SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
 No rigid assumptions about the distribution of the
populations - “Distribution-free tests”
 Answers the same sort of questions as the parametric
test – for each Parametric tests (PT) there is an
alternative Non-Parametric Test (NP) Test
 Applied to a wide variety of situations
continuous ordinal scores
 Assumptions of parametric test are violated
 Non-normal or skewed
 Variance very high in relative to mean
 Data is on an ordinal scale
 Very few observations
 Most powerful of the NP test – Wilcoxon Rank Sum
test
 Alternative to the parametric independent t-test
 To test whether two independent groups have been
drawn from the same population
Assumptions:
 Two sample are selected independently and at random
from their respective population
 Variable of interest is continuous
 Measurement scale is at least ordinal.
Compare the distribution of scores on a quantitative
variable obtained from two independent groups.
Group A : 2 4 2 6 4 8
Group B : 8 8 4 10 12 11
Ho: There is no significant difference between the medians
of the two samples
Ha: There is a significant difference between the medians of
the two samples
Mann-Whitney U Test (contd.)
A researcher designed an experiment to assess the effects of prolonged
inhalation of cadmium oxide. 15 lab animals served as experimental
subjects while 10 similar animals served as controls. Variable of interest
was Hb level following the experiment. Conclude that there is no
difference between exposed and unexposed animals in their Hb level
sno Exposed Unexposed
1 13.1 17.4
2 15.6 16.2
3 17.3 17.1
4 16.4 17.5
5 14.3 15
6 15.5 16
7 14.9 16.9
8 15.6 15.1
9 14.1 16.1
10 15.3 17.2
11 15.7
12 16.7
13 13.7
14 15.6
15 14
Deciding Normality
Large Sample: When n1,n2 > 10 (normal approximation)
The test statistic is given as
12
)
1
(
2
2
1
2
1
2
1




n
n
n
n
n
n
U
Z
)
var(
)
(
U
U
E
U
Z


where ‘U’ is the smallest sum of ranks between U1 and U2
 An alternative to the parametric paired t-test
 Used to compare 2 samples from populations are not
independent eg., measure a variable in each subject
before and after an intervention
Assumptions
 Samples must be paired
 Pairs are randomly selected from the larger population
 Probability distribution from which the sample of
paired differences drawn is continuous
Below is the measurement of anxiety before and after
two weeks of treatment.
SN
O
BEFORE
Rx
AFTER
Rx
1 130 120
2 170 163
3 125 120
4 170 135
5 130 143
6 130 136
7 145 144
8 160 120
Does the treatment have any beneficial effects?
Wilcoxon Signed-Rank Test
Examine whether there is any significant
difference in the systolic blood pressure of 16
subjects before and after receiving a standard
treatment
Sno Before After
1 142 143
2 148 146
3 144 147
4 142 138
5 140 136
6 144 139
7 146 141
8 150 145
9 149 143
10 142 136
11 149 145
12 143 140
13 145 143
14 146 142
15 143 140
16 146 141
 Nonnumeric data such as Taste of food: bad, good, great
and excellent, Smoking habit: light, moderate and heavy etc.
 Involves simpler computations than the corresponding
parametric methods and are therefore easier to understand.
 Since the inference is based on ranks, Nonparametric
methods are quick for small samples and less subject to
measurement error than parametric methods.
 No parameters to describe and it becomes more
difficult to make quantitative statements about
the actual difference between populations
 Tend to waste information because it deals with
ranks and discard the actual values
 Less powerful where parametric test is
applicable.
Type of Data
Measurement from
Normal Population
Rank, Score or
Measurement from
Non-normal
Describe one group Mean, SD Median, Interquartile
Range
Compare two
independent groups
Independent sample t-test
(unpaired t test)
Mann-Whitney test
Compare two paired
groups
Paired t test Wilcoxon Signed rank
test
Quantify relation between
two variables
Pearson Correlation Spearman Rank
Correlation

More Related Content

Similar to non-parametric test with examples and data problems

7 anova chi square test
 7 anova chi square test 7 anova chi square test
7 anova chi square testPenny Jiang
 
