SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Thomas E. Ballard
Taber Consultants
West Sacramento, CA

REMEDIATION BY NATURAL ATTENUATION
   A UST SITE CLOSURE CASE STUDY
SITE BACKGROUND
 Site located in Redding, CA
 Former Shell Service Station
 USTs removed in 1998
 Passive free product recovery by skimmer
 Total of 13 monitoring wells
 No drinking water wells nearby
 APT and sparge tests conducted
 Site closed in 2012 with no active remediation
1998
NATURAL ATTENUATION ANALYSIS
BIODEGRADATION OF PETROLEUM HYDROCARBONS

 Petroleum hydrocarbons are naturally
  biodegraded (oxidized) under both aerobic and
  anaerobic conditions
 Simpler hydrocarbons biodegraded more
  quickly (BTEX, n-alkanes)
 More complex hydrocarbons biodegrade more
  slowly
 LNAPL is biodegraded only along the air/NAPL
  and water/NAPL interfaces
BIODEGRADATION EQUATIONS BASED ON TOLUENE
ANAEROBIC PLUME ZONATION
EVALUATING BIODEGRADATION PROCESSES

   ORP*                     Minimum of three wells
   Dissolved oxygen*         (upgradient, 2 within
   Ferrous iron (Fe2+)       plume)
   Manganese (Mn2+)         If more than three wells,
                              contouring can be helpful
   Methane                  Prepare kpoint charts
   Nitrate                      Log normal concentration vs.
   Sulfate                       time at single well
   Alkalinity                   Log normal distance vs.
                                  concentration on plume
   Carbon dioxide                centerline
   pH*                      Changes over time to
   Temperature*              evaluate stable or
                              shrinking plume
NAA SAMPLING RESULTS

 Methane and nitrate results not as expected
 Appears to be the result of a leaking sewer line

 Other results appear to be typical of a stable
  petroleum hydrocarbon plume.
STATISTICAL TREND ANALYSIS
TPH-G CONCENTRATION TRENDS
BENZENE CONCENTRATION TRENDS
MTBE CONCENTRATION TRENDS
PLUME STABILITY ANALYSIS
PLUME STABILITY ANALYSIS METHODOLOGY

 Plume Area
 Plume Mass

 Plume Average Concentration

 Center of Mass
PLUME CHARACTERISTICS 2000 VS 2011
CONCLUSIONS

 Biodegradation appears to be active and
  ongoing at the site.
 Natural attenuation processes have reduced
  plume mass, size and concentration by 75 to
  99 percent.
 Trend analysis indicates achieving Water
  Quality Goals within 20 to 30 years.
 Site meets criteria as a low-risk site.
REFERENCES

 Ricker, J.A., 2008, A Practical Method to
  Evaluate Ground Water Contaminant Plume
  Stability, Ground Water Monitoring &
  Remediation 28, no. 4, pp. 85-94
 Newell, C.J., et.al., 2002, Calculation and Use
  of First-Order Rate Constants for Monitored
  Natural Attenuation Studies, EPA Ground Water
  Issue EPA/540/S-02/500
THANK YOU!
Thomas E. Ballard
Taber Consultants, West Sacramento, CA
(916) 371-1690
tballard@taberconsultants.com

More Related Content

What's hot

Monitored Natural Attenuation Of Groundwater Nitrate
Monitored Natural Attenuation Of Groundwater NitrateMonitored Natural Attenuation Of Groundwater Nitrate
Monitored Natural Attenuation Of Groundwater Nitrate
VicMadrid
 
Informe de laboratorio 1 determinación volumétrica de la alcalinidad
Informe de laboratorio 1 determinación volumétrica de la alcalinidadInforme de laboratorio 1 determinación volumétrica de la alcalinidad
Informe de laboratorio 1 determinación volumétrica de la alcalinidad
Pilar Balverdi
 
Informe de laboratorio 2 determinación potenciométrica de la alcalinidad
Informe de laboratorio 2 determinación potenciométrica de la alcalinidadInforme de laboratorio 2 determinación potenciométrica de la alcalinidad
Informe de laboratorio 2 determinación potenciométrica de la alcalinidad
Pilar Balverdi
 
