Logistics system analysis and design
A. Problem definition and planning.
 Feasiblity analysis
 Project planning
B. Data collection and analysis.
 Assumptions and data collection.
 Analysis
C. Recommendations and implementation.
 Recommendations
 Implementation
 Conclusion
A. Problem definition and planning.
1.Feasibility assessment.
 Logistics design and planning must begin with a comprehensive evaluation of the
current logistics situation.
 The objective is to understand the, process, and performance characteristics of the
current system and to determine what, if, any modifications appear appropriate.
 The process of evaluating the need and desirability for change is referred as feasibility
assessment.
A. Problem definition and planning.
2. Project planning.
Project planning involves 5 specific items.
 Statement of objectives.
 Statement of constraints.
 Measurement standards.
 Analysis procedures.
 Project workplan.
A. Problem definition and planning.
Statement of objectives.
 The statement of objectives documents the documents the cost and service
expectations for the logistics system revision.
 It should be stated specifically and in terms of measurable factors.
 The objectives define market or industry segments ,the time frame for revisions, and
specific performance requirements.
A. Problem definition and planning.
Statement of constraints.
– The second project planning consideration concerns design constraints .
– On the basis of the situational analysis, it is expected that senior management will
place restrictions on the scope of permissible system modification.
– The nature of such restrictions will depend on the specific circumstances of individual
firms.
A. Problem definition and planning.
Measurement standards.
 The feasibility assessment often highlights the need for development of managerial
performance standards.
 Such standards direct the project by identifying the cost structures and performance
penalities. And by providing a means to assess success.
A. Problem definition and planning.
Measurement standards.
 Management must stipulate guidelines for each category as a prerequisite to
formulation of a plan..
 It is important that the standards , adequately reflect the total system performance
rather than limited, suboptimal focus on logistics functions.
 Once formulated, such standards must be held constant through out system
development.
A. Problem definition and planning.
Analysis procedures.
– Once the critical issues and alternatives are defined, the appropriate analysis
technique should be determined.
– Analysis techniques range from simple manual methods to elaborate computerized
decision support tools.
– Models incorporating optimization or simulation algorithms are common when
evaluating and comparing alternative logistics warehouse networks.
A. Problem definition and planning.
Project workplan.
On the basis of feasibility assessment, objectives, constraints and analysis technique,
a project work plan must be determined and the resources and time required for
completion identified.
The alternatives and opportunities specified during the feasibility assessment
provide the basis for determining the scope of the study.
B.Data collection and analysis
 Assumptions and data collection.
 Define analysis approach and technique.
 Define and review assumption.
 Identify data sources.
 Collect data
 Collect validation data.
 Analysis
 Define analysis questions.
 Complete and validate baseline analyze
 Complete alternative analysis
 Complete sensitivity analysis.
B.Data collection and analysis
Assumption and data collection.
1.Define analysis approach and technique
Analysis should be done through any of the techniques like analytical, simulation, and
optimization.
The analytical approach uses standard numerical methods such as those available
through spreadsheet to evaluate each logistics alternative.
2.Define and review assumptions .
The assumptions define the key operating characteristics, variables, and economics of
current and alternative system.
B.Data collection and analysis
3.Identify data sources.
In actual practice the process of data collection begins with a feasibility assessment .
In addition a fairly detailed specification of data is required to formulate or fit the
analytical technique
4.Collect data.
once alternative data sources has been identified, the data collection process can
begin.
The process include assembly of required data and conversion to appropriate formats for
the analysis tool.
5.Collect validation data.
In addition to collecting data to alternative analysis ,base case or validation data must
also be collected to verify that the results accurately reflect reality.
B.Data collection and analysis
Analysis.
1.Define Analysis question.
The first task defines specific analysis questions concerning alternatives and the range
of alternative and the range of acceptable uncertainty.
This questions build on research objectives and constraints by identifying specific
operational policies and parameters.
2. Complete and validate baseline analysis.
The second task completes the baseline analysis of the current logistics environment
using the appropriate method or tools.
Results are compared with the validation data collected previously to determine the
degree to fit between historical and analytical findings.