Parmetric and non parametric statistical test in clinical trails
Parmetric and non parametric statistical test in clinical trailsParmetric and non parametric statistical test in clinical trails
Parmetric and non parametric statistical test in clinical trailsVinod Pagidipalli
 
slides Testing of hypothesis.pptx
slides Testing  of  hypothesis.pptxslides Testing  of  hypothesis.pptx
slides Testing of hypothesis.pptxssuser504dda
 
Application of-different-statistical-tests-in-fisheries-science
Application of-different-statistical-tests-in-fisheries-scienceApplication of-different-statistical-tests-in-fisheries-science
Application of-different-statistical-tests-in-fisheries-scienceAs Siyam
 
Statistical methods for the life sciences lb
Statistical methods for the life sciences lbStatistical methods for the life sciences lb
Statistical methods for the life sciences lbpriyaupm
 
Statistical test
Statistical test Statistical test
Statistical test As Siyam
 
TESTS OF SIGNIFICANCE.pptx
TESTS OF SIGNIFICANCE.pptxTESTS OF SIGNIFICANCE.pptx
TESTS OF SIGNIFICANCE.pptxAnchuRNath
 
Parametric vs non parametric test
Parametric vs non parametric testParametric vs non parametric test
Parametric vs non parametric testar9530
 
inferentialstatistics-210411214248.pdf
inferentialstatistics-210411214248.pdfinferentialstatistics-210411214248.pdf
inferentialstatistics-210411214248.pdfChenPalaruan
 
Analysis of data thiyagu
Analysis of data  thiyaguAnalysis of data  thiyagu
Analysis of data thiyaguThiyagu K
 
Analysis of Data - Dr. K. Thiyagu
Analysis of Data - Dr. K. ThiyaguAnalysis of Data - Dr. K. Thiyagu
Analysis of Data - Dr. K. ThiyaguThiyagu K
 
Commonly used statistical tests in research
Commonly used statistical tests in researchCommonly used statistical tests in research
Commonly used statistical tests in researchNaqeeb Ullah Khan
 

Similar to non-parametric test with examples and data problems (20)

7 anova chi square test
 7 anova chi square test 7 anova chi square test
7 anova chi square test
 
BIOSTATISTICS SLIDESHARE.pptx
BIOSTATISTICS SLIDESHARE.pptxBIOSTATISTICS SLIDESHARE.pptx
BIOSTATISTICS SLIDESHARE.pptx
 
Biostatistics ii
Biostatistics iiBiostatistics ii
Biostatistics ii
 
Parmetric and non parametric statistical test in clinical trails
Parmetric and non parametric statistical test in clinical trailsParmetric and non parametric statistical test in clinical trails
Parmetric and non parametric statistical test in clinical trails
 
slides Testing of hypothesis.pptx
slides Testing  of  hypothesis.pptxslides Testing  of  hypothesis.pptx
slides Testing of hypothesis.pptx
 
1 ANOVA.ppt
1 ANOVA.ppt1 ANOVA.ppt
1 ANOVA.ppt
 
Application of-different-statistical-tests-in-fisheries-science
Application of-different-statistical-tests-in-fisheries-scienceApplication of-different-statistical-tests-in-fisheries-science
Application of-different-statistical-tests-in-fisheries-science
 
Parametric tests
Parametric  testsParametric  tests
Parametric tests
 
Statistical methods for the life sciences lb
Statistical methods for the life sciences lbStatistical methods for the life sciences lb
Statistical methods for the life sciences lb
 
Statistical test
Statistical test Statistical test
Statistical test
 
Amrita kumari
Amrita kumariAmrita kumari
Amrita kumari
 
TESTS OF SIGNIFICANCE.pptx
TESTS OF SIGNIFICANCE.pptxTESTS OF SIGNIFICANCE.pptx
TESTS OF SIGNIFICANCE.pptx
 
Parametric vs non parametric test
Parametric vs non parametric testParametric vs non parametric test
Parametric vs non parametric test
 
T‑tests
T‑testsT‑tests
T‑tests
 
inferentialstatistics-210411214248.pdf
inferentialstatistics-210411214248.pdfinferentialstatistics-210411214248.pdf
inferentialstatistics-210411214248.pdf
 