Brannon_Poster
Brannon_PosterBrannon_Poster
Brannon_Poster
Elizabeth Wing
 
27 kuhlman sand2016 8647 c hydrologic-modeling-v2
27 kuhlman sand2016 8647 c hydrologic-modeling-v227 kuhlman sand2016 8647 c hydrologic-modeling-v2
27 kuhlman sand2016 8647 c hydrologic-modeling-v2
leann_mays
 
Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Techniques and Aplications for the Water Quality...
Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Techniques and Aplications for the Water Quality...Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Techniques and Aplications for the Water Quality...
Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Techniques and Aplications for the Water Quality...
Valentina Giraldo
 
Army Orion Park Housing Update to Moffett RAB
Army Orion Park Housing Update to Moffett RABArmy Orion Park Housing Update to Moffett RAB
Army Orion Park Housing Update to Moffett RAB
Steve Williams
 
20 EPA Review of DOE’s 2014 Compliance Recertification Application for WIPP
20 EPA Review of DOE’s 2014 Compliance Recertification Application for WIPP20 EPA Review of DOE’s 2014 Compliance Recertification Application for WIPP
20 EPA Review of DOE’s 2014 Compliance Recertification Application for WIPP
Sandia National Laboratories: Energy & Climate: Renewables
 
Single Well Tracer Test
Single Well Tracer TestSingle Well Tracer Test
Single Well Tracer Test
kumar Abhishek Singh
 
Wright nott
Wright nottWright nott
25 Basin-Scale Density-Dependent Groundwater Flow Near a Salt Repository
25 Basin-Scale Density-Dependent  Groundwater Flow Near a Salt Repository25 Basin-Scale Density-Dependent  Groundwater Flow Near a Salt Repository
25 Basin-Scale Density-Dependent Groundwater Flow Near a Salt Repository
Sandia National Laboratories: Energy & Climate: Renewables
 
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy WaterTracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
VicMadrid
 
Improved method for analysis of dic in natural water samples
Improved method for analysis of dic in natural water samplesImproved method for analysis of dic in natural water samples
Improved method for analysis of dic in natural water samples
Mahbubul Hassan
 
Environmental analysis
Environmental analysisEnvironmental analysis
Environmental analysis
Metrohm India Limited
 
Advanced Techniques
Advanced TechniquesAdvanced Techniques
Advanced Techniques
Tom Arnold
 
Alternative Point-Source CO2 Mitigation: Spontaneous Conversion of CO2 to Oce...
Alternative Point-Source CO2 Mitigation: Spontaneous Conversion of CO2 to Oce...Alternative Point-Source CO2 Mitigation: Spontaneous Conversion of CO2 to Oce...
Alternative Point-Source CO2 Mitigation: Spontaneous Conversion of CO2 to Oce...
UK Carbon Capture and Storage Research Centre
 
Konstandinos_Zamfes_PSI_OPAL-OnSurface_Petrophysical_Analytical_Logging
Konstandinos_Zamfes_PSI_OPAL-OnSurface_Petrophysical_Analytical_LoggingKonstandinos_Zamfes_PSI_OPAL-OnSurface_Petrophysical_Analytical_Logging
Konstandinos_Zamfes_PSI_OPAL-OnSurface_Petrophysical_Analytical_Logging
Konstandinos Zamfes
 
Article ok
Article okArticle ok
Symposium Pres
Symposium PresSymposium Pres
Symposium Pres
Elizabeth Coler
 
Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”
Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”
Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”
Michael Hewitt, GISP
 

What's hot (20)

Monitored Natural Attenuation Of Groundwater Nitrate
Monitored Natural Attenuation Of Groundwater NitrateMonitored Natural Attenuation Of Groundwater Nitrate
Monitored Natural Attenuation Of Groundwater Nitrate
 
Informe de laboratorio 1 determinación volumétrica de la alcalinidad
Informe de laboratorio 1 determinación volumétrica de la alcalinidadInforme de laboratorio 1 determinación volumétrica de la alcalinidad
Informe de laboratorio 1 determinación volumétrica de la alcalinidad
 
Informe de laboratorio 2 determinación potenciométrica de la alcalinidad
Informe de laboratorio 2 determinación potenciométrica de la alcalinidadInforme de laboratorio 2 determinación potenciométrica de la alcalinidad
Informe de laboratorio 2 determinación potenciométrica de la alcalinidad
 
Brannon_Poster
Brannon_PosterBrannon_Poster
Brannon_Poster
 
27 kuhlman sand2016 8647 c hydrologic-modeling-v2
27 kuhlman sand2016 8647 c hydrologic-modeling-v227 kuhlman sand2016 8647 c hydrologic-modeling-v2
27 kuhlman sand2016 8647 c hydrologic-modeling-v2
 
Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Techniques and Aplications for the Water Quality...
Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Techniques and Aplications for the Water Quality...Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Techniques and Aplications for the Water Quality...
Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Techniques and Aplications for the Water Quality...
 
