SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Dr Robert Senath Esuruku
Overview of the Presentation
• Introduction
• The PCI’s (PCDP- PRDP-ACCS Linkage; the ACCS PCIs and
the PRDP M&E framework.
• Methodology
• Consensus Panels, Key Informant Interviews , the leadership
rapid appraisal, the Perceptions Survey and validation meetings
• Results
• Recommendations
Peace and Conflict Indicators (PCIs)
• The PCIs are perceptual in nature and are 5 in numbers.
• Confidence in sustained peace and security.
• Local government responsiveness to community needs.
• Response of Dispute Resolution Mechanisms (DRMs) to SGBV
and community –level security disruptions.
• Accessed to increased economic opportunities.
• Competition and grievances between the PRDP regions and
between North and South of Uganda.
PCDP- PRDP-ACCS Linkage
• In December 2009, Department for International Development
(DFID) approved £100 million five year grant, under the Post-
Conflict Development Programme (PCDP) for Northern Uganda.
• PCDP is a comprehensive post-conflict recovery and
development programme, under the over-arching framework of
Peace Recovery and Development Plan (PRDP) for Northern
Uganda.
• The mandate of Advisory Consortium on Conflict Sensitivity
(ACCS) is to assist DFID to strengthen the potential of the PRDP
to address the causes of conflict and contribute to sustainable
peace and stability in Northern Uganda.
PCIs and PRDP Connection
• Monitoring Peace and Conflict Indicators (PCIs) started
in 2011 in Lango and Acholi.
• After the 2011 survey, the PCIs were modified and
adopted as part of the M&E framework for PRDP2.
• PRDP2 SO1; Consolidation of State Authority (sub
objective 1- Functional local government
administration: ‘% of respondents assessing that
local government is responsive to community
needs…..PCI 2.
Methodology
• Quantitative and Qualitative (Survey, Consensus
Penal, Key Informant Interviews ).
• In 2011 and 2012, we had 2 consensus penal at
district and 3 at sub county in each district.
• In 2013, we modified consensus penal (2 at the sub
county level ~ rural and urban). This a measure to
address mobilisation difficulties at the district level.
Methodology
• In 2011 and 2012, the consensus penal had only
district officers and security services.
• In 2013 and 2014 local CSOs and cultural leaders
were part of the consensus penal.
• 2011 to 2013, had a series of questions that guided
discussions.
• In 2014 we introduced a presentation the PCIs
results to guide consensus penal discussions.
Areas Covered and Sample Size
–Severely Affected: Acholi (Gulu, Amuru,
Kitgum, Lamwo) and Karamoja (Abim, Moroto,
Kotido)
–Sporadically Affected: Lango (Otuke, Lira) and
West Nile (Adjumani, Yumbe, Arua, Zombo)
–Spill Over Regions Bukedi (Tororo) Bunyoro
(Kiryandongo) Elgon (Mbale) Teso (Soroti,
Amuria)
–Control (Mbarara, Kasese, Masaka)
–Sample size 3982 in 2012, 3972 in 2013 and
4,233 in 2014
PCI 1: Confidence in sustained peace and security
Feeling safe and secure in the community
Annual Increase per region
Region Av. Change P-Value
Control 4.0 0.642
Severely Affected 2.5 0.212
Sporadically Affected 2.0 0.179
Spill Over 1.5 0.121
 Guns have fallen silent after 20 years of Anguish
 Crimes in the severely and sporadically affected regions have
reduced.
 People can move freely
 Few incidences of explosion of abandoned ordnances
 Conflicts between humans and spirits
 Conflicts between humans and animals
 Petty robbery
 Fear of transition
PCI 1: Confidence in sustained peace and security
Confidence in sustained peace and security
Region Av. Change P-Value
Severely Affected 9.0 0.081
Control 8.5 0.394
Spill Over 5.5 0.099
Sporadically Affected 5.0 0.212
Encouragement from NGOs, political, religious and cultural
leaders.
Presence of government institutions (Police, Judiciary,
Army).
Disarmament programme in Karamoja .
Return of business in Arua, Gulu, Lira , Soroti...
Fewer incidents of security disruptions (Lamwo, Moyo,
Elegu, Zombo, Arua , Adjumani).
Kony is still alive
Conflict in South Sudan
PCI 2 Local Government Responsiveness to community needs
Do the Local governments proved Social services in your communities?
Region Av. Change P-Value
Severely Affected 6.0 0.418
Sporadically Affected 0.5 0.846
Control 0.0 1.000
Spill Over -3.5 0.691
There is infrastructural development (schools, health
centres, feeder roads .
Extension of electricity and water points.
 Communities have not been involved in planning,
implementation and monitoring of projects.
Some local governments reported that they have been
sidelined by the OPM and line ministries i.e. construction
of houses for Acholi Chiefs, police posts.
Generally there is poor coordination.
PCI 3 SGBV and community level DRMs
Personal experience of SGBV
Region Av. Change P-Value
