SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Limited Impacts of Natural Gas Gathering Operations
on Shallow Groundwater in the Sacramento Basin
James A. Lehrman, PG, CHG
Jim.Lehrman@parsons.com
Walnut Creek, California
Current Conditions at Most Sites
 Little or no detectable BTEX in soil or groundwater (GW)
 GW plumes are small (<400’) and stable or shrinking
 Diesel range organic (DRO) concentrations exceed
water quality objects (WQOs) at all open sites (primary
regulatory driver)
 DRO concentrations exceed gasoline range organic
(GRO) concentrations in GW on average by a ratio of
>10:1 (puzzling…)
Approach/Activities Results/Lessons Learned
Typical Natural
Gas Gathering
Site
Natural gas, condensate and formation
water (typically >7,000’ bgs)
Dry natural
gas to end
users
Condensate releases from
dehydrators, ASTs, sumps,
etc.
In order to better understand the nature of the impacts:
 Collected fresh unweathered condensate from NGG
product storage tanks and weathered free product (FP)
from GW monitoring wells
 Compared the results of a suite of FP analytical tests
including hydrocarbon fractionation
 Analyzed GW samples from 16 sites for DRO w/ and
w/out gravity separation (GS) and silica gel cleanup
(SGC) from 2011 through 2014 (307 samples)
 Mapped the plumes using historical and recent data w/
and w/out SGC
Condensate Composition
Degradation of Hydrocarbons
To Polar Compounds
Biodegradation of (TPHg/GRO) can result in polar compounds
that are measured (elute) as TPHd/TEPH/DRO because the
polar compounds have higher boiling points than hydrocarbon
with the same number of carbon atoms. - CA LUFT Manual, 2012
Typical NGG Site Cross Section
Typical NGG Site GW Plume
Typical NGG Site Mass Reduction
Shrinking and Degrading to Polars
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
DRO w/GS DRO w/SGC DRO w/SGC & GS
Average
PercentRemaining(%)
19%
81%
12%
(16 Sites, 66 Wells, 13 Events)
w/GS & SGCw/SGCw/GS
19% 81% 88%
DRO
Avg.%Remaining
Reduction in DRO
with & w/o Gravity Separation
and Silica Gel Cleanup
Un-weathered
Weathered
AliphaticsAromatics
Unweathered
Weathered
Evidence of the loss of
the light fraction and
bioattenuation
#1 #2 #3
#4 #5 #6
with DRO in Soil Iso-concentration Overlay
Original Release
Mass Remaining
from Natural Attenuation –
Compared to estimated Original Release
 Natural Gas Gathering (NGG) sites are located within or
adjacent to gas fields throughout the Sacramento Basin
 NGG operations removed liquids (water and condensate)
from raw gas prior to transmission in pipelines since the
1940’s
 Condensate:
 Volatile
 High API gravity unrefined petroleum
 Similar to gasoline
 High % BTEX and carbon range of approximately C6 to
C16
 Environmental investigations performed at ~78 NGG sites;
most showed little or no impacts
 Remediation (i.e., source removal) conducted at ~15 sites
 17 sites/cases currently open with ongoing monitoring;
~61 closed
DRO ≈ Polars in Groundwater
octane (C8H18) BP = 125°C octanol (C8H18O) BP = 195°C
n‐hexane (C6H14) BP = 69°C caproic acid (C6H12O2) BP = 205°C
Polar compounds a have higher solubility and lower vapor pressure, therefore
lower Henry’s constant (than petroleum compounds)
 Most of the released condensate at NGG sites has
attenuated
 Remaining hydrocarbons are effectively insoluble
and strongly sorbed to soil in the smear zone
 Dissolved phase DRO is virtually all polar non-
hydrocarbons
 Intrinsic biodegradation is occurring at the NGG sites
and producing polar compounds as metabolic by-
products
 Comparison of GW data over time indicates plumes
are:
 Shrinking
 Less than 400 feet in length, and
 Limited to shallow GW w/in the vicinity of NGG
operations
 Based on detailed mapping of soil and GW
concentrations and current mass in place
calculations for 10 sites:
 Mass remaining is <10% of the original release for most
sites, even those with no prior engineered remediation
 The ratio of hydrocarbon mass (soil:groundwater) is
typically ~ 10,000:1
Background
Study Area: Sacramento Basin

