Process of Creative
              Regeneration
              Lecture on Corporate Creativity




                            WHERE GOOD
                            IDEAS COME
                             FROMS-4m


01-Oct-11              IMT - Management Creativity   1
LOGO                      Contents


       1.    THE PROBLEM-DRIVEN CREATIVITY

       2.    CREATIVITY & ITS MANAGEMENT




 01-Oct-11           IMT - Management Creativity   2
THE PROBLEM-DRIVEN
                 CREATIVITY




01-Oct-11          IMT - Management Creativity   3
LOGO               Problem Example

    A lift in a building is usually very crowded.
    You are being asked to submit a quotation for
    solving the problem.
    You could quote a new and larger lift. This requires
    major modifications to the building. Cost =
    $500,000.
    You are looking for a far cheaper solution:




 01-Oct-11           IMT - Management Creativity           4
LOGO

“Ask an impertinent question and you
are on the way to a pertinent answer”
                   [J. Bronowski, scientist]

       “Why?” followed by “So? ”
       Step-up using “Why?”
       “How?”
       “Unless?”

   [Petty 1997]

 01-Oct-11            IMT - Management Creativity   5
LOGO         WHY-SO REASONING [Petty 1997]
   I need to reduce the
      waiting time for lifts.
   WHY?
                                            So, fit a new lift shaft.
   Because the lifts are
      inadequate.
   WHY?
   Because they are old-                     So, modernize them.
      fashioned.
   WHY?
   Because they are in an                     So, move to a new
      old-fashioned                                building.
      building.
 01-Oct-11               IMT - Management Creativity                    6
LOGO
 I need to reduce
 waiting time for lifts
                                 How?

                Well, I could reduce the
                use of the lift
                                                     How?
                                             By increasing the
                                             use of stairs


   Asking How?
  01-Oct-11           IMT - Management Creativity                7
LOGO            Step-up using “Why?”

 I need to reduce the waiting time for lifts.
 Why?
 Because people find waiting for the lift very frustrating.
 Why?
 Because they are bored.




 01-Oct-11            IMT - Management Creativity             8
LOGO         Side-stepping using “Unless?”


 I want to reduce the frustration of waiting.
 No! It is a nice rest to wait.
 Unless! you make waiting interesting by providing
    some sort of entertainment.




 01-Oct-11           IMT - Management Creativity     9
LOGO

I need to reduce the waiting time for lifts.
Unless I can get people to accept the waiting time in some
   way.
Either I need to reduce the waiting time for lifts.
Or .reduce the number of people using them.
Or .encourage alternative ways for people to get together.
Or put people who communicate with each other a lot on
     the same floor.
No! the waiting time is perfectly acceptable, stop fussing!
No! let’s make use of the time for corporate communications.
What about a notice board.

 01-Oct-11            IMT - Management Creativity         10
LOGO

   The lifts are inadequate.
   Unless I can speed them up
   Either the lifts are inadequate
   Or too many people are using them
   No! slow lifts are fine, they encourage informal
      communication.

   It is boring waiting.
   Unless you make it interesting.


 01-Oct-11           IMT - Management Creativity      11
LOGO
                                        Or!
                                      Unless!
                                                           Sidestep to another
        Keep stepping up
                                                           way of achieving
        until you discover
                                                           this goal
        your true goal




Why?


                                                            Step down to find
         I’ve hit                                           a way of achieving
         a difficulty                                       this in practice


 01-Oct-11                   IMT - Management Creativity                         12
LOGO




                                Problem: How would you attach
                                the candle to the wall,
             [Petty 1997]       with only the candle,
                                a book of matches and
                                a box of drawing pins.

