyponymy is a sense relation where the meaning of one predicate is included within the meaning of another more general predicate.
2) Paraphrase is the relationship between two sentences that express the same proposition. Entailment is where the truth of one proposition necessarily follows from the truth of another.
3) The relationships are interdependent. Synonymy is a special case of symmetrical hyponymy. Paraphrase is symmetrical entailment. The basic
This document discusses implicature and entailment. It defines implicature as what is suggested in an utterance, even if not directly expressed or implied. There are two types of implicature: conversational and conventional. Conversational implicature relies on conversational principles while conventional implicature is part of a lexical item's meaning. Entailment is the relationship between sentences where the truth of one requires the truth of the other due to word meanings. There are also different types and classifications of entailment.
The recent history of second language learning research sla -presentation...jannesar_m
This document provides a summary of the major developments in second language learning research from the 1950s to the 1970s. It discusses key theories and models that emerged during this period, including: structuralism in the 1950s, which viewed language learning as acquiring speech habits; behaviourism in the 1950s-60s, which saw it as forming stimulus-response habits; first language acquisition research in the 1960s-70s, which looked at universal stages of development; error analysis and the concept of interlanguage in the 1970s, which viewed learner language as its own rule-governed system; Krashen's Monitor Model of the 1970s, including the acquisition-learning distinction and his input, natural order, monitor,
Individual learner differences and l2 acquisitionozzyl_bintang
1. Individual differences like age, intelligence, aptitude, motivation, and learning strategies affect how successful learners are in acquiring a second language even if they experience the same instruction.
2. Key factors that influence success include language aptitude (e.g. phonemic coding ability, inductive language learning ability), motivation types (integrative, instrumental, intrinsic), and cognitive learning strategies used.
3. Aptitude and motivation positively correlate with second language acquisition performance, while different learning strategies may suit different instructional methods.
Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.edac4co
It discusses how applied linguistics emerged from structural and functional linguistics in the 1950s to address issues in second language teaching and literacy. It examines how applied linguistics is problem-based and oriented toward real-world issues rather than theoretical explorations. It also looks at the domains and generations of applied linguistics as a field.
SLA ,Learning Theories , Second language Aquisitionmoji azimi
This document discusses theories of second language acquisition (SLA). It covers linguistic, psychological, and sociocultural theories including: Universal Grammar, Monitor Theory, Natural Order Hypothesis, Comprehension Input Hypothesis, Affective Filter Hypothesis, Behaviorism, Contrastive Analysis Hypothesis, Cognitive Psychology, Information Processing Theory, Connectionism, Processability Theory, Interactionist Perspectives, Sociocultural Perspectives, Interlanguage, Developmental Sequences, and the role of the first language and instruction in SLA. The document provides an overview of many influential theories that aim to explain how people learn a second language.
The document provides an overview of discourse analysis, including its origin, importance, differences between text and discourse, linguistic functions, cohesive devices, interpersonal functions, conventions of conversations, cooperative principle, and background knowledge. It discusses how discourse analysis was first introduced by Zelling Harris and defines it as the study of how stretches of language assume meaning and purpose. The document also distinguishes between the textual and interpersonal functions of language.
Sociolinguistics is the study of how language is influenced by social and cultural factors. It examines how language varies across social groups and contexts, as well as how factors like social class, gender, ethnicity, and power dynamics shape language use and norms. The key terms introduced in the document include concepts like linguistic variation, identity, power, solidarity, competence versus performance, and descriptive versus prescriptive approaches to language. Sociolinguistics encompasses both micro-level analysis of language patterns and macro-level analysis of broader social and political impacts of language.
The document discusses various types of language input provided to language learners, including comprehensible input containing linguistic items slightly beyond the learner's competence, and modified input using simplifications to aid comprehension. It also examines interaction and feedback, noting the interaction hypothesis that language acquisition benefits from negotiation of meaning during communication breakdowns and the various forms feedback can take, such as recasts, clarification requests, and explicit correction.
The document discusses the concept of interlanguage, which refers to the unique language system that L2 learners develop that is between their L1 and L2. It arises from learners applying abstract linguistic rules and their grammar system is permeable and transitional. The concept of interlanguage is informed by mentalist learning theory, which views language learning as involving innate cognitive mechanisms rather than just habit formation from external stimuli alone. Learning strategies like language transfer, overgeneralization, and simplification shape a learner's interlanguage system.
1. The document discusses the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, which proposes that the structure of a language influences its speakers' worldview and cognition. It describes studies showing how the categories used in a language to describe colors can influence color perception.
2. The text also introduces the concepts of "etic" and "emic" categories used in anthropology. Etic categories describe objective reality while emic categories reflect a culture's subjective perceptions based on its language and beliefs.
3. Finally, it discusses how semiotics studies how signs and their relationships construct meaning. Differences in how languages use signs can lead to divergent interpretations between cultures.
Content based syllabus combines language and content learning by focusing on teaching subject matter in the target language rather than separately teaching the language itself. It exposes students to the target language environment through subjects like in language immersion programs. While research shows this helps students learn faster, teachers must ensure student comprehension and account for differences in student age. Content based syllabus is applicable for both children and adults but does not guarantee communication skills without extensive interactive activities.
I thanks go to Naeem, Sher Azam, Monica Gill, Syed Aziz and Samia Kausar at Quaid e Azam University, Islamabad. I have tried to acknowledge all sources and true to the original data as much as possible, however there are undoubtedly still corrections to be made. If anyone who reads this acknowledgements find a piece of data that needs correction, please notify me at ahdihassan441@gmail.com.
Implicature refers to what a speaker implies rather than literally says. There are two main types: conversational implicature which is derived from cooperative conversation principles, and conventional implicature which is associated with specific words. Conversational implicature includes generalized implicature which does not depend on context, and particularized implicature which does. Scalar implicature also falls under conversational implicature and is implied when a weaker term on a scale is used. Particularized implicature provides more contextual information than generalized implicature. Implicatures can intentionally or unintentionally impact understanding in conversations.
The document discusses the role of the linguistic environment in second language acquisition. It covers 5 key ingredients: attitude, input, interaction, output, and noticing. Input alone may not be enough for acquisition and learners need opportunities for output and interaction. Noticing gaps in their language is important for learning. The environment can provide positive evidence, negative evidence, and opportunities for negotiation of meaning to aid acquisition, but individual and social factors also influence the learning process.
A Rationale For The Integration Of Critical Thinking Skills In EFL ESL Instru...Kate Campbell
This document provides a rationale for integrating critical thinking skills into English as a Foreign Language (EFL) and English as a Second Language (ESL) instruction. It discusses five categories of reasons for doing so: 1) Philosophical reasons related to the connection between language and thought, 2) Cognitive and metacognitive reasons regarding how critical thinking influences memory, comprehension, and metacognition, 3) Pedagogical reasons as modern language teaching methods require problem-solving, evaluation, and decision making, 4) Socio-economic reasons as critical thinking is a key skill required by the job market in the knowledge economy. The document concludes critical thinking can and should be developed through language instruction to benefit students.
The document discusses several topics related to globalization and language teaching:
1) The rise of Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) and Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT) as approaches that have spread globally over the past few decades.
2) How CLT/TBLT have become global phenomena through the flows of ideas, technologies, and people described by globalization theories. However, they have also been adapted locally through processes of "glocalization".
3) How global English language textbooks aim to give learners commodified identities as cosmopolitan consumers, but this risks overlooking local contexts and power dynamics. The document questions how teachers can critically reflect on textbooks and materials.
An Introduction to Applied Linguistics part 2Samira Rahmdel
The document discusses the scope and definition of applied linguistics. It begins by stating that applied linguistics is not exclusively about language teaching, but also involves other fields that utilize linguistic knowledge like speech therapy, literary criticism, and communications engineering. It then distinguishes applied linguistics as an activity rather than a theoretical study, using linguistic findings to address practical problems. Finally, it maps out the scope of applied linguistics by classifying its areas of study into three categories: language and education, language, work, and law, and language, information, and effect. Several examples are provided for each category to illustrate the broad and diverse range of activities to which applied linguistics is relevant.