B.Data collection and analysis
3.Complete alternative analysis.
Once the approach has been validated, the next step is to complete an evaluation of
system alternatives
The analysis must be accomplished either manually or electronically to determine the
relevant performance characteristics of each alternative.
4.Complete sensitivity analysis.
Once this analysis is completed , the best performing alternatives can be can be
targeted for further sensitivity evaluation.
Sensitivity analysis investigates the appropriateness of this ideal solution for different
demand or cost analysis.
Recommendation and implementation.
Recommendations.
1. Identify the best alternatives.
The decision tree analysis should identify the best alternative for implementation.
Performance characteristics and conditions for each alternative must be compared to
identify the two or three best options.
2. Evaluate cost and benefit
When evaluating the potential of a particular logistics strategy ,an analysis comparing
present cost and service capabilities with projected conditions must be completed for
each alternative.
The ideal cost benefit analysis compares the alternative for a base period and and then
projects comparative operations across some planning horizon.
Recommendation and implementation.
3.Develop a risk appraisal.
Risk appraisal considers probability that the planning environment will match the
assumptions.
It also considers the potential hazards related to system changeover.
Risk related to adoption of a selected alternative can be quantified using sensitivity
analysis.
4.Develop a presentation.
The final task develops a presentation to management that identifies,rationalizes, and
justify suggested changes.
Recommendation and implementation.
Implementation.
1.Define implementation plan
The first task defines the implementation plan in terms of the individual events, their
sequence and dependencies.
2.Schedule implementation
The second task schedules the implementation and builds on the assignment
identified previously.
The schedule must allow adequate time for acquiring facilities and equipment's,
negotiating agreement, developing procedures and training
3.Define acceptance criteria
The third task defines the acceptance criteria for evaluating the success of a plan.
Acceptance criteria should focus on service improvements, cost reduction, improved
asset utilization and enhanced quality.
Recommendation and implementation.
4.Implement.
The final task is actual implementation of the plan or design .
Implementation must include adequate control to ensure that performance occurs on
schedule and that acceptance criteria are carefully monitored.

Logistics system analysis and design

  • 2.
    Logistics system analysisand design A. Problem definition and planning.  Feasiblity analysis  Project planning B. Data collection and analysis.  Assumptions and data collection.  Analysis C. Recommendations and implementation.  Recommendations  Implementation  Conclusion
  • 3.
    A. Problem definitionand planning. 1.Feasibility assessment.  Logistics design and planning must begin with a comprehensive evaluation of the current logistics situation.  The objective is to understand the, process, and performance characteristics of the current system and to determine what, if, any modifications appear appropriate.  The process of evaluating the need and desirability for change is referred as feasibility assessment.
  • 4.
    A. Problem definitionand planning. 2. Project planning. Project planning involves 5 specific items.  Statement of objectives.  Statement of constraints.  Measurement standards.  Analysis procedures.  Project workplan.
  • 5.
    A. Problem definitionand planning. Statement of objectives.  The statement of objectives documents the documents the cost and service expectations for the logistics system revision.  It should be stated specifically and in terms of measurable factors.  The objectives define market or industry segments ,the time frame for revisions, and specific performance requirements.
  • 6.
    A. Problem definitionand planning. Statement of constraints. – The second project planning consideration concerns design constraints . – On the basis of the situational analysis, it is expected that senior management will place restrictions on the scope of permissible system modification. – The nature of such restrictions will depend on the specific circumstances of individual firms.
  • 7.
    A. Problem definitionand planning. Measurement standards.  The feasibility assessment often highlights the need for development of managerial performance standards.  Such standards direct the project by identifying the cost structures and performance penalities. And by providing a means to assess success.
  • 8.
    A. Problem definitionand planning. Measurement standards.  Management must stipulate guidelines for each category as a prerequisite to formulation of a plan..  It is important that the standards , adequately reflect the total system performance rather than limited, suboptimal focus on logistics functions.  Once formulated, such standards must be held constant through out system development.
  • 9.
    A. Problem definitionand planning. Analysis procedures. – Once the critical issues and alternatives are defined, the appropriate analysis technique should be determined. – Analysis techniques range from simple manual methods to elaborate computerized decision support tools. – Models incorporating optimization or simulation algorithms are common when evaluating and comparing alternative logistics warehouse networks.
