Drs. Ing. C.J. (Cees) Brouwer vice president Open University Netherlands  Educa Berlin, November 3 - 5, 2008 Open Educational Resources : the Dutch Lifelong Learning case  and a Business Case perspective
Agenda Mission Open University NL OpenER project characteristics Results Lessons learned Future strategy Open University NL Business model Customer life and study cycle
Mission OUNL OUNL develops, delivers, and advances high-quality and innovative higher education distance learning, collaborating in networks and alliances Being the University for Lifelong learners OUNL highlights the diverse learning needs of people in their course of life and the necessity to considerably increase the knowledge and competence level in society
OpenER - project launched december 2006 with grants NL-Ministry and Education Hewlett Foundation more access  non-traditional groups  to Higher Education (HE) extend opportunities for  lifelong learning  using an e-learning approach lowering  existing  thresholds : institutional, formal, financial, social,  time, place, pace making  access easy  and  attractive transfer gradually from  informal   to   formal  learning much attention from the media, education stakeholders and the (inter)national scientific and professional community
OpenER - Characteristics High-quality and attractive self-study learning materials Small course unit size (25 hours, some 4 hours) Some courses offer self-tests or are linked to TV-programmes Open and flexible in its most ultimate form Opportunities for formal testing  (not for free!)  and certification as a starting point for a full study Dutch language being used (no English …) Efficient explorative step-by-step investment in time / effort (not in money): temptation approach Research, evaluation and effect measurements
OpenER – the site:www.opener.ou.nl
OpenER - impressions Running term  extended from Dec. 2007 to June 2008 (with same budget!) Outcomes exceed intentions number of courses 15 (now), 16 (intended), 25 (expected) Outcomes outrange targets > 550.000 unique visits of website since launch (end 2006) 60% of the visitors did not participate in HE before  over 4400 registered learners OER offered affects future choices (1500 filled questionnaires) 37% has plans for buying courses on the level of HE of existing OU-students 69% indicated that this project affects  their further study plans 10% of actually newly registered students via OpenER (Spring 2008)
OpenER - general survey results Age, HE participation, visitors 71% of population aged 25-55  yrs 43% didn’t participate in HE before 73% returning visitors Reasons for visit (>1 choice) 61% follow a free course 21% ability test on university level   44% try-out of a study at OUNL 5% reuse material in own courses Use of materials 20% did not look through  any course 37% browsed through a  course 43% studied a course Study plans 75% not involved in any formal learning 17% intends to start a formal study in HE 37% intends to buy courses on HE level 87% indicates that OpenER affects their further study plans
OpenER - course related surveys Two types of forms, since August: 643 of type A: only looked through introduction 156 of type B: studied most of the material Some results type A (80% population) Why do you visit this website? 37% free course 35% test for level 31% curiosity Does this course meet your expectations? 97% yes (e.g. self study,interesting, . . .) Some results type B (20% population) 45% first time visitor 50% less than HE level  81% course meets expectations 66% completed the course 54% wants to do formal examination (not for free) 69% influenced by OpenER in study plans (of which 3%: I do NOT want to study)
OpenER - lessons learned Support of  top management  (deans of the OUNL Schools) is crucial for progress / success Setup separate  from regular operations, keep it ‘small’, manageable and technologically simple Identify OER  champions , extend their enthusiasm to others and build on feelings of  competition  between the Schools Rely on quality awareness and  competency  of OUNL course developers and offer  maximum support  for content processing External  funding  helps in this respect
OpenER - future strategy OUNL executive board positive attitude towards OER scenario Minimum scenario: continue OpenER approach, with further funding externally or (partly) by the OUNL marketing budget Advanced scenario: (a) All OUNL learning materials in OER (major government funding …), or (b) a new OER Initiative? dependencies national LLL policy , and  business model  adaptations
Business model – a customer focus Productview Bachelors and masters of science, professional masters, single courses, mini modules Learning experiences, knowledge enrichment Services, services and services Form, medium, price/performance Marketview students! Students?? Paying customers! Business mgt, HRM strategy Other involvement, result driven within a short period of time, LLL packages INFRASTRUCTURE CORE CAPABILITIES VALUE CONFIGURATION PARTNER NETWORK OFFER VALUE PROPOSITION CUSTOMER TARGET CUSTOMER DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP FINANCE COST  STRUCTURE DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL
The customer in the centre The driver for all interaction with the student is  the context of the student The student is located in a specific  “phase of life”   with specifc needs Motivation to study is connected with these phases: Personal development, to work on competences, for your own good of your job Carreer Knowledge development A student finds himself also in a certain phase of  the “ study cycle” In a life time a student can have more than one  study cycle:  ‘life-long-learning’ * Circle of Life, TNO Informatie- en Communicatietechnologie Choose Order Orientation Receive Study
A life long learning: learn to learn, learn to choose, learn to ‘grow’, learn to share, learn to experience Circle of Life: Phases of lyfe for the future needs teenagers study single starter single carreer living together carreer family with young children family with teenagers empty nesters pensioner experience becomes seriousness want to learn want to learn want to learn experience becomes seriousness experience becomes seriousness build up CV build up CV build up CV flexible offer flexible offer flexible offer fast & short fast & short fast & short mental fittness mental fittness mental fittness mental fitness comfort spare time social benefit in local area in local area comfort comfort carreer offer community community community initial  info - sources initial info-sources personalised edu offer personalised education offer personalised education ofer personalised education offer carreer offer carreer offer added  value services added  value services added  value services added value services added value services
Circel of life – learning moments Schoolcontext tertiair secundair primair course Working context Other contexts Informal  learning activity Nonformal  learning activity course course course course course course work Education  Nonformal  learning activity Nonformal  learning activity Nonformal  learning activity Nonformal  learning activity Nonformal  learning activity Nonformal  learning activity Nonformal  learning activity Informal  learning activity Informal  learning activity Informal  learning activity Informal  learning activity Informal  learning activity Informal  learning activity Informal  learning activity Informal  learning activity course time frame portfolio  target personal  development  plan OUNL BaMa
Three Interaction themes with students The needs of (potential) students translated in three interaction themes: Per theme different instruments Choice of instrument per targetgroup The OU knows me ‘ Personal’ Interaction in line with  customer needs I am connected ‘ Study together’ Fysical and virtual contact  with students and teachers The OU will follow me ‘ Contact’ We will be in contact  before, during and after  your study period
The OU knows me –  ‘Personal’ Personal study advice Personal bookmarks Other students who choose this course, did also choose..*  Tailor made brochure* Tips; interesting information as meetings, activities and news on courses (SMS, RSS, e-mail) Ordering interesting book with discount What about my order? (personal page) Call me*, (video)chat Contact with students  Podcast/vodcast of colleges My studyplanner Course reviews/testimonials by fellowstudenten* Make your own choice how to receive information My teaching schedule Visualisation of study progress DigiD** Pay creditcard, iDEAL, … *  Uitgewerkt in visualisatie ** Regelgeving moet onderzocht worden. Choose Order Oriëntation Receive Study
The OU will follow me – ‘ We keep in touch’ Customer surveys with phone follow-up) Study alert: think of your exam? (SMS/e-mail) News about courses During study Alumni network Tips about interesting jobs Tip: interesting key note speaker New courses Study trip with OU teacher Newsletter Traineeposts OU MSN buddy Newsletter Contact with business people In between and after studies Choose Order Orientation Receive Study
I am connected –  ‘ Study together’ Virtual study groups (Video) chat  with teachers Meet student of the neighbourhood Weblog/webpage with studygroup Who’s online? (teachers, students) (Video) call with teachers Virtual lectures  Forum (students, teachers, business people) Have a studytrip togehter Teacher invitation for virtual study group meeting Book online meeting room Upload of notes choose order orientation Receive Study
Value chain – business to consumer Consumer needs open access Time and location independent Compatible with work and family life - flexibility OU NL education portfolio