The psychological basis of contrastive analysissara_galastarxy
The psychological basis of contrastive analysis is transfer theory. Transfer theory hypothesizes that prior learning affects subsequent learning. There are three paradigms - A, B, and C - that describe how transfer occurs between a first and second language based on the similarity and differences of stimuli and responses. Paradigm A involves the same formal devices used for different purposes, paradigm B involves different formal devices for the same meaning, and paradigm C has no similarities and is not useful for contrastive analysis. Contrastive analysis uses a behaviorist stimulus-response model of psychology but two cognitivist alternatives are cross-association and the ignorance hypothesis. The ignorance hypothesis has weaknesses as it does not account for learners being exposed to the target language
This document discusses context and co-text in language. It defines context as the circumstances and audience that influence the meaning communicated by a speaker or writer. It also discusses reference as using linguistic forms like pronouns or definite articles to identify something, and how reference relies on shared knowledge between the speaker and listener. Finally, it explains how inference, collaboration between communicators, and pragmatic connections within a sociocultural community are necessary to understand references in context.
This document discusses equivalence and non-equivalence in translation. It begins by defining equivalence as when a linguistic unit carries the same intended meaning between languages. Non-equivalence occurs when there is no direct translation between languages and can happen at all levels from words to full texts. Common issues with non-equivalence include differences in idioms, collocations, and pragmatics between languages. When facing non-equivalence, translators must find workarounds like paraphrasing or using a combination of translation strategies. Achieving full equivalence is impossible but a high level can be attained through adaptations and avoiding overly literal translations.
This document discusses different types of sense relations between linguistic expressions, including synonymy, hyponymy, paraphrase, and entailment.
1) Synonymy is defined as the relationship between two predicates that have the same sense. Hyponymy is a sense relation where the meaning of one predicate is included within the meaning of another more general predicate.
2) Paraphrase is the relationship between two sentences that express the same proposition. Entailment is where the truth of one proposition necessarily follows from the truth of another.
3) The relationships are interdependent. Synonymy is a special case of symmetrical hyponymy. Paraphrase is symmetrical entailment. The basic
This document discusses implicature and entailment. It defines implicature as what is suggested in an utterance, even if not directly expressed or implied. There are two types of implicature: conversational and conventional. Conversational implicature relies on conversational principles while conventional implicature is part of a lexical item's meaning. Entailment is the relationship between sentences where the truth of one requires the truth of the other due to word meanings. There are also different types and classifications of entailment.
The recent history of second language learning research sla -presentation...jannesar_m
This document provides a summary of the major developments in second language learning research from the 1950s to the 1970s. It discusses key theories and models that emerged during this period, including: structuralism in the 1950s, which viewed language learning as acquiring speech habits; behaviourism in the 1950s-60s, which saw it as forming stimulus-response habits; first language acquisition research in the 1960s-70s, which looked at universal stages of development; error analysis and the concept of interlanguage in the 1970s, which viewed learner language as its own rule-governed system; Krashen's Monitor Model of the 1970s, including the acquisition-learning distinction and his input, natural order, monitor,
Individual learner differences and l2 acquisitionozzyl_bintang
1. Individual differences like age, intelligence, aptitude, motivation, and learning strategies affect how successful learners are in acquiring a second language even if they experience the same instruction.
2. Key factors that influence success include language aptitude (e.g. phonemic coding ability, inductive language learning ability), motivation types (integrative, instrumental, intrinsic), and cognitive learning strategies used.
3. Aptitude and motivation positively correlate with second language acquisition performance, while different learning strategies may suit different instructional methods.
Applied Linguistics: an emerging discipline for twenty first century.edac4co
It discusses how applied linguistics emerged from structural and functional linguistics in the 1950s to address issues in second language teaching and literacy. It examines how applied linguistics is problem-based and oriented toward real-world issues rather than theoretical explorations. It also looks at the domains and generations of applied linguistics as a field.
SLA ,Learning Theories , Second language Aquisitionmoji azimi
This document discusses theories of second language acquisition (SLA). It covers linguistic, psychological, and sociocultural theories including: Universal Grammar, Monitor Theory, Natural Order Hypothesis, Comprehension Input Hypothesis, Affective Filter Hypothesis, Behaviorism, Contrastive Analysis Hypothesis, Cognitive Psychology, Information Processing Theory, Connectionism, Processability Theory, Interactionist Perspectives, Sociocultural Perspectives, Interlanguage, Developmental Sequences, and the role of the first language and instruction in SLA. The document provides an overview of many influential theories that aim to explain how people learn a second language.
The document provides an overview of discourse analysis, including its origin, importance, differences between text and discourse, linguistic functions, cohesive devices, interpersonal functions, conventions of conversations, cooperative principle, and background knowledge. It discusses how discourse analysis was first introduced by Zelling Harris and defines it as the study of how stretches of language assume meaning and purpose. The document also distinguishes between the textual and interpersonal functions of language.
Sociolinguistics is the study of how language is influenced by social and cultural factors. It examines how language varies across social groups and contexts, as well as how factors like social class, gender, ethnicity, and power dynamics shape language use and norms. The key terms introduced in the document include concepts like linguistic variation, identity, power, solidarity, competence versus performance, and descriptive versus prescriptive approaches to language. Sociolinguistics encompasses both micro-level analysis of language patterns and macro-level analysis of broader social and political impacts of language.
The document discusses various types of language input provided to language learners, including comprehensible input containing linguistic items slightly beyond the learner's competence, and modified input using simplifications to aid comprehension. It also examines interaction and feedback, noting the interaction hypothesis that language acquisition benefits from negotiation of meaning during communication breakdowns and the various forms feedback can take, such as recasts, clarification requests, and explicit correction.
The document discusses the concept of interlanguage, which refers to the unique language system that L2 learners develop that is between their L1 and L2. It arises from learners applying abstract linguistic rules and their grammar system is permeable and transitional. The concept of interlanguage is informed by mentalist learning theory, which views language learning as involving innate cognitive mechanisms rather than just habit formation from external stimuli alone. Learning strategies like language transfer, overgeneralization, and simplification shape a learner's interlanguage system.
1. The document discusses the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, which proposes that the structure of a language influences its speakers' worldview and cognition. It describes studies showing how the categories used in a language to describe colors can influence color perception.
2. The text also introduces the concepts of "etic" and "emic" categories used in anthropology. Etic categories describe objective reality while emic categories reflect a culture's subjective perceptions based on its language and beliefs.
3. Finally, it discusses how semiotics studies how signs and their relationships construct meaning. Differences in how languages use signs can lead to divergent interpretations between cultures.
Content based syllabus combines language and content learning by focusing on teaching subject matter in the target language rather than separately teaching the language itself. It exposes students to the target language environment through subjects like in language immersion programs. While research shows this helps students learn faster, teachers must ensure student comprehension and account for differences in student age. Content based syllabus is applicable for both children and adults but does not guarantee communication skills without extensive interactive activities.
I thanks go to Naeem, Sher Azam, Monica Gill, Syed Aziz and Samia Kausar at Quaid e Azam University, Islamabad. I have tried to acknowledge all sources and true to the original data as much as possible, however there are undoubtedly still corrections to be made. If anyone who reads this acknowledgements find a piece of data that needs correction, please notify me at ahdihassan441@gmail.com.
Implicature refers to what a speaker implies rather than literally says. There are two main types: conversational implicature which is derived from cooperative conversation principles, and conventional implicature which is associated with specific words. Conversational implicature includes generalized implicature which does not depend on context, and particularized implicature which does. Scalar implicature also falls under conversational implicature and is implied when a weaker term on a scale is used. Particularized implicature provides more contextual information than generalized implicature. Implicatures can intentionally or unintentionally impact understanding in conversations.
The document discusses the role of the linguistic environment in second language acquisition. It covers 5 key ingredients: attitude, input, interaction, output, and noticing. Input alone may not be enough for acquisition and learners need opportunities for output and interaction. Noticing gaps in their language is important for learning. The environment can provide positive evidence, negative evidence, and opportunities for negotiation of meaning to aid acquisition, but individual and social factors also influence the learning process.