More Related Content

What's hot

Mel725 32
Mel725 32Mel725 32
Mel725 32
H.S. Hong
 
Mel725 32
Mel725 32Mel725 32
Mel725 32
ssusercf6d0e
 
Oil Properties
Oil PropertiesOil Properties
Oil Properties
M.T.H Group
 
Significance of Debutanizer Reflux Ratio
Significance of Debutanizer Reflux RatioSignificance of Debutanizer Reflux Ratio
Significance of Debutanizer Reflux Ratio
Muhammad Saeed
 
AHU Requirments1.pdf
AHU Requirments1.pdfAHU Requirments1.pdf
AHU Requirments1.pdf
naveedafroz5
 
Isentropic Blow-Down Process and Discharge Coefficient
Isentropic Blow-Down Process and Discharge CoefficientIsentropic Blow-Down Process and Discharge Coefficient
Isentropic Blow-Down Process and Discharge Coefficient
Steven Cooke
 
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regn
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regnHydrauliske kapacitet under regn
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regn
EVAnetDenmark
 
2002 DLP_Fluid-Properties-Marhoun2002
2002 DLP_Fluid-Properties-Marhoun20022002 DLP_Fluid-Properties-Marhoun2002
2002 DLP_Fluid-Properties-Marhoun2002
Muhammad Al-Marhoun
 
Dnapl Recovery Strategy For Coal Tar Final
Dnapl Recovery Strategy For Coal Tar FinalDnapl Recovery Strategy For Coal Tar Final
Dnapl Recovery Strategy For Coal Tar Final
Neale Misquitta
 
STURGEON RODUCTION OPTIMIZATION
STURGEON  RODUCTION OPTIMIZATIONSTURGEON  RODUCTION OPTIMIZATION
STURGEON RODUCTION OPTIMIZATION
Mohammad Gholizadeh
 
Heat transfer power point
Heat transfer power pointHeat transfer power point
Heat transfer power point
Idayu Razali
 
Pittcon Powerpoint (2014)
Pittcon Powerpoint (2014)Pittcon Powerpoint (2014)
Pittcon Powerpoint (2014)
Chris Dwyer
 
H2 plant skc
H2 plant skcH2 plant skc
H2 plant skc
Diponegoro University
 
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy WaterTracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
VicMadrid
 
Antiknock characteristics of vehicle fuel
Antiknock characteristics of vehicle fuelAntiknock characteristics of vehicle fuel
Antiknock characteristics of vehicle fuel
jiodadi
 
Benfield system
Benfield systemBenfield system
Benfield system
Prem Baboo
 
Reservoir fluid classification
Reservoir fluid classificationReservoir fluid classification
Reservoir fluid classification
Hashir Ali Siddiqui
 
Pvt behaviour
Pvt behaviourPvt behaviour
Pvt behaviour
Awais Sharif
 

What's hot (18)

Mel725 32
Mel725 32Mel725 32
Mel725 32
 
Mel725 32
Mel725 32Mel725 32
Mel725 32
 
Oil Properties
Oil PropertiesOil Properties
Oil Properties
 
Significance of Debutanizer Reflux Ratio
Significance of Debutanizer Reflux RatioSignificance of Debutanizer Reflux Ratio
Significance of Debutanizer Reflux Ratio
 
AHU Requirments1.pdf
AHU Requirments1.pdfAHU Requirments1.pdf
AHU Requirments1.pdf
 
Isentropic Blow-Down Process and Discharge Coefficient
Isentropic Blow-Down Process and Discharge CoefficientIsentropic Blow-Down Process and Discharge Coefficient
Isentropic Blow-Down Process and Discharge Coefficient
 
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regn
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regnHydrauliske kapacitet under regn
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regn
 
2002 DLP_Fluid-Properties-Marhoun2002
2002 DLP_Fluid-Properties-Marhoun20022002 DLP_Fluid-Properties-Marhoun2002
2002 DLP_Fluid-Properties-Marhoun2002
 
Dnapl Recovery Strategy For Coal Tar Final
Dnapl Recovery Strategy For Coal Tar FinalDnapl Recovery Strategy For Coal Tar Final
Dnapl Recovery Strategy For Coal Tar Final
 
STURGEON RODUCTION OPTIMIZATION
STURGEON  RODUCTION OPTIMIZATIONSTURGEON  RODUCTION OPTIMIZATION
STURGEON RODUCTION OPTIMIZATION
 
Heat transfer power point
Heat transfer power pointHeat transfer power point
Heat transfer power point
 