 01-Oct-11          IMT - Management Creativity                 13
LOGO                 Problem            Problem
                     The candle is too The candle splits
                                                                          etc.
                     thick for the pins


           The
          Candle                                                   P
         Challenge                                    P

                              P


                                                           etc.
                                           P


                                                                  [Petty 1997]



 01-Oct-11              IMT - Management Creativity                        14
LOGO             Backtracking
                                                         Cliché t.
                                Conventional thinking   Solution
                 P
                            P                   P

                     Backtracking



                                                        Original
                                                        Solution
                                          P

  [Petty 1997]




 01-Oct-11             IMT - Management Creativity                 15
LOGO            Analogy [Petty 1997]
   If a lift were a train
      an announcer would tell you when it was about to
      arrive
      there would be stopping and express lifts
   If a lift were a bus
      there would be a timetable telling you what times
      past the hour the lift would arrive
      you would be able to see it coming and rush for it




 01-Oct-11           IMT - Management Creativity           16
LOGO         Random Association [Petty 1997]
 Edward de Bono suggests that you could choose a set
   of simple nouns at random from the dictionary and
   then work towards the the desired subject matter
   through random association.
 Suppose a student is looking for the subject for her
   painting entitled ‘Human Group’.




 01-Oct-11          IMT - Management Creativity     17
recite→poem or reading →group as an audience at
LOGO
     a poetry reading
   revelation →religious revelation →angel appearing
     to group of shepherds
   glove →hand →handshake →group of people
     meeting for the first time




 01-Oct-11          IMT - Management Creativity        18
LOGO         Random Association: Lift
                   Problem
   Fork →Branching into two →could each lift shaft
     have two lifts in it, one abobe and one below?
   Flow →Could peak flow of people to the lift be
     reduced by staggering working hours and
     lunchtimes?
   Fund →Could people be required to pay (to charity)
     for a badge enabling them to use the lift?




 01-Oct-11          IMT - Management Creativity         19
LOGO           Provocation [Petty 1997]
 A designer was working on a design for a flower pot
   that waters itself while the household is on holiday.
 →Suppose the plant could water itself:
   Could you put back the water evaporating from the
   plant’s leave back into the soil?
   Say, by putting a plastic cover on the leaves?




 01-Oct-11           IMT - Management Creativity           20
LOGO lift were a taxi
  If a
      you could call one up whenever you needed it,
      and it would tell you when it had arrived
   If a lift were a bicycle
      it would have a bell on it
      it would carry you there under your own steam,
      whenever you wanted to go (you could use the
      stairs)




 01-Oct-11              IMT - Management Creativity    21
LOGO




 01-Oct-11   IMT - Management Creativity   22
FROM CREATIVITY
             TO INNOVATION




                     4 Steps for Creative
                     Visualization-2m30



01-Oct-11        IMT - Management Creativity   23
LOGO



                                                                      Innovation
                                                                     The practical
                                                                     application of
                  Creativity                  Screening           such ideas towards
             The thinking process                 of                  meeting the
                that helps us                   ideas               organization’s
              to generate ideas
                                                                    objectives in a
                                                                         more
                                                                     effective way



                                                [Majaro 88]




 01-Oct-11                          IMT - Management Creativity                        24
LOGO         Screening Ideas (Examples)

 Criteria of Attractiveness         Criteria of Compatibility
   Originality                      Compatibility with
   Simplicity                         Company objectives
   User friendliness                  Availability of financial
   Ease of implementation             resources
   Elegance                           Corporate image
   Difficulty of copying              Ability to protect or patent
                                      Needs to solve problem



 01-Oct-11           IMT - Management Creativity                25
LOGO
                                                 Creativity (Idea Attractiveness)
                                                           High             Medium                Low
             Innovation (Idea Compatibility)
                                                                           Second               Doubtful
                                               High     Best ideas
                                                                          best ideas             ideas
                                               Medium




                                                          Second            Doubtful        Poor ideas
                                                         best ideas          ideas




                                                           Doubtful         Poor ideas          Poor ideas
                                               Low




                                                            ideas




 01-Oct-11                                                        IMT - Management Creativity                26
LOGO         AID TO IDEA SCREENING

                                    A                           B                              AxB
                                  Weight
                                            10   9   8    7    6    5    4
                                                                         0   3   2   1    0    Score

       Criteria of Evaluations
           (examples only.)         0.10
        Idea Attractiveness
        Ease of implementation
        Originality
        Sustainability