Army Orion Park Housing Update to Moffett RAB
Army Orion Park Housing Update to Moffett RABArmy Orion Park Housing Update to Moffett RAB
Army Orion Park Housing Update to Moffett RAB
 
20 EPA Review of DOE’s 2014 Compliance Recertification Application for WIPP
20 EPA Review of DOE’s 2014 Compliance Recertification Application for WIPP20 EPA Review of DOE’s 2014 Compliance Recertification Application for WIPP
20 EPA Review of DOE’s 2014 Compliance Recertification Application for WIPP
 
Single Well Tracer Test
Single Well Tracer TestSingle Well Tracer Test
Single Well Tracer Test
 
Wright nott
Wright nottWright nott
Wright nott
 
25 Basin-Scale Density-Dependent Groundwater Flow Near a Salt Repository
25 Basin-Scale Density-Dependent  Groundwater Flow Near a Salt Repository25 Basin-Scale Density-Dependent  Groundwater Flow Near a Salt Repository
25 Basin-Scale Density-Dependent Groundwater Flow Near a Salt Repository
 
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy WaterTracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
Tracer Experiment using Hetch-Hetchy Water
 
Improved method for analysis of dic in natural water samples
Improved method for analysis of dic in natural water samplesImproved method for analysis of dic in natural water samples
Improved method for analysis of dic in natural water samples
 
Environmental analysis
Environmental analysisEnvironmental analysis
Environmental analysis
 
Advanced Techniques
Advanced TechniquesAdvanced Techniques
Advanced Techniques
 
Alternative Point-Source CO2 Mitigation: Spontaneous Conversion of CO2 to Oce...
Alternative Point-Source CO2 Mitigation: Spontaneous Conversion of CO2 to Oce...Alternative Point-Source CO2 Mitigation: Spontaneous Conversion of CO2 to Oce...
Alternative Point-Source CO2 Mitigation: Spontaneous Conversion of CO2 to Oce...
 
Konstandinos_Zamfes_PSI_OPAL-OnSurface_Petrophysical_Analytical_Logging
Konstandinos_Zamfes_PSI_OPAL-OnSurface_Petrophysical_Analytical_LoggingKonstandinos_Zamfes_PSI_OPAL-OnSurface_Petrophysical_Analytical_Logging
Konstandinos_Zamfes_PSI_OPAL-OnSurface_Petrophysical_Analytical_Logging
 
Article ok
Article okArticle ok
Article ok
 
Symposium Pres
Symposium PresSymposium Pres
Symposium Pres
 
Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”
Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”
Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”
 

Similar to Remediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST Site

Extraction of selected rare earth elements from anthracite acid mine drainage...
Extraction of selected rare earth elements from anthracite acid mine drainage...Extraction of selected rare earth elements from anthracite acid mine drainage...
Extraction of selected rare earth elements from anthracite acid mine drainage...
GuanrongSong1
 
Water Analysis & Test Method
Water Analysis & Test MethodWater Analysis & Test Method
Water Analysis & Test Method
Manikantan Gangatharan
 
MBBR - Moving Bed Bio Reactor
MBBR - Moving Bed Bio ReactorMBBR - Moving Bed Bio Reactor
MBBR - Moving Bed Bio Reactor
MartinGerulis
 
Q044114119
Q044114119Q044114119
Q044114119
IJERA Editor
 
Presentation_(B4-1).pdf
Presentation_(B4-1).pdfPresentation_(B4-1).pdf
Presentation_(B4-1).pdf
RamonEstebanMartinez2
 
Adaptive Management of SW_Final
Adaptive Management of SW_FinalAdaptive Management of SW_Final
Adaptive Management of SW_Final
Currie Mixon
 
nano catalysis as a prospectus of green chemistry
nano catalysis as a prospectus of green chemistry nano catalysis as a prospectus of green chemistry
nano catalysis as a prospectus of green chemistry
Ankit Grover
 
