ADJUVANT CHEMORADIATIONTHERAPY vs
RADIATION ALONE IN HIGH RISK
ENDOMETRIAL CANCER: PORTEC TRIAL -3
DR MEBANSHANBOR GAROD
(MS GENERAL SURGERY, FMAS,
FEBS SURGICAL ONCOLOGY)
SURGICAL ONCOLOGY DEPT.,
NEIGRIHMS, SHILLONG
FIGO Staging
Methods: open label, randomised trial.
Inclusion Criteria:
 High risk endometrial CA FIGO I
Endometroid type Grade 3 ;with deep endometrial invasion or LVSI
 Endometroid type stage II or III
 Clear or Serous types Stage I-III
 Parametrial invovlement
Exclusion Criteria:
 Uterine sarcoma/carcinosarcoma
 Prior endometrial Ca
 Previous pelvic RT/HRT/CT
 Bulky cervical involvement
 IBD
 Residual macroscopic tumor
 Impaired renal / cardiac function
 => grade 2 neuropathy
Patients Stratification:
Outcomes
Adverse Effects: CTCAE grading
Merits:
 Multicentric trial with strong international collaboration (six groups) : highly
representative of current world wide practice
 The primary endpoints were overall survival and failure free survival.
 The funding bodies had no role in the study design ;data collection,
interpratation, analysis, or writing of report
 Central pathology review was dine by reference gynaecopathologists
 Toxicity assessed by independent comittee using CTCAE
Limitations:
 Surgical staging varies
 Radiation dosage and types of radiation modalities not uniform
 Final outcomes / analysis were time based rather than events base; long
term outcomes needs to be analysed.
 Costs of CTRT in terms of toxicity and treatment duration needs to be
weighed against benefits
Conclusion:
 CTRT no overall survival benefit (5% );
5 year failure free survival 11% improvement
 Toxicities more in CTRT group: rapid recovery
 Response better in endometroid type: serous and clear cell types
associated with poorer prognosis
Summary
Risk groups for adjuvant Treatment:
 Low Risk : Endometroid IA, G-1/G2
NAT
 Low Intermediate Risk: Endometroid IB ; IC G1/G2
LND-> NAT, No LND->VBT
 High intermediate risk: stage IIA, IC or G3; LVI; >60 yrs,
LND-> VBT , No LND->EBRT
 High Risk Group: endometroi IC & G3; II B;serous or clear cell
EBRT , ? CTRT
Thank you...

PORTEC 3 trial

  • 1.
    ADJUVANT CHEMORADIATIONTHERAPY vs RADIATIONALONE IN HIGH RISK ENDOMETRIAL CANCER: PORTEC TRIAL -3 DR MEBANSHANBOR GAROD (MS GENERAL SURGERY, FMAS, FEBS SURGICAL ONCOLOGY) SURGICAL ONCOLOGY DEPT., NEIGRIHMS, SHILLONG
  • 2.
  • 14.
    Methods: open label,randomised trial.
  • 15.
    Inclusion Criteria:  Highrisk endometrial CA FIGO I Endometroid type Grade 3 ;with deep endometrial invasion or LVSI  Endometroid type stage II or III  Clear or Serous types Stage I-III  Parametrial invovlement
  • 16.
    Exclusion Criteria:  Uterinesarcoma/carcinosarcoma  Prior endometrial Ca  Previous pelvic RT/HRT/CT  Bulky cervical involvement  IBD  Residual macroscopic tumor  Impaired renal / cardiac function  => grade 2 neuropathy
  • 17.
  • 20.
  • 22.
  • 24.
    Merits:  Multicentric trialwith strong international collaboration (six groups) : highly representative of current world wide practice  The primary endpoints were overall survival and failure free survival.  The funding bodies had no role in the study design ;data collection, interpratation, analysis, or writing of report  Central pathology review was dine by reference gynaecopathologists  Toxicity assessed by independent comittee using CTCAE
  • 25.
    Limitations:  Surgical stagingvaries  Radiation dosage and types of radiation modalities not uniform  Final outcomes / analysis were time based rather than events base; long term outcomes needs to be analysed.  Costs of CTRT in terms of toxicity and treatment duration needs to be weighed against benefits
  • 26.
    Conclusion:  CTRT nooverall survival benefit (5% ); 5 year failure free survival 11% improvement  Toxicities more in CTRT group: rapid recovery  Response better in endometroid type: serous and clear cell types associated with poorer prognosis
  • 27.
    Summary Risk groups foradjuvant Treatment:  Low Risk : Endometroid IA, G-1/G2 NAT  Low Intermediate Risk: Endometroid IB ; IC G1/G2 LND-> NAT, No LND->VBT  High intermediate risk: stage IIA, IC or G3; LVI; >60 yrs, LND-> VBT , No LND->EBRT  High Risk Group: endometroi IC & G3; II B;serous or clear cell EBRT , ? CTRT
  • 28.