Control -27.5 0.333
Sporadically Affected -11.5 0.079
Spill Over -11.5 0.048
Severely Affected -8.0 0.136
Key drivers of SGBV include alcohol and drug abuse.
Polygamy in West Nile, Teso and Karamoja.
The belief that such acts are normal especially in the
control region and spill over .
Moral decay and lack of parental guidance especially in
the PRDP regions.
Men reclaiming and asserting their lost masculinities .
New culture – Female husbands.
PCI 3 SGBV and community level DMRs
Was the dispute resolved satisfactorily?
Region Av. Change P-Value
Spill Over 12.5 0.498
Sporadically Affected 8.5 0.452
Severely Affected 5.0 0.433
Control -7.5 0.512
Trust in clan, religious, cultural and lower local
government institutions.
There were material gains and love .
Perpetrators failure to respect ruling.
Failure by the DRM machinery to summon the
perpetrator.
In the control region, DRMs machineries ask for money.
PCI3b Response of DRMs to community level security disruptions
Personal involvement in conflict
Region Av. Change P-Value
Severely Affected -6.5 0.242
Spill Over -6.5 0.374
Control -4.5 0.198
Sporadically Affected -2 0.179
 NGOs, religious and cultural leaders advocate for
peace.
 We are tired of conflicts.
 We fear law enforcement officers.
 Its time to rebuild our lives.
 They cannot effectively resolve conflicts with spirits.
 Alcohol and drug abuse.
 Rampant land conflicts.
 Poverty and lack of employment.
PCI3b Response of DRMs to community level security disruptions
Access to justice by people in the community
Region Av. Change P-value
Control 14.0 0.179
Severely Affected 12.0 0.102
Spill Over 11.5 0.172
Sporadically Affected 7.0 0.293
 Formal justice system are available
 They are open to everyone
 NGOs help us to access justice
 There is discrimination and bribery especially in the
PRDP regions.
 Unjust court officials,
 High legal fees and
 Cases take to long to be resolved.
PCI 4 Economic Opportunities
Access to economic opportunities
Region Av change P-Value
Control 3.5 0.052
Severely Affected 1.0 0.846
Sporadically Affected -1.5 0.593
Spill Over -2.0 0.454
 Arua, Gulu, Lira and Soroti are booming, but we are
spectators.
 Investors are mainly outsider.
 We have limited access to economic opportunities.
 Agricultural products do not fetch a lot of money and
yet are labour intensive .
 We have limited skills .
 We are outcompeted by those who have connections
and are exposed.
PCI 4 Economic Opportunities
Satisfaction with government efforts in responding to the economic
needs of people
Region Av change P-Value
Severely Affected 8.5 0.065
Control 7.0 0.249
Spill Over 5.5 0.099
Sporadically Affected 5.0 -
 CDD, NAADS and NUSAF are good programees, but ltd.
 Limited vocational education services.
 Limited employable skills.
 Limited markets for agricultural products, especially in
the PRDP regions.
 Limited employment opportunities.
PCI 5 Competition and Grievance between North & South
Level of competition and grievance between the North & South
Region Av change P-Value
Control 8.0 0.046
Spill Over 3.0 0.740
Sporadically Affected 1.5 0.846
Severely Affected -0.5 0.948
 Political marginalisation
 High levels of poverty
 Social exclusion.
 Better infrastructure in South
 More vibrant economic activities in the South
PCI 5 Competition and Grievance between North and South
Is the government doing enough to bridge the gap between the north and
south of the country?
Region Av change P-Value
Control 11.5 0.357
Sporadically Affected 2.5 0.771
Spill Over 2.5 0.846
Severely Affected 1.0 0.891
 There are policy frameworks and guidelines
 There are some state machinery (Government officials,
police , judiciary
 Perceived sense of Marginalisation (political,
economic and social…).
 High levels of poverty
 High disease burden (HIV/AIDs, Hepatitis A,B,C,D,E ,
Nodding disease
 Unresolved border and land conflicts
Conclusions and Recommendations
• Concluding Remarks
– Does investment in infrastructure and state authority
alone address the root causes of the conflicts in NU?
– What will happen with PRDP if the implementation
does not balance community needs with
government interests?
– Do you think the implantation of PRDP will achieve its
purpose if it is spread beyond the war affected
districts?
– What roles should OPM and line ministries play in the
implementation of PRDP?
Conclusions and Recommendations
• Recommendations
– Graduate PRDP from a plan to a robust post conflict
development programme.
– PRDP should be driven by realities of the war affected
communities.
– It should have a strong focus to address conflict
drivers.
– OPM and line ministries should provide oversight
function.
– The implementation of PRDP should be done by local
governments, private sector and civil society
orgnisations.
PCI  Presentation Munyonyo