12883499.ppt
12883499.ppt12883499.ppt
12883499.ppt
Ali Al-naqa
 
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Neale Misquitta
 
2022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/22
2022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/222022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/22
2022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/22
Michael Hewitt, GISP
 
Percy Julian Invited Lecture
Percy Julian Invited LecturePercy Julian Invited Lecture
Percy Julian Invited Lecture
Soni Oyekan
 
Enzyme Based Analytical Chemistry - Nitrate and the U.S. EPA
Enzyme Based Analytical Chemistry - Nitrate and the U.S. EPAEnzyme Based Analytical Chemistry - Nitrate and the U.S. EPA
Enzyme Based Analytical Chemistry - Nitrate and the U.S. EPA
Anna-Marie Davidson
 
Flame Photometric Estimation
Flame Photometric EstimationFlame Photometric Estimation
Flame Photometric Estimation
Pritam Kolge
 
Selection of amine solvents for CO2 capture from natural gas power plant
Selection of amine solvents for CO2 capture from natural gas power plantSelection of amine solvents for CO2 capture from natural gas power plant
Selection of amine solvents for CO2 capture from natural gas power plant
UK Carbon Capture and Storage Research Centre
 
Optimized Geochemical Modeling of Produced Fluids Provides Important Insight ...
Optimized Geochemical Modeling of Produced Fluids Provides Important Insight ...Optimized Geochemical Modeling of Produced Fluids Provides Important Insight ...
Optimized Geochemical Modeling of Produced Fluids Provides Important Insight ...
Donald Carpenter
 
David singapore
David singaporeDavid singapore
David singapore
Marius Matache
 
I Dive Air test Oct 2012
I Dive Air test Oct 2012I Dive Air test Oct 2012
I Dive Air test Oct 2012
Andy Varoshiotis
 
NATURAL CONVECTIVE HEAT TRANSFER BY Al2O3 &PbO NANOFLUIDS
NATURAL CONVECTIVE HEAT TRANSFER BY Al2O3 &PbO NANOFLUIDSNATURAL CONVECTIVE HEAT TRANSFER BY Al2O3 &PbO NANOFLUIDS
NATURAL CONVECTIVE HEAT TRANSFER BY Al2O3 &PbO NANOFLUIDS
Alagappapandian M
 
Benfield system
Benfield systemBenfield system
Benfield system
Prem Baboo
 
Water analysis_Hardness.pptx
Water analysis_Hardness.pptxWater analysis_Hardness.pptx
Water analysis_Hardness.pptx
NaamkaranShukla
 

Similar to Remediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST Site (20)

Extraction of selected rare earth elements from anthracite acid mine drainage...
Extraction of selected rare earth elements from anthracite acid mine drainage...Extraction of selected rare earth elements from anthracite acid mine drainage...
Extraction of selected rare earth elements from anthracite acid mine drainage...
 
Water Analysis & Test Method
Water Analysis & Test MethodWater Analysis & Test Method
Water Analysis & Test Method
 
MBBR - Moving Bed Bio Reactor
MBBR - Moving Bed Bio ReactorMBBR - Moving Bed Bio Reactor
MBBR - Moving Bed Bio Reactor
 
Q044114119
Q044114119Q044114119
Q044114119
 
Presentation_(B4-1).pdf
Presentation_(B4-1).pdfPresentation_(B4-1).pdf
Presentation_(B4-1).pdf
 
Adaptive Management of SW_Final
Adaptive Management of SW_FinalAdaptive Management of SW_Final
Adaptive Management of SW_Final
 
nano catalysis as a prospectus of green chemistry
nano catalysis as a prospectus of green chemistry nano catalysis as a prospectus of green chemistry
nano catalysis as a prospectus of green chemistry
 
12883499.ppt
12883499.ppt12883499.ppt
12883499.ppt
 
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
Coal Tar DNAPL Mass Removal - Monterey Conference, Neale Misquitta, Key Envir...
 