  • 10.
    A. Problem definitionand planning. Project workplan. On the basis of feasibility assessment, objectives, constraints and analysis technique, a project work plan must be determined and the resources and time required for completion identified. The alternatives and opportunities specified during the feasibility assessment provide the basis for determining the scope of the study.
  • 11.
    B.Data collection andanalysis  Assumptions and data collection.  Define analysis approach and technique.  Define and review assumption.  Identify data sources.  Collect data  Collect validation data.  Analysis  Define analysis questions.  Complete and validate baseline analyze  Complete alternative analysis  Complete sensitivity analysis.
  • 12.
    B.Data collection andanalysis Assumption and data collection. 1.Define analysis approach and technique Analysis should be done through any of the techniques like analytical, simulation, and optimization. The analytical approach uses standard numerical methods such as those available through spreadsheet to evaluate each logistics alternative. 2.Define and review assumptions . The assumptions define the key operating characteristics, variables, and economics of current and alternative system.
  • 13.
    B.Data collection andanalysis 3.Identify data sources. In actual practice the process of data collection begins with a feasibility assessment . In addition a fairly detailed specification of data is required to formulate or fit the analytical technique 4.Collect data. once alternative data sources has been identified, the data collection process can begin. The process include assembly of required data and conversion to appropriate formats for the analysis tool. 5.Collect validation data. In addition to collecting data to alternative analysis ,base case or validation data must also be collected to verify that the results accurately reflect reality.
  • 14.
    B.Data collection andanalysis Analysis. 1.Define Analysis question. The first task defines specific analysis questions concerning alternatives and the range of alternative and the range of acceptable uncertainty. This questions build on research objectives and constraints by identifying specific operational policies and parameters. 2. Complete and validate baseline analysis. The second task completes the baseline analysis of the current logistics environment using the appropriate method or tools. Results are compared with the validation data collected previously to determine the degree to fit between historical and analytical findings.
  • 15.
    B.Data collection andanalysis 3.Complete alternative analysis. Once the approach has been validated, the next step is to complete an evaluation of system alternatives The analysis must be accomplished either manually or electronically to determine the relevant performance characteristics of each alternative. 4.Complete sensitivity analysis. Once this analysis is completed , the best performing alternatives can be can be targeted for further sensitivity evaluation. Sensitivity analysis investigates the appropriateness of this ideal solution for different demand or cost analysis.
  • 16.
    Recommendation and implementation. Recommendations. 1.Identify the best alternatives. The decision tree analysis should identify the best alternative for implementation. Performance characteristics and conditions for each alternative must be compared to identify the two or three best options. 2. Evaluate cost and benefit When evaluating the potential of a particular logistics strategy ,an analysis comparing present cost and service capabilities with projected conditions must be completed for each alternative. The ideal cost benefit analysis compares the alternative for a base period and and then projects comparative operations across some planning horizon.
  • 17.
    Recommendation and implementation. 3.Developa risk appraisal. Risk appraisal considers probability that the planning environment will match the assumptions. It also considers the potential hazards related to system changeover. Risk related to adoption of a selected alternative can be quantified using sensitivity analysis. 4.Develop a presentation. The final task develops a presentation to management that identifies,rationalizes, and justify suggested changes.
  • 18.
    Recommendation and implementation. Implementation. 1.Defineimplementation plan The first task defines the implementation plan in terms of the individual events, their sequence and dependencies. 2.Schedule implementation The second task schedules the implementation and builds on the assignment identified previously. The schedule must allow adequate time for acquiring facilities and equipment's, negotiating agreement, developing procedures and training 3.Define acceptance criteria The third task defines the acceptance criteria for evaluating the success of a plan. Acceptance criteria should focus on service improvements, cost reduction, improved asset utilization and enhanced quality.
  • 19.
    Recommendation and implementation. 4.Implement. Thefinal task is actual implementation of the plan or design . Implementation must include adequate control to ensure that performance occurs on schedule and that acceptance criteria are carefully monitored.