Pittcon Powerpoint (2014)
Pittcon Powerpoint (2014)Pittcon Powerpoint (2014)
Pittcon Powerpoint (2014)
 
H2 plant skc
H2 plant skcH2 plant skc
H2 plant skc
 
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy WaterTracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
 
Antiknock characteristics of vehicle fuel
Antiknock characteristics of vehicle fuelAntiknock characteristics of vehicle fuel
Antiknock characteristics of vehicle fuel
 
Benfield system
Benfield systemBenfield system
Benfield system
 
Reservoir fluid classification
Reservoir fluid classificationReservoir fluid classification
Reservoir fluid classification
 
Pvt behaviour
Pvt behaviourPvt behaviour
Pvt behaviour
 

Similar to Lehrman GRA Poster_Feb 2015

Liquid recovery
Liquid recoveryLiquid recovery
Liquid recovery
raviupeslog
 
LPG.PPT
LPG.PPTLPG.PPT
Remediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST Site
Remediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST SiteRemediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST Site
Remediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST Site
Thomas Ballard, PG, CHG
 
Incorporation of Carbon Footprint Estimates into Remedial Alternatives Evalua...
Incorporation of Carbon Footprint Estimates into Remedial Alternatives Evalua...Incorporation of Carbon Footprint Estimates into Remedial Alternatives Evalua...
Incorporation of Carbon Footprint Estimates into Remedial Alternatives Evalua...
cnglenn
 
Irms (introduction)
Irms (introduction)Irms (introduction)
Irms (introduction)
Mahbubul Hassan
 
Liquefied Natural Gas properties and processing
Liquefied Natural Gas properties and processingLiquefied Natural Gas properties and processing
Liquefied Natural Gas properties and processing
MoKandel
 
A Systemic Optimization Approach for the Design of Natural Gas Dehydration Plant
A Systemic Optimization Approach for the Design of Natural Gas Dehydration PlantA Systemic Optimization Approach for the Design of Natural Gas Dehydration Plant
A Systemic Optimization Approach for the Design of Natural Gas Dehydration Plant
IJRES Journal
 
5. Gas Dehydration.pdf
5. Gas Dehydration.pdf5. Gas Dehydration.pdf
5. Gas Dehydration.pdf
Elsayed Amer
 
Mitigation of GHE by carbon capture at NFCL,Kakinada.ppt
Mitigation of GHE by carbon capture at NFCL,Kakinada.pptMitigation of GHE by carbon capture at NFCL,Kakinada.ppt
Mitigation of GHE by carbon capture at NFCL,Kakinada.ppt
DR GIRI PRASAD REMINISETTY
 
Lab Test Shows TIGG GAC Removes TTHMs from Municipal Drinking Water
Lab Test Shows TIGG GAC Removes TTHMs from Municipal Drinking WaterLab Test Shows TIGG GAC Removes TTHMs from Municipal Drinking Water
Lab Test Shows TIGG GAC Removes TTHMs from Municipal Drinking Water
Distributor Service Incorporated
 
Does Heavy Oil Recovery Need Steam?
Does Heavy Oil Recovery Need Steam?Does Heavy Oil Recovery Need Steam?
Does Heavy Oil Recovery Need Steam?
Society of Petroleum Engineers
 
Headspace Gas Chromatograph/PID for Onsite Screening of Soil and Water at Haz...
Headspace Gas Chromatograph/PID for Onsite Screening of Soil and Water at Haz...Headspace Gas Chromatograph/PID for Onsite Screening of Soil and Water at Haz...
Headspace Gas Chromatograph/PID for Onsite Screening of Soil and Water at Haz...
Jennifer Maclachlan
 
Elsevier Fuel Mercury in Process
Elsevier Fuel Mercury in Process Elsevier Fuel Mercury in Process
Elsevier Fuel Mercury in Process
ISCT GROUP US LLC
 
compressed natural gas ppt
compressed natural gas pptcompressed natural gas ppt
compressed natural gas ppt
Shivam Kumar
 
Waste Heat Recovery in Power Station Boilers by Greens Power Equipment
Waste Heat Recovery in Power Station Boilers by Greens Power EquipmentWaste Heat Recovery in Power Station Boilers by Greens Power Equipment
Waste Heat Recovery in Power Station Boilers by Greens Power Equipment
RonakSharma83
 
wednesday pb sir presentation new 1
wednesday pb sir presentation new 1wednesday pb sir presentation new 1
wednesday pb sir presentation new 1
Hari Om Choudhary
 
