2. Share based payment means any contract of delivery of goods & services
to reporting entity whose settlement is to be made in equity instrument
or cash based on equity instrument provided vesting conditions are met.
Equity Instrument can be of reporting entity, it’s Parent entity or Subsy in
form of equity shares/options.
Examples:
• A ltd received machine for which payment will be made in equity
shares of A ltd, provided machine perform good for 2 years.
• A ltd received machine for which payment will be made in cash equal
to market value of 1000 equity shares of parent/subsy of A ltd,
provided machine perform good for 2 years.
Basics
3. i) Ind AS 102 is not applicable in following cases:
• Contract with Shareholder
For eg. we agreed with shareholder to issue bonus/right share.
• Contract of Speculation
Dealt by Ind AS 109, irrespective of cash payment based on equity instrument
• Payment in Equity instruments for acquisition of business
Dealt by Ind AS 103
ii) Share based payments can be settled via
Equity -called Equity Settled
Cash -called Cash Settled
Optional -called Phantom Options
Non Applicability & Settlement
4. Recognition
Entry : PPE/Asset/Employee Compensation(ESOPs) A/c …..Dr.
to SBP Reserve (if equity settled)-Shown in BS(Reserve & Surplus)
to SBP Liability (if cash settled)-Shown in BS(Current or Non-current liability based on period)
(Being SBP Recorded)
Employee Compensation Expenses(P&L) will be written off over Vesting period
Amount should be based on fair value of SBP on grant date and can be calculated on Direct or Indirect Approach
Grant date : Date on which both parties on terms of SBP
Direct Approach : If amount can be calculated reliably then it should be based on direct fair value (Actual) of goods &
services on grant date
Indirect Approach : If amount can’t be calculated reliably then it should be based on indirect fair value, i.e. fair
value(benefit) of options/goods & services on grant date-generally for valuing services of employees, consultants this
approach is used
Fair Value : Calculated as per Guidance note on Ind AS 102.
5. Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs)
It is a contract with employees to provide shares of entity to employees on satisfying vesting conditions for a specified
period of time(vesting term)
Points to remember
• Always measure fair value of options on Grant date only
• Grant date : Date on which both parties agreed to terms of ESOP
• Exercise Price : Price, employee will pay to company to get shares
• Vesting Period : Conditional period under agreement
• Vesting date : Date on which conditions are satisfied
• Exercise date : Date on which shares are actually subscribed by employee
• Lapse : Vesting conditions are satisfied, but options are not subscribed by employee or consultant
• Vesting Conditions :
Only Service conditions : to serve for specified period
Service conditions with performance conditions : to serve for specified period & other target attainments
specified-can be market based on non market based.
6. Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs)
Special Points
• If vesting date gets preponed, expense of future years should be write off in year of vesting.
• If vesting date gets postponed, expense can’t be postponed.
• Intrinsic value of options : Fair Value(computed as per GN) of shares on Grant date less exercise price
• Amount of expense :
• Best assumption should be for expected number of options only. Any change in fair value due to market condition is
not relevant
Number of options
expected to be vest
based on best
assumption
Fair value of options on
grant date
Vesting Period
Expired
Period
Expense already
recorded in
earlier years
7. Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs)
Modification to ESOPs agreement
There are favourable changes made to ESOPs agreement for employees, which are in favour to employees;
Number of options are increased later on
here we need to calculate additional expenses from date of modification for additional options on fair value on the
date of modification
Reduction in Exercise price
It is also called re-pricing, here we need to calculate additional advantage by comparing
• Fair value of original options on modification date
• Less, Fair value of original options on modification date post modification
we will get additional advantage
Amortise additional advantage over post modification period
Reduction in Vesting Period
Simply, just reduce Vesting period in formulae
8. Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs)
Cancellation of Options
Sometimes options are cancelled due to various reasons & those changes are unfavourable to employees.
Full Cancellation of Option Agreement
with/without Compensation-
• original expense should be recorded as it is, accelerate future expenses
• Transfer SBP reserve to General reserve
• In case of compensation paid, it is written off in P&L-Excess paid over FV on cancellation date
Other Changes that are unfavourable(like increase in target)
• original expense should be recorded as it is
• If option lapse, transfer SBP reserve to General reserve
9. Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs)
Cash Settled Options
• These are also called Stock appreciation rights (SAR), having same accounting treatment as of ESOPs
• Major difference is Fair Value of option is remeasured at the each year end. Difference due to such remeasurement is
recognised in Employee Compensation expense or P&L as remeasurement effect
• Instead of SBP Reserve, entity should record SBP Liability, further classified as Current / Non-current provision (based on
expected period of settlement)
Settlement of SAR
• Settlement is based on excess of Market price over exercise price.
• Settled in cash/bank, difference is recognised as remeasurement effect in P&L a/c
• When vested SAR are granted to employees then previously served period is considered as vesting period. Since vesting
period is already expired, expense should be required on date on grant, then here this is considered as employee
compensation (later on write off in P&L)
• Remeasurement effect is still to be considered
10. Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs)
Phantom Option/ Option with choice of cash or equity
• Choice of cash/equity can be with
Counter party OR
Entity
With Counter party
Calculate value of options, if equity settled
Calculate value of options, if cash settled
Calculate value of equity based options to be recognised,
difference of above two
Record Equity Settled & cash settled options. Remeasure cash
settled options.
Upon Settlement
Cash Settlement-Settle liability as per agreement, t/f SBP Reserve
to GR
Equity Settlement-T/f liability as per latest FV to SBP Reserve,
Issue shares & any difference is t/f to Security premium
With Entity
Record SBP Liability, if present obligation to settle in cash exists
Present obligation here means any of following:
Entity can’t issue shares
• Entity has past history of generally settleing in cash
• Entity has past history of giving choice to counter party-
Accounting remain same
11. Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs)
Group company shares allotment in case of ESOPs (Equity Settled)
Sometimes ESOPs are granted with allotment agreement for shares of group companies.
When ESOPs are granted by subsidiary company (to issue shares of parent company)
When ESOPs are granted by parent company (to issue shares of subsidiary company)
Holding / Parent Company Subsidiary Company
Investment in Subsy ………… Dr.
To SBP Reserve a/c
(Being ESOPs of Subsy agreed)
Employee Compensation Expense……..Dr.
To Equity
(Being ESOPs expenses recorded)
SBP Reserve will be used to issue shares Employee Compensation expenses will be
written off in P&L
Holding / Parent Company Subsidiary Company
Employee Compensation Expense……..Dr.
To Equity
(Being ESOPs expenses recorded)
Equity ………… Dr.
To SBP Reserve a/c
(Being ESOPs of Subsy agreed)
Employee Compensation expenses will be
written off in P&L
SBP Reserve will be used to issue shares
12. Disclosures requirement
• Information to understand the nature and extent of share
based payment arrangements that existed during the
period
• Description of SBPA
13. First time application of Ind AS 102 on Date of transition
On date of transition
Options are already vested
Choice of Entity (Ind AS 101)
To remeasure SBP Reserve
OR
To continue with same book value
Options are still not vested
Remeasure to fair value on reterospective
basis is mandatory