More Related Content

What's hot

Universal Basic Income
Universal Basic IncomeUniversal Basic Income
Universal Basic Income
Harsh Gupta
 
Neighbourhood Insight for Lambeth
Neighbourhood Insight for LambethNeighbourhood Insight for Lambeth
Neighbourhood Insight for Lambeth
Noel Hatch
 
Neighbourhood Insight for Norwood
Neighbourhood Insight for NorwoodNeighbourhood Insight for Norwood
Neighbourhood Insight for Norwood
Noel Hatch
 
Presentation Conference Dr. Jackie Maalouf-2
Presentation Conference Dr. Jackie Maalouf-2Presentation Conference Dr. Jackie Maalouf-2
Presentation Conference Dr. Jackie Maalouf-2
Dr. Jackie Kassouf Maalouf PhD
 
Case Simulation: Assessing HK's Mandatory Provident Fund for Retirement
Case Simulation: Assessing HK's Mandatory Provident Fund for RetirementCase Simulation: Assessing HK's Mandatory Provident Fund for Retirement
Case Simulation: Assessing HK's Mandatory Provident Fund for Retirement
Mark Raygan Garcia
 
ISBMohali
ISBMohaliISBMohali
A brief introduction to basic income
A brief introduction to basic incomeA brief introduction to basic income
A brief introduction to basic income
Citizen Network
 

What's hot (7)

Universal Basic Income
Universal Basic IncomeUniversal Basic Income
Universal Basic Income
 
Neighbourhood Insight for Lambeth
Neighbourhood Insight for LambethNeighbourhood Insight for Lambeth
Neighbourhood Insight for Lambeth
 
Neighbourhood Insight for Norwood
Neighbourhood Insight for NorwoodNeighbourhood Insight for Norwood
Neighbourhood Insight for Norwood
 
Presentation Conference Dr. Jackie Maalouf-2
Presentation Conference Dr. Jackie Maalouf-2Presentation Conference Dr. Jackie Maalouf-2
Presentation Conference Dr. Jackie Maalouf-2
 
Case Simulation: Assessing HK's Mandatory Provident Fund for Retirement
Case Simulation: Assessing HK's Mandatory Provident Fund for RetirementCase Simulation: Assessing HK's Mandatory Provident Fund for Retirement
Case Simulation: Assessing HK's Mandatory Provident Fund for Retirement
 
ISBMohali
ISBMohaliISBMohali
ISBMohali
 
A brief introduction to basic income
A brief introduction to basic incomeA brief introduction to basic income
A brief introduction to basic income
 

Viewers also liked

Қарапайым графикалық редакторы
Қарапайым графикалық редакторыҚарапайым графикалық редакторы
Қарапайым графикалық редакторы
Bilim All
 
Fishtail Ultra Flights - Corporate Identity - September 25 2013 v01
Fishtail Ultra Flights - Corporate Identity - September 25 2013 v01Fishtail Ultra Flights - Corporate Identity - September 25 2013 v01
Fishtail Ultra Flights - Corporate Identity - September 25 2013 v01
pratigya gautam
 
Fairfax 2015 World Police & Fire Games Official Athlete Entry Book
Fairfax 2015 World Police & Fire Games Official Athlete Entry BookFairfax 2015 World Police & Fire Games Official Athlete Entry Book
Fairfax 2015 World Police & Fire Games Official Athlete Entry Book
Robert Asperheim
 
English for emails
English for emailsEnglish for emails
English for emails
oscardiaztorres
 