Analysis of data thiyagu
Analysis of data  thiyaguAnalysis of data  thiyagu
Analysis of data thiyagu
 
Analysis of Data - Dr. K. Thiyagu
Analysis of Data - Dr. K. ThiyaguAnalysis of Data - Dr. K. Thiyagu
Analysis of Data - Dr. K. Thiyagu
 
Analysis of Data - Dr. K. Thiyagu
Analysis of Data - Dr. K. ThiyaguAnalysis of Data - Dr. K. Thiyagu
Analysis of Data - Dr. K. Thiyagu
 
Inferential statistics
Inferential statisticsInferential statistics
Inferential statistics
 
Commonly used statistical tests in research
Commonly used statistical tests in researchCommonly used statistical tests in research
Commonly used statistical tests in research
 

Recently uploaded

PKS-TGC-1084-630 - Stage 1 Proposal.pptx
PKS-TGC-1084-630 - Stage 1 Proposal.pptxPKS-TGC-1084-630 - Stage 1 Proposal.pptx
PKS-TGC-1084-630 - Stage 1 Proposal.pptxPramod Kumar Srivastava
 
Call Girls in Defence Colony Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Defence Colony Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝Call Girls in Defence Colony Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Defence Colony Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝soniya singh
 
INTERNSHIP ON PURBASHA COMPOSITE TEX LTD
INTERNSHIP ON PURBASHA COMPOSITE TEX LTDINTERNSHIP ON PURBASHA COMPOSITE TEX LTD
INTERNSHIP ON PURBASHA COMPOSITE TEX LTDRafezzaman
 
B2 Creative Industry Response Evaluation.docx
B2 Creative Industry Response Evaluation.docxB2 Creative Industry Response Evaluation.docx
B2 Creative Industry Response Evaluation.docxStephen266013
 
04242024_CCC TUG_Joins and Relationships
04242024_CCC TUG_Joins and Relationships04242024_CCC TUG_Joins and Relationships
04242024_CCC TUG_Joins and Relationshipsccctableauusergroup
 
RS 9000 Call In girls Dwarka Mor (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi
RS 9000 Call In girls Dwarka Mor (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝DelhiRS 9000 Call In girls Dwarka Mor (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi
RS 9000 Call In girls Dwarka Mor (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhijennyeacort
 
High Class Call Girls Noida Sector 39 Aarushi 🔝8264348440🔝 Independent Escort...
High Class Call Girls Noida Sector 39 Aarushi 🔝8264348440🔝 Independent Escort...High Class Call Girls Noida Sector 39 Aarushi 🔝8264348440🔝 Independent Escort...
High Class Call Girls Noida Sector 39 Aarushi 🔝8264348440🔝 Independent Escort...soniya singh
 
dokumen.tips_chapter-4-transient-heat-conduction-mehmet-kanoglu.ppt
dokumen.tips_chapter-4-transient-heat-conduction-mehmet-kanoglu.pptdokumen.tips_chapter-4-transient-heat-conduction-mehmet-kanoglu.ppt
dokumen.tips_chapter-4-transient-heat-conduction-mehmet-kanoglu.pptSonatrach
 
Amazon TQM (2) Amazon TQM (2)Amazon TQM (2).pptx
Amazon TQM (2) Amazon TQM (2)Amazon TQM (2).pptxAmazon TQM (2) Amazon TQM (2)Amazon TQM (2).pptx
Amazon TQM (2) Amazon TQM (2)Amazon TQM (2).pptxAbdelrhman abooda
 
RadioAdProWritingCinderellabyButleri.pdf
RadioAdProWritingCinderellabyButleri.pdfRadioAdProWritingCinderellabyButleri.pdf
RadioAdProWritingCinderellabyButleri.pdfgstagge
 
Indian Call Girls in Abu Dhabi O5286O24O8 Call Girls in Abu Dhabi By Independ...
Indian Call Girls in Abu Dhabi O5286O24O8 Call Girls in Abu Dhabi By Independ...Indian Call Girls in Abu Dhabi O5286O24O8 Call Girls in Abu Dhabi By Independ...
Indian Call Girls in Abu Dhabi O5286O24O8 Call Girls in Abu Dhabi By Independ...dajasot375
 