A Rationale For The Integration Of Critical Thinking Skills In EFL ESL Instru...Kate Campbell
This document provides a rationale for integrating critical thinking skills into English as a Foreign Language (EFL) and English as a Second Language (ESL) instruction. It discusses five categories of reasons for doing so: 1) Philosophical reasons related to the connection between language and thought, 2) Cognitive and metacognitive reasons regarding how critical thinking influences memory, comprehension, and metacognition, 3) Pedagogical reasons as modern language teaching methods require problem-solving, evaluation, and decision making, 4) Socio-economic reasons as critical thinking is a key skill required by the job market in the knowledge economy. The document concludes critical thinking can and should be developed through language instruction to benefit students.
The document discusses several topics related to globalization and language teaching:
1) The rise of Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) and Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT) as approaches that have spread globally over the past few decades.
2) How CLT/TBLT have become global phenomena through the flows of ideas, technologies, and people described by globalization theories. However, they have also been adapted locally through processes of "glocalization".
3) How global English language textbooks aim to give learners commodified identities as cosmopolitan consumers, but this risks overlooking local contexts and power dynamics. The document questions how teachers can critically reflect on textbooks and materials.
Critical language awareness_in_pedagogic_contextjacktriza
This document summarizes a study that investigated developing students' critical language awareness through teaching techniques of critical discourse analysis. The researcher integrated critical analysis activities into their teaching methodology with 18 graduate students. A pre-test and post-test showed that the students' critical thinking abilities increased after learning CDA techniques. Their motivation and ability to analyze the meaning and messages of texts also improved. The study concluded that teaching students CDA led to around 90% increase in their critical language awareness.
This document discusses two theoretical accounts of task-based language use: the psycholinguistic perspective and the socio-cultural perspective. The psycholinguistic perspective views tasks as devices that provide input for language learning based on their design. Three models are discussed: Long's Interaction Hypothesis, Skehan's cognitive approach, and Yule's communicative efficiency framework. The socio-cultural perspective emphasizes that participants co-construct activities based on their goals and that scaffolding supports learning. Both perspectives aim to understand how task design impacts language use and learning opportunities.
Linguistics is the scientific study of human language including its structure, use, and the implications of these. It can be divided into theoretical linguistics, which studies the structural properties of language through topics like phonetics, phonology, morphology and syntax, and experimental and applied linguistics, which studies language in relation to other fields through topics like bilingualism, dialectology, historical linguistics, and language acquisition. Linguistics allows for many different approaches including descriptive/theoretical, synchronic/diachronic, and functional. It has wide applications in fields such as artificial intelligence, forensic linguistics, lexicography, machine translation, speech therapy, speech recognition, and language teaching.
1) The document discusses language relativity and how speakers of different languages have different cultural worldviews due to differences in their linguistic and discursive practices.
2) Research in linguistic anthropology, language socialization studies and cultural psychology examines how language use shapes aspects of thinking and cultural understandings. Contextualization cues in language link what is said to cultural perceptions and interpretations.
3) Applying the concept of language relativity to research in second language acquisition can provide insights into how language learning is influenced by one's native language and culture. It avoids treating cultures as monolithic and recognizes individual and social variation.
How Culture And Perception Are Directly Influenced By...Tiffany Graham
Here are some key special factors and issues an EL professional faces in identifying if an EL student's problem indicates a special education issue or normal language acquisition:
- Lack of appropriate assessment tools that are culturally and linguistically relevant for EL students at different English proficiency levels. Standardized tests may not accurately reflect an EL student's skills.
- Difficulty distinguishing between a learning disability versus normal second language acquisition challenges. Features of SLA like errors in grammar/pronunciation can mask an underlying disability.
- Impact of sociocultural/linguistic differences that can place ELs at an academic disadvantage regardless of cognitive abilities. Cultural norms around learning may differ.
- Scarcity of qualified EL professionals with expertise
Critical discourse analysis and an applicationSuaad Zahawi
This document provides an overview of critical discourse analysis (CDA) and its approaches. It discusses the key concepts and theorists in the development of CDA, including Norman Fairclough and Teun Van Dijk. The document is divided into two sections. The first section defines CDA and outlines its five common features and differences between approaches. It then describes Fairclough's approach focusing on discourse as social practice and ideology/power, as well as Van Dijk's socio-cognitive model. The second section will apply one of the CDA approaches to analyze Charlotte Bronte's novel Jane Eyre.
The document discusses several theories of second language acquisition, including:
1. Krashen's Input Hypothesis which distinguishes between subconscious language acquisition and conscious language learning, and emphasizes the importance of comprehensible input.
2. Long's Interaction Hypothesis which builds on Krashen and argues that modified interaction between learners and others provides comprehensive input.
3. Research showing that aspects of language like grammar are more easily acquired during childhood, while factors like accent are most influenced by age of acquisition. Overall, age should not deter second language learning.
This document discusses the theoretical underpinnings of Learning Design from socio-cultural and ecological perspectives. It describes how Learning Design draws on socio-cultural thinking from Vygotsky, focusing on mediated activity through tools and signs. An ecological perspective views learning through the concept of affordances - how aspects of the environment enable certain actions. Learning Design aims to establish mediating artifacts that guide the design process and represent learning activities.
The document discusses theories of pragmatic competence and functional approaches to language. It covers:
1) The Prague School's view of language as a system of units with internal and external functions. External functions include referential, expressive, and conative.
2) Halliday's hierarchy of meaning potential which builds from behavioral to meaning to lexical-grammatical potential.
3) Models of pragmatic competence including Bachman's model with functional and sociolinguistic knowledge, and Celce-Murcia's model with 5 components.
4) Components of pragmatic competence including different categories of language functions proposed by different scholars.
This document provides an overview of discourse analysis and discursive psychology. It defines discourse as situated language use that constructs social worlds and identities. It discusses three strands of discursive psychology: a poststructuralist perspective, an interactionist perspective, and a synthetic perspective that combines the two. The document also outlines seven stages of discursive research: obtaining access and consent, data collection, data management, transcription, developing research questions, analysis, and validation. Throughout, it emphasizes discourse as action-oriented, situated language use.
FIVE LENSES INTO THE WORK OF LEV SEMENOVICH VYGOTSKYPaul Gruhn
FIVE LENSES INTO THE WORK OF LEV SEMENOVICH VYGOTSKY A group project presented by Stefan Carretero, Casey Cummings, Kim Csapo-Ebert, Paul Gruhn, Jonathan Lake
March 2017 - EDLD 813 – Theory in Education Research
Bilingualism main and Fundemental concepts in SLA.pptxNoorhussein32
The document summarizes key concepts and approaches in second language acquisition research from Ellis (2015), including:
1) Research has challenged the existence of a fixed acquisition order and shown that social context influences what is acquired.
2) Learners show variability in their language and alternate between target and non-target forms gradually abandoning non-target forms.
3) While first language transfer influences second language acquisition, it is one of several factors and its effects are broader than just pronunciation, vocabulary and grammar.
International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention (IJHSSI) is an international journal intended for professionals and researchers in all fields of Humanities and Social Science. IJHSSI publishes research articles and reviews within the whole field Humanities and Social Science, new teaching methods, assessment, validation and the impact of new technologies and it will continue to provide information on the latest trends and developments in this ever-expanding subject. The publications of papers are selected through double peer reviewed to ensure originality, relevance, and readability. The articles published in our journal can be accessed online.
This document discusses 7 approaches to discourse analysis:
1. Conversation analysis examines the structure and organization of natural conversation.
2. Ethnography analyzes language use within social and cultural contexts through observation and interviews.
3. Corpus-based analysis uses large text databases to study language patterns and variations in genres.
4. Multimodal analysis views communication as involving multiple modes beyond just language.
5. Genre analysis describes conventional language patterns associated with academic and professional settings.
6. Critical discourse analysis critically examines how language relates to power and social inequality.
7. Mediated discourse analysis focuses on how social actions are carried out through discourse within cultural and historical contexts.
American Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Development is indexed, refereed and peer-reviewed journal, which is designed to publish research articles.
This document summarizes a paper that proposes an Intercultural Interaction Model to enhance understanding of second language acquisition (SLA) by integrating factors from acculturation research. It discusses research on learner motivation in SLA and acculturation attitudes. The proposed model suggests different functioning levels in formal and informal language learning contexts influence the breadth and depth of SLA. Motivational schemas determine the extent learners undergo acculturation into new linguistic and cultural environments of a second language and culture.
This document provides an introduction and overview of an English 344 course on second language acquisition (SLA). It outlines the course objectives of exploring fundamental SLA concepts from linguistic, socio-cognitive, and sociocultural approaches. The document also briefly summarizes the historical development of the field from behaviorist to current sociocultural theories. Students are assigned to purchase course texts, set up a blog, and submit their first blog post by the next Tuesday at noon.
Second language acquisition and english language teachingOsnovna šola Pivka
This document discusses theories of second language acquisition and their influence on English language teaching. It examines key theories that have attempted to influence SLA over time, from behaviourism to cognitive approaches. While early theories focused on linguistic and psycholinguistic factors, more recent theories emphasize the importance of social and sociolinguistic factors in language learning. The document also discusses factors that influence the amount and type of language input learners receive, and how this impacts the development and success of second language acquisition.
Similar to Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in Terms of Application to Second Language Acquisition (20)
In the process of teaching grammar it is difficult to motivate students. A well-designed introductory text used in terms of the inductive method, theory of creativity, and Vygotsky’s socio-cultural theory can be a useful technique of enhancing students’ motivation. To motivate students, the introductory text must possess certain qualities: to be grammatically structured, vivid, humorous, and connected to some cultural issues. While reading the text students are urged to notice new syntax units, guess their meaning in the context, and discover the grammar patterns. Thus, students are immersed into a carefully guided learning process of scaffolded interactive communication.
The article is based on a detailed analysis of the introductory text (a dialogue between two friends) from Dr. Keith Folse’ textbook (2012) Clear Grammar 2. (2nd Ed.). In this textbook the introduction of the new syntax material in the dialogue takes place gradually: as the dialogue develops, it presents new grammatical complexities. Also, the dialogue contains some devices such as a celebrity name (Brad Pitt), colloquial expressions, and humor to catch and keep students’ attention. Only after students’ attention has been stimulated, the new syntax structures appear in the dialogue for the first time. As the result, the students’ understanding of the deep and surface structures of a new syntax form (past progressive tense in this case) may come at this stage of learning.
The research has illuminated the beneficial role of poetry in all major aspects of second language acquisition, such as the accuracy of pronunciation, development of L2 complex syntax and vocabulary, development of understanding of the L2 discourse, cultural awareness and promotion of multiculturalism, as well as in students’ motivation. Poetry, as an authentic, non-paraphrased utterance of personal perception created in certain socio-cultural environment is a unique linguistic formation. By introducing the activities of reading and writing poetry in second language classrooms such qualities as developing students’ second language in complexity, developing the students’ individual ways of self-expression and self-realization within socio-cultural settings of a second language can be expanded.
A Comparative Analysis of Present and Past Participial Adjectives and their C...Natalia Reilly, Ph.D.
This present study used the Corpus of Contemporary American English http://corpus.byu.edu/coca/ (COCA) to investigate the overall frequency of participial adjectives in use as well as their frequency within certain varieties of contexts. The results have shown that among most frequently used participial adjectives there are not only the participial adjectives derived from transitive verbs of psychological state, such as interesting/interested, but also the participial adjectives derived from transitive verbs of action with their intransitive equivalents, such as increasing/increased. The data also revealed that many participial adjectives lack corresponding counterparts and thus cannot be presented in –ing/-ed or -en pairs (e. g., existing, ongoing, concerned, supposed). Finally, a majority of the differences between participial adjectives, including the differences between present (-ing) and past (-ed or -en) participial adjectives, are reflected in their collocations. This study suggests that a new approach of teaching participial adjectives along with their collocations in relation to their frequencies in particular contexts can help second language learners develop awareness of how and when these participial adjectives should be used to convey an individual’s intended meaning in a native-like manner.
This document analyzes participial adjectives ending in -ing and -ed using corpus data. It includes 4 tables:
Table 2 shows the top 20 most frequent -ing and -ed participial adjectives, with few matches between the lists.
Tables 3 and 4 compare the top 20 -ing adjectives to their -ed counterparts, finding few perfect pairs and many "single" forms.
The document concludes certain adjectives are more frequent in different registers like academia and speech. Not all can be taught with counterparts, and students should be aware of "single" forms.
This document discusses the beneficial functions of poetry for second language learning. It argues that poetry can develop students' second language complexity through activities like reading and writing poetry. Poetry conveys meaning through unique features like grammar, vocabulary, registers, and themes not often addressed in textbooks. It also motivates learners by involving them in personal creative processes. The document provides examples of how poetry illustrates these concepts and recommends including poetry in language classrooms, particularly highly constrained forms, which force learners to stretch their skills through formal requirements.
The document discusses using an introductory text as a motivational tool for teaching grammar. It analyzes a dialogue from a grammar textbook that introduces the past progressive tense. The dialogue models target grammar structures in an engaging way that draws students in. Motivation theories support this approach, including the inductive method of inferring rules from examples and Vygotsky's sociocultural theory emphasizing social interaction and scaffolding within the zone of proximal development. Analyzing this dialogue shows how it fulfills criteria for motivating language learning according to the Motivation Orientation of Language Teaching framework.
An introductory text can be an effective motivational tool in teaching grammar. Getting students interested and engaged is one of the most important challenges for teachers, as unmotivated students will not pay attention. While grammar is often seen as tedious, a well-designed introduction can help attract students and make the lesson more engaging.
This presentation was provided by Steph Pollock of The American Psychological Association’s Journals Program, and Damita Snow, of The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), for the initial session of NISO's 2024 Training Series "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape." Session One: 'Setting Expectations: a DEIA Primer,' was held June 6, 2024.
This slide is special for master students (MIBS & MIFB) in UUM. Also useful for readers who are interested in the topic of contemporary Islamic banking.
Main Java[All of the Base Concepts}.docxadhitya5119
This is part 1 of my Java Learning Journey. This Contains Custom methods, classes, constructors, packages, multithreading , try- catch block, finally block and more.
The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...RitikBhardwaj56
Discover the Simplified Electron and Muon Model: A New Wave-Based Approach to Understanding Particles delves into a groundbreaking theory that presents electrons and muons as rotating soliton waves within oscillating spacetime. Geared towards students, researchers, and science buffs, this book breaks down complex ideas into simple explanations. It covers topics such as electron waves, temporal dynamics, and the implications of this model on particle physics. With clear illustrations and easy-to-follow explanations, readers will gain a new outlook on the universe's fundamental nature.
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP ModuleCeline George
In Odoo, the chatter is like a chat tool that helps you work together on records. You can leave notes and track things, making it easier to talk with your team and partners. Inside chatter, all communication history, activity, and changes will be displayed.
How to Manage Your Lost Opportunities in Odoo 17 CRMCeline George
Odoo 17 CRM allows us to track why we lose sales opportunities with "Lost Reasons." This helps analyze our sales process and identify areas for improvement. Here's how to configure lost reasons in Odoo 17 CRM
This presentation includes basic of PCOS their pathology and treatment and also Ayurveda correlation of PCOS and Ayurvedic line of treatment mentioned in classics.
Strategies for Effective Upskilling is a presentation by Chinwendu Peace in a Your Skill Boost Masterclass organisation by the Excellence Foundation for South Sudan on 08th and 09th June 2024 from 1 PM to 3 PM on each day.
2. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 2
Introduction
The application of Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory to second language acquisition
helps L2 learners bring their proficiency in a second language closer to the level of their first
language. The application of this particular theory is helpful for several reasons.