Балабақшадағы шаралар
Балабақшадағы шараларБалабақшадағы шаралар
Балабақшадағы шаралар
Bilim All
 
Jeremy Resume
Jeremy ResumeJeremy Resume
Jeremy Resume
Jeremy Whelan
 
Thank you 3.5.2017
Thank you 3.5.2017Thank you 3.5.2017
Thank you 3.5.2017
Kevin Schafer
 
Еңбекке баулу
Еңбекке баулуЕңбекке баулу
Еңбекке баулу
Bilim All
 
사물인터넷 기본계획
사물인터넷 기본계획사물인터넷 기본계획
사물인터넷 기본계획
메가트렌드랩 megatrendlab
 
사물인터넷 실현을 위한 플랫폼 및 기술 동향
사물인터넷 실현을 위한 플랫폼 및 기술 동향사물인터넷 실현을 위한 플랫폼 및 기술 동향
사물인터넷 실현을 위한 플랫폼 및 기술 동향
메가트렌드랩 megatrendlab
 
사물 웹(Wot) 융합 기술 및 표준화 동향
사물 웹(Wot) 융합 기술 및 표준화 동향사물 웹(Wot) 융합 기술 및 표준화 동향
사물 웹(Wot) 융합 기술 및 표준화 동향
메가트렌드랩 megatrendlab
 
Tca-Trends Review 2016
Tca-Trends Review 2016Tca-Trends Review 2016
Tca-Trends Review 2016
The Cocktail Analysis
 
ашық сабақ. ұлттық тағамдар
ашық сабақ. ұлттық тағамдарашық сабақ. ұлттық тағамдар
ашық сабақ. ұлттық тағамдар
Asem Sarsembayeva
 
chemistry in modern life
chemistry in modern lifechemistry in modern life
chemistry in modern life
lephuong281095
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Қарапайым графикалық редакторы
Қарапайым графикалық редакторыҚарапайым графикалық редакторы
Қарапайым графикалық редакторы
 
Fishtail Ultra Flights - Corporate Identity - September 25 2013 v01
Fishtail Ultra Flights - Corporate Identity - September 25 2013 v01Fishtail Ultra Flights - Corporate Identity - September 25 2013 v01
Fishtail Ultra Flights - Corporate Identity - September 25 2013 v01
 
Fairfax 2015 World Police & Fire Games Official Athlete Entry Book
Fairfax 2015 World Police & Fire Games Official Athlete Entry BookFairfax 2015 World Police & Fire Games Official Athlete Entry Book
Fairfax 2015 World Police & Fire Games Official Athlete Entry Book
 
English for emails
English for emailsEnglish for emails
English for emails
 
Балабақшадағы шаралар
Балабақшадағы шараларБалабақшадағы шаралар
Балабақшадағы шаралар
 
Jeremy Resume
Jeremy ResumeJeremy Resume
Jeremy Resume
 
Thank you 3.5.2017
Thank you 3.5.2017Thank you 3.5.2017
Thank you 3.5.2017
 
Еңбекке баулу
Еңбекке баулуЕңбекке баулу
Еңбекке баулу
 
사물인터넷 기본계획
사물인터넷 기본계획사물인터넷 기본계획
사물인터넷 기본계획
 
사물인터넷 실현을 위한 플랫폼 및 기술 동향
사물인터넷 실현을 위한 플랫폼 및 기술 동향사물인터넷 실현을 위한 플랫폼 및 기술 동향
사물인터넷 실현을 위한 플랫폼 및 기술 동향
 
사물 웹(Wot) 융합 기술 및 표준화 동향
사물 웹(Wot) 융합 기술 및 표준화 동향사물 웹(Wot) 융합 기술 및 표준화 동향
사물 웹(Wot) 융합 기술 및 표준화 동향
 
Tca-Trends Review 2016
Tca-Trends Review 2016Tca-Trends Review 2016
Tca-Trends Review 2016
 
ашық сабақ. ұлттық тағамдар
ашық сабақ. ұлттық тағамдарашық сабақ. ұлттық тағамдар
ашық сабақ. ұлттық тағамдар
 
chemistry in modern life
chemistry in modern lifechemistry in modern life
chemistry in modern life
 

Similar to PCI Presentation Munyonyo

Assistant Secretary Jennifer Santiago Oreta, Office of the Presidential Advis...
Assistant Secretary Jennifer Santiago Oreta, Office of the Presidential Advis...Assistant Secretary Jennifer Santiago Oreta, Office of the Presidential Advis...
Assistant Secretary Jennifer Santiago Oreta, Office of the Presidential Advis...
Geneva Declaration
 
