Influence and Negotiations Ask and You Shall Receive   NAWMBA Conference September 17, 2011
We measure  our worth  by what we  need
We compare our income to our women friends
 
We over-deliver to our clients and superiors and under-deliver to ourselves
We work  22% longer and  10% faster for the same reward
 
monkey economy 50  million  years
Recognize the  opportunity to negotiate!
Negotiation is a conversation leading to agreement.
Let’s have lunch or coffee . . .  Small talk . . .  How’s business? Me too . . . .  I was hoping we might be able to do business together . . . .  Here’s what I bring to the table I thought it might benefit you to have . . .  My rate is $_____ (more than you want)
Diagnostic Questions: Who  What  When  Where  Why How
 
Responses to Conflict Suppression Avoidance Resolution Transformation Transcendence
Dispute Resolution Tactics Yielding/Ingratiation Shaming Persuasive argumentation Promises of future action Threats of future action Physical force
S: if she wants to V: you want the kids to come down? V: how about Helen (ex-wife)? S: If they want to
Get your partner to switch seats with your.  Each winner will get a prize. You have 60 seconds to play.
Ask Ask for a meeting Gather stakeholders Set the tone Frame the topic Suggest an agenda Ask open-ended questions Be firm but flexible
ANCHOR In circumstances of uncertainty, the negotiator who makes the first offer sets the top of the bargaining range, which acts as an anchor that exerts a powerful influence on the outcome throughout the negotiation. Image credit istockphoto.com 2010
Anchor Make first offer Make it aggressive  Frame it as benefit
Reiterate terms  Or…recapture the main points, what’s left to resolve, and what’s needed to do so. Set day/time to reconvene End on hopeful note/congratulate both for progress made Close
Prepare to Ask Ascertain your market value Unbundle that value Be prepared to value and prioritize each item Research their interests Determine whether there are items of high value to you and low cost to them
Ask and Anchor My fee is $450 an hour SILENCE!!!! Wait for response; if none then, I generally ask for an upfront retainer that will cover the time we estimate the job will take – let’s talk about timing; OR is that a number you can work with?; OR if that number is too rich for your Board, we can talk about payment options; OR I’m always willing to negotiate
Frame Ask as a Benefit I’d like to talk about the ways in which we can create a mutually beneficial relationship
Interest-based negotiation is a  process  in which we seek to  expand  the pie of benefits available to the parties in an attempt to  satisfy  as many of their needs, desires, preferences and priorities as possible  (their interests).
What are my intended outcomes and interests? Preferences, priorities, needs, desires, fears, aspirations, bottom line What are their possible interests and outcomes? What are the options? Potential points of agreement Differences that might be dove-tailed ASK DIAGNOSTIC QUESTIONS Q is for Questioner copyright 2010 Reason Press
Logrolling, or trading off concessions on  low-priority issues for gains on higher priority  issues Trading differential time preferences Allocating more initial outcomes to the more impatient party  Allocating greater profits over a longer period to the more patient party TACTICS AND OPTIONS T is for Them and Us copyright 2010 Reason Press
add issues not inherent in the initial negotiation framework Bonuses Flex-time Best associates contingent contracts If I bring in $X this year, I ’ll receive Y% of it Creates appearance of concession Almost risk free MORE TACTICS AND OPTIONS T is for Them and Us copyright 2010 Reason Press
Label concessions & demand reciprocity Stress difficulty in making concession This will cut our profit razor thin If I make this concession, you should be willing to promise me partnership next year Concessions & Reciprocity
tit for tat S is for Shakedown Artist copyright 2010 Reason Press
Tit for Tat The most successful dispute resolution strategy bar none Begin cooperatively Punish proportionally for non-cooperation (or you’ll enter into a cycle of victimization) Forgive quickly and return to cooperation when your bargaining partner does so. How many times did she forgive
They ’re not evil; they have hidden interests Personal (unrelated to you or deal) Relational (related to you but not to the deal, i.e.,  “face”) Political, social, cultural O Is for Outlaw copyright 2010 Reason Press
They are not irrational; they have hidden constraints Institutional Precedential Promises to others Deadlines
Practice practice practice