Value chain – business to business Business to Consumer change in needs Business to business new markets and targetgroups new demands OU NL education portfolio EVC, assessment Carreer coach Studyplanner Personal development plan EVC, assessment on department  or company level Personal development planning Carreer and education plans Academy – themes, company OU NL  services OU NL  “ products”
(Future) portfolio OUNL CONSUMER CUSTOMER Bachelor Master Packages of modules Single modules Services: study planning, exam training, extra coaching mini modules Even smaller actual offers Other media Subscription model BUSINESS CUSTOMER Blended forms Distance learning Train together Theme academies Competences, function families Spin offs LEARNING EXPERIENCES
New products and services Carreer round abaut Research PoPs, functiefamilies, competenties, doorlopende leerlijn Health care, projectmanagement Spin offs Networking Open College for Professional Development Opener Academic experience Business model met LLL services Free content LLL services Certificering, diplomering Accreditering Begeleiding Membership for life Andere uitlevervormen multimedia, andere stukken content, toegevoegde waarde OU NL  services OU NL  “ products”
Value proposition People who know to find OUNL (adequate poresentation) Volontary registration, identity known, accessible Customer who pays for services OU NL basic education portfolio Subscription registrtion OER tools  and test OER  material The ouside world – unregistered
Future OER Strategy OUNL OpenER gave results in terms of measured  effects , ingredients for the  national LLL policy , and  business model  adaptations Task force Advanced scenarios : (a) All OUNL learning materials in OER (major government funding …), or (b)  A new OER Initiative ? Yet , a  positive decision  to continue on OER has been taken by the Executive Board recently
Future OER Strategy OUNL Not settled , OpenER running until June 2008 and still to bring up some crucial results in terms of measured  effects , ingredients for the  national LLL policy , and  business model  adaptations Yet , a  positive decision  to continue on OER has been taken by the Executive Board recently Minimum scenario : continue in the  OpenER approach , with further funding externally or (partly) by the OUNL marketing budget Advanced scenarios : (a) All OUNL learning materials in OER (major government funding …), or (b)  A new OER Initiative ?
THANK YOU … [email_address]

OER and new business models

  • 1.
    Drs. Ing. C.J.(Cees) Brouwer vice president Open University Netherlands Educa Berlin, November 3 - 5, 2008 Open Educational Resources : the Dutch Lifelong Learning case and a Business Case perspective
  • 2.
    Agenda Mission OpenUniversity NL OpenER project characteristics Results Lessons learned Future strategy Open University NL Business model Customer life and study cycle
  • 3.
    Mission OUNL OUNLdevelops, delivers, and advances high-quality and innovative higher education distance learning, collaborating in networks and alliances Being the University for Lifelong learners OUNL highlights the diverse learning needs of people in their course of life and the necessity to considerably increase the knowledge and competence level in society
  • 4.
    OpenER - projectlaunched december 2006 with grants NL-Ministry and Education Hewlett Foundation more access non-traditional groups to Higher Education (HE) extend opportunities for lifelong learning using an e-learning approach lowering existing thresholds : institutional, formal, financial, social, time, place, pace making access easy and attractive transfer gradually from informal to formal learning much attention from the media, education stakeholders and the (inter)national scientific and professional community
  • 5.
    OpenER - CharacteristicsHigh-quality and attractive self-study learning materials Small course unit size (25 hours, some 4 hours) Some courses offer self-tests or are linked to TV-programmes Open and flexible in its most ultimate form Opportunities for formal testing (not for free!) and certification as a starting point for a full study Dutch language being used (no English …) Efficient explorative step-by-step investment in time / effort (not in money): temptation approach Research, evaluation and effect measurements
  • 6.
    OpenER – thesite:www.opener.ou.nl
  • 7.
    OpenER - impressionsRunning term extended from Dec. 2007 to June 2008 (with same budget!) Outcomes exceed intentions number of courses 15 (now), 16 (intended), 25 (expected) Outcomes outrange targets > 550.000 unique visits of website since launch (end 2006) 60% of the visitors did not participate in HE before over 4400 registered learners OER offered affects future choices (1500 filled questionnaires) 37% has plans for buying courses on the level of HE of existing OU-students 69% indicated that this project affects their further study plans 10% of actually newly registered students via OpenER (Spring 2008)
  • 8.