A river blue reviewed strategic plan
A river blue  reviewed strategic planA river blue  reviewed strategic plan
A river blue reviewed strategic plan
Okweny George Ongom
 
The Healthy African City
The Healthy African CityThe Healthy African City
The Healthy African City
Dr. Ebele Mogo
 
ECOVERVE5
ECOVERVE5ECOVERVE5
Integrative Session ATSI Contemp 2020 student copy (1).ppt
Integrative Session ATSI Contemp 2020 student copy (1).pptIntegrative Session ATSI Contemp 2020 student copy (1).ppt
Integrative Session ATSI Contemp 2020 student copy (1).ppt
ShivSookun
 
ECOVERVE5
ECOVERVE5ECOVERVE5
Institutional Reform and Capacity Building Project for Sierra Leone
Institutional Reform and Capacity Building Project for Sierra LeoneInstitutional Reform and Capacity Building Project for Sierra Leone
Institutional Reform and Capacity Building Project for Sierra Leone
Maxwell Korpoi
 
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
Global Development Institute
 
Culture clash - managing relationships between the public and private sectors
Culture clash - managing relationships between the public and private sectorsCulture clash - managing relationships between the public and private sectors
Culture clash - managing relationships between the public and private sectors
Association for Project Management
 
Session Six: Special Session On Conditional Grants Motivation And Issues, Mee...
Session Six: Special Session On Conditional Grants Motivation And Issues, Mee...Session Six: Special Session On Conditional Grants Motivation And Issues, Mee...
Session Six: Special Session On Conditional Grants Motivation And Issues, Mee...
OECDtax
 
Presentation on issues in piloting dl gs to district leaders november 2019-es...
Presentation on issues in piloting dl gs to district leaders november 2019-es...Presentation on issues in piloting dl gs to district leaders november 2019-es...
Presentation on issues in piloting dl gs to district leaders november 2019-es...
ENVIRONMENTALALERTEA1
 
Back to Basics Overview Presentation - North West Provincial Launch 2014
Back to Basics Overview Presentation - North West Provincial Launch 2014Back to Basics Overview Presentation - North West Provincial Launch 2014
Back to Basics Overview Presentation - North West Provincial Launch 2014
Departments: Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs
 
Strategic Environmental and Social Assessment (SESA) of REDD+ strategy, Nepal
Strategic Environmental and Social  Assessment (SESA) of REDD+ strategy, NepalStrategic Environmental and Social  Assessment (SESA) of REDD+ strategy, Nepal
Strategic Environmental and Social Assessment (SESA) of REDD+ strategy, Nepal
IIED
 
Kconquer
KconquerKconquer
Barrett-CTT National Values Assessment Headlines
Barrett-CTT National Values Assessment HeadlinesBarrett-CTT National Values Assessment Headlines
Barrett-CTT National Values Assessment Headlines
Phil Clothier
 
Decentralization and popular democracy - governance from below in bolivia
Decentralization and popular democracy  - governance from below in boliviaDecentralization and popular democracy  - governance from below in bolivia
Decentralization and popular democracy - governance from below in bolivia
Institute of Development Studies
 
Why disaster risk reduction is all our business
Why disaster risk reduction is all our businessWhy disaster risk reduction is all our business
Why disaster risk reduction is all our business
Lafir Mohamed
 
Why disaster risk reduction is all our business
Why disaster risk reduction is all our businessWhy disaster risk reduction is all our business
Why disaster risk reduction is all our business
Lafir Mohamed
 
Tourism swia consultations ppt final (english version) for upload
Tourism swia consultations ppt final (english version) for uploadTourism swia consultations ppt final (english version) for upload
Tourism swia consultations ppt final (english version) for upload
Ethical Sector
 
Oneplace - What We Said About Rural Norfolk
Oneplace - What We Said About Rural NorfolkOneplace - What We Said About Rural Norfolk
Oneplace - What We Said About Rural Norfolk
NorfolkRCC
 

Similar to PCI Presentation Munyonyo (20)

Assistant Secretary Jennifer Santiago Oreta, Office of the Presidential Advis...
Assistant Secretary Jennifer Santiago Oreta, Office of the Presidential Advis...Assistant Secretary Jennifer Santiago Oreta, Office of the Presidential Advis...
Assistant Secretary Jennifer Santiago Oreta, Office of the Presidential Advis...
 