National Association of Women MBAs 2011 Negotiation Presentation

  • 1.
    Influence and NegotiationsAsk and You Shall Receive NAWMBA Conference September 17, 2011
  • 2.
    We measure our worth by what we need
  • 3.
    We compare ourincome to our women friends
  • 4.
  • 5.
    We over-deliver toour clients and superiors and under-deliver to ourselves
  • 6.
    We work 22% longer and 10% faster for the same reward
  • 7.
  • 8.
    monkey economy 50 million years
  • 9.
    Recognize the opportunity to negotiate!
  • 10.
    Negotiation is aconversation leading to agreement.
  • 11.
    Let’s have lunchor coffee . . . Small talk . . . How’s business? Me too . . . . I was hoping we might be able to do business together . . . . Here’s what I bring to the table I thought it might benefit you to have . . . My rate is $_____ (more than you want)
  • 12.
    Diagnostic Questions: Who What When Where Why How
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Responses to ConflictSuppression Avoidance Resolution Transformation Transcendence
  • 15.
    Dispute Resolution TacticsYielding/Ingratiation Shaming Persuasive argumentation Promises of future action Threats of future action Physical force
  • 16.
    S: if shewants to V: you want the kids to come down? V: how about Helen (ex-wife)? S: If they want to
  • 17.
    Get your partnerto switch seats with your. Each winner will get a prize. You have 60 seconds to play.
  • 18.
    Ask Ask fora meeting Gather stakeholders Set the tone Frame the topic Suggest an agenda Ask open-ended questions Be firm but flexible
  • 19.
    ANCHOR In circumstancesof uncertainty, the negotiator who makes the first offer sets the top of the bargaining range, which acts as an anchor that exerts a powerful influence on the outcome throughout the negotiation. Image credit istockphoto.com 2010
  • 20.
    Anchor Make firstoffer Make it aggressive Frame it as benefit
  • 21.
    Reiterate terms Or…recapture the main points, what’s left to resolve, and what’s needed to do so. Set day/time to reconvene End on hopeful note/congratulate both for progress made Close
  • 22.
    Prepare to AskAscertain your market value Unbundle that value Be prepared to value and prioritize each item Research their interests Determine whether there are items of high value to you and low cost to them
  • 23.
    Ask and AnchorMy fee is $450 an hour SILENCE!!!! Wait for response; if none then, I generally ask for an upfront retainer that will cover the time we estimate the job will take – let’s talk about timing; OR is that a number you can work with?; OR if that number is too rich for your Board, we can talk about payment options; OR I’m always willing to negotiate
  • 24.
    Frame Ask asa Benefit I’d like to talk about the ways in which we can create a mutually beneficial relationship
  • 25.
    Interest-based negotiation isa process in which we seek to expand the pie of benefits available to the parties in an attempt to satisfy as many of their needs, desires, preferences and priorities as possible (their interests).
  • 26.
    What are myintended outcomes and interests? Preferences, priorities, needs, desires, fears, aspirations, bottom line What are their possible interests and outcomes? What are the options? Potential points of agreement Differences that might be dove-tailed ASK DIAGNOSTIC QUESTIONS Q is for Questioner copyright 2010 Reason Press
  • 27.
    Logrolling, or tradingoff concessions on low-priority issues for gains on higher priority issues Trading differential time preferences Allocating more initial outcomes to the more impatient party Allocating greater profits over a longer period to the more patient party TACTICS AND OPTIONS T is for Them and Us copyright 2010 Reason Press
  • 28.
    add issues notinherent in the initial negotiation framework Bonuses Flex-time Best associates contingent contracts If I bring in $X this year, I ’ll receive Y% of it Creates appearance of concession Almost risk free MORE TACTICS AND OPTIONS T is for Them and Us copyright 2010 Reason Press
  • 29.
    Label concessions &demand reciprocity Stress difficulty in making concession This will cut our profit razor thin If I make this concession, you should be willing to promise me partnership next year Concessions & Reciprocity
  • 30.
    tit for tatS is for Shakedown Artist copyright 2010 Reason Press
  • 31.
    Tit for TatThe most successful dispute resolution strategy bar none Begin cooperatively Punish proportionally for non-cooperation (or you’ll enter into a cycle of victimization) Forgive quickly and return to cooperation when your bargaining partner does so. How many times did she forgive
  • 32.
    They ’re notevil; they have hidden interests Personal (unrelated to you or deal) Relational (related to you but not to the deal, i.e., “face”) Political, social, cultural O Is for Outlaw copyright 2010 Reason Press
  • 33.
    They are notirrational; they have hidden constraints Institutional Precedential Promises to others Deadlines
  • 34.

Editor's Notes

  • #3 ASK: We’re lawyers, business women, artists, editors, financial gurus, and entrepreneurs. And yet we hesitate to ask for higher fees, promotions, bonuses, flex-time, more staff, and better access to power. Most men don’t have a problem saying “I want a new Porsche or a corner office or YOUR clients.” Men tend to measure their worth by what they can get. We measure ours by what we need.
  • #4 Keeping the bar low hurts all of us. We have this in common with men – we want parity. And when we look around to see whether we’ve got it, we compare ourselves to our women friends, not our male colleagues and we feel good about our income even though it’s 30% lower than our market value.
  • #5 Some of us see-saw here – knowing our male peers are doing better but not wanting to rock the boat or call attention to ourselves or appear greedy or step over the lines
  • #6 And this is particularly true in this economy because we’re working harder for less – productivity is up – unemployment is flat – profits are up but everyone keeps telling us they can’t give us more because the economy is bad
  • #7 We’re limited by ourselves
  • #8 So we’re stuck here
  • #10 When’s the last time you had an opportunity to negotiate something? Every time you open your wallet; every time you provide a service – but the challenge is real. It IS HARD – we step over gender boundaries when we ask for ourselves. The goal today is to rethink our market value, find a way that’s comfortable for us to seek it and learn the strategies and tactics to get it.
  • #13 What do we want to know? We’re going to talk about a couple of venture capitalists at day’s end – John and Denise. On the surface, it appears that these two high-achievers want the same thing. Denise wants equity partnership and John wants to block her promotion. In fact he wants her out of the firm. She knows he is blocking her but she doesn’t know why. When she sits down with him, what does she want to know – what are his true desires, what are his attitudes toward the future, what does he fear, what does he need, how could she help him achieve what he wants to achieve and how could he help her do the same. When we realize negotiation is a means to empower everyone, it gets a lot more interesting.
  • #25 Talked about interests earlier today. Story about RIGHTS AND REMEDIES vs. INTERESTS – my own divorce.