13 c analyses of calcium carbonate comparison between gb and ea
13 c analyses of calcium carbonate comparison between gb and ea13 c analyses of calcium carbonate comparison between gb and ea
13 c analyses of calcium carbonate comparison between gb and ea
Mahbubul Hassan
 
Emission reduction by biogas use
Emission reduction by biogas useEmission reduction by biogas use
Emission reduction by biogas use
TechFinland
 
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Neale Misquitta
 
sekharppt-180121215105.pdf
sekharppt-180121215105.pdfsekharppt-180121215105.pdf
sekharppt-180121215105.pdf
Vara Prasad
 

Similar to Lehrman GRA Poster_Feb 2015 (20)

Liquid recovery
Liquid recoveryLiquid recovery
Liquid recovery
 
LPG.PPT
LPG.PPTLPG.PPT
LPG.PPT
 
Remediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST Site
Remediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST SiteRemediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST Site
Remediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST Site
 
Incorporation of Carbon Footprint Estimates into Remedial Alternatives Evalua...
Incorporation of Carbon Footprint Estimates into Remedial Alternatives Evalua...Incorporation of Carbon Footprint Estimates into Remedial Alternatives Evalua...
Incorporation of Carbon Footprint Estimates into Remedial Alternatives Evalua...
 
Irms (introduction)
Irms (introduction)Irms (introduction)
Irms (introduction)
 
Liquefied Natural Gas properties and processing
Liquefied Natural Gas properties and processingLiquefied Natural Gas properties and processing
Liquefied Natural Gas properties and processing
 
A Systemic Optimization Approach for the Design of Natural Gas Dehydration Plant
A Systemic Optimization Approach for the Design of Natural Gas Dehydration PlantA Systemic Optimization Approach for the Design of Natural Gas Dehydration Plant
A Systemic Optimization Approach for the Design of Natural Gas Dehydration Plant
 
5. Gas Dehydration.pdf
5. Gas Dehydration.pdf5. Gas Dehydration.pdf
5. Gas Dehydration.pdf
 
Mitigation of GHE by carbon capture at NFCL,Kakinada.ppt
Mitigation of GHE by carbon capture at NFCL,Kakinada.pptMitigation of GHE by carbon capture at NFCL,Kakinada.ppt
Mitigation of GHE by carbon capture at NFCL,Kakinada.ppt
 
Lab Test Shows TIGG GAC Removes TTHMs from Municipal Drinking Water
Lab Test Shows TIGG GAC Removes TTHMs from Municipal Drinking WaterLab Test Shows TIGG GAC Removes TTHMs from Municipal Drinking Water
Lab Test Shows TIGG GAC Removes TTHMs from Municipal Drinking Water
 
Does Heavy Oil Recovery Need Steam?
Does Heavy Oil Recovery Need Steam?Does Heavy Oil Recovery Need Steam?
Does Heavy Oil Recovery Need Steam?
 
Headspace Gas Chromatograph/PID for Onsite Screening of Soil and Water at Haz...
Headspace Gas Chromatograph/PID for Onsite Screening of Soil and Water at Haz...Headspace Gas Chromatograph/PID for Onsite Screening of Soil and Water at Haz...
Headspace Gas Chromatograph/PID for Onsite Screening of Soil and Water at Haz...
 
Elsevier Fuel Mercury in Process
Elsevier Fuel Mercury in Process Elsevier Fuel Mercury in Process
Elsevier Fuel Mercury in Process
 
compressed natural gas ppt
compressed natural gas pptcompressed natural gas ppt
compressed natural gas ppt
 
Waste Heat Recovery in Power Station Boilers by Greens Power Equipment
Waste Heat Recovery in Power Station Boilers by Greens Power EquipmentWaste Heat Recovery in Power Station Boilers by Greens Power Equipment
Waste Heat Recovery in Power Station Boilers by Greens Power Equipment
 
wednesday pb sir presentation new 1
wednesday pb sir presentation new 1wednesday pb sir presentation new 1
wednesday pb sir presentation new 1
 
13 c analyses of calcium carbonate comparison between gb and ea
13 c analyses of calcium carbonate comparison between gb and ea13 c analyses of calcium carbonate comparison between gb and ea
13 c analyses of calcium carbonate comparison between gb and ea
 