A river blue reviewed strategic plan
A river blue  reviewed strategic planA river blue  reviewed strategic plan
A river blue reviewed strategic plan
 
The Healthy African City
The Healthy African CityThe Healthy African City
The Healthy African City
 
ECOVERVE5
ECOVERVE5ECOVERVE5
ECOVERVE5
 
Integrative Session ATSI Contemp 2020 student copy (1).ppt
Integrative Session ATSI Contemp 2020 student copy (1).pptIntegrative Session ATSI Contemp 2020 student copy (1).ppt
Integrative Session ATSI Contemp 2020 student copy (1).ppt
 
ECOVERVE5
ECOVERVE5ECOVERVE5
ECOVERVE5
 
Institutional Reform and Capacity Building Project for Sierra Leone
Institutional Reform and Capacity Building Project for Sierra LeoneInstitutional Reform and Capacity Building Project for Sierra Leone
Institutional Reform and Capacity Building Project for Sierra Leone
 
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
David Hulme: Can Social Protection Contribute to Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa...
 
Culture clash - managing relationships between the public and private sectors
Culture clash - managing relationships between the public and private sectorsCulture clash - managing relationships between the public and private sectors
Culture clash - managing relationships between the public and private sectors
 
Session Six: Special Session On Conditional Grants Motivation And Issues, Mee...
Session Six: Special Session On Conditional Grants Motivation And Issues, Mee...Session Six: Special Session On Conditional Grants Motivation And Issues, Mee...
Session Six: Special Session On Conditional Grants Motivation And Issues, Mee...
 
Presentation on issues in piloting dl gs to district leaders november 2019-es...
Presentation on issues in piloting dl gs to district leaders november 2019-es...Presentation on issues in piloting dl gs to district leaders november 2019-es...
Presentation on issues in piloting dl gs to district leaders november 2019-es...
 
Back to Basics Overview Presentation - North West Provincial Launch 2014
Back to Basics Overview Presentation - North West Provincial Launch 2014Back to Basics Overview Presentation - North West Provincial Launch 2014
Back to Basics Overview Presentation - North West Provincial Launch 2014
 
Strategic Environmental and Social Assessment (SESA) of REDD+ strategy, Nepal
Strategic Environmental and Social  Assessment (SESA) of REDD+ strategy, NepalStrategic Environmental and Social  Assessment (SESA) of REDD+ strategy, Nepal
Strategic Environmental and Social Assessment (SESA) of REDD+ strategy, Nepal
 
Kconquer
KconquerKconquer
Kconquer
 
Barrett-CTT National Values Assessment Headlines
Barrett-CTT National Values Assessment HeadlinesBarrett-CTT National Values Assessment Headlines
Barrett-CTT National Values Assessment Headlines
 
Decentralization and popular democracy - governance from below in bolivia
Decentralization and popular democracy  - governance from below in boliviaDecentralization and popular democracy  - governance from below in bolivia
Decentralization and popular democracy - governance from below in bolivia
 
Why disaster risk reduction is all our business
Why disaster risk reduction is all our businessWhy disaster risk reduction is all our business
Why disaster risk reduction is all our business
 
Why disaster risk reduction is all our business
Why disaster risk reduction is all our businessWhy disaster risk reduction is all our business
Why disaster risk reduction is all our business
 
Tourism swia consultations ppt final (english version) for upload
Tourism swia consultations ppt final (english version) for uploadTourism swia consultations ppt final (english version) for upload
Tourism swia consultations ppt final (english version) for upload
 
Oneplace - What We Said About Rural Norfolk
Oneplace - What We Said About Rural NorfolkOneplace - What We Said About Rural Norfolk
Oneplace - What We Said About Rural Norfolk
 

