Skip to main content
Making Progress
Moving Forward with the Progress Report
A Few Reminders . . .
adapted from Thomas R. Guskey

Grading and Reporting are not
essential to the instructional/
learning process.
Teachers can teach without grades and reports.

   Students can and do learn without grades.
A Few Reminders . . .
Checking and feedback
are essential.
 Checking and feedback are diagnostic.
     - The teacher is an advocate.

         Grading is evaluative.
        - The teacher is a judge
A Few Reminders . . .
No one method of grading and
reporting serves all purposes
well.
      Recognize growth and progress.
  Identify areas of strength and challenge.
   Help chart path for continued learning.
Provide a "snapshot" of the student's growth.
A Few Reminders . . .
Method follows Purpose
    Multiple purposes require a ...

            Multi-faceted
           Comprehensive
          Reporting system
A Few Reminders . . .
The progress report is but one
way of communicating with
you about your child's
progress.
Formal/informal notes, student work, Family
    Conferences, portfolios, exhibitions,
conversations, weekly emails, homework . . .
A Few Reminders . . .

Grading and reporting
progress always involves
some degree of subjectivity.
A Few Reminders . . .
Reporting is more subjective
the more detailed and
analytical it is.
  More detailed and analytic
      reports are better
        learning tools.
5 Myths about Grading
Grades should provide the
basis for differentiating
students
         Select talent
      or develop talent?
5 Myths about Grading
Grade distributions should
resemble a normal bell-
shaped curve
      Random events
    or a purposeful and
      intentional act?
5 Myths about Grading
Grades should be based on
students' standing among
classmates
Peer-driven and competitive or
   criterion-based (rigorous,
challenging, and transparent)?
5 Myths about Grading
Poor grades prompt students
to try harder.
    Where's the motivation?
       Risk aversion and
       gaming the system
5 Myths about Grading
Students should receive one
grade for each subject or
course
    A confounded "hodgepodge grade"
•   Final projects, papers, and tests count for 50%
•   Quizzes and Homework count for 20%
•   Classwork and Conduct count for 30%
           Product/Process/Progress
Our Guiding Principles
•   CLARITY
    (for teachers, students and families)
•   Grounded in what is actually ASSESSED
    (skills and content)
•   Reflects an orientation to GROWTH
    (not all will move at the same pace)
•   Commitment to ensuring that ALL
    STUDENTS meet expectations
•   Recognizes performance that EXCEEDS
    EXPECTATIONS
Year-Long Skills/Content
•   We will report progress on the following scale
    Still Emerging, Meeting, Exceeding.
•   We will no longer use the number scale 1-4.
•   We will continue to use the shared items across
    all subjects for classwork, homework and
    conduct.
•   If there is an "Area of Concern" the teacher will
    report directly to families to discuss plans.
•   Unless there is additional communcation from
    the teacher a rating of "Still Emerging" should
    be seen as consistent with expected growth.
Year-Long Skills/Content
Quarter Content & Skills
•   These are the drivers of the report.
•   They reflect what was assessed/worked on
    during the quarter.
•   They are worded to reflect the actual skill/
    content that was addressed.
•   Will not be reported on the 1-4 scale, but
    rather as "Still Emerging" or "Meets Grade
    Level Expectations."
•   Those skills that "Exceed Expectations" will be
    reported separately on the report.
Quarter Content & Skills
Quarter Content & Skills
Quarter Content & Skills
•   Students and teachers will continue to work on
    skills that are "Still Emerging" until work "Meets
    Expectations"
•   In some cases, this will happen within the
    regular flow of the curriculum.
•   In some cases, the student may need to
    continue to work on the skill outside of the
    curriculum (i.e., IWP).
•   In either case, the teachers will continue to
    monitor and assess performance in this area
    until the expectation is met.
Quarter Content & Skills
Quarter Content & Skills
The Progress Report
Other elements:
•   Each quarter contains a curriculum statement that
    provides a narrative account of work completed
    during the quarter.
•   The second and third quarters provide a teacher
    comment on student progress.
•   The fourth quarter includes a comment by the
    student on her/his progress.
•   The fourth quarter also contains a comment from
    the student's advisor.
On Grading
Questionable Practices
•   Averaging to obtain a course grade
•   Across-the-board averaging on all
    assignments
•   Giving zeros for work missed or work turned
    in late
•   Giving partial credit for corrections
•   Giving "extra" credit unrelated to class
    objectives
•   Taking credit away from students for
    behavioral infractions
Alternatives
• Give priority to the most recent
  evidence
• Give priority to the most
  comprehensive evidence
• Give priority to evidence related
  to the most important learning
  goals and expectations
Family Conferences
Goal: To arrive at a holistic
understanding of the
student’s learning
experience.
The conferences will address, in a general sense,
the student’s work to date in all of her/his classes.
Family Conferences
•   Advisors will help students prepare
•   Students are active participants
•   Students share specific work samples
    and address specific areas of strength
    and challenge.
•   The conference will run about 30-40
    minutes.
•   The student's agenda for the
    conference
    comes first.
Family Conferences
• o"Areas of Concern"
      Subject area teachers will contact you prior to the conferences
    o You can alway contact the advisor and/or teacher

•   Contact the advisor if there are any particular issues
    that you would like to discuss.
•   Subject area teachers will also be available for brief
    5-10-minute meetings on conference days
•   If there is a specific issue/question that comes up in a
    conference, the advisor may encourage you to reach
    out to the teacher in question who can best respond to
    the issue.