2022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/22
2022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/222022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/22
2022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/22
 
Percy Julian Invited Lecture
Percy Julian Invited LecturePercy Julian Invited Lecture
Percy Julian Invited Lecture
 
Enzyme Based Analytical Chemistry - Nitrate and the U.S. EPA
Enzyme Based Analytical Chemistry - Nitrate and the U.S. EPAEnzyme Based Analytical Chemistry - Nitrate and the U.S. EPA
Enzyme Based Analytical Chemistry - Nitrate and the U.S. EPA
 
Flame Photometric Estimation
Flame Photometric EstimationFlame Photometric Estimation
Flame Photometric Estimation
 
Selection of amine solvents for CO2 capture from natural gas power plant
Selection of amine solvents for CO2 capture from natural gas power plantSelection of amine solvents for CO2 capture from natural gas power plant
Selection of amine solvents for CO2 capture from natural gas power plant
 
Optimized Geochemical Modeling of Produced Fluids Provides Important Insight ...
Optimized Geochemical Modeling of Produced Fluids Provides Important Insight ...Optimized Geochemical Modeling of Produced Fluids Provides Important Insight ...
Optimized Geochemical Modeling of Produced Fluids Provides Important Insight ...
 
David singapore
David singaporeDavid singapore
David singapore
 
I Dive Air test Oct 2012
I Dive Air test Oct 2012I Dive Air test Oct 2012
I Dive Air test Oct 2012
 
NATURAL CONVECTIVE HEAT TRANSFER BY Al2O3 &PbO NANOFLUIDS
NATURAL CONVECTIVE HEAT TRANSFER BY Al2O3 &PbO NANOFLUIDSNATURAL CONVECTIVE HEAT TRANSFER BY Al2O3 &PbO NANOFLUIDS
NATURAL CONVECTIVE HEAT TRANSFER BY Al2O3 &PbO NANOFLUIDS
 
Benfield system
Benfield systemBenfield system
Benfield system
 
Water analysis_Hardness.pptx
Water analysis_Hardness.pptxWater analysis_Hardness.pptx
Water analysis_Hardness.pptx
 

Remediation by Natural Attenuation at a Petroleum UST Site

  • 1. Thomas E. Ballard Taber Consultants West Sacramento, CA REMEDIATION BY NATURAL ATTENUATION A UST SITE CLOSURE CASE STUDY
  • 2. SITE BACKGROUND  Site located in Redding, CA  Former Shell Service Station  USTs removed in 1998  Passive free product recovery by skimmer  Total of 13 monitoring wells  No drinking water wells nearby  APT and sparge tests conducted  Site closed in 2012 with no active remediation
  • 3.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 10. BIODEGRADATION OF PETROLEUM HYDROCARBONS  Petroleum hydrocarbons are naturally biodegraded (oxidized) under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions  Simpler hydrocarbons biodegraded more quickly (BTEX, n-alkanes)  More complex hydrocarbons biodegrade more slowly  LNAPL is biodegraded only along the air/NAPL and water/NAPL interfaces
  • 11.
  • 14. EVALUATING BIODEGRADATION PROCESSES  ORP*  Minimum of three wells  Dissolved oxygen* (upgradient, 2 within  Ferrous iron (Fe2+) plume)  Manganese (Mn2+)  If more than three wells, contouring can be helpful  Methane  Prepare kpoint charts  Nitrate  Log normal concentration vs.  Sulfate time at single well  Alkalinity  Log normal distance vs. concentration on plume  Carbon dioxide centerline  pH*  Changes over time to  Temperature* evaluate stable or shrinking plume
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25. NAA SAMPLING RESULTS  Methane and nitrate results not as expected  Appears to be the result of a leaking sewer line  Other results appear to be typical of a stable petroleum hydrocarbon plume.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 35.
  • 37. PLUME STABILITY ANALYSIS METHODOLOGY  Plume Area  Plume Mass  Plume Average Concentration  Center of Mass
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 45. CONCLUSIONS  Biodegradation appears to be active and ongoing at the site.  Natural attenuation processes have reduced plume mass, size and concentration by 75 to 99 percent.  Trend analysis indicates achieving Water Quality Goals within 20 to 30 years.  Site meets criteria as a low-risk site.
  • 46.
  • 47. REFERENCES  Ricker, J.A., 2008, A Practical Method to Evaluate Ground Water Contaminant Plume Stability, Ground Water Monitoring & Remediation 28, no. 4, pp. 85-94  Newell, C.J., et.al., 2002, Calculation and Use of First-Order Rate Constants for Monitored Natural Attenuation Studies, EPA Ground Water Issue EPA/540/S-02/500
  • 48. THANK YOU! Thomas E. Ballard Taber Consultants, West Sacramento, CA (916) 371-1690 tballard@taberconsultants.com