PCI Presentation Munyonyo

  • 2. Overview of the Presentation • Introduction • The PCI’s (PCDP- PRDP-ACCS Linkage; the ACCS PCIs and the PRDP M&E framework. • Methodology • Consensus Panels, Key Informant Interviews , the leadership rapid appraisal, the Perceptions Survey and validation meetings • Results • Recommendations
  • 3. Peace and Conflict Indicators (PCIs) • The PCIs are perceptual in nature and are 5 in numbers. • Confidence in sustained peace and security. • Local government responsiveness to community needs. • Response of Dispute Resolution Mechanisms (DRMs) to SGBV and community –level security disruptions. • Accessed to increased economic opportunities. • Competition and grievances between the PRDP regions and between North and South of Uganda.
  • 4. PCDP- PRDP-ACCS Linkage • In December 2009, Department for International Development (DFID) approved £100 million five year grant, under the Post- Conflict Development Programme (PCDP) for Northern Uganda. • PCDP is a comprehensive post-conflict recovery and development programme, under the over-arching framework of Peace Recovery and Development Plan (PRDP) for Northern Uganda. • The mandate of Advisory Consortium on Conflict Sensitivity (ACCS) is to assist DFID to strengthen the potential of the PRDP to address the causes of conflict and contribute to sustainable peace and stability in Northern Uganda.
  • 5. PCIs and PRDP Connection • Monitoring Peace and Conflict Indicators (PCIs) started in 2011 in Lango and Acholi. • After the 2011 survey, the PCIs were modified and adopted as part of the M&E framework for PRDP2. • PRDP2 SO1; Consolidation of State Authority (sub objective 1- Functional local government administration: ‘% of respondents assessing that local government is responsive to community needs…..PCI 2.
  • 6. Methodology • Quantitative and Qualitative (Survey, Consensus Penal, Key Informant Interviews ). • In 2011 and 2012, we had 2 consensus penal at district and 3 at sub county in each district. • In 2013, we modified consensus penal (2 at the sub county level ~ rural and urban). This a measure to address mobilisation difficulties at the district level.
  • 7. Methodology • In 2011 and 2012, the consensus penal had only district officers and security services. • In 2013 and 2014 local CSOs and cultural leaders were part of the consensus penal. • 2011 to 2013, had a series of questions that guided discussions. • In 2014 we introduced a presentation the PCIs results to guide consensus penal discussions.
  • 8. Areas Covered and Sample Size –Severely Affected: Acholi (Gulu, Amuru, Kitgum, Lamwo) and Karamoja (Abim, Moroto, Kotido) –Sporadically Affected: Lango (Otuke, Lira) and West Nile (Adjumani, Yumbe, Arua, Zombo) –Spill Over Regions Bukedi (Tororo) Bunyoro (Kiryandongo) Elgon (Mbale) Teso (Soroti, Amuria) –Control (Mbarara, Kasese, Masaka) –Sample size 3982 in 2012, 3972 in 2013 and 4,233 in 2014
  • 9.
  • 10. PCI 1: Confidence in sustained peace and security Feeling safe and secure in the community Annual Increase per region Region Av. Change P-Value Control 4.0 0.642 Severely Affected 2.5 0.212 Sporadically Affected 2.0 0.179 Spill Over 1.5 0.121  Guns have fallen silent after 20 years of Anguish  Crimes in the severely and sporadically affected regions have reduced.  People can move freely  Few incidences of explosion of abandoned ordnances  Conflicts between humans and spirits  Conflicts between humans and animals  Petty robbery  Fear of transition
  • 11. PCI 1: Confidence in sustained peace and security Confidence in sustained peace and security Region Av. Change P-Value Severely Affected 9.0 0.081 Control 8.5 0.394 Spill Over 5.5 0.099 Sporadically Affected 5.0 0.212 Encouragement from NGOs, political, religious and cultural leaders. Presence of government institutions (Police, Judiciary, Army). Disarmament programme in Karamoja . Return of business in Arua, Gulu, Lira , Soroti... Fewer incidents of security disruptions (Lamwo, Moyo, Elegu, Zombo, Arua , Adjumani). Kony is still alive Conflict in South Sudan
  • 12. PCI 2 Local Government Responsiveness to community needs Do the Local governments proved Social services in your communities? Region Av. Change P-Value Severely Affected 6.0 0.418 Sporadically Affected 0.5 0.846 Control 0.0 1.000 Spill Over -3.5 0.691 There is infrastructural development (schools, health centres, feeder roads . Extension of electricity and water points.  Communities have not been involved in planning, implementation and monitoring of projects. Some local governments reported that they have been sidelined by the OPM and line ministries i.e. construction of houses for Acholi Chiefs, police posts. Generally there is poor coordination.
  • 13.