Emission reduction by biogas use
Emission reduction by biogas useEmission reduction by biogas use
Emission reduction by biogas use
 
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
 
sekharppt-180121215105.pdf
sekharppt-180121215105.pdfsekharppt-180121215105.pdf
sekharppt-180121215105.pdf
 

Lehrman GRA Poster_Feb 2015

  • 1. Limited Impacts of Natural Gas Gathering Operations on Shallow Groundwater in the Sacramento Basin James A. Lehrman, PG, CHG Jim.Lehrman@parsons.com Walnut Creek, California Current Conditions at Most Sites  Little or no detectable BTEX in soil or groundwater (GW)  GW plumes are small (<400’) and stable or shrinking  Diesel range organic (DRO) concentrations exceed water quality objects (WQOs) at all open sites (primary regulatory driver)  DRO concentrations exceed gasoline range organic (GRO) concentrations in GW on average by a ratio of >10:1 (puzzling…) Approach/Activities Results/Lessons Learned Typical Natural Gas Gathering Site Natural gas, condensate and formation water (typically >7,000’ bgs) Dry natural gas to end users Condensate releases from dehydrators, ASTs, sumps, etc. In order to better understand the nature of the impacts:  Collected fresh unweathered condensate from NGG product storage tanks and weathered free product (FP) from GW monitoring wells  Compared the results of a suite of FP analytical tests including hydrocarbon fractionation  Analyzed GW samples from 16 sites for DRO w/ and w/out gravity separation (GS) and silica gel cleanup (SGC) from 2011 through 2014 (307 samples)  Mapped the plumes using historical and recent data w/ and w/out SGC Condensate Composition Degradation of Hydrocarbons To Polar Compounds Biodegradation of (TPHg/GRO) can result in polar compounds that are measured (elute) as TPHd/TEPH/DRO because the polar compounds have higher boiling points than hydrocarbon with the same number of carbon atoms. - CA LUFT Manual, 2012 Typical NGG Site Cross Section Typical NGG Site GW Plume Typical NGG Site Mass Reduction Shrinking and Degrading to Polars 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% DRO w/GS DRO w/SGC DRO w/SGC & GS Average PercentRemaining(%) 19% 81% 12% (16 Sites, 66 Wells, 13 Events) w/GS & SGCw/SGCw/GS 19% 81% 88% DRO Avg.%Remaining Reduction in DRO with & w/o Gravity Separation and Silica Gel Cleanup Un-weathered Weathered AliphaticsAromatics Unweathered Weathered Evidence of the loss of the light fraction and bioattenuation #1 #2 #3 #4 #5 #6 with DRO in Soil Iso-concentration Overlay Original Release Mass Remaining from Natural Attenuation – Compared to estimated Original Release  Natural Gas Gathering (NGG) sites are located within or adjacent to gas fields throughout the Sacramento Basin  NGG operations removed liquids (water and condensate) from raw gas prior to transmission in pipelines since the 1940’s  Condensate:  Volatile  High API gravity unrefined petroleum  Similar to gasoline  High % BTEX and carbon range of approximately C6 to C16  Environmental investigations performed at ~78 NGG sites; most showed little or no impacts  Remediation (i.e., source removal) conducted at ~15 sites  17 sites/cases currently open with ongoing monitoring; ~61 closed DRO ≈ Polars in Groundwater octane (C8H18) BP = 125°C octanol (C8H18O) BP = 195°C n‐hexane (C6H14) BP = 69°C caproic acid (C6H12O2) BP = 205°C Polar compounds a have higher solubility and lower vapor pressure, therefore lower Henry’s constant (than petroleum compounds)  Most of the released condensate at NGG sites has attenuated  Remaining hydrocarbons are effectively insoluble and strongly sorbed to soil in the smear zone  Dissolved phase DRO is virtually all polar non- hydrocarbons  Intrinsic biodegradation is occurring at the NGG sites and producing polar compounds as metabolic by- products  Comparison of GW data over time indicates plumes are:  Shrinking  Less than 400 feet in length, and  Limited to shallow GW w/in the vicinity of NGG operations  Based on detailed mapping of soil and GW concentrations and current mass in place calculations for 10 sites:  Mass remaining is <10% of the original release for most sites, even those with no prior engineered remediation  The ratio of hydrocarbon mass (soil:groundwater) is typically ~ 10,000:1 Background Study Area: Sacramento Basin