        User-friendliness

        Global acceptability
        Compatibility Criteria
                                  0.20
        Availability of finance
        Solutions to problems

        Our image
        Our ability to protect

          Our marketing competence

                                  1.00                                           Total Score


 01-Oct-11                                 IMT - Management Creativity                                 27
What you could do
LOGO
                  to become an innovator
       Develop a desire to create (invent).
       Channel mental energy into creating.
       Review magazines on innovations regularly.
       Become familiar with unusual phenomena.
       Familiarize with areas of science not included in your
       curriculum.
       Investigate products before discarding them.
       Improve hands-on working ability (hence the prescription
       of your basic training even though it is “boring”).
       Remember that opportunities arise as technology
       changes.
       Do not be in a hurry to become a manager.

 01-Oct-11               IMT - Management Creativity              28
LOGO

   How ‘you’ can improve ‘your creativity
       Keep track of your ideas at all times.
       Pose new questions everyday.
       Maintain competence in your field.
       Read widely in fields that are not directly related to your field of
       interest.
       Avoid rigid patterns of doing things.
       Be open and receptive to your own as well other’s ideas.
       Be alert in observation.
       Engage in creative hobbies (arts, crafts, puzzle solving, etc.).
       Improve your sense of humor and laugh easily.
       Adopt a risk taking attitude.
       Learn to know and understand yourself.
 01-Oct-11                   IMT - Management Creativity                      29
LOGO
                                                         Level of Creativity
                                              High             Medium              Low


                                                              Creative         Uncreative
                                            Winner
                                   High
                                                              Imitator         Plagiarist
             Level of Innovation

                                   Medium




                                             Creative          Average         Uncreative
                                             Innovator                          Bumbler




                                            Extravagantly      Creative            Loser
                                   Low




                                              Creative         Waster



 01-Oct-11                                           IMT - Management Creativity            30
LOGO         Organizational Barriers to Creativity
                                [Majaro 88]



       Lack of organizational ‘slack’
       Inadequate emphasis on ‘thinking’ compared to
       ‘doing’
       Bureaucracy
       Too centralized organizational structure
       Poor lateral communication
       The ‘imported talent’ syndrome
       ‘Bean-counting’



 01-Oct-11             IMT - Management Creativity     31
How can a manager promote
LOGO                 innovation/creativity

       Be willing to absorb the risks taken by subordinates.
       Be comfortable with half developed ideas.
       Be willing to stretch organizational policy.
       Be prepared to make quick decisions.
       Be a good listener.
       Do not dwell on mistakes.
       Focus and gear the pressure to goals.




 01-Oct-11              IMT - Management Creativity            32
How can a manager promote
LOGO                innovation/creativity


       Foster interpersonal contact.
       Give continuous feedback.
       Recognize the need for outside stimuli.
       Recognize creativity - publicly.
       Put up with some innocent foibles
       Maintain a balance between need for freedom and the
       necessity of structure.




 01-Oct-11             IMT - Management Creativity       33
LOGO

   In 1940s, D avid P ackard created
   the concept of M anagem ent by
   W alking A round (M B W A ). S ince
   the quality is achieved by great
   attention in each step. P ersonal
   involvem ent needs to be frequent,
   friendly ,       unfocused        and
   unscheduled. A nd one of the ideas
   of this principle is seek out people’s
   thoughts and opinions.
 01-Oct-11      IMT - Management Creativity   34
www.themegallery.com




                        Back to Orbit
                       A Song About
                      Innovation.6m06