Building on a FAIRly Strong Foundation to Connect Academic Research to Transl...
Building on a FAIRly Strong Foundation to Connect Academic Research to Transl...Building on a FAIRly Strong Foundation to Connect Academic Research to Transl...
Building on a FAIRly Strong Foundation to Connect Academic Research to Transl...Jack DiGiovanna
 
Top 5 Best Data Analytics Courses In Queens
Top 5 Best Data Analytics Courses In QueensTop 5 Best Data Analytics Courses In Queens
Top 5 Best Data Analytics Courses In Queensdataanalyticsqueen03
 
Industrialised data - the key to AI success.pdf
Industrialised data - the key to AI success.pdfIndustrialised data - the key to AI success.pdf
Industrialised data - the key to AI success.pdfLars Albertsson
 
Dubai Call Girls Wifey O52&786472 Call Girls Dubai
Dubai Call Girls Wifey O52&786472 Call Girls DubaiDubai Call Girls Wifey O52&786472 Call Girls Dubai
Dubai Call Girls Wifey O52&786472 Call Girls Dubaihf8803863
 
Saket, (-DELHI )+91-9654467111-(=)CHEAP Call Girls in Escorts Service Saket C...
Saket, (-DELHI )+91-9654467111-(=)CHEAP Call Girls in Escorts Service Saket C...Saket, (-DELHI )+91-9654467111-(=)CHEAP Call Girls in Escorts Service Saket C...
Saket, (-DELHI )+91-9654467111-(=)CHEAP Call Girls in Escorts Service Saket C...Sapana Sha
 
Beautiful Sapna Vip Call Girls Hauz Khas 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
Beautiful Sapna Vip  Call Girls Hauz Khas 9711199012 Call /WhatsappsBeautiful Sapna Vip  Call Girls Hauz Khas 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
Beautiful Sapna Vip Call Girls Hauz Khas 9711199012 Call /Whatsappssapnasaifi408
 
DBA Basics: Getting Started with Performance Tuning.pdf
DBA Basics: Getting Started with Performance Tuning.pdfDBA Basics: Getting Started with Performance Tuning.pdf
DBA Basics: Getting Started with Performance Tuning.pdfJohn Sterrett
 
办理学位证中佛罗里达大学毕业证,UCF成绩单原版一比一
办理学位证中佛罗里达大学毕业证,UCF成绩单原版一比一办理学位证中佛罗里达大学毕业证,UCF成绩单原版一比一
办理学位证中佛罗里达大学毕业证,UCF成绩单原版一比一F sss
 

Recently uploaded (20)

PKS-TGC-1084-630 - Stage 1 Proposal.pptx
PKS-TGC-1084-630 - Stage 1 Proposal.pptxPKS-TGC-1084-630 - Stage 1 Proposal.pptx
PKS-TGC-1084-630 - Stage 1 Proposal.pptx
 
Call Girls in Defence Colony Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Defence Colony Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝Call Girls in Defence Colony Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Defence Colony Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
 
INTERNSHIP ON PURBASHA COMPOSITE TEX LTD
INTERNSHIP ON PURBASHA COMPOSITE TEX LTDINTERNSHIP ON PURBASHA COMPOSITE TEX LTD
INTERNSHIP ON PURBASHA COMPOSITE TEX LTD
 
B2 Creative Industry Response Evaluation.docx
B2 Creative Industry Response Evaluation.docxB2 Creative Industry Response Evaluation.docx
B2 Creative Industry Response Evaluation.docx
 
04242024_CCC TUG_Joins and Relationships
04242024_CCC TUG_Joins and Relationships04242024_CCC TUG_Joins and Relationships
04242024_CCC TUG_Joins and Relationships
 
RS 9000 Call In girls Dwarka Mor (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi
RS 9000 Call In girls Dwarka Mor (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝DelhiRS 9000 Call In girls Dwarka Mor (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi
RS 9000 Call In girls Dwarka Mor (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi
 
