This document discusses different types of group power dynamics:
- Compliance refers to obeying authority and conforming to group norms. Conformity can be more powerful than authority alone.
- Coalitions form when subgroups or individuals temporarily align to achieve mutual benefits or objectives, increasing their influence. Coalitions alter the balance of power in a group.
- Resistance is a covert form of noncompliance that can include strategic mistakes, forgetfulness, tardiness, and procrastination. It is important to confront resistance strategies and provide clear directions.
- Defiance is overt rebellion against attempts to induce compliance, which risks alienating others if not addressed properly depending on the norms.
2. Compliance
The process of consenting to the
dictates and desires of others.
Obedience to authority
Conformity to group norms
Conformity to group norms is sometimes more
powerful than authority
‘Code Red’ in USMC
Senior ‘Skip Day’ in high schools
3. Alliance: Coalition
Formation
An association of sub-groups and
(sometimes) individuals entered into for
their mutual benefit or to achieve a mutual
objective.
Must involve two or more sub-groups or individuals
Temporary in nature (i.e. until objective is achieved)
Increases influence of parties in a matter of mutual
importance
These temporary alliances are called coalitions
All coalitions are negotiated
Coalitions can change the distribution of power in a
group – and often do!
4. Coalitions & Power
Power is the central reason
for the formation of a
coalition
Increases the power of the
members
Control of the decisions of the
group
Formation of a coalition is
adversarial and contentious.
Alters balance of power in the
group
Communication is important
Poor communication lowers
enthusiasm
5. Resistance: ‘Foot Dragging’
Resistance is a covert form of
communicating non-compliance.
Non-cooperation is well hidden
Covert non-compliance
Subtle sabotage
Duplicitous and manipulative
Hard to identify
Outwardly sincere
Seemingly compliant
7. [Still more] Resistance
Strategies
Selective forgetting!
Only forget the distasteful
Tactical tardiness!
Late for reasons in person’s
control
Purposeful Procrastination
Putting tasks off repeatedly
‘Manana, manana!’
8. Coping with
Resistance
Confront the strategy
Identify the communication
Uncover hidden hostility
Find alternatives that work
Don’t encourage or
enable
Don’t do tasks for resisters
Begin meetings on time
Give specific directions
Write out what you want
Repeat and go over instructions
9. DEFIANCE!!!
Defiance is overt, not covert!
Audacious rebellion against attempts to induce compliance.
No ambiguity or subtlety!
10. Defiance continued…
Defiance can spread quickly
If one person acts in a defiant way, the numbers can
grow
Reactions to defiance vary depending
on the norms in play and which norms
are violated
Some norms are more important than others
Degree of deviation also affects group response
Defiance must be obvious – not inadvertant or
incidental
The person who is acting in a defiant
manner runs the risk of alienating the