  • 14. PCI 3 SGBV and community level DRMs Personal experience of SGBV Region Av. Change P-Value Control -27.5 0.333 Sporadically Affected -11.5 0.079 Spill Over -11.5 0.048 Severely Affected -8.0 0.136 Key drivers of SGBV include alcohol and drug abuse. Polygamy in West Nile, Teso and Karamoja. The belief that such acts are normal especially in the control region and spill over . Moral decay and lack of parental guidance especially in the PRDP regions. Men reclaiming and asserting their lost masculinities . New culture – Female husbands.
  • 15.
  • 16. PCI 3 SGBV and community level DMRs Was the dispute resolved satisfactorily? Region Av. Change P-Value Spill Over 12.5 0.498 Sporadically Affected 8.5 0.452 Severely Affected 5.0 0.433 Control -7.5 0.512 Trust in clan, religious, cultural and lower local government institutions. There were material gains and love . Perpetrators failure to respect ruling. Failure by the DRM machinery to summon the perpetrator. In the control region, DRMs machineries ask for money.
  • 17. PCI3b Response of DRMs to community level security disruptions Personal involvement in conflict Region Av. Change P-Value Severely Affected -6.5 0.242 Spill Over -6.5 0.374 Control -4.5 0.198 Sporadically Affected -2 0.179  NGOs, religious and cultural leaders advocate for peace.  We are tired of conflicts.  We fear law enforcement officers.  Its time to rebuild our lives.  They cannot effectively resolve conflicts with spirits.  Alcohol and drug abuse.  Rampant land conflicts.  Poverty and lack of employment.
  • 18. PCI3b Response of DRMs to community level security disruptions Access to justice by people in the community Region Av. Change P-value Control 14.0 0.179 Severely Affected 12.0 0.102 Spill Over 11.5 0.172 Sporadically Affected 7.0 0.293  Formal justice system are available  They are open to everyone  NGOs help us to access justice  There is discrimination and bribery especially in the PRDP regions.  Unjust court officials,  High legal fees and  Cases take to long to be resolved.
  • 19.
  • 20. PCI 4 Economic Opportunities Access to economic opportunities Region Av change P-Value Control 3.5 0.052 Severely Affected 1.0 0.846 Sporadically Affected -1.5 0.593 Spill Over -2.0 0.454  Arua, Gulu, Lira and Soroti are booming, but we are spectators.  Investors are mainly outsider.  We have limited access to economic opportunities.  Agricultural products do not fetch a lot of money and yet are labour intensive .  We have limited skills .  We are outcompeted by those who have connections and are exposed.
  • 21. PCI 4 Economic Opportunities Satisfaction with government efforts in responding to the economic needs of people Region Av change P-Value Severely Affected 8.5 0.065 Control 7.0 0.249 Spill Over 5.5 0.099 Sporadically Affected 5.0 -  CDD, NAADS and NUSAF are good programees, but ltd.  Limited vocational education services.  Limited employable skills.  Limited markets for agricultural products, especially in the PRDP regions.  Limited employment opportunities.
  • 22.
  • 23. PCI 5 Competition and Grievance between North & South Level of competition and grievance between the North & South Region Av change P-Value Control 8.0 0.046 Spill Over 3.0 0.740 Sporadically Affected 1.5 0.846 Severely Affected -0.5 0.948  Political marginalisation  High levels of poverty  Social exclusion.  Better infrastructure in South  More vibrant economic activities in the South
  • 24. PCI 5 Competition and Grievance between North and South Is the government doing enough to bridge the gap between the north and south of the country? Region Av change P-Value Control 11.5 0.357 Sporadically Affected 2.5 0.771 Spill Over 2.5 0.846 Severely Affected 1.0 0.891  There are policy frameworks and guidelines  There are some state machinery (Government officials, police , judiciary  Perceived sense of Marginalisation (political, economic and social…).  High levels of poverty  High disease burden (HIV/AIDs, Hepatitis A,B,C,D,E , Nodding disease  Unresolved border and land conflicts
  • 25. Conclusions and Recommendations • Concluding Remarks – Does investment in infrastructure and state authority alone address the root causes of the conflicts in NU? – What will happen with PRDP if the implementation does not balance community needs with government interests? – Do you think the implantation of PRDP will achieve its purpose if it is spread beyond the war affected districts? – What roles should OPM and line ministries play in the implementation of PRDP?
  • 26. Conclusions and Recommendations • Recommendations – Graduate PRDP from a plan to a robust post conflict development programme. – PRDP should be driven by realities of the war affected communities. – It should have a strong focus to address conflict drivers. – OPM and line ministries should provide oversight function. – The implementation of PRDP should be done by local governments, private sector and civil society orgnisations.