First, the theory takes into consideration the external as well as internal stages of human
cognitive development. So, the theory provides the opportunity for the research of the social
aspects of communication as well as mental functions of cognition, and therefore, for obtaining
varied results for further development of SLA theory (Anton & DiCamilla, 1999; Brooks &
Donato, 1994; Evensen, 2007; Lantolf, 2006; Nassaji, 2006; Zuengler & Miller, 2006).
Second, one of the main Vygotsky’s concepts – the zone of proximal development (ZPD)
– provides the explanations of the conditions (socio-cultural and cognitive) which are necessary
for the processes of human learning. The conditions for the further learning consist of already
existing knowledge, the social interaction with the more knowledgeable ones, and the
transformation of the external processes into internal (cognitive) processes and functions (Anton
et al., 1999; Brooks & Donato, 1994; Kinginger, 2002; Lantolf, 2006; Nassaji & Cumming,
2000; Ohta, 1995, 2005).
Consequently, within the contours of the mentioned two concepts of the Vygoskian
theory (the existence of social and cognitive elements in the processes of SLA and the concept of
the zone of proximate development), the following three issues can be emphasized.
The first issue is a variety of schemes for interpretation and, therefore, for a broad range
of applications of the concept of the zone of proximal development in second language
acquisition research. The variety of applications may lie, for example, in the phenomenon that
the conservative as well as progressive educators while acclaiming the matter of the ZPD,
3. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 3
provide different interpretations of its meaning (Kinginger, 2002; Nassaji & Swain, 2000), or in
the researches of the ZPD in L2 learner-written material collaboration (Appel & Lantolf, 1994;
McCafferty, 1994; Ohta, 2005), or in the researches concerning the development of higher
potential level of SLA in the ZPD in creative writing (Tin, 2011).
The second issue considers private speech, or self-talk, – socially originated, verbalized,
but internal speech. Although dialogic in nature, private speech changes its function: it is used by
L2 learners to organize, plan, direct or evaluate the problem solving process while encountering
a difficult task. The issue is important because this evolution of speech – from social to self-
directed to internalized – exemplifies the path of higher mental functions including second
language acquisition (Anton et al., 1999; Lantolf, 2006a, 2006b, 1994; McCafferty, 1994, 1992;
Schinke-Llano, 1993; Tarone & Swain, 1995).
The third issue is the functions of L1 in the process of L2 acquisition. Because both
languages – L1 and L2 – are the tools of second language acquisition in the process of L2
internalization, which is the move from the imitation to private and inner speech, and to the
capacity of purposeful and autonomous self-regulated expression in L2, the issue of the functions
of L1 is important (Anton et el., 1999; Brooks & Donato, 1994; Brooks, Donato & McGlone,
1997; Lantolf, 2006; McCafferty, 1992, 1994; Tin, 2011). The studies reveal the role of L1 in
SLA and the connections between the emerging second language private speech and the cultural
heritage of the first language.
Thus, the following is the analysis of the main concepts of Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural
Theory and its entailed issues. The analysis focuses on the possibilities of the development of the
SLA theory for the purpose of minimizing the gap between learners’ proficiencies in their first
and second languages.
4. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 4
Main Concepts of Vygotsky’s Theory in Application to SLA
Social and Cognitive Processes of SLA
Second language acquisition involves two kinds of processes – social and cognitive. The
Vygotsky’s socio-cultural theory gives the opportunity to synthesize the two processes and to
provide the most complete view on the development of L2. As it is mentioned in the works of
Brooks and Donato (1994), Lantolf (2006, 1994), Nassaji (2006), Thorne (2005), Zuengler and
Miller (2006), Vygotsky focused on the connections between people and the sociocultural
context in which they act and interact in shared experiences thus obtaining knew knowledge.
According to Vygotsky, social interaction plays a fundamental role in the process of cognitive
development, yet, social and cognitive processes are inseparable: “Every function in the child’s
cultural development appears twice: first, on the social level, and later, on the individual level;
first, between people (interpsychological) and then inside the child (intrapsychological)” (As
cited in Thorne, 2005, p. 395).
The notions of interpsychological and intrapsychological processes in SLA can be traced
in more researches, such as those conducted by Anton and DiCamilla (1999), and Brooks and
Donato (1994, 1997). Thus, Anton in her research concerning the socio-cognitive functions of L1
in the collaborative interaction of adult learners of Spanish in the L2 classroom, has interpreted
the functions of L1 in two ways: in interpsychological terms – as the construction of scaffodled
help and the establishment of intersubjectivity, and in intrapsychological terms – as the use of
private speech. The other researchers, Brooks and Donato, having analyzed speech data from
adolescent learners of Spanish who were engaged in a problem-solving speaking task, have
considered that if interaction lacks intrapsychological elements, the learning does not occur,
5. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 5
in small-group processes, language learning activity must be viewed as cognitive activity
and not merely the rehearsal and eventual acquisition of linguistic forms … it is not only
the communicative activity or contents of the lesson that is paramount, but engagement
with and control of communicative interactions that will ultimately benefit the foreign
language learner (Brooks et el., 1994, pp. 272, 273).
In 1997 Brooks and Donato continued their research of the role of sociocultural and cognitive
processes in SLA. They studied student discourse of three pairs of third-semester intermediate-
level learners of Spanish at the university level. The students had to speak in the target language
to accomplish a given task of discussing the variety of problems, such as difficulties with
vocabulary or how to rehearse target language forms. The research confirmed the previous
conclusion that if the purpose and function of learner language are not clearly understood, the
collaboration doesn’t lead to learning, that mere collaboration is not enough, and that the most
important part in second language learning is “how forms of collaboration and social interaction
unite the development of second-language orality with an individual’s cognitive functioning”
(Brooks et el., 1997, p. 534).
Moreover, Lantolf (2006a, 2006b, 1994) has stated that social and cognitive processes
(mediation and internalization) are two central constructions in Vygotsky’s theory in terms of
application to the development of SLA theory, “I concentrate on two areas that I believe are
particularly important, especially with regard to future research: L2 mediation and the
internalization of L2s” (2006a, p. 68). This theme of the further development of the SLA theory
by applying the Vygotskyan apparent dualism between social interaction and cognitive,
neurological characteristics of second language learning are continued by recent researches.
Evensen (2007) has suggested that more considerate and less confrontational understanding of
6. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 6
social and cognitive aspects of Vygotsky’s theory may help to shed new light on the theory of
second language acquisition,
I have sought to demonstrate the radical possibility – that a socially oriented, multi-plane
framework may be useful for understanding even cognitive or neurological aspects of
learning. Vygotsky’s dictum that learning and development moves from intermental to
intramental seems to imply exactly such a possibility… The inner logic of a mediational
system is appropriated by learners, but once appropriated, its inner logic will affect its
‘users’ in return. Cognitive structures … may be qualitatively restructured or transformed
as such mediated processes continue (p. 348).
So, learning occurs only when the social interaction undergoes the transformation from
external processes into internal (cognitive) processes and functions.
This synthesis of sociocultural and cognitive aspects in the Vygotskian approach to the process
of second language acquisition contributes to the development of the SLA theory by the means
of overcoming the conflicting debates concerning cognitive and social understandings of
learning. As Zuengler (2006) pointed out, “development doesn’t proceed as the unfolding of
inborn capacities, but as the transformation of innate capacities once they intertwine with
socioculturally constructed mediational means” (pp.38,39). This can prove that cognitive and
sociocultural perspectives are not two parallel SLA worlds, but the reflection of two essential
elements of learning.
Zone of Proximal Development
One of the main concepts of Vygotsky’s theory is the Zone of Proximal Development
(ZPD). According to Vygotsky, the ZPD is
7. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 7
the difference between the child’s developmental level as determined by independent
problem solving and the higher level of potential development as determined through
problem solving under adult guidance or in collaboration with more capable peers (As
cited in Ohta, 1995).
So, the ZPD is the zone where learning occurs. As it has been pointed out in the previous
unit concerning social and cognitive processes in second language acquisition, learning occurs
only when the external processes of social interaction with the more knowledgeable ones are
transformed into internal (cognitive) processes and functions. This transformation takes place in
the zone of proximal development, “The transfer of functions from the social (or
interpsychological) domain to the cognitive (or intrapsychological) plane occurs within the zone
of proximal development (ZPD)” (Anton et el., 1999). It means that the concept of the ZPD
explains the conditions of the processes of human learning.