High Class Call Girls Noida Sector 39 Aarushi 🔝8264348440🔝 Independent Escort...
High Class Call Girls Noida Sector 39 Aarushi 🔝8264348440🔝 Independent Escort...High Class Call Girls Noida Sector 39 Aarushi 🔝8264348440🔝 Independent Escort...
High Class Call Girls Noida Sector 39 Aarushi 🔝8264348440🔝 Independent Escort...
 
dokumen.tips_chapter-4-transient-heat-conduction-mehmet-kanoglu.ppt
dokumen.tips_chapter-4-transient-heat-conduction-mehmet-kanoglu.pptdokumen.tips_chapter-4-transient-heat-conduction-mehmet-kanoglu.ppt
dokumen.tips_chapter-4-transient-heat-conduction-mehmet-kanoglu.ppt
 
Amazon TQM (2) Amazon TQM (2)Amazon TQM (2).pptx
Amazon TQM (2) Amazon TQM (2)Amazon TQM (2).pptxAmazon TQM (2) Amazon TQM (2)Amazon TQM (2).pptx
Amazon TQM (2) Amazon TQM (2)Amazon TQM (2).pptx
 
RadioAdProWritingCinderellabyButleri.pdf
RadioAdProWritingCinderellabyButleri.pdfRadioAdProWritingCinderellabyButleri.pdf
RadioAdProWritingCinderellabyButleri.pdf
 
Indian Call Girls in Abu Dhabi O5286O24O8 Call Girls in Abu Dhabi By Independ...
Indian Call Girls in Abu Dhabi O5286O24O8 Call Girls in Abu Dhabi By Independ...Indian Call Girls in Abu Dhabi O5286O24O8 Call Girls in Abu Dhabi By Independ...
Indian Call Girls in Abu Dhabi O5286O24O8 Call Girls in Abu Dhabi By Independ...
 
Building on a FAIRly Strong Foundation to Connect Academic Research to Transl...
Building on a FAIRly Strong Foundation to Connect Academic Research to Transl...Building on a FAIRly Strong Foundation to Connect Academic Research to Transl...
Building on a FAIRly Strong Foundation to Connect Academic Research to Transl...
 
Top 5 Best Data Analytics Courses In Queens
Top 5 Best Data Analytics Courses In QueensTop 5 Best Data Analytics Courses In Queens
Top 5 Best Data Analytics Courses In Queens
 
Industrialised data - the key to AI success.pdf
Industrialised data - the key to AI success.pdfIndustrialised data - the key to AI success.pdf
Industrialised data - the key to AI success.pdf
 
Dubai Call Girls Wifey O52&786472 Call Girls Dubai
Dubai Call Girls Wifey O52&786472 Call Girls DubaiDubai Call Girls Wifey O52&786472 Call Girls Dubai
Dubai Call Girls Wifey O52&786472 Call Girls Dubai
 
Saket, (-DELHI )+91-9654467111-(=)CHEAP Call Girls in Escorts Service Saket C...
Saket, (-DELHI )+91-9654467111-(=)CHEAP Call Girls in Escorts Service Saket C...Saket, (-DELHI )+91-9654467111-(=)CHEAP Call Girls in Escorts Service Saket C...
Saket, (-DELHI )+91-9654467111-(=)CHEAP Call Girls in Escorts Service Saket C...
 
Beautiful Sapna Vip Call Girls Hauz Khas 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
Beautiful Sapna Vip  Call Girls Hauz Khas 9711199012 Call /WhatsappsBeautiful Sapna Vip  Call Girls Hauz Khas 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
Beautiful Sapna Vip Call Girls Hauz Khas 9711199012 Call /Whatsapps
 
DBA Basics: Getting Started with Performance Tuning.pdf
DBA Basics: Getting Started with Performance Tuning.pdfDBA Basics: Getting Started with Performance Tuning.pdf
DBA Basics: Getting Started with Performance Tuning.pdf
 
办理学位证中佛罗里达大学毕业证,UCF成绩单原版一比一
办理学位证中佛罗里达大学毕业证,UCF成绩单原版一比一办理学位证中佛罗里达大学毕业证,UCF成绩单原版一比一
办理学位证中佛罗里达大学毕业证,UCF成绩单原版一比一
 