    OpenER - generalsurvey results Age, HE participation, visitors 71% of population aged 25-55 yrs 43% didn’t participate in HE before 73% returning visitors Reasons for visit (>1 choice) 61% follow a free course 21% ability test on university level 44% try-out of a study at OUNL 5% reuse material in own courses Use of materials 20% did not look through any course 37% browsed through a course 43% studied a course Study plans 75% not involved in any formal learning 17% intends to start a formal study in HE 37% intends to buy courses on HE level 87% indicates that OpenER affects their further study plans
  • 9.
    OpenER - courserelated surveys Two types of forms, since August: 643 of type A: only looked through introduction 156 of type B: studied most of the material Some results type A (80% population) Why do you visit this website? 37% free course 35% test for level 31% curiosity Does this course meet your expectations? 97% yes (e.g. self study,interesting, . . .) Some results type B (20% population) 45% first time visitor 50% less than HE level 81% course meets expectations 66% completed the course 54% wants to do formal examination (not for free) 69% influenced by OpenER in study plans (of which 3%: I do NOT want to study)
  • 10.
    OpenER - lessonslearned Support of top management (deans of the OUNL Schools) is crucial for progress / success Setup separate from regular operations, keep it ‘small’, manageable and technologically simple Identify OER champions , extend their enthusiasm to others and build on feelings of competition between the Schools Rely on quality awareness and competency of OUNL course developers and offer maximum support for content processing External funding helps in this respect
  • 11.
    OpenER - futurestrategy OUNL executive board positive attitude towards OER scenario Minimum scenario: continue OpenER approach, with further funding externally or (partly) by the OUNL marketing budget Advanced scenario: (a) All OUNL learning materials in OER (major government funding …), or (b) a new OER Initiative? dependencies national LLL policy , and business model adaptations
  • 12.
    Business model –a customer focus Productview Bachelors and masters of science, professional masters, single courses, mini modules Learning experiences, knowledge enrichment Services, services and services Form, medium, price/performance Marketview students! Students?? Paying customers! Business mgt, HRM strategy Other involvement, result driven within a short period of time, LLL packages INFRASTRUCTURE CORE CAPABILITIES VALUE CONFIGURATION PARTNER NETWORK OFFER VALUE PROPOSITION CUSTOMER TARGET CUSTOMER DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP FINANCE COST STRUCTURE DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL
  • 13.
    The customer inthe centre The driver for all interaction with the student is the context of the student The student is located in a specific “phase of life” with specifc needs Motivation to study is connected with these phases: Personal development, to work on competences, for your own good of your job Carreer Knowledge development A student finds himself also in a certain phase of the “ study cycle” In a life time a student can have more than one study cycle: ‘life-long-learning’ * Circle of Life, TNO Informatie- en Communicatietechnologie Choose Order Orientation Receive Study
  • 14.
    A life longlearning: learn to learn, learn to choose, learn to ‘grow’, learn to share, learn to experience Circle of Life: Phases of lyfe for the future needs teenagers study single starter single carreer living together carreer family with young children family with teenagers empty nesters pensioner experience becomes seriousness want to learn want to learn want to learn experience becomes seriousness experience becomes seriousness build up CV build up CV build up CV flexible offer flexible offer flexible offer fast & short fast & short fast & short mental fittness mental fittness mental fittness mental fitness comfort spare time social benefit in local area in local area comfort comfort carreer offer community community community initial info - sources initial info-sources personalised edu offer personalised education offer personalised education ofer personalised education offer carreer offer carreer offer added value services added value services added value services added value services added value services
  • 15.
    Circel of life– learning moments Schoolcontext tertiair secundair primair course Working context Other contexts Informal learning activity Nonformal learning activity course course course course course course work Education Nonformal learning activity Nonformal learning activity Nonformal learning activity Nonformal learning activity Nonformal learning activity Nonformal learning activity Nonformal learning activity Informal learning activity Informal learning activity Informal learning activity Informal learning activity Informal learning activity Informal learning activity Informal learning activity Informal learning activity course time frame portfolio target personal development plan OUNL BaMa
  • 16.