For this reason, many researchers in the field of Vygotskian approach to SLA are
focusing on the zone of proximal development (Anton et al., 1999; Brooks & Donato, 1994;
Kinginger, 2002; Lantolf, 2006; Nassaji & Cumming, 2000; Ohta, 1995, 2005). Thus, Ohta,
(1995) analyzed students’ learning and progressing by means of collaborative interaction within
the ZPD. Ohta, while conducting a qualitative research of a combined – teacher leading and peer
pair work – interaction with two Japanese intermediate-level learners, conceptualized the ZPD
for SLA purposes by defining it as
the difference between the L2 learner’s developmental level as determined by
independent language use, and the higher level of potential development as determined
by how language is used in collaboration with a more capable interlocutor (p. 96).
8. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 8
Within the zone of proximal development the improvement of L2 occurs by means of
scaffolding which is “the concept … [that] originates with the work of Wood et al. (1976) and
serves as a metaphor for the interaction between an expert and a novice engaged in a problem-
solving task” (Anton et al., 1999, p. 235). Ohta especially emphasized the importance of learner-
learner communicative interaction in the process of scaffolding. Ohta stated “examining learner
interaction in the ZPD provides a richer view of L2 development, allowing the researcher to
examine what learners are able to do with language and how language development occurs” (p.
97).
One of the important features of the occurring development of L2 highlighted by Ohta
was the fact that “in learner-learner interaction … the learners contribute [not only their
established knowledge, but also] their individual differences in matures and maturing skills” (p.
97), and as a result, “the more advanced learner can also benefit from interaction with a learner
less proficient in the L2 as learner strengths are collaboratively joined” (p. 93). The concept of
collaboratively joined efforts of two or more learners and its importance in second language
acquisition was also pointed out by Anton et al. as intersubjectivity (1999).
The application of the zone of proximal development to SLA research also helps reveal
new features of the ZPD concept. According to Nassaji and Cummings (2000), the study of
teacher-student interaction via dialogue journals written over ten months elucidated “some of the
salient qualities of the ZPD that they mutually constructed in this context over time” (Nassaji et
al., 2000). The cooperative correspondence took place between a six year Farsi speaker at the
beginner level of learning English and his Canadian teacher. In the process, ninety-five
exchanges in interactive were analyzed. The longitude of the research and the contrastive
interaction between a much more knowledgeable one (a teacher) and a complete novice (a six
9. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 9
year old beginner) allowed to bring to light two salient characteristics of the ZPD: “ (a) sustained
intersubjectivity and (b) complementary, asymmetric scaffolding” (p. 103).
Furthermore, the application of the ZPD in its dialectical aspect allows to analyze
language learning holistically by perceiving integrally unified, interactive phenomenon of
language. As Nassaji and Cummings (2000) in the same study point out, “Vygotsky claimed that
learning is formed through the ZPD, which creates ‘a dialectic unity of learning-and-
development’” (p. 97) where “the culturally mediated interaction among people in the zone of
proximate development is internalized, becoming a new function of the individual” (p. 98). This
brings the language acquisition to the pragmatic level, and vice versa – dialectically speaking,
the counter process is going on, in which “sociolingustically oriented theories have traced how
the language varieties that adults develop in a second language acquisition arise from pragmatic
functions people try to fulfill while communicating” (p. 96). In the relation to the results of this
particular study, the authors emphasized that
This dialogue journal writing set a long-term context for the student and teacher to
communicate routinely through written English … in which both participants reciprocally
shared common knowledge, purposes and tools of communication, evidently
understanding and appreciating them. … A sociocultural perspective highlights teaching
and learning in conjunction and close-up, looking to fundamental characteristics of the
ZPD as a set of interactive processes wherein learning occurs because teaching facilitates
it … instead of fragmenting [language] essential interconnectedness … for example, by
treating language as a system of elements divorced from their social functions and
context (pp. 114, 115).
10. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 10
The dialectic aspect of the ZPD was also emphasized in studies of such authors as Nassaji
and Swain (2000), and Kinginger (2002). According to Kinginger, the dialectical
interpretation of the ZDP
hints at the possibility of recovering the unity within a dialectic synthesis … through
recognition of the notion that language-in-use constitutes and object of reflection, raising
students awareness to all levels: metalinguistic, metadiscursive, metapragmatic,
metacultural (p. 257).
The comparative researches continue to support the general idea of applicability of the
ZPD concept to second language learning theory. Thus, Nassaji and Swain (2000) in their
qualitative and quantitative study of two Korean students’ English compositional writings
compared help provided within the ZPD with random help. The ZPD student was provided with
help to be moved gradually to the needed level “using prompts through the Regulatory Scale
developed by Aljaafreh and Lantolf (1994)” (Nassaji et el., 2012). At the same time, the non-
ZPD student was provided with random help in the form of prompts without regarding her ZPD.
As the research has proved, “help provided within the ZPD was more effective than help
provided randomly” (Nassaji et el., 2012).
Therefore, these results continue to prove the research reliability of the ZPD approach
and show the perspectives of the further development of the theory of SLA by applying to the
study the concept of the zone of proximate development.
Some Entailed Aspects of Vygotsky’s Theory in Application to SLA
Variety of Interpretations and Applications of the ZPD
The interpretation of the research materials obtained in the studies of the zone of
proximate development often depends on the researcher’s theoretical academic domain as it is
11. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 11
mentioned by such researchers as Kinginger (2002) and Nissaji and Swain (2000). Thus,
according to Kinginger, the representatives of both – the conservative and progressive domains
of SLA studies acclaim the matter of the ZPD, yet they provide different interpretations of its
meaning. In the interpretation of conservative scholars “interactions where students participate in
reaching the instructor’s goal are identified as ‘scaffolding’, as constructing the ZPD … where
students comply with their instructor’s directives in producing sentences that are maximally
correct” (pp. 254, 255). Nevertheless, the important aspect of ZPD is missing here – it is the
social activity of students. In the pseudo-ZPD studies students “are invited to participate and
even to share the floor; but they are not authorized to question what they are accomplishing and
why” (p.255). Usually conservative educators uncritically linked the ZPD “to Krashen’s Monitor
Model in order to reinforce a conservative ‘skills’ based practice … [where] the ZPD serves to
represent the diffusion of participant roles within canonical classroom discourse (e.g. Gifford and
Mullaney, 1999)” (Kinginger, 2002, p. 257). On the other hand, progressive educators “suggest a
prospective understanding of language learning, even though they limit the scope of this
understanding to the specific case of the negotiation of linguistic structures” (p. 257). This
approach to ZPD through prospective understanding was also considered by Nassaji and Swain,
2000, who, after Wells, 1998, interpret the ZPD “not as a fixed trait of the learner but as an
emergent and open-ended one that unfolds through interaction and expands the potential for
learning by providing opportunities which were not anticipated in the first place” (Nassaji and
Swain, p. 36).
One more interpretation of the ZPD occurs with the introduction of a written text as a
communicator. The mainstream research in terms of the ZPD is conducted in peer-peer or
teacher-pupil collaborative interaction, yet the ZPD as a space where second language learning
12. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 12
can take place is not limited by these collaborations only. In her later study, Ohta (2005)
assumed that learning within the ZPD occurs also in interaction with a written source, “The ZPD
is a key developmental space for language learning acquisition. As learners bump up against
their own limitations and are assisted to move beyond them with the help of teacher, peer, or
written source, development follows” (p. 513). How the processes of interaction and scaffolded
help occur via communication with a written source can be partly explained by the post-modern
notion (Appel & Lantolf, 1994) that the meaning of the text is created by the reader at certain
level of the reader’s competence; then the created meaning affects the reader’s comprehension;
then, in its turn, the emerged comprehension creates a next in turn meaning at the higher level of
the reader’s competence, and the dialectical process of the mutual meaning-comprehension
influence will go on, “One of the consequences of the post-modernist movement … is the
recognition of the possibility that meaning does not reside in texts per se, but is created through
some type of reader-text interaction” (p. 449). Therefore, here we have one more example of
Vygotsky’s dialectical (versus linear) approach to the psychological development, emphasized
by McCafferty (1994), when “development is a complex dialectical process characterized by …
metamorphosis or qualitative transformation of one form into another, intertwining of external
and internal factors” (Vygotsky, 1978, as cited in McCafferty, 1994).