01-Oct-11        IMT - Management Creativity   35

Process of Creative Regeneration: Lecture on Corporate Creativity

  • 1.
    Process of Creative Regeneration Lecture on Corporate Creativity WHERE GOOD IDEAS COME FROMS-4m 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 1
  • 2.
    LOGO Contents 1. THE PROBLEM-DRIVEN CREATIVITY 2. CREATIVITY & ITS MANAGEMENT 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 2
  • 3.
    THE PROBLEM-DRIVEN CREATIVITY 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 3
  • 4.
    LOGO Problem Example A lift in a building is usually very crowded. You are being asked to submit a quotation for solving the problem. You could quote a new and larger lift. This requires major modifications to the building. Cost = $500,000. You are looking for a far cheaper solution: 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 4
  • 5.
    LOGO “Ask an impertinentquestion and you are on the way to a pertinent answer” [J. Bronowski, scientist] “Why?” followed by “So? ” Step-up using “Why?” “How?” “Unless?” [Petty 1997] 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 5
  • 6.
    LOGO WHY-SO REASONING [Petty 1997] I need to reduce the waiting time for lifts. WHY? So, fit a new lift shaft. Because the lifts are inadequate. WHY? Because they are old- So, modernize them. fashioned. WHY? Because they are in an So, move to a new old-fashioned building. building. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 6
  • 7.
    LOGO I needto reduce waiting time for lifts How? Well, I could reduce the use of the lift How? By increasing the use of stairs Asking How? 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 7
  • 8.
    LOGO Step-up using “Why?” I need to reduce the waiting time for lifts. Why? Because people find waiting for the lift very frustrating. Why? Because they are bored. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 8
  • 9.
    LOGO Side-stepping using “Unless?” I want to reduce the frustration of waiting. No! It is a nice rest to wait. Unless! you make waiting interesting by providing some sort of entertainment. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 9
  • 10.
    LOGO I need toreduce the waiting time for lifts. Unless I can get people to accept the waiting time in some way. Either I need to reduce the waiting time for lifts. Or .reduce the number of people using them. Or .encourage alternative ways for people to get together. Or put people who communicate with each other a lot on the same floor. No! the waiting time is perfectly acceptable, stop fussing! No! let’s make use of the time for corporate communications. What about a notice board. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 10
  • 11.
    LOGO The lifts are inadequate. Unless I can speed them up Either the lifts are inadequate Or too many people are using them No! slow lifts are fine, they encourage informal communication. It is boring waiting. Unless you make it interesting. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 11
  • 12.
    LOGO Or! Unless! Sidestep to another Keep stepping up way of achieving until you discover this goal your true goal Why? Step down to find I’ve hit a way of achieving a difficulty this in practice 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 12
  • 13.
    LOGO Problem: How would you attach the candle to the wall, [Petty 1997] with only the candle, a book of matches and a box of drawing pins. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 13
  • 14.
    LOGO Problem Problem The candle is too The candle splits etc. thick for the pins The Candle P Challenge P P etc. P [Petty 1997] 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 14
  • 15.
    LOGO Backtracking Cliché t. Conventional thinking Solution P P P Backtracking Original Solution P [Petty 1997] 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 15
  • 16.
    LOGO Analogy [Petty 1997] If a lift were a train an announcer would tell you when it was about to arrive there would be stopping and express lifts If a lift were a bus there would be a timetable telling you what times past the hour the lift would arrive you would be able to see it coming and rush for it 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 16
  • 17.
    LOGO Random Association [Petty 1997] Edward de Bono suggests that you could choose a set of simple nouns at random from the dictionary and then work towards the the desired subject matter through random association. Suppose a student is looking for the subject for her painting entitled ‘Human Group’. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 17
  • 18.
    recite→poem or reading→group as an audience at LOGO a poetry reading revelation →religious revelation →angel appearing to group of shepherds glove →hand →handshake →group of people meeting for the first time 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 18
  • 19.
    LOGO Random Association: Lift Problem Fork →Branching into two →could each lift shaft have two lifts in it, one abobe and one below? Flow →Could peak flow of people to the lift be reduced by staggering working hours and lunchtimes? Fund →Could people be required to pay (to charity) for a badge enabling them to use the lift? 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 19
  • 20.