    Three Interaction themeswith students The needs of (potential) students translated in three interaction themes: Per theme different instruments Choice of instrument per targetgroup The OU knows me ‘ Personal’ Interaction in line with customer needs I am connected ‘ Study together’ Fysical and virtual contact with students and teachers The OU will follow me ‘ Contact’ We will be in contact before, during and after your study period
  • 17.
    The OU knowsme – ‘Personal’ Personal study advice Personal bookmarks Other students who choose this course, did also choose..* Tailor made brochure* Tips; interesting information as meetings, activities and news on courses (SMS, RSS, e-mail) Ordering interesting book with discount What about my order? (personal page) Call me*, (video)chat Contact with students Podcast/vodcast of colleges My studyplanner Course reviews/testimonials by fellowstudenten* Make your own choice how to receive information My teaching schedule Visualisation of study progress DigiD** Pay creditcard, iDEAL, … * Uitgewerkt in visualisatie ** Regelgeving moet onderzocht worden. Choose Order Oriëntation Receive Study
  • 18.
    The OU willfollow me – ‘ We keep in touch’ Customer surveys with phone follow-up) Study alert: think of your exam? (SMS/e-mail) News about courses During study Alumni network Tips about interesting jobs Tip: interesting key note speaker New courses Study trip with OU teacher Newsletter Traineeposts OU MSN buddy Newsletter Contact with business people In between and after studies Choose Order Orientation Receive Study
  • 19.
    I am connected– ‘ Study together’ Virtual study groups (Video) chat with teachers Meet student of the neighbourhood Weblog/webpage with studygroup Who’s online? (teachers, students) (Video) call with teachers Virtual lectures Forum (students, teachers, business people) Have a studytrip togehter Teacher invitation for virtual study group meeting Book online meeting room Upload of notes choose order orientation Receive Study
  • 20.
    Value chain –business to consumer Consumer needs open access Time and location independent Compatible with work and family life - flexibility OU NL education portfolio
  • 21.
    Value chain –business to business Business to Consumer change in needs Business to business new markets and targetgroups new demands OU NL education portfolio EVC, assessment Carreer coach Studyplanner Personal development plan EVC, assessment on department or company level Personal development planning Carreer and education plans Academy – themes, company OU NL services OU NL “ products”
  • 22.
    (Future) portfolio OUNLCONSUMER CUSTOMER Bachelor Master Packages of modules Single modules Services: study planning, exam training, extra coaching mini modules Even smaller actual offers Other media Subscription model BUSINESS CUSTOMER Blended forms Distance learning Train together Theme academies Competences, function families Spin offs LEARNING EXPERIENCES
  • 23.
    New products andservices Carreer round abaut Research PoPs, functiefamilies, competenties, doorlopende leerlijn Health care, projectmanagement Spin offs Networking Open College for Professional Development Opener Academic experience Business model met LLL services Free content LLL services Certificering, diplomering Accreditering Begeleiding Membership for life Andere uitlevervormen multimedia, andere stukken content, toegevoegde waarde OU NL services OU NL “ products”
  • 24.
    Value proposition Peoplewho know to find OUNL (adequate poresentation) Volontary registration, identity known, accessible Customer who pays for services OU NL basic education portfolio Subscription registrtion OER tools and test OER material The ouside world – unregistered
  • 25.
    Future OER StrategyOUNL OpenER gave results in terms of measured effects , ingredients for the national LLL policy , and business model adaptations Task force Advanced scenarios : (a) All OUNL learning materials in OER (major government funding …), or (b) A new OER Initiative ? Yet , a positive decision to continue on OER has been taken by the Executive Board recently
  • 26.
    Future OER StrategyOUNL Not settled , OpenER running until June 2008 and still to bring up some crucial results in terms of measured effects , ingredients for the national LLL policy , and business model adaptations Yet , a positive decision to continue on OER has been taken by the Executive Board recently Minimum scenario : continue in the OpenER approach , with further funding externally or (partly) by the OUNL marketing budget Advanced scenarios : (a) All OUNL learning materials in OER (major government funding …), or (b) A new OER Initiative ?
  • 27.
    THANK YOU …[email_address]