The other connection of the ZPD with a written source is the interpretation of the
emergence of more complex L2 in creative writing tasks with high formal constraints (acrostics)
in comparison with those of looser formal constraints (similes) (Tin, 2010). The study was
conducted over 2 weeks with 23 non-native 18-22 year-old English speakers from a university in
Indonesia who wrote a number of poems in pairs and individually; students’ discussions in pairs
were audio taped and analyzed. As Tin has pointed out, the creative writing tasks mean the play
13. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 13
with the language; yet only the play where the rules are strictly defined creates the ZPD and
provides the scaffolding that brings students to the higher level of potential development.
Acrostic (poem w/formal constrains) Simile (free style poem)
Joy
Jar of amazing feeling
Overcoming sadness
You should get it (p. 222)
Our friend is like an orange
She always freshes us
She is stubborn when unripe
But wiser when ripe (p. 229)
The more complex L2 (the poem on the left) emerges because the formal constraints
require students “to develop new compositional strategies and syntactic structures, combining
known familiar utterances in unfamiliar ways in order to construct new meaning” (p. 231). So,
according to Tin, only the play with acrostics gives students the Vygotskian opportunity to
perform “a head taller than they are” (Vygotsky, 1978 as cited in Tin, 2010, p. 232).
Private Speech
Private speech is one of the most important socio-cognitive functions within the zone of
proximal development. Private speech is a self-talk. It is socially originated, verbalized, but
internal speech dialogic in nature (Anton et al., 1999; Appel & Lantolf, 1994; Lantolf, 2006a,
2006b, 1994; McCafferty, 1994, 1992). Although socially originated and dialogic, private speech
changes its function: it is used by a L2 learner to organize, plan, direct or evaluate the problem
solving while encountering a difficult task. According to Anton and DiCamilla (1999), “private
speech is social in its genesis and may therefore be social or communicative in its appearance,
but it nevertheless psychological in function. That is, it is speech directed to the self for the
purpose of directing and organizing one’s mental activity” (p. 235). This statement is rooted in
Vygotsky’s belief that
14. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 14
with the acquisition of language, children gain access to the most powerful of “mental
tools,” that they use language to transform the cognitive functions appropriated through
interpersonal experience into intrapersonal functions. In children … this transformation is
greatly facilitated through the use of speech for the self, or private speech (As cited in
McCafferty, 1994).
In application to SLA theory, the issue of private speech helps understand how private
speech mediates second language learning. In the study of the nature of private speech and its
role in the mental activity in the process of recalling and comprehending written texts, Appel and
Lantolf (1994) showed “how speaking, especially in the form of private speech …, not only
mediates the subjects’ attempts to report on what they understand from the text, but also how it
serves as the process through which they come to comprehend the text” (Appel & Lantolf, 1994,
p.439). The researches also proved the nature of private speech to be social.
In this study there were 28 participants – all young adults: 14 native speakers of English
and 14 advanced English speakers from a German university. The subjects were given two texts
– one narrative (a typical children’s fairy tale) and one expository (about propagation of coffee
plants). The subjects were instructed to read the texts carefully and recall them in a while orally
being alone in the room; no time restrictions were imposed. The responses were tape recorded
and analyzed. I was expected that the oral responses would be “marked by a high frequency of
metacomments, or what we refer to as private speech” (Appel et al., 1994, p. 439). The
metacomments in forms of macrostructures – “the gist of the text for the reader” (p. 443) showed
that the more difficult the task was and the less proficient the speakers were, the more
macrostructures in increasing variability were produced. Concerning the nature of private speech
Appel and Lantolf (1994) concluded,
15. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 15
private speech, as a way of mediating mental activity, … is rooted in communicative
speech. In our view all of this means that people can construct meaning from a text … by
conversing with others, with the self in presence of others, or, as in the case of our
subjects, with the self in the presence of no one other than the self. All of these activities
are at their core, social (p. 449).
The process of the use of private speech by second language learners was also studied
cross-culturally (McCafferty, 1992). The study revealed psychological idiosyncrasy in the
manner of using private speech by the L2 learners from the different countries. In this study the
“central idea” (McCafferty, p. 181) of Vygotskian theory that cultural-historical background
impacts cognitive development was set as a research question to investigate it in terms of private
speech. The study considered “the influence of cultural background to see how adult second
language learners of English from two different cultural backgrounds (Asian [15] and Hispanic
[15] [all ESL college students]) attempt to gain self-regulation in a communicative task in their
L2” (p. 181). The subjects were asked to construct a narrative based on a story as portrayed
through a series of six pictures. The results showed that the Hispanic subjects were using far
more different kinds of utterances of private speech than the Asians (Hispanics – 61-16, Asians –
4-7). The differences in the use of private speech by ESL learners from two different cultural
contexts, also showed, according to McCafferty, that “the L2 learners’ use of private speech …
would seem to indicate the degree to which individual autonomy is valued within cultures” (p.
188).
Functions of L1 in SLA
The functions of L1 in second language acquisition closely related to the notion of private
speech: L1 is one of the tools of second language acquisition in the process of L2 internalization.
16. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 16
In this process learners help themselves by producing private speech in L1 or L2 to obtain the
capacity of purposeful and autonomous self-regulated expression in L2 (Anton et el., 1999;
Brooks, Donato & McGlone, 1997; Lantolf, 2006; Tin, 2011). So, the question of how second
language learners’ communication in L1 and L2 affects their second language acquisition is an
important issue in the theory of SLA. There are several opinions concerning the use and the role
of L1 in the second language learning process.
Some researchers, such as Anton and DiCamilla (1999), emphasize the beneficial
functions of L1 in general, while others (Brooks & Donato, 1994; Brooks, Donato & McGlone,
1997; Lantolf, 2006; McCafferty, 1992, 1994; Tin, 2011) emphasize the transitional role of L1,
considering its beneficial role mainly at the early stages of SLA.
Thus, in their research, Anton and DiCamilla (1999) studied the interaction of five pairs
of the beginner Spanish learners (all – young adults, native speakers of English) in their L1 for
solving L2 writing tasks. Three sessions of the intense course of Spanish were recorded and
analyzed. The results showed that the functions “of L1 in the second language learning process
are beneficial since it acts as a critical psychological tool that enables L2 learners to construct
effective collaborative dialogue in the completion of meaning-based language task” (p. 245).
Moreover, when analyzing the results of the experiment, the authors marked out two types of L1
functions – interpsychological (construction of scaffolded help and establishment of
itersubjectivity) and intrapsychological (use of private speech).
The variations of the use of L1 in two different writing tasks are revealed in the research
concerning writing acrostics (structured poems) and similes (freestyle poems) (Tin, 2011). This
study has been described here in the unit Private Speech. Tin called the finding “unplanned
insight … offering a new way of regarding the use of the L1 vs. the L2 in collaborative writing
17. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 17
tasks” (p. 231). First, the author mentions the results of the previous studies conducted by Swain
and Lapkin (2000), where, according to Tin, “pair writing stimulates collaborative dialogue in
the L1 and creation of text in the target language (Tin, 2011, p. 231). In her research Tin has
proved the different usages of L1 and L2 in the two different tasks while analyzing private
speech. The author has come to the following conclusion, “In acrostics, conceptual systems are
activated through the L2 directly. … However, in similes, concepts are first retrieved in the L1
then translated into the L2” (p. 232). So, in acrostics, “the formal constraints … allow students to
conceptually mediate L2 directly, strengthening the link between L2 lexicon and conceptual
representation” (p. 232), while in similes, “L1 becomes a communicative strategy and a
cognitive tool to access L2 forms that are available” (p. 232).