E-Commerce Order PredictionShraddha Kamble.pptx
E-Commerce Order PredictionShraddha Kamble.pptxE-Commerce Order PredictionShraddha Kamble.pptx
E-Commerce Order PredictionShraddha Kamble.pptx
 

non-parametric test with examples and data problems

  • 1.
  • 2.  No rigid assumptions about the distribution of the populations - “Distribution-free tests”  Answers the same sort of questions as the parametric test – for each Parametric tests (PT) there is an alternative Non-Parametric Test (NP) Test  Applied to a wide variety of situations continuous ordinal scores
  • 3.  Assumptions of parametric test are violated  Non-normal or skewed  Variance very high in relative to mean  Data is on an ordinal scale  Very few observations
  • 4.  Most powerful of the NP test – Wilcoxon Rank Sum test  Alternative to the parametric independent t-test  To test whether two independent groups have been drawn from the same population Assumptions:  Two sample are selected independently and at random from their respective population  Variable of interest is continuous  Measurement scale is at least ordinal.
  • 5. Compare the distribution of scores on a quantitative variable obtained from two independent groups. Group A : 2 4 2 6 4 8 Group B : 8 8 4 10 12 11 Ho: There is no significant difference between the medians of the two samples Ha: There is a significant difference between the medians of the two samples
  • 6. Mann-Whitney U Test (contd.) A researcher designed an experiment to assess the effects of prolonged inhalation of cadmium oxide. 15 lab animals served as experimental subjects while 10 similar animals served as controls. Variable of interest was Hb level following the experiment. Conclude that there is no difference between exposed and unexposed animals in their Hb level
  • 7. sno Exposed Unexposed 1 13.1 17.4 2 15.6 16.2 3 17.3 17.1 4 16.4 17.5 5 14.3 15 6 15.5 16 7 14.9 16.9 8 15.6 15.1 9 14.1 16.1 10 15.3 17.2 11 15.7 12 16.7 13 13.7 14 15.6 15 14
  • 9. Large Sample: When n1,n2 > 10 (normal approximation) The test statistic is given as 12 ) 1 ( 2 2 1 2 1 2 1     n n n n n n U Z ) var( ) ( U U E U Z   where ‘U’ is the smallest sum of ranks between U1 and U2
  • 10.  An alternative to the parametric paired t-test  Used to compare 2 samples from populations are not independent eg., measure a variable in each subject before and after an intervention Assumptions  Samples must be paired  Pairs are randomly selected from the larger population  Probability distribution from which the sample of paired differences drawn is continuous
  • 11. Below is the measurement of anxiety before and after two weeks of treatment. SN O BEFORE Rx AFTER Rx 1 130 120 2 170 163 3 125 120 4 170 135 5 130 143 6 130 136 7 145 144 8 160 120 Does the treatment have any beneficial effects? Wilcoxon Signed-Rank Test
  • 12. Examine whether there is any significant difference in the systolic blood pressure of 16 subjects before and after receiving a standard treatment Sno Before After 1 142 143 2 148 146 3 144 147 4 142 138 5 140 136 6 144 139 7 146 141 8 150 145 9 149 143 10 142 136 11 149 145 12 143 140 13 145 143 14 146 142 15 143 140 16 146 141
  • 13.  Nonnumeric data such as Taste of food: bad, good, great and excellent, Smoking habit: light, moderate and heavy etc.  Involves simpler computations than the corresponding parametric methods and are therefore easier to understand.  Since the inference is based on ranks, Nonparametric methods are quick for small samples and less subject to measurement error than parametric methods.
  • 14.  No parameters to describe and it becomes more difficult to make quantitative statements about the actual difference between populations  Tend to waste information because it deals with ranks and discard the actual values  Less powerful where parametric test is applicable.
  • 15. Type of Data Measurement from Normal Population Rank, Score or Measurement from Non-normal Describe one group Mean, SD Median, Interquartile Range Compare two independent groups Independent sample t-test (unpaired t test) Mann-Whitney test Compare two paired groups Paired t test Wilcoxon Signed rank test Quantify relation between two variables Pearson Correlation Spearman Rank Correlation

Editor's Notes

  1. 1
  2. 10
  3. 12
  4. 14