    LOGO Provocation [Petty 1997] A designer was working on a design for a flower pot that waters itself while the household is on holiday. →Suppose the plant could water itself: Could you put back the water evaporating from the plant’s leave back into the soil? Say, by putting a plastic cover on the leaves? 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 20
  • 21.
    LOGO lift werea taxi If a you could call one up whenever you needed it, and it would tell you when it had arrived If a lift were a bicycle it would have a bell on it it would carry you there under your own steam, whenever you wanted to go (you could use the stairs) 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 21
  • 22.
    LOGO 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 22
  • 23.
    FROM CREATIVITY TO INNOVATION 4 Steps for Creative Visualization-2m30 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 23
  • 24.
    LOGO Innovation The practical application of Creativity Screening such ideas towards The thinking process of meeting the that helps us ideas organization’s to generate ideas objectives in a more effective way [Majaro 88] 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 24
  • 25.
    LOGO Screening Ideas (Examples) Criteria of Attractiveness Criteria of Compatibility Originality Compatibility with Simplicity Company objectives User friendliness Availability of financial Ease of implementation resources Elegance Corporate image Difficulty of copying Ability to protect or patent Needs to solve problem 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 25
  • 26.
    LOGO Creativity (Idea Attractiveness) High Medium Low Innovation (Idea Compatibility) Second Doubtful High Best ideas best ideas ideas Medium Second Doubtful Poor ideas best ideas ideas Doubtful Poor ideas Poor ideas Low ideas 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 26
  • 27.
    LOGO AID TO IDEA SCREENING A B AxB Weight 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 0 3 2 1 0 Score Criteria of Evaluations (examples only.) 0.10 Idea Attractiveness Ease of implementation Originality Sustainability User-friendliness Global acceptability Compatibility Criteria 0.20 Availability of finance Solutions to problems Our image Our ability to protect Our marketing competence 1.00 Total Score 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 27
  • 28.
    What you coulddo LOGO to become an innovator Develop a desire to create (invent). Channel mental energy into creating. Review magazines on innovations regularly. Become familiar with unusual phenomena. Familiarize with areas of science not included in your curriculum. Investigate products before discarding them. Improve hands-on working ability (hence the prescription of your basic training even though it is “boring”). Remember that opportunities arise as technology changes. Do not be in a hurry to become a manager. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 28
  • 29.
    LOGO How ‘you’ can improve ‘your creativity Keep track of your ideas at all times. Pose new questions everyday. Maintain competence in your field. Read widely in fields that are not directly related to your field of interest. Avoid rigid patterns of doing things. Be open and receptive to your own as well other’s ideas. Be alert in observation. Engage in creative hobbies (arts, crafts, puzzle solving, etc.). Improve your sense of humor and laugh easily. Adopt a risk taking attitude. Learn to know and understand yourself. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 29
  • 30.
    LOGO Level of Creativity High Medium Low Creative Uncreative Winner High Imitator Plagiarist Level of Innovation Medium Creative Average Uncreative Innovator Bumbler Extravagantly Creative Loser Low Creative Waster 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 30
  • 31.
    LOGO Organizational Barriers to Creativity [Majaro 88] Lack of organizational ‘slack’ Inadequate emphasis on ‘thinking’ compared to ‘doing’ Bureaucracy Too centralized organizational structure Poor lateral communication The ‘imported talent’ syndrome ‘Bean-counting’ 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 31
  • 32.
    How can amanager promote LOGO innovation/creativity Be willing to absorb the risks taken by subordinates. Be comfortable with half developed ideas. Be willing to stretch organizational policy. Be prepared to make quick decisions. Be a good listener. Do not dwell on mistakes. Focus and gear the pressure to goals. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 32
  • 33.
    How can amanager promote LOGO innovation/creativity Foster interpersonal contact. Give continuous feedback. Recognize the need for outside stimuli. Recognize creativity - publicly. Put up with some innocent foibles Maintain a balance between need for freedom and the necessity of structure. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 33
  • 34.
    LOGO In 1940s, D avid P ackard created the concept of M anagem ent by W alking A round (M B W A ). S ince the quality is achieved by great attention in each step. P ersonal involvem ent needs to be frequent, friendly , unfocused and unscheduled. A nd one of the ideas of this principle is seek out people’s thoughts and opinions. 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 34
  • 35.
    www.themegallery.com Back to Orbit A Song About Innovation.6m06 01-Oct-11 IMT - Management Creativity 35