The most of the researchers (Brooks, Donato & McGlone, 1997; Lantolf, 2006;
McCafferty, 1992, 1994) point out the transitional role of dialogic L1 in helping L2 learners
overcome the beginner stage of communicative interaction in L1 and move to the stage of pure
L2 interaction. First of all, the researchers recognized that communication in L1 at the early
stages of learning is not the evidence that students are off-task, or sabotage the activity, or unable
to work in small groups. In this experiment, native speakers of English learning Spanish
(university students of intermediate level) were specifically instructed to speak in L2 only while
performing L2 tasks (jig-saw activity with pictures). In spite of this, the subjects involved private
speech in both L1 and L2 when they encountered difficulties. According to the authors, “The
implication of these findings is that learners can gain self-regulation if provided multiple
opportunities to collaborate” (Brooks, Donato & McGlone, 1997, p. 532). The authors stated
that, at least initially, “in the attempts to regulate their participation in collaborative tasks, …
they [L2 learners] can carry out the tasks in the native language,” because “systematic
18. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 18
opportunities for collaboration with the target language may eventually enable individuals to
perform cognitively demanding tasks in the target language” (p. 534). From the Vygotskian
perspective “all forms of collaboration and social interaction unite the development of second-
language orality with an individual’s cognitive functioning” (p. 534), and L1 is considered to be
one of these collaborative forms of socio-cultural interaction. Thus, L1 becomes a cognitive tool
as well as a communicative strategy to “access L2 forms that are available” (Anton et el., 1999,
p. 238).
Conclusion
Vygotsky’s socio-cultural theory in terms of second language acquisition considers the
main features of the SLA processes. According to the theory, human development goes through
the following stages: mediation – communication through words, gestures, facial expressions,
imitation, and internalization/appropriation – the creative use of language with the help of private
speech (Anton & DiCamilla, 1999; Brooks & Donato, 1994; Evensen, 2007; Lantolf, 2006;
Nassaji, 2006; Nassaji & Cumming, 2000; Ohta, 1995, 2005; Zuengler & Miller, 2006). Thus,
the theory considers the connections between the socio-cultural aspects and cognitive linguistic.
Moreover, the Vygotskian approach takes into consideration the necessary conditions of the
processes of SLA. The conditions of second language acquisition are considered in terms of the
zone of proximate development and consist of already existing knowledge, the social interaction,
and the transformation of the external processes into cognitive ones (Anton et al., 1999; Brooks
& Donato, 1994; Kinginger, 2002; Lantolf, 2006; Nassaji & Cumming, 2000; Ohta, 1995, 2005).
Within the contours of the socio-cultural/cognitive processes and conditions more issues
are considered. Such as private speech that mediates and regulates mental functions in complex
cognitive tasks as well as facilitates the internalization of mental functions. As a result, second
19. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 19
language learners become self-regulated in the process of private speech turning into inner
speech (Anton et al., 1999; Appel & Lantolf, 1994; Lantolf, 2006a, 2006b, 1994; McCafferty,
1994, 1992).
Also, in connection with private speech, the role of L1 in acquisition of the target
language is considered. According to Vygotsky, the higher cognitive development originates in
social interaction by means of psychological and communicative tools. Because the native
language (L1) is one of the critical tools in bringing already existing knowledge to the social
interaction and in transforming the external processes into cognitive functions, the role of L1 in
second language acquisition is beneficial in solving meaning-based language tasks (Anton et el.,
1999; Brooks, Donato & McGlone, 1997; Lantolf, 2006; Tin, 2011).
Finally, Vygotskian theory creates perspectives for future research in the field of the
theory of SLA. Some aspects that remain to be established are: the connections between the
socio-cultural processes and cognitive linguistic ones in terms of the zone of proximate
development and private speech, the further theoretical explanation of scaffolding through the
concept of regulation, the transmission of cultural knowledge as socially based bringing second
language acquisition to the pragmatic level (Anton et al., 1999; Lantolf, 2006a, 2006b, 1994;
McCafferty, 1994, 1992; Nassaji and Swain, 2000; Schinke-Llano, 1993; Ohta, 1995, 2000;
Tarone & Swain, 1995)
20. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 20
References
Anton, M., & Dicamilla, F. J. (1999). Socio-cognitive functions of L1 collaborative interaction in
the L2 classroom. The Modern Language Journal, 83(2), 233-247. Retrieved from
Appel, G., & Lantolf, J. P. (1994). Speaking as mediation: A study of L1 and L2 text recall tasks.
The Modern Language Journal, 78(4), 437-452.
Brooks, F. B., & Donato, R. (1994). Vygotskyan approaches to understanding foreign language
learner discourse during communicative tasks. Hispania, 77(2), pp. 262-274.
Brooks, F. B., Donato, R., & McGlonem, J. V. (1997). When are they going to say ?it? right?
understanding learner talk during pair-work activity. Foreign Language Annals, 30(4), 524-
541. doi:10.1111/j.1944-9720.1997.tb00860.x
Donato, R., & Mccormick, D. (1994). A sociocultural perspective on language learning
strategies: The role of mediation. Modern Language Journal, 78(4), 453.
Evensen, L. S. (2007). 'With a little help from my friends'? theory of learning in applied
linguistics and SLA. Journal of Applied Linguistics, 4(3), 333-353.
Frawley, W., & Lantolf, J. P. (1985; 1985). Second language discourse: A vygotskyan
perspective. Applied Linguistics, 6(1), 19-44.
Kinginger, C. (2002). Defining the zone of proximal development in US foreign language
education. Applied Linguistics, 23(2), 240-261.
21. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 21
Lantolf, J. P. (2006). Sociocultural theory and L2: State of the art. Studies in Second Language
Acquisition, 28(1), 67-109.
Lantolf, J. P. (2006). Language emergence: Implications for applied linguistics-A sociocultural
perspective. Applied Linguistics, 27(4), 717-728.
McCafferty, S. G. (1994). Adult second language learners' use of private speech: A review of
studies. The Modern Language Journal, 78(4), 421-436.
McCafferty, S. G. (1992). The use of private speech by adult second language learners: A cross-
cultural study. The Modern Language Journal, 76(2), 179-189.
McCafferty, S. G., Roebuck, R. F., & Wayland, R. P. (2001). Activity theory and the incidental
learning of second-language vocabulary. Language Awareness, 10(4), 289-294.
Nassaji, H., & Cumming, A. (2000). What’s in a ZPD? A case study of a young ESL student and
teacher interacting through dialogue journals. Language Teaching Research, 4(2), 95-121.
Nassaji, H. (2006). [Vygotsky's and A. A. leontiev's semiotics and psycholinguistics]. Modern
Language Journal, 90(1), 133-134.
Nassaji, H., & Swain, M. (2000). A vygotskian perspective on corrective feedback in L2: The
effect of random versus negotiated help on the learning of english articles Taylor & Francis
Ltd.
Ohta, A. S. (2005). Interlanguage pragmatics in the zone of proximal development. System,
33(3), 503-517. doi:10.1016/j.system.2005.06.001
22. Reilly_Vygotsky’s Socio-Cultural Theory in SLA 22
Ohta, A. S. (1995; 1995). Applying sociocultural theory to an analysis of learner discourse:
Learner-learner collaborative interaction in the zone of proximal development. Issues in
Applied Linguistics, 6(2), 93-121.
Schinke-Llano, L. (1993). On the value of a vygotskian framework for SLA theory and research.
Language Learning, 43(1), 121-129.
Thorne, S. L. (2005). Epistemology, politics, and ethics in sociocultural theory. The Modern
Language Journal, 89(3), 393-409.
Tin, T. B. (2011). Language creativity and co-emergence of form and meaning in creative
writing tasks. Applied Linguistics (Oxford), 32(2), 215-235.
Zuengler, J., & Miller, E. R. (2006). Cognitive and sociocultural perspectives: Two parallel SLA
worlds? TESOL Quarterly, 40(1), 35-58.